Comments by "G L" (@gelinrefira) on "F.D Signifier"
channel.
-
219
-
40
-
23
-
22
-
17
-
9
-
7
-
6
-
6
-
4
-
One important point that should be made is the difference between East Asian culture of manhood Vs American.
In anime, you will see a quirky thing is that somewhere along the story, the protag will be asked, "what are you trying to protect (mamoru)? Why do you want to be strong?"
This goes directly to a large part of East Asia cultures (Japan, China, Korea etc.) is that you are not alone and you derive your greatest strength from service and selflessness. Protecting something or someone is what gives you conviction and determination.
In contrast, this is very very different from American culture where media aimed at teenagers tends to be all about bursting out of your shell and leaving everything and everyone behind, including your family, friends and most importantly any social and civic obligations. It is always about what you want, but it is never about what your role can be. Now of course, there are always exceptions to the rule, like the American cultural obsession with military service, but it generally holds. OTOH, in East Asian cultures, the struggle between finding yourself and finding your role in life is always examined in teenage media. It is always a balance between oneself and one's dreams and one's obligations to others.
For East Asians, happiness and fulfillment comes from connecting with people, family, friends, lovers and reconciling that with oneself. The individual is part of the collective and the collective is more than the sum of the individuals. It is very different from the toxic, hyperindividualism in America and western culture in general. It is about not being alienated from your community while maintaining one's own individuality. Which is why in most shounen media, the protag usually achieve his ultimate strength when he is with his people, lifting them up while they lift him up. That's why "mamoru" and "nakama power" are troupes in Japanese media. It is through the harmonious integration of everyone's strength and their understanding of their roles and genuine bonds that true power can be achieved. Cooperation and selflessness and harmony are built into East Asian cultures.
These concepts are antithetical to American culture.
4
-
4
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@rimaq_ Exactly. As much as the western media wants to slander China unfairly and let's be clear the Chinese themselves will tell you that China is not perfect and have a lot of problems, the Chinese and many African countries share a common history: western imperialism from both Europe and America.
China's rise showed that there is another way to do it that is different from western model, and the existence of such model and its wild success is an existential threat to American capitalistic elites. Africa, South America and large parts of Asia can look at China and see that it is not merely FREEDOM(TM) that brings prosperity, peace and stability. Freedom follows prosperity and peace. China's freedom to decide its own destiny, and yes the Chinese people have a lot of influence on its government even if it is indirect, is guaranteed by China's current strength. America today would have destroy China if China could not defend itself, there is little doubt about that.
Africa nations can only have freedom from interference from western imperialism if they are strong themselves, and that means industrialization, economic growth and prosperity. China knows how to get there, and that's what they are telling thee Africans; the BRI is the manifestation of that will and it is making American elites shitting their pants as more and more countries tell America to f**k off.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1