Comments by "Debany Doombringer" (@debanydoombringer1385) on "The Sad Tale of The Rings Of Power" video.

I've seen it brought up several times. Was there an extermination of every dark skinned carried out by every single race? It just shows how they don't care about the story, the work, or continuity. They only care about the message. My understanding is it's far more sinister. Celeborn is dead somehow, even though he's in LotR and Galadriel gets involved with the guy on the ship and he's the dark Lord (before he's the Dark Lord, but he went by many names prior). It's completely lore breaking in an attempt to do what Bezos demanded and turn it into GoT.
42
@rafnogueira You mean the ones that Amazon paid for an all expenses trip to watch 20 minutes and gave them lots of swag? Yeah not listening to paid off shills. Even most of them are finding it hard to defend it saying things like every show takes 3 seasons before it gets good. He addressed the professed Tolkien "scholars". That group doing the convention sound like they really love his work by how almost every panel is about how wrong he was and how to "improve" it. Edit: Define "ages". All I've seen are people in their 20s and maybe 30s who have degrees in things like gender something or race something along with other degrees. If you have a degree in an ideology, that ideology will affect the view you have on the other subjects you have a degree in. If you have studied something for ages, you'd be elderly.
3
@eoghankelly4377 It was the 6th king that changed it. Miriel was supposed to be the ruler, but her cousin forced her to marry him and he seized the Scepter of Numenor making him ruler. So this series makes no sense. Maybe know the lore before calling people names. She isn't supposed to be the ruler. She's an abused woman in a horrible relationship dominated by her husband. Her husband, the Golden, is corrupted easily by Sauron and attacks Valinor. Miriel is swept away and the line dies.
3
I was looking forward to how they would portray her given her situation. That perhaps there were those still loyal to her that helped protect her or help her not feel so alone and betrayed. Nope! They just ditch it all because we can't have a weak female portrayed ever.
2
At least with this trailer it has "based on". So they've changed the marketing from adaptation to based on.
1