Comments by "J ay" (@Jay-ho9io) on "PolyMatter" channel.

  1. रात का शहर
    6
  2. By all means, provide detailed sources for anything you want to disprove in this video.
    5
  3. Provide specific detailed resources that contradict anything said in the video.
    4
  4. So what was said in this video that was wrong?
    4
  5. Guess you'll have to cook.
    4
  6. Get back on subject. Regardless of what is or is not going on in Ukraine, you have anything in the way of credible recent sources that disprove anything that was said in the video?
    4
  7. What specific things about Russia's population growth was he inaccurate about? Can you provide sources that disprove the incredibly low birth rate within Russia?
    3
  8. So you didn't watch the video. Only two other countries have a lower birth rate, and none of them have it for the same suicidal and alcohol related reasons well simultaneously fighting a war that is killing the very age group you would want to preserve the most.
    3
  9. What specific things were said in this video that were not accurate?
    3
  10. I think maybe you've got an issue with jumping from one extreme to another, my guy. (But for real this place sounds like a nightmare)
    2
  11.  @xxxdieselyyy2  It's going to be a couple of years, but I look forward to visiting.
    2
  12.  @xxxdieselyyy2  X, you seem like a good guy, for real. But maybe a couple less coffees.😂
    2
  13.  @Ravi9A  Then you'll be disregarded as an irrelevant lying child.
    2
  14. "Sanjay ghandi" Oh THIS is going to be a shit idea...
    2
  15. ​ @Sunday8916  Sources?
    2
  16. You say 1.8, which is still below replacement rate, and you've provided no source for that. Go right ahead and provide detailed sources to counter The statements made in the video. Address alcohol related deaths and replacement birth rates.
    2
  17. Cool. You can also choose to believe that the world is flat, that vaccines don't work, That birds aren't real, and any other dumbass belief you want to have. Those facts aren't dependent upon your particular belief.
    2
  18.  @meetshah5003  I mean, it's not? If you look at the timeline from partition to ISRO landing Chandrayaan-1... It's a AMAZINGLY brief period of time. The thing is, everyone wants to be the exception but we are all in a moment in our cultures or countries time. The US has a transitional period where it was basically where India is now. (The late 1800s). Rural india has a lot of catching up to do to urban wealthy India and there's a lot preventing that, but I don't think a vibrant, educated country that's on its way to being the most populous one planet Earth is going to remain where it is at for a very long. The coming centuries are going to see Asia reassert itself as the home of great world powers. And India will be among them.
    2
  19. Even if this is true, does that refute anything that was said in this video?
    2
  20. Except that a significant and politically powerful majority within Japan absolutely have no desire to open the country to immigration.
    2
  21. Provide sources for your bald-faced lie that Russia's birth rate is fine. Make sure they are detailed sources which can be identified and checked.
    2
  22. So you acknowledge that Russia has a rapidly dwindling overall population in an unsustainable birth rate. Good. It's nice to see somebody that doesn't at least argue provable facts
    2
  23. I don't know about holding it back but Hinduism isn't helping India.
    2
  24. So you agree with what said in the video? That's good to know. The video was not about Ukraine. The video is about Russia. It is good to see that you accept facts
    2
  25. I'm sure you have detailed sources to back up every single thing you're saying he gets wrong. So provide them
    2
  26.  @josephboehmer1245  I asked if you had any detailed resources that rebutted anything in the video. You have not provided them. Do better.
    2
  27. I'm sure there are plenty of other bigoted or ignorant people who also blame an entire country for the actions of their elites.
    1
  28.  @lllzzz2363  I hate it.
    1
  29.  @G-Mastah-Fash  That's not irrationally over the top at all.
    1
  30.  @Apocalypse9696  Millions requires some proof. But it's also relevant to the video. The forcible rape of Ukraine's eaten population, and their removal, does nothing to fix any of the cultural/social issues in the video.
    1
  31.  @Apocalypse9696  Russia's population has not increased. Ukraine's population has nothing to do with the video. You are repeatedly attempting to make this about Ukraine when it is not about Ukraine, it is about systemic cultural issues in Russia that have it locked in a cycle of demographic collapse. The only portion of the Russian invasion of Ukraine that matters is the significant amount of military age Russian men that have been killed In it, but cannot be replaced.
    1
  32. In the sense that their president is trying to raise the retirement age? Yes But not at all in the sense that they are at a massive population negative, and that open protest and even fires burning in the street is going to bring down the French government. Putin's response to something like what is going on in France would involve machine guns because it would have to. It would be too close to him being replaced. But if macron is replaced, France goes on just fine..
    1
  33. I did not know that I needed to hear this and now I do.
    1
  34. What does that have to do with hydrology?
    1
  35. Only in winter. In spring it's absolutely beautiful. I mean the parts that aren't polluted.
    1
  36. ​ @МаксимТарасов-в3б  Tsar Nicholas I didn't seem to think so.
    1
  37. I don't think he's kidnapped enough to replace the number of military age males he's getting killed among his own.
    1
  38. Provide specifics about exactly where he was wrong.
    1
  39.  @pelegsap  big 🧠🏆👍🏽
    1
  40. So what did he get wrong?
    1
  41. ​ @d0fabur5st82 Not anymore than Austria and Germany are both German. They both speak German, but one is Austrian and the other is Germany. It's not particularly complicated understand. Same goes for Canada and the United States
    1
  42.  @AdarkMK  You can argue the party line as much as you want. Taiwan does not consider itself China, has no desire to be ruled by China, and will not be forcibly reunited with China. They are separate country in everything but some technicalities, technicalities that are an extension of the world throwing the Chinese obsession with Taiwan a bone. China is experiencing a tremendous ascendancy in the world, and has every right and reason to be proud of that. It would be a tragic waste to throw that ascendancy away pursuing the obsession of Chinese boomers at the cost of the kind of devastation that a war would inflict.
    1
  43.  @AdarkMK  cool story. And yet the PRC doesn't run shit in Taiwan. And yet Taiwan has a separate government, political relations and generally prosperous polity. Aaaaaand yet, the military invasion of the country of Taiwan would ruin all the amazing gains the country of China has managed to accrue. These are facts, just as the separate nature of these two historically and culturally linked countries are facts. Die mad about that.
    1
  44.  @gater6090  What does that have to do with the low birth rates in Russia? And what specific sources are you using to demonstrate a higher birth rate in 2024, a year that is not yet over?
    1
  45. Should have won the war. If it makes you feel any better, give it another 50 years and take another shot at it and you will probably be able to beat England's ass easier than they beat yours. Quite possibly won't even have to fire a shot.
    1
  46.  @Sunday8916  Where are your sources? Where are your sources? Do you not respect Russia enough to defend it in a way that makes it look cultured and educated? I thought nekulturny was an insult, not a goal.
    1
  47.  @tim3172  So lies, basically. I mean if their source is "trust me bro, I see plenty of babies" then they're unable to actually provide any evidence.
    1
  48.  @Sunday8916  So a liar then. Quite common.
    1
  49. Ukraine is increasingly Ukrainian. And the Russian invasion of Ukraine has given China more reason to pause from any military attempt at taking over Taiwan in the immediate future Then anything else. China has something that Russia chose to abandon, which is patience.
    1
  50.  @horatiuscocles8052  That message only means that you don't understand Ukrainian, and are lying about the fact that Ukraine now controls more of their territory than they did last month. What was destroyed can be rebuilt.
    1
  51. The Soviet Union was an empire. The British empire was an empire. The United States is an empire. The window dressing doesn't change the purpose of the ship.
    1
  52. You were never subscribed.
    1
  53. The reality on the ground is that Somalia can't organize a dog show. Somaliland manages to organize everything a functional state needs. You wrote a very long and pompous post and you do not have one answer for the absolute across the board of failure of every structure within Somalia. The facts on the ground, using the phrase you like so much is that Somalia is conducting itself in no way shape or form like a country, and Somaliland is doing so in every way. Like it or not, there it is.
    1
  54. Somalia doesn't respect itself. If Somalia is a great nation, or just a nation, why can't it conduct itself like Somaliland?
    1
  55. Found the pro-putin troll. Or sycophant, it's hard to tell these days
    1
  56. Which part specifically
    1
  57. Yeah no one on the continent thinks that.
    1
  58. It's not a terrible one. Few people have as much investment in their health.
    1
  59. You're not from the US
    1
  60. The US system never offers cheap and only actually offers quality at higher end payments.
    1
  61. Also you would find women with more of those qualities if perhaps you weren't the kind of human that reduced them to that kind of a calculus. Because it doesn't seem to be hamstringing all of us.
    1
  62.  @real_exodus  There's no major aspect of healthcare in the United States that has a price point that isn't above the majority Western countries equivalent level. We are orders of magnitude more expensive across the board, generally with no improvement in care, and in fact often with much lower standards of care. And whether I'm emotionally invested in women or not (I am, they're some of my favorite human beings.) I'm not the one with the problem having enough interactions with them. You are. You being bad at math and you being an incel are two separate issues. You can choose which to improve, in your case math might be easier. Or you can choose neither... Which would probably be easiest. Either way some of the rest of us will have to bear both the burden of mathematical competency and a healthy social interaction outside of our gender. It's a hard life, but someone's got to do it.
    1
  63. One thing I would like to point out is that Google is now an approved verb for "searching on the internet" in the English language. Take your complaint up with Merriam Webster.
    1
  64. We are the only reason Ukraine is still Ukrainian. Despite their incredible bravery and skill, without the support t that they have received, Russia would have been successful in their unprovoked invasion.
    1
  65. What specific things did he say inside the video that are inaccurate. Provide detailed sources.
    1
  66.  @appleratpipe  ah. You have none then. Noted.
    1
  67. Cool. Start a channel and talk about it.
    1
  68. It's neither north nor in the Atlantic.
    1
  69. Not over an entire country it's not.
    1
  70. Lol. Not in most of the places people want to.
    1
  71.  @christianweibrecht6555  You might want to read up a little on World War II, and that could explain a significant amount of why there's some strong frictions against that kind of interaction.
    1
  72. Like you had to ask. 🤣
    1
  73. ​ @shukriiii congrats, and it's good to Love the place you're from. Now answer the question: what is Somalia going to do about Somaliland? (Not a damn thing.)
    1
  74. Lol nope
    1
  75.  @miliba I mean, It's slightly less impossible than the moon actually being made out of cheese. But yeah would be great.
    1
  76. Your own country's crime statistics make it very clear how dangerous your country is for women. Check the NCRB. It's not particularly difficult to find.
    1
  77. Anybody that makes the claim that this war is going well for Russia shoots their credibility in the face and buries it in a ditch.
    1
  78. It would be good to apply that to every country.
    1
  79. Yeah because World war I and World war II were all about immigration. The two worst wars in human history were caused by European people wanting to slaughter each other. You didn't need any body else's help.
    1
  80. So what did he get wrong about the demographics?
    1
  81. Asian nation:*succeeds* This Guy: "And I took that personally" I don't have to stand in favor of dictatorships, authoritarianism or anything else like that to acknowledge the specific accomplishments of Singapore, particularly in comparison to the many neighbors they have that have attempted a variety of other options and achieved significantly less success. Something that seems fundamentally beyond the grasp of westerners is that they might be best served outside of global catastrophes, to mind their own fucking business. And when they do have to treat, conduct diplomacy or negotiate with others, to do so from a frame of reference that trends more towards relativism than absolutes.
    1
  82. ​ @franknwogu4911 Yeah that's not it.
    1
  83. What did he get wrong about the demographics?
    1
  84. So what was inaccurate about the demographics?
    1
  85. ​ @Baz.007 China swears it has a fifth gen fighter, and promises to go ahead and show the world its performance at open air shows real soon now. Trying to also routinely humiliates itself with using bad CGI in weapons demonstrations. The Chinese 5th gen might be the real deal, it might not. But the Chinese aren't doing a very good job of demonstrating it.
    1
  86. Except that people actually want to move to Canada.
    1
  87. So what did he get wrong in this?
    1
  88. That comment is the product of a lifetime diet of paint chips.
    1
  89. Every single one of you humans who says something to the effect of "We can do better" never seems to have an actual numbers effective scheme for doing so. It's almost like you don't have a better plan.
    1
  90.  @aldoushuxley5953    "freedom" is in no way a value of this country. Anybody who believes it is buying into the propaganda of the state with the highest incarceration rates and length on planet Earth. Freedom in the United States is completely predicated upon your nearness to wealth and whiteness, skewing every kind of possible measure or metric of "freedom" so overwhelmingly as to be beyond the realm of any kind of rational argument otherwise.
    1
  91.  @aldoushuxley5953  "What privilege does the dude in the trailer park have" He killed less often than his economic peers, he has greater access to health care, higher survivability rates, dies at an older age, has greater in comparison access to private and public funds, serves less time for the exact same crimes committed, Is less likely to be violently attacked by law enforcement whether or not he is obstructing the law or initiated the encounter, and if he does initiate the encounter is less likely to be killed in response. He's hired more often, went to schools with significantly better educational marks, AND recieves greater credit from financial institutions when all other values except race are balanced. Arguing against the impact of race in the United States has the same level of scientific rigor as arguing for the flatness of planet Earth. You're bad at this.
    1
  92. ​ @temchak  funny, the Czar agreed with him.
    1
  93. In what specific, provable ways?
    1
  94. ​​ @neolithictransitrevolution427  It won't. It doesn't actually drill any wells, and doesn't have any specific rebuttals.
    1