Comments by "No Fate But What We Make" (@SonoftheAllfather) on "Trump Pitches Solar-Panel Topped Border Wall System" video.
-
740
-
19
-
12
-
10
-
7
-
7
-
4
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@ neil: So, from an electrical engineering standpoint, the most difficult aspect of a massive solar array like the one proposed would be storage, correct? Much of the wall would be in very isolated and desolate locations, which is kind of like the cabin concept you mentioned. A border wall would be a massive expenditure, clearly, but I would be happy if it were built and the complex was merely self sufficient from an energy usage standpoint. To be effective, a wall structure along the border would need to produce energy somehow for maintenance tools, spotlights, detection devices, video monitoring, thermal, etc. etc. as long as it produced enough energy to not equal a net energy deficit, I would consider it acceptable. I don't need the wall to be a massive green energy producer, but it would be nice. If it can be done, why not? Either way, stopping mass illegal immigration would save the U.S. taxpayer money in many many direct and indirect ways. Court expenditure for alien criminals, prison costs, deportation costs, welfare and healthcare for illegals etc. the list goes on. Btw, I don't normally attack anyone unless they attack me first, they are a troll I'm familiar with, or they say something so utterly pseudo intellectual that I can't help myself.
2
-
@ neil: It seems like an archaic practice to build walls, sure, but over 29 border walls have been planned, proposed, or built all over the world since 2000. There are 65 operating border walls in the world. Certainly all these countries have critically assessed the effectiveness and concluded they aren't an unnecessary waste of money and resources. I think the main difference between ancient and modern border walls is fairly obvious. Ancient walls were built to hinder, delay or thwart invading armies and raiding parties, as well as "mount detection devices (human surveillance)" as you said. Modern walls need only to hinder, delay or thwart the much less formidable and motivated common migrant. The exception being walls in places like Israel and the late great Berlin Wall. I also added earlier in this thread that physical barriers are used everywhere to designate boundaries and private property, not just national borders. It adds a psychological factor that implies "keep out," especially when concertina wire is used. Although it sounds simplistic, even walls that are easily defeated usually thwart human traffic to a significant degree. Apartment complexes, industrial yards, port facilities, government facilities, military bases, etc. all invest in physical barriers. I don't know how feasible a purely "detect and react" system would be, and in all actuality, we have plenty of detection and reaction capabilities that could be easily employed right now, but are not. I think solar powered drone systems could be used for detection and alerting reaction forces. This in conjunction with a physical barrier would be highly effective, in my opinion.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2