Comments by "Jim Werther" (@jimwerther) on "Piers Morgan vs Norman Finkelstein On Israel and Palestine | The Full Interview" video.
-
24
-
4
-
4
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
@RC-qf3mp
Every single word Finkelstein said. How about the opening statement, when he claimed that no one knew about the carnage for four days? How about his bullschitt explanation about why he kept up his article despite it being based upon a lie? Piers didn't ask why Finkelstein didn't amend it with a note afterward explaining his supposed shift in thinking.
Piers left a lot of questions out, actually, such as:
* If Israel wanted control of Gaza, why did they hand it over fully in 2005?
* If Hamas terrorism is a response to Israeli aggression the last 17 years, then why did Hamas establish itself, and dedicate itself to extermination of all Jews, in 1988?
* If Hamas cares about their own lives, why does their founding document promise to exterminate Jews?
* If Hamas cares about their civilians, why do they hide behind them?
* If Hamas cares about their civilians, why did they stop civilians from moving south by shooting at those civilians?
* If Gaza is a concentration camp, why do they measure their lives in decades, not days or hours such as in 1940s Germany?
* If Gaza is a concentration camp, then why do you see Mercedes Benzes on the street? Why do they receive billions in aid packages? How do they build hundreds of miles of tunnels?
* If Hamas had attacked Egypt instead of Israel, would the notorious anti-Semite Finkelstein have similarly celebrated? Egypt has a border with Gaza, with a stronger separation than Israel does. Why does the anti-Semitic Feinkelstein focus on Israel instead of Egypt?
* Israel gave over Gaza in 2005, but only erected the fence in 2007, after Hamas won power and began attacking Israel. If Israel was out to get the Gazans, why did they wait a couple of years to erect a fence?
There's a start for you, based off what I remember of Finkelstein's lies. If Piers doesn't know enough to counter Finkelstein's lies, he shouldn't have him on.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@natural9242
Every single word Finkelstein said was a lie.. How about the opening statement, when he claimed that no one knew about the carnage for four days? How about his bullschitt explanation about why he kept up his article despite it being based upon a lie? Piers didn't ask why Finkelstein didn't amend it with a note afterward explaining his supposed shift in thinking.
Piers left a lot of questions out, actually, such as:
* If Israel wanted control of Gaza, why did they hand it over fully in 2005?
* If Hamas terrorism is a response to Israeli aggression the last 17 years, then why did Hamas establish itself, and dedicate itself to extermination of all Jews, in 1988?
* If Hamas cares about their own lives, why does their founding document promise to exterminate Jews?
* If Hamas cares about their civilians, why do they hide behind them?
* If Hamas cares about their civilians, why did they stop civilians from moving south by shooting at those civilians?
* If Gaza is a concentration camp, why do they measure their lives in decades, not days or hours such as in 1940s Germany?
* If Gaza is a concentration camp, then why do you see Mercedes Benzes on the street? Why do they receive billions in aid packages? How do they build hundreds of miles of tunnels?
* If Hamas had attacked Egypt instead of Israel, would the notorious anti-Semite Finkelstein have similarly celebrated? Egypt has a border with Gaza, with a stronger separation than Israel does. Why does the anti-Semitic Feinkelstein focus on Israel instead of Egypt?
* Israel gave over Gaza in 2005, but only erected the fence in 2007, after Hamas won power and began attacking Israel. If Israel was out to get the Gazans, why did they wait a couple of years to erect a fence?
There's a start for you, based off what I remember of Finkelstein's lies. If Piers doesn't know enough to counter Finkelstein's lies, he shouldn't have him on.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@anouarkrassimovich7481
I'm not. He is a deeply sick man, a Holocaust denier, and a liar who is no longer welcome among polite society due to his Holocaust denial and support of terrorism, along with the likes of David Irving, another Holocaust denier.
Those who are interested in the truth can see the reams of evidence put up for all the world to see by the likes of Megyn Kelly, Douglas Murray, Ben Shapiro and many others. Finkelstein lied from the word go here, as anyone can easily find out. It took "four days" to know that over a thousand were killed? The worldwide news reports had the number at over 1,000 in under 48 hours. That is long before we get to all of Finkelstein's other absurd lies, such as calling Gaza an Israeli-administered concentration camp. Why don't "Palestinians" go out the border they share with Egypt? Oh, right, because Egypt doesn't want them either. Neither does Jordan, Lebanon, Kuwait, or any other country which has expelled them over the years, nor any of the other 50+ Muslim countries which refuses them entry. Ever wonder why that is? Ever wonder why 1.8m Muslim Arabs live comfortably as Israeli citizens while serving in the IDF, on the Israeli Supreme Court, in the Israeli Knesset (Parliament), as doctors, lawyers, businessmen and police officers?
The conditions in Gaza are 100% the fault of Hamas. If the Gazans wanted peace instead of genocide of Jews, they would have been living comfortable lives for many years already.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@RK-um9tu
How exactly would I post evidence in a YT comment, particularly when they don't even allow for links? Anyone who cares about the truth can see the reams of evidence put up for all the world to see by the likes of Megyn Kelly, Douglas Murray, Ben Shapiro and many others. Finkelstein lied from the word go here, as anyone can easily find out. It took "four days" to know that over a thousand were killed? The worldwide news reports had the number at over 1,000 in under 48 hours. That is long before we get to all of Finkelstein's other absurd lies, such as calling Gaza an Israeli-administered concentration camp. Why don't "Palestinians" go out the back door? Oh, right, because Egypt doesn't want them either. Neither does Jordan, Lebanon, Kuwait, or any other country which has expelled them over the years, nor any of the other 50+ Muslim countries which refuses them entry. Ever wonder why that is? Ever wonder why 1.8m Muslim Arabs live comfortably as Israeli citizens while serving in the IDF, on the Israeli Supreme Court, in the Israeli Knesset (Parliament), as doctors, lawyers, businessmen and police officers?
The conditions in Gaza is 100% the fault of Hamas. If the Gazans wanted peace instead of genocide of Jews, they would have been living comfortable lives for many years already.
1