General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Seek1878
History Buffs
comments
Comments by "Seek1878" (@loner1878) on "History Buffs: Apocalypto" video.
Historically inaccurate, yes, but cinematography is brilliant, I still enjoy watching it. I just think of it as historical fiction.
97
I just took the smallpox girl to mean hints at prior European contact, maybe scouts or something. nothing to freak out about. Its kind of a preview of the ending.
11
I would, this is fun lol
3
Did you even listed to the video? He explains how its depicting the classic maya collapse which was not in the 1500s.
2
Why are you watching a history channel if historical accuracy offends you?
2
I love people who watch a channel about historical accuracy then whine about just that. lol
2
@rackenture7045 People get upset by their movies being criticized, and make noise. Look at the likes vs dislikes bar, most people agree with this review. Me, I still like this movie even though I know the historical mistakes are pretty bad, I enjoy the cinematography and consider it historical fiction. The review made me laugh.
2
lol "shooted"
1
Riiight, disliking historical innacuracies is what's wrong with Western society, lol. And why are you watching a channel DEDICATED to evaluating historical accuracy in films if it offends you so much?
1
LOL mel is that you?
1
@herediaee I said the cinematography is brilliant, not the plot.
1
Plenty of those on his channel. Look through it and quit your whining.
1
@krombopulosliam9736 Not really
1
Not a good defense
1
Except a lot of people treat movies like books.
1
@norsesaga1984 So you agree?
1
lol
1
Uh no its not, lol.
1
wat
1
He explains the issue with them supposedly being isolated tribes - speaking the same language and being so close to the Mayan cities. The channel isn't what's stupid here.
1
@BobPantsSpongeSquare97 Yeah I know but I'm just talking about the movie ending, not actual history.
1
Honey, if you don't like your movies analyzed with facts, why watch a channel dedicated to that? Go elsewhere BRO
1
Yeah its hinting at the end of the film.
1
Except it depicts the mayan collapse. And mixes up Mayans and Aztecs.
1
Yes, considering that syphilis was the one disease brought from the new world to the old.
1
Did you even pay attention?
1