General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
afcgeo
CaspianReport
comments
Comments by "afcgeo" (@afcgeo882) on "CaspianReport" channel.
Previous
1
Next
...
All
@thesalmannizar They are NOT indigenous. Islam is a relatively recent religion, not an ethnicity.
9
@ALADAR-f6t None of the conversation is about individuals with ties to land, but since you’ve raised that issue, Palestinian Arabs that live in the region today are predominantly from Southern Arabian peninsula and Egypt, by origin. They are not native to the Levant. The Arab section became Jordan. The West Bank and Gaza were the ethnic Egyptian settlements. The only ones with a legitimate ethnic trace to the land are bedouins (few of them left) and Mizrahi Jews (majority of Jews in Israel) as they are both native to the Levant.
4
@marius3115 To be fair, most Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza are Egyptians, not Arabs. The Arab settlements became Jordan.
4
@NiRvAnA6890 He was talking about actual buildings not any book!
2
@ Yes, that’s true.
2
@Kokachiii-r1b No. In India it’s about citizenship, not ethnicity. Foreigners can’t own majority. In Zimbabwe it’s simply that whites cannot, even if they’re citizens for generations.
1
@ You mean the Jews?
1
@ Except those people are LITERALLY the descendants of the Jews, as modern day Palestinians are from Egypt and the Arabian Peninsula. So yeah… that’s exactly what he’s talking about.
1
@ No, they aren’t. Most of those living in Gaza came from Egypt and most living in the West Bank came from what is today Iraq and Saudi Arabia. Very few of the original Bedouin tribal people or their descendants live in Palestine today. Go study history and why/how Jordan was created and why the other Palestinans didn’t want to be a part of it! All of the cities you’ve just listed were Jewish cities! How are you so ignorant?!
1
Previous
1
Next
...
All