Comments by "TJ Marx" (@tjmarx) on "Einzelgänger" channel.

  1. 2
  2. 2
  3. 2
  4. 2
  5. Solipsism is such a silly idea and I don't believe anyone truly believes in it nor that anyone ever has. If solipsism were true than we have some fundamental questions that must be resolved. For example If the sole solipsistic mind is the only mind in existence, than why bother posing the philosophy externally at all? That includes what is the point in this video? If this is all at best a dream, a reflection of a single solipstistic mind and at worst a lonely conversation with automatons devoid of consciousness, than why would anyone ever discuss their philosophy of solipsism? Surely if it were a reflection of a single mind, we'd all know the philosophy simply because one thinks it, and if the latter and it's a lonely conversation with drones what's the point? I mean one hardly discusses complex philosophy with a chat bot and expects anything meaningful to come of it. And that's ultimately what solipsism is proposing. Consider even the use of the word "you" in any of them ramblings. If there is but one solipstistic mind in existence and all else does not exist, than the concept of "you" is not only unnecessary but false. It's a slip of the tongue someone whom genuinely believed they were the only being in existence would not make, and it tells us far more about the mind of the individual making such a slip than perhaps they might like. The examples given at the end of this video of scenarios which might hold solipsism to be true are self defeating. A simulation needs to be created by another entity and thus you're not alone. Same to for automatons. Which leaves only the dream or other reflections of ones own mind. For this to be true, not only would physics not exist but every mind would merely be a reflection of the single solipstistic mind. Or in other words, everyone would be at once both enlightened and constrained to the knowledge of the solipstistic mind. There would be therefore no difference of opinion, no cultural or social variance, just shadows echoing back the experience of a single mind. And from that one might suppose it's quite a depraved mind indeed, with all the pain, suffering and disease in the world one might call that a nightmare as opposed to a dream. Still too, such a mind dreaming might find that it exists in something. To change subjects with some vulgarity, would it be possible to have some philosophy videos that don't reference the Matrix? I understand that many people like that film, but ultimately it's quite underwhelming and has little of substance in actuality to impart.
    1
  6. 1
  7. 1
  8. 1
  9. 1