Youtube hearted comments of TJ Marx (@tjmarx).
-
313
-
90
-
46
-
2
-
1
-
I know some people are making a point about the fact this guy was a soldier. However, it is important to understand that a POW requires there to be a war. A war requires there to be two states with professional military forces going up against each other. That is not what is happening in Gaza. It is an occupied territory under blockade. They are essentially prisoners. If prisoners in a jail take their guards captive thost guards are not POWs. They're hostages. So it is important to understand that hostage is the correct term for this guy even as a soldier because he isn't being held by a military. He's being held by a civilian resistence. These are very important distinctions to make because that is what makes what Israel is doing a war crime and a crime against humanity.
I don't think anywhere near enough is made about dual citizenship. Let's remember what citizenship is, it isn't just membership to a club. It's a promise of allegiance to your people. That you believe in the country, will participate in its processes and will defend it against all who would seek to cause harm to it.
You can't be aligned in that way to two countries at the same time because if those two countries ever went to war even if that's an unlikely possibility, you would need to pick one side over the other. The side you would pick is the side you have actual allegiance too and the other country is just there for its benefits. There is no difference in functional outcomes between a dual citizen and an illegal economic migrant. Worse still, if their allegiance is to another country, they are in fact a national security risk and a mole.
Dual citizenship should be illegal. It should similarly be illegal to serve in a foreign military force except where enlisted domestically and posted as an official military swap between allies.
This soldier either wouldn't have been a soldier at all, or wouldn't have had US citizenship had that been in place. Either way, the US national security would be stronger right now, and the president would be in a much better negotiating position. Making dual citizenship illegal must be a priority.
If you allow dual citizens, I don't see you as a real country.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1