Comments by "SsjC" (@ssjcosty) on "Sabine Hossenfelder" channel.

mysticone1798 Sabine has published several videos on the JWST findings about those early galaxies. It’s all super exciting stuff, but the science on them isn’t yet settled. So she refers to more established science until we find out more. Also, it’s also not necessarily Big Bang that those findings are challenging, but the existing models about galaxy formation. And we expect that new resolution telescopes will help us further refine our models, just like it’s now the case thanks to JSWT.
3
Do notice that he never published these findings in any peer reviewed journal, because the reviewers would highlight all his mistakes and reject his submission. Instead he decided to make a public presentation out of it, hoping that he can just coast on his credentials in another field instead of actually going through the scientific process with this. This is exactly what all the "anti mainstream science" pseudoscience gurus do, like Graham Hancock, Nassim Haramein, or religious apologists such as Kent Hovind, Ken Ham etc. Obviously those guys have no scientifc credentials at all, but it's disappointing to see actual scientists go the same route when their motivated reasoning leads them to think they're right and that there's a big conspiracy among scientists in the field to hide the truth.
2
Do notice that he never published these findings in any peer reviewed journal, because the reviewers would highlight all his mistakes and reject his submission. Instead he decided to make a public presentation out of it, hoping that he can just coast on his credentials in another field instead of actually going through the scientific process with this. This is exactly what all the "anti mainstream science" pseudoscience gurus do, like Graham Hancock, Nassim Haramein, or religious apologists such as Kent Hovind, Ken Ham etc. Obviously those guys have no scientifc credentials at all, but it's disappointing to see actual scientists go the same route when their motivated reasoning leads them to think they're right and that there's a big conspiracy among scientists in the field to hide the truth.
1