Youtube comments of (@kallachi729).

  1. It intrigues me. It has been some time since I have noticed, that whenever there is a terror attack in the valley, the main stream media concentrates more on the lax security forces ( of course the laxity, if any, should be highlighted) and almost always fails to condemn the terrorists and the terror attacks. Just saying. Tailpiece: A National media should have its priorities right while enjoying almost unfettered freedom of speech.
    279
  2. Smell the coffee. Back in the late 1980s, I was posted in a government institution. In those days serial Ramayana was screened for an hour every Sunday morning. During times of heavy workload, because of the added work schedules, the institution worked on Sundays of some weeks. On those Sundays, I recall, the staff wanted an hour’s break between 09.30 – 11.00 AM to watch the serial Ramayana. I believe the whole nation came to a standstill during the screening. BJP etc. was not even on the horizon during that period. All said and done, the “Ram Mandir” in Ayodhya will be a boost to the hospitality, travel and tourism industries while boosting the State and local economies. Tailpiece: The stock value of L&T who constructed the Ram Temple, has almost doubled in the last one year.
    269
  3. Rift is not caused by speaking out the atrocities, any atrocity. Rift is caused by hiding the atrocities and by taking postures of denials.
    188
  4. We Indians protest. If a “democracy” like Canada allows such drama on their streets they only reveal their ignorance, pressure on government from fringe groups (poor administration), a false notion of free speech and democracy, poor leadership and much more. I pity the Canadians , Tailpiece: We move on as it does not change anything in India..
    181
  5. INC’s reaction to all crisis situations reminds me of the story of the ostrich which when encountered with danger buries it’s head in the sand and hopes the danger will pass by. Race to bottom? Gravity takes over! Tailpiece: Yes the Nation needs a strong “opposition” … not in words but in deeds. I hope the INC during its course of agitations against the price rise etc., also tell us what has led to the price rise and recommend actions to curb the same.
    150
  6. An eye opening exposition, DK. Here is one minister who probably runs his ministry as a corporate… looking at expenses, People, efficiency, profitable use of working capital, production at maximum capacity, innovation and the bottom line (in this case deliver to the public). Tailpiece: Many lessons there, I suppose. Ah and yes, he also finds corporate style delivers better than political inefficiency:)
    124
  7. Does Kamla Harris have to “remind” us that India matters? An intriguing headline! Appalled! Or is it a matter of English that says “..for the USA India matters”. Or is it my (mis)understanding that is intriguing. Any which way, it is intriguing!!!!!
    107
  8. Why did the media also fail to communicate? Is the media only to criticize and follow opportunistic/convenient journalism? Tailpiece: The easiest part of journalism is to criticize governments and institutions. Media must also some time do the difficult part of educating the people - in this case the farmers, possibly. It is a failure of self styled “experts” too.
    106
  9. IAS is a relic from the past. When we have specialists for each part of our body , in place of the good old family doctor, whither this general purpose service. What can they deliver in this century of specializations and going ahead? Tailpiece: Learning on the job is no more an option.
    103
  10. Hinduism is not a religion in the sense of Abrahamic religion. If you insist, it is the only democratic religion if you want to call it that). one can be a Hindu “believing’ in any deity (even of any Abrahamic religion) or no deity at all; having faith in any God or in no God at all; one can pray any which way one wants to at any time of day or/and night or not pray at all; Culture is a set of values which in the Indian sense is to be respectful, accommodating, open-minded, deeply but not ostensibly spiritual and concerned with the common human welfare offering respect and acceptance to all philosophies / religions. THIS, sir is Hindutva.
    98
  11. Another relevant and thought provoking presentation from SG. Yes, the electorate needs viable choices… But….I have a few points very briefly, (reams can be written on each) as follows:- 1. Why defeat Modi in the first place.? Defeating Modi (or any HOG/Government can not be an aim of the opposition). There is a Nation to be governed. 2. I do not suppose that economy is an issue as it is being handled fairly well in the obtaining circumstances. 3. The reports are that Indian foreign policy has placed it in a very comfortable position among the comity of Nations. 4. One can’t fault the administration too much (some failures/mistakes are always part of any governance….one has to only look at 75 years of Independent India to realize that) in general matters of governance and policies. 5. Handling of security has NOT weakened, given the long history of long unresolved and nebulous Northern borders. 6. If it is politics…here is a take. The Hindutva or rather “anti-Hindutva” and” secular” are no more relevant in Indian politics. The refrain is if political parties can be parochial (TMC, SS, DMK, TRS etc..), religion based (Muslim leagues, Akali etc..), Clan based (Yadavs, Gujjars etc.) and Dalit based (BSP etc.) or Dynastic (INC,SS, Yadavs, DMK, TC etc..) why can’t there be a party which is “Hindu” based? (I have my own take on this “Hindu” myth). What is the difference in any of these approaches? In electoral democracies every political party will attempt to create a strong faithful voter base. Probably BJP is doing just that. (BTW “Hindus” in droves are not blindly flocking to BJP ). THAT is a natural process in democracy. The perception of exclusion is just because the majority are not minority!!! That is also natural. In such an environment it is difficult to separate the wrong from the right in Indian politics – like it or not. And is that not part of diversity too? Can you have diversity with the exclusion of the majority? Tail piece. Before anything, the opposition has to convince “we the people” that they will do a better job for the Nation. So just a defeat will surely not “deliver “ the Nation from “evil”.
    96
  12. A good recall. I wonder why give a seemingly clean chit to Ms Gay. I sat through the congress deposition live On TV. It is abundantly clear from the deposition that all three Presidents, did not admit that call for genocide is abhor able even though it was evident they were aware. She also said that the words become abhor able only when it turns to action. On this when Gay was asked if she will take notice only on occurrence of genocide or words to that effect, she floundered and still did not condemn the call for genocide. She was abundantly aware of what she was saying I watched it, all,of it. Tailpiece: Now Ms Gay is just trying to redeem something out of it all, by the left - right and other such arguments. Let us not fall for it. Unfortunately we carry and profess wrong aspects of liberalism which is not good for liberalism. Just saying.
    84
  13. I am ashamed of our elected representatives. A kinder garten class of toddlers are better behaved. As a citizen who helped elect them I condemn such behaviour - if it means anything at all. Tailpiece: Also there is less commotion than in here at the proverbial “fish markets”. Is this democracy? Just asking.
    78
  14. I have a question Shekar. Why should fading (faded) politicians, rejected by the electorate, be revived. Why should we make a case for the resurgence of failed parties. Should we not be moving ahead? Just asking. Tailpiece: Do we want stories or development?
    75
  15. Does “releasing” Abagail absolve the terrorists of the gruesome murder of her father. Will that be forgotten by humanity? Just wondering… about justice etc..
    74
  16. SG. Okay. But attacking congress may bring congress votes to BJP which may make a difference in states like TN, Kerala, AP and Telengana etc… How did you miss that point? Tailpiece: Naming the parochial regional parties in Parliament by PM May give them prominence which the BJP does not want..
    73
  17. Good assessment. My take This IS serious… Consider this hypocrisy. The US Congress asked for the resignations of these presidents because they said.. action will be taken only if genocide or physical violence takes place, which was unacceptable to the US Congress. Different standards of free speech for propped up “dissidents” and homegrown universities? A blatant and glaring failure to take action in the case of Nijjar and Pannun who spew threats against India and Indian assets. . Tailpiece: Who will call out the USA?
    65
  18. I feel that the media should not talk about what other people think. Thoughts should not be news. Tail piece: What retired officials say in regard to their erstwhile vocations should always be taken with a pinch of salt for obvious reasons. The Q why they say it is more important than what they say.
    57
  19. Very true. Basic problem with Islam is “khafir, ummah and jihad to kill”. Very very true. The problem is neither beef nor idol beneath mosques. I fervently wish and hope all concerned see this for what it is. Tailpiece: All mankind is one family.
    57
  20. Now, comparing UP with Kerala is like comparing India with Japan. In this era of “data” there are places where data does not reveal everything. Developments in Kerala, for instance is a contribution of factors inherent in the State since many centuries. For instance, Kerala was trading with many other countries since millennia. Another fact is today, in more than 70% households in Kerala there is someone who is earning outside the state. It is a process. Central India has to install a process for development and NOT expect results overnight. Tailpiece: It is such matters that make India diverse and not religion and caste etc…. Change the narrative.
    56
  21. I also disagree with Swasti that India does not know the destination… in a multi lateral arrangement the engagements are issue based and at no time all the cards are laid on the table. The game is being deftly played by India. Media is never part of any diplomacy.
    51
  22. Old wine in old bottle. Elementary Dr. Watson, unless there is 7% (17%?) growth, there can’t be more employment. We are the second largest populated (soon to be the largest) Nation in the world. We are just 70 years old as a polity, after our colonisers left (with sizable loot?) and we got Independence. The growth in relative terms have been phenomenal. Politics by nature is diverse. In an evolving large and diverse as diverse can be Nation like India it can at times get beduffled. I wonder, why economists pass judgements in silos. Historical past, demography, natural resources, population etc. etc. play a major role in economic development. In relative terms, considering all variables, India has been progressing at a much faster pace than rest of the world since the past three decades. Tail piece: Universities churn out academic details and are less practical in analysis. Just saying.
    50
  23. That was the voice of a strong lady delivered with conviction. Bravo.
    50
  24. “We must look bad news in the face”. Absolutely right. But this over simplification of reality also does not make it go away. The bottom line is as a Nation we have failed to build industries (including for military hardware, which every major economies [ excluding Germany and Japan for reasons well known,]have done) , even though India traditionally has two belligerent neighbours, is a travesty and the singular reason for China galloping ahead. Let us now not cry over spilt milk. Instead let us concentrate, at least now, in helping the Nation build its own industries. A start is being attempted. Let us (the media) highlight this requirement. Tailpiece: Less discussions of street politics and more of of policies etc… in the media will help. Let us not live from election to election.
    49
  25. Good point. But I have a point for media in general (not to The Print). I only hope the case of “crying wolf” does not overtake such incidents. The media has been going Gaga whenever a crime is committed and a Muslim is involved on either side, to play it up as a. “Crime against Muslims” ( similarly for Dalits) even if the incident has nothing to do with religion or caste. Honest reporting by all sections of the media too may help. Tailpiece: The media out there should stop playing politics.
    49
  26. Unfortunate. Shocking. Tragic. Heartfelt condolences to all family and friends of the departed soldiers.
    49
  27. A good programme as usual. The Q remains. Are we Indians satisfied with mediocre politicking? Is it because we have never been exposed to quality politicking? There is something wrong here. Not sure what. Tailpiece: what can the people and the media do to improve matters?
    48
  28. Disclaimer : I am for a strong Media and a fan of The Print and recently of SG too. The irony is the belief of a large section of the media that the idea of India is only about politics. My experience in living (not visiting) in many parts of India over decades is that over 85% percent of Indians are, thankfully, NOT interested in the brand of "politics" played out in the media. Very few are followers. For instance, the 1 million subscribers subscribers (including me) to The Print form only .7693 % of the Indian population. Extend this liberally to all such media (print, tv, digital) you will get the whole picture. Also, for once, in this situation, the statistical data whether it is in regard to COVID or the economy are no indication of reality and should not be relied upon for possible corrective actions in economy. The answers are not also available in text books (the usually employed methods have failed all over the world) but in novel thinking and ingenuity. Divisive? What is it? Is it new or traditionally part of the society and politics since ages? Is it utopia? Just asking.
    47
  29. Such informative programmes are good and SG, Snehesh and The Print are doing a commendable job to tell something on Indian Defence matters. Well done. Keep it going. Some points from a Veteran: 1. Military history (including Balakote) is as fascinating as fiction. But the effect of any small operation like Balakote is for the immediate and is pointless as a historical study. Yes, all views should be considered but note that the perspectives of the commentators will be different - some of them may really not know the real “why” of such minuscule strikes. 2. The Chinese conundrum will play out for as long as the LAC remains undefined. Resolving the issue is not with the Military. 3. Defending India is a serious matter and not about sops, soaps and shampoos
    45
  30. “India thinks UP politics is the ultimate news” – I like that. A major blame for this should go to the mainstream media of India. Even with some perceived warts, ThePrint, I must say is changing the way Indian media handles news. I am impressed. Tailpiece: The media plays a major role in shaping a Nation.
    44
  31. Whether it be Ashokan, Nehruvian, Gandhian( not the Mahatma), Modian(? In the future) the Indian state has to do what it must to correct a mistake as soon as it is identified. By that time Ashokas, Guptas, Mauryas, Mughals, Marathas, British, Nehrus, Gandhi’s etc. would have already enjoyed their place in the Sun and may be irrelevant as administrators in the scenarios obtaining in the present. While we respect history we have to move on.
    44
  32. A great historical perspective. “In those days any Government in the centre could dismiss a state government, under article 356, it did not like”. So we can conclude that there is some improvement in the political arena these days. Tailpiece: we should also have cut the clutter like SG did on Narasimha Rao, concentrating on his contributions to Nation building.
    43
  33. At the outset my felicitation and thanks to Vikarm for telling the story, although much delayed, of the "misunderstood and maligned patriot"(in Vikram’s words) and a social reformist. What beats logic is that in our school days, Autocratic rulers like Aurangzeb, Hyder Ali etc (whose conduct was contrary to the nominal Human Rights standards - recorded and proven) were given prominence, if at all there were only passing references to VDS and Netaji. Just the social reform of breaking the “seven shackles” is reason enough to promote and study VDS Would you say that the British Raj, deliberately downplayed the contribution of leaders like VD Sarkar and Netaji in the Freedom movement (Indian) and propped up leaders of the INC, including influencing the school syllabus in an education system modelled in the British style? It then became a fait accompli for the new leaders of Independent India.
    42
  34. Useful information. Well presented. Tailpiece. The importance of self reliance and Indian democracy can’t be emphasized more. Let us not squabble. There is a world beyond religions and castes. A more practical and pragmatic world.
    40
  35. Do you mean you have a resurrected SAARC to just die again? I thought the original SAARC was dead and buried a decade back!!!!!
    39
  36. I disagree. Decisive actions need to be taken on perpetually simmering issues like J&K. There never was, is or will be utopia. In a large and diverse country as India, with power hungry politicians and a plethora of “experts” ( talk without responsibility) there can’t be please all policies and decisions. Tailpiece: Let us cut the small talk and try and take the country forward. Let us not repeat talks like broken records.
    39
  37. Way to go, ThePrint and Rajesh. Present the real India….let the people decide, what to do. Real democracy.
    38
  38. DK, we have never had a discussion on why Sidhu in the first place? Does he hold the strong suit or a trump card? if I may. Confounding.
    38
  39. Politics is no more “Dal-roti” of am aadmi. We have graduated to other sources for entertainment.
    36
  40. Is ignoring nine ED summons for an ongoing case implicating the AAP, the Dy CM is in jail denied bail by various courts, good morality and correct constitutional practice by a CM? Do you think this would have happened now, just before elections after a court denied AK protection in the case, if he had attended the first summons months ago?:Or is AAP deliberating doing this ( not attending summons calls) to play the victim card just before the elections elections.? Just asking
    35
  41. Shouting (not chanting)"Jai Sriram", or for that matter "Allah be praised" or "Praise the Lord", may have been out of place on such an occasion - but definitely not insulting. Is it a case of low self-esteem? Mamata and TMC, I suppose, are capable of doing better.
    35
  42. Sana is very clear about China… she knows China well…. Should be consulted by powers that be more often
    34
  43. When A. Kejriwal said free education and healthcare are not freebies he is right. But he and other politicians now don’t talk about the other freebies. Let me explain…. About education, which up to high school has been free since independence, So has been healthcare for decades in Government run hospitals. Nothing new here. In the late 1950s and 1960s, I also did not pay for my school education initially when I attended Government schools. What about free bus rides, water and electricity, cash payments, rations etc. etc. distributed “ Free” by AAP and other political parties but paid for from the taxes I pay - or not paid at all and accumulated as losses leading to state debt etc.? Media need to highlight these aspects also….to be really politically correct. Free electricity is killing many sates now. Tailpiece: Half truths are the hallmark in politics. (And sections of media?) Disclaimer. I am only a tax paying citizen and not a member of any political party. The real debate that media does not talk about is between the tax payer and political parties.
    34
  44. The title gives an impression that You are shocked that China is looking down on India. Do you expect otherwise with the history of Indo-China relations and its intention to lord over Asia? Is the impression a problem with the language mine/ yours? Or is it just to simply attract attention. Either way I find these headings for your videos are totally not in sync with what is discussed in them… Improvement required here
    33
  45. The larger debate should be “Should democracies allow anti National activities against other established democracies, from its soil? Also. What and why did the USA do to to eliminate”terrorist” Osama Bin Laden? Etc..etc…. Tailpiece: Let us not miss the wood for the trees….
    33
  46. Unique programme. Also proves that politics is in everything but it is NOT everything!!!! Great off the cuff.
    33
  47. DK. Yes. The aim- “To bring Modi down”. Is that really an aim the Nation wants? The aim defines intend. What are we the electorate supposed to read in these political developments in relation to Nation’s development. Tailpiece: Oh! By the way, there is also a Nation to be governed - Economy, foreign policy, Defence, etc.
    32
  48. It was always known that China will; the Q was only when? The “when” has multiple answers. The current time is just one of them. It is also that India has not been preparing. India is aware and has been constantly beefing up its defenses as best as it can. On a nebulous border, undefined across most of the 3500 km length, an undependable and aggressive China can be expected to play games as and when it suits them. In the absence of a judicial process to decide the dispute, there are only two options 1. Winner of a duel decides. 2. Negotiate; in which case there will be some give and take India (and China) has to decide. Did I get you right, SG?
    32
  49. Is the General suggesting that Operational orders and debriefing of operations be in the public domain? As it is there is enough in the public domain for even the uninitiated to surmise the situation. Should not the Nation leave some room for other actions like diplomacy and negotiations? Or is the General on to some agenda other than a winning case for India? E.g. will telling China in public ”look here, I have given you a bloody nose, now get back” work? Or does he, who was calling the shots in these areas as an Army Commander not long ago, suppose holding a public inquiry on all border skirmishes, within days, will help the military (I mean own military, not the enemy’s). I know many Indians, who have their own ideas of free speech and democracy etc, will applaud this General. But Defence, battles and wars are handled differently than Bollywood scandals. I am sure the General knows it too. But alas!
    32
  50. China’ s “claims” are real - a dragon is no match to a tiger. Unfortunately dragons exist only in imagination and stories while tigers are for real.
    32
  51. There has to be no right or wrong in any controversy. All this is “Much ado about nothing”. Regimented religions have to accept the free spirit of some other “religions”. How do we get the message across to such religions to come down from a stand that “my way is high way” even if scriptures have to be rewritten. Also, religious freedom is directly proportional to freedom within religion. Ah and yes, tolerance is not a one way street. Yes,Religion is not essential for existence. It is only a medium for exploitation and blackmail.
    31
  52. DK, if you term Sons and daughters of politicians joining politics as dynasts should you not also classify the Indian Defence forces as a dynastic force? Also the Indian judiciary as dynastic? I wonder, if The print is also joining the TRP brigade.
    30
  53. Good prentation SG. My take. We want all things to be perfect the first time. That has never ever happened anywhere anytime with anybody. It is about making a beginning and progressing. Why so long…. We know why…. It all started much later. Much much later….. so so long…. But then again there never can be a perfect thing…. We continue to aim for perfection… Tailpiece: Yes SG, future and look ahead….. debates are perennial … good for improvements… bestest to us Indians. Jai Hind.
    30
  54. I agree for whatever its worth. Freedom... of expression etc.. Uphold it. Tolerence is not a one way street.
    30
  55. A fantastic analysis of Politics, which has its place in the media. But are we missing the woods for the trees? My two bit. I feel, with the increasing reach of the media in various media (print, TV, digital etc.), it is time to take these discussions to another level. The discussion should now focus on the approach to economic development, law and order, social uplift etc. of the political parties rather than on their winnability by any other means. Discourses always, on just “politics” does not benefit the Nation in any way. Tailpiece: We need to focus on the approach to National progress and development by political parties more, rather than on caste creed and such stuff. Can The Print take a lead?
    29
  56. Do we agitate for MSP for all products including in manufacturing and services sector. Just asking.
    29
  57. In the Armed Forces any target is always neutralized. Killing the enemy or the target is not an aim anytime. There is a difference. Tailpiece. Good programme “Cut the clutter”.
    28
  58. Good intention in the presentation. But SG and possibly, for whatever reasons, some senior veterans recommend reduction in the strength of the Indian Army. A sagacious thought in the 21st century, no doubt. We all want a lean and strong Army. In the process some very basic realities are overlooked - notwithstanding the advent and prowess in technology. 1. We can’t be compared with the US for any and every aspect of life. We are different and in a way unique. 2. India is the only sovereign Nation in the world with a long border of varied and rugged terrain ( from glaciers to deserts) of over 4000 Kms with two belligerent neighbors. Technologies required to defend these borders will be varied. 3. I hope the experts will also consider the cost of technology, its maintenance costs, cost of upgrades, operational costs and time ( as in period) required to deploy them before recommending debilitating actions. Tailpiece: we want to defend the sovereignty of our Nation efficiently at minimum cost…. But….
    28
  59. Fortunately the time for such Hindu-Muslim debate is in the past. One need not be a Hindu, Parsi, Sikh, catholic, Buddhist or Muslim to deliver to the people, of India… Sabke saath San ka vikas. It is not one has to be from a a particular religion to deliver to the people of that religion. Stop that narrative especially the media. Any Indian can deliver to any Indian. The time for communal polities and appeasement of minorities is over. Give your vote to the party that will deliver on its promises of a return to the highest traditions of Indian secularism: equality and justice and not on religious lines. Tailpiece: UCC Will go a long way to reclaim real secularistic idea, equality and Vikas all around. Unfortunately this is a wrong narrative by you SG. Indian Muslims are the best off among all Muslims in the free world… make no mistake The INC has only taken the Muslim votes and done nothing for their education and wellbeing
    27
  60. Who lays down the limit? Is the limi defined for only one end or for both (all ends). Tailpiece: with due respect to ALL religions, please do not wear your religion on your sleeves. In a fair situation the insult is always on the “insulter” and not on the perceived “insulted”. We must tone down the unwanted rhetorics.
    27
  61. DK, I was expecting you say that the Gandhis should make way for others to lead the INC. Gandhis can never ever rejuvenate INC. As you have said earlier, even Modi is leaving the states to the local party leaders. Also whoever comes as the “face” INC has to veer away from the Modi-Adani narrative…
    27
  62. DK a factual recount. Your commentaries are balanced and informative. But, I am disappointed with the mainstream media in general. Most media talk of what the Governments are not doing. That is fine and should be so. In the same breath, should not the same media also be speaking what the Governments are doing? Tailpiece: I vent my feelings here as the Print is the only media I follow, these days after more than half a century of listening to mostly unproductive “news” put out in public domain.
    27
  63. Anything that happens anywhere in the world, you have a lesson for India… agreed learning is a continuous process. But let us not stretch it Let us get this right, Shekhar In any which way, India is NOT Bangladesh; India is also not the USA, China, Singapore or any European nation. India is India with its own unique characteristics. India, as it is doing since the past couple of decades, has to cut its own path. We the people are the key. There is a famous dialogue by RajniKant, the Tamil super star, (“En Vazhi, Thani Vazhi”) meaning my path is my own Enjoy, smile, laugh
    27
  64. Rishi for PM is following a path much like the Indian victory over Pakistan yesterday, in a group match of the ongoing T20 World Cup - From a point of no rerun, so to speak. Could be the best bet for British economy, hopefully.
    27
  65. Uhmmmm….. Future PM? Letting the cat out of the bag. Tailpiece: I sincerely hope RG meets real Indians during his “walkathon” and not only those paid to meet him.
    26
  66. These issues are less complicated than they are made out to be. The simple explanation is that unless there is a quid pro quo there is no relationship. Geographical location of Pak (as SG had said in an earlier programme) is what they can give. China and Russia are interdependent economically (SG has said this also in an earlier programme). What can India contribute? A market? Can India give away the one thing that will help in its development, progress etc. Tailpiece: India has no choice but to keep at bay the wolves on two fronts and concentrate on the economy. Elementary Dr. Watson.
    25
  67. What is freedom of religion and individual rights when religion itself binds you and tells you what to wear, what to eat, sees women different from men etc…. It is akin to political parties who do not practice democracy within wanting to defend Nation’s democracy and constitution. A paradox par redemption. Let us grow out of archaic shackles. Tailpiece: It is time to redefine methods ordained in religions….all religions.
    24
  68. Some plain talking for whatever it’s worth. The shenanigans of elected members (irrespective of parties, today and in the coming days) in the house, should end. We the people are fed up with the sham happenings in the August houses.. Tail piece: Such commotion does not happen even in the worst class in a badly managed school.
    24
  69. RSS Vs Marxist in Kerala predates BJP ! Just saying
    24
  70. Hats off Swamy….Hope Pakistani people are listening to this
    24
  71. It is sad to see that the people evaluate Governments by feelings rather than by performance. Discuss the acts, omissions and commissions at length without coloring it with prejudices.
    24
  72. I wish the real picture is presented in these programmes.
    24
  73. Are we following the constitution to the T. Why have we had more than 100 amendments? Why are we ignoring many aspects of the constitution and emphasizing only a few Articles? Why are the “experts” and the media silent or soft peddling on many Articles of the constitution not yet implemented? While methods to implement may differ the point is the Constitution WANTS a UCC. Period. Discuss that. Tailpiece: We the people should shun hypocrisy and double standards in our approach to Nation building. The jirga system of Afghanistan is well past its shelf life in 2022.
    24
  74. Good programme(s) on world affairs. Dispels “frog in the well syndrome”...
    23
  75. At the outset my felicitation and thanks to Vikarm for telling the story, although much delayed, of the "misunderstood and maligned patriot"(in Vikram’s words) and a social reformist. What beats logic is that in our school days, Autocratic rulers like Aurangzeb, Hyder Ali etc (whose conduct was contrary to the nominal Human Rights standards - recorded and proven) were given prominence, if at all there were only passing references to VDS and Netaji. Just the social reform of breaking the “seven shackles” is reason enough to promote and study VDS Would you say that the British Raj, deliberately downplayed the contribution of leaders like VD Sarkar and Netaji in the Freedom movement (Indian) and propped up leaders of the INC, including influencing the school syllabus in an education system modelled in the British style? It then became a fait accompli for the new leaders of Independent India.
    23
  76. Will the Western media now climb down from the high pedestal on which they reside and stop sneering at the “developing” Nations?
    22
  77. Rahul Gandhi “entered” politics in 2004 as part and virtual,leader of a century old political party. Arvind Kejariwal “entered” politics in 2012. Quality and acumen is all too evident or absent as you want to see…. Just saying. Tailpiece: You can make somebody a manager but you can’t make nobody a leader. Again just saying.
    22
  78. Snehesh, A good account of events etc.. as usual. The incident in Mon, is unfortunate and regrettable. The families of the victims should be cared for. The inquiry should not stop with the elite Army Unit, which has an exemplary record of operations and can’t be expected to kill civilians on purpose. Let me explain. The issue is more than that meets the eye. It has been more than seven decades since India is an independent Nation. In many areas in the North and North East the Indian Army has been entrusted with the responsibility of containing the insurgents. An unacceptable situation in a democracy, which clearly indicates that the democratic and diplomatic processes have not been employed efficiently by the elected Governments. The Nation can’t expect the Armed Forces to do that job ad nauseum. The responsibility for this unfortunate and regrettable incident lies even outside of the Army unit. Tail piece: While we have a bureaucracy with immense authority and no responsibility, we expect the Armed Forces to be responsible without authority. Let us accept that AFSPA is a sham as it provides no authority and very little protection to Armed Forces – remember they are dealing with their own country men as opposed to what they are trained to do on the battlefield.
    22
  79. Obviously a political posturing. OK, this is democracy. But many Indians like me do not consider this or that a victory. But then the language of politics in our Nation is suck. We have to endure it, I suppose. Can some opposition political party explain through a white paper, how the rescinded farm laws do not benefit the farmers of India or any Nation which has such laws? Can that party also explain why only about 30% farmers from 20% geographical extent of India were protesting? How can it be a “victory” of farmers of India let alone people of India. As Indians we want the opposition to function responsibly in an informed manner. Be sure, that we will vote in any party that can really deliver. Tailpiece: The investments are flowing back to China because with all its warts the Chinese Goverment can take decisions and implement them. If India succumb to protests by minuscule population and vested interests and allow these agenda based “agitations” to derail its progressive policies, we will forever be a laggard democracy and remain the favorite place of the Western press and a large section of our own (mirroring) media to showcase our “backwardness”.
    22
  80. Vijay Diwas is about remembering the soldiers who laid down their lives on the battle field in 1971. There is no doubt that Indira Gandhi was a PM to be remembered….may be on many other days.
    22
  81. “Diwali Gift?” Pathetic heading! I am sure The Print can use better language for affairs of Defence, rather than treat it like a soap opera.
    22
  82. Fanatastic, upfront, truthful, and bare facts. Europe have always been imposing for centuries.. proud of India and Indian FM
    22
  83. Absolutely right. About education which up to high school has been free since independence, So has been healthcare in Government run hospitals. Nothing new here. In the late 1950s and 1960s, I also did not pay for my school education initially when attended Government schools. What about free bus rides, water and electricity? Free by AAP and other political parties but paid for from the taxes I pay - or not paid at all and accumulated as losses leading to state debt etc.? Tailpiece: Half truths are the hallmark in politics. Disclaimer. I am only a tax paying citizen and not a member of any political party.
    21
  84. A constitution that has been amended more than a 100 times in 75 years? Still a work in progress? Just asking. Tailpiece: We must get down to plain talking from hypocritical ventilations.
    21
  85. I wonder why some of the media repeatedly want to compare chalk with cheese. With due respect all around…. Modi has been in politics since his teens; He knows the history of India; He has grown under the leadership of Vajpayee and Advani; He was CM of a large state for 15 years; the PM of India for 7 plus years; Rahul? Well…. Just saying. No disrespect but just bewilderment at the attempts to compare…. Tailpiece: The media should realize that the audience are a much wiser lot than, say, a couple of decades ago. Just saying.
    21
  86. A new style of presentation, DK. In a real democracy there can’t be a leader who is not ‘controversial’. And a leader who remains a leader despite controversies is the one who delivers. Very elementary. Tailpiece: A detached person with no encumbrances has a freer mind and is more passionate towards work. Again elementary .
    21
  87. The art of seeing politics in any and everything is pervasive in Indian media. ‘Democracy’ you would say. OK. Is it good or bad for progress? Who decides? The media? This is no exception. But be mindful of one aspect,; most Indians lead a life divorced from politics. They are the majority…..Finally what matters is only roti, kapda and makkan. Tailpiece: To what end such interpretations? When will we “grow out of this?”
    21
  88. I have never heard Mr Owaisi speak on development, education, upping the living standards etc.. for his electorate. Have you? Or is it that he thinks those don’t really matter in life? Tailpiece: It is time all politicians stop poodle,faking and taking the electorate for a ride.
    20
  89. Does election as an MP or MLA absolve the person of all crimes committed by him / her? We know money can get one elected to a house. Be honest
    20
  90. The character of a Nation is shaped by its own culture and the influence of external cultures predominantly through occupation (Kublai etc. in China (only 160 years), Delhi Sultanate, Mughals etc. in India (621 years) and influence of colonization (East India Company, British and others (1608-1947); none in China. As is evident, the Chinese culture as in a polity, has had very little telling influence from the outside. The one-party rule of the CCP for decades has ensured a direction to the economy and society of China. The methods may be dubious and unpalatable to the free world but the effect is seemingly effective as desired by the CCP, so far. CCP directly controls most of the economy while it influences the remaining businesses. Tailpiece. Ultimately money talks. That is the first language of China and not Mandarin.
    20
  91. Why is defeating Modi a topic for discussion…. The discussion should be the pros and cons of Governance..just Governance…policies successes and failures. The very aim of combined opposition with an aim just to defeat Modi defeats democracy. Pathetic politics in India. Tailpiece: Et tu media?
    20
  92. Is disagreeing same as destruction, disruption, desecration and defilement and debasement? Tail piece: Patriotism is not in the picture unless created by the media.
    20
  93. Why does not the media, including programmes in this space, discuss in details the role not played by the states in nation building? A federal republic lie India can’t depend only on the central government to deliver progress including jobs. fault the states and hold them too responsible for inaction… well, I can sense you will not do it
    19
  94. A good analysis. Relationships, even in a marriage, takes time to mature and become stable. Like wine, older the better. Moreover, in this dynamic multifaceted world, we have few options. Unfortunate.
    19
  95. Interesting… good articulation. Can ThePrint define “Hindutva” as meant by Sonia?
    19
  96. No issues whether Aryan Khan should or should not get bail. Say, I am not a legal expert. But my point is as a citizen, why does the media go to town for celebrities and celebrity kids etc… only. There are 1000s of citizens languishing in jails in the country for similar reasons (may be less severe alleged “crimes”). If the justice system needs improvement (it sure does) the “experts”, I am sure have many avenues than fire the gun from celebrities shoulders. Such selective media attention produces a stink. If the aim is to raise awareness such cases are not the ideal examples. Tailpiece: Such unwanted publicity may be detrimental to the celebrities vocation, peace of mind etc… and surely does not help the case either way in any way.
    19
  97. Do I get a feeling some leading Qs were put out? Uhmm… Tailpiece: Crypto as of now is like Tghlak’s chamde ka Sikka.
    19
  98. There is a feeling in a very large section of the Indian population, that some farmers and some politicians have AS USUAL turned the representations of farmers into nothing more than political gimmick. What with talks still open and the judiciary also involved in the matter, is there a genuine reason for prolonging this “agitation”? Who represents the voice of this section of Indians who see a deja Vu in these shenanigans from all sides? Agitation-failed talks- violent agitation- casualties- political parties come for photo ops and In front of the camera with the sole aim of garnering votes. In the past five decades we have seen this game played over many times. Frustrated. Tail piece: There are “genuine demands” from the unorganized sector, from laborers, from industrial workers, from the informal economy, from MSMEs, from the industry, from airline operators and from just about all and sundry. At some point we have to get real and move on.
    19
  99. It is always a pleasure to hear an accomplished economist (who by nature are and should be pessimistic/cautious) give views on the economy. What sours RR’s comments are there is always a suspicion that they are coloured because of his proclaimed political leanings. We have already lost a great economist, MMS, to the vagaries of politics. I am afraid we may lose another one. Tailpiece: Economy is more important than politics. Economy feeds. Politics consumes . Just saying.
    18
  100. Is it absolutely necessary to react to everything Pakistan says in regard to India. Most times mere silence (ignoring) is enough to convey thoughts. Tailpiece: Pakistan, most times, uses India to fight internal problems, just by way of distraction. Let us not play their game and waste our time. Media should also recognize this.
    18
  101. DK, a good point in regard to BJP. It may be for the good. The secret is that old adage “How you do it is more important and effective than what you do”. Elementary approach. Dissensions and individual identities of members within any political party from within is healthy in a real democracy. Shows our democracy is maturing. Tailpiece: Also, silence at times makes more noise than shout out. In chess, the winning tactics is to find new moves and not follow known moves to catch the opponent by surprise !!! Changing face of politics?
    18
  102. I find the heading a bit provocative. Could have been better.
    18
  103. An important reflection of politics in India. Tail piece: We the people have to ask the big Q. “Are the politicians controlling the electorate like puppets with feelings for strings?
    18
  104. Presented with clarity and natural exuberance of a seasoned journalist, SG. Tailpiece: With so many meaningful quotes, probably, the judgement does not need more than 50 pages!
    18
  105. It was Nationalism that got us our independence. The natural follow up is it has to be Nationalism that will sustain our independence. Tailpiece: what is parochialism (Tamil pride, Bengal pride, Jat pride, and such other “prides”)? Are they any different from Nationalism in feelings and resultant actions? Let us not fool ourselves by saying NATIONALISM is dangerous. It is time “pseudo liberals” changed the narrative. Nation is not confined to drawing rooms and “media articles etc.”.
    18
  106. “Every job looks easy when you’re not the one doing it.”
    18
  107.  @Lifegoeson98-z6x  haha. Indians do not celebrate.. Maybe, you actually mean a few in India do. Right?
    18
  108. In the frenzy to defend the agitators and public property damages, the media, AS USUAL ( thinking that they are the only defenders of free speech and democracy), are considering it as more important than defending the sovereignty of India. While the aenipath is a super programme for better distribution of wealth and empowering the youth who other wise may have languished ( they get a degree, possible skill set and 15-20 lakh by age 26). So some on, the media should concentrate on sending the agitators (who are once again exploited by interested middlemen) back home. Tailpiece: Don’t for God’s sake glorify agitations.
    17
  109. I also disagree with Swasti that India does not know the destination… in a multi lateral arrangement the engagements are issue based and at no time all the cards are laid on the table. The game is being deftly played by India. Media is never part of any diplomacy. I also agree with Santa that for China or for India was. /is never about trrritory
    17
  110. I get a feeling that a section of the media and some journalists are more fixated with Nehrus, Gandhis, Modis and Shas than 137.975 core Indians. I wonder whether this attitude will help in building the young India.
    17
  111. Commendable knowledge on hockey. In the 1960s, it was 1 goal keeper, 2 backs (left &right), 3 in half line (left, centre, right), 5 forwards - left out, left in, centre forward, right in, right out.
    17
  112. Basically, it was NOT done before 1991. Period. If the bureaucracy has to get the credit they must also take flak and punishments for the wrongs too. Tailpiece: Let us not take away the effects of initiatives and actions taken by the minority government of NS Rao. Period
    17
  113. Probably India needs a “Abraham Lincoln”.
    17
  114. A good diplomat, experienced and a well nuanced take on China. I wish, for the sake of India and Indians, he had taken a minute to explain the difference between National pride and Nationalism. The narrative of National pride is getting increasingly eclipsed by the agenda based discourses on Nationalism. Tailpiece: National pride is essential to safeguard sovereignty, more so in a vibrant and diverse democracy. Make no mistake here.
    17
  115. Great. Indians need to know these issues to understand that running a Nation is not easy. Rhetorics are a facade and temporary. Gotta view National affairs beyond religion and caste and more importantly parochial interests. Tailpiece: A positive aspect of digitization… improved knowledge
    17
  116. Ha. Tell us something new. Heard this these past 70 years or so… a deja Vu. E.g. when congress aligned with communists, congress aligned with BSP, with Shiv Sena, with NCP, etc.. In Indian democracy ideological differences among political parties is a myth and/or perception and fodder for the media.
    16
  117. A sane evaluation as usual. My two bit: It is best to leave history behind and focus on a solution in the Middle East, considering the present…. Sample these notes (my notes) from History…. The first written records referring to Palestine emerged in the 12th-century BCE, twentieth dynasty of Egypt, which used the term Peleset for the neighboring people or land. In the 8th century BCE, the Assyrians referred to the region as Palashtu or Pilistu. Since we know that Judea and Samaria (Jewish states) existed in the region much before the last two millennia, how is it that the Jews are not included in Palestinians? Reading the history of evolution of Islam, with particular reference to Jerusalem (620 CE) is recommended. How far back in history do we want to go? The further we go back the future suffers… our children suffer. Instead, the Arabs and the world can create another “Israel” with the other “Palestinians”. Note: Israel Est: 1948 – is the third richest Nation in Asia. Tailpiece: And ah! (With malice to none, a general statement) No religion has brought peace to the world… some individuals may have benefitted from some religions… but in general religions have only wrought destruction over centuries.
    16
  118.  @Valkyri3Z  Calling for genocide is free speech and killing school children every other day is freedom of expression, right? And please do not get worked up and get personal
    16
  119. A good point raised in LS, by the opposition. No doubt. Wonder why such a passage was even conceived by somebody is despicable Ruhi, this is not a point raised by the Gandhi family.How can you say that. That is the language of the dynastic congress, which does not bode well for the Nation. As bad as being a misogynist. Tail piece: For any opposition or media to be taken seriously the language matters. Also, while criticizing the perceived faults the good also needs to be appreciated. .
    16
  120. Why and unpopular for who? Unnecessary comment TCA…. In a democracy everybody is unpopular to somebody… cheers. You sound, overall, apologetic in commending N. Sitaram… why?
    16
  121. Could it be because they seldom put their heart into what they do (should be doing)?
    16
  122. As usual a good analysis. Is Pakistan in a good place? No. Well brought out by SG. If Pak “claims” Taliban, it will also be responsible for what they do and a don’t do in respect to the people of Afghanistan. If they are seeing China as a money bank a Q is relevant. The Q is what has Pakistan economy gained from China in the past three decades? Tailpiece: Bottle caps are not Available here to generate reverse swing. And the world is watching if Pakistan plays with a straight bat.
    16
  123. The heading suggests that Yasin Malik is a harbinger of peace to Kashmir. Can Praveen S. clarify to all Indians especially those in Kanyamumari etc… what he really means by implying that. The Hippocrycy of it all is damning.. It is time the facade is broken. Tailpiece: ENOUGH IS ENOUGH. GET INTO THE DEMOCRACTIC SYSTEM OR STAY OUT OF THE SYTEM. That should me the message to separatists. A separatist by definition can’t bring peace to a Nation.
    16
  124. Anybody, I say ANYBODY, wearing his/her religion on his/her sleeve is dangerous to the well-being of society…any which way. Tailpiece: I repeat, tolerance is NOT a one way street.
    15
  125. I wonder why media persons are continually advising the Givernment instead of just presenting the alternatives in a palatable language. She should have also added that since a decade Indian already doing trying to indigenise. She also fails to say that it should done this since 1950s. It can’t happen overnight…
    15
  126.  @rohinipanakal  I agree. What is the qualification of a first time MP, Ms P. Gandhi Vadhra, elected from a very very safe seat to lead a Nation of 140b people except that she is a woman…
    15
  127. Great aim of Indian political parties “dislodge the ruling party, get to power and amass…… The end of democracy. What an idea Sirji?
    15
  128. Is ignoring nine ED summons for an ongoing case implicating the AAP, the Dy CM is in jail denied bail by various courts, good morality and correct constitutional practice by a CM? Do you think this would have happened now, just before elections after a court denied AK protection in the case, if he had attended the first summons months ago?:Or is AAP deliberating doing this ( not attending summons calls) to play the victim card just before the elections elections.? Just asking
    15
  129. “Modi”, Rajyapaksha” and “China” and not “India”, “Sri Lanka” and “China”! Wonder why….Xi has a far more tighter stranglehold on China….. Not objective reporting…. Just saying. Tailpiece: The Print needs to improve the Headlines in this segment of videos.
    15
  130. The best line “Can’t say no to mangoes”. Tailpiece: There never was, is or will be a utopia (Ramrajya) even in (especially in?) a democracy and in any system of Governance.
    15
  131. The incident in Mon, is unfortunate and regrettable. The families of the victims should be cared for. The inquiry should not stop with the elite Army Unit, which has an exemplary record of operations and can’t be expected to kill civilians on purpose. Let me explain. The issue is more than that meets the eye. It has been more than seven decades since India is an independent Nation. In many areas in the North and North East the Indian Army has been entrusted with the responsibility of containing the insurgents. An unacceptable situation in a democracy, which clearly indicates that the democratic and diplomatic processes have not been employed efficiently by the elected Governments. The Nation can’t expect the Armed Forces to do that job ad nauseum. The responsibility for this unfortunate and regrettable incident lies even outside of the Army unit. Tail piece: While we have a bureaucracy with immense authority and no responsibility, we expect the Armed Forces to be responsible without authority. Let us accept that AFSPA is a sham as it provides no authority and very little protection to Armed Forces – remember they are dealing with their own country men as opposed to what they are trained to do on the battlefield.
    15
  132. I will give 2.5/10 for the effort. This “election” will surely silence those who want the Gandhi name out from the helm. But two Questiins remain. 1.Are Gandhis really out of controlling the congress? 2.Will this effort really benefit the congress as an election is supposed to provide? Tailpiece: I doubt there will be many buyers here. No change expected in the stock price.
    14
  133. In any organization, serious matters are discussed only after informing the superiors/peers of the agenda and giving them time to study the matter(s) to be discussed. So then, what does Mr. Swarup want to convey by saying “..ministers have to take an appointment etc.” as if it has a negative connotation. In fact that is how National matters are to be discussed…with warning and time for study. A press meet by a minister is a serious affair…. All concerned including the PM should know about in advance. What is wrong with that? Now don’t bring in humbug of freedom etc… there is enough and more freedom going around in our Nation. Tailpiece: The penchant to wash linen…. Etc.. should be curbed. Monitoring is not the same as control…right?
    14
  134. Ms. Jyoti you have headlined your article in the digital print version as “will India abandon…..and become a camp follower”. I feel it is a demeaning heading far from truth. You know it. Then why? Tailpiece: In life how you do it matters more than what you do. As a leading media person how you do it matters more than what you write.
    14
  135. Best practices in Indian democracy? Ah!!! Support the statement or condemn it? Can we have views of “experts”, media, liberals, leaders of political parties, leaders in civil society et al? Just asking.
    14
  136. A potent topic. It is best for India to keep track and act in our interest where necessary in regard to Af, rather than let things meander and trouble finds its way into India. Tailpiece: Good that ThePrint is gives space to such developments. But such repeats prove the more things change more they remain the same
    14
  137. Therein lies the irony of politics in democracy. The stated aim of this leader is to get his party into power. For most parties the aim is “get power and retain it at all costs”. For sections of society the aim is to agitate and retain undue advantages, like some of the “farmers” of India. Long live democracy. Tailpiece: In democracies all over the world people go out and vote. In India people are encouraged to cast(e) their votes. So we remain a laggard democracy. One step forward two steps back.
    14
  138. With malice to none. It would seem from various media reports (including The Print) that India has a lesson to learn from whatever is happening in the world whenever with whoever and the media and experts will teach her. Tailpiece: A bit intriguing and bordering on preposterous.
    14
  139. The most striking feature of today’s very impressive RD parade was that the Supreme Commander of the Indian Armed Forces (The President) took the Salute smartly (army like) without twitching or swaying, standing erect for the whole duration of 50 odd minutes of the marching contingents filing past. A first for a President. Tailpiece: Watch it again.
    14
  140. Rajasthan did not go to polls this year. Just saying
    14
  141. A true presentation, SG. In all this melee we forget our youngsters who probably go astray using drugs coming from Afghanistan etc…. That is the bigger National problem. This case will also pass, any which way - after everybody (including the media - not The Print ) gets mileage. Tailpiece: concentrate on the larger problem. Here size of seizures from users does matter, as they are replenished regularly from those thousands of kilos. Drug is a drug is a drug.
    14
  142. Super off the cuff…refreshing and upfront!
    14
  143. The actual normal irritants of democracy…SG, give a thought to the Nation…democracy is not synonymous with chaos I f RG or anybody has a half the acumen of Modi (with all his warts) India will be well served, alright… But… is there? “Democracy” is “back” in India. We will be able to witness the dance of democracy in social media and on the streets with false narratives, out of context comments, protests, hartals, road blocks (Rasta roko), bandhs, constant disruptions in parliamentary proceedings etc. Everything except policies, progress, development, economy, reforms etc. will be discussed in the media – all media. The West and all those who want India to stagnate will laugh all the way to the bank. Will India go back in time to be a subservient state? You got a ring side view to season 3 of the “India” series… Get your dinks, snacks and plonk on the sofa in front of your TV.
    13
  144.  @KiranKumar-nb4nx  the power is really with the bureaucracy who are not ever held accountable. Hence the delays and that is what the Minister has conveyed
    13
  145. Good DK. But isn’t it ironic that we continue to discuss diversity in diversity even in the twenty first century…. I am disheartened at 70+ unfortunate Tailpiece: who exactly is playing divisive politics in India? Just asking.
    13
  146. A must know by us Indians…what is happening elsewhere too is important… About two decades back, it was reported that a President of USA thought that India-Pak conflict is civil war… Tailpiece: It is good to know India is discussed/ has interests in all parts of the world… better now than never
    13
  147. Another milestone towards superpower status… with help from Pakistan….. just saying
    13
  148. The biggest "investment" is not putting boot on ground. What ever we did in Afghanistan is for the Afghan people. Afghanistan is a sovereign state whose people will decide what is best for them. I suppose nothing else is possible. So what different policy is there? Cohabit overtly with the Taliban?
    13
  149. Snehesh (and The print), you are doing great. Yes, to day while the battles are fought across physical borders and geographies, the wars are fought elsewhere. Perceptions (internal and external) is vital for a strong democracy to sustain. The battlefield encompasses information influence, economy (sanctions) and even sports like Cricket, Olympic Games etc… This is a vast subject by itself which Snehesh may take on one day. There is no harm in disseminating any information except tactical plans and troop dispositions (also any other particular sector specific aspect so defined). Tailpiece: It is imperative for the Nation to know it’s soldiers. It will add to the strength of the Defence forces.
    13
  150. Why is no media coming up with the month wise total deaths in India for 2019 and 2020 to discern likely increase in deaths due to the virus. The world and India is only shadow boxing with testing and statistics
    13
  151. In any negotiation there is always a give and take. May I request Mr. Gokhale, what’s is India prepared to give?
    13
  152. For who is this programme. Do your target audience have enough knowledge on Afghanistan to answer your Q? Can do without these “leading” headings. It is not the common man who will decide whether India should get involved. If you are attempting to educate or inform, have the headings right. Thank you.
    13
  153. Looking at the behavior of Muslim leaders, etc. why do I get an uncanny feeling that most of them want tensions to simmer, for existence. So do some fringe elements, for existence. In such a scenario situations are exploited by vested interests. When there are political parties catering to Muslims, Dalits, sectarian (DMK etc..) etc. etc..and promoting their respective localized interests only, the refrain is why can’t there be a party whose core support base is “hindu” (some Hindus or whatever) based? (I do not support the concept of Hindus. That is another story). Any pro is considered by the other as anti. Unlike the virtual world the real world is not binary. As I mentioned elsewhere too, dog whistles can be blown by anybody. Tail piece: It is time we change these narratives. Else all will exploit and such discussions will eclipse the million dollar progress etc.
    13
  154. Yes, the BJP is playing its cards to implement strategies in electoral politics. The Hindutva or rather “anti-Hindutva” and” secular” are no more trump cards for the opposition parties. The refrain is if political parties can be parochial (TMC, SS, DMK, TRS etc..), religion based (Muslim leagues, Akali etc..), Clan based (Yadavs, Gujjars etc.) and Dalit based (BSP etc.) or Dynastic (INC,SS, Yadavs, DMK, TRS etc..) why can’t there be a party which is “Hindu” based? What is the difference in any of these approaches? In electoral democracies every political party will attempt to create a strong faithful voter base. THAT is a natural process. In such an environment it is difficult to separate the wrong from the right in politics. Tailpiece: There never was, is or will be a Utopia (Ramrajya).The electorate has realized that Governance is all about the Nation to deliver Roti, Kapda and Makkan to its people. All else are distractions. Economy and development (Ease of living) will be key. In order to further preserve Indian democracy, the opposition parties have to change tactics and strategies. We fervently hope that they will do it. Welcome to the changing face of Indian politics.
    13
  155. Is Mumbai/Maharashtra a private property of Mr Raul’s Shiv Sena? Let us have some erudite politics from seasoned poiticians, please
    13
  156. I wonder. With my experience, I can say that the industry always prefers to take in locals at the levels indicated for “reservations”, if qualified locals are available for the jobs. So, why this political drama which is “much ado about nothing”….except political posturing…. Deja Vu….
    13
  157. Deplorable. Worth checking if he was inebriated. Tailpiece: Immediate suspension, by speaker ( though not in the house)… unfortunately the police will not press charges
    13
  158. Did you say, you go to sleep?
    13
  159. HAMAS should also stay away from hospitals….just saying
    13
  160. Sermons are dime a dozen and media houses aplenty. Just saying. Top officials of our own country, INDIA, are saying neutrality is a way forward while condemning violence and calling for peace. India can have a mind of its own and say what it has to say without really saying it. Tail piece: There IS a lesson here - especially for NDTV too - National interest are paramount in any dealings, diplomacy, stand. National interest is paramount for a "leading" news channel of the Country.
    13
  161. Is dislodging a party a matter for discussion at National level? I thought policies and progress under a Government / parties should be discussed. I feel the media (sadly, including some programs in The Print too) are following a wrong narrative which eclipses the good and bad policies of Governments. Politics should not be treated like a game by the media - “How many runs have to be put up on the board to guarantee victory”. Tailpiece: one doubt. How Is seeking votes in the name of caste, and sub castes different from seeking votes in the name of religion?
    12
  162. I do not know what you mean. If the rule of law has been absent, this fracas of “agitations” would have resulted in more casualties, as it has happened during many such invented “agitations” in the past decades since independence. Get real. I am not a fan of the BJP or Yogi. But just an Indian thirst,y for real news….not news of concocted incidents…Have we not seen violence in such offensive concocted agitations in the decades since Independence? One just has to visit all the agitations since Independence. It is a deja vu
    12
  163. How competent are “experts” and the media to teach “lessons” to the Government. It is naive and presumptuous to assume one knows better on these aspects than a Government and a Defence Force who have safeguarded the sovereignty of the Nation for decades, and continue to do so. Tailpiece: Experts and media would do well not to get beyond themselves. The establishment is not playing a cricket match. Just saying.
    12
  164. Wow! This view that India has lessons to learn from all around the world is preposterous and self defeating. A very poor world view, I dare say. In Britain, historically, the majority (England) were the oppressors? Tailpiece: India is unique: for e.g. in comaparison to India: Britain and Ireland are “tiny” in size and population: Ireland has only one language and two religions, both “praying” to the same GOD. Etc….Etc… Wonder why such comparisons from the erudite community!
    12
  165. So many experts, especially from abroad, seem to know how India should be governed. Media has to introspect whether it is a wholesome opinion. Experts are experts in one field and generally know very little about many other aspects which indirectly affect their field of expertise. A Nation has many facets where homogenous progress is needed. To what end such piecemeal opinions. I respect all these erudite experts. What is their intention in coming on TV and telling how governments should be run is also another point to ponder. Tailpiece. Music is an interplay of only only limited notes and octaves. Yet it requires a learned conductor to direct an orchestra. But in a Nation it requires more to integrate different aspects of society and economy. Also what is the ratio of officials to people and geographic extent in India as compared with rest of the World….Has anyone given this a thought? My point is that such opinions should be heard but not taken as the ultimate. There could be a better view.
    12
  166. In Nehru Gandhi era names of projects etc were given the dynast name by themselves. In the current era some section of the media, livinng in the past tend to give all policies and project Modis name ( a hangover like the. Colonial hangover?) even though Modi or the Government or the party may not want it. Tailpiece: It is difficult to comprehend agenda based "impartial" media.
    12
  167. Why is it always vendetta when politicians are investigated? Does that mean all politicians are clean? (Like asking are all citizens clean and nothing more implied). Just asking. Tailpiece: Change the system of governance if you don’t trust the system. And trust is a two way street.
    12
  168. Freedom of press? Unsubstantiated allegations on Government agencies can be made on such platforms unabashedly? Democracy eh? There’s is a political party some of whose members who are adults and an make independent decisions,(whether forced, lured etc.) want to breakaway, why encourage such drama in public? Let them battle it out without various parties making the media as a stage to fight it out. Tailpiece: You can’t air trash to a gullible and unsuspecting public.
    12
  169. Shekhar, how naturally and easily you say that KCR’s children will have grown in five years to take over the leadership in Telangana….eerie…. The only party without such princes is BJP. You do not emphasize this… by default or design… I know by default but…. Tailpiece: It is eerie that how we Indians and the media so easily accept dynastic politics…. Unfortunate
    12
  170. You should bite only as much as you can chew. In a big Nation like India, after a slow start, the pace can be increased only gradually. Most Indians are aware that there is a long way to go. That is the last line of all positive reportage.. “But…… etc. etc…”
    11
  171.  @nishanxr  NJ. Greetings. You do not know me, so please do not attack me. I am not important. If you have a point to make make your point. That is expression. Be happy. Stay safe.
    11
  172. Well presented. Tail piece: what do you say about religions using (and not using) history to suit narratives? That is more damaging than political history.
    11
  173. Unfortunate. At most respect to the fallen Air warriors.
    11
  174. A beginning has to be made some time. All major advanced Nations do have a robust indigenous Defence production sector. Besides self reliance they create jobs and boost the economy. We should have started this earnestly on 15 August 1947.
    11
  175. Yes, true. My take. Indian politics is like Religion. The protagonists in each case feel “My way is highway and the only way”, “Only I do right things and everybody else is wrong”….. Tailpiece: The opposition should publicly acknowledge the achievements of the government and the government should acknowledge its failings. But then it is easier to bring down the moon, I suppose.
    11
  176. A good analysis. My two bit. We must realize that politicians do not divide societies. In India religions, castes, languages, regional peculiarities, weather etc… were not created by politicians. Politicians sure exploit the differences by appealing to sentiments to nurse support bases. That is how politics works in a democracy. Tail piece: Finally we must realize that sentiments belong to the people.
    11
  177. On my way from the airport on 26 Dec 2020, after spending over an year in the USA, and seeing the plight of NY area in person, I was appalled by how the people in our country were taking it easy. It was as if nothing had changed since I left India in September 2019. All shops open. 50% were not wearing a mask, 30% were wearing it on their chin. Later when I asked my vegetable shop fellow why he was not wearing a mask, he replied “Corona has gone, so why wear a mask?”. It was not as if the administration had said so. Because on the same day while we were driving in our own vehicle, my wife and I (only two of us in the car) were fined Rs 350/- for not wearing a mask in the car – I was told that it was mandatory. Tailpiece: The problem in our country is not the rules. It is the implementation of the rules by an inadequate, overworked police and paramilitary on a people whose standards of self-discipline are abysmal. Let us admit it and strive to improve. I request the media too to highlight this aspect.
    11
  178. Great analysis DK. TN is an important state (as are all other states, of course) in the numbers game. It is obvious that split in political parties, especially in regional parties, though ostensibly for ideological reasons, is actually for usurping power by individuals and/or factions. I believe this is a phenomenon unique to India political space. Déjà vu. In all he political drama s (soap operas to be specific), as in watching the soaps on TV, it is all a sentimental play on the spectators / electorate, producing nothing substantial but macabre “entertainment” and waste of time. My hope is that the we the people of India realise, they are the real losers. Tailpiece: Could it be that a “North” dominated party was lured by “Panneer”? Just asking.
    11
  179. A unique presentation by The Print (thanks SG) which throws light on major fault lines in Indian Defence strategies. It is an indisputable fact that Pakistan is one of the two – the other being China – major adversaries of India. Whereas talks and diplomacy are ways to diffuse potentially explosive situations and overcome adversaries, one can win in these parleys only from a position of strength – meaning, to have a potent and deadly Armed Forces. While in Pakistan and China, with whom we have long borders of varied terrain and climatic conditions, the Armed Forces have a great say in matters of National security, unfortunately we cannot say the same of our great Nation. Since more than a couple of decades back, our senior military leaders are perceived to be administratively ( provide necessary equipment, keep the morale of the Forces up, not dilute dignity etc…., so essential to face adversities) weak. Tailpiece: Are we (the people, the legislature, the governments, the executives and the judiciary) as a Nation taking our Armed Forces for granted? Just remember no other democracy except India has such vast and varied land & sea borders and air spaces to guard in order to preserve the sovereignty. The sooner the Nation wakes up to these facts the safer our future generations will be.
    11
  180. Did this spokesperson say anything to “hurt” religious sentiments? Just asking. All this religious sentiment bit is much ado about nothing. Sentiments do not feed us, nor clothe or house us. Just saying.
    11
  181. Haha. Gas can’t replace solid fuel. Having said that, a lot of us overlook the fact that in this whole world, while major religions have a number of Nations to Tom Tom their respective religion, Hindus have only one Nation…ok there is Nepal too. Disclaimer. This is not a religious statement but a factual representation.
    11
  182. I wonder. PCs were available in India, running Basic on DOS since the mid 1980s. That is 40 years back.
    11
  183. In a true democracy citizens must live among and negotiate the terms of their common lives with others who hold diverging interests. That means deliberating with people with whom we disagree. This transactional existence is a two way process of give and take – respect and acceptance. But Can the Muslims admit tat in the past centuries, mosques have been built on temples and express regret. I feel that should end this unnecessary and unending retrograde steps. Stay well Forward Ho!!
    11
  184. Fantastic…. Name.I suppose the “United opposition” is also aware that elections is not an end and there is a Nation INDIA to be governed without discrimination of any kind….. no appeasement….and reservations etc based purely on economic status….. 75 years of discrimination is enough….. do not let another class system emerge. Tailpiece: whose Nation is it anyway? Just asking
    11
  185. It is appalling that the hostage “release” is being celebrated like an OTT serial… sad…season 2? Can’t the media just say it in one line as part of the news…”so many hostages freed”… that would be more humane than dramatizing the event and offering publicity to a terrorist organization.
    11
  186. Rishi for PM is following a path much like the Indian victory over Pakistan yesterday, in a group match of the ongoing T20 World Cup - From a point of no rerun, so to speak. Could be the best bet for British economy, hopefully.
    11
  187. On the same lines does China also have a similar problem? Apropos the General’s quote. Lessons are dime a dozen… but an army is only as good as it’s soldiers. That is a major subjective factor in the equation of war. Look at any recorded war in history. Tailpiece: Luck is directly proportional to hard work. And one more point. Wars do not ever result in absolute victory…. Every participant, these days non participants too, lose something or the other…. Rhetorics notwithstanding. And one more point. Yes. Concessions are given to those who deserve, to those who recognise them as a sacrifice from someone else , and to those who are grateful for the same. To give something to some one, you have to take it away from someone else. For instance, releasing 90,000 Pakistani prisoners of war in 1971/72 was a concession….Then, what happened? (Not all Indian prisoners were returned).
    10
  188. A good exposition of the exact state of wheat and farm matters. Kudos. Tailpiece: Note: Laws or no, be sure, all goats will ensure that own countrymen do not suffer….Govts are allowed to do that. In this reduce domestic prices for the common man. Just think, why do Alphonso mangoes cost a bomb in India?
    10
  189. A very informative presentation. Soon more Indians will have smart phones. This is a quote from a book, yet undated. "From anger arises bewilderment, from bewilderment loss of memory ; and from loss of memory the destruction of intelligence and from destruction of intelligence he perishes." Tailpiece: The most destructive emotion is anger.
    10
  190. It is all very well to have a coordinated action by “opposing” political dispensations in a democracy. From a standoffish view there is a problem in this coordinated action. Firstly, the stated aim of these CMs is defeat of BJP. Secondly, these local parties were formed and came to power on promises for local and parochial development (if I may). Thirdly if India does not become a strong UNION of states, as stated in the Constitution, it will lose out globally. You can add such fourthly, fifthly etc…. Politics is not only about winning and losing as made out by political parties (by giving away freebies. and subsidies) and unfortunately by the media. It is much more about governance and the economy. Tailpiece: whose Nation is it anyway?
    10
  191. There is a feeling in a very large section of the Indian population, that some farmers and some politicians have AS USUAL turned the representations of farmers into a political gimmick. What with talks still open and the judiciary also involved in the matter, is there a genuine reason for prolonging this “agitation”? Who represents the voice of this section of Indians who see a deja Vu in these shenanigans from all sides? Tail piece: There are “genuine demands” from the unorganized sector, from laborers, from industrial workers, from the informal economy, from MSMEs, from the industry, from airline operators and from just about all and sundry. At some point we have to get real and move on.
    10
  192. Lucid, as usual DK. Catching the pulse is the phrase. Catch line…”non Gandhi…”…. In which case we will have two strong National parties in the next decade
    10
  193. The former union secretary is not probably correct based on what we see. The secretaries from the finance ministries, commerce ministries, railway ministry, Foreign ministry, etc very often appear on TV and hold press availability etc. something wrong here… Tailpiece: I was also a government servant for 33 years.
    10
  194. Brilliant observation of a brilliant nuance. DK, is it good for political,leaders (especially in Governments) to be flexible? How decisive can Governments be in democracies even with a “majority” in the lower house and/or upper house? Tail piece: is it not true that a parent - child in a profession (politics?) is different from a family for generations controlling a party.
    10
  195. All of us go to town with our constitution for many matters. Article 44 of the constitution mandates UCC. Just saying Tailpiece: Let us shun hypocrisy and double standards.
    10
  196. Good programme from Theprint. Way to go.
    10
  197. The people and media of our great Nation should talk less of politics and more of that which affect the real daily lives.
    10
  198. ThePrint hallmark. “This is the picture, form your view”. The picture is clear. Good journalism. Tailpiece: My take. Wealth can be distributed only if wealth is first created. China recognised this in the 1970s…moved to capitalism to create wealth..and now have become the second largest economy. India started (slowly) the exercise at least 2.5 decades later. We can see the difference.
    10
  199. Ha! The problem with any religion is not its truth. It is the untruth followed by some!!! Let us get real.
    10
  200. What an informative programme, especially for the young ones! Kudos. The Gen Z and later should know that there is a life beyond politics, ..isms, schisms and binary. Kudos. Tailpiece: Education is much more than what edutech companies give you.
    10
  201. No doubt economy is paramount to progress in this millennia. When I hear these “experts” ( full respect to them and their knowledge of history etc…), as a common Indian I wonder whether all the experts in the Governments since more than 7 decades were fools. No. The problem is the debilitating side of democracy. Any political party who will “concede” territory will be annihilated at the hustings. Now, tell me how do we approach this dilemma? Finders keepers - how do we do it? Tailpiece: Can we have a recommendation from experts? Who and how will this give and take happen? Who will be at the vanguard of the negotiations? An all party Parliamentary committee ( only elected members fro LS), do you think?
    10
  202. Trust Indian historical events post 1947, that “controversial” incidents are routine in an institute carrying a “Nehru” name. Irony? Reflect. Tailpiece: As I reiterate as always and everywhere for decades socio-religious differences are not in the domain of politics. These have to be handled by leaders of religious dispositions and civil societies. They are the ones who are abdicating their responsibilities.
    9
  203. It is time ALL politicians realize that today’s Indian does not learn about their political and other leaders from what politicians talk about them. Original materials and contact information, as the case maybe depending on antiquity of leaders, is authentically gathered from various other reliable sources. It is also time that our politicians stop talking about themselves and discuss, development, progress, education, skill,development, employment, amenities, economy, security and such matters that matter to us. We want an erudite opposition. Tailpiece: Politicians will come and go, the Nation and its people,are forever.
    9
  204. You mean join the herd and get lost?
    9
  205.  @daniyalbbd5281  that is the problem ...rule because you are somebody's daughter/son?
    9
  206.  @blr370  bir. I have been saying this for over half a century now. I always speak for myself.Now I find this person speaks what I speak. Discuss the point if you must. It is not about me or any org/party. It is about US, our children . Enjoy.
    9
  207.  @akshayagrawal5114  well .. Akshay, … Adi Sankaracharya, Jesus H Christ, The Buddha, Swami Vivekanda, Mata Amritananda Mayi and….
    9
  208. Are intellectuals some sort of soothsayers? Why I ask? Intellectuals by definition are given to study, reflection and speculation rendering their conclusions as subjective… Tailpiece: Words like intellectuals and experts are relative.. was Karl Max an intellectual? Just asking.
    9
  209. This is another example where an agitation/protest (projected as a constitutional right) flagrantly violates the constitutional right of citizens by denying them the use of public utilities. Is the media listening?
    9
  210. Why security breach is in quotes? Does thePrint feel it is not a security breach? Good standards of journalism? Uhmmm
    9
  211. The panorama of coverage of topics and current affairs by The Print is really pathbreaking. The wish is that all media take a leaf (or many leaves) from the way The Print handles its responsibilities of informing and educating the public. Take a bow SG. Tailpiece: politics in Israel is the messiest. “Nationalism” is the binding factor there. Politics in the US, Britain, Germany, France, Italy is messy too …. just saying.
    9
  212. Good presentation as usual. This war has two revelations for India. 1. The Indian soldier is the best in fighting / winning / holding out in wars and battles using these very Russian equipment. 2. It is time for India to rethink the way we arm ourselves. Tailpiece: The most potent weapon in war is the soldier.
    9
  213. Has any of the “victims” submitted their phones for forensic examination? They could give it to a court and demand action. At least one of the “eighty” should do it. Let us not have one more cat and mouse game.
    9
  214. Some points at random, to be viewed positively 1. Today, a person at 60 years can deliver what a 40-year person delivered a few decades back. 2. We Indians do not allow progressive policies to be introduced. Farm laws and unique identity are cases in point. 3. Indians (and the media) need to reduce discourse on politics (sorry, SG) which is unproductive in the least. 4. Post school education system requires major overhaul. 5. Infrastructure to be developed (happening). Tailpiece: Look at the positives and work on them.
    9
  215. Everybody can’t gain from Every policy..well said. Good analysis. Banks can’t take care of all investment needs of a Nation. India needs more billionaires and HNIs who will make quality investments and promote businesses and industries. They will keep both interest rates and inflation, to an extend, automatically remain subdued. With more investments, more jobs will be created.
    9
  216. Do efforts win elections or does development etc? Just asking. Tailpiece: Winning elections is not the end. There is a Nation to govern. Secularism and ideologies by themselves do not feed people.
    9
  217. Consequences of civilian (innocent people) casualties in terrorist/ militant activities in populated areas cannot be avoided. If the militants do not realize this and desist from such activities, it is not right for us to expect the “other side to show the other cheek”…. This world has never been a non violent world - never ever. Tailpiece. Wonder whether we can ever get the narratives right. Correct narratives may sometimes fetch solutions.
    9
  218.  @jayakrishnanm2975  “patriotism” is your word. I don’t believe it applies to anything these days. It is obsolete anyway. Enjoy.
    9
  219. QUAD worries China. Putin-Xi bonhomie worries India. All par for the course and on predictable paths. India is doing what it must. There is nothing it can do differently. Tailpiece: India is NOT like China and Japan is not like USA etc. Dhoni is not Like Azhar and Kohli is not like Dhoni. All of them play to win, in different manner.
    9
  220. When will these small parties realize that to form a useful ( though we need “powerful” , we can do with a “useful “ to start with”) Government at the centre. To become a power economy and Nation( I am not unpatriotic, If I say Like China, as it has become powerful through whatever means) to compete with China and the developing and developed economies, we have to look beyond petty politics. Tailpiece: I suppose we the people and the media have a task to take the people beyond petty politicking.
    9
  221. The aim of bringing out this story by US department of Defence now, without giving out the full details, and some of the Indian media echoing it word for word makes one suspect the intend. Just saying.
    9
  222. Swamy, Your analysis are always well researched and articulated. But at time you miss the point Urban Naxals or idealogues or whatever are okay as long as they do not take money and resources from a foreign country or agency and they do not intrude into the liberty and freedom of others in the society who do not support their ideology, through disruption of daily life and / or violence. They are free to write or speak anything tat does not advocate separatism or division of the Nation. It is not as upfront as this in India. These people are often wooed by opposing political parties to further their own agenda. As far as arrests as concerned we all know that there can’t be smoke without fire. Let us call a spade a spade and not as a tool for misplaced liberty.
    9
  223. I feel there must be discussions on how the people will benefit when one or the other party will come into power in the states or at the centre. Who will win or lose will be meaningful only if the electorate knows what difference it will make on roti, kappa or makkan, if at all.
    9
  224. A defeatist statement. Mr ST is capable of doing better.
    9
  225. Useful reality projection. That what matters. My point. Roti, kapda, makkan… reinforced. Tailpiece. Indians, look at economics and not politics. Politics will not help in the kitchen.
    9
  226. One cannot help but comment. Comments on a prospective National level leader. It is not about sanghi, Bakht or whatever you may call me…I am certainly not and THAT is not the issue as I am just one voter with no more influence on anything that may matter… 1. “Home” … Are we to read between the lines? What is implied ? 2. All this while during his yatra, was he not at “Home”? 3. Or is he emphasizing the fact that J&K in its entirety has been, is and will be an integral part of India…. a reiteration of the endorsement of abrogation of article 370… 4. ????? So many Qs. A leader has to be specific in his comments especially in the case of a subject like J&K. We want a young leader like RG to come up. Whatever he says whenever is very important. Tailpiece: Until ……. Unfortunately we will be in search for an alternate party and leader…. We are only about a year away before the next general elections.
    9
  227. Pray, is there any type of history other than the distorted variety in regard to Nations, people and religions? While the events in history do not change, the narration will constantly be changing as new evidences are revealed. The recorded narration of history is always a prejudiced version of the narrator.
    8
  228.  @Ashish-yo8ci  Ashish, that is the problem. Preconceived, politically motivated thinking. A better question may be "Should We the people take a comprehensive look at our constitution?" Think beyond politics .
    8
  229. Excellent presentation. Neat and on the rocks. Tailpiece: I hope the mainstream media is watching.
    8
  230. Good observations. Politics should not be made the staple. The Nation - people and media- should be working on far more important matters brewing in this world. The Print discusses them on its channel. Great for us. Tailpiece: It is time we treat political news as secondary and fillers.
    8
  231. Not that I promote any political party in public….But BJP? Are all these breakaway leaders, elected by We the people, not responsible for breaking away from their own party in which they have been all their life. Do you mean they are absolved of all guilt just because another force (BJP?) from the outside is influencing them. Come on gimme a break. Tailpiece: Media should say it as it is in the correct priority of commission….
    8
  232. Even without rules, such behaviours in the August houses of Parliament by elected members (of any party, for that natter) is an unforgivable act, as these behaviours are a direct insult to the electorate and hence a violation of democratic principles and common civility. Tail piece. There are unwritten rules too to be followed by the respected elected members. I hope they realize that a majority of Indians feel, Enough is enough.
    8
  233. Reservations….reservations and reservations. Complications in an already inefficient post-school education system in our country. Costs, syllabus, infra, approach….. all require overhaul. Should we approach the honorable SC? What is our elite bureaucracy doing? Should we hand over the executive functions also to judiciary? Just asking. Tail piece: I often wonder who are the real minorities in our great Nation. Just wondering.
    8
  234. Is it a gift? For who? As a veteran journalist, do you really believe that this disQ of Mr RG, will unite the opposition to take India forward in economy, diplomatic, Defence, technology and development in all areas? Do you really believe that? Do you expect the Nation to believe that, Ms Jyoti? Tailpiece: India today wants roti, kapda, makkan and a lot of self respect. A pseudo combination of opportunistic political partiies can’t deliver that. Oh yes, democracy under threat? Really…. What is new now that was not there in all these 75 years after Independence to threaten democracy? Maybe, you mean some parties, besides the communists, seeking foreign help to return to power. Yes, THAT, I agree, is a real threat to democracy in India.
    8
  235. BJP is playing a dangerous game, DK. Makes me wonder,,,, there is something in these elections we do not know…. The mood of the people on ground…. The dream 11 advertisement says… Team is above family (shetty, KL and Rohit). Interesting
    8
  236. “Kicked out socialism”… The sentence of the presentation. Kudos. That team was Great.. Narasimha Rao and MM Singh. Tailpiece: What we the people should know.
    8
  237. I wonder whether words like “bulldozed” etc should be used in quality reporting. Just saying. Tailpiece: Let us not assume, even for a moment, that we are better informed than the people who have voted - whether in Punjab, UP or elsewhere. Be the change
    8
  238. “Sustainability of banking sector’s strong run” could have been a better headline. Do you, The Print, consider reader (viewer) inputs on such issues. I have earlier too Questioned the question mark on the “head lines” for your videos…. The ? Mark in all headlines is regressive
    8
  239. I have my doubts; the religious, corruption etc. angles are all dead horses and nothing will come out of flogging dead horses. It is inevitable that economy, Defence, IS matters and foreign policy will have to be debated by the “opposition”..and Ah! Adani is a non issue too…. for the electorate … Tailpiece: A tough job ahead for the “coalition” who lack a track record of efficient governance capabilities. Unfortunate for Indian democracy.
    8
  240. Chess Olympiad is being in Chennai these days. It has been organized very well, technically, administratively and efficiently by TN Govt and Govt of India vividly showcasing culture. Chennai, TN and India are on the world stage there. Real federalism. Tailpiece: Now chess is a game of employing tactical moves vide a planned strategy. 32 pieces on 64 squares present immense variations. It seems, going by the moves, the BJP (I am not a member, but a common INDIAN) has learnt to play chess well. It may be well worth for the opposition MPs to visit the Chess Olympiad and learn the moves.
    8
  241. Is this “expert” talking all sense? Too simplistic observations. He can afford to do just that as an academic. I am in the US. I find that most leading experts here have only an academic idea of this great Nation. Be warned. While nobody in the West wants a strong China, they do not at all want a strong democratic, assertive India as well!!!
    8
  242. Lucid analysis. The poll outcome in Karnataka has also established beyond any doubt. 1. That democracy is very well alive and kicking in India. 2. Both the electoral process and the voting machines function effectively and truthfully. Tailpiece: We in Karnataka, look forward to efficient administration in public services, which has been poorly managed for at least the last two decades. And ah! Polarization in INDIAN POLITICS - Dalit party, Muslim leagues, Akalis, caste based parties, parochial - DMK, AIADMK, TMC, Telangana congress, YSR congress , LOK Dal, Gomantak, Shiv Sena - has existed for decades. Is the media trying to give a new flavor to polarization? Is that a right approach?just asking.
    8
  243. Diwali greetings to team , ThePrint. Forward Ho!
    8
  244. At present India has very limited options. Instead of all work towards a goal and not at cross purposes to achieve parochial and personal goals, India may yet recover and progress. Individuals and parties are least of India’s problems. It is the bureaucracy and other constitutional institutions that have to come up and perform. Not the least the incompetent media who have contributed precious little to Nation building.
    8
  245. All very well. Capt Amirinder Singh’s party is not yet a factor in the Chandigarh results. Just saying
    8
  246. AAP can come up as a negative choice. Then what? Experience?. Base? Tailpiece: Negative choices are just that. Negative…. Choices. Immature most of the time.
    8
  247. Lucid analysis…balanced.
    8
  248. Pia, thanks for the hidden nuggets of info, which actually affect matters more than the run of the mill mainstream media. More power to you style. Tailpiece: What is heard is not mostly what it is.
    8
  249. DK, I am wondering whether this Yatra was/is for RG to get to know India or is it the other way around? Just asking. Tailpiece: Either way, probably it had / has to be done without an entourage etc… or maybe I am old fashioned.
    8
  250. It looks like the AAP has leant fats…. A few ropes of politics. Welcome to the soap opera
    8
  251. Bharat Jodo after Bharat phodo for long? Just asking. The problem is this “Vichar dharma”. Time for change. We want a revived strong congress party. After all What is a democracy without a GOP? Just saying. Tailpiece: More mileage can be gained by talking of developments, economy etc than by talking about BJP and undertaking padyatras. You see BJP is only a political party. Congress should always keep the Nation in the frame. Plurality, secularism et al are passé. It is all about life and living.
    8
  252. It should be “Big boost to FIRE power” and not AIR power.
    8
  253. JNU is better?
    8
  254. It is appalling that the hostage “release” is being celebrated like an OTT serial… sad…season 2? Can’t the media just say it in one line as part of the news…”so many hostages freed”… that would be more humane than dramatizing the event and offering publicity to a terrorist organization.
    8
  255. Why were the Quacks there in the first place? If Kerala can maintain a okay primary health care system, why not in other states over these pat 70 old years of independence?
    7
  256. Well analyzed, DK. BJP and RSS can’t do without the other…..
    7
  257. It is a good thing that the Government is so transparent that the media is always aware why it is doing something when it intends to do something. Great for our democracy. Now don’ t tell the world that the Indian media is kept in the dark by Governments. You can’t have it both ways.
    7
  258. A bit intrigued by the ‘importance’ the case is receiving in the media and at The Print.
    7
  259. Okay, a known secret. Good an open secret is being discussed so blatantly. Oh, “it is all about money honey” and in such cases how it is shared among stake holders - the public (for utilities etc.) being one stake holder. Tailpiece: Political,parties are NOT NGOs. It is another matter that most NGOs act like political parties!!! Public service? What is it? Just asking.
    7
  260. Great attempt, SG. Karnataka is one perpetual clutter. Here is a “prosperous” state during the last two decades, which has not seen any governance. Possible. Check out. Have nots wanting to be haves….always.:( Tailpiece: Are regional parties (hundreds of them) good for a big country (geography) and Nation (diversity) like India or Bharat? Potent topic for cut the clutter in five parts maybe. SG?
    7
  261. Refreshing, Snehesh and Wajad
    7
  262. So Indian democracy is reduced to board room battles rather than out there on ground. Correct? No wonder then that while in all other democracies people go out and vote, while here in India people cast(e) their votes!!!!!
    7
  263. Fantastic…. I suppose the “United opposition” is also aware that elections is not an end and there is a Nation INDIA to be governed without discrimination of any kind.
    7
  264. What are PG’s concrete plans for UP’s economy? If she has one, the media has not projected it prominently comparing the same with that of the incumbent Government’s policies and plans. Tailpiece: How often have party manifestos manifested into something tangible? Are most of the political parties leading the public up a garden path?
    7
  265. We, in India, should have wide ranging debates on religions and religious practices. In India I am afraid there are no public debates on religion because the politicians are afraid; the government is afraid; the media is afraid; the people are afraid; those that are not afraid are dissuaded by those who are afraid. Of course there are also those with vested interests who want to perpetuate ignorance. They are into exploitation and take shelter behind ‘religious sentiments’. The result is the proliferation of Nityanandas. Opinions on religion and beliefs have to be expressed. We do not have a right to debate the practices of an individual where only (s)he is involved. We definitely have a right to discuss what is practiced in public – because it affects society at large. I am / was calling/ recommending for a public debate. I strongly believe knowledge is NOT what is disseminated through preaching...
    7
  266. A good interaction…covering many aspects as obtained today, in Pakistan. Yet, it seems that the reality of matters in Pakistan was bypassed by one of the participants. Not accepting the realities in the Nation has been the undoing of Pakistan. Tailpiece: Conveying perspectives is much better than airing views/opinions.
    7
  267. Winning elections is not the end all of democracy. Governance is a necessary follow up. Ah, yes, shouting, heckling and creating chaos in the hallowed houses is by no means governance. Nor is creating controversies (to hide ignorance and lack of knowledge for debates on bills) like our honorable LOP in LS has done. It is a Shame that MPs, being the elected representatives to govern, have to be told all these basics.. Tailpiece: The difference between Chaff and Wheat will emerge. Good going.
    7
  268. Disclaimer: This is in no way an anti Muslim comment. Integration and tolerance cannot happen on a one-way street. There is lot of discussion on alienating the Muslims. There is no mention of alienating the Christians, for instance. Wonder why? What if the Muslims are alienating themselves and are reluctant to adapt to the social structure that exists in India? I will tell you, having grown up in Kerala, that the Christians are as passionate about their religion as anybody. But they are integrating with the society around them. Look around, you will notice. Tail piece: Let us have a national debate on what the Muslims should be doing to integrate with the society and not alienate themselves from it.
    7
  269. I wonder. The tone of this presentation suggests that the bureaucrats can never underperform. You just have to go out and ask "we the people" who will tell you that the antiquated bureaucratic system in India has inherent flaws and has underperformed since decades. Tailpiece: Is this a case being made out for errant bureaucrats? Just asking.
    7
  270. A good presentation DK as usual. But the larger picture remains an enigma.. Reshuffling for what? For optics, for equal (religion, caste, region and many more..... ha ha) distribution, to buttress ego or improved efficiency. It is only in India I notice this reshuffling in all governments. The media makes it a big issue. . Why reshuffle at all? An odd change is par for the course. A reshuffle? Why? A fit topic for cut the clutter? In passing - I often wonder who is a bakht and who is a Kambhakt?
    7
  271. We salute our soldiers. Jai Hind.
    7
  272. Nostalgic. No not for the stupid protest. “Ckakka” is the Malayalam for jackfruit. A unique jam is prepared from jackfruit. The process is elaborate and the jam is made over naked fire. Usually made during summertime, it can be preserved for the year. Tailpiece: While my Chaka Jam is heavenly to the taste buds, the modern types of chakka jams just cause inconvenience to the public and serve no useful purpose. The media would, of course, call it a democratic right.
    7
  273. Correct points.... could add one more to the incorrect precedents. The media always stands up for the rights of its citizens and touts freedom of every kind at the drop of a hat. So, it is intriguing why does not the media come out vehemently against those who willfully and repeatedly violate the constitutional rights of millions of citizens by blocking and disrupting public conveniences. Media has an obligation...
    7
  274.  @Vizorfam  Good that you are expressing your views. But again just academic, I m afraid. Equitable distribution of wealth has nothing to do with capitalism. For distribution of wealth through any means first THE WEALTH has to be created. Only capitalism can create wealth. Look around you…even China (have you heard the ilk of Jack Ma etc..?) embraced capitalism (remember Deng Xio ping?) in the late 1980s to become a sizable economy in a matter of 45 years. Enjoy…. Doing is far difficult than just writing.
    7
  275. We the people of India will appreciate a proposed comprehensive approach to economic development for the Nation in the next five years, from the combined opposition - rather than have just defeating BJP as its goal. Depending on this approach paper, we will take a call on the next Government at the centre. Tail piece: Both, the party in power and the opposition need to cut the rhetorics. Especially the opposition whose job is not only to just oppose anything and everything the Government proposes. We are mature enough to see through this. If the governments do not deliver they will be out in any case.
    7
  276. The whole discussion, even in the piece written by Shekar on ThePrints web site, the whole premise seems to be the the BJP is out to get AAP and AAP (including AK) have not committed any crime at all. Various (not one) court proceedings and documents suggest otherwise. But the media fails to highlight this aspect. Also is AK the AK who sat with Anna Hazare… media skirting these points. Tailpiece: Liberalism I suppose
    7
  277. A relevant and factual presentation with a warning to be careful. Prevention is always better than cure. Good message. But I fail to get it; when we talk of available statistics why are we not talking of the low ratio of deaths to population in India. If we don’t do it, it shows a defeatist and self-denigrating attitude. I am talking of the number of deaths despite floating bodies in rivers. As per worldometer statistics as on today - deaths, due to COVID, per million population of the USA is 2509 whereas that of India is 349. Can the "experts" say something about this? Total deaths (absolute numbers) are also about half of that of USA. Tailpiece: Let us talk good of ourselves too. It is not blasphemous to do that. Disclaimer: Any untoward death is devastating and bad,
    7
  278. 💯The Print. A story always projects a hero and a villain. What is a story otherwise? So in life. In life every person is free to chose villains and heroes. That definitely is NOT a material matter as the aspect is more sentimental. The crux of living is not religion or sentiment any more, which, in the age of virtual reality is more “cosmopolitan”, if I may. Tailpiece: In the final say, life is always about “roti, kapda and makkan”. And ah! The Bhagwat Gita says “Change is the only constant”…. This is Not a religious statement, mind you.
    7
  279. It just beats me how experts try to standardize situations….. that type of comparisons, analysis and reporting are more dangerous than bullets and bombs, Tailpiece: Remember “the pen is mightier than the sword”. So those competent should use the pen wisely.
    7
  280. Is theprint definite, as the heading suggests, that the motive for the attack is that the victims are Dalits? My Q is not to in any way dilute the cruelty of the crime as described by the victim, who should definitely get justice for victimization,, it is the larger Q of whether such reporting gives an impression that crimes are committed only against people based on caste and caste alone. Is it a true picture?
    7
  281. A lot of runs are scored playing back foot shots. For one, the batsman gets more time to play ( cuts and pulls etc.) the ball from a “back foot” position.
    7
  282. In continuation of my earlier comment... The Print is definitely doing a good job by bringing in an assortment of experts in this programme. Among other things, such interactions are required to reveal the ignorance of the West in many aspects relating to India.
    7
  283. Is it a problem that they are not talking CAA etc?
    7
  284. Well presented. Tailpiece: Conflicts, survival and economy are seldom dictated by morality. Unfortunate? Non violence was never a “weapon” anywhere; I repeat, anywhere. For the learned a hint is enough. (Samajdar ke liye is ishara kaafi hain).
    7
  285. All very well SG. ThePrint does present unique programmes. Kudos. My take. Whatever initiative by whichever side should be “headlined” as a positive and NOT as intriguing. In any move, like in chess, some moves in advance are planned. But we must encourage a fair attempt for brining sanity between the communities. Religion is a highly misunderstood and misused dispensation in the world. Tailpiece: It would be nice if the media helps positively. I feel RSS is not aiming to reconciling with Muslims , who are all good (like any Hindu, Christian, Buddhist, Parsi or whoever), but with Islam, the most exploited idea in the world. It may be recalled that we cannot expect politicians to take initiative (as they have their vote banks to consider); the overtures and actions towards reconciliation have to be initiated by religious leaders. Anybody can see that. Note: There is a difference in reconciling with Muslims (they are like all other Indians) and Islam and vice versa.
    7
  286. Letting "major" political parties express views can't be said to be "not neutral". The media has to give equal opportunity to all. Letting everybody speak is neutral. Knowledge or ignorance is revealed only when one opens her/his mouth.
    7
  287. What is freedom of religion and individual rights when religion itself binds you and tells you what to wear, what to eat, sees women different from men etc…. It is akin to political parties who do not practice democracy within wanting to defend Nation’s democracy and constitution. A paradox par redemption. Let us grow out of archaic shackles. Tailpiece: It is time to redefine methods ordained in religions….all religions.
    7
  288. Good journalistic approach. All aspects of all issues need to appear on the same platform for informing and not influencing. I want to believe The Print is doing its best in this respect.
    7
  289. Good analysis…. But all what happens in the world is relative…. Having said that…. Do we want unbriddled inflow of bad foreign money… also look at domestic investments…. Have they improved… just asking
    7
  290. When will political leaders start talking and discussing and acting instead of just attacking? Just asking.
    7
  291. SG, as usual, a masterclass in politics… my two bit…don’t you feel it is a dead horse being beaten again and again…. Temple-mosque- temple story. Which was razed to build which etc...? Who destroyed what etc…. The anti BJP parties have to change the narrative. The anti establishment is now the establishment. Tailpiece: Also, with what religion has the opposition an issue ?
    7
  292. To move to a place to pay less taxes….. Will that be an Indian company? And Singapore…. A country? Or a facilitator? The Qs are bigger tha taxes. Tailpiece: Those moving HQ abroad are shortsighted and in foe quick money.
    7
  293. Lucid analysis. The poll outcome in Karnataka has also established beyond any doubt. 1. That democracy is very well alive and kicking in India. 2. Both the electoral process and the voting machines function effectively and truthfully. Tailpiece: We in Karnataka, look forward to efficient administration in public services, which has been poorly managed for at least the last two decades. And ah! Polarization in INDIAN POLITICS - Dalit party, Muslim leagues, Akalis, caste based parties, parochial - DMK, AIADMK, TMC, Telangana congress, YSR congress , LOK Dal, Gomantak, Shiv Sena - has existed for decades. Is the media trying to give a new flavor to polarization? Is that a right approach?just asking.
    7
  294. What a state of judiciary in India.. when grant of bail is “celebrated” as a victory
    7
  295. I have been hearing this for more than 10 decades in India. Before every reform some sections of the media, self styled experts and after the advent of the digit media anybody and everybody asking the question “Is. India ready….”. It because of this very unfounded doubt India has been labeled a “laggard democracy” and China, Japan, Korea etc sped past us in the past decades. And I a septuagenarian watched helplessly all this from the sidelines. Now, India has resolved to move ahead and try and catch up with the world. For God’s sake do not start this question “Is India ready….” Else it will be a case of waiting for Godot. At least let the next generation benefit from progress and development. Pluracy is intact in other world democracies which follows UCC in their respective countries. For instance there are Muslims and Hindus in the Christian majority country UK. There Mosques and temples in the country where citizens celebrate Eid and Diwali with equal fervour. Tailpiece: There was, is or will be an ideal time for anything.
    7
  296.  @Opp_Man  yeh. Your sentiments are well taken. But to say “alienation” in a democracy like India is presumptuous. If you mean discrimination of sections of population in the social environment, yes, Maybe. That is a social issue and not Governance issue. The constitution, franchise, freedom to built religious edifices, law, justice etc… are amply clear on not discriminating… Tailpiece: Love, friendship, bonhomie etc are two way process. All sections involved need to work towards Dealientaion. If you mean religious discrimination….then let all religious leaders come on to one platform and unequivocally declare that “Your God is as great mine, the way you pray is as pure and effective as how we do it… etc”. The issue is not political (politicians merely exploit). The issue is societal where all religions are equally responsible to maintain harmony.
    6
  297. A monumental judgement. Just the other day I had written about alternate ways other than the current system of reservations for inclusive progress of society. We have to find better ways other than reservations and subsidies. But for sure we have to carry everyone. I do not by any stretch of imagination suggest that we must do things pronto. We have to find better ways over time…. Tailpiece: EWS is one of them; skill enhancement, dignity of labor, appropriate compensation, improved primary and secondary education, equal positions in society etc… are some of the others
    6
  298.  @mg.f.9023  Apathy of knowledge about India is evident in this one sentence., mg. Let us have some more erudite discussions with knowledge of economy, governance etc…. Not preconceived idea and ignorance
    6
  299. When was the world not in a mess? Major events natural and manmade have created havoc as borne out by recorded and unrecorded events since the last 7-8 millennia. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    6
  300. Ms Jyoti, Why are you using “Why..” in most of the titles for your YouTube presentations? Is it because you feel you have all the right answers? May be, a more humble title will enhance the appeal of your good shows. Just saying.
    6
  301. All said and done, The “Ram Mandir” in Ayodhya will be a boost to the hospitality, travel and tourism industries while boosting the State and local economy.
    6
  302. What is opposition unity? Is it like a Lagan cricket team assembled to defeat a team of ruling dispensation on a playing field? Is the unity a fantasy? If so, the meetings mean that the opposition is not considering policies etc.. of the Government. The is just to defeat another party. Governance, progress, economy etc. are passé and don’t mean anything. The opposition should be opposing selectively the policies etc... If the opposition considers that all what the ruling dispensation does is bad, India will forever remain a laggard democracy. Tailpiece: what is opposition ‘unity’ anyway? Just a means to grab power?
    6
  303. No offense and with malice to none. In the old days, an economist will whisper (inaudible) to a diver on the 7 meter high diving board board that there is no water in the pool. After the diver hits the bottom, he will shout “I told you so”. These days the economist is wiser. He will now shout at a diver on the 10 meter board “ Look here you see the pool is full now, but it may dry up by the time you finish your dive”!!! Tailpiece. The process is more important than the results.
    6
  304. Hinduism is not a religion in the sense of Abrahamic religion. If you insist, it is the only democratic religion if you want to call it that). one can be a Hindu “believing’ in any deity (even of any Abrahamic religion) or no deity at all; having faith in any God or in no God at all; one can pray any which way one wants to at any time of day or/and night or not pray at all; Culture is a set of values which in the Indian sense is to be respectful, accommodating, open-minded, deeply but not ostensibly spiritual and concerned with the common human welfare offering respect and acceptance to all philosophies / religions. THIS, sir is Hindutva.
    6
  305. The Q now is one of capability. Even old Companies like Ford, Mercedes and Coca Cola have changed and innovated new ideas and new technologies. You can’t win a test match only by sledging the opposition; you have to back it up with performance to beat them.
    6
  306. INC and NC share seats. So, DK, does it mean INC endorses NC manifesto? Especially on 370 and Pakistan…. Could you tell us? And can we have a cut the clutter on such devious politics?
    6
  307. Good thing. Cleansing taking place. Either follow Chinese model for Government control of business (Pakistan model is an unknown quantity through the Army controls 75% of Pak business, they say) or just sell it off at current values. PSUS were a bad idea since the beginning... If......?????
    6
  308. We Indians should be least surprised at the developments in the USA. At the end of the day in a democracy, most people vote from the heart and not the head. I have to mention that the proliferation of all types of media, mostly with vested interests and parochial, does not attempt to correct the phenomenon - pardon, I have to mention the media who are very integral in Nation building. For instance in the recently concluded Bihar elections it was mostly Yadav, Yadav and Yadav and Paswan etc..and very little on matters of administration - if at all mentioned was “reported” in small print. Take it from me, a common man, when you say “Modi Government” the focus stops at Modi and the contents of the “reports” become inconsequential to the reader. If the heading is on the issue and ”Modi”, “Rahul”, “Captain” or “Mamata” are in small print the real message will get across better.
    6
  309. A divisive presentation, at best. When the USA was lecturing India on providing the right legal platform for Aravjnd Kejriwal, when the USA judicial system is all political… where was ThePrint?
    6
  310. In trying to understand Modi, it seems nobody cares to study the virus. Haha. Missing the wood for the trees. Obsession with anything or anybody misleads.
    6
  311. There is a lot for farmers in the new laws. The present system of trade of farm produce is a proven failure, pan India. A myopic and political approach to the issue is self defeating. In a large country as India looking at any single factor in isolation is short sightedness; an entire orchestra needs to be put together to create a symphony. The Indian Farmer enjoys the following 1. Free electricity 2. Free water 3. Free /subsidised fertiliser 4. No income tax from farm income 5. Subsidised ration through PDS 6. Direct income transfer 7. Freedom to sell to anybody, anywhere, any time (new laws) 8. Freedom from essential commodity tag 9. Writing off of loans 10. Easy loans 11. Free / subsidized cooking gas These farmers are the only producers (for argument’s sake manufacturers, services sector, dairy sector, farmers of perishable crops etc. are also producers) who is assured of a fixed price (MSP) for some of their produce. It is recorded that even then he does not get what is due to him as he does not have the freedom to directly and freely interact with the market. For instance, there is no MSP for eggs, milk, milk products, perishables (vegetables and fruits) et al. Hence for a common Indian it is beyond comprehension why he can’t get direct and free access to all markets anywhere. Some trepidation is natural while migrating from one system to another. A pragmatic approach for long term benefits have to be considered, rather than make it a political battle ground which benefits none.
    6
  312. Did you say prominent “Muslim” leader? A Muslim secular leader? Why is he not just a political leader? I understand that came in the flow….Therein lies the paradox of double standards in Indian political discourses. Tailpiece: The “politics” is such that the people are at a loss to believe or not to believe…
    6
  313. Yes. Extreme views on any subject is bad. Arguments rather than discussions do not yield solutions. But…But… we are not traveling on a one way street. The traffic has to flow smoothly in both directions if commuters have to reach their respective destinations safely. May be we will have to add this in our narratives on harmony, tolerance etc.. etc…. Media is important to convey the correct messages as are it’s narratives to infuse love and togetherness in any society. Tailpiece: I wonder what message Theprint wants to convey with the collage fronting this YouTube video. It is only today Theprint had a programme highlighting the detrimental effects of such graphics and emojis in respect to Facebook. Reflect. And 1% of the 20% of our population (using Twitter) do not represent a Nation. Again a wrong narrative.
    6
  314. Good move. More importantly, they have to kept in the loop of decision making.
    6
  315. Good analysis DK. Can be considered by the INC as between the devil and the deep sea…. Or as a serving of gajaar ka halwa… if I may. Tailpiece: at least five more years of vanvas in any case… plan ahead…. Secularism is a dead horse… delivery is the galloping steed
    6
  316. A good presentation… My two bit The whole matter is “Elementary Mr. Watson!” Wealth has to be created before it can be distributed. Government can’t create wealth for distribution. E.g. In Pakistan wealth is “created” mostly by the Army. We know how it is there. China gave up socialism to embrace capitalism and privatization. Russia too has embraced privatization. Cuba (have you heard of this country?) of course follows total socialism. Only an efficient and free private sector can create wealth which can be “distributed” to others if necessary. Only private sector can create the required number of jobs. OK. Areas like space and nuclear can’t yet be privatized in India, though these sectors also have been privatized in some other countries. Just imagine…If the IT sector in India were to be with the Public sector!!!!!
    6
  317. But SG, the issue should not be that Europe is turning extreme right, it should be why is that happening? Even in the USA. Tailpiece: For cut the clutter. Is liberalism absolute or should it have borders?
    6
  318. I hope he has written to the HM with a copy to PM, which is how it is done. Good job any way - talking of matters rather than the man. Way to go RG.
    6
  319. Historically, there is never an occasion where different tribes have successfully united under one leader. The approach to Govern Afghanistan may have to change. U.A.E may offer a viable model.
    6
  320. Beaten paths do not lead to new places. Perpetual thinking will not produce results.
    6
  321. Yes, corona pandemic is not caused by any religion. Very true. Yet the activities of a group of persons which aggravated its spread needs to be examined. More than that India needs to widely debate Religions and religious practices. In India I am afraid there are no public debates on religion because the politicians are afraid; the government is afraid; the media is afraid; the people are afraid; those that are not afraid are dissuaded by those who are afraid. Of course there are also those with vested interests who want to perpetuate ignorance. They are into exploitation and take shelter behind ‘religious sentiments’. The result is the proliferation of Nityanandas and the likes all over. Opinions on religion and beliefs have to be expressed. We do not have a right to debate the practices of an individual where only (s)he is involved. We definitely have a right to discuss what is practiced in public – because it affects society at large. I am calling for a public debate on all religious practices in vogue- their effects on society et al; I strongly believe knowledge is NOT what is disseminated through preaching...
    6
  322. I am definite she did not have the Chinese in mind when she said “...God”.
    6
  323. Taiwan, Tibet and ….. Arunachal? Be that as it may….. Even UN has not given Taiwan a seat…all complicated… Tailpiece: One China policy…yes, which one China eh?
    6
  324. Love your take on politics…unadulterated…funny (as politics is to the public)… stylish. Tailpiece: Mr. AK, what is the difference between an educated politician and an uneducated politician, if at all? Just asking.
    6
  325. Swami, besides being a security specialist, you probably are becoming an historian too… liking it
    6
  326. An erudite analysis. Way to go. My two bit... Talks and diplomacy are ways to diffuse potentially explosive situations and overcome adversaries; one can win in these parleys only from a position of strength – meaning, to have a potent and deadly Armed Forces. Unfortunately, even while attempting at catch up, the truth is that we are lagging behind for the size of the conventional borders we have. China has built an invisible twenty-first century wall, surpassed only by N’ Korea, around the Nation. I had the occasion to speak with some Chinese professionals while I was in the USA. It seemed to me that they either were unaware of a lot that is happening within China or they were reluctant to say it. I suspect it is the former, else the Americans would have elicited all information. It could also be that the Americans know exactly what is happening within China and are incapable of opposing them or they deliberately avoid doing it in deference to the economy. Either way as of now it seems to be a win-win situation for China. The border pinpricks (with names like Depsang, Pangog etc…) are just that…. pin pricks. China can't achieve much more there. They use LAC as a smoke screen. The larger aim is “economic colonization”. We need to continue to wage an all out war against that. Tail piece: China practices autocracy within and liberal democracy outside the country. It seems to be paying off. The rest of the world has to come up with a brand new ‘weapon’ (tactics, coalition, economic offensive – whatever) to tackle the rise of China. Unless…. China implodes from within (is it happening?). Elementary, Dr. Watson.
    6
  327. This piece fails to address why there are no violent protests, stone throwing, indignant ventilation from “liberals”, etc. on this despicable destruction which is worse than any “insult”? Tailpiece: what pray is tolerance? Who has it and who does not?
    6
  328. Thank you The Print for bringing out the complexities of advance weapon systems to the public. They should know as the information is available in public but they have no time to pursue. But yes, it is good they know. Thank you. Tail piece: The cats law may not work for long as many Nations are breeding a variety of canines!
    6
  329. Sharad, concerns are also good news. If we do not recognize them in time they will become bad news. Thanks for raising them
    6
  330. SG, Tussi great Ho! A courageous presentation. Tailpiece: Pragmatism pays; emotion fails you always and every time. Even in love. Folklore and poets have forever told us this.
    6
  331. Tanpura and Kazakhstan - A heady mix. There is a world out there outside India and it’s politics. Helps perceptions. Tailpiece: A wholesome channel - ThePrint.
    6
  332. Good presentation.. Tailpiece: Whatever, honey it is all about money. As an appeal to politicians - stop trivial politicking. The clock is ticking for India to catch up and make progress.
    6
  333. We the people mentioned in the preamble do not expect our elected representatives to disrupt proceedings in our parliament, to which place we have sent them to carry out erudite discussions on matters of policies etc. Jumping up and down, shouting and jumping into the well are not among them. Tailpiece: I beseech our respected MPs not to behave like unruly children in a badly managed classroom
    6
  334. When World wide a large number of Nations /people are following millennia old texts, why should India forget its legacies which are as old and may be even older than those followed in many other parts of the world ? Tailpiece: change the narratives of liberalism.
    6
  335. Rishi for PM is following a path much like the Indian victory over Pakistan yesterday, in a group match of the ongoing T20 World Cup - From a point of no return, so to speak. Could be the best bet for British economy, hopefully.
    6
  336. On my way from the airport on 26 Dec 2020, after spending over an in the USA, and seeing the plight of NY area in person, I was appalled by how the people in our country were taking it easy. It was as if nothing had changed since I left India in September 2019. All shops open. 50% were not wearing a mask, 30% were wearing it on their chin. Later in the week, out to buy rations, when I asked my vegetable shop fellow why he was not wearing a mask, he replied “Corona has gone, so why wear a mask?”. It was not as if the administration had said so. Because, on the same day while we were driving in our own vehicle, with closed windows and ac on, my wife and I were fined Rs 350/- for not wearing masks inside the car – I was told that it was mandatory. Tailpiece: The problem in our country is not the rules. It is the implementation of the rules by an inadequate, overworked police and paramilitary on a people whose standards self-discipline is abysmal. Let us admit it and strive to improve. I request the media too to highlight this aspect. This is not a cricket match; statistics in a pandemic are just that; just some numbers. Get real
    6
  337. The incident in Mon, is unfortunate and regrettable. The families of the victims should be cared for. The inquiry should not stop with the elite Army Unit, which has an exemplary record of operations and can’t be expected to kill civilians on purpose. Let me explain. The issue is more than that meets the eye. It has been more than seven decades since India is an independent Nation. In many areas in the North and North East the Indian Army has been entrusted with the responsibility of containing the insurgents. An unacceptable situation in a democracy, which clearly indicates that the democratic and diplomatic processes have not been employed efficiently by the elected Governments. The Nation can’t expect the Armed Forces to do that job ad nauseum. The responsibility for this unfortunate and regrettable incident lies even outside of the Army unit. Tail piece: While we have a bureaucracy with immense authority and no responsibility, we expect the Armed Forces to be responsible without authority. Let us accept that AFSPA is a sham as it provides no authority and very little protection to Armed Forces – remember they are dealing with their own country men as opposed to what they are trained to do on the battlefield.
    6
  338. Obviously Gurkhas, traditionally fought for the British and then for India as a legacy of the British. With passage of time and Nepal growing a distance from India - whether we accept or not - such was bound to happen. Luckily Pakistan, Myanmar, China and Bangladesh would not take them in their respective armies for obvious reasons. The British are dismantling their Gurkha troops. India is bound to follow suit in time. Tailpiece: This news is not as big as it is made out to be.
    5
  339. Yes. Concessions are given to those who deserve, those who recognise them as a sacrifice from sine ine else , and those who are grateful for the same. To give something to some one, you have ti take it from someone else.
    5
  340. Gang wars are no wars? War against drugs peddling and use is no war? Just asking. Tailpiece: Let us stop kidding….. and stop being dampeners against governance
    5
  341. Good perceptions from Mr. Bremmer. This unique off the cuff is great.
    5
  342. This means if can be changed once, can be changed as many times as required!!!!! Tailpiece: change is the only constant. An observation: If we bring in the Gandhis, Nehrus, Modis and all and sundry in every conversation about progress and change we will never get there. Discuss ( in the media) a point for as being useful vs useless, progressive vs regressive, benefits people vs does not benefit people etc. I feel that in the larger picture people (including former PMs etc.) are only so much important to progress.
    5
  343. A super vision by ThePrint. To appreciate (either which way) National issues, knowledge on world and international matters is a must. Tailpiece: who is responsible that Indians have tended to be frogs in the well? But mind you India is not unique in this matter. More than 60% of Americans (mostly from the central states) have no real knowledge about India.
    5
  344. Why make the statement at all? Who advices him? Pathetic public utterances. Earnestly hope the INC gets its act together fast. Democracy is not only asking others to act but to activate oneself too in the right direction. Tailpiece: I wonder why the “chintan shivir” does not see the writing on the wall. It is there in big BOLD letters for all to see. Congress can yet keep the remaining good will by changing the leadership… and the LOP too.
    5
  345. When the media, opposition, "experts", activists and about everybody (including JM) repeatedly say "Modi" instead of "GoI", do we take it that 'We the people" are so obsessed with personalities that we prefer dictatorship of democracy. I make the statement, not id defence of any INDIVIDUAL, I make the statement in defence of democracy... Meidia....please....
    5
  346. Voila! In a multi split verdict, we can always devise a method whereby all parties get to be in the Government on a time sharing basis. This is what exactly happened in Mumbai and is happening in Bihar! If prearranged in this manner, the electorate will not be surprised with childish antics of political leaders mostly following agenda other than clean and efficient governance. Just saying. Coalitions cater to the constituents and not to the constituency. Tailpiece: The alternate is that once an alliance is formed, pre/post elections, it should remain so until the next elections. You can’t leave it to these guys (Honorable MLAs and MPs) to create havoc for five years between elections. Just saying
    5
  347. Why make the statement at all? Who advices him? Pathetic public utterances. Earnestly hope the INC gets its act together fast. Democracy is not only asking others to act but to activate oneself too in the right direction. Tailpiece: I wonder why the “chintan shivir” does not see the writing on the wall. It is there in big BOLD letters for all to see. Congress can yet keep the remaining good will by changing the leadership… and the LOP too.
    5
  348. Shekhar “Tussi great Ho”! With hatke peshkash! Way to go! Creative journalism.
    5
  349. With Kharge, are we really moving away from the “Gandhis.” DK? Just asking Tailpiece: Something better than nothing. Better late than never… etc…come to mind
    5
  350. Jai Hind! Tailpiece: They ensure we are where we are.
    5
  351. Are we to believe that there will be fire without smoke…even if it is close to election heat?!!!!! Why is such a prosperous state in dire straits even after 75 years of Independence? An answer to this Q may lay the facts straight. Politics does matter; as it is the most popular game in India after cricket.
    5
  352. Simply put. Clear. Way to go.
    5
  353. I think he meant rented house and not rented home!:)
    5
  354.  @mountolympus1098  why not? There is no NDA there yet.
    5
  355. During the 70s and 80s China was a poor Nation. That is, far poorer than it is now. But even then, they were well ahead on the LAC deployment than India. We too have now improved our deployment since the 80s. But we are not there in the infrastructure. Since a couple of decades, after China became less poor, for various reasons (I am not discussing them) it has attempted to unilaterally alter the LAC. It is moot how successful they have been, but it would not be a surprise given their better preparedness over decades after 62. Indias neglect of the borders with China since 1962 has been admitted by the Defence Minster Mr. AK Antony on the floor of the house more than a decade ago. China has its fingers (pun intended) all over. Wherever there is a dispute (there sure is on the LAC, especially in eight locations) it is either settled by force or through negotiations. Negotiations means “give and take” without bloodshed. War also means give and take after wasteful expenditures and bloodshed. Points for consideration are: 1. War or negotiations. 2. Is India politically ready for negotiations? 3. Is China ready to negotiate? 4. Is India ready for war? 5. Does China want war? 6. Will internal bickering (in nIndian media and parliament etc…) on a well-known situation help India or China? 7. Is China aiming to destablise India politically (a sure enough aim of any Nation to destablise its neighbour), even proposed as an instrument of war by Chanakya. 8. Are there other options for India like Internationalising the dispute etc. (Not recommended due to obvious reasons as everybody involved will want their pound of flesh) and also extend their “help” all over the place. I am no expert of any sort and have only put out my views as I see the situation. I may be missing a lot.. but then, a view is a view… right? Tailpiece: Could Mr. Rahul Gandhi or any other bureaucrat / political leader address these issues….. or can we have a cut the clutter in this.
    5
  356. I will be grateful if I am told why my comments have been removed. Just so that I become more careful
    5
  357. Shekhar, I beg your pardon. You are wrong. In India Islam can kill democracy without the Army. The reason for the “divide” today, I feel is explained in a quote from the book “New clash of civilizations” by Minaz Merchant published in 2013. “You reap what you sow and if any religious group sow the seeds of communalism by insisting on separate laws (and / or exclusivity) for themselves, they will reap the ill will of communal backlash” I endorse his view as we have a precedence. The Caste system in India was created by affording separate laws, special privileges and political patronage to the upper castes. We do not want to repeat that by creating another privileged class with separate laws etc.; do we? A “secular” democracy is one which has the same laws for all its citizens within which different religions practice their faith according to prevalent societal practices. A secular nation is not one which has different laws for different religions, which divides societies, allowing such divisions to be perpetually exploited by vested interests within and outside the country. Only “We the people” can change, without changing core values and just by emerging out of medieval era methods to make a difference in society. Smell the coffee instead of beating around the bush Forward Ho!
    5
  358. DK, shall we say, Nitish is the only constant in modern matchematics.
    5
  359. Great analysis as usual. The outreach just about May work. Kerala is declining in everything except in literacy ( do not confuse with education). Tailpiece: Kerala’s tryst with pluralism is many centuries (millennia?) old.”Singularsm” of ANY type will not work here.
    5
  360. Late night gyan, RG. Brief and precise though.
    5
  361. The Indian Farmer. 1. Free electricity 2. Free water 3. Free /subsidised fertiliser 4. No income tax from farm income 5. Subsidised ration through PDS 6. Direct income transfer 7. Freedom to sell to anybody. anywhere/any time (new laws) 8. Freedom from essential commodity tag for all produce (new) 9. Writing off of loans 10. Easy loans Of course, even so, the farmer should definitely get the right price for his produce without cartelised and mandatory markets (mandis).
    5
  362. When the dust settles down, it will be realized that the “tour of duty” is a good programme to enable the youth of the Nation and may be detrimental to the efficiency of the Armed Forces. It is damning to see how political parties do not see beyond the party and are ready to do anything, even destroy the fabric of society, for power and wealth? Hopefully the Nation will one day, soon, see through these machinations of vested interests. Tailpiece: Gotta see how a balance in the Agnipath can be stuck. May require mid term course corrections.
    5
  363. Who is classifying change in Senior citizen CM as a political crisis. Is this statement for drama effect. I am in Bangalore. Life for the citizen is as normal as ever. I do not find any chaos or feeling of chaos in the environment. Change the language of news presentation. We have progressed in our intellect outlook.
    5
  364. Does this not reflect the weakness, Amethi issue, the weakness of a leader / aspiring leader? Doe not Wyandotte show Rahuls timidity taking cover behind Muslims( nothing religious but statistics of electorate demography)…. Tailpiece: The political rhetorics more so of the opposition parties is disgusting to say the ….least
    5
  365. A good presentation. But incompetency in the war? I doubt. Incompetent battles, may be. Does that India, with “inferior” forces, thwarted the only aim of Pak to take Kashmir, by reaching Lahore in a sort of preemptive move count for nothing? Tailpiece: Read the bottom line. With inferior technology and forces India could not have destroyed the Pak Army. Winning a war is achieving an aim. India achieved the aim of preventing Pak taking Kashmir. Period.
    5
  366. We will head to nowhere if we are forever waiting for “God”ot.
    5
  367. A good presentation. Telling us what you know with your interpretation. Great show. But comparing India to a less than 1 Crore country? Come on….The Print. You must be joking like Jaspal Bhatti:) Tail piece: The bottom line should have been “How can NATO and the West demand of the world what one of its constituent is rejecting”. The hypocrisy is damning. SG just made a “passing reference” and dwelled on a far fetched idea for eyeballs? Disclaimer: There is nothing binary about this comment (Just like The Print). The view pertains to this programme only.
    5
  368. The meme is sure hilarious. Well brought out issues. The opposition ventilations are sure Ill directed. As you say DK the real issue is not what but the the why and how of matters.Let us assume that things could be better. To make a mark and an impression, the opposition need to convince the electorate they can do better. I don’t see that happening. So most opposition governments dole out freebies and such states get into deep debts. These realities are all too evident. Tailpiece: Hindutva and secular are no longer issues. We have Dalit parties,Muslim leagues and political parties run like family trusts cozying up to particular sections of society etc….so why not a party with the support of select “Hindus”. It is not even that Hindus in droves are cozying up to the BJP. Oh well, BTW, where is the opposition really? in fragments of parochial local outfits?
    5
  369.  @vivekt4896  True if you mean the “justice” delivered by the Kings, Mughals and the British. The brand of justice too was different. . Regards
    5
  370. Tolerance is multilateral and not unilateral, as in any marriage!
    5
  371. Oh yes. The BJP does not understand Punjab politics. Pray tell me which National level political party understands the politics in all states including the GOP, the Congress. That fellow Indians is the bane of Indian politics. Tailpiece: We must insist that progress and development should be the language of politics. Not caste etc as the political parties, strategists and unfortunately, the media too, thrive for sustenance. No wonder that India is branded as a laggard democracy.
    5
  372. A plausible analysis. That is why Theprint is different. The million dollar Q remains. How will Pakistan play China and the USA simultaneously in Afghanistan? A difficult task, unless China is not interested in Afghanistan - which is not a possibility. In the context, will the “QUAD-2” (UAE-Israel-India-US) play an influencing role in Afghanistan. Remember "the Strength, the Money, the Technology and the Strategy" statement of Israel MEA? An alternative to Pakistan if it come to that. Tailpiece: The Indian priority should be to break the drug economy of Afghanistan has to be broken, if repeats of the ongoing "Tamasha" of youngsters, celebrities, governments etc... is not to be repeated. An Aside: "You can always respect somebody even if you have differences with that person". There can't be a more relevant expression to put Indian politics on the right track. Could also be a byline on the mug.
    5
  373. Very informative programmes these by Apurva. Thanks. The present laws are more apt and provides for better justice. The doubt still remains, with the law (the old one is relevant here as ordained by the SC) as what it is, is there a provision with the State Government(s) to reject the applications. Could the Givernment have rejected the ‘mercy’ petitions in this case?
    5
  374. Is that how INC wants to reestablish?. I am afraid the majority of the electorate will see otherwise. Instead strengthen the INC by bringing in real leaders who can be seen to deliver. Start with the Telengana model.
    5
  375. “Honey, it is all about Money”. Politics is a career now as has always been; Any turmoil or assault in the name of religion or caste is nothing but criminal activities for material (money, land, pleasure, ego...) gains. “Secularism” is misused as a smoke screen by the lumpen elements. Let us grow out of this hypocrisy of “secularism” which causes more harm than good to the society.
    5
  376. Unsophisticated way of demanding an explanation by the opposition…. Ashamed of this more than “the security breach” Tailpiece: As elected representatives their priorities are misplaced. As with or without their belligerent protests there will be a thorough investigation etc …
    5
  377. Comparisons are inevitable. My take. Are we, including the stalwarts, of the media doing the people of India a Great disservice by undermining their intelligence by comparing a large, diverse, federal (more than half the federal states are traditionally governed by different political dispensations) Nation like India, to countries like Germany etc. where the population and geographical expanse is not even comparable with some large states in our great Nation. Academic comparisons are useless. Discuss India for India. India is unique in many ways even if for its large and diverse population and its undeniable rich (impoverished by colonization etc.) history and past economy. Tailpiece: Discuss India for what we are. Anybody can see India is unique. For God’s (there IS one, right?) sake, stop crying wolf.
    5
  378. A programme by JM, where Modi does not feature. A welcome change. In Pakistan, what is happening is not ‘media vs the army’. It is media vs the Government ( In effect the Army). In some ways is that not what is happening in India too? Tailpiece: Nowhere in world (except may in China and North Korea) can the media sustain without constantly attacking the establishment for something or the other. Ponder.
    5
  379.  @anuragchakraborty8766  Definitely not China or Pakistan; not Russia or Türkiye either. Enjoy
    5
  380. Politics is SG’s forte? Good analysis. It s a shame that we Indians don’t call out these politicians who flit like the bees to collect nectar. Tailpiece: If India has to shake out from being a laggard democracy we need at least two big National parties. It is time we Indians realise this.
    5
  381. What is this video supposed to specifically convey? So many "Opinions" and “views” get published on this site as well as on very many other such sites and social media platforms across the web. Some stupid (depends on perception) comments like this one also get published. What exactly do these “experts” and self-styled proponents (I too am one rooting for democracy) of democracy mean by freedom of expression? I have been living in one great democracy for more than six decades and do not find impediments in speaking my mind in a civil language. Do these people who are themselves parroting National policies looking down on developing Nations as second class citizens of this world, mean exercising unlimited freedom without taking on responsibilities that come with such freedom? These are at best trivial and artificial discussions on democracy. We, Indians definitely do not need lessons on freedom and democracy.
    5
  382. Is 10 years enough to solve an 80 year “problem”, perpetuated by design by vested interest? Just asking. Should we ask the Q in a different way? Are we expecting too much in a short period and defeating the purpose of Nation building? Some more questions. Tailpiece: I feel the media at times use improbable language for TRP. Time for a cut the clutter on over expectations etc.
    5
  383. The irony is that while some Nations (like India) who are doing well by, any standard, discuss and highlight the shortcomings, some other Nations sweep the imminent dangers under the carpet. Tailpiece: How has the play of the Pakistan establishment with their brand of politics, all these years, helped the people of Pakistan to progress? I wonder why the people of Pakistan seem to be oblivious to these aimless direction of Pakistan establishment?
    5
  384. The catch phrase Shekhar “ Honey, it is all all about money”….even governance…. The consumer is king….accept and move on
    5
  385. Time line of the whole case is important. The scam took place between 2005-2012. Tailpiece: The time line of the fraud should be spelt out upfront. The loans became NPA in 2013.
    5
  386. Excellent. He takes a stand that we should not be binary in our thoughts and deeds. You need all types of “friends” to build a Nation. It is up to India to juggle the relationships in its favor as much as possible. A great interview. Kudos.
    5
  387.  @durranishaheer1538  Now you are off track. India accepts that Muslims conquered and ruled parts of the subcontinent. We can’t change that. But how they ruled etc… the truth is recorded … let us not go to those grey ages and let us say it is also history. We are not talking of Governance. Let all religious leaders unequivocally accept each other’s religious and religious way and proclaim so. That was all that I ask for as an Indian just say” your religion is as good as mine”…. And in the world out there let the Real Islam of peace and love be seen and embraced by all. Don’t let Islam be hijacked with a gun on its head.
    5
  388. Congrats. They should take up cases before it reaches tragic ends!
    5
  389. Snehesh, Good show. This IS a tough job. If such efforts by Indians reach the “common man” it will enrich our social capital…. Such as trust, confidence and resolve to improve in whatever one is doing…rather than waste time in political bickering…. Tailpiece: What one wears is only a visual presentation. What one does benefits.
    5
  390. Is it the real democracy, when political parties fight against each other in one part of the country and join hands and fight shoulder to shoulder from the same side in another part of the country? I don’t see much said on this by “experts”, “intellectuals”, “political pundits”, “academics” et al. Just asking. Views are personal and neutral
    5
  391. The real media The Print. Give it as it is, and let the people decide.
    5
  392. Uncharted waters….coloured in green and ….red… strange bedfellows
    5
  393.  @shubhamkumaroriginal  sure. In a democracy the political leadership is supreme and the military leadership cannot and will not act independently Vijay Diwas is about the victory of the military and not about political leadership or misogyny .
    5
  394.  @Liberty55555  may be you are one of those who is a fan of “non state” actors? Enjoy
    5
  395.  @amanshukla8758  that is the point...
    5
  396.  @ibadurrehman5764  with due respect to your points…have you read the school texts of 1950s, 60s and 70s? Also, during the Raj, the British too ruled like Emperors and Kings….Thanks for your inputs. Enjoy
    5
  397. Good discussion….
    5
  398. Never mentioned the greatest dynasty destroying INC, Shekhar… just saying
    5
  399. Smell the coffee. Back in the late 1980s, I was posted in a government institution. In those days serial Ramayana was screened for an hour every Sunday morning. During times of heavy workload, because of the added work schedules, the institution worked on Sundays of some weeks. On those Sundays, I recall, the staff wanted an hour’s break between 09.30 – 11.00 AM to watch the serial Ramayana. I believe the whole nation came to a standstill during the screening. BJP etc. was not even on the horizon during that period. All said and done, the “Ram Mandir” in Ayodhya will be a boost to the hospitality, travel and tourism industries while boosting the State and local economies. Tailpiece: The stock value of L&T who constructed the Ram Temple, has almost doubled in the last one year.
    5
  400. SG can you ‘ cut the suspense’ and tell us from where you get your kurtas?
    5
  401. For a moment I thought it read “G20 leaders”. What with the obsession of our media for “foreign” opinions!!!
    5
  402. The government is also cautious, Snehesh. It is not as if they have opened the champagne. Right?
    5
  403. As usual a different programme fro DK and ThePrint. “Modi is more Sikh than Sikhs”. Two parts to any religion… teachings and methods…teachings are the soul of religions and hence more important than methods and symbols (like jhenua, Beard only, method of prayers, temples, mosques, churches etc. etc.). Tailpiece: A profound statement made by Mr I Singh.
    5
  404. The very reason a number of political parties of various hues and flavor have sprouted in India is because all of them felt they had nothing in common with the other parties as parochial interests and thirst for power divided them…. Divisive politics I must say. I wonder when such a disparate set of parties come together to just unsurp power, talking abstract subjects like ideology , secularism etc (because of which each went their own way in the fist place as they could not tolerate each other etc…), where does it place the Nation? Just asking. Tailpiece: I wish these parties come up with more tangible arguments for the Nation to have a disparate alliance for Government….when India can’t take their foot away from the accelerator of development and progress
    5
  405. What does President Obama have to say on this? Could somebody ask him? As an addendum, I would also like President Obama’s views on USSC rejecting proposed affirmative action by Harvard and NC universities? This also is a poser to all likewise thinkers in the West..
    4
  406.  @Opp_Man  Friend. That is the half way…. Hijab is something not mandated by religion, it is just a practice. So go half way…. There are such issues in the Vedic practices too. For instance the Vedas mandate only 7 rituals during a marriage ceremony. But many social dispensations in India do much more and term them as a religious practice. So I say Hijab is dispensable (as not part of religion) I am not saying it because it is the custom (not religious) in a community and not against Islam. I maintain that all religions was formed with good intentions. But religions have been exploited by unscrupulous elements from within. We have to recognise that first..before we point fingers on outsiders.
    4
  407. I wonder, if it is time for India to caste away castes and tell people to go out and vote rather than go out and cast(e) their votes. I also wonder whether it is time for We The People to reject fragmented politics in India. I find that there is no meaningful discussions on these aspects in the media, for fear or sustenance or whatever. For instance, though SG has talked sense, it propagates more intolerance and is propagating divisive thoughts. Nobody is rejecting such commentaries. I again wonder why? These are thoughts expressed briefly. The subject is vast and begs for widespread discussions. Tailpiece: A view is that the reservation policies as exists today, mostly introduced with votes and power in mind, does more harm than good for those who are to benefit from them. Also, the reservation policies creates a divide where injustice is dispensed to a section of the society for something perceived to have been done by people many generations ago. While wealth can be redistributed, redistribution of justice is undemocratic and, if I may, unjustified! Disclaimer: I am for empowerment for the all those disadvantaged sections of society. But actions for that have to be commensurate with the aim and not drive by an agenda to seek votes and power. Media should also realise this.
    4
  408.  @titaboria  India has one aim... To get the best for India in a peaceful world.
    4
  409.  @KiranKumar-nb4nx  kiran you have a point. But we can't get exceptional ministers always. It is the bureaucrats who are permanent and should be accountable for particular projects and implementation.
    4
  410. Why do you use “they” for the Indian government as if it is an alien organisation and not Indian? Instead, if you just say “Target set by the ….. etc…”, we, your audience, will feel more comfortable.. Thanks
    4
  411. The cap is sublime…old world. And the tweed is a steal. Tail piece: A veritable take on geopolitics in the West vis a vis Russia. So, what we see is not always what it is!
    4
  412. INC’s reaction reminds me of the story of the ostrich which when encountered with danger buries it’s head in the sand and hopes the danger will pass by. Tailpiece: Yes the Nation needs a strong “opposition” … not in words but in deeds. I hope the INC during its course of agitations against the price rise etc., also tell us what has led to the price rise and recommend actions to curb the same.
    4
  413. Who decides who is smart? Beware all "experts" grow to become "experts" feeding on preconceived ideas.
    4
  414. A good quick rejoinder! And a goo one, SG!!! My take. There is no absolute definitions for secularism and Hindutva. The meanings of these words are defined by individuals as per their desired perception. Therein lies the paradox. These words matter little except to raise agenda based controversies. There can be a life without these words too. A better, more rewarding life. We the people have to see through the politics in these words and just ignore /stop using these words. Tail piece: Unless we change the basic narrative in the society, the politicians (even very senior, elderly inconsequential ones) will try to exploit and the people (who are perpetually busy with getting their life together) will let themselves be exploited by design or by default.
    4
  415. World appreciation for the Mahatma is a mirage. The presidents and PMs of the world praise Gandhiji and his path of “non violence”. Do they really practice it - personally and/or professionally? Diplomatic parleys are seldom the truth. Just saying
    4
  416. Foreign policies of the USA belong to the Nation and not to the POTUS. Packaging may be different but the contents will almost always remain the same. It is true with most democracies; so it is with India too.
    4
  417. Another important aspect evident here is:- 90% of a community votes on religious lines 15% of a community votes on religious lines Who is more “secular” / communal? Just asking… Tailpiece: ALL political parties should just discuss Roti, Kapda Makkan…. That is real democracy…. Concentrate on the dinner table and not on the altar
    4
  418. Controversy or objections and protests by some citizens against a legal and constitutional process in an Indian state? Just asking. Tailpiece: Sometimes the media inadvertently create controversies. Just saying.
    4
  419. Great story. It must be told. BUT... But journalistic standards are abysmal. The impact would have been much more without the macabre pictures. Don't bank on shock and awe for Pandemic stories - because IT IS A PANDEMIC. The youngster is not being groomed well.
    4
  420. I hope these politicians, especially, the opposition are aware that there is a Nation to be governed. Tailpiece: We the people know that financial irregularities always have a money trail and documented details. So, let the courts decide. If this is harassment, We the people will handle it. Get on with Governing the Nation.
    4
  421. The adage "the enemy of your enemy is your friend"!!! But then todays enemy may become a friend...as our politicians say "there are no permanent enemies or friends in politics" Tailpiece: What really drives the politicians in a democracy? Personal gains, Party or the Nation?
    4
  422. Deja Vu ! We have heard these for decades . As a rule the opposition cries fowl of all government policies. That sums up our laggard democracy. No maturity, no logic, no “constructive criticism” - just plain and simple playing to the galleries... a shame Whose country is it anyway?
    4
  423. Thank you The Print for broadcasting this ICS programme. Grateful. 1. Capability - .2. Resolve - 3. Communication. While 2 & 3 are mostly a function of training and development, 1 is a function of resource - political will; diplomatic skills; resources like weapon systems, surveillance systems, communications, software, manpower etc..; intelligence - local and international and so on... All these should stem from a coherent security doctrine. Did I get this right?
    4
  424. Jihadism in India….That is exactly what this Government has been acting to prevent by inclusive policy…. Should be vary of all who do not want to be included. Right? Tailpiece: when we know there can be problem…prevention is always better than cure…. Hope all sections of our society recognise this and do not encourage violence in their respective societal circles….very important. Deferring to fear (possible terrorism) is not the answer
    4
  425. Again a very relevant topic handled intelligently with maturity. My take… Indian politics.The Hindutva or rather “anti-Hindutva” and” secular” are no more relevant in Indian politics. The refrain is if political parties can be parochial (TMC, SS, DMK, TRS etc..), religion based (Muslim leagues, Akali etc..), Clan based (Yadavs, Gujjars etc.) and Dalit based (BSP etc.) or Dynastic (INC,SS, Yadavs, DMK, TC etc..) why can’t there be a party which is “Hindu” based? (I have my own take on this “Hindu” myth). What is the difference in any of these approaches? In electoral democracies every political party will attempt to create a strong faithful voter base. Probably BJP is doing just that. (BTW “Hindus” in droves are not blindly flocking to BJP ). THAT is a natural process in democracy. The perception of exclusion is just because the majority are not minority!!! That is also natural. In such an environment it is difficult to separate the wrong from the right in Indian politics – like it or not. And is that not part of diversity too? Can you have diversity with the exclusion of the majority? Tailpiece: There never was, is or will be a Utopia (Ramrajya).The electorate has realized that Governance is all about the Nation to deliver Roti, Kapda and Makkan to its people. All else are distractions. Economy and development (Ease of living) will be key. In order to further preserve Indian democracy, the opposition parties have to change tactics and strategies. We fervently hope that they will do it. Welcome to the changing face of Indian politics.
    4
  426. When the dust settles down, it will be realized that the “tour of duty” is a good programme to enable the youth of the Nation and may be detrimental to the efficiency of the Armed Forces. It is damning to see how political parties do not see beyond the party and are ready to do anything, even destroy the fabric of society, for power and wealth? Hopefully the Nation will one day, soon, see through these machinations of vested interests. Tailpiece: Gotta see how a balance in the Agnipath can be stuck. May require mid term course corrections.
    4
  427. Siddhant I agree. But today it will be impossible for The Print to remain like this and maintain quality, if it goes on the air. The environment there is totally vitiated
    4
  428. @gouthamvidyasagar  statista statistics 2001- 44%, 2011-55%, 2017-75%, 2019- 90% .... Now come ..let us face facts . Okay I will elect RG as PM... If that is what you want. Stay well
    4
  429.  @gouthamvidyasagar  self made has worked… India is rolling ahead… BTW I am not a BJP member nor working for any political party. Politics does not interest me…but governance does. Progress of India does… I have no problem with RG or PG becoming PM etc… but he / she nor the current leaders of INC give me any confidence as leaders who can lead my nation. Modi etc… have done it …but are individuals here today gone tomorrow…. India and its people are forever… prove your mettle and stake claim…. INC is degenerating by the day. Current dynastic leaders of INC should step aside and hand over the party to new leaders who can rejuvenate the party with a vision for India….
    4
  430. Thank you ThePrint for bring it to the public. Tailpiece: Such activities have been going on from across the North Western borders since decades in order to destabilize the bordering Indian state of J&K. Just saying
    4
  431. All well Swami… let truth be told Wherever there is a dispute (there sure is on the LAC, especially in eight locations) it is either settled by force or through negotiations. Negotiations means “give and take” without bloodshed. War also means give and take after wasteful expenditures and bloodshed. Points for consideration are: 1. War or negotiations. 2. Is India politically ready for negotiations? 3. Is China ready to negotiate? 4. Is India ready for war? 5. Does China want war? 6. Will internal bickering (in nIndian media and parliament etc…) on a well-known situation help India or China? 7. Is China aiming to destablise India politically (a sure enough aim of any Nation to destablise its neighbour), even proposed as an instrument of war by Chanakya. 8. Are there other options for India like Internationalising the dispute etc. (Not recommended due to obvious reasons as everybody involved will want their pound of flesh) and also extend their “help” all over the place. Where do we go Swami? You. Said it
    4
  432. A good presentation as to how matters unfold at a physical level - My two bit is purely an academic observation. I reserve the right to be wrong. The crux of the problem is the mix of religious methods with law – telling people (more importantly women) how to behave and dress etc… This is completely against the principles of individual freedom, the right of every individual, and democracy. Who decides what is good for the people irrespective of religion? How can a few armed outfits be allowed to hijack a society? Tailpiece: Is discussing individual freedom a tirade against a religion or political outfits? Humanity needs to discuss these aspects at the abstract levels. The intellect has to be addressed. Or, is this what is known as prodding a hornet’s nest?
    4
  433. A good programme. Reassuring. Tailpiece: The problem is that law treats everyone as same, the basic essence of justice “on time” is not delivered in the same equal measure. Therein lies the discrimination.
    4
  434. Well said, DK
    4
  435. Unfortunately, discussions in the media almost every time is how a rule hurts and not how a rule helps. The discussions, including among professionals who are “experts” in tax matters, are how to circumvent paying taxes rather than pay them. The media talks of right to protest and not about the reason or that the protests themselves end up violating the basic rights of the people at large. The discussions in the media mostly absolves all citizens of their transgressions and responsibilities. The role of each individual in a democracy does not end with casting a vote. He too is required to perform his duties and uphold the law diligently. There is no discussion as to how a limited, ill equipped overworked police force and an inadequate overworked judicial system (it costs a lot of tax payers money to have a police force in a ratio of at least 1 -100; it costs money to appoint 10 times more the number of judges as required for the population, again to be paid from taxes; it costs money to enhance the infrastructure for efficient implementation of security and related matters) will handle deliberate violations of law and rules by all and sundry.
    4
  436.  @ahmedshahid5271  everything except development and a sweeping statement about joblessness. I am not trying to make a point for any party…. Enjoy
    4
  437. How about this heading to this video? "China damages its relations with India because of the Ladakh incident"...What you say matters less than how and why you say it.
    4
  438. Indians cannot be generalised in anything and everything. I wonder why Dr.Tarun K, missed the aspect of diversity.
    4
  439. Branding it as Indias dilemma is preposterous… a couple of million people is not India
    4
  440. Haha! “State of the union, address”… like it
    4
  441. SS has always been a surreal party evolving on “anti” platforms. The only reality is economy…money….where does Mumbai get it from? Tailpiece: It is high time India grows out of dynastic politics. There can only be one Balsaheb Thackeray…. Period… time to move on…move on sons and grandsons…they can’t perpetuate his “legacy”….it is already proved
    4
  442. Diwali greetings to team , ThePrint. Forward Ho!
    4
  443. While the political parties know not a thing, we are all wise and know -all? Right? Just asking. You are doing a good job. Keep it going.
    4
  444.  @Vizorfam  yeah sure. That is free speech for you eh?
    4
  445. Gotta give it to BJP leadership….they have a plan for the party as they have a plan for the Nation. Bothe are visible to the electorate. Tailpiece: As always I call for the Gandhis to make way for INC to up hold democratic ways for a two party India.
    4
  446. Is this Iran- Israel animosity rooted in racism and/or religion? Why is Iran fighting Israel… any old cut the clutter on it?
    4
  447. Should all foreign media reports be probed? It is pathetic that our leaders follow up only on foreign media and do not come up with original demands with proof…as some say this is happening from 2019….what we’re our opposition leaders doing all these 3 years?
    4
  448. Somebody had famously said “I disagree with what you say but I will forever fight to uphold your right to say it” or words to that effect. Exercising a right to protest does not automatically make the reason of the protest automatically right too. The celebrities and activists jump onto a band wagon supporting the right to protest as, often it is their bread and butter to fame. A democratic Nation is run by elected Governments and not celebrities and activists. And democracy is not always about protests...
    4
  449. SG, sounding a bit apologetic… Nifty PSE ( 20 major PSU s where The Govt holds at least 51% of the stock in the company) rose from 680 in 1995 to 4410 in 2022 and from there to 9307 today in Feb 24. (In 2 years) There is an important special story there which you missed. To get value gotta increase value. Let us watch. Tailpiece: A good hatke analysis though
    4
  450.  @pardeeptandon  pst, what is whatsapp? And pst a view is a view which ( even I do not claim) may not always be the correct view. Discuss points, don’t involve characters of narrators. If you don’t like my view, I will fully understand and thank you for your counter views. Enjoy.
    4
  451. @RK2022 RK, I disagree. SG has not said he wants Modi defeated. ThePrint is only reporting and doing a good job at that. Discuss points and not the commentator. Enjoy.
    4
  452. Definition of obsession : something somebody else is pursuing which one does not like/ refuse to appreciate. Tailpiece: Is there, here, an “obsession” with BJP? Just wondering.
    4
  453. The best selling author, historian, philosopher and professor, Yuval Noah Harare, says that in a democracy the politicians treat the people like puppets (katputhli) who are controlled by emotional strings. As such people are made to vote vide their feelings rather than by thoughts. Very relevant to India which is known as a laggard democracy with a poor rate of progress and development . In the context, isn’t it time the people and more importantly the MEDIA change its major narrative from the transitional rhetoric of political dispensations and discuss how policies and directions of these political parties improve living conditions of the people? Tailpiece: we need to ignore political rhetoric at all all levels.
    4
  454. I wonder why oblique references are made to India when discussing issues in Pakistan and China, when such matters do not even remotely affect a federal Nation like India where states are ruled by different political outfits. I wish our media shows more responsibility towards We the people of India and do not inadvertently mislead them. Tailpiece: In my nearly 7 decades of living and working and giving my service to fellow Indians, there has never been any widespread perception (even during the emergency) that any single person or entity can dictate to Indians…No “power” in the world can do that for that matter. Rest assured.
    4
  455. Cheap publicity. Sickening…Trumplistic?
    4
  456. There is a feeling in a very large section of the Indian population, that some farmers and some politicians have AS USUAL turned the representations of farmers into a political gimmick. What with talks still open and the judiciary also involved in the matter, is there a genuine reason for prolonging this “agitation”? Who represents the voice of this section of Indians who see a deja Vu in these shenanigans from all sides? Tail piece: There are “genuine demands” from the unorganized sector, from laborers, from industrial workers, from the informal economy, from MSMEs, from the industry, from airline operators and from just about all and sundry. At some point we have to get real and move on.
    4
  457. JI, it is not about leaders being good or bad in a diverse India. As people we should not expect Utopia (the proverbial "Ramrajya" - NOTE: not connected to Ram Mandir!!!!) , which never existed and never will come. If we let federal and state governments to function with even 50% efficiency and let them make mistakes, India will race ahead with its economy.
    4
  458. Every war is fought with an AIM. In 1965, India was drawn into the war by Pakistan and hence the Aim of our Defence Forces was to thwart Pakistan and not defeat it. I wonder where was the “failure” when defeating the Pak Army was not an aim in the first place.So much for your analysis. Tailpiece: wars, battles, Defence strategies et al are specialized matters. We had an aim in 1971 and and also in Kargil. We achieved those aims and we commemorate those victories. There is a difference.
    4
  459. Unfortunate. Shocking. Tragic. Heartfelt condolences to all family and friends of the departed soldiers. (Posted at 6.41PM).
    4
  460.  @bratwurstmitbiryani  Biryani, I agree with you 100%. So, why then is the GOP talking mostly about It and not on development etc. The GOP is disintegrating. The leadership is found wanting…for a long time. The Nation is the loser when a party that has been in power for more than 75% of the period since independence is vanishing. We need the Congress. For it to revive it has to talk something more than Hindutva and gaurashaks.
    4
  461. truth seeker Hi Truth seeker, suffice to say (the truth is) that I have served in the Pango Tso area multiple times since 1975....hope you get the picture. My Q to the G is not about what but Why in the media? Regards
    4
  462. Another interesting programme from SG. My take. I wonder if putting a political angle to such matters (I know you say politics, like, salt is added to all that is served up) take the shine off “advantage India” internally and externally. In this presentation, you started off laying the emphasis, unfortunately, on the wrong facet of the event. Almost trivializing the meet itself. Uncharacteristic, I must say.… Tail piece: And ah; does Modi require to be provided a stage? Just asking.
    4
  463. From where does the NDA (National Defence Academy) comes in… Uninformed interviewer.
    4
  464. Good take on economic matters by SG! My take. You win some you lose some. Economy has its ups and downs especially in trying times as this. For instance, once Indian bonds get added to the world bond index (will happen soon), the foreign exchange reserves will right itself. CAD too will steady to an extent after that. Other steps to steady the economy are, Oil imports from Russia, Rupee payments for some imports etc. etc. etc. Tailpiece: It is not an “alarming” situation by any standards as yet.
    4
  465. A very free flowing interview where for once the star was not SG ( my apologies SG). I must admit that I had a very different picture of PK. He has turned out to be a very erudite and knowledgeable person. My apologies for my uninformed remarks on PK wherever. Please convey to him. Tailpiece: It appears that PK is a bit frustrated in not finding a right platform to take forward his ideas. An observation - PK is young. He should not have (and express) strong likes and dislikes.
    4
  466. Did Biden say that? Or did he say that the thaw between Saudi and Israel was the main reason? And he referred to a normalization process… He did NOT specify the “corridor”. I heard it live as I am in the US these days. Did I hear wrong, Snehesh? Tailpiece: This reference to the “corridor” was denied by Mr John Kirby also specifically… May like to recheck
    4
  467. Great. Such programs will result in a better informed electorate. Way to go...
    4
  468. Obviously China is after Tawang, if only for the second holiest and important Buddhist monastery there, (where Dalailama stayed in 1959: while fleeing from Tibet). But probably in the short and medium term China will achieve more by just threatening and instigation. A distraction for India… a diversion of its economic resources… a live political point for the opposition… etc.. etc…. Tailpiece: In the case of LAC actions and China’s intentions it is not always what we see/hear is actually what is. Also since decades in regard to China the Indian Government knows (and hides) much more than we know. Whether it is for good, bad or worse only time can tell. By discussing the unknown we are playing into the Chinese hands.
    4
  469. This little country conducted the last soccer World Cup tournament successfully.
    4
  470. Mush needed clarification. But of course there is much more… Tailpiece: Nothing will be a “walk in the park” for Chinese along the LAC, any more.
    4
  471. A merry go around in the offing! I wonder why those who are victimized go to the courts to seek justice. A media upheaval will fizzle out like a fireworks a lot of noise and dazzle for a while and smoke and stink until the air clears by itself. A deja Vu.
    4
  472.  @chinmayshetye3  Sure Chinmay. Scholars are needed. But what they say is not always the dictum.Like all of us they too have prejudices. A comment section is not a place to present copious data. What I have expressed is also A VIEW. A view from some one who have seen both sides of the world (West and India, lived in both places) and interacted with people of both worlds for over half a century. If you are really interested, a lot of data on the economies of various nations are available on the internet for free. Else you can start with Ruchir Sharmas books. BTW even in developed countries there is a lot of disparity in living standards of people. It is just that because of the progress they have made over centuries, the general standard of living is higher than in the developing countries. Bye. Enjoy. Forward Ho!
    4
  473.  @Vizorfam  No. It is that wealth which is redistributed as subsidies etc... In all societies disparities exist . Even in developed Nations. It is taking more time in India to reduce this gap merely because of the population. Look at the bug picture without prejudice and preconceived ideas. Enjoy.
    4
  474. Kudos, SG for the introspection. Well presented. Does art imitates life or is it the other way around. An egg and chicken situation. Tail piece: Such programmes, I suppose, will set the mind to work instead of wagging tongues.
    4
  475. The conditions for business in India are better now than say two decades back and better than a decade back...including lesser taxes, lower interest rates and improved infrastructure. Is the economy of a country solely depended on the Governments? Just asking.... Also, a coach always knows how to play his team...but he can never perform when he is part of the team. Just saying....
    4
  476.  @durranishaheer1538  brother, i don't doubt it even a bit, having spent by childhood in North Malabar. Let the religious leaders come on to one platform in villages, towns, districts up to National level and let each religious leader repeatedly proclaim "Your religion is as good as mine. Your God is as good as mine. You chosen path to your God is as efficient as mine". Don't leave it to the politicians or the media to bring in religious harmony. Peace can't be confined to chapters in books.
    4
  477. Does it mean that Mr Nitish K had not wished so or had not worked for that in his earlier tenures? Just asking.
    4
  478. How dependable are these deals…. Not much, I suppose. China on LOC and Pak on LOC are cases in point. Limitations of pacts such as NATO stand exposed. Tailpiece: Yet we have to endure “diplomacy” as a matter of hope….
    4
  479.  @brainiac1595  Reign or rein, (political influence by CCP) the biggest real estate company in China has crumbled putting the Chinese economy at risk. You cannot and should not attempt to control the economy through politics. (Do not confuse with governence and constitutional institutions like, RBI, Audit, Tribunal and the courts). It is only now there is an environment in India for startups. In a decade or so we will see more Tatas, Birlas, Ambanis and Adanis emerging - hopefully.
    4
  480. There is a feeling in a very large section of the Indian population, that some farmers and some politicians have AS USUAL turned the representations of farmers into a political gimmick. What with talks still open and the judiciary also involved in the matter, is there a genuine reason for prolonging this “agitation”? Who represents the voice of this section of Indians who see a deja Vu in these shenanigans from all sides? Tail piece: There are “genuine demands” from the unorganized sector, from laborers, from industrial workers, from the informal economy, from MSMEs, from the industry, from airline operators and from just about all and sundry. At some point we have to get real and move on.
    4
  481. A good analysis as usual. My two bit, in regard to few who have guns… That is the problem of insurgence. A faceless enemy. The Defence forces or even the para military (who are trained to deal with the society) can’t know who have the guns and who don’t because of the ‘silent’ majority who are terrified of those who have the guns (terrorists?). A phenomenon more prominent in the border states (not surprised). Tailpiece: We the people should know these problems faced by the paramilitary and the Defence forces. Collateral damage is a collateral in handling such situations. The silent majority need to speak up and act and not speak only when there is some damage.
    4
  482. I was in NY in Mar-Apr 2020. I did not see the US media report even once "What is the foreign media saying about the chaos in NY". If we have to get over our obsession with "foreign" we have to do it now...especially the Indian media and the "old hats" in the Indian media.
    4
  483. A honest true representation. Kudos The Print (and SG) for the efforts all around. Tailpiece: We the people should also remember that all problems are not because of politicians and Governments can’t solve all problems without the help of “we the people”.
    4
  484. The media too does not help to overcome this psychosis. Does the media at least NOW get the point regarding correct reporting?
    4
  485. India also used Stand off ammunition in Balakote
    4
  486. Counter productive. Why give that statement so much importance and exposure? Remember that "Silence is the perfect expression of Scorn".
    4
  487. The premise of this argument by TCA unfortunately is that it is the “right” (or okay) for tax payers to default as they have been doing repeatedly for decades prior to the GST regime. Loss of revenue is as usual on the account of the Government.. TCA and experts should address and educate taxpayers to comply….. the media does not address tax payers to comply….. is that a “liberal” (always self defeating) attitude attitude or is that for TRP. Tailpiece: Nobody (read media) tells The bike rider to wear helmet…. If the fines are increased Government is autocratic… if the youth dies, the government is responsible..It is time to cut the crap. Let us see the print take the lead in asking citizens to be compliant. Stop mollycoddling the public. Let them do their bit for Nation building. Rome was not built in a day.
    4
  488. “Secular”. Does anybody know the real,meaning? Each defines the word as per his/ her wants and intentions. Media should desist using this word. Tailpiece: Same goes for Hindutva. E.g. Bajrang Dal is NOT a Hindutva group. You could instead call it an aggressive Hindu outfit. If Hindutva means Hindus does the news paper The Hindu cater to only Hindus?
    4
  489. Good to know your neighbours. Good presentation. Tail piece: Taking BBC Urdu seriously? Are you serious? Just asking
    4
  490. @Ajitpal Ghuman oh yes Ajit... Indulging in a bit of sarcasm,: nothing can be forever.. msp, subsidies et al.. Got to start addressing that too. Else too the economy will collapse one day. Farmers need hand holding, it us being dine.. Need not be over done; else too the economy will collapse
    4
  491. THAT is a pervasive problem in everything. “So many “experts” say so many different things”!!!! Well brought out. Good programmes these, from The print. Way to go Sandhya.
    4
  492. Passing the bill or not is not as important as revamping the archaic bureaucratic set up in India. The relic definitely requires a make over. In a democracy, especially in India, there will never be an unanimous vote in Parliament except possibly to raise the salaries of its members. So, what is new? Tailpiece: If in democracies, is a majority in the August houses a “brute force”? Isn’t democracy and the freedom etc. that comes with it integral to India? So, stop sulking about majority etc. Some party or coalition will and should always have majority. Else India will forever remain a LAGGARD DEMoCRACY as labeled by the world at large.
    4
  493.  @TheKyahua  Fahd I suppose you are in India. The rest of the world does not think about India as you project. I am not into politics, INC too governed India for many years. They may do so again sometime in the future. Hence we want Gandhi family out of politics, so that INC can again become efficient. We will always welcome a PM 10 times better performing than Modi. The standards have to be very very high. It will be super for India.
    4
  494. Not right Ruhi. Allies have Congress aversion because of congress weakness (unpopular?) while BJP (more popular?) has ally aversion because of their strength. There is a world of a difference here. Just saying; nothing political
    4
  495. Haha! Again. Media teaching a Nation and the professionals (not journalists etc) a lesson. And Ah! Is Mr Swamy equating the Israel-Gaza border with what is obtained along LOC? Beats all logic. Tailpiece: Wonder why the media always thinks itself as knowall…. Beats me…May be I too have a lesson to learn from the media. With all respect does this headline as in the video give credence to the commentators stature? No. Substandard.
    4
  496. Let us stop comparing the incomparable and waste precious media time. India is unique in all its ways. We must concentrate on having our own datums for gauging our progress and development
    4
  497. After all China is social and does have media and can express dissent on social media, is that your point? Of course there can only be one official Chinese view.
    4
  498. Earnestly hope the INC is able to take its position as the main Pan India opposition soon. It has to project itself as concerned about development rather than the redundant secularism, Hindutva etc. Tailpiece: we can’t wish away the effects of millennia of history.
    4
  499. Nice little presentation. Little as this public address “conveys” very much more than what they convey. The open secret has now become public knowledge. The issues are a lot more ….. and more dangerous. Let us not tie the Indian Governments and administration to handling “insults”. If India does not as a Nation and also its people do not now rise as one…we will be much worse than a a laggard democracy. I wonder what will we leave behind for the later generations. Tailpiece: The people should only realize that Governing India is much beyond conducting elections.
    4
  500. Good programme, this off the cuff where different people speak on different matters (and sometimes on same matters) at different times, answer different questions from the same anchor at different places. All relevant points were brought forth. One point for me stood out. I recall the daily briefings by President Donald Trump during the peaks (in different parts of the US) of the pandemic in the USA. I was in NY in those days. When the peak was seemingly subsiding in some parts of the USA, President Trump wanted everything to come back to normal at the earliest. He asked Dr, Faucci to explain the time table. The opening statement of Dr. Faucci was that "We can’t switch back to normal at the flick of a switch. It will be gradual . ..." and then he went on to detail the process. Getting back to India and to a system of minimum government and maximum governance as discussed here, can’t happen at the flick of a switch. So also various other reforms. Hopefully India will slowly graduate from an enforcing state to a deregulated state. The process has started. Are we ready? For, in a deregulated state the onus of governance will be more with the people than with the state. It is then more than ever every Indian will be tested on traits like honesty, integrity, sincerity etc… Tail piece: It is time “We the people” assume our responsibilities for minimum government and maximum governance. What we do will matter more than what we wear.
    4
  501. Right analogy. Umbrella is used by individuals. Each one has to repair his/her umbrella herself. In this case each should ( should have) follow(ed) appropriate COVID behavior.
    4
  502. A simple analysis…. Nothing about economy… a different take okay. Good Tailpiece: SG..nothing any politician says is without politics. Not only Modi.
    4
  503. That would be great to have a real, erudite and committed opposition at National level. We wish RG and INC all the best. Tailpiece: Hope it was not just scuba diving for fun and feeling the under currents.
    4
  504. I see that there are no “protests” on the two sixes that Kohli smacked in the last two balls of the penultimate over. THAT my friends sealed the match. Stop crying. Pakistan has a world beater team with many world class players. The only lesson they have to unlearn is “How to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory”. For instance, there were no such “no balls” in the Zimbabwe game. Tailpiece: Waquar, are you listening? Love the Pak team…. Lead them
    4
  505. There is a feeling in a very large section of the Indian population, that some farmers and some politicians have AS USUAL turned the representations of farmers into nothing more than political gimmick. What with talks still open and the judiciary also involved in the matter, is there a genuine reason for prolonging this “agitation”? Who represents the voice of this section of Indians who see a deja Vu in these shenanigans from all sides? Agitation-failed talks- violent agitation- casualties- political parties come for phot ops and I front of the camera with the sole aim of garnering votes. In the past five decades we have seen this game played over many times. Frustrated. Tail piece: There are “genuine demands” from the unorganized sector, from laborers, from industrial workers, from the informal economy, from MSMEs, from the industry, from airline operators and from just about all and sundry. At some point we have to get real and move on.
    4
  506. What intelligence did the US have in regard to Russia attacking Ukraine and upsetting the world economy. Even if India takes punitive action on Pakistan, it will be localized. The world should concentrate where major problems are.
    4
  507. Policy of construction always pays dividends while a policy of destruction in the least destroys all…and may be finally annihilates.
    4
  508. Lucid analysis. The poll outcome in Karnataka has also established beyond any doubt. 1. That democracy is very well alive and kicking in India. 2. Both the electoral process and the voting machines function effectively and truthfully. Tailpiece: We in Karnataka, look forward to efficient administration in public services, which has been poorly managed for at least the last two decades. And ah! Polarization in INDIAN POLITICS - Dalit party, Muslim leagues, Akalis, caste based parties, parochial - DMK, AIADMK, TMC, Telangana congress, YSR congress , LOK Dal, Gomantak, Shiv Sena - has existed for decades. Is the media trying to give a new flavor to polarization? Is that a right approach?just asking.
    4
  509. A good presentation as usual. But can we have a cut the clutter on the following? Whenever a politician is charged / prosecuted, is it always a case of misuse of authority and / or vindictiveness? Just asking
    4
  510. See the writing on the wall. Not graffiti!!! Not panic. Cycling, walking, EVs, Solar, Wind etc.. may require more attention. Tailpiece: Camels and elephants are used in allegories. Those who may still wonder, SG means, 5million barrels is like a drop in the ocean.
    3
  511.  @Cyrano1971  Barlekha, it is all perception. I request discuss a point, if you can or if you must. That is free speech and democracy we are privileged to enjoy. Attacking a person, thick headed etc., does not speak well of anybody. Reflect. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    3
  512.  @chakkamaheedhar2295  US after putting boots on ground have now taken back the tattered leather. Russia failed miserably in the 1980s leaving with boots left behind. It is easy for an Army to fight another Army. Army can never win a conflict against local armed guys especially in a foreign land and in a terrain like in Afghanistan. India will have to fight a different battle. A difficult diplomatic battle.
    3
  513. DK, an extract from a recent article of mine Here is a brief on all important political parties in India and their voter bases (in brackets): BJP (religion), Shiv sena (religion, dynasty), INC (Muslims(religion)), dynasty), Muslim Leagues(religion), Akali (religion), SP (clan, dynasty), BSP (Dalits), DMK, AIDMK (Dravidian Identity, parochial.), - JD(U), YSR Congress, TMC, Biju JD, are all parochial. AAP is a relatively new party and the Left as an ideology is almost extinct in India. Only a couple of parties from these have a national identity, so essential to grow, develop and be counted in the elite Nations of the world. All parties are obviously pursing diverse politics by cozying up to their respective voter bases. None of these parties are really “secular” unless “secular” refers to only wooing Muslims. So, secularism falls flat on its face even before Indian politics is discussed. Gaining and staying in power is the ultimate aim of all political dispositions. Except for two, the BJP and INC, no party can boast of a real national presence. While regional parties come to power in the federal states with a parochial agenda, it has always been a worry for India in the past few decades as to who will rule at the Centre. “It is time we Indians, stopped fooling ourselves with this misplaced sense of secularism. Except pity, all other emotions including tolerance are a two-way traffic, unless as they say one wants to “play politics”. But then on the final count in India, as elsewhere in democracies, politics is a game ultimately played with people’s emotions. The Nation does not progress on emotions. The delivery of progress and development to the people is the only long-term sustaining factor. Yet in a diverse and very big democracy like India, the Nation has to have an emotive rallying point. initiated by a majority of like minded people and carried by all citizens. A simplistic example is the way the nation is moved by cricket. For one of the only surviving ancient civilizations like India, falling back on the still valued ideals and ideas of those times is in no way anti “secular”, if it can unite a nation with a bit of tolerance and understanding from the “minority”, so to speak. “ Tailpiece: Again, I say… Leave I N C to professionals
    3
  514. Great. It makes me wonder what were the “people” (the society) doing in Manipur during the despicable act by a crowd? Balme everybody in the world. But blame the society and the people of Manipur too for not "thrashing" the perpetrator but taking videos and cheering. Does anybody feel we the people" are beyond reproach for such despicable acts in society. Tailpiece. Therein lies a truth that feel that all of us are the people are beyond blame for the ills in society whereas we should be the ones at the forefront to prevent such acts. Media too should not shield the society.
    3
  515.  @klakmin7937  The world of binary is over except in a computing ecosystem. The varied stance of India in tge different groupings is what will lend the world stability and lead it to peaceful coexistence in good time. At the end of it all India will be content and respected Nation may not be the richest. Enjoy…
    3
  516. In jest, to be read in the right spirit. A declaration by husband and wife: We do not do politics nor do we contest elections. Yet we are always fighting letting the children grow up (if at all) by themselves. Tailpiece: constantly “attacking” and “abusing” each other shows immaturity and a don’t care attitude for the Nation and its people. I do not see that India has done badly on the economic front despite COVID, cleaning up the banking sector, introducing tough reforms etc. these past years. Why are such matters not part of election rally speeches.
    3
  517. Yes. Yeddi son, a negative choice for the post in a faction ridden BJP in Karnataka. BJP will have to start from scratch as they are doing in other Southern states. Tailpiece: In the South Kerala and Karnataka state governance is on auto pilot anyway.
    3
  518. True. Well presented and required. But… Whether it is Nationalism, cultural appropriation or attacking the sentiments etc., “We the people” are at one end of it all. We must not demean the intellect of our people to decide for themselves what is right and what is not. Propaganda, appropriations, advertisements, coercion, blackmail, appeasements, concessions etc. have been part of Indian politics and palace intrigues for millennia. At the end of the day, the public, I suppose are aware enough to make their own decisions.
    3
  519.  @kartikprasad1044  Therin lies the real problem. The bureaucracy have insulated themselves from being held responsible with deftly introduced provisions and rules for self preservation. How many times, since Independence, have bureaucrats been held directly responsible for inefficient implementation? It is a close knit organization where everybody scratches each other’s backs.
    3
  520.  @KiranKumar-nb4nx  are they, really? Uhmmmm
    3
  521. It is a good thing that the Party is so transparent that the media is always aware what and why of things. Great for our democracy. Now don’ t tell the world that the Indian media is kept in the dark by Political parties. You can’t have it both ways.
    3
  522. Yes finally bring in politics, the inevitable? No. Could have done without it in this report so that the public takes the issue seriously. Once you involve politics the matter dissipates. Tailpiece. The story is incomplete without the response of the authorities. I hope aThe Print brings in the response. We are waiting.
    3
  523. Okay two battle grounds, different forces…. My take… It is a winners world…. When there is victory, it is the best strAtegy, team and all… Everything is wrong in defeat. Tailpiece: The difference in the two battlefields is that in politics winning is not the end but the beginning for the electorate but in sports winning is the end for team and fansl.
    3
  524. Good recall of Zia. But in the end of all of this, ironically, everybody in power in Pakistan seems to have actually abandoned Pakistan. Right? They were investing more on China, Afghanistan and India. Unfortunate. Tail piece: Ginger beer it would be!!! A “beer” with a pungent taste!!!
    3
  525. A good discussion….but has it come to this that Defence journalists and experts have to “teach” strategy and tactics to the Defence forces? Just to go and face the bullets in the jungles takes much more …. Be that it may…..what is more important is that the morale of the ARMED forces is maintained at a high level. The Nation - its people, journalists, administration et al - have a special responsibility to ensure that. That Morale is the most potent weapon with the Defence forces….more potent than the “favorite” of journalists - the drone. Do discuss that too…. Tailpiece: The man (women too, now) behind the machine is most important.
    3
  526. Are we missing a point in regard to migrant labour. The exodus for work is largely from the four big central Indian states – Bihar, UP, Orissa and W. Bengal) – lately from Assam as well. Why is it so even after 70 years of Independence? Is this a reflection on the lagging development in these states? India needs to reflect.
    3
  527.  @rohitsinghsharma5012  surely Rohit, no doubt quality lacks.. Hopefully the new education policy addresses this lag..
    3
  528. You missed the most important point of them all Swamy… By default or by design… more likely by design Only the wearer knows where the shoe pinches. There never was, is or will there be a utopia. It is never easy to Govern Nations – especially a large polity. Tailpiece: In this world it is not always what you see is what it is. Showing the other cheek was never an option. Admire the movie. Such stories are not dissected
    3
  529. A stitch in time saves nine
    3
  530.  @karthika560  uhmmm.... Maybe.. Let us watch
    3
  531. We make the man larger than life by making Modi the subject of discussion every time, from panchayat to international. In the event the real issues are forgotten. Not good for the Nation.
    3
  532. I wish the "news" is only reported and analysed. Journalists should not attempt back seat driving (Governance). We the People have elected a Government (s) for that. Tailpiece: Can the statements that the Government should do that or do this by journalists be classified as "fake news"?
    3
  533. In the light of the G20 Presidency of India and connected events etc. I find that in every and all press interactions the big Q is about the consensus statement on Russia-Ukraine conflict. Is THAT statement all that important in the context of a flailing global economy and other more important matters such as debt, health, climate etc. Will a solution to these issues be obtained by the evasive “joint statement”? Or will the war cease after the joint statement? In a world with multilateral leadership environment, as envisaged for the next century, joint statements are unimportant. Rest of the World has to keep moving. Tailpiece: The media should smell the coffee and not try and make this non issue as paramount to success just to bring in the word “failure”. And in the context of the European War, it is obvious even to the uninitiated that the solution lies elsewhere than in “joint statements”.
    3
  534. Very unfortunate. Should not have happened. Was her death because she was a Dalit or she was a woman or because she was economically challenged? The real real reason makes a huge difference in how we Indians behave in some sections of our society as also the media. Tailpiece: The real reason for the killing is important to dispense right justice.
    3
  535. As usual a very well presented (increasingly, so) programme. It is a vast subject, well handled. My two bit. There is no absolute in this world – (absolute may exist in the afterlife). As such there is no datum to measure equality and inequality in the material world - albeit reams of paper produced by the venerable social scientists etc. Only distributing the wealth created by some is not equality. AS I It is a vast subject. Tailpiece: Yes, equality has to be at an abstract level to ensure happiness and satisfaction for every one measured differently for different people. Yes, complicated.
    3
  536. @ yes. Chosen for capability from the ranks… not because he was a scion… chosen from the ranks with proven capabilities is the catch phrase Advani did not want to ostracise Patel and was concerned about Modi's lack of experience in government. Modi declined an offer to become Patel's deputy chief minister, telling Advani and Atal Bihari Vajpayee he was "going to be fully responsible for Gujarat or not at all". On 3 October 2001, Modi replaced Patel as Chief Minister of Gujarat with the responsibility of preparing the BJP for the upcoming December 2002 election.
    3
  537. @daniyalbbd5281  uhmmmm.., you parrot the same old myth.... Unfortunate .. the truth lies elsewhere and I know you know it
    3
  538.  @gouthamvidyasagar  sure...but they did not take over a party, ministership, lop etc overnight.. win from safe seat, go through the grind fir a decade, show your nettle and become whatever if you can... Not because you are somebody's daughter or grand daughter etc..
    3
  539. Between a rock and a had place: Lives or livelihoods? An uncomfortable debate. The only solution going ahead is to have more people who work for a living than those who vote for a living.
    3
  540. Nobody can ask this question in China, where I suppose there is a sort of real dictatorship and this Q can be asked of the Chinese people. Just saying.
    3
  541. I wonder whether lancet considered these peculiar social fabric in India. It is a medical journal. Right? Keep educating the public...they are the key to arrest the pandemic.
    3
  542. “Not necessarily a good way” was a rank give away! Not an impartial media after all? Lest probably some peers may not like the comment?
    3
  543.  @Vizorfam  DB I endorse that SG has come into his own and exudes class. I would not have said that of him before he started The Print. The print has varied programmes with the intention of disseminating information rather than trying to influence. Having said that, in my comment I did not mean that the media should just keep asking questions for the the sake of exhibiting “free speech”. In China nobody can ask Qs, so the Govt goes ahead and does what it wants. China is far ahead than many of the advanced democracies in its economic outlook. The other extreme is excessive freedom when nothing constructive can happen as questions are raised and protests are held for anything and everything. I wonder whether the Nation is aware that India has a reputation of being a laggard democracy, with no progress as it should have We do not want to be another China without any freedom, so to speak. Neither do we want to be a democracy where only questions are raised.to impede progress. Media has to always present a balanced view. The Print is close to doing it.
    3
  544. Greetings to the two media stalwarts, on one stage so to speak, who I have followed these past two decades. You are the best bet to address, my question. There was a time in the 1960s, my school days, when the refrain was “Oh if it is in the papers (Newspapers) then it must be true”. Alas! We can’t sat the same about the media these days – the reasons for this media decadence and reduced confidence in it are many and recognized. What can the media do to regain the lost confidence?
    3
  545. There is a feeling in a very large section of the Indian population, that some farmers and some politicians have AS USUAL turned the representations of farmers into nothing more than political gimmick. What with talks still open and the judiciary also involved in the matter, is there a genuine reason for prolonging this “agitation”? Who represents the voice of this section of Indians who see a deja Vu in these shenanigans from all sides? Agitation-failed talks- violent agitation- casualties- political parties come for photo ops and In front of the camera with the sole aim of garnering votes. In the past five decades we have seen this game played over many times. Frustrated. Tail piece: There are “genuine demands” from the unorganized sector, from laborers, from industrial workers, from the informal economy, from MSMEs, from the industry, from airline operators and from just about all and sundry. At some point we have to get real and move on.
    3
  546. Absolutely on the money. Among the many colonial archaic laws to be revise, the 1861 (OMG 1861!) should be done yesterday. Unfortunately I suspect that more than 70% of Indians are unaware of this travesty. Congrats for bringing it up.
    3
  547. I wonder how uncontrolled tests will help in employment, when one could contact the virus on way back home from tests!, some planning there required. Can somebody throw some torchlight on these widespread uncontrolled tests
    3
  548. Extremely informative….knowledge is power.
    3
  549. Good analysis. Yes, the BJP is playing its cards to implement strategies in electoral politics. The Hindutva or rather “anti-Hindutva” and” secular” are no more trump cards for the opposition parties. The refrain is if political parties can be parochial (TMC, SS, DMK, TRS etc..), religion based (Muslim leagues, Akali etc..), Clan based (Yadavs, Gujjars etc.) and Dalit based (BSP etc.) or Dynastic (INC,SS, Yadavs, DMK, TRS etc..) why can’t there be a party which is “Hindu” based? What is the difference in any of these approaches? In electoral democracies every political party will attempt to create a strong faithful voter base. THAT is a natural process. In such an environment it is difficult to separate the wrong from the right in politics. Tailpiece: There never was, is or will be a Utopia (Ramrajya).The electorate has realized that Governance is all about the Nation to deliver Roti, Kapda and Makkan to its people. All else are distractions. Economy and development (Ease of living) will be key. In order to further preserve Indian democracy, the opposition parties have to change tactics and strategies. We fervently hope that they will do it. Welcome to the changing face of Indian politics.
    3
  550. Convenient journalism!!!! Tail piece: In India, where 30%. popular votes gets 350 seats in LS, what is real majority is debatable. Also, reforms are either good or bad. If it is good for the Nation alll arms of democracy, including the “all knowing” media,have to rally behind it. But unfortunately it is opportunism all around, including the media. Sad
    3
  551. Right for the media...presenting the good and the bad with equal poise and tone. An example for other anchors of all types...
    3
  552. At last. Yes, there are some things in this world, once done re very difficult to undo. I suspect in respect to our Nation, there are many things to be undone by the Governments. Religion and methods are not among them. Tailpiece: Whose Nation is it anyway?
    3
  553. DK, while governence can be improved etc…. If “Politics and politiking” changes whither democracy? Especially very diverse, large and multiparty democracies?
    3
  554.  @iki740  Loki, greetings. I appreciate your response. Please note that my assessment is of a media over half a century, whenTV, digital media etc. was absent and to this day when there is so much “news” out there in various avatars. Today everybody and anybody with a smart phone is a “media” person. Yes, if you consider the sum total of what comes into your smart phone and if the fake can be discerned truthfully by the news seeker, you have a point. Also, I said the same media house putting out both aspects - done and not done. Not about one sided presentations. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    3
  555. Was it Mamata or CM of Bengal who skipped the meet. It it is Mamata then federal democracy is safe - individuals do not matter. But if it is CM of WB who skipped the meet.. then it is an undemocratic act which needs to be condemned. Will the media explicitly condemn it? Tailpiece: The media in a democracy is NEVER impartial. It is always loaded against the Government of the day.
    3
  556. Mr PK is wrong….intention is not material here…it is a reform for sges. What party of mettle will stand to see its rival(s) prosper and itself decline? Why not Me? The age-old Q of an envious person. Hatred always accompanies envy. Tailpiece: Let us have some erudite discussions on the pros and cons of ONOE, please
    3
  557. Were not Indians always indifferent towards corruption? Ever willing to grease the palm of willing officials to GET things done, faster and on the sly (even when right things were to be done).? Traffic violations is another well known area. Why the change in the narrative now as if it is something new? Tailpiece: Look at things as they are and NOT as what YOU want it to be.
    3
  558. When the LAC is discussed between the PM of India and the POTUS, it is amply clear that the recent PLA maneuvers along its border with India is part of a larger game. It is very easy for either side along the LAC to up the ante at any time. Believe me!
    3
  559. To hold meetings is the prerogative of the ministers. We can’t fault that. We can fault policies and decisions. The “dissection” has by design or default leading comments, ( should they or should they not, etc.) though the stated aim was otherwise. The Print can do better. Views are personal
    3
  560.  @TheFilhal  yes. I have. But I do not discuss with people who get personal and call names. Continue to enjoy.... It is Holi.
    3
  561.  @TheFilhal  it is obvious your argument is weak, the moment you got personal. Enjoy... All the best
    3
  562. Can we expect the bjp’s presser in response, in keeping with The Prints neutral stand? Just asking
    3
  563.  @fazalurahman1308 you have a point
    3
  564. The problem is with everybody else except the SELF - right? We can never confront any PANDEMIC by looking only elsewhere for faults. On my way from the airport on 26 Dec 2020, after spending over an in the USA, and seeing the plight of NY area in person, I was appalled by how the people in our country were taking it easy. It was as if nothing had changed since I left India in September 2019. All shops open. 50% were not wearing a mask, 30% were wearing it on their chin. Later in the week, out to buy rations, when I asked my vegetable shop fellow why he was not wearing a mask, he replied “Corona has gone, so why wear a mask?”. It was not as if the administration had said so. Because, on the same day while we were driving in our own vehicle, with closed windows and ac on, my wife and I were fined Rs 350/- for not wearing masks inside the car – I was told that it was mandatory. Tailpiece: The problem in our country is not the rules. It is the implementation of the rules by an inadequate, overworked police and paramilitary on a people whose standards self-discipline is abysmal. Let us admit it and strive to improve. I request the media too to highlight this aspect.
    3
  565. The Labour going back has definitely been a communication problem. When I speak to some builders, they have told me that many of these workers were being cared for but they wanted to go home as they were unsure of the future. A psychological issue rather than a material problem....yes, a dropped catch. But, I feel we have now to tighten our fielding, rather than rue the catch as unlike the cricket semi final, we HAVE to win THIS game
    3
  566. I wonder how this will work….PK as CEO. Uhmmmm…… The best formula would be (((4M-3G) + (G21 - G16)) + Local leaders.) Tailpiece: So, is the aim of the congress to only win elections? There is a Nation fellas.
    3
  567. The most striking feature of today’s very impressive RD parade was that the Supreme Commander of the Indian Armed Forces (The President) took the Salute smartly (army like) without twitching or swaying, standing erect for the whole duration of 50 odd minutes of the marching contingents filing past. A first for a President. Tailpiece: Watch it again.
    3
  568. There is a feeling in a very large section of the Indian population, that some farmers and some politicians have AS USUAL turned the representations of farmers into nothing more than political gimmick. What with talks still open and the judiciary also involved in the matter, is there a genuine reason for prolonging this “agitation”? Who represents the voice of this section of Indians who see a deja Vu in these shenanigans from all sides? Agitation-failed talks- violent agitation- casualties- political parties come for phot ops and I front of the camera with the sole aim of garnering votes. In the past five decades we have seen this game played over many times. Frustrated. Tail piece: There are “genuine demands” from the unorganized sector, from laborers, from industrial workers, from the informal economy, from MSMEs, from the industry, from airline operators and from just about all and sundry. At some point we have to get real and move on.
    3
  569. Unlike poetry, truth will always exist in the past
    3
  570. In bad taste. We the people only want economic progress. All else in society will fall in place by itself - roti, kapda, makkan. The parliamentarians, once elected should mostly concentrate on doing their job inside the parliament and in their respective constituencies. Tailpiece: Balme games reek of ineptitude and inefficiency… especially from very very senior leaders …. From whichever party.
    3
  571. India would have done better with all the warts - read, swing - if they had had at least one practice 3 day game before this all important one-off.
    3
  572.  @darthludicrous99  Thanks Darth for the inputs. I respect your views. Enjoy. Take care
    3
  573. This thing about Gandhiji, ahimsa, nonviolence, Indian independence etc. has intrigued me since my school days. I have yet not been able to comprehend that showing the other cheek when you get slapped on one, is a nonviolent act. It actually invites more violence. The World, (who is the “world”?) celebrates Gandhiji’s nonviolence, but I still am dumb and miss the point. Have those who talk of Gandhiji’s nonviolence, “ideals” and eulogize Gandhiji, especially those from the Western Nations, really abjured violence? How has the pursuit of this concept of ahimsa and nonviolence helped India’s progress? Just saying niceties in diplomatic parleys is not the same thing as doing ii that way. Maybe, I am missing a lot somewhere. I will keep looking. Tailpiece: It is a moot point whether the British left India because of Gandhiji or they left the way they departed, because of Gandhiji. There is an old saying in Malayalam, loosely translated reads like “You can’t subdue a raging bull (enemy) by whispering the Vedas into its ears” Disclaimer: No Indian who had thoughts of independence in the decades before 1947, is irrelevant. This is only a point of view and I am not going to go to the end of the Earth arguing for it; to each her own.
    3
  574. DK, we have been saying this for ages…. Oh! Yet, the INC / the Gandhis (And Vadras) refuse to see it. Intriguing. I am but a common man. You are a political journalist (If I may) who knows a thing or two. Yet, the Gandhis don’t get it. Yes, “sacrifice one last time”. Rightly put. India does need a strong and erudite opposition to appropriately keep in check a strong and erudite Government. Tailpiece: Rahul Gandhi “entered” politics in 2004 as part of and virtual leader of a century old political party. Arvind Kejariwal “entered” politics with a brand new party in 2012. Knowledge and political acumen or its absence, as the case be, is all too evident for the Nation to see…. Just saying. You can make somebody an ordinary manager; but you can’t make nobody a leader. Again just saying.
    3
  575. What is freedom of religion and individual rights when religion itself binds you and tells you what to wear, what to eat, sees women different from men etc…. It is akin to political parties who do not practice democracy within wanting to defend Nation’s democracy and constitution. A paradox par redemption. Let us grow out of archaic shackles. Tailpiece: It is time to redefine methods ordained in religions….all religions.
    3
  576.  @ringan1287  HaHa! Same story. . “Blame it on Rio” (an old movie) - BTW way, I am from my generation too!!! Enjoy; stay safe.
    3
  577. Thank god for Some mercies, real democracy is back in India…. Gandhi (Mahatma) style
    3
  578. Just can’t keep away from cricket? SG. Love it… cricket and the programme. Tailpiece: Power consumes everything. More destructive than fire.
    3
  579. Media seems to be revelling in the mechanisation of elections by “professional” schemers like Mr. Kishore. I thought in a democracy, aided my the media etc., the political leaders directly feel the pulse of the electorates by through the elected representives ( and those who wish to be elected) rather the employ” professionals” to do the mathematics in “cast(e)ing the votes etc. A big shame to democracy including the media who score the music for this “dance”. Tailpiece. Should the media treat people like Mr P.Kishore as celebrities or expose them for what they are? Let the people decide.
    3
  580. All very well. Should the media also play up the “politics” of politics, (as defined by the heading and most contents of this show) rather than other socio-economic factors necessary for progress? Be the leader..
    3
  581. Has anything ever happened in India without controversies (media’s halwa). Fed up. For Christs sake it is not controversy…it is some people who disagree with parts of a law…. There is a difference
    3
  582. Will the women’s commission swing into action? Just asking.:) Tailpiece: This is what I had written in the comments section a few days back “The electorate has realized that Governance is all about the Nation to deliver Roti, Kapda and Makkan to its people. All else are distractions. Economy and development (Ease of living) will be key. In order to further preserve Indian democracy, the opposition parties have to change tactics and strategies. We fervently hope that they will do it”. And Lo behold! This happens. I never intended THIS type of change in tactics. Does this reflect the shallowness of the opposition.? I dare say it does. And THAT, my fellow Indians , is our bane.
    3
  583. While in all other democracies people go out and vote, in India the electorate cast(e) their votes!!!
    3
  584. @ too late for what… to say that temples were demolished… ai am not asking for evacuation…only acknowledgement as fellow humans and fellow Indians… just an “Yes”
    3
  585.  @antonyjohnpeter549  Same as what people were doing when India was invaded and when India was colonized…. Failed to put up collective resistance
    3
  586. Best solution is that in the spirit of secularism, the Muslims should admit that mosques in India were built over demolished temples, wherever. Thereafter it should not matter who prays for the Nation in those places …. Everybody is after all human
    3
  587. DK, why don’t we call out the politicians and their mouthpieces making irrelevant points, especially during build up to the elections… with aim to mislead the public?Media should concentrate on policies past, present and future that will empower the people of India that is Bharath, The the politicians Will fall in to place when their gibberish is ignored. Tailpiece Can I expect The print to take a lead?
    3
  588. It is worth examining if one state, Kerala, could manage their guest workers (as called by the STATE and wrongly referred to by all else as migrants) fairly well, why did other states fail.
    3
  589. Akshay Dixit not a lot of difference bail and jail - just one alphabet!
    3
  590. All about politics DK. Nothing about development and vision from the “strong” opposition. Power or National? Where is opposition going? Whose Nation is it anyway.
    3
  591. Why is this National news. There are very many others too who are educating many children. Such political shenanigans by the media can be avoided. The people and media of our great Nation should talk less of politics and more of that affect the real daily lives.
    3
  592.  @GabbarWaldHariSingh  MH. You have your views and probably your reasons. Respect that. I speak from a position where I have been actively involved in both the games for over half a century. There is no more elitist games. There may be elitist entertainment. Whether elitism is desirable, I can’t say. But elitism will be part of a democracy and free market.
    3
  593. Taking nothing away from Ms Jacinda Arden, let us admit that it is easier to lead a small band of homogenous people. What we are doing here is just what my barber told me once. I am bald with sparse hair on the rim. I asked my barber as I had just 5% of hair as compared with many others, I should be charged accordingly less. He told me that the count is not of hairs but of heads. It is OK for him but not for countries!!!!!
    3
  594. Very true. “Jihad” should be eliminated at its source… Just saying.
    3
  595. Stake holders must be surely criminals..haha
    3
  596. When the dust settles down, it will be realized that the “tour of duty” is a good programme to enable the youth of the Nation and may be detrimental to the efficiency of the Armed Forces. It is damning to see how political parties do not see beyond the party and are ready to do anything, even destroy the fabric of society, for power and wealth? Hopefully the Nation will one day, soon, see through these machinations of vested interests. Tailpiece: Gotta see how a balance in the Agnipath can be stuck. May require mid term course corrections. And one more point….. the great thing about the laggard Indian democracy is that for every good leader you get an equally good misleader. Validates Newton’s first law of motion
    3
  597.  @durranishaheer1538  hi Durani, Bhai; Firstly I have not told you what my religion is. You assume. Secondly, I said accept other religions for what they are, accepting does not mean becoming a follower. If some religions worship idols accept it and say so. That does not mean you have to worship an idol. If the law of the land allows some practices, accept it. You don’t have to necessarily practice it. And lastly what is religious freedom and peace if a religion itself is discriminatory and regimented within. But that is ok as long as one religion does not call a person from another religion a non believer. Love means accepting the other for what they are.
    3
  598. Most welcome. Join the gang. Indians will definitely support those who “DO” for the Nation. For The Whole of the Nation without fear or favor. Tailpiece: we look forward to all opposition political parties echoing AK. The central Government is already on the job of making India No. 1 by 2047.
    3
  599. A good effort to recall these leaders who endeavoured to give selfless and quality service to India. They don’t make such moulds anymore. we need to remember them. My two bit. India is a vast country. People of India, in large numbers, have become more informed and involved in National matters in only the last decade or so , since the proliferation of the digital and social media. For most Indians in the South and East of our great Nation, for instance J. Ram and YB Chanvan were non entities, unfortunately. Tailpiece: I joined an elite and world famous institution, in India, in 1969. There were teenagers there from all over India. A majority of those from the North and central India, for instance, were unaware about the different states in the South. For them all South Indians were thambis! So too with states from NE.
    3
  600. A very good programme usually well presented. I have an observation in regard to this programme. While referring to use of oxygen cylinders in Congo, Pia made a remark '".... Like in India during..... ". This was totally not required in the context to convey anything specific. Such casual statements are best avoided.
    3
  601. What is happening now, incursions and excursions et al, between India and China has happened many times earlier; it is just that this time because of technology and increase in international interest on China, the game is being played out louder in the media. The fact is, nothing about LAC has really changed since 1947, as the exact line of LAC has never been agreed by the two parties. Using this as an excuse, China often tries to grab unoccupied territories (patrolled by both etc…) wherever possible and whenever it suits them, along the LAC. The primary intend is nothing more than to keep India on a leash and ensure it is not a competition in South Asia. It is also sad that two Nations, even after wars and lengthy talks, have not been able to resolve it for decades. This happens when one or both parties do not want a resolution. It is abundantly clear here as to who does not want the issue resolved. It is fallacious to expect that, this issue will get resolved any time soon. China has to be brought to the negotiating table, hopefully one day in the near future and define the IB (not LAC). It is imperative that we maintain a strong Defence Force and better strategic stance (not backing down) when we go to the negotiating table, China will win the day, if we as a Nation divert most of our energies here rather than on the economic and societal issues which are more fundamental and enduring to a better future for India. Unfortunately in a geo-political polity we can’t chose our neighbours. Like Snehesh (The Print) often says, War is not a solution while it can extend the problem.
    3
  602. An "activist" is not beyond reproach. All novice "activists" are usually propelled by some actuators for own agenda. Tail piece: If the farmers were really being treated in a inhuman manner, rest assured the whole Nation would have rallied behind them.
    3
  603.  @brainiac1595  Government regulation is required…Not political regulation….. like in Russia and China…
    3
  604.  @Sunil5291  Sunil, The SC did pass some orders which some farmers “rejected.” Anyway, which democratic Government anywhere in the world at any time have had all the people’s trust at any time (except probably in a wat scenario). In a democracy everybody will always have some grievances. That is the nature of the beast. All democratic Governments do “lip service” and everybody’s grievances will never end. Also if we expect the Judiciary to step in everywhere, we might as well hand over the legislature and the executive too… may be Defence also.
    3
  605. The Pakistan Army is formidable etc… and everything else you said, SG.. It’s problem is it does not think like an army but like a government….Therein lies a deficiency which is always ripe for India to exploit…. A lot said here for those who understand. Tailpiece: All said and done Pak army on the whole is NOT better than Indian Army as a wholesome fighting force…. 65 notwithstanding…they are not a walkover either
    3
  606. As usual a good discussion on arithmetic. Don’t you think the electorate in India generally are moving more towards governance than other criteria for voting? Tailpiece: A wish maybe…. But changing maybe…. A point for discussion?
    3
  607. No sense in this programme. Unhelpful media. As the heading suggests, does The Print want preferential treatment for artistes, media persons etc?
    3
  608. We surely have to be vary of this new variant. The onus of fighting any onslaught from Omicron has to lie with the people and how they behave. The public have to take responsibility and not target the system (Government) just because we are a democracy. Governments do not have a panacea against such Pandemic. Tailpiece: We the people of India (and the media) have to start taking responsibilities and not mindlessly lay the reasons for all ills at the feet of Governments. And yes, we should all not become scientists and experts.
    3
  609. There just is no purpose in the “liberals” boiling the ocean. That energy and time can be put to other productive activities.
    3
  610. Is ignoring nine summons from the ED, in a case his party (AAP) and his Dy CM is in jail ( bail denied by various courts including the SC) morally right and politically a good democratic practice?
    3
  611. Sure, the farmers deserve to celebrate as they have "won". Tailpiece: The bigger question being sidestepped by mainstream media, experts and economists is "Has the Indian Nation won?" Just saying
    3
  612.  @Vizorfam  depends on who are categorized as “experts”. All governments, all over the world, have their own experts to advice. And listening does not mean that the Governments Have to do what all experts say. Experts work in their domain of expertise. Governments have to look at collateral effects too. A bit complicated. Matters of perception… so DB, enjoy. Experts are mushrooming by the dozen and most have an agenda…. Need to be careful
    3
  613.  @sudarshanramaswamy7529  and the largest debt for any country
    3
  614. Why do the media encourage Politicians to discuss individuals and concessions rather than policies and implementation aspects of development in detail. Media is equally responsible for the low level of politics largely practiced in India. A shame.
    3
  615. He had / has more to offer! Travelled with him in economy class some time in the late 1990s.
    3
  616. SAARC is done and dusted. How, what and when has any SA Nation benefited from SAARC - in any manner except the rhetorics. Tailpiece: Time is at a premium and should not be spent chasing ghosts.
    3
  617.  @agytjax  True… argyle…my point is those involved in building the Nation, including small businesses should pay up and learn to report in time…. If 10 can do it, 1000s can do it…. I have been watching for five years as an involved party…. Those who mollycoddle the public are adopting the lazy path Stay well…
    3
  618. Preparing for entertainment (show) rather than substance… why are the media not been condemning this mayhem,in parliament since decades. Is the media , who do not want to be suppressed, playing a constructive role in Nation building? Have they ever? Introspect. Let us ask for fruitful discussions in parliament. Rather insist. We do not want wishywashy contested politics for drama and the media TRP
    3
  619. Slip of tongue
    3
  620. When the media, opposition, "experts", activists and about everybody (including here) repeatedly say "Modi" instead of "GoI", do we take it that 'We the people" are so obsessed with personalities that we prefer dictatorship over democracy. I make the statement, not in defence of any INDIVIDUAL, I make the statement in defence of democracy... Media....please...., opposition please, “Experts” please, activists please, opinion writers please – do the right thing for the Nation
    3
  621. From the frying pan into the fire? Do you sincerely expect improvements. Look at the resins for slow progress. The main reason is that all institutions and states take sides and work at cross purposes never looking beyond the tips of flat noses. No party has a magic wand or the Midas touch.
    3
  622. There are comments that India’s foreign policy is in a challenging situation. Running a country, internally and externally, is a perpetual challenge…especially a democratic Nation the size of India. Opinions and views will differ depending on information available to and intention of the proponent. Presentations such as this are efforts to bolster the former (information). I like SG’s take that let us not be subsumed by unproductive discussions on internal politics. Tailpiece: It is important that each individual forms his/her views on matters. And … After recent developments in Pakistan, What is Imran’s current locus standi?
    3
  623.  @ibadurrehman5764  You are absolutely right Ibadur. Aurangzeb, Tipu etc… were KINGS. But then in my school days, about more half a century ago, it was them who were in our text books and not leaders like Savarkar, Balgangadhar T, Sardar Patel etc. THAT was the point I am making, with malice to none. Did we have our priorities right then? We need not have glorified our errant “Kings”. Also, we should also included and laid empanadas on the life and works of great Indian fighters like Kunjali marikkar, Azad, Patel, Savarkar etc…
    3
  624. Not nana but dada:) I suppose Shekhar’s Malayalam is a goner but I wonder why Pia’s Hindi is not up there
    3
  625. Is ignoring nine summons from the ED, in a case his party (AAP) and his Dy CM is in jail ( bail denied by various courts including the SC) morally right and politically a good democratic practice?
    3
  626. A lot of facts ignored...poor show. While we are at it....here is the larger picture It is all about power and money. Principles and integrity are thrown to the high velocity cyclones, plenty of them blow inland these days, by all political parties and their crony “experts”. These politicians and “experts” nuance their utterances to seemingly oppose introduction of reforms by present Governments, previously touted by them in the past as imperatives for growth. What a shame that politics and ”expert” opinions have fallen to such abysmal depths. It is not new but something that has been happening for a few decades now. The fault lies at two places. First with “We the People of India” a vast majority of who close their eyes to this travesty. Second, with the high voltage media who are either scared of the unknown or have vested interests in not highlighting such issues – a blatant dereliction of duty by the media. Disclaimer: The comment is a general observation and Not directed at The Print.
    3
  627. Final whistle? Lot of play still left! Nothing will be over soon. And expect a lot of shouting.
    3
  628. Swamy, do I hear a condescending tone for the terrorists a la NC chief, FA?
    3
  629. All religious texts have flaws because they were written / compiled by humans in a time and space much different from the present. While preserving the ideals (mind, thought etc..) the methods (visuals) have to change. Respective religious leaders fail in their duty to bring this up and make corrections. In the circumstance the media (as usual, the know all) assume the responsibility and do it all wrong Religious harmony, I suppose simply is that each religion recognizes each of the other religions and its GOD(s). Period. For a multidimensional (religion) society to be harmonious all religious leaders should periodically come together on a common platform and proclaim “Your God(s) is as good as mine; your path to reach him is as good as mine”. Period. If this is done in a society no politician can use religion to garner votes. Tail piece: Any other definition of religious harmony (majority, minority, appeasement et al..)is only for exploitation and fail to address oneness of humanity with many GODs. Harmony does not flow in one direction – it is multidirectional.
    3
  630. "We can complain about undermining of institutions, misuse of agencies, discriminatory laws, use of sedition, rail-roading of legislations". Misleading, unfortunately! Media should not be only about complaining. Poor show Also this show is proof enough that in India democracy is intact and freedom of speech is as free as cab be.
    3
  631. Great DK on Politics and mafia. Tailpiece: Yes, “All governments rest on opinion”; opinion(s) count… as votes based on opinions are to be counted for a win. AND A major doubt: Is it because the judiciary takes over the work of executive often the executive extend a helping hand to judiciary by occasionally doing their job. Just asking.
    3
  632. If you don’t do anything, “nothing being done’. If something is being done, it always has a motive. Right. Tailpiece: Does the media too always work with a Motive? A million bitcoin question.
    3
  633. When an economy is growing – which can happen only with wealth creation, seen in communist China too - some misuse of power and money can’t be avoided. Any let up here will be exploited by those interested. I see here in the USA big donors to political parties openly curry favours from the Government and are given. For instance, ever wonder what Elon Musk is doing? And the Crypto Industry? This matter about Adani group is not earth shattering in any way. The Indian story, if anything, will only strengthen in the mid and long term. The danger is from those revealing inside information Rest easy Enjoy, smile, laugh
    3
  634. SG a good presentation. But tell me which bill presented by the Government (except increasing MP salary etc.) is without vehement opposition from thee “opposition”? Basic… this (including comments by “experts”) is all about power and not really about power. Tailpiece: mindless Subsidies and freebies (offered by political parties and underwritten by tax payers )are pulling the economy down…especially the distribution of power for power!!!! If I may.
    3
  635. Do not expect anything consistent from any top nation in the world today. Most consistent big National today is India….. I believe except for BD and Pakistan all countries (including Nepal and China) want to befriend India…. Any comments from Swamy?
    3
  636. Deja Vu ! We have heard these for decades . As a rule the opposition cries fowl of all government policies. That sums up our laggard democracy. No maturity, no logic, no “constructive criticism” - just plain and simple playing to the galleries... a shame Whose country is it anyway?
    3
  637. Good to learn the medical emergencies have been handled successfully.
    3
  638. Pegasus in India. Another Tom and Jerry cartoon. Everybody (including the media) will enjoy it until the release of the next cartoon. You can neither kill Tom or Jerry… Democracy for you.
    3
  639. They could give it to a court and demand action. Such matters can't be handled by "media reports". The holier than thou attitude of the media is self defeating as you get "all sorts of media" these days. Let us not have one more cat and mouse game initiated by the some "foreign media". Our media should not play second fiddle and halt Parliamentary proceedings, thus attacking democracy. phones
    3
  640. .26 % is 43 positive cases with no traceable contacts vs 16000 tests
    3
  641.  @Cri-cater  A poor argument. May be a reason for INC failings . Enjoy. Forward Ho!
    3
  642.  @akshayagrawal5114  sure,. Is it same as saying I feel like coming home…when Kerala elected him….etc. etc. if you are comparing him with Modi you are making the same mistakes that the INC (you?) is making….. He has to come up for what he is….. Smell the coffee… I am not a fan of anybody or a detractor of somebody…. It is a comment from a citizen for whatever it is worth….
    3
  643.  @akshayagrawal5114  daily 10 Km chalta hum, golf kelta hun aur saal mein ek baar Scuba driving bhi karta hun. Ah aur, mein patla hum aur sirf 64 kg vajan. Enjoy.
    3
  644.  @Vizorfam  Agree… But, AAP will take a while to reach National level. India cannot lose anymore years of development and need progressive policies now and only now.
    3
  645. Rishi for PM is following a path much like the Indian victory over Pakistan yesterday, in a group match of the ongoing T20 World Cup - From a point of no rerun, so to speak. Could be the best bet for British economy, hopefully.
    3
  646. @HT. This is a sadistic ally painful way of presenting news. Our time is at a premium.We, the fans may avoid HT if you show no consideration for our time.
    3
  647. I am reminded of a Shakespearean comedy " Much ado about nothing" India is a vibrant and super active democracy. Anything and everything that happens in this Nation will have a political hue. Ask the media stalwarts, they feed on it. The ruling party as well as the opposition will constantly play games with people’s sentiments. That is the lot of Indian democracy. Yes, finally the people will choose. That is another story. Sentiment is a type of illness, a medical condition. Like the ember it will come to life when fanned and die away when no attention is paid to it. So, with this issue of Parliament inauguration and many, many such matters in our chequered history since Independence. Memory is short-lived, whether of the people or political parties who will oppose a matter while out of power which they had advocated when in power. The Nation sees all this like watching a soap opera. This new parliament thing is but another such instant. The Nation will move on... Parliament will function in its new place. Governments will come and governments will go, the soap opera will roll on. Whatever, there is a new India, which hopefully have realized this hollow games. The New India will move on. It HAS to move on to survive. Forward Ho!
    3
  648. True… very true
    3
  649. Fantastic…. Name:) I suppose the “United opposition” is also aware that elections is not an end and there is a Nation INDIA to be governed without discrimination of any kind….. no appeasement….and reservations etc based purely on economic status….. 75 years of discrimination is enough….. do not let another class system emerge. Tailpiece: whose Nation is it anyway? Just asking
    3
  650. Smell the coffee. Back in the late 1980s, I was posted in a government institution. In those days serial Ramayana was screened for an hour every Sunday morning. During times of heavy workload, because of the added work schedules, the institution worked on Sundays of some weeks. On those Sundays, I recall, the staff wanted an hour’s break between 09.30 – 11.00 AM to watch the serial Ramayana. I believe the whole nation came to a standstill during the screening. BJP etc. was not even on the horizon during that period. All said and done, the “Ram Mandir” in Ayodhya will be a boost to the hospitality, travel and tourism industries while boosting the State and local economies. Tailpiece: The stock value of L&T who constructed the Ram Temple, has almost doubled in the last one year.
    3
  651. How about “lying” about quarantine….does no vaccine mean no qauaratine too. I do not see any controversy here.
    3
  652. In a war situation, targeting enemy supply lines is par for the course. So then, what is new?
    3
  653. Fantastic…. I suppose the “United opposition” is also aware that elections is not an end and there is a Nation INDIA to be governed without discrimination of any kind….. no appeasement….and reservations etc based purely on economic status….. 75 years of discrimination is enough….. do not let another class system emerge. Tailpiece: whose Nation is it anyway? Just asking
    3
  654. Selective journalism here
    3
  655. Why do we need a report on a minute to minute position on the President? Is the media hyperventilating?
    3
  656. This is a uncalled for comparison. Under N Rao, MM had a free run. He excelled. Under UPA, MM was a dummy PM. Unfortunate.
    3
  657. C295 is not a fighter aircraft… it is a transport aircraft
    3
  658. Is ignoring nine summons from the ED, in a case his party (AAP) and his Dy CM is in jail ( bail denied by various courts including the SC) morally right and politically a good democratic practice?
    3
  659. Great academic coverage… would it have helped if the quality of foreign investments (outgo) by India (like for energy related assets etc…) were also covered? Also the foreign exchange reserves are meant for use during emergencies like now when the value of dollar is skyrocketing, renminbi is being devalued and generally all currencies are down in relation to dollar. Without the full explaination, especially by the economy expert of The Print, the presentation looks like an agenda based effort, though I want to believe it is not - by The Print. Expect better quality being an ardent follower of The Print. Thank you
    3
  660. Agnipath. A unknown territory. We the people of India hope that the decision for “tour of duty” is deliberate with extensive brainstorming and active study by the Services HQ. We are a democracy and the elected Government has the right to shape the Armed Forces. We are here wading into unchartered waters which will have far reaching consequences for the sovereignty of India. Efficiency of the Armed Forces is not measured by pension bills; all the more so when Defence civilians take away more than 50% of the Defence pension outlay for a strength less than 50% of veterans. Tailpiece: Does the Nation Nation have a right to the study after which this decision has been arrived. That, I suppose is an obligation by the Government to the people and a right of the electo
    3
  661. Agnipath. A unknown territory. We the people of India hope that the decision for “tour of duty” is deliberate with extensive brainstorming and active study by the Services HQ. We are a democracy and the elected Government has the right to shape the Armed Forces. We are here wading into unchartered waters which will have far reaching consequences for the sovereignty of India. Efficiency of the Armed Forces is not measured by pension bills; all the more so when Defence civilians take away more than 50% of the Defence pension outlay for less than 50% of veterans. Tailpiece: Does the Nation Nation have a right to the study after which this decision has been arrived. That, I suppose is an obligation by the Government to the people and a right of the electo
    3
  662. When even a few Indians do not want a strong and progressive India, what can we say about China and Pakistan… futile discussions
    2
  663. Irony personified. A democratic Nation allowing the celebration of assassinating a democratically elected leader of the largest democratic republic of the world, speaks poorly of the democracy, governance and leadership in Canada. A bad leader and example of the free world. A shame to the spirit of democracy. Tailpiece: Well, this drama is local politics…… Has India crossed the halfway mark as the leader of the free world. Looks like.
    2
  664.  @Opp_Man  Friend... Why do you say that? What has any government to do with it? I grew up in a Islam neighbourhood in the 50s and 60s. I know what I am saying. The problem is US. You and me and the religious leaders. Religion is NOT a set of customs... It is much greater.
    2
  665.  @Opp_Man  Not in religion. But customs, yes. There is a difference. Customs are wrongly and wilfully passed on, by those within the religion, who want to exploit, as a religious practice. This happens in ALL religions. Some fight, some succumb to the exploits. It is your choice.
    2
  666. Blame games or a lame game, the electorate will decide. We have to accept that this Government is breaking new paths towards progress and development. We can’t be a forever subsidy Nation. Also we have to first create wealth to be able to distribute the same. Forget political games. It is all about money. This is the twenty first century. Time for a change of narrative. Tailpiece: Sometimes as they say, we have to give the devil its due.
    2
  667. As an afterthought to my earlier comment - does this suggestion of “resetting politics” reek of a similarity to Gandhiji’s reaction to the khilafat movement of the pre - independence 1900s. This aspect of mixing religion with politics is not a recent phenomenon. It is as old as advent of religions into the sub-continent, centuries ago. If we do not accept that as a Nation, we can’t even make a beginning to work together for economic progress.
    2
  668. Good coverage of vaccines and prognosis including in US and Europe. Post 2nd wave We the people of India have played up. Proud of India. Excellent commentary on India-Afghanistan-Pakistan conundrum of the USA and the worldview post US defeat in Afghanistan. Well done.
    2
  669.  @nishanxr  So, in your words showering abuses on an unknown person who has a view point you may not feel is right, is freedom of expression. Right, NJ? Just chill and enjoy.
    2
  670. True DK. For the pilot war…has Rajasthan taken off or is it still taxing? Anybody? Tailpiece: In mid air when control changes hand between the Pilot and the co Pilot, the Pilot after taking control says “I got her”. Where is she? The big Q.
    2
  671. Is it now the case of the Empire striking back? Just asking.
    2
  672. ThePrint sure takes pains to cover wide ranging topics of interest. We appreciate that immensely. But SG, tricolor is politics? Uhm….. that is the danger when we are made to feel that politics is everything and it has to be in everything. Not true. just saying. Everything in this world is relative (and relations in international matters)…. For the knowledge of the public the cost involved in developing nuclear arsenals and a Defence force subsisting (until recently) on imported equipment and technology could also have been brought out. The quality suffers greatly. If nothing the “freebie” army will be aware what they are taking away. For a Nation all these are shaped by decades of policies and planning. That was not done in India. It was all the way mostly about politics and power (except for 1991). At least now let us see the light and concentrate on reshaping mindsets, so that such programs signifying deficiencies are not forced to be “repeated” after two decades.. Tailpiece: I suppose once bitten by politics ( in real life / journalism) you get smitten. The prism is seldom changed thereafter. There is life only beyond politics. Just saying - without malice.
    2
  673. Whenever a chance come up the Canadian rep sidesteps Canada and goes on to USA.. in other word seems to be floundering in regard to Canada and Trudeau… Obvious
    2
  674. Great take on Ashok Ghelot - Royal Nepal Navy, haha! “Chingari….. “ hahaha! Fantastic. Ukraine is a muddle. Follow up of the USSR break up was inefficient. Okay, that is in the past. I do not see a peaceful resolution unless Putin is removed by Russians. I feel removing Putin may be easier than removing the Gandhis from the helm of Congress. Tailpiece: An out of the box approach would be sending medicines and food for Russians as is being done for Ukrainians.
    2
  675.  @lightyork8268  everything in this world is relative. Some relatives are ok to live with and others are not!!!! Jokes apart. If livelihoods are imperative, innovations are a must.
    2
  676. A solution to climate change effects, will emerge only if all countries sit down at working level and discuss a pragmatic and doable approach to reduce carbon emissions. Tailpiece: Indians use (have been always using ) solar energy to dry washed linen. In “advanced nations” most people dry their washed linen using carbon emitting energy. Just saying.
    2
  677. We salute our Police and paramilitary who work tirelessly 24/7 (not the news channel). “We the people”, in a democracy, are always beyond reproach. Right? Like road accidents are not always because the roads are bad or the traffic policeman was not doing his duty. Most accidents are the drivers' fault. The sooner “we the people” (including media persons) also take more responsibility for everything happening in the society, it will be better for the Nation. Be consciously aware of it and let there be no doubts on this. The problem in our country is not the rules. It is the implementation of the rules by an inadequate, overworked police and paramilitary on a people WHOSE STANDARDS OF SELF-DISCIPLINE IS PATHETIC. Let us admit it and strive to improve. I request the media too to highlight this aspect. The notion that the people (blindly supported by the media) are always right is the undoing of liberal democracies. Tailpiece: The media may not want to admit that it also has certain duties like educating the public about their responsibilities, which it does not fulfill most of the time.
    2
  678. A logical conclusion. Good analysis. A very important and pertinent subject, which the Nation needs to debate. Nobody can win a war any longer anywhere in the World. But let us not be under any illusion. To be in a commanding position, looking West, East or North, we do need a strong military. If we are forced to take overt military protection in any way from anybody, we will only grow weaker and suffer in the long run. Tail piece: Building a Nation is more than just about “ripped jeans” and a similar comment, on another dress, of a “million dollar suit”. Let the Nation (and the media) not lose sleep on such frivolous issues.
    2
  679.  @DataCrusade1999  point taken, thanks . Because od on the fly typing etc..
    2
  680. Well researched info to clear perceptions of us Indians about China and LAC. It is a difficult terrain more in the news now because of social and digital media and ThePrint? Has that "compounded" the problem? We need to reflect. Is it all a game of perceptions? Tailpiece: SG, did you mention Shyok river in AP?
    2
  681.  @ytadltspv  Sundar good point. But probably made in a short sighted manner. My point is definitely not anti farmer. MSP etc are means to compensate the farmers. Wheat is a staple used daily by the ordinary citizens and not like mangoes which is a discretionary food. A wider vision may help see my point. No hard feelings. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    2
  682. Good positive distraction. A lesson in isolation, really! The print is coming around towards positives
    2
  683. Good spirit. Well done.
    2
  684. Appreciate The Print broadcasting World affairs, so very important for wholesome development of a Nation. SG is doing it with clarity. Tailpiece: “Iraq, Turkey, ancient civilizations…..”. India?
    2
  685.  Kiru  i have no special interest in the story at all. I don't like the media hype either which way. I respect others views too.
    2
  686. Et tu The Print?
    2
  687. I wonder why Pakistan’s politics is analyzed to determine the Nations path. It uses a different GPS and land marks to steer a course…. to the unknown? That is what India should worry about…. I ran or Sharrif or Bhutto do not make any difference to the fate of the Nation. Have we not seen pit all? Tailpiece: This apparition which, to use a cliche, holds the destiny of Pakistan is what India should be vary of. Revealing the apparition should be the aim of media and experts for the good of Pakistan and the region.
    2
  688. Clear as clear can be. The first step is to stop the bleeding. Then the tetanus injection. Cleaning, applying balm and bandages if necessary. The most important stage is to let it heal naturally, without intervention.. Tailpiece: A process to redeem the bleeding PSUs.
    2
  689. An important assessment…..DK
    2
  690. The presentation of issues by The Print give all round coverage. Love it. My take, If UCC was allowed by the Nation (read all political,parties) it would already have been implemented and would not be an election issue. Just saying. Tailpiece.There are good intentions too in Government actions. Again just saying.
    2
  691. Diwali greetings to team , ThePrint. Forward Ho!
    2
  692. A good and fresh approach. But… Modi vs Who? Unfortunately the Q itself, DK, is misleading. We as an electorate must discuss policies, development, progress, jobs, economy, security etc. etc. Instead we discuss all those aspects like veils, face covering, charisma (important though), caste, religion, parochialism, language and such trivial which do not bring food on the table. The electorate too fall for the ruse and vote emotionally rather than with the head. Unfortunate. There just are no experts, media or any social leader of standing who try to educate the public on such matters. None I have seen in fifty years. To give it to this government, in the past few years there has been an effort at more discussions in the public on policies etc But woefully inadequate to reach the masses. Tailpiece: Man to man (or woman) give the name of one person who has been in politics for life, A CM of a state for more than 14 years continuously and a PM of India for 10 years under age around 70years.
    2
  693. Avoidable unwanted theatrics to say the least. Talk to the people about economy, and progress. Roti, kapda aur makkan and nothing else. That would be class. Just saying.
    2
  694. It is well known to all and sundry that a political twist can be played out in the media on all actions by elected Governments in a democracy. I wish the media, especially The Print, sees this and tries to convey the real implication of such initiatives to the society. Tailpiece: The “Why”;of politics does not fill the plates at the dining table.
    2
  695. Very clear. Thanks
    2
  696. The most striking feature of today’s very impressive RD parade was that the Supreme Commander of the Indian Armed Forces (The President) took the Salute smartly (army like) without twitching or swaying, standing erect for the whole duration of 50 odd minutes of the marching contingents filing past. A first for a President. Tailpiece: Watch it again.
    2
  697. If would be nice if Mr. NK could tell us with past, present and future data including economy, progressive policies, development, trade, etc.. etc.. As a senior leader, we expect some erudite comments from Mr NK. As a statesman Mr. NK is expected to highlight the achievements of all Governments too. This is not in Defence of anybody, every Government will have failings and setbacks as Mr. NK has repeatedly experienced in Bihar. Tailpiece: It is for senior leaders like Mr. NK, to show the way to better political language, essence, truthfulness, conviction and such qualities in public life. Winning elections, by opportunistic alliances is neither good governance or sincerity of purpose towards the electorate. Hope Mr. NK reads this message from a citizen.
    2
  698.  @gauranautiyal7987  True GN. No harm in calling them out... and asking for better work
    2
  699. The “Seven seas” ? Saath samundar Paar?
    2
  700. Way to go. Such positive public service should have been done by all political parties looooong baaaaack.
    2
  701. There is a feeling in a very large section of the Indian population, that some farmers and some politicians have AS USUAL turned the representations of farmers into a political gimmick. What with talks still open and the judiciary also involved in the matter, is there a genuine reason for prolonging this “agitation”? Who represents the voice of this section of Indians who see a deja Vu in these shenanigans from all sides? Tail piece: There are “genuine demands” from the unorganized sector, from laborers, from industrial workers, from the informal economy, from MSMEs, from the industry, from airline operators and from just about all and sundry. At some point we have to get real and move on.
    2
  702. Ha! there you are. The real issue is not Farm laws or the farmers. We knew it all along. Didn't we?
    2
  703. I disagree totally though respect the right of this media person to offer his views though skewed. Comparing India with Britain is preposterous. The culture, societal set up, diversity, history, etc. etc. preclude any comparison. Governance aspects in Britain albeit with lesser people and immensely more resources obviously does not reflect in the wellbeing of its people. It is obvious with the lot of discontentment we see among the common people there. A Wimbledon, Lords or EPL does not reflect the reality either from within or without. For lessons on political parties in a democrAcy, there is more than one party in India from who a majority of other parties can learn. Ah, then… a diverse country like India will require leaders not in the mould of Majors, Browns, Camerons, Mays, Sunaks or Johnsons! Tail piece: India has a unique character demographically, culturally, geographically, economically, historically and politically among other aspects.
    2
  704. Discalimer: If any suffering can be foreseen and could have been prevented should have been done whether by the society, media or the state(s). It is positive to learn that The Print acknowledges that India does have a global reputation which according to them, says Jyoti, has now been "damaged". Tailpiece: Everybody (except the media) sees a Pandemic when there is one. Pandemic is not the same as Politics or diplomacy. It does not behave as stated in any manuals! These are desperate times for which I am sanguine that even Harvard does not have a management manual.
    2
  705. AFSPA is really a sham and exists only on paper. On ground It neither gives enough power nor provides any real “ protection” to the armed forces in dealing with insurgents. Something like a free ride in a public transport (just saying) or to move freely anywhere anytime is not real power. Right? AFSPA is past sell by date. At the same time there is a requirement for the Government, legislature and executive to interact with the people of Nagaland in a constructive and transparent way. Help of prominent and influential (in Nagaland) citizens, politicians, media persons, and security forces should also be taken A time bound action plan has to be drafted monitored and communicated to the Nation. Is the civil administration up to it? Tailpiece: Like so many other vague regulations of the past the apparition of AFSPA is only a perception.
    2
  706. By some of the logic discussed, now that Putin has put his Nuclear deterrent forces on the highest alert, it would only be a matter of about an hour for the usual pre Nuclear strike procedures to go through, before the finger is put to the button. So, is it time for all Governments to declare Nuclear emergency and move its citizens to nuclear shelters etc? Just asking. Tailpiece: Like opposition for the sake of opposing and criticism for the sake of criticizing has become a trait in democracies and free press; much like fashion, trending and ‘in-things’. Just saying.
    2
  707.  @aryans5129  absolutely right….change with times.. etc… We must rewrite our constitution. Enjoy.
    2
  708. Disclaimer. I have nothing against the author nor the book or any specific comments on the contents therein - as yet. This is a general observation. A pitfall of democracy is that just about everybody, including the media, other than the elected Government knows what is good or bad for the Nation in general. It does not matter which Government etc…smart people seem to be the experts, opinionatotrs (if I may) and the media not to mention the plethora of study groups ( more importance given to study groups from outside the Nation, so to speak). Tailpiece: it seems that in a democracy Governments can’t do any right, right? Is it time to reconsider our approach to governing India?
    2
  709. An excellent take as usual, SG. Urdu is a beautiful language when spoken with love and elan. What is more intriguing here is the “language” of the Pakistan Army. Will they finally put Pakistan on the road to progress? They may. The new senior ranks are from a “modern”, exposed generation. Tailpiece: Change is the only permeance – in politics or in RELIGION.
    2
  710. My 2bit on why the INDI alliance, whose stated aim is not to win to rule but to defeat the BJP, is a nonstarter. The possible constituents are: - All political parties cultivate voter bases – Shiv sena, INC (Muslims, dynasty), Akali, Yadavs, BSP (dalit), JD(U), YSR,. TMC, Biju JD, (all parochial) etc. All the above parties are obviously pursuing diverse politics voic0ing “secular” as only wooing Muslims only because they oppose BJP. It is obvious no one party above will want the other party to dominate. Also as brought out in the discussion, the realization has dawned that hitching a ride with INC will weaken the mostly regional parties in the coalition. One other example why this is an alliance of divergent views… As political parties DMK is no different from BJP. 1. DMK thrives on a platform of ethnic identity whole the BJP is rejuvenating the Bhartiya identity 2. Both are perceived to have alienated a part of their respective electorate – DMK the upper castes (and wooing Muslims) and the BJP the Muslims (and wooing upper castes). 3. Both recall from old literature 4. Both are good administrators –chess Olympiad in 2022 and the recent Global investor forum in Chennai conducted by DMK were as efficient as the G20 functions organized by the BJP. 5. Both are keen on development, progress and delivery to the needy There just is no underlying ideology, except to defeat BJP. If DMK learns Hindi and becomes a National party, it will be better Nationally than most other regional parties or INC.
    2
  711.  @AshishSahoo  intriguing and disappointing, Swami. Any response ThePrint?
    2
  712. Congress will do well to concentrate on statutes rather than on statues and such non productive issues. We the people of India rest our hope on independent media like The Print to highlight the gamesmanship of politics which should not overshadow progress and development of the Nation in the name of unproductive “liberal democracy “. Are up you up to it, The Print?
    2
  713. “Gen Malik said that while the short-term goal is status quo ante, the long-term objective should be to make the Chinese agree to delineation of the LAC on the maps. “ ““Because unless that is, these kind of intrusions and small actions that take place on the LAC will continue,” he said.”” There is a lot said in these two statements... In the wake of these statements, the big Q is how often and how much in detail should we be discussing these “intrusions and small actions” in the media where the perceptions and knowledge of “experts” vary. Also what is the aim of “informing” the public about the conjectured temporary uncertainties on an unresolved line. A public discussion on the ultimate resolution may benefit the Nation - “in the long run”. This is more in the domain of Diplomacy than in the hands of the Military.
    2
  714. PM (of India) ..” share video of first day of his visit ..” So do we assume that the Indian media is not covering his vist and this high profile world meet? Just asking: of course the “free media” if free to do as it deems fit…. Freedom of speech also includes when, what and how to speak, right? Tailpiece: A bit confusing as confused as the media.
    2
  715. And one more point….. the great thing about the laggard Indian democracy is that for every good leader you get an equally good misleader. Validates Newton’s first law of motion.
    2
  716.  @grapeshott  I as a Hindu am free to pray or not pray...panths are by choice... No mandate... There is a difference...
    2
  717. @Ximrets-ix8ux Hinduism is not a religion in the sense of Abrahamic religion. If you insist, it is the only democratic religion if you want to call it that). one can be a Hindu “believing’ in any deity (even of any Abrahamic religion) or no deity at all; having faith in any God or in no God at all; one can pray any which way one wants to at any time of day or/and night or not pray at all; Culture is a set of values which in the Indian sense is to be respectful, accommodating, open-minded, deeply but not ostensibly spiritual and concerned with the common human welfare offering respect and acceptance to all philosophies / religions. THIS, sir is Hindutva.
    2
  718. “Shadow...”. How can a shadow be cast in an environment which is perpetually dark without even a ray of light for illumination? Just asking.
    2
  719. Forget about Russia attacking Ukraine; it will be a no event. Our media tells us that our politicians attack each other every day somewhere and even inside the August house(s). They are none the worse for it. Tailpiece: I wonder why our media uses violent language while reporting to the public. If some politicians do that, it does not follow that they should too,
    2
  720. Is there some place where one can find the details of assets created under the scheme of MNREGA?
    2
  721.  @nirmalyanirbisank8512  I like the one time subscription bit, which can, of course, be executed multiple times. I can continue to patronise The Print and pay for it, or get out if the standards deteriorate. It is not the Q of freeloading more than necessity/ interest, once it loses the 'new kid on blick' moniker. For the present The Print ream is interesting.
    2
  722. Disclaimer: Not a political statement but some facts as they have shown up. Politicians should not take the people of India to be naïve. “secularism” is losing its artificial sheen. Politics dividing the country? Let us see the genesis. Political parties formed on religious lines (The Muslim Leagues, JMM etc…), formed on parochial basis (TDP, Siv Sena, Biju JD, Samajwadi, BSP, aligned on Caste lines (e.g based on Jats, Lingayats, Gujjjars etc.. - aligned with particular political outfits - , Dalits (BSP)) – may have missed out some smaller ones – were already in existence decades before the BJP was formed. Tailpiece: If the Nation sees a problem in such religion, caste and parochially based alignments (yes, there sure are dangers here) the remedies have to be sought in the right places – in the society and not in politics.
    2
  723.  @khagapatibisoi3835  Bisoi, What happens if both just ignore it. Think for a while. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    2
  724. An erudite analysis. My take. The opposition can unite to defeat Modi. Not beyond for obvious reasons such as different agenda, personal ambitions, parochial bias, caste bias, religious bias etc.,etc. ad nauseam, will take over the thought process of parties in coalition. A minimum common programme (a joke actually for a Nation as large as India, remember 1.4 b people) will be woefully inadequate for economic progress and development. Tailpiece: It beats me as to what UNITY is the opposition talking. It will be better for India if the Nehru-Gandhi family abdicates (vanish to private lives) and hands over the INC to competent leaders, not just symbolically. Let the Nation discuss this at length. We as a Nation should debate the larger picture and not piecemeal politics.
    2
  725. A few “Union leaders” who have a huge disconnect with the crowd (turned into a mob) they profess to “command” can,t control these thousands of disoriented people in various state of mind, themselves unsure of what really is happening. Nobody knows who comes or goes. Such events become a stage for mob indiscretion. Authorities, obviously can use only so much force. The end result is widespread damage, pointing fingers and bad taste. Should such “protests” be allowed in the first place. A deja Vu event!
    2
  726. Also DK, What is the qualification of a first time MP, Ms P. Gandhi Vadhra, elected from a very very safe seat to lead a Nation of 140b people except that she is a woman… how, as journalist, do you expect her to lead the opposition and subsequently the Nation…. We do not need just women… we need capable women… women empowerment is the key and not women leaders, all of a sudden from nowhere
    2
  727. Very true. All concerned have then to realize that peace and reconciliation do not travel on a one way street. Acceptance of each other’s deities and methods of prayers etc… by all clerics of ALL religions and practinioners of respective religions may be a start point.
    2
  728.  @OhiSandhu  Sandhu, this is the National problem. You are more interested in my Political leanings than the points I have raised. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    2
  729.  @vikashsinghtanwar1147  vikash, I agree with you wholeheartedly. I request you to read my comments again (if you have read it at least once already) slowly. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    2
  730. Is the PM feeling so or is it a lot of people feel that PM is feeling so. You know actions on “feelings” fanned by some sections of the media is retarding the country’s progress. Not now, it has been so for decades. So I request all experts to wake up and get out of the “ feeling” syndrome and passionate obsessions to see India progress. Tail piece: borrowing from Tyson”...PMs will come and PMs will go but “We the people” will go on forever.”. For heavens sake discuss issues and not people, especially JM.
    2
  731. The real news are always beyond the headlines. You see, what you is not always what it is. Applies to everything in life. Good programme. Way to go. Music is necessary in life; a bit softer would be nice;
    2
  732. Dear SG, good points. But “itna drama mat karo”...
    2
  733.  @fromearth4546  :)
    2
  734. For a moment forget the study. I am in NJ just across the Hudson from NY. We all, by now know that the worst hit city in the whole of the world is NY. At the peak, NY required about 4-5 times the hospital beds required. For most part of April and May (till now) dead bodies lined up the streets of NY although in refrigerated vans. This situation came about because NY did not implement any type of lockdown until it was too late. It has taken NY about 3 months to flatten the curve. So study or no study, if a city like Mumbai (where I was born) had not locked down when it did, the condition would have been pathetic. Academic studies ( even in case of economy for that matter) are just that- academic. This study referred here was shunned by many, including India and the much respected Dr. Fauci long back. With the experiences in Wuhan, Tehran and NY we don’ t require academic models to discern the behavior of this virus. The controversy on the various models worldwide is just political and to be ignored.
    2
  735. Dictionary meaning of criticism is “the expression of disapproval of someone or something based on perceived faults or mistakes.” Anything based on perception is subjective. Should we criticize or instead express concern, give a view, object , protest, represent and such. Just asking Also, intelligence is “the ability to acquire and apply knowledge and skills”. It is a catastrophe if you “apply” without “acquiring”. Just saying
    2
  736.  @wakerue5324  thanks for you inputs. Stay safe.
    2
  737. I must stop commending The Print any more as good journalism is it’s norm. Tailpiece: There is a system of biodiversity. Rice was largely cultivated on the West coast and North East which received plenty of monsoon rains. Aadmi bandar ban Sakt hain, lekin bandar admission nahin ban Sakta.
    2
  738. As usual a balanced view of politics, SG. India definitely needs the Congress. A new congress. Or old congress with new leadership. Anybody, except a handful (literally) can see that. Yes, politics and its discussion are part of a democracy as long as the discussion includes the benefits to the electorate, mostly in its united functioning to improve the lot of its people and in the progress of the Nation to compete with developing and developed economies of the World. Frankly, winning elections and defeating a party (in this case the BJP?) as the declared aim is an affront to democracy. Mamta, P. Kishore, Sharad Pawar, the Yadavs and Patnaiks are all passe’. May be an odd Patnaik or a Stalin may work for a while at local levels. We do need two strong political outfits at the National level, each with a 40% voter base for a strong Government at the Centre always and every time – without that India will forever remain a laggard democracy. Tail piece. Coalitions are no answer. You can’t expect to consistently win test matches with T20 specialists. Like IPL, the best coalitions in India can offer only some excitement. An aside: It is time we stop talking about defeating the BJP and talk of a political environment best suited for progress. A nation ca't make progress by just praying any which way.
    2
  739. SG, it is really sad and disappointing that you also sing the tune of “stopping Modi” as if he is an enemy of the state. Do you also feel that should be the aim of the INC and others? I feel better language can be used. Of, course you are politically well “educated”, very much better than I am. But I have also seen the political journey of India for over seven decades. Stopping Modi is not the issue for a progressive India. It is Governence. Democracy does not end with elections. Tailpiece. Modi is human and just another PM in the Nations journey.
    2
  740. Loved it: Source of inspiration. Tailpiece: The most powerful fuel in the world - “ inspiration” followed by perspiration…ok, ok, some gyan.
    2
  741. Would we and the whole world get to see the minutes of the conference here?
    2
  742.  @mlg1279  All Religions. In effect the Abrahamic religions, yes. Hinduism was, is and will not be a religion. I consider Hinduism, Buddhism ad Jainism as philosophies and not as religions. There are no mandates. THAT will take some imagination and understanding……But then, I can always have, expound and follow my views. Forward Ho!
    2
  743.  @sachinreddybappa1273  1. Elections are far away. 2. In politics chaos precedes reason. In other words chaos is created for reasons other than what is given as a reason afterwords. As they say, what will happen will happen either which way. Yenjoy.
    2
  744. In this pandemic situation, without a precedence in the current place where the world is in, I wonder how come we have so many experts suggesting what governments should have done and what they should do. What is the credibility of these experts when they speak in hindsight and in silos. Economists talk about business, Businesses talk of their own businesses, medical experts talk differently and so on. The media in general make a ‘kichdi’ of all these (except ‘cut the cutter’ ) and generally confuse the public..e.g. all theses weeks we have been following 6ft and today there is a report in the media, quoting another ‘expert’ to say 6 ft is not enough it should be 24 ft....ridiculous....in the same breath we clamour for for the economy to reopen. Why don’t we all shut up for a month and let the Administration do its job any which way.... for better or for worse. I fail to understand how the media at large are ‘helping’ in this situation by sending mixed signals, when it is accepted that no body really knows which way the wind will blow. Somebody has to take charge (as in China?) and get the situation under control. Too many cooks spoil the broth. Leave the job to those who are responsible for it.
    2
  745. Can’t beat India to play opposing sides… Rest easy… would you say, Swamy?
    2
  746. Totally agree. Expect better standards from ThePrint. Disappointing, in the least.
    2
  747. For Goverments to downsize the people and the media too have to become more responsible and contribute visibly to nation building. Nation building is NOT only finding faults with the governments (state / central) in the name of free press and democracy
    2
  748. You forgot to mention that the current Government supported this judgement… just saying
    2
  749. I would like to see the media repeatedly drill it into the people regarding COVID appropriate behaviour. This morning, in my locality, I found that about 60% of the 200 odd individuals I counted either did not wear a mask or wore it around their necks. These, I am sure is the case all over the country. I don’t see media reporting this lapse on the part of us, the citizens on a regular basis. My nukkad vegetable vendor (corner shop) from who I purchase my daily veg needs (not from BIG or Small basket) was not wearing a mask this morning. When I asked him why not he said that what is the necessity now that the virus is going away. He did finally wear the mask when I explained the situation. Tailpiece: Who do you think is responsible for the uncontrolled spread of the virus in the second wave? What do the experts say about this? Let us get real
    2
  750. Distraction. Not in keeping with the high standards of The Print. May avoid such programmes which is meaningless any time any where.
    2
  751.  @MichToJoshya  A valid observation
    2
  752.  @lioness5838  Oh brain. I do not use it anymore. So no washing!!!
    2
  753. Bilawal Bhutto the statesman? Uhmm….
    2
  754.  @sundareshkrishna6457  Sunderesh, great you see that the society has a responsibility. Society and people need a leader - it has been so since millennia. Who will lead? For religious harmony, the best people to lead are the religious leaders. We need to consider the psyche of We the People…probably those like you and me will form less than 10% of the population. Others need to be led.. reflect. Thanks for your indulgence. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    2
  755. As usual a veritable equanimous take bringing out the effervescence of diversity in our society. Where do we look for answers to this disharmony? To quote Lao Tzu ‘…if you are not afraid to die there is nothing you cannot achieve”… unfortunately, these days life can be bought cheap - by those who want to “achieve”. The society suffers. How do we handle social harmony in India, the most diverse Nation with the most number of entrenched religions. All these years we have been barking up the wrong tree. Harmony can’t be brought in by politics which in our great Nation, constantly exploit this diversity for votes and power. You can’t expect anything else from them in a large and again diverse democracy like India. The lead has to be taken by religious leaders and the society. Tailpiece: It is high time that we the people of India hold religious leaders responsible for the harmony or disharmony in society because of religions and Gods. I will go so far in saying that it is the ONLY solution.
    2
  756. Yes we are cricket crazy partisans…. Disclaimer: I am not a religious bigot, but I say my prayer every day privately in my own way and do not wear my GOD on my sleeve. 1. When the sign of the cross is made by players on the field, there is nothing religious about it. 2. When prayers (kissing the ground etc..) are offered in a particular way on the cricket field, there is nothing religious about it. 3. When before an interview (after the match etc.) when some players invoke a religious prayer (Bis… ), there is nothing religious about it. But when a sizable section of a crown chants the name of a particular deity, the heavens (or hell) or the sky some down as everything about it religious…. Let us get real….. and not cry wolf. Tailpiece: The media should start ignoring such shenanigans. Disclaimer: I am not a religious begot, but I say my prayer every day privately in my own way and do not wear my GOD on my sleeve.
    2
  757.  @karankapoor2701  Karan, hi. Tge ill intention is in attacking an individual rather than the policy. ONIE merits National debate and that should be the intention of all of us. The suggested change transcends time and individuals. Forward Ho!
    2
  758.  @kaustubhnarkar  Great. Respect your views. Wish you the very best to take the country forward. Enjoy.
    2
  759. Yes, the Nation should know. SG, it is important to tell about the events. Well done. Tailpiece: Narratives can change but events can’t.
    2
  760.  @thisoverpcworld  haha. Now you are gettin personal…. Enjoy
    2
  761. DK, as usual a true analysis of the events as they were, are and possibly will be. Now, various narratives by any and everyone, much like historical accounts, can be “manuscriptulated” as per preconceived notions and desired effect. In regard to the just concluded T20 Asia cup cricket match which India lost to Pakistan, the narrative can be that Pakistan played brilliantly or India dropped catches and lost. Tailpiece: What is evident is that BJP has a real workable plan for the Party and the Nation (except possibly a formal security doctrine for the Nation, which may be in the making) … one may like / approve it or not, that there is a plan cannot be disputed. And that is saying a lot in the current political dispensations in India.
    2
  762. Bertie Wooster, like our media, would have retorted “ I cannot do with any more education Jeeves. I was full up years ago”. (Bertie quote not in this context in Wodehouse work). Suitable for similar programmes in the media. But there was only one Bertie, but the media he gets fresh patrons to be served with old wine in new bottles. Tailpiece: Pelham Grenville Wodehouse is eternal. Tanka for bringing him in…. A break from monotony.
    2
  763. Prithwish Mandal who is Modi? Just asking!!!
    2
  764. Why restrict someone to be pro or against something or somebody or some institution etc. It is that person’s prerogative and right to take sides. Let us not be selective in our propagation of freedom of thought and action. Let us not try to moderate the social media except for offensive and damaging contents. Let people express or not express either which way. Cancel culture is not a big deal. Tailpiece: “Cancel culture” is also expression of a viewpoint.
    2
  765. Reminds me of Shakespeare’s comedy “Much ado about nothing”. Just saying. Tailpiece: Tolerance is not a one way street.
    2
  766. A lot of Indians do not know these intricacies. Thanks, Theprint and SG. Takeaway: what is the takeaway from this “revealation”? What with the Army, ISI, various Islamic groups who are not on the same page of religion or politics, the truth is that the Pakistan Government itself does not know Pakistan. In the context how can we expect Governments of other countries to deal with Pakistan? “Talk to Pakistan” is a chorus from a section of Indians for decades. Now it must be clear why it is difficult to talk to Pakistan. Nobody knows what is Pakistan, least of all (unfortunately) the people of of Pakistan who are always at the receiving end of raw deals. Tailpiece: A related issue. There are voices (even in an article in ThePrint today) which say enough is not being done in the valley to curb terrorism and violence. If political revamping is not an approach, can any of the voices come up with a comprehensive integrated plan to handle this sovereign part of India providing justice for all belonging to the valley and the State?
    2
  767. Nice take on alternates. Nitish..uhmm.. We have not had the Sun in Bangalore since about 10 days (can you. Envisage that?). That makes me wonder… some of these politicians and political parties have to “make hay when (where) the Sun shines. Tailpiece: I see the best bet for a National level opposition (much needed for a federal democracy like India) is imploding. Unfortunate.
    2
  768. All these reformative bills work towards minimum government and maximum governance, which can’t happen at the flick of a switch. So also various other reforms. Hopefully India is slowly graduating from an enforcing state to a deregulated state. The process has started. Are we ready? For, in a deregulated state the onus of governance will be with the people more than with the state. It is then more than ever every Indian will be tested on traits like honesty, integrity, sincerity etc Tail piece: It is time “We the people” assume our responsibilities for minimum government and maximum governance. What we do will matter more than what we wear.
    2
  769. Media coming alive, though late. Great. Well done
    2
  770. Okay, will BJP get to be the main opposition at least?
    2
  771. Great narration, SG. Should the media take the blame for inadequate coverage of the successes of the Indian Defence forces since 1947? A point to ponder. Tailpiece: The media by design or by default…. Was not fair to the soldier in decades since Independence. Just saying
    2
  772. INC’s reaction reminds me of the story of the ostrich which when encountered with danger buries it’s head in the sand and hopes the danger will pass by. Tailpiece: Yes the Nation needs a strong “opposition” … not in words but in deeds. I hope the INC during its course of agitations against the price rise etc., also tell us what has led to the price rise and recommended actins to curb the same.
    2
  773.  @desibigfoot3874  True. These “ jobs”, at times not permitted, are few in the context of reducing the strength using technology to replace soldiers; the “misuse” as you may have “seen” does not in any way reduce the combat capabilities. We are here talking about technology to enhance combat capabilities and at the same time reducing the manpower. THIS is a colossal exercise.
    2
  774.  @OnkarShrma  Onkar agree with you 100%. My points are :1. How many drones? 2. what quality / technology… different for deploying them in High Altitudes; jungles; mountains; deserts etc. 3. Initial cost; operational costs; maintenance costs;replacement costs; 4. Time (as in period- months, years etc..) required to acquire train personnel to operate them and deploy them effectively. 5. A new system can’t replace an old system overnight. 6. Drones are not the panacea; they require back end systems to monitor; The backend system has to process data acquired; many times a reactionary force positioned close by will be required to react on ground to information received.. My further point is the whole process is not as simple as some of these “experts” and media want you to believe. The process is already underway. But rest assured (In spite of what these experts and some veterans say), it is NOT easy. A lot of resource, time and effort are required for the change.
    2
  775. Is it at great? Just asking
    2
  776. SG in this video has simply put out the seemingly complex issue of Islam. Human rights, the driving force that accepts desperate refugees, while addressing individuals does not address culture. Invasion of culture by Islam is the major issue in European and Western democracies. It is becoming an issue in India too. This fissure is exploited by terrorist organizations in the name of pan Islam. Over centuries, since the advent of Arab traders on the West coast, Arab culture and later Islamic culture permeated into the Indian society. During my school days this was very evident in my state Kerala. It worked both ways. Then, a woman in a burqua was rare and if we saw one we were sure she has arrived from Saudi Arabia. I left Kerala after School. For some reason things there are different today. The problem is not religion affecting politics....the problem is religion affecting cultures. As I always say, in India if all religious leaders come on one platform and proclaim in unison that “ your GOD is as good as mine” and ingrain this idea into young minds, we would have come a long way in maintaining communal harmony and peace. Culture will automatically adjust.
    2
  777. Her is another “expert”... An economy solely dependent on consumerism can’t sustain for ever. Only sustained domestic production, including high tech Defence requirements, can sustain economic growth. Hence - Make in India. “Putting money” in the hands of people is an unsustainable way forward for the economy. The only way forward is to ensure that no one starves an d let the economy recover in the normal course by adhering to known methods of stimulation.
    2
  778. If, as some say, being secular is divorcing religion from governance, then are we a secular Nation, where the constitution differentiates based on caste and religion. Just asking!
    2
  779. The problem is with everybody else except the SELF - right? We can never confront any PANDEMIC by looking only elsewhere for faults. On my way from the airport on 26 Dec 2020, after spending over an in the USA, and seeing the plight of NY area in person, I was appalled by how the people in our country were taking it easy. It was as if nothing had changed since I left India in September 2019. All shops open. 50% were not wearing a mask, 30% were wearing it on their chin. Later in the week, out to buy rations, when I asked my vegetable shop fellow why he was not wearing a mask, he replied “Corona has gone, so why wear a mask?”. It was not as if the administration had said so. Because, on the same day while we were driving in our own vehicle, with closed windows and ac on, my wife and I were fined Rs 350/- for not wearing masks inside the car – I was told that it was mandatory. Tailpiece: The problem in our country is not the rules. It is the implementation of the rules by an inadequate, overworked police and paramilitary on a people whose standards self-discipline is abysmal. Let us admit it and strive to improve. I request the media too to highlight this aspect.
    2
  780. Ah! Religions came into India inky about 2000 years ago. About 1000 years ago there were no Hindus... Definitely not at the time of the epics of during the vedic age... Hinduism was/is a philosophy. To reclaim the ideals and ideas of ancient Indian civilisation ( only one of a couple still remaining) is not anti secular even by the definition of secular by wokes etc..
    2
  781. Good programme. But it beats me. In such interviews, SG, and the Indian media, always repeatedly (once is understandable, but…) ask these foreign guests, whoever they are “What do you think should India do”, etc. I find this approach a bit slavish. Needs introspection. Tailpiece: we are as good as anybody in the World and we know what we are doing.
    2
  782. Necessary analysis. Good points as views. The elementary fact in fact check remains. Common / any sense is that step 2 can be taken only after step 1 is taken. So ulterior motives may have prevented step 1 being taken. Simple. Yes, India can administer and establish progress anywhere, but in reality only in parts of India where aliens should not have a leeway to interfere. The process will take time. Meanwhile we can have endless debates as is the case with J&K for more than 7 decades. We must give at least a decade to pass judgement on the new order. Tail piece: In hop, step and jump we can’t change it to step, hop and jump though we now call it triple jump!
    2
  783.  @oonaghanderson6993  THAT exactly is a major point contained in my comment….Enjoy.
    2
  784. An apt programme…after all it is the ruling (in all ways) party. Presented nicely My take: The change could be for wider representation. Probably shows that one need not be a VIP / celebrity for able administration etc. just saying. Tailpiece: Let us look at the positives…and ah! It is politics, isn’t it:)?
    2
  785. Sexy names, wow!
    2
  786. In this brief presentation of the "Sedition Act" SG has brought in many aspects of democracy. Do watch this video many times for the real insights into democracy. “Sab mile hue hain” is a dangerous situation. The real question to ask is, why are we (including the Judiciary) waking up to these pitfalls in democracy and asking questions only now, after more than seven decades of Independence. Among other factors we can attribute the “awakening” because of more participation in the debates with improved social media and communication systems. In the present context it is necessary that the media and the public should also become more responsible and not succumb to feelings and parochialism. Tail piece: In a democracy the responsibilities of other "pillars" of democracy and its people are more than that of the Government of the day.
    2
  787.  @satyabanerji1982  intellectuals are seldom doers. It is the street smart who are achievers. An intellectual like Dr. Radhakrishnan was President material but not a natural PM. While Indira Gandhi (with all the warts) was not president material but she was street smart. Narasimha Rao was an exception...he was an intellectual and a doer by circumstance (driven to the wall)
    2
  788. If the party wants to change leaders, why the huha? If leaders are changed commentators find fault if they are retained the commentators find fault. If they fail at the hustings it is their funeral. Concentrate on Governmental matters. You have rules and rules and more rule, then you have exceptions too to the rule. It is a natural thing. An odd or two Khattars are par for the course, right? This commentary is unwarranted. Now, don’t come up with democracy and free speech etc. What I mean is you are free to comment but the Q is are such analysis helping the people in any way? DK, you are right and you are great, but this….
    2
  789. Disclaimer: With malice to none. The Print is my favorite and the only channel I watch/ read for some of its offerings. As SG himself says, politics is an essential ingredient, as salt in food, in a democracy. But the all pervasive media is a more essential portion of life ( food, entertainment, work, play, religion, caste etc. etc.) in a democracy where free press and free speech is incumbent. The end result is that media and politics feed on each other and the people just take the left overs. Tailpiece: In a democracy, the politicians will use the fissures in society ( which precedes modern politics by many centuries) to create vote banks (religion, caste, creed, language, parochialism etc.. etc..). So do not except them to solve societal problems.By sheer logic, it is not even a probability.The media creates the din.
    2
  790.  @StarSprangledBanner  just because some farmers dont want it? There are so many such laws that concerned people don't want. For instance many want taxes to be reduced; many don't want privatisation of PSUs but want the same inefficiency to continue; bank employees donot want privatisation; informal economy donot want their businesses to be tracked; retirees do not want to pay income tax; many don't want pay hefty traffic violation fines; if the farm laws are perceived to be hurting some farmers that does not mean laws have to be repealed....at the whims snd fancies of some interested parties.
    2
  791. Mexico caertels are where they are without “help”:from outside their Nations but of course with help fro local politicians. If we can stop,foreign money “(Khalistan+ criminals?) I” and illegal immigrants from Myanmar and Bangladeshi India can never become a Mexico. Do not be coy to call out “Khalistnis” and illegal immigrants Swamy… that also concerns security threats
    2
  792. Ayyayya karum mein kya Sukhu, Sukhu….
    2
  793.  @zetaforever4953  please read history how all this came to pass…. You may go as far back as the British occupiers of the land, or the occupation by Ottoman Empire before that since 7th century or even millennia before that to see who were ousted from where. The very idea of the people of the area to kick out a particular sect from there is the genesis of the problem. Zeta , I suggest, you get the facts right. Yes what you say may be true in the present situation, but what are the events that led to this impasse is important and has to be addressed by the region for a lasting solution. In any case INTENTIONALLY and brutally killing unarmed humans Including women and children is nothing less than barbaric. Maybe in your dictionary it means freedom struggle. Stay well.
    2
  794. I meant a National debate on all these aspects affecting the socity at large. :-)
    2
  795.  @mohdshariq5814  sure.
    2
  796. Good show and helpful. Great initiative. In life, generally and in journalism in particular, it just doesn’t matter what you tell or show, what matters most is HOW and WHY you tell or show something. E.g. in journalism: Whether it is to inform or influence; whether it is for shock and awe and thus for readership or eyeballs; whether it is honest or there is an hidden agenda and so on. Tailpiece: Media is to inform and help he public; especially in times of unprecedented PANDEMIC where it is important NOT to enhance fear and panic.
    2
  797. Very true about truth. What we talk mostly is just academic and relative to many imponderables, including time. There is nothing absolute. Hence unfortunately, everything is perception. What one thinks is her view or her truth. Truth is really a subject of eternal search. Tailpiece: So, one wonders; does truth really matter?
    2
  798. Worth a revisit.Among all the incompetence “squabbling Generals” rankles. The Army fought bravely. And therein lies the irony. Tailpiece: The Q is have we leant a lesson? Can we have an MOD filled with those not in Uniform, without doubtful knowledge on National security issues? Just asking. Security of a Nation against external threats has to be handled by a combination of diplomats, bureaucrats, Defence persons in service et al. working in unison as a team. MOD is that team. I do not see the media, security e perks et al debating this issue.
    2
  799. john smith uhmmm......you have a point
    2
  800. True. The Earth was made over billions of years. It has been plundered for centuries at a rate millions of times faster than its creation rate. It is now beyond repairs. Tailpiece: Digitisation, AI, data analytics etc… are not tools to repair the damage already caused.
    2
  801.  @DKSingh-wf8tn  DK, the Gandhi-Nehru syndrome I suppose
    2
  802. On a lazy morning in Bangalore, I see the situation as follows: Political parties have been accepting donations, mostly in cash since decades. Since the Bond scheme, donations have been through the bank. All (especially National level) political parties have received such donations…. Some more, some less, some MUCH more. It is documented and can be seen as soon as the key is found in the dog poo. The honorable SC can fault the procedure and no more. The problem for the political parties can arise on two counts 1. If any book keeping procedure (I think, for obvious reasons, no such procedures have been laid down) have been violated by political parties. 2. If any quid quo pro can be established for any donation…. Which can obviously be only with ruling parties (Centre or State) What is got is for keeps and procedure for the future has to be laid down following SC guidance. I may be wrong…
    2
  803. Ha ha! So many “Abdullahs” and so many “begani shadis” these days.... a bit of humor now and then in these difficult times is always welcome.
    2
  804. SG, your first sentence is the truth and that is it. The “but-tears” want to deny. Like all tragedies the key is discussions of the incidents in public domain. Accept the atrocities and try to move on providing to the victims, whatever justice is possible. In this case their rehabilitation. How many killed is a secondary. They had to leave their homes. That definitely would not have been voluntary. Simple logic. Tailpiece: Acceptance, tolerance, freedom of expression etc are not one way streets.
    2
  805. Should the UP CM resign? This all about the established social fabric which the society and the media turned a blind to all these years.
    2
  806. Very very I’ll informed interviewer. Where does NDA (National Defence Academy) come in in Agnipath? It was said that the process of recruitment will start by December etc and not train and join in 3 months. I wish better informed people handle this matter in the media. Tailpiece: It is obvious that the media is handling it in a political perspective.
    2
  807. Cut the clutter on tree cutting! A natural topic for cut the clutter:)? Yes, only The Print has the axe to do this. Tailpiece: A laggard democracy. One and a half step forward and pushed back one step by those who have no real stake in the matter. Also a topic for discussion over cutting chai and no more?
    2
  808. A fresh approach to the happenings of the times. The unique imprint of The Print. Well done. Tail piece: The bottom line is politics does not fashion religion and neither does religion fashion politics in the larger picture. Even in India. It is all about money. In a way exploitation of some (in all religions but much more pronounced in some) by those who proclaim false claims on religious knowledge (if I may).
    2
  809. Good points. Many battles are fought constantly away from the war zones to avoid a war or to be in a winning position in case of a conflict. Europe failed in this aspect in respect of Putin. Europe failed to smell the coffee. Tailpiece: Good poker players hold their cards close to the chest and present a cold countenance to win the stakes.
    2
  810. Surely it is condemnable to ask for /play for / manipulate the public for votes in the name of religion, by this leader or any leader, in any form overtly or covertly. Thankfully, I presume, the people are now educated enough to see through the overt and covert manipulations by various political parties and are competent to decide for themselves and the Nation.
    2
  811. A valid point, Swamy. With agniveers being released, India could become a good source to recruit mercenaries…. A rule could come in to forbid it
    2
  812. Modi and Harris are not important in the interaction an remarks…It is about India and the USA. Modi will be PM for say 10 years? 15 years? India and US, in comparison will be forever.
    2
  813. Yes, what this government has done in this tenure is going for far reaching economic and foreign policies which may not bring immediate results to the common man. Is this a conscious decision by the PM? Worth a look. Tailpiece: Nation first?
    2
  814. Well analysed Shekhar. But what about the Nation and its governance? Tailpiece: What about development etc… not a poll issue as usual, Skekhar? Are elections the ultimate in democracy and governance…therein lies the paradox
    2
  815. Novel method of analysis. Great job. The greatest change is intent. Did you mention that, SG? One way to get democracy going may be constructive politics by major opposition parties without using the word “secularism”.
    2
  816.  @hanfucolorful9656  Thank you for recognising that National Pride is different from Nationalism. In regard to Rover ( I wonder whether you are a cricket fan/follower - but with your intelligence you will understand what I say). The NZ cricket team lost to Australian cricket team in the final of the T20 World Cup cricket tournamnet. It does not necessarily mean that the NZ cricket team and the NZ Nation can't take pride in the performance of the team and declare the campaign (performance in the tournament) as a whole, a success just because they lost a nail biting final match.
    2
  817. I am reminded of a Shakespearean comedy " Much ado about nothing" India is a vibrant and super active democracy. Anything and everything that happens in this Nation will have a political hue. Ask the media stalwarts, they feed on it. The ruling party as well as the opposition will constantly play games with people’s sentiments. That is the lot of Indian democracy. Yes, finally the people will choose. That is another story. Sentiment is a type of illness, a medical condition. Like the ember it will come to life when fanned and die away when no attention is paid to it. So, with this issue of Parliament inauguration and many, many such matters in our chequered history since Independence. Memory is short-lived, whether of the people or political parties who will oppose a matter while out of power which they had advocated when in power. The Nation sees all this like watching a soap opera. This new parliament thing is but another such instant. The Nation will move on... Parliament will function in its new place. Governments will come and governments will go, the soap opera will roll on. Whatever, there is a new India, which hopefully have realized this hollow games. The New India will move on. It HAS to move on to survive. Forward Ho!
    2
  818. Would cautioned be better than warned? No, warn is correct here as the intention is belligerence. Good.
    2
  819. A good debate in the august house, for a change. If consensus is democracy is our electoral politics the right way to elect governments? If all political parties have to agree on a legislation, why stop at 13. Why not the 100s of other political parties too, who each have a following but are unrepresented in the parliament, for a true consensus? No political dispensation should be allowed to bulldoze if the intend of reforms is anything other than progress and the welfare of the Nation. Facts too have to be presented in the real sense as represented in any bill. For instance, this bill says (paraphrased) that the centre will guide the use of District fund (which is to be used by the Districts to repair the environmental damage caused by mining, but is lying unused by the districts for decades) if it is not used by the districts for the purpose as laid down in a laid down timeframe. This clause is entirely different from usurping the power of the states as presented in this video…yes, English is a difficult language. It can be used and misused with equal dexterity by those who are proficient. But misleading is not a worthy way to use language. If our children and their children are to live in an India which is at least as good or bad as it is now, reforms and privatization have to be implemented with haste. We have already lost decades due to inaction for a variety of reasons. Disclaimer: I am not making a political comment but for a determined Governance so that India does not remain a laggard democracy.
    2
  820. A good programme. My take briefly (though it is long for “comments”). But the a message, which religious leaders and politicians intentionally fail to convey, need to be conveyed (with malice to none) The only permeance in this world is change. There are two facets to any religion. The core message and the methods. While the core message (probably same for all religions) is simple and addresses the inner self the methods are more ethereal and prone to changes as civillisation evolves. Else, we would still be in the vortex of child marriages and the Sati. It is imperative that every religion changes the methods in a multicultural environment. The split of the Catholic churches and the various sects in Islam are a result of such desires for change in methods. There is nothing wrong or blasphemous in changing methods. Even among the followers of Islam, while the Sunnis recommend wearing of Hijab on most occasions, the Shias mandate it only during the offering of prayers. In the context every method prescribed are matters of interpretations. The Hadiths (addons) are but interpretations of what is ordained in the Quaran and should be treated as subjective. Tailpiece: Let me illustrate: In an Iyer marriage the prescription is for the wedding ceremonies to span four days mandating 48 rituals. The Vedas prescribe only seven and many of you will be surprised to learn that wearing the Manglsutra or the Sindhoor (above the forehead or anywhere else) are NOT among them. The followers of a religion tend to add on customs and practices to suit an environment or for mere exploitation – mostly for the latter. The people are made fools and politicians have a field day laughing all the way to the vote bank.
    2
  821. What exactly are these “welfare” measures? I thought the Nation always wanted to uplift the marginalized through empowering programmes. I suppose the funds are not for welfare but for empowering so that the marginalized become more and more self reliant. Right?
    2
  822. Unbecoming of a “cultured” person. Nothing personal. But I have to say this. The issue is Mr. Rahul Gandhi seems to have no idea about Kauravas or khakhi half pants. My school uniform was Kakhi half pants, The cadets at the military academies wear kakhi h😅alf pants, the police too in many states….etc…. And Kauravas were not demons. They were just made to be villains in an epic. Like Many “villains”,they had their good sides too…many, may be. Sime see tge villainsvas heroes... In the Greek epic Iliad was Achilles a hero or a villain? Etc. Etc. Tailpiece: I wonder, ( do you too?) who is spreading hatred?
    2
  823. But DK, we have to first ask the elected representatives, why do they stall the proceedings of Parliament on excuses presumably of importance. Take for instance this is “security lapse”. The opposition should have moved a motion for answers from the Government say, in 3 days (as an example) and carried on with the business in hand… can say more.,but those who understand an indication (given here) this is enough. Tailpiece: Travails of democracy, would you say? The only answer is to make INC stronger with the exit of Gandhis.
    2
  824. @paper plane Hi PP, seasons greetings. You are absolutely right. But the point is, In spite of freedom to practice all religion as a personal choice, India is the only Nation where citizens following certain religions, claim (as a given right) and enjoy special privileges and perks and demand sympathy over other citizens and get it. All religions should accept all practices of other religions, as long as they are private, and accept it openly. There is a difference in practicing and preaching. Again nothing against any religion, but a factual statement. No offense all around. Enjoy, stay safe.
    2
  825. Good informative presentation, as usual. Instant coffee is not the same as brewed coffee. My take… Agnipath, an unknown territory. We the people of India hope that the decision for “tour of duty” is deliberate with extensive brainstorming and active study by the Services HQ. We are a democracy and the elected Government has the right to shape the Armed Forces. We are here wading into unchartered waters which will have far reaching consequences for the sovereignty of India. Efficiency of the Armed Forces is not measured by pension bills; all the more so when Defence civilians take away more than 50% of the Defence pension outlay for less than 25% of the strength of the veterans. We are inclined to believe that restricting the Defence civilian organization may have yielded better results for the aim propounded. We are here dealing with the Defence of the sovereignty of the Nation. Tailpiece: Does the Nation have a right to the study after which this decision has been arrived at? That, I suppose is an obligation by the Government to the people and a right of the electorate.
    2
  826. Mandatory…
    2
  827. Of course, if Martin Wolff says so, it must be true.
    2
  828. Earnestly; We and the whole big world yearn to see the real, tolerant, all inclusive, peaceful Islam stand up and be seen and be embraced.
    2
  829. Know the area. Great work by The Print on Sikkim disaster.
    2
  830. What is in a name, the bard asked. These places we call Cantonments now were military stations when they came into being. Tailpiece: The Q is who will,control Defence land…as of now controlled by Defence Estate Office under MOD. Just asking. Can’t Boards are dispensable.
    2
  831.  @agytjax  agytax, thanks for your comments. I respect your comments on my views. But it is totally unnecessary to arraign my character. I suspect it also revels the hollowness and vague remarks you put forward. Never the less, IT is a view, you have a right to your views and respect it. But you will do well not to pass personal comment on an unknown person. Also Ido not have a personal PM. And I comment after listening to the “experts”. I am nobody to tell them to stop. But I can always give my view. If my views are not liked by anyone, please ignore the view and do not conclude what sort of a person I am.Thanks for your time. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    2
  832. Is Left ideology different in the East from what it is in the South and the Centre? Just asking.
    2
  833. Is it the real democracy, when political parties fight against each other in one part of the country and join hands and fight shoulder to shoulder from the same side in anther part of the country? I don’t see much said on this by “experts”, “intellectuals”, “political pundits”, “academics” et al. Just asking. Views are personal and neutral
    2
  834. Uncomplicated, thanks.
    2
  835.  @Kenkalsi  yes KenHK... That too I do not approve...But one swallow does not make a summer...
    2
  836.  john smith  true. But smart phones (good at user end) do not yet support "serious" computing...as in developing large applications and computing products...but the computing environment on the whole is definitely much improved now than it was 4 decades back.
    2
  837.  Anik Basu  depends. I had one at home in 1987. The rich aspect....well ...do the poor have computers at home in India today?
    2
  838. A great analysis as usual. When many want to befriend you, maybe you really have Something. Caution is the word, though. Tailpiece: “…who is friend and foe?…”. Is the Q about outsiders or insiders… for a moment I was in doubt. Just saying.
    2
  839. Beware! A fool even after changing his mind may remain a fool.
    2
  840. Kalatheeswaran TM Anything that comes naturally should continue as such. This is different. If this programme changes we will not learn...but become victims of the binary syndrome of the general media. Knowledge will not permeate beyond politics
    2
  841. What exactly is “State Capitalism” ? The phrase is an oxymoron. If the CPC controls the Chinese businesses, how will the world react? What will happen to its “aid” friends like Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Nepal(?) etc… This will have a direct bearing on the economy of the region and of India. Probably much more than what the “agenda based” WSJ may be saying. Tail piece. A good commentary. But unfortunately WSJ speaks less (truth) about countries in the region. We will have to take that in while referring to WSJ works. While we must read publications like WSJ, we have to realize they are not gospel.
    2
  842.  @EBZ-bx7zc  QED.
    2
  843. The media always stands up for the rights of its citizens and touts freedom of every kind at the drop of a hat. So, it is intriguing why does not the media come out vehemently against those who willfully and repeatedly violate the constitutional rights of millions of citizens by blocking and disrupting public conveniences. Media has an obligation...
    2
  844. True
    2
  845. Yes SG, it is different…your presentation…. What all politics these days and perpetual elections in India etc…. Indicate is that we need a more erudite, determined opposition talking about India rather than on Modi, RSS and religions. Tailpiece: AAP is an indication….but obviously they are new and not all that well organized as yet.
    2
  846.  @pp_01123  PP, so you feel that this thing about wealth and distribution was “revealed” for the first time in ES20-21. This is something known to mankind since Millennia!!! Enjoy.
    2
  847. Correct. Too many contradictions leading to doubt the intend
    2
  848. Illogical. Don’t make India Delhi centric just because it is the seat of GOI… India is much too diverse. SG, have you got this wrong? I suspect
    2
  849. When the dust settles down, it will be realized that the “tour of duty” is a good programme to enable the youth of the Nation and may be detrimental to the efficiency of the Armed Forces. It is damning to see how political parties do not see beyond the party and are ready to do anything, even destroy the fabric of society, for power and wealth? Hopefully the Nation will one day, soon, see through these machinations of vested interests. Tailpiece: Gotta see how a balance in the Agnipath can be stuck. May require mid term course corrections. And one more point….. the great thing about the laggard Indian democracy is that for every good leader you get an equally good misleader. Validates Newton’s first law of motion
    2
  850. Disclaimer: I stand for Human Rights and have always strived for it. The guy with the gun is always the fall guy when the other is supposedly unarmed. He is not human. Being armed against the unarmed is an unequal fight. Right? When the enemy is invisible (often from your own family) it gets worse. So, let it be? Of course not. There are unfortunate incidents in all the armies in war and in peace. I will recommend a movie on Netflix (I assure you I am not being paid for this) ”The Liberator”, to get an idea of conflicts and human rights.
    2
  851.  @DKSingh-wf8tn  you must create..worth it
    2
  852. Kya idea hain sirji!
    2
  853. Dig the hole deeper…develop easy accessibility…. 6 way lanes..metro etc…. Sort of makkan on the parotta Tailpiece: Alternately give to DLF, wait for a decade
    2
  854. Good analysis. In brief….I wonder why the Captain allowed himself to be needled. Look at Yeddi of Karnataka - with all his warts he holds his ground.
    2
  855.  @anshuraj4277 The burden of proof in the Indian judicial system is too heavy. That is the reason why cases in the Indian courts take decades for conclusion. The criminals, including the political variety, know this only too well. The media plays along with the liberals by default and / or design. Reflect. Whose National is it anyway?
    2
  856. I wonder whether the Left will cut into BJP cotes or will it be the other way, considering the Left was in absolute power in WB for decades.
    2
  857. Very data centric dissection of the most job (unskilled) generating sector.
    2
  858. We often want the President to intervene more in Governments. We do not want Governors to intervene in Government matters. Just noticing. Tailpiece: Democracy is NOT absolute. Shall we say?
    2
  859. All quite on the Afghan front? Suits Taliban…more importantly suits the World. (Especially the US). suits Pakistan and just about everybody except the people of Afghanistan. The Western media gorges on the images of the under nourished children of Africa. Well soft “targets” eh? Tailpiece: Sincere media? Just asking.
    2
  860. Win or loose…. Change is good or bad?
    2
  861.  @dullhorse9251  i have no issues. It is a pandemic and pandemics leave untold misery in their wake. My point is we don't need the media to highlight the miseries endlessly. Your comment is more likely to help many
    2
  862. Discussing these "strategies" in a public forum does not benefit anybody, least of all India or the the Indian Defence Establishment. I am sure that the General, an erstwhile Army Commander, is fully aware of this. Hence these discussions raise the question of motive. Is it just that the General and the media feel that by discussing these in such forum the right to freedom of expression etc is upheld? If so, the least I can say is that it is the most irresponsible interpretation of freedom.
    2
  863.  @isabelalbert3478  "experts" ,consultants and media are not accountable for results....they can talk BIG in silos and often get away with murder after enjoying their days in the Sun.
    2
  864.  @anshuraj4277  so Anshu, you mean here in our Nation, you can’t trust the CBI, ED, Police, the federal government, even the people who gave the federal Government a mandate to rule etc… we can now trust only AAP and it’s politicians. Right ? Tailpiece: This is serious. So, what do we do for governance? wWho will govern as anybody coming to power will misuse (or use?) the system to retain power.
    2
  865. Lucid and factual, as usual. Tailpiece: This is real reporting, journalism… with no hidden agenda
    2
  866. A very good view point...let me add my piece as The Print, lets me do it. Thank you, The Print... We have got it wrong all along if we expect politicians to define secularism (religion) and absolve religious leaders and the public at large in the process. Secularism should flow multilaterally and not unilaterally. What exactly is meant in secularism? In religious matters it should simply mean that every religion should be free to pray to its God in a manner each wants – that is assuming that every religion has a God and every one professing that religion wants to pray. In effect, (religious) secularism should simply mean that each religion accepts each of the other religion on as is where is basis. The leaders of these various religions should repeatedly announce to its followers that “there is not only one way (their own) to reach GOD but there are many ways. What the other religions follow are also paths that lead to GOD. Those who practice religions other than ours are also believers of God”. Tell the followers that there is only one God with many names…call it/he/she by any name. Teach the kids this in Schools of all types. All politicians, self-styled “activists” of all types and THE MEDIA should convey this message always and all times. Why is this NOT done? Why are these people especially the activists and the media not seeing it this way? I am afraid we are doing this all wrong.
    2
  867. @john doe yes. That is my point. All support, rightly, is only to that extent...say mutual benefit. The world missed that one on China in the past two decades. I agree. India is no threat to the world or anybody like China. But as in this world a democratic super economic power will dominate, there is no denying that India wants to be an economic power for its own good. Of course, all this is decades ahead.
    2
  868.  zzz g  Even without definitive ambitions India can influence world affairs because of its demography (read, market), overseas Indians etc....It will be a natural process, to influence, if and when India becomes an economic power. Te West and China do not want it to happen.
    2
  869. Everything has a price, but not all prices appear on labels!
    2
  870. Good topic. India had Lost a great economist, MMS, to the vagaries of politics. Another in waiting? Just asking.
    2
  871. Current is not future… current can’t become future in a day..some traveling involved
    2
  872. Good as usual…probing? Tailpiece: Action whole hog after the impending state elections…humor all till then: BJP
    2
  873.  @DKSingh-wf8tn  Yes. Thanks for the response. Agree.
    2
  874. Politics hotting up. Karnataka, nobody’s nothing actually. DK, you have your plate full for the next one year, even with a poor monsoon. Tailpiece: Unwittingly the INC (along with opportunistic allies) will put all its efforts now to “save Rahul G” than “save INC” or Nation. Just saying.
    2
  875. He had / has more to offer! Travelled with him in economy class some time in the late 1990s.
    2
  876. Childish, kindergarten type reply. “We the people” have to accept it? Where are the “liberal” voices? Tailpiece: wonder how serious is this “insult” to democracy and the “diversity” of India by the Leader of the Opposition. Ah! Oh! Then why was SG (Sonia G) saying yesterday that he has already apologized? That was just a liberal statement. Right?
    2
  877.  @kittyman7015  haha, Kitty! We are still alive!!!
    2
  878. Why suppose it will be one? You can as well put forth your expectations without this negative and preconceived headline. Just saying
    2
  879. Terming the riots as a show of power of any group is fallacious. Rioters don’t wield power. They are at best criminals. Please don’t make heroes of them. Religion of the rioters is immaterial. Tail piece: As an extension, is the media guilty of glorifying rioting and rioters?
    2
  880. Yes run the. Else can the illegal “colonies” of mostly illegal immigrants posing security threat to the area and beyond, remain? Just asking. Tailpiece: Either play politics or run the administration. Chose. You can’t have both.
    2
  881. I like it. Christophe thinks Indians are imbeciles. How Ill informed is he. But he has a view and we will hear it.
    2
  882.  @DKSingh-wf8tn  point taken... Pardon typos
    2
  883. Yes. True. Arrogance is not at top but in the states. MAy be the opposition is a following your commentary. Et us watch. Tailpiece: Congress talks at cross purposes…on the one hand it complains that LOP in RS was not invited to the dinner, but castigates Mamata (not Stalin, not Nitish..) for attending the G20 dinner. (LOP of RS had ignored the RF invite on 15 Aug…that is another story)…. Who’s is scripting INC strategies? A subject for being olitically correct.
    2
  884.  @deepphilip6971  In our type of democracy as opposed to the Presidential system in the USA, is it right to say Modi Government (instead of saying GoI)? In a Presidential system like in the USA, the President is elected separately to run the administration. Hence there it is said Trump administration or Biden administration. Are we aping without thought?
    2
  885. What does this indicate when in the largest democracy we discuss, arguably the biggest and historically a very significant political party, in terms of a family vs the rest? Just asking.
    2
  886. An interesting, bold and relevant presentation, SG. Does art imitate life or is it the other way around? Probably the jury is still out on it. For sure, it is difficult to surpass the music of our times. Tail piece: This program should set the mind to thinking instead of the wagging tongues.
    2
  887. The whole discussion, even in the piece written by Shekar on ThePrints web site, the whole premise seems to be the the BJP is out to get AAP and AAP (including AK) have not committed any crime at all. Various (not one) court proceedings and documents suggest otherwise. But the media fails to highlight this aspect. Tailpiece: Liberalism I suppose.
    2
  888. DK, I have a very simple explanation. The similarity between religion and politics is that in either one does not know where fiction ends and truth (fact) begins and vice versa. In such an environment, agenda based sections exploit the ignorant (both, by design and default). As in religion so in politics. Tailpiece. I suppose this is an occupational hazard in a diverse and democratic society. Forward Ho!
    2
  889. Politics at its best. All for votes - either to get one or deny one. All else is passé. Way to go.
    2
  890. No drama. Played out as per the script. Indian team was not prepared…they were not given a chance / they did not ask for time to,prepare in England under English conditions. They should have been given / they should her demanded at least one 3 day game before the test.
    2
  891.  @ihavenojawandimustscream4681  Hi jawless… all very well. The point I am making is that foreigners from outside the geography (expect for the Mongols briefly) did not rule or colonise China as was done to India by people from Central Asia, Persia and Europe, for centuries. The influence is there for everyone to see vis a vis China etc…. Enjoy. Thanks for the response.
    2
  892.  @anantdhyani2882  Thanks. All true. But the “diversity” is internal to the geography and not imported (from Persia, Central Asia and Europe etc…) like in India. This difference is the difference! Enjoy.
    2
  893. The ideal and desirable situation no doubt. To get something (good will or whatever) we have to give something ( read money) We did not have enough. China had/have. So Sri Lanka and Nepal went the China way. Burma was/is politically undependable. Yet, we are doing our bit and these countries are seeing friendship with India may be better than cozying up to China. Let us watch
    2
  894. All religious texts have flaws because they were written / compiled by humans in a time and space much different from the present. While preserving the ideals (in mind, thought etc..) the methods (visuals) have to change. Respective religious leaders fail in their duty to bring this up and make corrections. In the circumstance the media (as usual, the know all) assume the responsibility and do it all wrong. The untruth (exploiters) have a field day and laugh all the way to the Bank. Get real.
    2
  895. CCS? I can see some extra people, who are not part of CCS.
    2
  896. Getting the “opposition together” is a recipe for retrograde movement of the economy. Sample this.. 1. Regional parties will have parochial interests in all policies. 2. “Dynastic” parties, proclaimed religious parties like the Muslim leagues, Akali etc, clan based parties, caste based parties (Dalit etc…) and those parties with support base among minorities will have their own agenda... 3. If India needs to progress a Common Minimum Programme is not enough. We need a Common Maximum Programme. 4. With CMP etc India will be designed to remain a laggard democracy…while China, Bagaladesh and rest of the world have raced ahead since decades just because of our “Politics for Power”. Tailpiece: Whose Nation is it anyway? Definitely not of the power (at any cost) hungry..just saying
    2
  897. “Save future”. Is that not the aim of all,politicians? In most cases the priority is not the electorate - except just enough to garner votes. Tailpiece: The media will do well to stop discussing politicians and maximize discussions on development, policies, progress etc…..politicians are less important than their actions for the electorate
    2
  898. My comment on this video has been removed. Can you tell me why? Will be much obliged. I have reposted. Don't know if it will stay. It has not stayed. I wonder why. Is it because I am critical of such surveys and our media echoing them as if the world has come to end?
    2
  899.  @TheKyahua  Fayad your reality may not be THE reality, that is why the rest of India and the world have different views. Possible? Maybe. No? O
    2
  900.  @anonymousboy8802  hi anonymous. This hiding behind anonymity itself speaks volumes about why you say what you say. Enjoy. Take care. Keep hiding.
    2
  901.  @TheKyahua  Fayad, but a lage part of the big world (not only India) out there do not view it the same way as you do, especially where the Indian economy is today. I wonder why. May be I am not all that well informed. I will read up more . Thanks. Enjoy.
    2
  902. Diwali greetings to team , ThePrint. Forward Ho!
    2
  903. As usual a good declutter… very informative programme. To emerge from a laggard democracy, some unpopular “reforms” and policies are essential for a Nation. To make real progress, Governments have to take this risk of perceived dissatisfaction among voters; many don’t; to counter this phenomenon, Governments either have to be confident of a dedicated voter base or face being voted out. Dance of democracy. Only some have gumption.
    2
  904. Something missing here in this comment. For there to be a left (equitable distribution, socialism, subsidies) there has to be a right (wealth creators) else their won’t even be leftovers. Where in this world does religion feed aNation?
    2
  905. I agree.. Mr. Swamy's Much ado about nothing... Just for TRP. Totally different evrything... LOC and Gaza... Comparison...? Seriously?
    2
  906. Itna intezar Kiya.. Thoda aur Sahi...kya Jaldi hain. Typical case of unnecessary media hype!!!! The Print needs to be different
    2
  907. SG, well explained… but each time you skip the matter of India relinguishing fishing rights in 1976
    2
  908. Haha… simple and revealing…. Now that such issues of Chinese economy are being discussed in detail outside the WALL, does it mean CCP hold on China is weakening? Interesting subject for Shekhar Tailpiece: A National interest subject… yes, of the Chinese Nation.
    2
  909. Besides the RE issue, China has problems with increasing debt, reducing consumption, reducing manufacturing, exiting foreign money, reducing exports, increasing unemployment etc… just saying
    2
  910. A typical example of political expediency in so much as to take a portion of the electorate for a ride. How competent are our politicians to talk about religion? It is time we the people sit up and take hold of the society. There is no absolute definitions for secularism and Hindutva. The meanings of these words are defined by individuals as per their desired perception. Therein lies the paradox. These words matter little except to raise agenda based controversies. There can be a life without these words too. A better, more rewarding life. We the people have to see through the politics in these words and just ignore /stop using these words. Tail piece: Unless we change the basic narrative in the society, the politicians (even very senior, elderly inconsequential ones) will exploit and the people will let themselves be exploited by design or by default.
    2
  911. Super analysis. All facts… kudos. Tailpiece: The Nepalese soldiers issue had to come to a head someday. Nepal is becoming more and more independent, if you may.
    2
  912. Some points possibly missed out / not highlighted by SG. 1. Chita Ramakrishna (CR) has been working with SEBi since late 1980s. 2. CR was involved in the automation process Almost since inception. 3. Co-location of servers was permitted in NSE around 2009. 4. Some brokers in collusion with some employees of NSE exploited the arrangement. 5. The misuse came to the fore in 2015 through a whistle blower 6. CR “case” is as reported and possibility of further. Misuse of power is under investigation. 7. The SEBI (regulating body) is under fire for treating the whole matter lightly through its report released last week. These are a collation from various media reports. Tailpiece: Most times it is not always what it is what you see.
    2
  913. Is politicians condoling the Great singer’s passing, deserving of special mention? Just asking. Don’t put the politicians on a pedestal where they don’t belong. Just saying. Tailpiece: Lataji can’t just go away. She is one of those eternal voices.
    2
  914. So the blackcaps had a Jammie session?
    2
  915. One day the bill will become due as it always does.
    2
  916. I agree, NYT has a reputation. But don’t get carried away, its views ARE prejudiced. Let us not ignore that.
    2
  917. Who is the target audience, Snehesh?
    2
  918. There never was, is or will be a Utopia. If there is democracy there will be politics (or politics will be applied to any and everything). When there is politics there will be commentators, analysts, media, experts, spokespersons and now PR agencies to handle digital media. Politics in a democracy is the best employer in terms of numbers. Long live democracy. Tailpiece: But my experience of more than half a century in public life, shows that the final word is Roti,, kapda, Makkan.
    2
  919. All the analysis boils down to just one aspect... In cricket we have seen this play out time and again...The quicky comes speeding, sends in a couple of short balls, mouths some expletives and sees the batsman squirm. That is a sign for him to dominate the player and the game. But if the batsman pulls one of the short balls over the square leg or the midwicket fence, the wind is taken out of the pacer's sail. He quietens down. It is time for India to take fresh guard. It is good to know that it is already happening. Never mind the rhetoric.
    2
  920. Well done…either way, it is accepted for decades that an ani India lobby is at plat across the world
    2
  921. Thanksgiving is fast approaching!
    2
  922. With malice to none....especially to ILA whose programs are full of information. A wild thought... Will the solution be for the Government to step aside and hand over the Finance and related ministries to the many “experts” who tell the Nation what is the solution for an economic recovery? After all if they have solutions why NOT give them a chance to execute it. As a concerned citizen I will welcome the move and overlook the form and rules etc... I wonder how many agree with me.
    2
  923.  @rosaborrajo8540  i presume you are not Indian. In hindsight you are right. In the dynamics of Indian politics and rules I am not sure who could have mandated the cancellation of the rallies. The Kumbh is another kettle of fish. Surely people could have been dissuaded from attending the event. India, a huge country , with 13369 lakh people is a difficult country to govern. A Pandemic does not help in the efforts either.
    2
  924. I am aware that this TOT “officer” exists in all such deals. Wonder what Swasti is suggesting. Please clarify. I feel this is an incorrect information transmitted to the public. Secondly what may be required for India is more and better Research ecosystem involving universities and the private sector Stay well
    2
  925. .2 % is 43 untraceable contacts vs 16000 tests
    2
  926.  @akshayagrawal5114  okay, Akshay, aisa hin karta hun ksl se. Phir bhi, enjoy. Maje karo...
    2
  927.  @sunlight2078  thanks “young” boy.
    2
  928.  @Vizorfam  I donnot feel so. Religion etc. is only a facade raised by vested interests. Indian people are now looking beyond the facade. They are "smelling the coffee", Roti, kapda and makkan which only development can provide. Let us also discuss development and not religion and play into the hands of the scheming few who raise the bogey of religion. Enjoy. Forward Ho!
    2
  929. off the cuff is a notch better and more informative than "Walk the Talk". Benefits of being your own boss?
    2
  930. A better statement would ha been “ How Mumbai etc.. are forced to bring back to contain the spread of omicron”. The cities are not doing it as a luxury.
    2
  931. Chess Olympiad is being in Chennai these days. It has been organized very well, technically, administratively and efficiently by TN Govt and Govt of India vividly showcasing culture. Chennai, TN and India are on the world stage there. Real federalism. Tailpiece: Now chess is a game of employing tactical moves vide a planned strategy. 32 pieces on 64 squares present immense variations. It seems, going by the moves, the BJP (I am not a member, but a common INDIAN) has learnt to play chess well. It may be well worth for the opposition MPs to visit the Chess Olympiad and learn the moves
    2
  932. Great. It makes me wonder what were the “people” (the society) doing in Manipur during the despicable act by a crowd? Balme everybody in the world. But blame the society and the people of Manipur too for not "thrashing" the perpetrator but taking videos and cheering. Does anybody feel we the people" are beyond reproach for such despicable acts in society. Tailpiece. Therein lies a truth that feel that all of us are the people are beyond blame for the ills in society whereas we should be the ones at the forefront to prevent such acts. Media should not shield the society.
    2
  933. Irritating presentation of news…just to hold us I….. pathetic journalism
    2
  934. Lucid analysis. The poll outcome in Karnataka has also established beyond any doubt. 1. That democracy is very well alive and kicking in India. 2. Both the electoral process and the voting machines function effectively and truthfully. Tailpiece: We in Karnataka, look forward to efficient administration in public services, which has been poorly managed for at least the last two decades. And ah! Polarization in INDIAN POLITICS - Dalit party, Muslim leagues, Akalis, caste based parties, parochial - DMK, AIADMK, TMC, Telangana congress, YSR congress , LOK Dal, Gomantak, Shiv Sena - has existed for decades. Is the media trying to give a new flavor to polarization? Is that a right approach?just asking.
    2
  935. Which party…Political or cocktail?
    2
  936. Yet the congress has won one state and is second in two states…Do we get a two party democracy at National level ….hopefully..Google for Bharat… Tailpiece: Time for the “Gandhi to take a real backseat…. India hopes
    2
  937. It is sad that the hostages “release” is played out in the media like an OTT serial.. season 2?
    2
  938. I see the propaganda…go ahead
    2
  939. Is Al Jazeera a HAMAS mouth piece?
    2
  940. 1.4b - 10000 people of India are sick of this political one upmanship played out by “adults” who have the nation’s rein. Please grow up
    2
  941. Great economist , yes definitely. Unfortunately , he did not have any freedom as PM (well known). He did not have the freedom to even "advice " the UPA. Narasimha Rao gave him freedom and he excelled. But... M
    2
  942. Any change that don’t leave the Gandhis out of mainstream is a non starter; will be an exercise in futility. Just saying.
    2
  943. Right. You ask Q when an answer is required. When a Q is asked assuming you know the answer it is that shows ignorance. Tailpiece: I would urge all reporters (especially from the “West” to read the 2004 book “Cold Terror” by Stewart Bell
    2
  944. How many Indians are VHP followers? Less than .1% I suppose. Simultaneously the media should also carry the appeal of RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat to end this shenanigan of looking for idols under every mosque. Instead the media should appeal to MUSLIMS to accept the past and Hinduism as a reality. Tailpiece: The solution for amity is as simple,e as that. All sides accept the past acknowledge the existence of each other and build a future for our children.
    2
  945.  @sanjaysable2006  Sanjay.... I am talking of post event dissemination which was done post demonetisation too. The Govt need not have to go to the people for taking every decision. But they should infirm the people of the benefits etc if decision. Govts are not enemies of the people, unless you mean to make political comments. Enjoy.
    2
  946.  @sanjaysable2006  The decision is within the authority of the Cabinet…no issue there. The problem is that reducing the pension bill (and not improving the Defence capability) is the reason is a bit disconcerting; more so because more than 50% of the Defence pension outlay goes to Defence civilians, whose strength is only about 20% of the veterans. Here, we are inclined to think, restructuring this Defence civilian organization may have been a better approach.
    2
  947. Bob…. It is not about one tax or the other….. it is the amateurish approach towards the economy in twenty first century…. Economy is not only about distribution it is also about wealth creation.. yo can distribute wealth only if you have it and can continuously create it… it can’t be done in a socialist freebie type economy…. This is NOT about politics of Sanghis or Congis…it is about India and the next generation
    2
  948. In 1950 I studied in a vernacular government school I’m North Malabar. Muslims were not barred from joining the school. But only few Muslim boys joint school and only a handful of Muslim girls. Muslims need to introspect
    2
  949. INC’s reaction reminds me of the story of the ostrich which when encountered with danger buries it’s head in the sand and hopes the danger will pass by. Tailpiece: Yes the Nation needs a strong “opposition” … not in words but in deeds. I hope the INC during its course of agitations against the price rise etc., also tell us what has led to the price rise and recommend actions to curb the same
    2
  950. Good discussion – informative My twobit 1. Trudeau held on to power, not because of his capability, but because the Canadian system allowed him to do so. 2. In international diplomacy and relationships does individuals matter beyond the optics? But change in leadership may provide the administration course correction opportunities 3. In all discussions all subjects have a side beyond politics... The Print may consider these points. Thank you
    2
  951.  @ht5389  i respect your views. But disagree. I suppose, you have no way of knowing how I firm my views. Thar is an un-called for and ignorant comment. Enjoy , Stay safe..
    2
  952. But unfortunately a poor performer as a PM, an “appointment” he should have rejected.
    2
  953. Please do not decry democracy and attribute political motive to an investigation without sufficient reasons. An extract from the judgement in Disha Ravi’s (DR) case as published in sections of media… “…It is not mere engagement with persons of dubious credentials which is indictable rather it is the purpose of engagement which is relevant for the purpose of deciding culpability…” When there is a suspicion, as in this case where DR contacted persons of dubious credentials ( as established by the state) and tried to conceal her identity, there is always a case for investigation as to the purpose. We can’t say that such matters should not be investigated. In this case democratic ways as laid down was followed in the investigation. Taking into custody, the courts, bail etc. is a process of investigation in a real democracy. So once again, please do not decry our democracy. Also note that there have been hundreds of thousands of supporters in social media and such platforms Disclaimer: I believe in the innocence of Disha Ravi. But more than that I believe in the process of investigation, which is absolutely necessary here, as a democratic process. Tail piece: I want to believe Justice will prevail. When one attempts the extraordinary, it is but natural to encounter the extraordinary.
    2
  954. The advice from Pannun to Trudeau (self proclaimed adviser, no denied by Trudeau) is reveling and dangerous in a democracy that claims to follow the rule of Law. Canada?
    1
  955. Of Zelenski is not sacrosanct. Back stabbing is Brutusish
    1
  956. Elementary… overpricing and manipulation…. Just two reasons
    1
  957. EM is rich… should he be getting such attention for what he says just because he has money and nothing much else
    1
  958.  @sandrathompson1277  Khalistan activists are terrorists in some parts of the world as are Al Queda in some parts of the world. QED. This has nothing to do with women… you are safe. Enjoy
    1
  959.  @sandrathompson1277  ha! Hypocrisy at its best, Sandra.
    1
  960. I wonder if Canada, Britain and such “democracies” will allow AlQuida to hold such protests on their soil… will I get a reply from. Canadian authorities?
    1
  961. Why is there no widespread condemnation of such vitriolic rhetoric in the media…. Where are the intellectuals and experts hiding
    1
  962. Contradictions force coalitions…else why coalitions? No two Nations can align all their respective interests…
    1
  963. Reportage is not free speech but hate speech is freedom of expression… Wah Trudeau, saab
    1
  964. For a large section of the media any policy decision in India by any government is “politics” and not governance. By the yard stick employed in discussions as here and elsewhere in the media there can never ever be governance. What a pitiful media. Tailpiece. This approach by the media since decades has been a bane that kept India a laggard democracy. A shame
    1
  965. Routine or damage control is also diplomacy…. At its best…. Positive thinking
    1
  966. Interesting. Türkiye anti Israel and Pro Israel…. In different geographies. Multilateral world is here
    1
  967.  @cosmopolitanwonder9675  Hi Cos! “It is bigger than you think”…. Okay, please tell me why you feel so. As I said Nepal after all is another country which can make its own choices.
    1
  968. Great. It makes me wonder what were the “people” (the society) doing in Manipur during the despicable act by a crowd? Balme everybody in the world. But blame the society and the people of Manipur too for not "thrashing" the perpetrator but taking videos and cheering. Does anybody feel we the people" are beyond reproach for such despicable acts in society. Tailpiece. Therein lies a truth that feel that all of us are the people are beyond blame for the ills in society whereas we should be the ones at the forefront to prevent such acts. Media should not shield the society.
    1
  969.  @LionKing-vd3oi  oh Lion. I do not think I was discussing the right of Palestinians. I was just discussing the weapons used by the deplorable terrorist group (large, yes) HAMAS. Have a nice day.
    1
  970.  @LionKing-vd3oi  Lion king, that is the problem. As reflected in your post many think the other does not know anything. Wherein in my post have I said that HAMAS is small or they are not supported by regimes who traditionally support terrorism and militancy …. At the end of the day HAMAS is firing from the shoulders of helpless Palestinians. You too are firing from behind anonymity. Period.
    1
  971. The MOST powerful weapon of HAMAS are the civilians…..not their arsenal. If only the terrorists were not among the dense civilian population, it would have taken just one day to annihilate the, do not be mistaken by them, I mean HAMAS and Not repeat NOT Palestines. Tailpiece: Media should get its narrative correct….
    1
  972.  @harrylowe6438  There are many Brits who feel otherwise. Obviously cutting taxes was never a good idea to steady the economy. Proved right. Skin colour does not affect the brain.
    1
  973. With Sunak at the Helm, maybe , India may have helped Britain to tide over the crisis!!!!! Just saying.
    1
  974. Unity for development or just for electoral gains….? The media should discuss prove administrative capabilities of leaders in politics rather than their political “achievements” for their respective parties. We the people care about developments. Tailpiece: All religious leaders need to have guts enough or rein in their followers from creating grounds for political exploitation. The problem is not religion in politics or vice versa, it RELIGION in SOCIETY.
    1
  975. 80% of what is happening (including in mainstream media and social media (all the more), in regard to politics (more so in electoral politics) is drama as part of distraction of the public (voters)who are considered “ Puppets “ (katputhli) controlled by emotional strings.
    1
  976.  @maquacr7014  "Ḥadīth or Athar in Islam refers to what the majority of Muslims believe to be a record of the words, actions, and the silent approval of the Islamic prophet Muhammad as transmitted through chains of narrators. In other words, the ḥadīth are transmitted reports about what Muhammad said and did." Maquua, it has been a very informative and satisfying duscussion with you. I will cintinue to learn. If we and especially our children want to live in an atmosphere of love, religions have to evolve and change. Thank you. Bye. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    1
  977.  @maquacr7014  sure Maqua... These add ons...like in all religions the followers added "customs etc to control and discriminate. IN AL RELIGIONS. This exactly is my point... Discriminate and Control. I repeat, in ALL religions.
    1
  978.  @maquacr7014  I wonder where in the Holy script ( the original holy script and not the add on) is it said explicitly that women should be covered all over in public. Prove the positive..that they should wear. The negatives prove themselves as they are not written. I am not arguing for or against any religion. Exploitation and misrepresentations are part of all religions. . Religions are man made as none of them is as old as the Homo sapiens.Enjoy. Stay safe
    1
  979.  @maquacr7014  OK. Though I have read all texts... I have not memorised them or studied them. But I can tell that all of them (of ALL religions ) have been written by Humans (scholars ? As you say) fir a time and space as visualised at the time of writing.All have flaws. I grew up among Muslims and studied in a jesuit school more than half a century back. I have relatives and friends from different religions . So from experience , I can tell.
    1
  980.  @maquacr7014  The major problem are these so called "religious scholars" whi mislead. You need not be a scholar to know the basics. For e. g. Ine need not beca scientist to know Newton's laws of motion.
    1
  981.  @Cyrano1971  Stay blessed
    1
  982.  @MichToJoshya  Yes. But when some, after an M Phil or Phd, talk like running a Nation or organising the Defence of a large country like India can be handled in drawing room discussions, you can’t let them get away. Such commentaries mislead a lot of gullible fellow Indians and provide a rallying point for the ignorant and mischief mongers.
    1
  983. Another event to study. Yes. But all given the British Society is not Indian society. At least in majority India. That said, could there be other reasons for the party to oust Boris? Just asking. Yeah sure, you are right in saying that Boris J was never a boring PM. Tail piece: Higher standard of British propriety? Really? Since when?
    1
  984. And one more point… There are generations of soldiers serving in the Defence forces. Carrying forward SG’s argument, do we have a dynastic Defence Force? Your call. Tailpiece: Dynasty is about dynastic control of an institution, Party or Nation. In India, DMK, NCP, Shiv Sena, SP, TNC, INC, Akali Dal, NC, Biju JD etc which are forever controlled by dynasties are dynastic parties. A father/mother/son/daughter in politics together etc. is not about dynasts. Let us get the distinction right.
    1
  985. After so s so many many decades, are we still surprised about the nexus of terrorism on our West? Tailpiece: I heard some one say that Pak and China are coming “closer” because we are not cozying up to Pakistan. Ah!!!
    1
  986. Whither democracy. When the Nation is battling a once in a 1.5 life time Pandemic (by nature unpredictable), the constitutional institutions are busy apportioning blame. In a democracy, it is a given that the Government will be the punching bag. So be it. Governments change. But legacies left behind by constitution institutions stay to haunt the Nation. It is damning to see that the even so called pillars of democracy are engaged in sparring, deflecting attention from the real issue of the pandemic. Tail piece: Not even once, not even a single time has the highest offices of justice admonished the public for not following COVID appropriate behaviour. Any one can become intelligent and know-all in hindsight! Even MLAS and media.
    1
  987. The best advantage Afghan has is the terrain. Like the Vietnamese jungles which did in the US in 1960s, it is the mountains in Afghanistan that has defeated the USA and allies. Not brain, intelligence etc of fighters. To say that a major political party of a sovereign state needs to change its politics to “woo” Taliban may be preposterous. If you meant, foreign policy, OK. Good programmes, like this analysis, in The Print are negated by unthnking headings of some of its videos! SG? Tail piece. Cross your heart and tell me whether religion in politics, in India, is a creation of BJP which is only 3+ decades old. Disclaimer. I am not an eternal supporter of any political party.
    1
  988.  @neellss  1. less than 5% of population do not reflect a trend. 2. Durian the pandemic India has not issued stimulus Cheques to feed people 3. I have also lived in the US and visited all those countries and more (except China as a country, but have set foot on its soil) . We are handling more than 13369 lakh people. It is easy to paint a pathetic picture with selected pictures and cases. Request do not indulge in these selective opinions. You, I feel, are more intelligent than to be doing that. Maybe you have had a bad personal experience with your boss. Don’t generalize what is not. And, you think, nobody sucks to the boss in ,say, USA. Just asking
    1
  989.  @neilpina898  the poverty in India is similar in ratio and feeling as in any advanced Nation. The poor here are poorer. Rest assured nobody goes hungry in India.
    1
  990. A very simplistic way of putting it. The point at issue WHAT is good for India? A peaceful and progressive Afghanistan. There a civil war is in the offing between Government forces and the Taliban. There will be chaos in the region and loose mercenaries who can be activated in Kashmir by Pakistan. Now tell us WHAT is a good action plan by India; to use your words “ What is good for India?”
    1
  991. I know RS means well. I suppose he also roots for all Nehru stadiums to be renamed too. As we are on the subject why not rename all airports after our air heroes? Tailpiece: We yearn for an erudite opposition. We do not want a “Kuchdi” of an opposition, each constituent with only one common agenda, defeat BJP. When that is done….what next?
    1
  992. Self reliance is the key. We did not start the process decades back. Unfortunate. Having said that, Will taking a middle path in the circumstance hurt India in the long run, is a moot point. If seen with an open mind, India has options. Tailpiece: Hypocrisy almost always fails.
    1
  993. Simply sulking….. not expected from INC
    1
  994. A part of Nation has to work ahead at saving livelihoods. Else more lives are likely to be lost in the next decade.
    1
  995. It will be nice in your discussion to stay upfront what is working and then get on to what is not working or the improvements
    1
  996. Yes, we need to concentrate on this area of economy. This is the real battleground and not LAC. I feel India is aware and fighting on this (economy) front. It is not easy. Tailpiece: China uses LAC as. distraction. It is time we smelled the coffee.
    1
  997. Congress can be THAT party, possibly the only one at National level, to challenge the BJP if it promotes pluralism as opposed to secularism ( not possible as long as The Constitution and Govt policies discriminate based on castes and religions) and work towards a uniform civil code with and intent of purpose towards development.
    1
  998.  @reach2prasanna  yes. I suppose, thankfully, that is what the Indian electorate is doing.
    1
  999.  @reach2prasanna  Prasanna, thanks for your response. Exactly my point. Many leaders, experts, media persons and such speak for the Nation in the same vein as I have spoken. They interview a few persons (already readied? may be) and project it as "public opinion". But none of them any time have sought my view on any of the subject on which all of them express the "View of the Nation". I accept that I have no authority to speak on behalf of 1.3 billion people. No body has, except "We the people" Regards
    1
  1000. I wonder why the police always ( I am hearing these same accusations, highlighted by the media, by all detained activists for more than 50 years) "misbehave" with activists and create a deja vu situation. A long tail piece: In any protests are only those arrested / detained for whatever reasons are known as activists? Why do some people think that only they care about farmers, labourers etc. and media highlights that? Is it a case of only perception? I can assure you that "We the people" respect all of our citizens, including farmers and labourers, as we have been for decades. I can also assure you with an experience of seeing various Governments in states and the centre for more than 50 years, that they may have been inefficient, but surely none of them have been enemies of its own people.
    1
  1001. Any idea Thrown up for discussion need not necessarily be when there is a majority for a party in both houses. There are contradictions here in this presentation for once. 1. BJP or Modi is not perpetual while ONOE if gets through is permanent. 2. If anything is passed by a majority, it is termed as majoritarianism. 2. This sort of discussion, like this one on ONOE and such policies accentuating Politics in everything is cheating the viewer of the real benefits/losses from the policy. And so on…. Tailpiece: can we have discussions on policies like ONOE…? If elections are to be covered term it as electiins… there was nothing here on ONOE:(
    1
  1002. The need for leadership changes in Congress party (for God’s sake, it is our Nation which requires an erudite opposition). Just saying. Tailpiece: Is there a more obvious signal than “the writing on the wall”? After all whose Nation is it anyway?
    1
  1003. Global South and India….like look here see there…. Such a vision helps:):):)
    1
  1004. Good analysis as usual. A major difference from old times of decades ago is that the people are more aware and have a taste of another major party, with a dedicated following, forming Governments in the states and at the centre. Some regional parties are stronger. Tailpiece: We can’t apply templates to anything in these dynamic times. Refreshing actually. And one more point. Are we here attempting to compare Indira Gandhi to Rahul G. Well…..
    1
  1005. Are we to understand that India the experts in Government etc. do not know what they are doing?
    1
  1006. A thought in passing - apolitical and only to highlight governance aspects. With some sections of the media and few experts "predicting" a defeat for BJP in the ensuing elections, I hope the party at least gets to be the main opposition to take care of national issues while the I.N.D.I. alliance is busy handling parochial and vote bank matters. Tail piece: whose National is it anyway
    1
  1007. The question remains. Whose Nation is it anyway? We know to who the party belongs.
    1
  1008.  @prastagus3  conversely these Supee powers as you say are also disposable. And ah! No SP can sustain by itself.... It will collapse immediately without support
    1
  1009.  @prastagus3  of course it is also a view to which you have a right. That the world is discussing India seriously means it has some power. Super or otherwise it is wrong to think only money is power. Knowledge is power… civilized past is power…. Work is power…. Stereotypes will not work in this world any longer… Enjoy
    1
  1010.  @prastagus3  Prastagus, opportunism is not when you know what you are doing and creating the opportunities. Opportunism is when you are a a loss and see an opportunity along the way and grab it. It is deftness when one is sure and knows what one is doing and foresees where one is going. India is doing it right. BTW is it your case India takes sides with The US? Just asking Enjoy, stay well
    1
  1011. Political action in Kashmir needed. Great revelation. Do you think, elsewhere too, there is more intent in legislative actions these days? The handloom bit was joyful...having schooled in Cannanore (Kannur now, can be googled!!), love that fabric. Thanks
    1
  1012. Simple, Shekhar…. Deliberate action to lead USA on… and tell them we know! If you get what I mean…. Probably in the past maybe we were “scared” to. call out the nefarious games definitely and surely played by the USA in meddling in the internal affairs of other sovereign nations . aadmi ke liye ishara Kafi hain A. It the clutter on this? The activities of USA and the scared third world of the past
    1
  1013. A different “story”, regional presented in the inimical style of SG. Informative. Tailpiece: But…can’t miss “….part of Indian map” and “….what we cal POK”. Why?
    1
  1014. Phew! Alas, I wonder if the venerable Pew has considered it takes more than one entity to integrate. Integration requires adjustments from all who wish to integrate. It is difficult for those who feel “My way is high way” to integrate. Tail piece: I wonder, after living in the free country for decades, why would one require such views to realize where we are or what is good for us Indians. And our media, grabs such surveys for TRP? Readership? 133 billion Indians should know better.
    1
  1015. It is all about winning…. If criteria for voting is beyond the candidate…. The candidate matters less for a win..but mat serve subsequent causes better…
    1
  1016. Yes, a real test to capitalism in India. Or again, is it? A brief take on its effect on macroeconomy of India… , very briefly, in this case of Adani group of Companies, the major issue raised in the Hindenburg report is the offshore Shell companies (owned by the family, hence violating related party transactions dictate) used for round tripping for inflating the stock prices of group companies to raise capital by pledging the group companies’ thus overvalued securities. Though not correct, yet not new to Indian industries! It is pertinent to note here in this case, that the money so raised has been invested in visible and tangible assets (Ports and cash generating companies etc.) in the country. Thus, the assets of the group exceed loan liabilities with enough cashflow in the group and ability to service the debts in the near term, (3-4 years) as per major lenders in the country. Ports, Power, Cement, Green energy etc. are industries unlikely to fail with potential to continually generate cash. I do not foresee any short term or long-term danger to the Indian economy from this event – gains and losses in the stock market notwithstanding. Yes, the ability to raise fresh capital by the group will be dented and there will be scrutiny and some possible investigations. Tailpiece: My observations are only on the impact on Indian economy and NOT on whether any political party has benefitted (we are in a DEMOCRACY) or on any possible violations by the Group etc. which will reveal itself. Another important point to note is that the aim of Hindenburg is obviously to make money by short selling (That is what this company does for a living) and not “help” Indian economy in any way.
    1
  1017. May be we must stop comparing Pakistan with India except in cricket….Not even in hockey. Just saying.
    1
  1018. Know this, the names of parties and politicians do not matter in the least. We will travel a blinkered path as long as long as people who work for a living are outnumbered by those who vote for a living. “We the people” have to get out of this rut. The general perception is that corruption always involves money. Even if all political parties dishonestly take Rs. 10,000 crores per year from the exchequer, it will not make any significant difference in progress or development. What hurts most is that all political parties are ethically corrupt and they carry practice into matters of governance as well. The modus operandi is not important to the point being made here. Also there is not enough place here to discuss the kaleidoscopic overt and covert unethical practices of these parties. The politicians and the media by their utterances channelize our feelings and not our thoughts. This exploitation of feelings may sound the death knell of liberal democracy in India and all over the world. Democracies are but a puppet show where the people are controlled by emotional strings. Feelings are not cosmic powers. They surely do not reflect “free will”. In the wake of the aforesaid, the role played by the media in democracies is also suspect. You see, Caesar's wife has to be above suspicion. Is SHE? Tailpiece: While in all democracies across the world people go out and vote, in India the electorate cast(e) their vote! This is but just one small aberration among a million transgressions.
    1
  1019. Don't most Indians relish political talk, with feelings? - especially those with an opinion?
    1
  1020. It just does not matter as long as there are more Indians voting for a living than there are who work for a living. The situation is further compounded when feelings rather than thoughts guide voters! Media too is just fanning the feelings rather than fueling thoughts. All pillars of democracy in India are working at cross purposes. While the people in other democracies go out and vote, most Indians cast(e) their votes. Can the media work truthfully and get the house in order? Yes, one more point. The Congress has to be led by someone who does not have surname of Gandhi or Nehru.
    1
  1021.  @trinity4248  Yes, people are puppets (katputhli) being controlled by these politicians and manipulated through emotions (strings).
    1
  1022. An ideal state, utopia is desired….but can we achieve that state. An equilibrium of independence to ministries and central control…either extremes are bad. How will the balance be decided? Who will decide? What exactly is the balance? All subjective. Tailpiece. The taste of the pudding is in eating. We should concentrate on tasting the pudding.
    1
  1023. True. We still do not know about the inquiry into the 1962 debacle. Never trust elected governments in a democracy. Time for a change of the system?
    1
  1024. Congrats SG. Back to you after decades....a fresh beginning?
    1
  1025. Another nice presentation. Tailpiece: Whatever… today the “Ram temple” is a social issue and not a political one… wonder why the opposition does not see it that way
    1
  1026.  @Anomander5622  Hi! Politics is important in a democracy… But serious and balanced comments are expected from great people, not partisan quips. Now, regards per capita GDP. In India, for per capita gdp to reach $10000 the GDP has to increase to 15 trillion… approx etc,, Now two points. 1. Because there is scope for this expansion, India is better business opportunity where capital should come. For that ease of doing business should improve… Labour laws, land reforms etc… 2. Yet the living conditions is based on PPP. A loaf of bread in the US is $4.2 in India it is under $1. Can write volumes Enjoy
    1
  1027.  @okeng71487  what is your point? You too, like the Canadian fellow, are going in to the USA case… when the subject is about Candian terrorist
    1
  1028.  @libshastra  Not saying anything is also reaction! Especially the media, always wanting a comment :) More powerful is silence. Enjoy.
    1
  1029. Possibly normal healthy individuals have a longer sustained shelf life than “models”.:). Just saying.
    1
  1030. A good subject manufacturing vs services. The only service viable without manufacturing is massage. For that too at least oil is required. Nobody can define direction of debates. That is the unfortunate part. The hungry will also debate about food. He will not be bothered to check the stock availability with FCI. This is the essence and beauty of debates. Life is not only about statistics. In fact it is not about statistics. Some points: 1. All major economies have huge domestic manufacturing in the Defence sector. Produce own weapons, save foreign currency, create jobs, less dependence on others etc… simple. 2. Without TV, phones and other display hardware there will be no OTT and broadcasts. No computer software without hardware. And so on and so forth….. Note: context or no context…. In this context “Services sector is better for climate change” is a non statement. What we must ask is, for instance, do we need 5G? Do we need fuel guzzling cars? Do we require faster jets? Do we require wars? Etc. Etc.
    1
  1031. People behaving better, the key to economic progress. The critical key.
    1
  1032. SG..tussi great Ho! Islamist and not Islamic.. there is a similar difference between Hindutva and Hinduism too.. in a positive for Hindutva, Would you say? Just asking Tailpiece: The business fraternity sees armed conflicts (mostly Islamist) as a threat in the next 2 years but not in the next 10 years… money talks …. Possible truth….let us face it SG, there is no militancy anywhere near Hind… as rampant as the islamists… let us not cry wolf
    1
  1033. ThePrint roots for democracy… it should. When a person is part of a political party, he/she echoes the view of that political party. In the spirit of true democracy when he decides to execise his / her right to switch parties it natural that the person will follow the tenant of the new party. Does not this form part of the freedom much touted by the media… is freedom only calling each other names often snidely applauded by the media? Make up your mind
    1
  1034. Of course now “democracy” Will make a grand return in the forms of protests, road blocks, hartals, strikes, walk outs in parliament, fake narratives (new in the age of digital media), media sensationalism and TRPs etc… cut the clutter on SG?
    1
  1035. Why is The Print giving importance to the uttering of a designated terrorist? Liberalism? Free press? Old habits of chief editor?
    1
  1036. Ah! For once Chinese are forthright? What suits self is the best suit in the hand?
    1
  1037. Who requires a pat? India needs to wake up to the reality at the earliest. On my way from the airport on 26 Dec 2020, after spending over an in the USA, and seeing the plight of NY area in person, I was appalled by how the people in our country were taking it easy. It was as if nothing had changed since I left India in September 2019. All shops open. 50% were not wearing a mask, 30% were wearing it on their chin. Later in the week, out to buy rations, when I asked my vegetable shop fellow why he was not wearing a mask, he replied “Corona has gone, so why wear a mask?”. It was not as if the administration had said so. Because, on the same day while we were driving in our own vehicle, with closed windows and ac on, my wife and I were fined Rs 350/- for not wearing masks inside the car – I was told that it was mandatory. Tailpiece: The problem in our country is not the rules. It is the implementation of the rules by an inadequate, overworked police and paramilitary on a people whose standards self-discipline is abysmal. Let us admit it and strive to improve. I request the media too to highlight this aspect.
    1
  1038. Add on comment. This discussion on climate change effects and carbon emissions should have started soon after the II world war. All the “energy” spent towards nuclear weapons should have been used for energy generation. All the money spent on ICBMs etc. should have been used for research on generation of clean energy. And so on.. and so forth… Tail piece: Discussion on panels and TV by “experts” now will yield little result. People have to cut down on their wants. Governments, now do not have magic wands for creating solutions in a jiffy. Every citizen of this world will need to sacrifice and contribute towards the efforts.
    1
  1039. Disclaimer: Not a political comment. More to do with getting a clear picture. Please do a cut the clutter on the following two topics both of which are political and a strong suite for SG. 1. Post poll violence in West Bengal 2. Why is there not a whimper in political circles on efficacy of EVMS? Thank you.
    1
  1040. I wonder why the picture of both participants are shown smiling as if in happiness. Is that how reporting of grim situations are done? Just asking? Doesn't make a nice picture...considering the caption (heading) of the video. Just saying
    1
  1041. Direct From wiki...poor we are in wealth but... "The Republic of India was the only South Asian country to recognize the Soviet-backed Democratic Republic of Afghanistan in the 1980s, though relations were diminished during the 1990s Afghan civil war and the Taliban government.[3] India aided the overthrow of the Taliban and became the largest regional provider of humanitarian and reconstruction aid to the present day Islamic Republic of Afghanistan.[4][5] Indians are working in various construction projects, as part of India's rebuilding efforts in Afghanistan. Pakistan alleges the Indian intelligence agency R&AW is working in cover to malign Pakistan and train and support insurgents,[6][7][8] a claim rejected strongly by India."
    1
  1042. @UCeYzLC8TUTLniG27TC_OiSQ True. We ARE poor. But the USA wanted Indian boots in Afghanistan. India refused. Whatever the intention of USA, India could easily have had its army in Afghanistan but then what would have happened is a conjecture…
    1
  1043. We are missing the point. The fight is not between two armies. It is a civil war between Government forces and the rebels. SG, you are right about the mind game. The Taliban does not care who it kills but a trained soldier just can’t kill faceless “enemies”. After all the Taliban are afghans. Just like the Naxals ( ok, Maoists) in India are Indians. It baffles me that the USA , or the world, did not see it coming decades back. The Indians knew it. So, not boots on ground. Welfare, yes. Tail piece: It is all about extreme Islamism. Islam has to fight Islam to keep peace with Taliban. A tall order?
    1
  1044. A factual analysis by SG, for sure. As I write this, I hear that Kabul has fallen. If not yet, it will soon. All problems do not have an immediate solution. India will have two failing states to its West. Even if Afghanistan were to remain in medieval times and just eat and fight, I wonder from where will the supply of arms, ammunition to Afghanistan come from. Will Afghanistan’s economy be based purely on drug trafficking? There s yet hope if fingers are pointed against Pakistan (US has no more use of Pakistan now) an its master China. I believe China is considering recognizing the” Taliban”. Yes, interesting and bloody time ahead. Tailpiece: The only immediate problem for India is from cross border terrorism. India can continue extending help to the Afghan people.
    1
  1045. Tom and Jerry! Very apt description. Most politicians, especially in big democracies, are just like cartoon characters who stay live in the minds of people by entertaining them!!!! We the people and the MEDIA should call the bluff of such politicians and political parties and condemn such machinations which stinks of personal ambitions. Progress, development, economic policies etc. are never a major point of discussion in the run up to Indian elections. Pathetic – even by the mainstream media. Giving freebies and promising unaffordable economic concessions and subsidies should be decried. Tailpiece: It is no wonder that India is seen as a laggard democracy, a soft state and easy game. It is time, we the people WOKE UP TO THIS REALITY. Can The Print lead the way to change the narrative?
    1
  1046. In bad taste. We the people do not appreciate such off the cuff remarks from Governors, out of context. Tailpiece: In any case Since when do we expect Pakistan to honour paper unless it is money. Just saying. Accords and treaties are not in PAK vocabulary, in any language.All the more reason to avoid such remarks.
    1
  1047. "Clutter is not just physical stuff. It's old ideas, toxic relationships, and bad habits. Clutter is anything that does not support your better self" - Eleannor Brownn: Clutter definitely needs cutting! Great idea! Great work! A refreshing programme
    1
  1048. We the people send elected members to the parliament to do business on matters of Governance. When they renegade from this constitutional responsibility by walking out of the hallowed Parliament halls or boycott its proceedings, are they not committing an undemocratic act and trampling on the democratic rights of the electorate and the citizens of the Nation? This is a very serious issue which the other “pillars” of democracy should take issue. There just is not a concerted effort from the media to persuade all these elected members to discharge their constitutional duties in earnest. The media should realise that We the people of India have no issues with Freedom Speech and such other freedom which we enjoy in an undiluted measure, which the media feels is trampled upon. That I am able to freely express this view here with no possible retribution says it all. Our elected representatives need to be more responsible towards Governance rather than on rabble rousing. Get to the real issue.
    1
  1049. Only an efficient and free private sector can create wealth which can the be “distributed” to others if necessary. Only private sector can create the required number of jobs. OK. Areas like space and nuclear can’t yet be privatized in India, though these sectors also have been privatized in some other countries. Just imagine…If the IT sector in India were to be with the Public sector!!!!! Tail piece: Wealth will continue to be created by those who create them. GOI did not create Dhirubhai Ambani, Narayana Murthy, Shiv Nadar, Azim Premji, Kiran Majumdar, Uday Kotak, Sachin Bansal, Binny Bansal, Byju Ravindran etc.. Wealth can be created by people without a surname of Adani too. If Byju Ravindran can do it you can too
    1
  1050. It was always known that China will violate agreements; the Q was only when? The “when” has multiple answers. The current time is just one of them. It is also not that India has not been preparing. India is aware and has been constantly beefing up its defenses across the LAC as best as it can. So has been China on their side. On a nebulous border on most of the more than 3500 km length, how can one forever depend on non-military type agreements like no weapons, no firing, no explosions, “I patrol now, you patrol later” etc. An undependable and aggressive China can be expected to violate these norms and play games as and when it suits them. After all the maxim “All is fair in love and war” is enduring. In the absence of a judicial process to decide the border dispute, there are only two options – neither of them is easy or well defined. 1. Winner of a duel decides – whatever the manner of the “duel” – more this is prolonged more will be the cost in terms of “(wo)men and materials”. 2. Negotiate (diplomacy or whatever…); in which case there will be some give and take India (and China) has to decide. Sooner the better. Everything else is academic, media fodder and offers breeding ground for “experts” especially for Veterans who had a chance once upon time.
    1
  1051. That It is a tweet is not important. He has said something in public that the court finds wrong. So, the Q is, is what he said contempt of court? Shall we say, justice will prevail. Also, when somebody makes judgements based on prejudice rather than on the deeds, it sometimes boomerangs!
    1
  1052. In any case you won’t miss anything by not watching them?
    1
  1053. So more majoritarianism, capitalism , BOLD economic reforms... Media support will be required for this in any democracy to tell the real story and not popular eyeball catching and sentimental narratives. Are you ( main stream media and , not a the print in particular) ready?
    1
  1054.  @KiranKumar-nb4nx  you make good points. But Kiran, you can get ministers only as good as the candidates. Moreover their turnover is quick and barring a few do not know the subject they handle that well. The bureaucrats are permanent, on the job providing continuity. They are expected to be experts in what they handle. If they are incompetent, ignorant and irresponsible even an exceptional minister can do only that much. To use a phrase from the ministers’ talk under discussion “gadhe ko godha nahin bana skate” - either which way.
    1
  1055.  @KiranKumar-nb4nx  Kiran, thanks for the inputs. But I suppose you don’t mean only paper work when you say work. Yes, I agree Some ministers did assert. But exceptions can’t be accepted as the rule. WE can name two handful of ministers from among hundreds since independence. How many bureaucrats are held accountable for inefficiency and delay?
    1
  1056. A déjà vu. In India for decades, we see “raids” on politicians, especially on those who had risen from "humble" beginnings in the party cadre, and seem to have amassed wealth (in their name and the names of their near and dear ones). Nothing much comes out of these “allegations”, as very very unfortunately our judicial procedures give enough elasticity in its procedures and proceedings to take such cases to one’s grave. That such cases are registered with documentary evidence of such wealth is a reality. It is also true, that in a couple three decades these politicians could not have built such wealth from known sources of income. Such wealth will require political influences to raise huge wealth, the secrets of which are openly known but rarely discussed by the media (who may carry their own agenda in such matters). Tail piece: That which is built with political influence will require greater political influence to to be exposed and brought down. Like the straight drive through the V in cricket, in politics too timing is extremely important to beat the defenders and score maximum. And unlike in cricket this stroke need not always be played with a straight bat. Elementary Dr. Watson.
    1
  1057.  @DataCrusade1999  Is the readability better now?. Enjoy
    1
  1058.  @Iam_always_rt  The Print, overall is doing better than other media. For instance, the programme Ilanomics on Fridays in The Print, discusses the economic policies for what they are - the pros and cons. But the problem is programmes such as this one eclipses the real issues.
    1
  1059. Good analysis as usual. Required and appropriate in cut the clutter. But In General I wonder.... That every political discussion is on the “fortunes” of BJP and the protagonist of every discussion on Government action is NAMO points to an unassailable strength of the BJP. Once the Congress party held that position. This annealing in politics is good for democracy in the long run. Long = a 100 years. That we live in the first 100 years in a large democracy is not our fault.
    1
  1060. Very informative. But all clutter there. Unpredictable… Taliban, Al Qaida, Pakistan, terrorism etc….. and educated terrorism? Well… Tailpiece: Any ideal (educated or otherwise) is definitely not conducive to universal love. Ah yes, neither are religions who profess “My way is high way”.
    1
  1061. Jamaican Sonnets I presume, any smart Alec would be a charmer too eh? We have plenty of them in the media.
    1
  1062. Can we have some positives which this government is doing? Or is it the view that this Givernment will have to keep learning and in the process will take the Nation to destruction? Is there anything the Indian opposition too has to learn to do its duty in Nation building? Somebody ahas to tell the opposition too, what it should do, Shakira. Tailpiece: Do not sacrifice governance at the altar of politics.
    1
  1063. Deja Vu! Old wine in new bottle. I suppose the first action by all governments should be to stop freebies, especially free electricity and free bus rides. We expect something new from AAP rather than the stuck record about corporate taxes. To understand that one should talk basic economics (even an IIT graduate who understands etc. will sidestep this for the sake of politics and power). Just saying. Economy is a specialized subject. Let us not mislead the common man in regard to taxes, for his sake.. We owe him atleast that much. Tailpiece: We the people and the media should strive to change these old false narratives by political parties.
    1
  1064.  @DKSingh-wf8tn DK, I have a feeling you have misunderstood. My point is that Perceptions (and may be only perceptions) matter, especially in politics, more than anywhere else! What I am saying is the rules of this “game of perceptions” in Indian politics may be changing. Tailpiece: DK, you are the best. Truly.
    1
  1065. Good analysis..No comments
    1
  1066. A Lot of ordinary Indians, economists in India and the world, many “experts” who attend media events etc…, do not seem to think so. If being populist to include tax cuts etc as was done in many budgets in the past is the hallmark of a “good budget”, he may be right. But if the budget is expected to take India from being a laggard democracy, then, unfortunately HE is wrong and probably he knows it too. Tailpiece: You can either be true to oneself or be a politician. You can’t be both. Right? Irony of democracy.
    1
  1067. What is the score? Statistics is just not the way to monitor COVID. Testing also does not prove anything. Trump was being tested Every three days. Still he contacted COVID and nobody is the wiser!!! There are those who are tested multiple times. Those who have tested positive are tested again, probably multiple times, to test whether they are COVID negative. So, what testing and statistics are we talking about? Maybe, using logic rather than just numbers will help better to understand this virus. Who is a better batsman? Don Bradman or Sachin Tendulkar - Technique or statistics? Well...the jury is still out.
    1
  1068.  @smartlearning6390  Just diplomacy….just talk as everyone does. Has India ever practiced non violence since the times of the great epics? And may be even before that. When you are slapped on one cheek showing the other one, definitely will invite more violence. In this world or wherever, you can’t subdue a raging bull (enemies) by whispering the vedas into its ears (an old Malayalam saying). Tailpiece: Religions are for peace. One only has to study the events of the past to see how untrue this statement is in practice!
    1
  1069. Decency in politics. Good point about South. But…. Is the mainstream agenda based media (Not The print), also responsible for the “indecency” in politics. Tailpiece: The media can prevent politicians from “playing to the gallery”. Reflect.
    1
  1070. Pray tell us something new. We know that the villain will kidnap the heroine and the hero will rescue her wit the police arriving on cue. But the media can change the narrative and tell us about so much else that is happening. The bogey of Defence deal will not any more help the political,parties and will,definitely not help increase viewership of even YouTube channels. Tailpiece: The print need not have a dedicated programme for this. Also all,political parties are “attacking” each other’s present and future too. Don’t miss out on that.
    1
  1071. Great analysis of Indian sports. Most important aspect of performance is money…sports needs to pay for itself. Look at cricket for instance. It is that simple.
    1
  1072. Pegasus is not the only Snooping SW available. It is available to be bought - ready to use. Rest assured that the secret services of all developed countries and some developing countries have their own snooping methods and SW (not for sale overtly like Pegasus, of course) which have been in use for decades. Just saying.
    1
  1073. There is a future for democracy, so to speak…. If the Gandhis leave INC and politics…. A National party to challenge the BJP may be rejuvenated Tailpiece: when the whole world is convinced, I wonder why the INC is indifferent…. Because the party was and is most undemocratic…. So many splits etc… is testimony
    1
  1074. This is all fine. Can we have a cut the clutter on “Can India adopt a Presidential system of democracy?” The pros and cons for India. Tailpiece: With due respect, can we avoid phrases like “sharpening knives” etc?
    1
  1075. Foreign policies of the USA belong to the Nation and not to the POTUS. Packaging may be different but the contents will almost always remain the same. It is true with all democracies; so it is with India too. Tailpiece: Economy, foreign policies and Defence will be much the same with all Governments in a democracy. The only significant changes will be in procedures and societal show pieces which play out for the core constituencies of supporters.
    1
  1076.  Kiru  if you know Brutus, he was not a traitor. At worst he betrayed a trust...a belief....do you see what I mean? If not, it is alright. Each one has views...sone right some wrong and we mive in
    1
  1077.  Kiru  i respect your views on 'trial' I have mine. Regards
    1
  1078.  Kiru  because i don't expect The Print to get involved in this media 'trial'. That is it.
    1
  1079. In our type of democracy as opposed to the Presidential system in the USA, is it right to say Modi Government (instead of saying GoI)? In a Presidential system like in the USA, the President is elected separately to run the administration. Hence there it is said Trump administration or Biden administration. Are we aping without thought? Tailpiece: When the media, opposition, opinion writers and just about everybody, repeatedly say "Modi Govt" instead of "GoI", do we take it that 'We the people" are so obsessed with personalities that we prefer dictatorship over democracy? Reflect.
    1
  1080. You should know that in Liberal Democracies people vote as per feelings fanned by all political parties and the media. Analysis and thought are absent in deciding reasons and factors. This pandemic is a case in point where, as usual, pundits all over the world emerge to say "what should have been done". Media boost such "opinions". As such, in ALL democracies perception management and image makeover are the norm to stay in power. Tell me ONE party in the world who does not do it. Tailpiece: Tell us something new.
    1
  1081. China may have to be reminded that Kublai Khan, a grandson of the Mongol Genghis Khan, founded the Yuan dynasty in 1271, which ruled over China much before the Ming dynasty. Can Mongolia then claim Northern China?
    1
  1082. An excellent analysis, DK. Says it all. Let money roll into the economy. Some points 1. No campaigns with gatherings more than a 1000 people….not required with digital reach. 2. No model code of conduct at all…as brought out by DK, if voters do not know they do not deserve what they do not know. 3. Poll dates announced for states just two weeks in advance and general elections one month in advance. A bracket of dates could be announced earlier to facilitate preparation by election commission. Tailpiece: India is different….. ONOE is a non starter now….. why the huha is a surprise.
    1
  1083. SG always gives a “inside” vision of politics, which is not always good looking but what the electorate has to see. Now We the people are really fed up and disillusioned in the manner many political parties conduct themselves - mostly the dynasts. Tailpiece: In a cut the clutter can we have the Ill effects on the Nation’s development and peoples aspirations (real and not the apparition) as a result of these shenanigans (read infighting)? Thanks.
    1
  1084. In another two decades the grain will be separated from the chaff. It is unfortunate (or fortunate - it being a matter of perception like everything else in life) that we are living in the first 100 years of a maturing democracy. Given the size and diversity of the country, we are doing alright as a Nation - never mind Obama or Gandhis. And bash on...as SG says “Politics is Politics” - don’t expect anything else fro it!!
    1
  1085.  @nishanthnellutla  👍🏻
    1
  1086.  @egg-h4b  yes…. All
    1
  1087.  @gghb_bbb5944  Sure. I only gave a few examples. More power to you. Enjoy
    1
  1088. Absolutely a wonderful presentation. Disclaimer: This comment is not about religions but about people, love and hospitality. It may be apt to also say who welcomed St Thomas in 52 AD and later the Arabs Muslims in Kerala to make complete this discussion. Do we overlook this in all our discussion?
    1
  1089. I find that once again my comment has been removed. In my view i was not offensive etc... No objections to removing it for whatever reason. But could I know the reason.... if for nothing else but for self improvement. Thank you
    1
  1090. In our Nation, as long as We the people, like in all other democracies, go out and vote instead of cast(e)ing their votes (based on caste and religions), we will forever remain a lagging democracy. I suppose, we as well as the media should refrain from discussing religion with politics even while the political parties continue to base their strategies (with people like Mr. Kishore, who is actually doing a disservice to the Nation with his work during elections) on caste and religion. Probably then in a decade or so the politics will solely be based on development and we will make rapid progress as only India can. Tailpiece: Will the media take a lead?
    1
  1091. Privatization is the panacea? OK. What could be a pragmatic road map, like consolidation->equity dilution->total privatization? Can’t happen on the flick of a switch. How long will the process take? Will there be any losers or winners?
    1
  1092. A very good take on the present and immediate future of Indian politics. We the people should note the basis of this analysis and develop our own thought process. I wonder whether one important point has been missed. Probably there is a change in the way politics and governance is viewed in India, and may be across the world too. With the advent of technology and proliferation of the digital media, reaching the semi-urban, semi-rural and even some rural areas, views and opinions are formed from what one sees rather than from what one thinks. The Q: Then, will the perception of politics change in the coming days and be influenced by the texture rather than the colour – the good old roti, kapda, makkaan. Tailpiece: There are no ideal formulae in any system of politics. For instance, it is a fallacy to assume that there is contentment and happiness even in the CPC (China); politicians are a perpetually discontent lot; “dil mange more” types , much like all other people; hence harmony in any political party in a democracy is not even a myth; there are always turmoils and undercurrents in any political,party; so ignore them…feel the texture
    1
  1093.  @anuragrajasingh  Oh! Anuarag, the language is not only about wren and Martin…. Communication is more important than grammar…. Missing the woods for the trees… Enjoy, Forward Ho!
    1
  1094. At last media highlighting societal behavior in spite of rules to the contrary. This publicity of not following COVID appropriate behaviors should have been continually highlighted by the media since the last 6 months. Well done.
    1
  1095. A wonderful declutter especially for the uninitiated. I get a feeling The Print, guided by SG, is trailblazing a new path for informative journalism in India. Impressed. Tailpiece: The worst disservice to a Nation is when the media starts speculating and sensationalizing just for TRP and hidden agenda. I hope the rest of the media is watching ThePrint.
    1
  1096. Would you classify Margaret Thatcher an Alpha Female,if ever there is one? Oh yes, btw, this Alpha male Trump managed 47 % of the popular votes cast. Who creates the Alpha leaders? Just asking
    1
  1097. He may actually may prefer many fans at any distance facing any which way!!!
    1
  1098. No issues whether Aryan Khan should or should not get bail. Say, I am not a legal expert. But my point is as a citizen, why does the media go to town for celebrities and celebrity kids etc… only. There are 1000s of citizens languishing in jails in the country for similar reasons (may be less severe alleged “crimes”). If the justice system needs improvement (it sure does) the “experts”, I am sure have many avenues than fire the gun from celebrities shoulders. Such selective media attention produces a stink. If the aim is to raise awareness such cases are not the ideal examples. Tailpiece: Such unwanted publicity may be detrimental to the celebrities vocation, peace of mind etc… and surely does not help the case either way in any way
    1
  1099. I would say that the media is fixated ( now, including the print). Please do not include the whole Nation in the “fixation”. To me it is just another drug case, as is for millions of other Indians. I wonder why the media is creating a song and dance about it. The overplay by the media has not helped the accused, the state, friends and relatives of the accused etc. Tailpiece: Media is not the Nation. Aside. Having made my point (which ThePrint allows me to do) I appreciate the quality of SG’s presentation here. But there is absolutely no need to fault a system.
    1
  1100. Another addendum. Peer pressure is obvious here. :(
    1
  1101. An addendum.. This is just a case of a wayward kid. Not a National interest topic. We have so many such wayward kids in India and the world. There is absolutely no requirement to fault the system. The whole idea just stinks. Let not a Nation be taken for a ride by the media.
    1
  1102.  @Hawa_Chapal  stupid comment..haha
    1
  1103. 🤔
    1
  1104. In a lighter vein.... The renowned musician Ilaya Raja was once asked his view on blatant plagiarising of tunes in the film world. He had this to say - paraphrased “ There are but seven basic musical notes. Music has been created since millennia. There are bound to be some seemingly similar tunes in the newer creations. All of them need not necessarily be plagiarisation” For the moment we are interested only in the Music..,.
    1
  1105. How I wish we had a proactive and constructive opposition rather than reactive and blinkered political parties without any vision! Looking for and finding faults (often with help from media) is not the way to go. The fledgling AAP is doing immensely good job. It will take at least a decade for it to make its presence felt Pan India. All other parties are either caste based and " local Nationalists" (regional bias). The LEFT is no more a presence in India or else where in the world. I do not see visionaries either in the political firmament, among intellectuals and high profile media personalities. Even if the ruling dispensation falls, be warned there is no safety net for India.
    1
  1106.  @studyonline4763  hi Study! You may ask this Q of IMF, World Bank, S&P etc and look up data published by international organizations. Alternately, if you abhor international commentaries by authorized organizations, you could glean the data on various economic indicators published by domestic organizations who are supposed to do that. If you are still not satisfied you could get onto the street and get information first hand. It is because this Government has been “Doing” that India is in a better position post the pandemic and in an environment of the European war. Tailpiece: Ah, yes so you approve majoritarianism, right….as you accuse the government of inaction in spite of a majority? Just asking.Enjoy, stay safe, stay well.
    1
  1107. Did I get a feeling in the middle there is a comparison between India and Pakistan… or was it just a feeling
    1
  1108.  @vinayakdeodhar8641  She fails to say that it is already doing since a decade what it should done since 1950s. It can’t happen overnight…
    1
  1109.  @vsdktbkm5012  agree...original comment is on the message
    1
  1110. what a great democracy…Igor is it Demo Crazy? When the dust settles down, it will be realized that the “tour of duty” is a good programme to enable the youth of the Nation and may be detrimental to the efficiency of the Armed Forces. It is damning to see how political parties do not see beyond the party and are ready to do anything, even destroy the fabric of society, for power and wealth? Hopefully the Nation will one day, soon, see through these machinations of vested interests. Tailpiece: Gotta see how a balance in the Agnipath can be stuck. May require mid term course corrections
    1
  1111. The only permanence is change.
    1
  1112. Pakistan: A “democratic” Nation whose Government is controlled by the Army. The Army in turn is controlled by its Secret service. The secret service is in the grip of “non state actors”. The chain reaction is evident since decades. Throw into the mix an autocratic (almost) China who calls the shots in many takes in Pakistan but never exposes the film - meaning nothing to show. The people of Pakistan suffer interminably. Tailpiece: How effective is the FATF list? May be China too wants Pakistan in the list forever. Ever thought of that? An aside. So we now have a mini hospital with many sick persons in the region. Time to sit up and ponder.
    1
  1113. Well done AK. I hope, like AAP, all other political parties too join in and make it a “Har Dil Tiranga” event. How wonderful that would be. Tail piece: And ha, after all it is every Indian’s Tiranga.
    1
  1114. The point is here a “criminal” is condoned without punishment and/ or expressing remorse. It is stupendously unacceptable that a person of “criminal” pedigree can wield such powers. We the people need to research this. It serves very little purpose to minutely examine such cases in the media. We must have system where such cases are examined Prima facie within a stipulated time. Tailpiece: In this case my personal view is that antecedents of the accused speaks for itself.
    1
  1115.  @Akshay-fw6yc  shukar hain kambakht nahin balayage. Yenjoy. Thanks
    1
  1116. All very well and well explained. Can we have a cut the clutter on “caste politics and economic progress in India”… Is there an empowerment system other than reservation? Tailpiece: A honest National level discussion can be initiated.
    1
  1117. Harping on the Indian Origin bit is intriguing. Indians needs to introspect.
    1
  1118. Please remember it is a PANDEMIC All day long the media is only showing--- hospitals full of patients, disadvantaged families, helpless families roaming around, suffering from hunger, dying people, burning pyres etc. This doesn't in any way conceivable help if fighting the Virus. It only creates fear among healthy and willing workers and makes them sick.. We all know that there is a PANDEMIC going on, we also know that it is enough to say that there is no control over the situation - and nobody knows what's the right decision!! NO country in the world small or big have taken correct decisions to fight the virus. The active cases in the USA today are more than in India. Not even Dr. Faucci, who I have been following since March last year (when I was in the USA) knows exactly what will happen. He has said so to the Senate panel in the USA in no unequivocal terms.
    1
  1119. Bravo. way to go
    1
  1120. DK, don’t you think the congress and RG etc should be talking the real statutes that lead a relook than the statues unrelated to the constitution and stop misleading the Nation in much the same way as they accuse the BJP of doing?
    1
  1121. Over thirty top companies of the World with a net value of over a trillion dolars are led by Infdian origin CEOs. Given the circustance, capabilities of Indians to acjieve is beyond doubt. Indian is changing WITH SUCH OPPORTUNITIES hopefully being facilitated in our country after many decades of decadence. My appeal to the Indian “Opposition” political parties is that for your dynastic, sectorial, parochial, power mongering agenda do not muddy the waters with a “fight” against nonexistent apparitions of ideology and “threat to democracy”. We Indians are aware that you are aware but blinded by lust for power. Do not upset the banana cart – be more erudite and fight on the platform of development and progress. Tailpiece: Humanity has tried for millennia and failed to serve the right food for the people through religions etc…. concentrate on getting the food on the dinner table.
    1
  1122.  @jotendrakumar2852  very very true. And the media does nothing all to educate and persuade the people to follow appropriate COVID behavior rather. They play more “ politics” than politicians themselves. Sickening, to say the least.
    1
  1123. Conveyed in letter (to Santa) and spirit (to the rest), shall we say?
    1
  1124. No other Nations have ever had, have or will have a more than 3500 Kms of undefined, disputed and very difficult borders. Under these conditions it is very easy for either of the Nations to “intrude” into the other’s territory at will. Unlike India China exhibits intentions of territorial expansions wherever feasible including at the Indo-China border. Presently when India is faced with problems internally with a raging pandemic and a wearing economy, any belligerent enemy will attempt to take advantage. China is doing just that. I only hope the Indian media and its people recognize this and leave this matter to be handled by the system, which is capable of handling the situation. A ball by ball commentary on what may be happening on the borders is of no help to anyone but the enemy. The Nation will be better served if the media concentrates on the health and economic crisis, where it can help by not falling prey to enemy intentions.
    1
  1125.  @kevinp9110  yes. For a long period during the decades of the 1990s and 2000s, there has been hardly any new induction of ACs into the IAF. IAF are helpless as they have a task to perform - safekeeping of the sovereignty. IAF can’t unilaterally decide we won’t fly….like the usual strikes and hartals by some in the public and private sector. Military will use all at its disposal to do its duty. It is for the NATION to provide them with the wherewithal to do that. I fervently hope that Nation (and the Government) do that. Thankfully it is happening now. Rafael’s, Indigenous LAC etc… But we lost precious two decades for military upgrades.
    1
  1126. Yes Sudhir... But the IAF can't stop flying those planes unless the Nation gives them enough new ones. They have a job to do. They dutifully do it to the best of their ability with all that they have. I hope the speed of replacements picks up.
    1
  1127. A very objective and perspective analysis of political dispensation in Bihar by SG, who knows a thing or two about hinterland heartbeat. Sadly while what Modi brings to the table was touched upon, in the end one was left to wonder what young Tejaswi (wish him the best to serve the people), Paswan and the future Left will do for the people. Do they have a USP other than caste and such inherited credentials?
    1
  1128. A good analysis as usual. Will the churn bring up Amrut for the State and the Nation. Just asking. Tail piece: A doubt. Does this question make me a supporter of BJP? Again, just asking!!!!!!
    1
  1129. Good programme. Validation by foreigners? Do I hear it right? I thought we were done with doing the bid of foreigners since 15 August 1947. Tail piece: Is it that some politicians and a section of the media are still obsessed by foreigners and a servile status? India does need an erudite opposition and mature media. Both absent now.
    1
  1130. shubham verma If done, it will disrupt The Print for the worse. I find the current formats informative enough and refreshing. After decades I am inclined to become a fan of SG. Don’t change it.
    1
  1131.  @kumarDI5374-h5d  " Honey it is all about money"...anywhere in the world, including in India.
    1
  1132. Disclaimer: I am not a religious bigot. So when it comes to money ( material requirements) religion can get relegated....Chinese are not fond of religions, especially Islam... Islamic Republic of Iran?
    1
  1133. Open discussions on customs in societies is welcome and refreshing. Kudos to the Print. Hijab is something not mandated by religion, it is just a practice. So go half way…. There are such issues in the Vedic practices too. For instance the Vedas mandate only 7 rituals during a marriage ceremony. But many social dispensations in India do much more and term them as religious mandates. So I say Hijab is dispensable (as not part of religion). I am saying it because it is just a custom (not religious) in a community (discriminatory?) and not against Islam. I maintain that all religions were formed with good intentions. But religions have been exploited by unscrupulous elements from within. We have to recognise that first..before we point fingers at outsiders. Tailpiece: Customs are wrongly and willfully passed on as religious mandates by those within the religion, who want to exploit society.. This happens in ALL religions. Some fight, some succumb to the exploits. It is your choice where you want to be. Religion is much greater than a set of customs. ELSE why reservations?
    1
  1134. Uhmm… good story… Spy stories are good for movies (and now for OTT platforms)…. They are not good copies for mainstream media…. Nobody will know the truth… best to avoid fiction Tailpiece: Media should avoid discussing such matters
    1
  1135. Kitchen gardens may reduce inflation. Do not laugh this off
    1
  1136. The Chinese “if”. Haha: But geopolitically the conflict will not be in anyway a reflection of Russian invasion of Ukraine. Yet hypothesis is also news. Right? Tailpiece: In reality India is not Ukraine. Yet any war is damaging leaving losers all around. I doubt whether China is really interested in expanding on our Northern borders. Sometimes the threat of war brings progress. Also What we see may not be what it is. In countries like China and Pakistan the Armed Forces have to remain engaged as they and only they ensure that power remains with those who feed it. Get the point?
    1
  1137. Screen replaces yellow sheets. Change is the only permanence. Whether it be “National interest”, geopolitics or religion. Tail piece: Change, change and change.
    1
  1138. So, with the history in UK, it does not tell anything about UK politicians, eh? Just asking. Narratives can be suited to any view, right?
    1
  1139.  @lakshaykataria  yep. You have a point. Please note that changing approach does not necessarily entail changing the system!!!!! Enjoy.
    1
  1140. National news? 😒
    1
  1141. Tatas and Birlas are Nation builders and paragons of equality. But Ambanis, Adanis are Nation wreckers and primarily responsible for inequality? Just asking. We want entrepreneurs to become Unicorn owners and billionaires; but we abhor wealth? just asking Unless somebody makes money somebody else can’t get it. Just saying
    1
  1142.  @sirantisocial9681  Hi! You see the source of evolution of Urdu can also be"traced" exactly like you can of Hindi and English, which much like Urdu are also evolved languages and not original.
    1
  1143.  @sirantisocial9681  They as they are spoken today are both NOT original. Hindi an extract... "Hindi has been described as a standardised and Sanskritised register[9] of the Hindustani language, which itself is based primarily on the Khariboli dialect of Delhi and neighbouring areas of Northern India.] Hindi, written in the Devanagari script, is one of the two official languages of the Government of India, along with English.[13] It is an official language in 9 States and 3 Union Territories and an additional official language in 3 other states. Hindi is also one of the 22 scheduled languages of the Republic of India." English ---An extract... " The earliest forms of English, a group of West Germanic (Ingvaeonic) dialects brought to Great Britain by Anglo-Saxon settlers in the 5th century and further mutated by Norse-speaking Viking settlers starting in the 8th and 9th centuries, are collectively called Old English. Middle English began in the late 11th century with the Norman conquest of England, after which considerable French (especially Old Norman) and Latinate vocabulary was incorporated into English over some three hundred years.[9][10] Early Modern English began in the late 15th century with the introduction of the printing press to London, the printing of the King James Bible and the start of the Great Vowel Shift." Enjoy. Stay safe.
    1
  1144.  @sirantisocial9681  There is a lot of poetry and literature in Urdu too. Yes, Urdu is not an original language. But then, how many original languages are there in India and for that matter in the world? Is Hindi or English, one of them ? No offence all around.
    1
  1145. What is the aim of these series (also in print in The Print) - Exhibit knowledge ( having commanded the Northern Army, the General will be privy to a lot of classified information), educate the general public on military strategies and deployments, advice the current disposition on actions which he wanted to but could not do on his watch, an unknown agenda with an aim plus. Worthy reasons? Just asking.
    1
  1146. Selective questioning is the problem created by those seeking votes from selected sections of people…. That is the bane of Indian politics and why India has been labeled a Laggard democracy by the world economic community…you cannot make progressive policies in the government when pleasing your voters bank is the priority. Tailpiece: Media should highlight this point….It has nothing to do with secularism or such bunkum,. The issue should always be economy..roti, kapda and makkan..all else will fall in place
    1
  1147. Why not that the BJP, here is more interested in the Nation rather than the elections? SG, do you, as a veteran political journalist, suppose that BJP or any political party can’t put Nation ahead, al least, some time? Just asking
    1
  1148. I wonder whether the “Western reports” also consider racial discrimination in education, employment, indiscriminate violence, violent riots, racial profiling, racial violence, hate crimes et al in various democracies while formulating their “reports”. They must be. After all being from the West, they must be doing everything right. Right? In the late 60s, they said that the news is right if BBC (radio) has reported it. The whole absurdity of that became evident to me years later.
    1
  1149. Did I hear somewhere that action speaks more than words and is more harmful? Just asking.
    1
  1150. Oh yes, SG, we understand. You just could not ignore this “stand up comedy”… There is enough time for Cryptos to vanish…well done! It is not India but Pakistan which is being set back because of their “Kashmir polices” Tailpiece: It is unfortunate that Pakistan refuses to see the obvious. There is a saying in Malayalam that a “Man burnt his house to kill a rat”
    1
  1151. Useless. Just ignore and carry on… treat is as a work of fiction…. If somebody thinks the vent will be different with names…. Well fools can imagine anything… waste of time spending time on 814. How about reforms… to attract investments and create jobs…. Forward Ho!
    1
  1152. I think you miss a BIG point the build up to Indian indolence and independence itself are the genesis to the polarization of the Indian society. If we close our eyes to the we can never find a solution to this now perceived polarization. Just saying.
    1
  1153.  @Hawa_Chapal  Head of the Army (Chief Of Army Staff)
    1
  1154. Good style and substance, Swamy… blending with ThePrint landscape…. I am wondering…..Last month the COAS of Pakistan visited the USA… just saying Tailpiece: Unfortunately, we can see only so much
    1
  1155. Comparing statistics of countries like NZ, Germany et al with that of countries like US and India are misplaced. Even within India The spread of the virus in Kerala can’t be compared with that of Delhi or Delhi’s with that of Mumbai....population, density, life styles, resources (like for tests, PPE....), mental dispositions, economic capabilities (individual and country or state) are all different....also the capability to assess the “enemy” at the beginning of the “war”. I am here in the US. Believe me, India is doing good.
    1
  1156. Who says the world is changing?
    1
  1157. Somebody rightly said that the bane of India is that it is a laggard democracy because the opposition (over decades) does not allow reforms and progress. The parliament does not function. The media, and the “experts”, are also for most part partisan. The honorable courts , already over burdened , have to adjudicate on anything and everything. It is time “We the people” of India get away from these political dramas and get down to business,. It is already late. Our neighbors in Asia are racing ahead. Tailpiece: Unless entrepreneurship and the Big money players (who were once entrepreneurs) make money and create jobs there will be no money going around. Besides India has ignored the Farm sector for decades. Hopefully at the end of the present “noise” farming economy in India will be on the ascend. Also caste, religion and political gamesmanship dominating the India media is an impediment to progress. Media too need to play up.
    1
  1158. Fantastic…. I suppose the “United opposition” is also aware that elections is not an end and there is a Nation INDIA to be governed without discrimination of any kind….. no appeasement….and reservations etc based purely on economic status….. 75 years of discrimination is enough….. do not let another class system emerge. Tailpiece: whose Nation is it anyway? Just asking
    1
  1159. As usual an important aspect emphasized by ThePrint. Tailpiece: Infrastructure. Yes, better late than never.
    1
  1160.  @shivbhaskar4988  Shiv, thanks for the comment. My “Ramrajya” is in the context of the Nation as is the rest of what I have written. Can we have a “ramrajya” in any Nation, in the twenty first century? The best we can do is work towards one…provisions for a just and fair Governance already exists in our constitution and statutes. But Uhmmm… I respect your view. Enjoy.
    1
  1161. Required programme SG. An eye opener. Well presented. But…. My take. When we take pride in diversity why talk of divide. I feel the divide is far less in India. There is a large “divide” between Americans (US) on the coasts and those inland. Very discernible. In India despite “anti Hindi” etc with immigration of labor from Eastern and NE states a large population of South Indians are learning spoken Hindi. The joke going around is that “what we were not taught in schools”, we have to learn now. But yes, there is a vast difference in the status of economy, literacy etc…. These require immediate address. Tailpiece: Let us work towards development (sabbath saath sabbath visas - not a political statement but a genuine appeal) and not lose the Indianness.
    1
  1162. I suppose "we the people" should rely, for such issues, more on our local experiences rather than on self established organisations depending on donations. Donations are a dangerous source of income when the recipient is modelled to express views / opinions - there is a saying “ money talks”
    1
  1163. Why are we not talking about the most potent weapon of HAMAS…the human shield in the thickly populated GAZA strip…. Condemn them in all reports and as an extension their handlers and their supporters…. Asymmetric war…uhmmmm.. Such programs are not to glorify militants and Terrorists but to expose their handlers Tailpiece: I find that the media at large are loathe in condemning terrorists and their handlers…. Is it fear is it a misplaced sense of ..of what? Beats me. In all discussion 0ct 7 action of HAMAS never gets mentioned….. So who is the villain?
    1
  1164. Why don’t you quote Indian authors also, Shekhar? Are we not good enough? You are one of them Also, Shekhar should not the oppostion to who the government has to ‘listen’ come up with constructive suggestions? Can the Print take the lead in telling the. Samvad is constructive vivad is destructive
    1
  1165. That does not suggest a fresh approach. Tailpiece: I suggest that the new President of INC Walkman unbeaten Ptah of progress, development, education,infrastructure, jobs etc rather than flog the “dead horse” of fascism,secularism, Nationalism etc… India has progressed beyond trivialities while the INC was reorganizing. This is not a political,statement but a statement for development.
    1
  1166. Informative… Shall we say that the Havana “attacks” started decades back with the addictive Havana cigars? Now it is the 21st century-anything can happen! The jury is still out on the W** V****.
    1
  1167. Excellent and quick analysis. But drawing parallels with India is, in the least, mischievous. Inequality is a character of democracies. The relative inequality is more or less in the same ratio in all democracies. The only answer is for the private sector to address this inequality in a more determined way. The rural - urban divide in India is the bane. Media should also address how India need to address this. It is doing it by improving connectivity. Remember, as a consequence less than 1% of the Indian population watch/read theprint (just a guess from what statistics I see on YouTube). That is the nature of the beast. Yet India can’t now turn away from being a democracy. Can it?
    1
  1168. In a lighter vein! BARC researches bark? All said done, we need good media.
    1
  1169. Good simplification. But SG, don’t you think that the rescinded farm laws (with a bit of tweaking on the way), would have had the same results as these very “recommendations” as a natural process of market intervention? A democratic way…. Tail piece: The syndrome where the Indian feels that every step of action (life) needs to be legislated will keep India as a laggard democracy, unfortunately. The economy can’t grow at a desired pace, with such shackles.
    1
  1170. God interesting programme. But… one doubt… One can pick diamonds from the dust only when someone drops them there. Better success can be achieved by mining? Just asking.
    1
  1171. I wonder whether such media programmes help anybody, especially the Muslims – if that was the intention (or Is there any other intention?). Despite all the hoopla on religion, caste and gotras et al, life is only about roti, kapda and makan (provided by identity, relevant education, empowerment and employment). Nobody has ever lived, lives or will live only on love and free air…and oh! also Religion. Tailpiece: It is time we (all Indians) get real. Everybody has grievances and stories.
    1
  1172. Manipulator….can anybody manipulate half the population of a Nation of 130 billion people. Even renowned prophets have failed to wield such an influence in India for centuries. A bit of overreach? Mr Kapil is more intelligent, we think. So why such base statements? With all due respects to Mr K. Sibal, the efficient lawyer and a glib speaker, he is not true to himself talking politics. Tailpiece: Those political leaders who have risen from the ranks always keep their ears to the ground. Rajyasabha MPs just don’t have this in them. Give good leaders their due….
    1
  1173. Are you missing a larger picture of messaging to the “developed” world. Okay.... Something akin to the "Empire strikes back".... Interesting few days ahead..... Either way India has conveyed a message to he West... "Do not mess with us".... Same message to ALL anti India elements and Hands at home too... subject for cut the clutter…. Forward Ho!
    1
  1174. SG Greta show and it takes something to politically surprise you! So then, are we in a different era in politics? Tailpiece: Fun, yes. But the the Q always remains….. whose Nation is it anyway? Not surely to the dynasts in the 21st century.
    1
  1175. Yes SG three parties victorious. Long live democracy. Election commission is alright, voting machines are all right, the voters are alright… I suppose no Indian will have any more grouse in this regard. They should not. Tailpiece: It is time for all politicians and media to talk of development, economy, jobs, education, progressive policies etc…. And desist from stupid religious and other distractions and move towards UCC as intended in the Constitution.
    1
  1176. Could it be few Indians fantasies and as usual, you (some media) exploit. Tailpiece: Only about a million Indians would have heard of Mossad…let alone fantasizing. Get real with expert comments
    1
  1177. The ‘hum do, hamare do’ slogan has made a comeback as the country is today run by just four people, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi said in the Lok Sabha Thursday.” Not a political comment but simple arithmetic: The situation is four times better than being run by one (wo)man. Infinitely better than being run by a nobody. Tail piece: A view of “We the people”.. Let the parliament discuss the farm laws in the house clause by clause. Invite the farm “leaders” to attend the proceedings from the gallery. Live stream the discussions.
    1
  1178. All said and done, the Q is should anyone jump into the deep end without learning to swim....75 years and still a non-swimmer!!! We can definitely do it....the people also have to learn to swim...
    1
  1179. Truth, when can’t be physically experienced (like a vaccine) is very subjective and varies with perception. Yuval Noah Harari, speaking on a different plane, goes all the way to say that the only truth is suffering. Well, if all believed in the same (one) truth, we would not have so many religions. In journalism truthfulness is more important than the truth. Reporting should be unbiased and free from pre conceived ideas. A difficult task. That is why good journalism (Like The Print?) is not very easy.
    1
  1180. As an afterthought: Are people rooting for RCEP because it implies “free” trade .... you know how ‘free’ works, especially with the gullible
    1
  1181. Also you and me will never be able to exchange views like this!
    1
  1182.  @ChandranPrema123  Hinduism is not a religion in the sense of Abrahamic religion. If you insist, it is the only democratic religion if you want to call it that). one can be a Hindu “believing’ in any deity (even of any Abrahamic religion) or no deity at all; having faith in any God or in no God at all; one can pray any which way one wants to at any time of day or/and night or not pray at all; Culture is a set of values which in the Indian sense is to be respectful, accommodating, open-minded, deeply but not ostensibly spiritual and concerned with the common human welfare offering respect and acceptance to all philosophies / religions. THIS, sir is Hindutva.
    1
  1183. SG, are the kurtas from fab India? They are fab!
    1
  1184.  @arjunnava  Arjun, asympomatic cases and people with passing mild symptoms donot need medical care....after a while they become virus free automatically. Besides, the " poor" India has already created close to 2 lakh hospitsk beds for covid, if needed. It is our Nation....
    1
  1185.  @arjunnava  Arjun, a unique characteristics of this virus is that one can carry it fir weeks and not be aware of it (or have only mild symptims)! It is imperative that in India too has/had such caes. These are the people who will herald herd immunity without even being aware if it!!!! No special efforts required here!!!!!!!
    1
  1186. I wonder, whether herd immunity is already happening in India!
    1
  1187. Maladies of governing a large nation with long boundaries with belligerent neighbours… par for the course Shekhar…. It is not easy to govern India with a please all approach….
    1
  1188. DK. 3 Qs. AK was not saying anything which was not discussed earlier, now and then. 1. Will such diatribe’s influence 30% of remaining voters? 2. Should voters be influenced by such contrived rhetoric? 3. Why are Indian voters considered gullible.? Are they really? Regards
    1
  1189. What is new? Being a Bollywood fan SG, you should know this depiction of typified “villain” is not new. May be , like you are doing now, we should ask the question “why” and initiate a National debate to lay this “practice”:to rest. It is in the domain of The society and more aptly with “we the people”. Tailpiece: Is it that most of us have got the definition of religion and “God”:wrong? Unless the society answers these questions the ignorance will be exploited by politicians, show biz and also the media.
    1
  1190. Great repeat. But did I miss something? Who was responsible for hatching this conspiracy and why?
    1
  1191. SG. Well spoken. My take… One can behold anything any which way….Tax payer richer and not Governments… Tailpiece: The old adage. “Beauty lies in the eyes of the beholder”.
    1
  1192. Could it be also that larger part of the media, ( not The Print) traditionally, in the name of free press, constantly highlight the cracks and negatives ignoring the bonds and positives?
    1
  1193. Does the Congress expect the people of India to seriously believe this? On the contrary, now, I fully agree with the letter writers that democracy should replace dictatorship in the Congress party which has led India for long. We do want a strong congress party, if feasible, to return as a force to “save” democracy. Hold elections to CWC and congress presidentship. Show the way...
    1
  1194. Why the why? Let me explain. Xi is NOT the new Mao as Mao as we know him can’t today lead China into a new era. The Chinese people are different, the economy is different, China is not the same internationally, China has more powers outside China than Mao could have ever hoped for with his ideals etc….etc..etc… Tail piece: It is a new China and Xi is Xi and not Mao. It will be better for supporters and detractors of Xi to recongnise this at the earliest and channelize their thoughts accordingly and, if necessary, recast their action plans. And one more point, as a person too Xi is totally different from Mao. For sure, Xi is more intelligent!!!
    1
  1195. Aryan Sharma yes. So I am amazed why my favorite channel has removed today’s comment on this video.
    1
  1196. Why it had…? Good Q. Sometimes you need bottle caps to swing the ball. Tailpiece: wonder who is really caring about Pakistan and its people.
    1
  1197. A window to look at the world and see something other than electoral gimmicks all around. There is more to governance than just elections. Tailpiece: Ah! St Stephens cut off… more than just marks? Just asking.
    1
  1198. Pardon my indiscretion, if you may. I am not a journalist but a lay Indian. It is in appropriate to address the PM speech from only from the point of elections, even for a political ( or former). Political journalist. This gives an impression that Democracy and the Nation is ONLY about elections. This has been the bane of journalism since six decades when I started with reading vernacular news papers. The PM speech had many development point - in Defence, economics, J&K, NE, manufacturing, foreign policies, self reliance and many more. Those need to be highlighted before politics. Tailpiece: The media narrative has to change if India (Bharat) has to progress p, develop a f become a better society and a better prosperous society. Elections are not the ultimate.
    1
  1199. To convey the “secular” of the media, Could the heading have read “Sinister move by Akhilesh to garner Dalit votes ......”, considering that the free press, appropriately, in India abhors caste/religion based politics? Just asking.
    1
  1200. Tolerant, intolerant, freedom of speech, democracy, liberalism, independence voice , muzzling, truth et.. etc.. - what is violated and by whom? But then...it is only a Western opinion?
    1
  1201. Good going. Only 36 more to get a billion subscribers. Way to go.
    1
  1202. Like the selection of such additional topics for discussion by SG - in spite of juicy political stories going around. Debt trap is a way of economic terrorism….time for a cut the clutter on the subject.(economic terrorism). Tailpiece: Jimmy Choo is a Malaysian designer shoe maker of Chinese descent living in UK. Would JimmyChoo shoes be “Chinese Shoes' ?. And yes, in the 1980s, the one item that was smuggled into India from a not so developed China were cheap footwears.
    1
  1203. Excellent briefing, Colonel. But to The Print - is it a good idea to discuss in these details the tactical positions along LOC / LAC, whenever there is a skirmish. It will be helpful for Defence and diplomacy if you make this one programme an exception. I am a veteran who has served along LAC in North and East, more than a couple of tenures, since 1976.
    1
  1204. hy Sahara? What about sand from our own riverbeds?
    1
  1205. Are we following the constitution to the T. Why have we had more than 100 amendments? Why are we ignoring many aspects of the constitution and emphasizing only a few Articles? Why are the “experts” and the media silent on many Articles of the constitution not yet implemented? Tailpiece: We the people should shun hypocrisy and double standards in our approach to Nation building.
    1
  1206.  @sureshharinathbabu9717  when you say it with an American accent it sound like “Kamal biding time” - for her turn at the WH (the unsaid but implied)
    1
  1207. Kamal(a) Biden time!
    1
  1208. What is the difference in “benefits” between subscription and one time payment?
    1
  1209. We expect The Print to continue to inform and not influence. I am a believer that whatever, there is always room for improvement. More power to you. Tail piece big Q: Will the decisions taken by Biden administration be majoritarian or democratic?
    1
  1210. I am glad that the honourable SC of India has also taken this view.
    1
  1211. As usual a sagacious presentation... But there are always at least two sides to anything - matter or views. Responsibility (in this case for The Government) adds new dimensions to issues that is seldom foreseen or ignored in the free speech domain. A recent stark example is the New Presidency in the United States – this example is just because it was a bitterly fought elections with contrasting promises during the campaigns. But once in the chair, the new President finds it hard to keep his campaign promises, especially in foreign affairs matters, after taking over the controls. It will be naïve to assume that Governments introduce rules to wield the stick over the media. The media will have a case only if self-regulation is followed in letter and spirit. But “We the people” have concerns about the media handling issues without trying to influence, either which way.
    1
  1212. That you allow us to say our piece and publish it in these comments is in itself fantastic. Likewise letting all types of experts to publish / say their piece is also great. Why you eologise them is also passé’. So go right ahead, you are doing fine. In the end saying is not everything; doing is... Also, In this specific regard the aspect of tolerance and intolerance is yet to be discussed?
    1
  1213. DK, you are a good messenger yourself! Engrossingly narrated. Tailpiece: Messaging is also important. Only messaging will not deliver consistently.
    1
  1214. Yes “allegedly” should correct!!! Tailpiece: Could the faith be allegedly working both ways - second in line to leader and vice versa. A deja Vu.
    1
  1215.  @hellojake7684  Absolutely right, Jake. My point is, that do we expect China & Russia to concur with the others...? I suppose that is how we put pressure, maybe. Or look at other ways to end the aggression.
    1
  1216. Why is Sheehan apologetic to accept growth? At least he came out as he was sad
    1
  1217. There is a world out there, that makes a difference, beyond the heartland. Handle them with caste politics. Governance more than politics. Copper for instance!!!!:) Tail piece. What if some “young” prominent National level leaders of India get some tattoos? just asking.
    1
  1218.  @maniaphobia4719  Yes. But I suppose most of the social media is actually a “medium” and not media...a sort of a pub with unlimited capacity
    1
  1219. When the dust settles down, it will be realized that the “tour of duty” is a good programme to enable the youth of the Nation and may be detrimental to the efficiency of the Armed Forces. It is damning to see how political parties do not see beyond the party and are ready to do anything, even destroy the fabric of society, for power and wealth? Hopefully the Nation will one day, soon, see through these machinations of vested interests. Tailpiece: Gotta see how a balance in the Agnipath can be stuck. May require mid term course corrections. And one more point….. the great thing about the laggard Indian democracy is that for every good leader you get an equally good misleader. Validates Newton’s first law of motion
    1
  1220.  @sauron2000000  Freudian!!!! Of course imagination has no bounds, I suppose:))))):)
    1
  1221.  @sauron2000000  Sauron of 2000 Sau. Thanks. I meant Advani.. typo. Enjoy
    1
  1222.  @YashSharma-rx3ff  thanks Yash. Obviously I meant Advani…typo… Enjoy.
    1
  1223.  @SattickDas2001  ALL of US have to make efforts. If ALL of US ignore provocations…provocations will vanish over time. Just saying.
    1
  1224. When the dust settles down, it will be realized that the “tour of duty” is a good programme to enable the youth of the Nation and may be detrimental to the efficiency of the Armed Forces. It is damning to see how political parties do not see beyond the party and are ready to do anything, even destroy the fabric of society, for power and wealth? Hopefully the Nation will one day, soon, see through these machinations of vested interests. Tailpiece: Gotta see how a balance in the Agnipath can be stuck. May require mid term course corrections. And one more point….. the great thing about the laggard Indian democracy is that for every good leader you get an equally good misleader. Validates Newton’s first law of motion
    1
  1225. Effect from Russia-Ukraine war on economy the world over will be minimal. It is just that the world does not want that. So, the West will make a lot of noise which will culminate into a whimper and vanish. Sanctions will not affect energy supplies. Tacitly Russsia will get what it wants from the “conflict”. The West will soon deflect attention to other matters…. Vietnam, Libbya, Iraq, Sudan, Syria, Crimea and of course Afghanistan are all examples. Tailpiece: The NATO will be left holding the baby…..inflation, loss of face etc….
    1
  1226. Yep. Every country should act in its interest. Diplomacy is like an elephant with two sets of teeth. One for show (tusks) and one for chewing! Tailpiece: what you see is not what you get. India is in a comfortable place in the comity of Nations. Buddha is smiling!!! Ah! One more point. SG, You forgot to mention the changes in landscape of US-India relations during the Vajpayee Government (in the media language).
    1
  1227. SG, you do quote a few authors/journalists/experts etc. Are you being selective? It would be good if such quotes are accompanied by occasional counter quotes too. My point is purely from a view of impartiality. Whatever the views, the hypocrisy of some related parties in regard to world peace etc… is blatantly evident. Let us not brush THAT under the “liberal” carpet. Tailpiece: Make no mistake, The Print is way above any other media “house” in our Greta Nation.
    1
  1228. Will the authorities please share with the public the National Security policy of India for the decades after Independence, Only then can we know what worked and what did not, all along. We can't obviously be discussing (speculating) matters on national security based only and purely on what appears in the media and/or individual perceptions. If the policies are available for public access anywhere will somebody please let us know.
    1
  1229. OK. We should not hide from the truth. But pray tell us where are the hungry Indians hiding? Identify them. We can surely give them all at least one square meal a day. Unless this can be identified, the report, unfortunately, will remain just that. A report - notwithstanding the reputation and history of the “reporters”. Else, name the index something else. Like health or nutrition index. Yes genetically, because of malnutrition over generations, a large number of Indians need additional nutrients to catch up. That is the reality. Let us address it that way and not as “hunger index” and gloss over the real need. Tail piece: Though it has been explained in the content rightly as a nutrition deficiency, the photo is misleading; children waiting for food and not nutrition? The problem is genetic malnutrition which is a totally different animal than hunger. So much for the “world hunger report”. A misnomer by any standard.
    1
  1230.  @theplmotivationofficial  To say media won’t change is defeatist. If governments can be changed by people, they if they really want it, can change the media too. Media is not infallible.Neither are people.
    1
  1231. Kudos SG for the programme. Covers a wide range of contemporary issues. As usual ThePrint comes up with real issues which are very complicated and more damaging than Hijab etc….. This verily accentuates the real issues which the world (and as an extension, INDIA) has to grapple with…. These issues are beyond how and to who a Nation prays. These studies lay out certain aspects and are no end in themselves. Else, how did the USA miss the recent action by OPEC+ to reduce oil production. This was surely coming but not discussed or anticipated as recent events reveal. Will require many pages to elucidate…. Tailpiece: It is time that India and Indian media should not make issues of what political parties do internally. The real question should be, are the Indian political parties equipped to deal with internal and external issues and gain advantage for the People of India. Ah yes. How to fight China is a stand alone topic.
    1
  1232.  @ThePrintIndia  haha! Thank you. The analysis is the inspiration
    1
  1233. Foul play was so obvious, one wonders…
    1
  1234. If India has to really progress and prosper...there should be no discrimination in the Constitution and Government policies based on caste and/or religion (uniform civil code?). The sole effort of the governments must concentrate in uplifting the economically challenged. Universal income, skill building or whatever... Everything else will automatically fall in place.
    1
  1235. Sixer Sidhu was great on the pitch, with the bat. He also improved his fielding skills in later years. It was just inquisitiveness that prompted me to listen to this programme. He started auspiciously with a drop of honey – sweet. But what surprised me was his willingness to hook on the front foot, by talking on the economy etc., in the opening over itself. It will be interesting (and entertaining?) to watch his new innings – though a test match (the elections) he may get to play only one innings. Tailpiece: I can understand NSS hugging Imran, a fellow cricketer. His hugging Gen Bajwa was a top edged reverse sweep.
    1
  1236.  @pointtobenotedyespointtobe2762  Over centuries, the real “Andh” (blind) are those from ALL religions who BLINDLY follow beliefs (and what the clergy say), without trying to find out the truth and make progress. They tend to remain in a time warp, when the rest of world progresses. Tailpiece: Sentiments suppress the intellect.
    1
  1237.  @RP027  Great. True. Let ALL Indians of ALL religions read it. Change the perception. Walk half way.
    1
  1238.  @longliveindia837  One Arabic language analogue to infidel, referring to non-Muslims, is kafir. Infidel is an insulting word. So you see the perception? We are all basically good ..we need to change perceptions.etc... Long live India. Jai Hind.
    1
  1239.  @ABC-lw7qq  Are you sure? Well, so much for honesty . You are in a democracy. Enjoy.
    1
  1240.  @MichaelVohra  which one?
    1
  1241.  @MichaelVohra  missing the wood for the trees ( British) or missing the forest for the trees (American)
    1
  1242. Please remember it is a PANDEMIC All day long the media is only showing--- hospitals full of patients, disadvantaged families, helpless families roaming around, suffering from hunger, dying people, burning pyres etc. This doesn't in any way conceivable help if fighting the Virus. It only creates fear among healthy and willing workers and makes them sick.. We all know that there is a PANDEMIC going on, we also know that it is enough to say that there is no control over the situation - and nobody knows what's the right decision!! NO country in the world small or big have taken correct decisions to fight the virus. The active cases in the USA today are more than in India. Not even Dr. Faucci, who I have been following since March last year (when I was in the USA) knows exactly what will happen. He has said so to the Senate panel in the USA in no unequivocal terms.
    1
  1243. The cocktail, Af-Pak and Turkey, is dangerous for the region and the World especially with an Af where a free for all environment will soon prevail. I like your reference to Imran Khan’s Govt. Is it?
    1
  1244. I am sure, the suggestion is not to make pick pocketing legal as there are a million pickpockets who may strain the legal system, if booked. Jokes apart... Cannabis is nothing but Bhang...not even as damaging as tobacco probably?
    1
  1245. This is a process which will take time. In India the problem is compounded by decades of neglect by successive Governments in matters of Military build up - equipment, soldier and doctrine. Three things: 1. The Military has to be adequately equipped for the task. 2. Nation has to ensure that the fire in a soldiers belly is kept always burning ; at the end of the day, it is the (wo)man who takes the bullet who will make the difference. Treat him / her well. 3. The Media should desist from treating matters of Military like a soap opera. Yes, a Nation needs to invest in the Military the right way, as a wholesome unit, if it wants to Defend its sovereignty and have a say in World Matters.
    1
  1246. The irony is that politics can’t be served for lunch - nor for b’fast or lunch for that matter. A vast region of India knows the “ heartland” only through politics and politicians. Tailpiece: I have lived in these states. They have much more to give and take than agenda based politics, which does not address progress; such as education, skill sets, infrastructure etc…. Hopefully some work on these have started recently.
    1
  1247. I have heard the there can’t be smoke without fire. Just saying. Along with “use of ED”… the media and experts (like her) fail to clarify that there IS a case to investigate where ED is “used” by incumbent Governments. Yes the Governments should be be questioned in democracy. It is a Right. In the same vein the opposition should also be questioned…, that is democracy plus. Media is meant for democracy plus. Tailpiece: Victim cards are now passé. Just saying.
    1
  1248. A data analytical exposition. All good. But… But I have a problem here. The differing narratives about policies could also be an assumption by some stakeholders because of legacy and / or seeking sympathy. The messaging is used by both sides, whenever and whatever. Is that not so? This presentation also suggests this. Just saying. Tailpiece: Is implication of religion “assumed” by all stake holders for gains through vested interests. Seems so. Everybody can blow dog whistles.
    1
  1249. The print could have avoided this. There are many (more) erudite Muslim women in India. One tweet? Don’t you know one swallow does not make a summer?
    1
  1250. A two step solution: 1. Centre compensates states for loss of real revenue (realized) 2. Centre loans the states the additional money (not part of unnrealised revenue)it requires ( after all States are in India) and the states repay the loan in the normal course. A non technical solution...”experts” can work out the technicalities. No precedence set here for compensating for unrealized revenue. No money? Well, it has to be arranged using the dry gun powder, so to speak.
    1
  1251. ​ @axxoaxx288  The whole pandemic has nothing whatsoever to do with religion; any congregation is a superspreader including rallies, Kumbh etc... This congregations has more to do with people and liberal democracy than anything else. To put matters in perspective.. India is a Nation with a population of 13664 lakhs; USA 3282 lakhs (all 2019 figures given here only for comparison). Per capita GDP (IMF data), USA $68319; India $2191. Total Covid Cases USA: 33,452,985:: India: 22,295,911: Total deaths: USA 595,587 India: 242,398 (COVID info from worldometer.info) I am not even talking percentages. I wonder what Lancet and experts have to say about the high percentage of infections and deaths in the USA, Europe, UK and such advanced Western countries. It is but natural to blame the Governments for everything in a democracy. But the nature of the spread of the virus in India really ells another story. Let us not miss the wood for the trees Regards
    1
  1252. Thanks SG - for revealing open secrets! Even in these times when there is no public screening, the PVR cinema is doing well at the stock markets - in anticipation. Such is the power of cinema; all leading publishing houses want to hold film award functions. Should they?
    1
  1253. DK…important event(s)… PM could be looking for God in God’s own country… would you say? Tailpiece: In my teen days in the 1960s etc… the rivalry between RSS and CPI (M) ( with at least one killing per day in North Malabar) was rampant… worth visiting that era to identify the root cause etc…
    1
  1254. But the USA has vaccinated only 41% of its population as yet. …. Kabhi socha hain? The irony!
    1
  1255. Good, interesting angle and points SG. But there is a difference…. We know it. You know it. Period. Subsidies, fuel prices etc… (indirectly benefits all Indians- supply chain costs, food prices etc…) have larger implications than free bus rides and pressure cookers (benefits only targeted individuals)….:) Tailpiece: But of course, we are discussing politics.
    1
  1256. As we say in the media - this covid-19 is yet a developing story. Right?
    1
  1257. There can’t be a utopia. Humanity is always working towards an utopia. Like the horizon, utopia will recede as we seemingly approach it. In a democracy, or for that matter in any form of Governance, there just can’t be a piece of legislation that please all. Specifically, on this issue of farmers bills, it is not possible to bring in a legislation that will please the farmers, traders (the whole supply chain), black marketers, hoarders and the end users. Tailpiece: Can we assure a one hundred percent guaranteed price for any product in a free market? We may not find a solution to the “Price” in guarantees – next will be adjustment for inflation; we measure inflation also through food prices; a vicious circle will ensue. Just saying.
    1
  1258. It is time the Media put its hand up and owns up its frailties. The Media is not fighting? I am not sure… It will be apt to recall an incident in 2019 where Sashi Tharoor had some words of appreciation for NaMo. He was castigated by the congress for it. He responded as follows:- “Defending his praise for PM Narendra Modi, Congress leader Shashi Tharoor on Wednesday has responded to the notice sent to him by Kerala Congress asking for an explanation for his praise. In his letter to the Kerala Pradesh Congress Committee (KPCC), he highlights the increase in vote percentage due to PM Modi. He also told that Congress must acknowledge this fact and learn from it. He also urged Congress to publicly stand for nationalistic issues. “ ST had also said that you have to appreciate the good to be taken seriously when you criticize. You see, leaders, The media,” experts”, commentators and the like have to give the devil its due, whether the Devil be in the Government or in the opposition. This is NOT happening in the mainstream media. Some of the leaders and the Media have to mature. Sadly, it is they who are trying to polarise the Nation for vested interests. Senior media personalities have a big role to play in this. Thankfully, the fact is that most of the Indians are NOT as polarized as the media and many of the experts and commentators are making out it to be.
    1
  1259.  @anwarshahid1  it is not about one up man ship Anwar Bhai, 1. What is committed in the Iranian port is less than 2% spent on the road belt 2. Similarly what is being invested thin SE Asia is what we can afford… if either fails India will will not fail. We want a vibrant and thriving Pak as our neighbor… have no doubts about it. Stay well..
    1
  1260. Could the impasse be Because a lot of political journalists messed it up? Who holds the weapons? Only one side?
    1
  1261. Correct analysis. Federal Democracy lives on….:):):) Tailpiece: India is a unique democracy. It will take at least another decade for a course corrected BJP to flower.
    1
  1262. Hurting religious sentiment is a misnomer. Please don’t throw bricks at me. What I say applies to ALL religions. Sentimentality is an emotional state disproportionate to the situation, and thus replaces extreme and generally unthinking feeling for normal ethical and intellectual judgment. Psychologically sentiment is an abnormal condition. While there can be a condition of religious sentiment, being abnormal it cannot be hurt but only aggravated. Being abnormal it is better for the society (all religions) to ignore such situations, especially any depiction in ANY art form. In time, the abnormality will all go away on its own.
    1
  1263. “A stitch in time saves nine”. Lack of foresight. Now it is too easy for China to play its game. Unfortunate Naga people don’t realize that they are just pawns in the Chinese game. Tail piece: The unfortunate aspect on Indian Independence is that, much like most political parties of today, aims at just winning and nothing beyond that.
    1
  1264. The bureaucrats have fallen in line. The problem is with the edifice of bureaucracy...the methods and the maze of rules...even our Constitution of 1950, unfortunately, has more than 100 amendments!!!! Let me illustrate – on the maze of rules unattended for decades after Independence. After leaving a salaried job at age 50, like SG, I became an entrepreneur and, unlike SG, founded an MSME in the manufacturing sector. I played by the rules. So I thought, until the concerned “Inspector” did not renew my license. The reason – my MSME did not maintain a register which recorded and certified that all my workers were wearing tight fitting clothing at work every day – a bit of paraphrasing here; but I suppose you get the drift. These rules, clauses, notes and notes to notes will take decades to decode and change. I will recommend that India sit down and draft all together new rules for business!!!
    1
  1265. Putting open secrets up front? Required to clear perceptions. In any case allies obstruct constructive and progressive policies at National level, so very essential for India to progress to the next level. Tail piece: I like that “Bombay”…
    1
  1266. Interesting story Shekhar…. You are battle hardened alright…. Gripping narration had got a copy before the ban set in…
    1
  1267. Does what you see depend on the glasses you wear? Just asking
    1
  1268.  @vivekagrv  Most politicians do and THAT is my point. A Deja Vu. And we the people just lump it. Using the farmers, using us all.... Is that the way to progress?
    1
  1269. The rumblings in a party in a democratic set up show up the true nature of Democracy. When only "Yes" men are retained in any party, it is either a dynastic set up or a monolithic party like the CCP. More the rumblings without destabilising effect, better will be the party.
    1
  1270. Great cutting! Like Pant in Brisbane. Clean with no doubts!
    1
  1271. When the PM of India visits soldiers at the borders the media narrative is “…the PM is sending a political message…” When the PM of India does not visit the soldiers at the borders the media narrative is “ …the PM does not care for the soldiers of the Nation and shies away fro. I siting them a the borders…” Tail piece: The Print being different, please change the narrative.
    1
  1272.  @ThePrintIndia  Traveling :)
    1
  1273. Nice of SG to explain the CDS situation etc. Informative as ever. Kudos. Tailpiece: CDS is a new concept for India. The role is evolving. The Nation needs to be patient. India is a democracy. So mind you, the politicians and bureaucracy will be vary of creating a “powerful” military appointment. Way of democracies.
    1
  1274. Unfortunate. May increase as election nears. Media may call out this trend. Tailpiece: In Indian politics power takes precedence over NATIONAL. SAD.
    1
  1275. Does it sound like someone in his neighborhood continent. Tailpiece: in the world today, has Ravans overtaken Rams (used in a metamorphic way) in popularity? Cut the clutter topic?
    1
  1276. What is freedom of religion when the religion itself binds you and tells you what to wear, what to eat, sees women different from men etc…. It is akin to political parties who do not practice democracy wanting to defend Nation’s democracy and constitution. A paradox par redemption. Tailpiece: It is time to redefine methods ordained in religions….all religions.
    1
  1277. I suppose the first step towards to UCC is uniform. Just saying. Is there religious freedom in any religion which tells you how to dress etc… any religion
    1
  1278. An addenda. It is a convoluted argument that right to education should not be denied because of a dress. Students require to wear uniform dress in schools. That is the mandate much like the police need to wear uniform dress. Tailpiece: Democracy and freedom too have limits which have to be respected. I hope the media too educate the people as such.
    1
  1279. It is the way you tell it DK…. makes for more than a good copy…. Indian political scene was OTT long before the likes of Netflix etc…. Tailpiece: what we all seem to miss is that we accept these politically incorrect politicians without batting an eyelid… we call it equal opportunity in democracy….
    1
  1280. Please do not decry democracy and attribute political motives without sufficient reasons. An extract from the judgement in Disha Ravi’s case as published in sections of media… “…It is not mere engagement with persons of dubious credentials which is indictable rather it is the purpose of engagement which is relevant for the purpose of deciding culpability…” When there is a suspicion, as in this case where DR contacted persons of dubious credentials ( as established by the state) and tried to conceal her identity, there is always a case for investigation as to the purpose of engagement. We can’t say that such matters should not be investigated. In this case democratic ways as laid down was followed in the investigation. Taking into custody, the courts, bail etc. is a process of investigation in a real democracy. So once again, please do not decry our democracy in the name of your democracy. Disclaimer: I believe in the innocence of Disha Ravi. But more than that I believe in the process of investigation, which is absolutely necessary here, is a democratic process. Tail piece: I want to believe Justice will prevail. When one attempts the extra ordinary, it is but natural to encounter the extra ordinary.
    1
  1281. When the dust settles down, it will be realized that the “tour of duty” is a good programme to enable the youth of the Nation and may be detrimental to the efficiency of the Armed Forces. It is damning to see how political parties do not see beyond the party and are ready to do anything, even destroy the fabric of society, for power and wealth? Hopefully the Nation will one day, soon, see through these machinations of vested interests. Tailpiece: Gotta see how a balance in the Agnipath can be stuck. May require mid term course corrections. And one more point….. the great thing about the laggard Indian democracy is that for every good leader you get an equally good misleader. Validates Newton’s first law of motion
    1
  1282.  @Sarkarinaukarichahiye  haha. Tit for tat eh,? You are off the mark. All politicians include ALL politicians of all parties who do not speak development etc.. Enjoy.
    1
  1283. Will the Western media now climb down from the high pedestal on which they reside and stop sneering at the “developing” Nations?
    1
  1284. Even main stream news are not above reproach… The other day, during a video call, I enquired from a friend whether he had got the first jab of the vaccine. Immediately I sensed a worried look in his face. The reason, he explained, was because it was all over TV that after a vaccine dose one is susceptible to life threatening blood clots. There just was no point in explaining the real thing to him. The Indian media has driven it into him by repeating half-truths. It becomes a belief. How would I know better than the TV people? On legal analysis the media would not have said anything wrong. But the way it is, as are other news items, presented is all wrong – with wrong emphasis at the wrong places. It is like that for every news item. Emphasis on the negatives. This is sad. And the new entrants to the media are also learning it all wrong! Tail piece: Real thing and optimism has never killed the cat!!!
    1
  1285. People have lived like this for centuries. It is just that everything is coming out because of the available communication media -especially social media and digital media, where even I can say my piece. As usual, vested interests exploit this chaos. In principle nothing has changed.
    1
  1286. “When you watch the Indian TV media channels the impression you get is that a war is imminent”. How true. A very good analysis. What China is most scared, more than USA etc. are the Chinese people - and Taiwan May be unwittingly showing the Chinese people the way. With malice to none, a general observation - I will take this opportunity to very briefly underline that the Indian mainstream media requires a makeover. Let me explain, if you are a regular watcher, two major messages relayed are a) There are only predominantly criminal activities (mostly politically motivated) that goes on in our country 2) All governments (ALL) are inimical to the Indian Nation and all their actions are always anti-everything good. – and such other broadcasts. Tailpiece: Thankfully we can now get our news from other sources as the net etc…
    1
  1287. A fair assessment. There is a way where you can have the cake and eat it too.... The minimal defence expenditure has been more by default than by design. We have only so much money and so much to do. The solution is not in cutting essential expenditure on personnel for equipment. The nature of our borders (LAC) do not allow for reducing troop strength.. Neither can we let down our guard on the West. The answer lies in developing a robust defence equipment manufacturing eco system, including R&D, in the country. The money now spent on imports remains within the country and creates jobs and improves GDP and tax collections. A case of having the apple and eating it too. Unfortunately, we did not do that all this while. We have made a start now. Better late than never. An unfortunate state. But there is hope our industry will deliver sooner than later.
    1
  1288. A very good report alright. But pray tell me, do the people (public) need to know even these details - tactical positions in the face of an enemy, so to speak? Troop build up, patrolling....? Yes, the Nation needs to know if there is a danger of war or limited action etc....let the Nation concentrate on getting the economy back on track...for the time being leave the Border actions against PLA to the army.
    1
  1289. Deja Vu! I suppose all Governments bring in new bills to harass the electorate and make money. So the opposition has to oppose irrespective of the real contents of the bill. Tailpiece: when will India see deliverance? Then after 20 years “experts” will say India has missed the bus and China are years ahead. Please give us a break, media, opposition and “experts”. Please be objective and result orientated in your criticisms and views.
    1
  1290.  @DKSingh-wf8tn  Thanks DK. Like the "googly"..Just an observation...out of context here may be but you may consider My comments elsewhere--- As political parties DMK is no different from BJP. 1. DMK thrives on a platform of ethnic (Dravida) identity while the BJP is rejuvenating the Bhartiya identity 2. Both seem to have alienated a part of their respective electorate 3. Both recall from old literature 4. Both are good administrators – recent chess Olympiad and foreign investors forum conducted by DMK were as efficient as the G20 functions organized by the BJP. 5. Both are keen on development, progress and delivery to the needy INDI bolc etc.. have no qualms in aligning with DMK though they are anti "upper caste" (in principle)but cozy up to Muslims who have no Dravidian connection really... Intriguing politics
    1
  1291. DK..I like it “ most convinced, the INDI bloc” My 2 bit…The WORLD (NYT, Economist etc..) is aghast at India and is wondering how India can be pluralistic and Nationalistic at the same time. In a pluralistic (BJP has only 1,385 out of the 4,120 MLAs) democracy like India, it will be a surprise only if political parties do not leverage this sentiment one way or the other….by attending or not attending. The important point is the change in the “Establishment” and subsequent politics…. Tailpiece: All said and done, the “Ram Mandir” in Ayodhya will be a boost to the hospitality, travel and tourism industries while boosting the State and local economy. DK, A Question. So, is the 10 years of BJP rule also included in the 1000 years
    1
  1292.  @DKSingh-wf8tn  Point taken. Yes, hope that day comes. I suppose it is we the people who will have to make that day come. In our democracy, where it is vote bank politics as in all democracies by nature, it is the people and not the politicians who have to change. And it has to work both ways.,Also DK, can religions which do not afford freedom (to dress, pray etc.), know anything about religious freedom? It is much like political parties who do not practice inner party democracy, wanting to safeguard democratic practices of the Nation. A paradox, to say the least.
    1
  1293.  @JohnSmith-vn8dm  Yes John. Decisions have to be taken beyond political considerations. That too is a tall task. The good old adage…”It takes two to tango”….
    1
  1294. What are the reasons for the price rise. I did not hear this here. Did you? Also, it seems that the INC here is reacting to media reports as it seems the resignation letter of GNA has not been received by the acting president of INC. uhmmm… Tailpiece: It is tough to digest that a veteran leader (with demonstrated capability) of more than half a century in INC, is leaving for personal reason with a great lot of disgust. Just saying.
    1
  1295. My two bit Regarding air quality in North India… 1. What I have noticed in the USA that majority industrialization has been in the coast areas – West and East. Central USA has largely remained agrarian… The winds, so to speak, paly in the coast and at times to devastating effects! 2. In regard to the sports federations… the sports persons are not saints… I will leave it at that. Don’t call for politicians to put it right. Call for sportspersons to put it right. Believe me they can. 3. The opposition in India just opposes. Not now, but for 75 years. But the media always wants to be “liberals” and support the opposition actions. Here again the media and the people can put it right and not the Government alone. 4. Kharge… then again, the Dalit and caste discussions… abhorring for the common woman. better avoided. Raghuram Rajan can’t lead but he can play a good role in the government. 5. Sarcasm and mimicking in parliament is deplorable. 6. Whether the opposition or the Government who did not want to debate is a moot point. 7. Any law can be misused as they have been for ages We avoid discussing the real issues. Tailpiece: The point is that the opposition since 70:years have been abdicating their real job and do not allow the government to function in Parliament with the only intention of regaining power.
    1
  1296. So what?
    1
  1297. Poor choice of words for the heading to the video. Playing to the gallery is evident.
    1
  1298. DK, a bit long. Allow me to Political parties have been accepting donations, mostly in cash (black money, God knows where it went) since decades. Since the Bond scheme, donations have been through the bank. All (especially National level) political parties have received such donations…. Some more, some less, some MUCH more. It is documented and can be seen as soon as the key is found in the dog poo. It is very evident that BJP has got not one Lion’s but “a pride of Lions’s” share of the bond donations probably following the basic psychology of backing a winner. Usually, corruption is established by following the money trail. In the case of electoral bonds, money trails are crystal clear and it is all in white. The donations are reflected in the books of the donor as well as the receiver. An improvement from the old system, definitely. Donations to political parties are not illegal. A watertight case has to be proved in the courts of law to establish direct quid pro quo with Government (Center or State). Comments and commentaries by all and sundry and the ‘experts” at best can be aimed at swaying the electorate against the incumbent governments (who are the major beneficiaries) before the elections with allegations (some may be even true) of quid pro quo, connecting some dots. No real effect unless proved in Court of Law as said earlier It will be interesting to see how the opposition will leverage the issue (if at all) and the whole post Bond effect will unravel. Note: The opinion of the honorable SC in relation to the unconstitutionality is not on the donations but in the opaqueness of the procedure.
    1
  1299. SG, what about foreign intelligence interfering in another sovereign Nations politics and election through non state actors like NGOs and such influential groups…. This has become a more dangerous threat to India which the media is avoiding to discuss impartially. Liberalism? Free speech? Tailpiece: Impartial reporting.
    1
  1300. When the dust settles down, it will be realized that the “tour of duty” is a good programme to enable the youth of the Nation and may be detrimental to the efficiency of the Armed Forces. It is damning to see how political parties do not see beyond the party and are ready to do anything, even destroy the fabric of society, for power and wealth? Hopefully the Nation will one day, soon, see through these machinations of vested interests. Tailpiece: Gotta see how a balance in the Agnipath can be stuck. May require mid term course corrections. And one more point….. the great thing about the laggard Indian democracy is that for every good leader you get an equally good misleader. Validates Newton’s first law of motion
    1
  1301.  Nihal Singh  Nihal, I have put in all my points in brief. That is enough here to support my points. I am astonished that you are getting personal. That is a weakness showing lack of logic. I respect your views except that about me. Thanks anyway, for the brief interlude. Have a nice day.
    1
  1302.  Nihal Singh  I hold my view. You may have doubts about me. I may not matter. And I am not the issue.
    1
  1303.  Nihal Singh  past data...reservations, concessions, subsidies still on even after over 70 years. These are points requiring wide ranging discussions ....not on twitter and comments...but in Parliament
    1
  1304.  Nihal Singh  Obviously I doubt it. Why shy away from an extensive debate by the “experts” and parliamentarians?
    1
  1305.  Nihal Singh  Yes Nihal. Possible? Maybe. Such topics should be debated in the media and in the parliament.
    1
  1306. While choosing a religion is, thankfully, the prerogative of an individual, it is not the answer to stop crimes against the deprived. The deprivation is because of the economy and not due to caste or religious differences. In the case of the unfortunate Hathra’s case the HC asked the authorities (Paraphrased) “Would this have happened if the victim was from a rich family”. Religious conversions over centuries have not improved the living conditions. Uniform civil code will help differentiate society based solely on economy, to facilitate more equity in distribution of wealth. It is time for India to end differentiation and officious discrimination based on caste and religion. Improved living conditions (Roti, kapda, makkan) will automatically reduce crimes – even the Hathras’ type.
    1
  1307. It is time the nation discusses religion divorced from politics. The people have to take the initiative. WE have to take the initiative. “You reap what you sow and if any religious group sow the seeds of communalism by insisting on separate laws for themselves, they will reap the ill will of communal backlash” A “secular” democracy is one which has the same laws for all its citizens within which different religions practice their faith according to prevalent societal practices. A secular nation is not one which has different laws for different religions, which divides societies, allowing such divisions to be perpetually exploited by vested interests. Only “We the people” can change, without changing core values and just by emerging out of medieval era methods to make a difference in society. This is how generally it is in ALL democracies which affords “religious freedom”. Enjoy, smile, laugh Forward Ho!
    1
  1308. China practices autocracy within and liberal democracy outside the country. It seems to be paying off. The rest of the world has to come up with a brand new ‘weapon’ (tactics, coalition, economic offensive – whatever) to tackle the rise of China. Unless…. China implodes from within. Elementary, Dr. Watson. Tailpiece: The Islamic world is, obviously, divided. It is time that right thinking Islamic countries are inducted into world alliances etc… With this formation a taboo which was removed by Trump administration by getting UAE and Israel on one stage, is totally eradicated. Good for the world.
    1
  1309.  @moviesenthil  🤔
    1
  1310. When the whole commentary has been I’d caste since decades (centuries) inky the media can change the narrative… Tailpiece: Yes, I know, a chicken and egg situation, DK.
    1
  1311. For a large section of the media any policy decision in India by any government is “politics” and not governance. By the yard stick employed in discussions as here and elsewhere in the media there can never ever be governance. What a pitiful media. Tailpiece. This approach by the media since decades has been a bane that kept India a laggard democracy. A shame
    1
  1312. The headlines of Mr. P. Swami’s persistent and constant advice to Governments suggests that a haute know-all attitude. The Government is a machinery and does not work in silos. Mr PS often assumes without anything to show for it (like Indians help Srilankans to upend China- hogwash) and discounts the inputs and the larger picture of matters which the Government will surely have. A course correction in attitude by Mr PS will help the cause of communicating the real,picture all round. A hallmark of good journalism, I suppose. Tailpiece: This is an impression and probably the fact most times…With malice to none
    1
  1313. It is not that certain ingredients have the capability to fight particular viruses. It is just that some of the herbs helps in boosting the efficiency of the human immune system. I suppose we should not have anything against that - not even science. A better trained border troops will fight better.
    1
  1314. Gives an impression of glorifying assassination. Maybe only to me, perhaps
    1
  1315. Please remember it is a PANDEMIC All day long the media is only showing--- hospitals full of patients, disadvantaged families, helpless families roaming around, suffering from hunger, dying people, burning pyres etc. This doesn't in any way conceivable help if fighting the Virus. It only creates fear among healthy and willing workers and makes them sick.. We all know that there is a PANDEMIC going on, we also know that it is enough to say that there is no control over the situation - and nobody knows what's the right decision!! NO country in the world small or big have taken correct decisions to fight the virus. The active cases in the USA today are more than in India. Not even Dr. Faucci, who I have been following since March last year (when I was in the USA) knows exactly what will happen. He has said so to the Senate panel in the USA in no unequivocal terms.
    1
  1316. Vide worldometer.com as of yesterday: Serious cases : in the USA 8611: India 8944
    1
  1317.  @johndoe-vc1we  in other words, misleading... Bad journalism by any standard
    1
  1318.  @johndoe-vc1we  sure, but where possible the preconceived quips can and should be pointed out…that is all a reader / viewer can do and must do.
    1
  1319.  @johndoe-vc1we  john... .. Yes, contents matter ... But the Title matters more.. as it channelises the readers thought process.. a divisive ruse used by writers
    1
  1320.  @johndoe-vc1we  uhmmm… possible. By editors do not interfere with reports from journalists of her seniority.
    1
  1321. Let us face it. With the Indian constitution discriminating citizens based on caste and religion, India can never be a secular Nation, which calls for separation of religion and Government. It becomes more difficult as there are other Government policies, since Independence, which provides concessions based on caste and religion. At best India is a Pluralistic Nation practicing different religions. In the circumstance the onus to maintain harmony in the society is with the people. The rhetoric and the shrill ventilation by politicians on secularism and religion is just to mislead the people with the aim to get/remain in power and hence purely based to make money. We the people of India, should realize this at least now, and work for enhancing the economy as one People and not the Governments.Let us not be exploited.
    1
  1322. So, tomorrow how do we classify silver coated popcorn? Don’t confuse the issue, the media, salt and sugar are different. Liberal press is not always finding fault with the governments - centre/ states.
    1
  1323.  @SunilKumar-rd2uk  yes Sunil… perceptions differ… Governance is more than dealing with riots and insults and just about everything else including contrived hate.
    1
  1324. Good
    1
  1325. I hope there are honest efforts to identify the weaknesses. It could be at the top. Just saying. Tailpiece: We wish you, the INC, all the best. We want an erudite and “unified” opposition in the Nation.
    1
  1326. Good idea. Interesting. Memoir could come later… in ten years, SG?
    1
  1327. Who is writing the screenplay in Bollywood? Who will produce?
    1
  1328. Haha! Politicians, even those from IIT etc.never cease to amaze me!!!! Tailpiece: We do not expect trivializing issues from some politicians.
    1
  1329. A talk lonnnnnnnngggggggg overdue. Tailpiece: Indian = manufactured in India. Indigenous =. Home bred technology from scratch
    1
  1330. All said and done A thought in passing - apolitical and only to highlight governance aspects. With some sections of the media and few experts "predicting" a defeat for BJP in the ensuing elections, I hope the party at least gets to be the main opposition to take care of national issues while the I.N.D.I. alliance is busy handling parochial and vote bank matters. Tail piece: whose National is it anyway
    1
  1331. May be, just may be there is much more to the second wave than just "mishandling" and they know it better. After all they are foreigners, right?
    1
  1332. Good coverage, SG. I suppose we have been for long ignoring the ethical corruption in the world order. It is time we address the trajectory of globalization and its stated aim to create a more equal world. Are we on track? I would say a big NO. Tailpiece: Are people puppets controlled by strings of feelings?
    1
  1333. SG, at last taking guard on home ground? I am waiting for that day when I hear “Congress”, the visage that comes up in my imagination is of some leader who does not answer to a surname of Gandhi or Nehru. I am sanguine that this GOP has competent people with other surnames. I am not sure that the BJP will collapse if someone with a surname other than Modi leads it. Turmoil, yes. Collapse no. Tailpiece: Language of politics is not defined : legitimate and illegitimate are too in the vocabulary.
    1
  1334. Good point. Could the point have been made more forcibly in lesser time? Just asking Disclaimer: I respect the view that every Indian should be free to practice which ever religion she chooses and pray to any God(s) of her choice. It is afforded in the constitution and upheld by the freedom that comes with existence. But is that the real problem? Are we just fooling ourselves with psychedelic views reflected from mirrors and prisms? The problem is not the view in the rearview mirror. The real problem is basic tenets of some religions which profess that “My view is the only view”. As good neighbours, if the occupants of these structures respect the existence of the inmates, if I may and recognize the driveway to each as fair ways to reach their respective abodes, we would have come a long way. Tailpiece: Respect is not a one way traffic it has to flow both ways.
    1
  1335. This discussion on climate change effects and carbon emissions should have started soon after the II world war. All the “energy” spent towards nuclear weapons should have been used for energy generation. All the money spent on ICBMs etc. should have been used for research on generation of clean energy. And so on.. and so forth… Tail piece: Discussion on panels and TV by “experts” now will yield little result. People have to cut down on their wants. Governments, now do not have magic wands for creating solutions in a jiffy. Every citizen of this world will need to sacrifice and contribute towards the efforts.
    1
  1336.    👍
    1
  1337. pro looser you mean it is sad SAD left?
    1
  1338. Let us look at the larger picture within which India has to strategise its policies in the neighbourhood. For the present we have to assume that as a sovereign Nation our sole intention is to Defend our borders. We have a situation where we cannot chose our neighbours, at least two of who are unreliable across contentious and treacherous borders (in as much as, when both sides claim the same piece of land, it becomes contentious). We have seen that with China and Pakistan, diplomacy can take us only so far.The ultimate intention of our hostile neighbours is to keep India under wraps and not allow it to grow into any sort of regional / world power.The only strategy with India, in the circumstance, is a two pronged approach. 1. Develop and maintain a well equipped and highly motivated Defence force as all major powers are doing. This entails high expenditure. 2. Develop the Nation as a self sustaining (not a closed door policy) economy - a robust domestic defence industry is paramount to sustain the economy in which high Defence spending (point 1 above) is imperative. The money spent on importing the much required equipment, if channeled into the domestic manufacturing, while supplying the Defence with the much needed equipment, will generate many jobs as well as enhance our GDP. It is easier said than done. We have to make a start some time and any time is not too late. To succeed, the domestic manufacturing sector should become highly quality conscious. In regard to the minor (but important) neighbours, we need to realize that no country can live on love and free air. There is always a quid pro quo. We have to be in a position that being a friend of India becomes highly beneficial to the friend. We can discuss methods till the cows come home. We have to map our actions against this larger picture.
    1
  1339. Is having different views and pursuing it vigorously views polarization? Just asking
    1
  1340.  @serendipity1575  By that, do you mean that you are being brave by calling all journalists FRAUDs?
    1
  1341.  @serendipity1575  I respect your view. But will agree with it only to disagree.
    1
  1342.  @serendipity1575  oh yeah. We all , all of us, tend to pretend some time. Right? Enjoy . Stay safe. P. S. Do I know you?
    1
  1343.  @serendipity1575  That is not a very serendipitous remark! If what you say is true, then we are all too.. FRAUDS, would you say?
    1
  1344. What a programme on the media. Constructive journalism, if I may. This is also education. Kudos SG and The Print. Nice colour of Kurta too. Tailpiece: Digital gold and recycling gold may help India to save foreign currency and maintain a better balance of trade.
    1
  1345. That is the point. Details of such incidents are best left to its designs. The mystery has to remain to achieve the aim.
    1
  1346. It is a presumptuous statement by Mr. Vir Singhvi to say that Indians do not protect institutions. In the last five decades or so, it is more than obvious that the elected representatives (some times in collusion with some media who look for contrarian views for TRP) who stall parliament proceedings for reasons other than the stated when there are more pressing needs from them to be discussing issues of National importance. A look at the productive functioning hours of the August houses in the past few decades will support my case. The media and its stalwarts will do well to reportedly bring out this point and impress upon the MPS to do their job rather than always point fingers at the electorate. Tailpiece: The people are well aware what is good for them. The recent drama is a sham. The media should get more aware of what is good for the people and report their frustration …. at the opposition opposing only to regain power.
    1
  1347. This whole conversation is a scam and political browbeating. Here is an extract from a report from CNN, dated May 3, 2020, on the initial days of the pandemic in New York City, without lockdown – the most advanced Metro in the most advanced country. "Though the city doubled to about 2,000 its capacity to store bodies, funeral homes are still turning down cremations because they can't hold onto the bodies. A Brooklyn cremation chamber broke down under the sheer volume of corpses. Cremations are delayed to mid May and beyond. Bodies rest in refrigerated trailers in funeral home parking lots. Burials are backed up." "So many more deaths than we could have ever imagined," said Joe Sherman, the fourth-generation owner of Sherman's Flatbush Memorial Chapel in Brooklyn. "I'm doing this 43 years. I've never seen anything like it." Here is a link where you can read more https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/03/us/coronavirus-funerals-bodies/index.html NYC went into a lockdown subsequent to taking a big hit when there was no lockdown. I was a witness to this in NYC, where I am still stranded.
    1
  1348. What a waste of time..MPs should do better than play on the feelings of the electorate….this a childish act at best. They could, for instance organize a presentation where they can tell the electorate how the fuel prices can be reduced without adversely affecting an economy which subsists on where only 3% of the population pay direct taxes and 50% of trade is in unorganized (non tax paying) sectors.
    1
  1349. DK, The physical temple may not be the raison detre of BJP. With this event, BJP who have been the antiestablishment even while in Govrnment, will finally become the establishment. Tailpiece: The idea is more important here… also politics at its zenith, of course.
    1
  1350. Military strategy for public debate. WOW! Times, they are changing. If nothing else, it conveys that equipping the Nation for defense is a primary requirement. If only the Nation had realized this decades back. Just saying.
    1
  1351. DK, great as usual. Yes, these are not the real dynasts…they are probably not even sure of a ticket in the next elections…. a bit complicated Tailpiece: In the corporate world Amabnis control reliance, Adanis control Adani, Birlas control….. etc. etc… likewise, INC, Akali, SP, YSR, the Telengana Congress are in a different world of their own.
    1
  1352. Next stop for NSS….AAP?
    1
  1353. I fail to understand what really this video wants to convey, if at all it wants to convey anything. There are more ambiguous (with an agenda?) views here than facts. We know it is difficult to get the facts from that area. But please do not put forth "views" which serve no purpose than personal obsession. Obsession is a dangerous phenomenon which is detrimental to good health and the immune system. Tailpiece: We the people are a permanent fixture in the Nation. All officials are temporary and transitory in nature.
    1
  1354. If info (pre 2019) was given to ECI in a sealed envelope and the sealed envelope was handed over to H’ble SC, how can ECI have a copy? Just asking
    1
  1355. Disclaimer: Not a political comment. More to do with getting a clear picture. Please do a cut the clutter on the following two topics both of which are political and a strong suite for SG. 1. Post poll violence in West Bengal 2. Why is there not a whimper in political circles on efficacy of EVMs? I wonder whether these important ‘clutters’ topics will be in your priority, though. Thank you.
    1
  1356. Good
    1
  1357. Great analysis as usual. Mixing political analysis with civilization is fine . But civilization is not solely about religion (e.g. of Morocco is misplaced here) ). Tailpiece: Is Islam a civilization or religion? It is just a modern religion. The civilizations in the Middle East and N Africa including West Asia predates long before Islam. Islam is a modern regimented religion. I am not in any way discussing the merits and demerits of Islam; that is not my intention.
    1
  1358. You see polarization in a multicultural Nation can be eliminated only by instilling, owning by people, if you may, a sense of Nationalism. A common pursuit is essential for unity and in a polity this can happen only through a passionate common cause. Tailpiece: I wonder why the “experts” and the media are scared to accept this simple logic. A strong feeling of Nationalism is a must for a strong and unified Polity.
    1
  1359. Besides the media who has confirmed the surveillance. I ask the Q, not to exonerate the guilty but to avoid a merry go round and deja Vu. In other words this will also be a Much ado about nothing. We the people will want action, like judicial etc, rather than just rants by all and sundry!
    1
  1360. Plausible as there is nothing natural about this virus. The questions now are 1) Whether the escape was one which was facilitated by authorities. 2) If so, whether it is acceptable to the people of China? (we know how the rest of the world feels about it)
    1
  1361. Absolutely, Politics subsumes all. Should we get politics out of most things…especially the media and political “experts”. Absolutely. We the people are fed up. Discourage the public from discussing politics. Discuss progress…. In this case, there definitely has been a security lapse, no expertise required to surmise that with the PM of India (not Mr. N. Modi of BJP) stranded within striking distance of the enemy (drone?). A huge bureaucratic failure without doubt. It has to be established whether the incident was by default (failure) or by design (induced failure). Either which way heads have to roll immediately. Else these incidences will recur as a routine - a la sulli-bulli. We want the culprits and not endless useless discussions on the “politics” of the matter. Tailpiece. We gotta learn from the Defence forces for decisive actions. The report on the recent helicopter crash (with the CDS on board) has been already submitted by the inquiry committee
    1
  1362. How I wish we had a proactive and constructive opposition rather than reactive and blinkered political parties without any vision! Looking for and finding faults (often with help from media) is not the way to go. The fledgling AAP is doing an immensely good job. It will take at least a decade for it to make its presence felt Pan India. All other parties are either caste based and " local Nationalists" (regional bias). The LEFT is no more a presence in India or else where in the world. I do not see visionaries either in the political firmament, among intellectuals and high profile media personalities. Even if the ruling dispensation falls, be warned there is no safety net for India.
    1
  1363. SG, Dalda generation was our generation! Even the new generation has probably realized that all photocopiers is not Xerox. Interesting area to watch out.
    1
  1364. A veritable interaction. Essential for knowing the panorama of democracy. True, we must strengthen liberal democracy, a non statement. It is being strengthened. Some essentials I did not notice being mentioned here regarding democracy in India. (I reserve the right to be wrong)… In a large and diverse democracy like India, where political parties, since Independence (and some even before that) are - a) Parochial b) Run like family trusts (in most cases cozying up to particular sections of society c) Openly catering (since decades) to certain religious denominations d) Sectarian– each of these with the exclusion of other sections of the society, why are some erudite persons, suddenly using phrases like “Liberal Democracy”. Does this mean that in all these years since 1947, India was not a liberal democracy? Not clarified . Tail piece: Robespierre, Karl Marx and MG Gandhi were created by circumstances and they did not create any circumstance. So let us not try to portray nonexistent circumstances and try to prop up modern revolutionists. After all, t is the people’s nation
    1
  1365. Why do we produce only one Sonu Sood? Or are there more unsung real heroes?
    1
  1366. Also, TCA, do you suggest that ego should drive policy…the right ones? Can you give me an answer?
    1
  1367. Can’t government express its views to an autonomous body…. Why are you spinning it negatively? Please TCA you can do better
    1
  1368. Yes. The heading says it all.
    1
  1369.  @thisoverpcworld  okay, sir.
    1
  1370. The Print is doing a great job of informing. We appreciate, SG. Thank you for giving us a forum to express views. My two bit. In discussing politics, the emphasis is on how political parties maneuver to win elections. I have a sneaky feeling that the media programmes are channeled (pun intended) in such a way as to give an impression that winning elections is the ultimate in democracy. There should be more discussions on how one party or the other when in power will make a difference to the progress and well being of the Nation. It is all about economy – roti, kapda and makkan. We must keep these as the corner stone of political discussions rather than castes, defections, machinations etc. Tailpiece: The illusion that breasting the tape is the ultimate in democracy has to be removed.
    1
  1371. What about the 1976 agreement. SG, you skipped that
    1
  1372. I can say that your assessment of Indian cricket is spot on. Cricket is so encompassing that you can apply parallels in any walk of life. India is losing in cricket for reasons other thank cricket, the game. Also, what is happening outside the field is not “cricket”!! In Indian politics what is prominent is not Governance and the Nation. India is losing out on progress and development because of politics, which should have been the other way around. In both cases the action on the field suffers. Tailpiece:: Political defections stink.
    1
  1373. Want to provoke Bangladesh eh? Media and the Media persons can do better. Ah here it is. The philosophy of Hinduism does not see “insults” as it is such an all consuming and forgiving system. ( that is not to say that some may get provoked). Hinduism generally, is not worn on the sleeves. I suppose ALL religions who have confidence in their faith should do likewise. Show large hearts, character, resilience and keep confidence in their respective faith - ignore and move on. And those who don’t (including the media) should refrain from provoking them. Tailpiece: Religion (ALL) is not something that can be insulted with words or deeds. It is much bigger. Understand, realize and don’t wear your religion on your sleeve.
    1
  1374. Good. But I wonder whether it was only Modi’ s India which forgot the farmers. Also what is Modi’s India? In our political discourses all these years after Independence, are we guilty of discussing individuals rather than issues? Much like shooting the messenger to hide the message? I am a fan of the print...It is time we grow up from discussing Gandhi’s, Nehrus and Modi’s and Sha’s. They are not more important than the policies and the citizens. These leaders are temporary. Citizens are permanent. The Print should lead the way. Downplay individuals, put more emphasis on policies...else we will lose focus
    1
  1375.  @mananmehta6910  okay
    1
  1376.  @BlahAndBlah  Israel does not want to win. It wants to exist. Just by existing it lends stability to the region. Iran does not want it... Here again it is not about Palestinians. Isreal will any day take the two nation theory if Hezbollah, Houthis and Hamas go away. There will be peace. Iran does not want peace with Israel in the region. Iran is the villain Forward Ho!
    1
  1377.  @mananmehta6910  okay. So?
    1
  1378. Any comparison between Ido-Pak and Indo-China is preposterous. The dynamics, if I may, differ more than chalk and cheese!
    1
  1379.  @mohdshariq5814  great. Respect your opinion. To each his own then. Regards
    1
  1380.  @mohdshariq5814  True. They could have been avoided. By the people, judiciary, CEC, the Parliament, the Opposition, the media through a campaign and of course the Government. And they happened much later. Much after all that what I have observed. Do not see only what you want to see. We all make such mistakes of seeing only what we want to see. That will not enable us to fight the Pandemic. All have to accept their responsibilities rather than only point fingers at others. People attend Kumbh , People attend rallies. Regards
    1
  1381. When a Government takes a popular policy decision, the media and self-styled experts, who have the welfare of the Nation in mind [all others do not have the same feeling?]) reports it as a case of populism for votes to stay in power! When a policy decision attracts protests from a section of the Nation, the policy is bull dozing. When a Government follows its manifesto, it is majoritarianism and not a consensus decision. What exactly is democracy in India? How do we move forward with hundreds of political parties in fray in any election? Obviously, any party who can garner 30 odd percent of valid votes gets a majority to rule. If that is what we have chosen, so be it let the Government function. If we are forever protesting, rest assured we will make no progress. If we the people (represented through the media as well) do not change our attitude, it will be status quo and India will remain a laggard democracy. Tail piece: To protest is a right. But by exercising that right the cause does not become equally right.
    1
  1382. Great. It makes me wonder what were the “people” (the society) doing in Manipur during the despicable act by a crowd? Balme everybody in the world. But blame the society and the people of Manipur too for not "thrashing" the perpetrator but taking videos and cheering. Does anybody feel we the people" are beyond reproach for such despicable acts in society. Tailpiece. Therein lies a truth that feel that all of us are the people are beyond blame for the ills in society whereas we should be the ones at the forefront to prevent such acts. Media should not shield the society.
    1
  1383.  @DKSingh-wf8tn  ThePrint has pubkished some of my pieces and has my mail id.
    1
  1384.  @johndoejohnnydoe1477  uhmm…
    1
  1385. Is he sure of the 155 from his party? Reports indicate otherwise. Tailpiece: SG, phenomenal reading (and listening) capacity). Take a bow.
    1
  1386. A different type of a diesel problem, I suppose.
    1
  1387. India and Israel have a violent history, which in the case of India was glossed over in the 1900s by a false narration of non-violence. B. H. Liddell Hart writes in the book Why Don’t We Learn From History?: [History] cannot be interpreted without the aid of imagination and intuition. The sheer quantity of evidence is so overwhelming that selection is inevitable. Where there is selection there is art. Those who read history tend to look for what proves them right and confirms their personal opinions. They defend loyalties. They read with a purpose to affirm or to attack. They resist inconvenient truth since everyone wants to be on the side of the angels. Just as we start wars to end all wars”. Yuval Noah Harari in his book “21 Lessons for 21st Century” writes “Ability to explain the past, feeling world is understandable when really it is not, does not make sense even when you feel it makes sense, and the mistakes are made” History is not only about the past; it is also about the present and the future. There will be a livable future only if the present finds consonance with the past. Until then we are doomed to conflict situations.
    1
  1388. Absolutely right. Free money is not free. It enslaves.
    1
  1389. @Abhiuday Pratap singh yes, Abhi. True. Kerala has degenerated into an I’ll managed state since a decade or so. UP has improved, no doubt. We need to correct course for Kerala. Enjoy.
    1
  1390. Does this mean that all other major democracies in the world who follow UCC, do not have pluralism i their Nations?. For instance, there are Muslims and Hindus in UK….there are mosques and temples in UK…Diwali and Eid are celebrated in UK. Tailpiece: Do not speak of non existent apparitions
    1
  1391. Political Flashback. Thanks for the link. Good beginning. It will help if the same is done for all metros including cause of deaths. I suppose somebody must be already on the job..hope somebody is!!!
    1
  1392. Premjit Singh Hawaibam Possible. Such an analysis is in order.
    1
  1393.  Aryan Sharma yes, you can't think backward to move forward.
    1
  1394. Very informative for the uninitiated in matters of economy….simplified. Great
    1
  1395. Nothing of value should be given free to anybody anywhere. Even highly valued freedom should have price attached.
    1
  1396. Ha! A good (macabre?) take on the war scene in Europe. Scorched Earth? Normally adopted by defenders, mostly on retreat, to destroy everything to deny advancing enemy the use of all facilities left behind. Wonder why the commentator ( the Russian) says that Russia will resort to this policy. Does it mean Russia is planning a disengagement and withdrawing? Tailpiece: Makes sense to disengage - take Donbas etc. and get out. Face saving and okay for Russian economy and people too. Even Russia can’t sustain this war for long anymore. Neither can rest of the World sustain.
    1
  1397. A very informative coverage of world affairs, as usual SG. Such knowledge is very essential to appreciate and guide the dynamics of internal affairs of any country. Could the young profile of Taliban leaders be because of reduced life expectancy in Afghanistan? Tailpiece: foreign policies and relations can’t be developed in silos. The dynamics are turbulent.
    1
  1398. The real problem with democracy in India (also in all big democracies anywhere else in the world too) is, for good or bad, that elections are all about what we feel and not about what we think. The politicians and the media by their utterances channelize our feelings and not our thoughts. This reliance on feelings may be the undoing of liberal democracy in India and all over the world, which has even now degenerated into a puppet show controlled by emotional strings. The Governments, media and all other constitutional bodies are scared to tell the people to behave, especially in Pandemic times!!!! Feelings are not some divine qualities and they definitely do not reflect “free will”. I wonder where is democracy without thoughts. Tailpiece: Even today the emphasis is on showing sufferings (a pandemic will bring sufferings [disclaimer: Oh I too have feelings, but….] to defeat it we have to move on. Don’t be a puppet on a string. Address the real core issues and make people THINK instead of fanning their feelings.
    1
  1399. Absolutely, Politics subsumes all. Should we get politics out of most things…especially the media and (tongue in cheek) memorabilia (pardon SG, I couldn’t hold back)!!! There has been a security lapse, no expertise required to surmise that with the PM of India (not Mr. N. Modi) stranded within striking distance of the enemy (drone?). A huge bureaucratic failure without doubt. It has to be established whether the incident was by default (failure) or by design (induced failure). Either which way heads have to roll immediately. Else these incidences will recur as a routine - a la sulli-bulli. Tailpiece. We gotta learn from the Defence forces for decisive actions. The report on the recent helicopter crash (with the CDS on board) has been already submitted by the inquiry committee.
    1
  1400. Border disputes between Nations, especially like the ill defined LAC, should not be a matter for public discussions. Veterans of any ranks should definitely desist from airing views. The incoherent cacophony by these “experts” speaking in silos on particular incursions at best makes some TRP stories. The real issue may lie beyond the 3000 Kms of ill defined LAC. So, as far as the Indo-China border is concerned such “incursions” need not bother us unless it is war. There are competent people in charge dealing with it. If they fail the Nation fails. Veterans or the media can do very little. Border disputes are not the usual religious, political, economic, judicial or such matters for discussion on prime time media.
    1
  1401. Controversy stalks all “Boris”es - Boris Yeltsin, Boris Spassky, Boris Becker. Ha! Just saying. Tailpiece: In democracies row themes rule. 1. What is in it for me? 2. Grass is often greener on the other side.
    1
  1402.  @momobhai3792  obviously.. .But we may have to redefine many things….a bit complex when I say that we may have to call the Chinese bluff…reds between the lines
    1
  1403. I like ThePint as it lays down data in all discussions. Data is IMPPORTANT. Way to go, SG. My two bit, if I may. Why data is important. In India, we have a problem with data. Those who abide by faith are scared of the truth. Faith creates perceptions. Most Indians believe in faith and hence do not care much for data (truth). For instance, some faiths, as proclaimed, do not believe in birth control and consider those who do as non-believers etc…. This has more effect on the society than data. This notion has to be dispelled. Tailpiece: Is there a case to revisit “faith” by all stake holders? A special Note; Applying "Data" logic. Will reservations based purely on economic considerations, encompass all those who are in that category today. Some relevant data may throw much light.
    1
  1404. I have always maintained that religious texts were written by humans and should be treated as such. If we were to go back in time many modern religions will reveal an ugly side. I appeal to all sections of society to look ahead. For a society to be secular the religious leaders should periodically come together on a common platform and proclaim “Your God(s) is as good as mine; your path to reach him ( or her) is as good as mine”. Period. If this is done in a society no politician can use religion to garner votes. Any other approach for harmony (majority, minority, appeasement et al..)is only for exploitation and fail to address oneness of humanity with many GODs. These decisions such as Tuesday/Friday et al should be taken by the society and the people and not by law makers. All RELIGIONS need to recognize this and come out of medivial mindset and the “My way is high way” syndrome Tail piece: Some modern religions will have to travel more than half way to achieve this harmony.
    1
  1405. A good analysis. But the situation is clear. HAMAS, Houthis and Hezbollah are terror outfits / sponsored militia , with the latter two occupying and functioning from foreign(to the sponsor, Iran) soil. Iran is least interested if the Yemenis or Lebanese suffer. HAMAS (being a terror organization, explicit by their activities) also do not care about Palestinians in GAZA strip who they exploit and use as shields. Iran also sponsors HAMAS. Israel a democratic nation with a regular army is fighting these forces. Some of us who have operated in J&K and the NE are well aware how terrorists use the local population without any qualm. Israel is fighting a war for survival (do or die). Nobody wants to die. IF the world does not recognize this and keep supporting non state actors and terrorists there will be no peace in the ME or anywhere else in the world. Forward Ho!
    1
  1406. Good points SG. “Love your journalism.” Why the development in Brazil is important for India is because, Brazil is part of BRICS. With the left coming back in Brazil, China where they are as you say, Russia embroiled in war, SA..uhmmmm….. India will be the favorite for investments. Tailpiece: The World has shrunk.And one more point….Before the weather department stated saying”It may or may not rain” using “data”, the Indians and other tribes around the world forecast rains by just smelling the air. More effective even today…… “smelling the. coffee” is the mantra…. So “data” is not a must in many cases….I know you will say, this is a stupid statement. But there you are… when FMCG companies report reduction in sales in rural areas, we can “smell the coffee”.
    1
  1407. This programme should help supersede some perceptions. The problem about Perception is it works one way - as very few look at the self. On the lighter side; could it be because you probably need a thief to catch a thief?
    1
  1408. On a serious note DK, filing an FIR is in the ambit of police work. Should criminality be considered only when the court admits a case? Accepting an FIR is almost mandatory for the police. Anybody can file an FIR. Therein lies the anomaly.
    1
  1409. SG permit me to write this here… An extract....from one of my works “…..Let me illustrate…..I have narrated this incident many times to many people. I was posted in Delhi during 11/2011. When the ‘planing’ of WTC was being broadcast live on that evening of 7/11, four tenners (then serving in separate establishments), a Hindu (self), a Jew (R Jacob, (not Jake) visiting Delhi) and a Muslim (Azad Zamir also visting Delhi), a christian ( George, posted with NSG) were reminiscing old days in the company of Bacchus. We were recalling the bonhomie we had shared in the unit…. where we lived like in a community… we worked, played and partied together…..we attended the Gurudwara / Temple on Sunday mornings…where every one of us prayed for the good of the ‘community’…the emptiness of what we were witnessing on the TV was not lost on any of us…” Tailpiece: Life is all about incidents and meeting people
    1
  1410. Having seen the world and interacted extensively with people at large, I am convinced that most of the World has no real knowledge of India. An US president of a few years back was under the impression that Indo-Pak conflict was a civil war.
    1
  1411. Good assessment. My friend had an old beetle with ambassador wheels. A novelty and a very popular car. Everybody wanted a ride. Tailpiece: Beaten paths do not lead to new places. “Forever thinking” do not yield results.
    1
  1412. Great commentary SG. But do you really suppose that President Biden will be anything other than POTUS in the meeting? And I feel THATbis something good for India. India and USA. Not Biden and Modi. Tail piece. Relationships between entities endure… except in a marriage where the sole relationship is between husband and wife!!! Let us keep it that way.
    1
  1413. National news? What is the aim of this broadcast? How does this help in fighting COVID? If the sim is to point out shortcomings of GovernmentS, it can be done in a better journalistic way than this. A pathetic piece of journalism, in the least.
    1
  1414. The real problem with democracy in India (also in all big democracies anywhere else in the world too) is, for good or bad, that elections are all about what we feel and not about what we think. The politicians and the media by their utterances channelize our feelings and not our thoughts. This reliance on feelings may be the undoing of liberal democracy in India and all over the world, which has even now degenerated into a puppet show controlled by emotional strings. The Governments, media and all other constitutional bodies are scared to tell the people to behave, especially in Pandemic times!!!! Feelings are not some divine qualities and they definitely do not reflect “free will”. I wonder where is democracy without thoughts. Tailpiece: Even today the emphasis is on showing sufferings (a pandemic will bring sufferings [disclaimer: Oh I too have feelings, but….] to defeat it we have to move on. Don’t be a puppet on a string. Address the core issues and make people THINK. Fanning feelings will be counterproductive.
    1
  1415. Great. Our Panama to the responsible citizens.More of us can become useful like this in our own environment.
    1
  1416. Please remember it is a PANDEMIC All day long the media is only showing--- hospitals full of patients, disadvantaged families, helpless families roaming around, suffering from hunger, dying people, burning pyres etc. This doesn't in any way conceivable help if fighting the Virus. It only creates fear among healthy and willing workers and makes them sick.. We all know that there is a PANDEMIC going on, we also know that it is enough to say that there is no control over the situation - and nobody knows what's the right decision!! NO country in the world small or big have taken correct decisions to fight the virus. The active cases in the USA today are more than in India. Not even Dr. Faucci, who I have been following since March last year (when I was in the USA) knows exactly what will happen. He has said so to the Senate panel in the USA in no unequivocal terms.
    1
  1417. Sorry SG: Bringing Hindu Muslim aspect into this was least expected from The Print. You have missed the main point of political maneuvering and predominant influence of MIDDLEMEN (ADITYAS) in Punjab. Whatever, the media including THE Print, have failed to communicate the pros of the farm bills and taken the nonconformist stand (the media premise that it is chic to always talk against the establishment; pro establishment shows a weak press). The major issue here is NOT the protests but the farm bills. You missed the point this time. Unfortunate. Tail piece: To protest is a right. But by exercising that right the cause does not become equally right.
    1
  1418. Good show, DK
    1
  1419. I think the problem at Nizammuddin was NOT about religion...it is more probably because of the indifference of a group of infected people and their behaviour subsequent to the realisation that many who attended the function were potential spreaders. This aspect needs to be pursued to bring out the dangers of such behavior; also to examine any lapse on the part of the administration. The matter should not be trivialized under the garb of “communalist ion”. I see nothing communal in this premise.
    1
  1420. Honest and sincere reporting. Well done.
    1
  1421. Yes maybe something that should not have happened. The overworked and understaffed police force need to mend their ways. With due apologies to The Print.... The media is not indignant when a million Indians go about without wearing masks potentially endangering the lives of tens of other million fellow Indians. Wonder why. Just asking
    1
  1422. Thanks, Shekar….. A neglected area in Defence equipment,..of our Nation. Tailpiece. But those responsible will never ever be put in the dock… a travesty of democracy
    1
  1423. What is right or wrong in politics to learn lessons. Political games, have been played in the Nation since British days (if I may). All this while nobody wants to give a free hand to an elected Government. If you don’t like the way Governments are elected in India let us change the method. Firstly, let us limit the number of political parties. It is ridiculous to have 100s of political parties and expect one to garner anywhere near 50% of votes. Let us not be deceived. There is nothing known as coalition Dharma. Those in the game long enough will know it. Tail piece: You can't buy unless someone sells.
    1
  1424. A balanced powwow...no speculations...just facts...no overblown predictions...no “expert” comments Way to go...
    1
  1425. TCA is the heading a bit twisted? When stake holders are consulted you come up with “wish list”. When stake holders are not consulted the process is not democratic… Good media?
    1
  1426. SG, the front runner has said all what is to be said and felt. It is now natural to let the opposition commit and then attack. I am sure you know the sport Kabbadi. Tailpiece: Politics and politicians need not always be puppetteer with emotions being the string being the emotions and the electorate as puppets. Let us geom out of it, Your help is solicited by the common man
    1
  1427. How does anything change if peace is desired? We can take back pok through peaceful means too. And in any case we had never declared war against China or Pakistan. Why are you and the media in general seeing what is NOT? And when did India ever say that it did not desire peace? Will my favorite news channel, The Print, clarify what exactly was this video trying to convey? Thanks.
    1
  1428. If there is a strong ideology okay you have a point SG…. But it is almost always for power and money…. If you don’t get it in one defection it is difficult to manouvre for the less know leaders that is it….
    1
  1429. Bread and butter, politics? Ha ha. That is what the people are served instead of roti, of roti, kapda and Makan. Therein lies an issue.
    1
  1430. SG, you left out Captain’s take that Modi is not less popular but he “The Captain” is more popular in Punjab!!! …… possible. Tailpiece: This rant (or build up) of anti Modi (for that matter any individual) or pro Modi (for that matter any individual) is not real democracy. The media should be aware of this.
    1
  1431. As usual some aspects the main media does not dare cover. That these states are up and running (still a “going concern” in corporate parlance) shows the power of real federalism. Federalism is not how one prays or to who one prays or does not pray. Tail piece: One state in Kerala with 1.5 times the population of Sri Lanka has more than double its debt. One Q: who ruled these states for most years since independence? Just asking
    1
  1432. What you do is more important than what you wear so say. So watch the actions rather the words.
    1
  1433. So, can India too back out ? Ye it can. Any side can back out of any agreement.
    1
  1434. Am I right to assume that as the tone of this programme suggests, that Houthi’s are the heroes and the rest are villains. Just asking. Tailpiece: It can never cease. Homo Sapiens (including Morden media etc…) thrive on conflicts and destruction. We talk about it more than good things. Disclaimer: This not saying that this presentation was not required or wonderfully done. It is a general observation on ways of the world.
    1
  1435. In 1967 EMS Nambudirippad of CPM came back to power in Kerala.I remember one catchy slogan of that time. “Annan tharatha congress eh unnampole parappikkum” it meant “we will blow away the congress which does not give rice (Annam) as if it were cotton (Unname). There was widespread rice shortage in India then. The effect of the slogan including rhythm can be felt only in Malayalam. It was the best political slogan I have ever heard…. Nothing better in the past more than 6 decades… Tailpiece: But at the end of the day, Shekhar, I feel the narrative has changed and it is only about delivery these days… not even religion…The media may like to change the narrative.
    1
  1436. Shekhar, a good presentation. But you missed the main point. LAC is Line of Actual Control. The border is still disputed by both sides. There is no IB. THAT is the genesis of the friction.
    1
  1437. Could we have pure Governance, pure progress, pure development instead of pure politics.... The politicians are feeding off such “pure politics”. Media should stop doing a tango.
    1
  1438. Over thirty top companies of the World with a net value of over a trillion dolars are led by Infdian origin CEOs. Given the circustance, capabilities of Indians to achieve is beyond doubt. India is changing fast these days, WITH SUCH OPPORTUNITIES hopefully being facilitated in our country after many decades of decadence. My appeal to the Indian “Opposition” political parties is that for your dynastic, sectorial, parochial, power mongering agenda, do not muddy the waters with a “fight” against nonexistent apparitions of ideology and “threat to democracy”. We Indians are aware that you are aware , but are blinded by lust for power. Do not upset the banana cart – be more erudite and fight on the platform of development and progress. Tailpiece: Humanity has tried for millennia and failed to serve the right food for the soul of the people through religions etc…. concentrate on getting the food on the dinner table. With governments in more than half the federal states from parties other than one in the centre, democracy in India is flourishing. Your (opposition) recent meet is another instance of free speech and expression.
    1
  1439. Over thirty top companies of the World with a net value of over a trillion dolars are led by Infdian origin CEOs. Given the circustance, capabilities of Indians to acjieve is beyond doubt. Indian is changing WITH SUCH OPPORTUNITIES hopefully being facilitated in our country after many decades of decadence. My appeal to the Indian “Opposition” political parties is that for your dynastic, sectorial, parochial, power mongering agenda do not muddy the waters with a “fight” against nonexistent apparitions of ideology and “threat to democracy”. We Indians are aware that you are aware but blinded by lust for power. Do not upset the banana cart – be more erudite and fight on the platform of development and progress. Tailpiece: Humanity has tried for millennia and failed to serve the right food for the people through religions etc…. concentrate on getting the food on the dinner table.
    1
  1440. Politicians can’t even dance in peace. They don’t deserve peace, right?
    1
  1441. The media is, u fortunately, off track in following and reporting political parties. The obvious emphasis is on their winnability against incumbents. The quality of leadership, capabilities for governance, visualized direction (policies) in Defence, home, finance, foreign affairs, education etc… of the wannabe rulers are never ever discussed. Tailpiece: Winning elections is not the same as Governance.
    1
  1442. A revelation of sort to the layman by ThePrinf(SG). China steals data and makes a highway for exchange (use) this dat and later monetize the data and get an advantage in the war at the new frontier - DATA. A potboiler indeed. Tailpiece: You see what we see is not what it is. “Insults” and “loud speakers” are distractions. Governance is much more than that. Earlier “We the people” recognise this and change our priorities, the better. Keep religion private and do not wear it on your sleeve. Let us get out of a medieval mindset. The world is moving on.
    1
  1443. Activists are not beyond reproach just becuase they are actvists. Moreover every novice acivist will have many actuators! What you see is not what it is.
    1
  1444. We must thank these eminent citizens for a bit of humor in these tough times. “Goose that lays the golden eggs...”...aptly put. It is elementary Mr. Watson, unless someone continuously makes money, you can’t continuously give it to someone else. China and Russia have leant it. Cuba is yet to learn and remains very poor. One pandemic and some “eminent” persons want to surrender. Pathetic.. I suppose, “well meaning”should also be “well thought out”!
    1
  1445. P S each of these states has a population less than Ranchi!
    1
  1446. Actually the decline of INC unobtrusively started in 1948, if you get what I mean…. Inaction
    1
  1447. An "activist" is not beyond reproach. All novice "activists" are usually propelled by some actuators for own agenda. Tail piece: If the farmers were really being treated in a inhuman manner, rest assured the whole Nation would have rallied behind them.
    1
  1448. My comments are deleted. Can I know why? I can correct if I transgress. But I should know.
    1
  1449. ​ @94pranjalshukla  i understand your concern and respect it. But.. 1. There is no place for anger in diplomacy. 2. I feel no Nation formulates foreign policies based on reflected statements from political podiums in other countries. If they do, it is THEIR monumental failures. 3. The discussion here is on diplomacy not feelings...what should India do at UNHRC? Regards
    1
  1450. Tell me frankly, do such reflected comments like forming governments in neighboring states from a party podium really influence anything. I for one is hearing this only now. May be the shadows of those comments lasted for a day or two and were soon dismissed as being nothing more than a boisterous remark for show . Political statements are in any case shallower than policy statements. Commentators will do well to confine themselves to policies while discussing issues of foreign diplomacy rather than statements from party podiums.
    1
  1451.  @SPrabhakar  to the extend of young and fresh leaders... Out with ineffective and failed leaders....
    1
  1452. Finding only faults with the world in general
    1
  1453. Politics, especially for the media and media persons, is a lot more than just finding faults.
    1
  1454. Uncomfortable for India, rightly, is that China has not acknowledged it violated the agreement in Galway in 2022…. Yet India moves on that subsequent actions will be automatic acknowledgement…. Chinese pride is eclipsed
    1
  1455. The Great Britain has come a full circle from the days of colonization. Will that count in the equation?
    1
  1456. Very simplistically put. The look South strategy is all very well. To achieve success in any strategy many tactical battles have to be fought. We can’t wish away the tactical battles we will have to continue to fight on our Western and Northern borders. In regard to Afghanistan; in stock market trading, there is a saying that at times one makes more money just by doing nothing. By doing so you may not win any money but neither will you lose part of your capital resulting in net gain. India is in such a position where it does not have to stretch itself in dealing with Afghanistan and related issues – no gains but no losses too. You (SG) have already covered it well. Tail piece: We can’t say that India has been neglecting the South. Developing new Naval establishments in the South, making our own Naval equipment (The Aircraft Carrier, Submarines etc… ) indicate that India is aware and prepared for the new Geopolitical, if I may, realities.
    1
  1457. If our leaders feel anarchy is better than democracy, should we move to amend our constitution accordingly?
    1
  1458.  @freesoul3466  Thanks Srikanth. I too want the best for my country. I am not sure of the statistics. I also do not say that demonetization did not bring sufferings. Any change (1991, IT policy (Rajiv’s), GST etc…) will immediately provoke negative reactions. Some will suffer to recover. That is the hall mark of switching systems. My hand cart fruit vendor was back to his trade within days of demonetization. I understand all may not have come back so quickly. But since two years my ( I seldom visit departmental stores etc for daily needs…) milkman, grocer, snacks fellow, vegetable chap, handyman et al are on digital payment mode. Economists say that is better for the economy in near, medium and long terms! Regards
    1
  1459. I am not even remotely qualified to discus matters of economy with our ex PM. But… An informal economy (informal sector or grey economy) is the part of any economy that is neither taxed nor monitored by any form of government. Although the informal sector makes up a significant portion of the economies in developing countries, it is labelled as troublesome and unmanageable which it is. It is true the informal sector provides critical economic opportunities for the poor. Integrating the informal economy into the formal sector is an important policy challenge. We have to encourage any Government that attempts to do that. India can never become a developed country with a large informal sector. The transition is a must for progress. Tail piece: Any churn in a system results in temporary flux.
    1
  1460. SG, you can't stay away from the mike for long... That is okay.. But today you tried your best to stay away.
    1
  1461. Wars in INC are a result of bars in showing quality leadership for fear of baring the. barren top…… Tailpiece: Leave INC to new leaders for a few years…. 2024 is a lost cause anyways.
    1
  1462. An Extra judicial statement? Oh no! It is a democracy. One can talk anything anywhere. Freedom of speech. Right?
    1
  1463. What exactly is meant in secularism? In religious matters it should simply mean that every religion should be free to pray to its God in a manner each wants – that is assuming that every religion has a God and every one professing that religion wants to pray. In effect, secularism means that each religion accepts each of the other religion on as is where is basis. So, why don’t the leaders of these various religions announce to its followers that “there is not only one way to reach GOD but there are many ways. What the other religions follow are also paths that lead to GOD. Those who practice religions other than ours are also believers of God” Tell the followers that there is only one God with many names…call it/her/him by any name. Teach the kids this in Schools of all types. All politicians, self-styled “activists” of all types and THE MEDIA should convey this message always and all times. Why is this NOT done? Why wouldn’t these people, especially the activists and the media, convey this as it is - and stop blaming all and sundry for leading or misleading. Without beating around the bush, please tell me if this is not secularism, what is? It is definitely not about majority and minorities; definitely nothing to do with politics (how in hell did the two get mixed up?) . For those who talk “secularism” it is only about popularity, TRP, votes and money. All concerned have to walk the talk (with permission from SG?)
    1
  1464.  @altersimon9036 Where did I say I am not hurt by the intrusion?... Yes... I am definitely much more hurt by the way the MPs behave within the Parliament.
    1
  1465.  @uvg319  Umaid. Good points. Yes, the deficiencies and inefficiencies of any government should be highlighted, discussed and remedies sought. This or any government is not without faults. Parliament is meant for just this and not for heckling and haggling. THAT and there is exactly how Governments should be challenged and exposed so the people can make right choices. Enjoy.
    1
  1466. Has Modi become so powerful and positively popular among voters that only alliances of minor, regional, caste and religion based parties with divergent views of the Nation and policies have to ‘forcibly’ come together to ‘ defeat’ him. I suppose it speaks volumes of Modi as a leader. (Call me Bakht or kambakht; but that is not the point here) For instance Powar S has been in politics for more than 50 years and about four decades of it is at National level. Yet, he has no Pan India influence. Accordingly are such attempts to ‘defeat’ an indivual (as the HEADING of this video suggests) good for democracy. Tailpiece: Are we seeing a media play of villain and hero(es) a la Bollywood of the past decades?
    1
  1467.  @RAIRADIO  Rai, true. Partition was terrible. But then such “portioning” does not happen everyday. And so life is, to most, about roti, kapda and makkan. India is bogged down with petty politics. So it is rightly called a laggard democracy. We can do better by, as you say, acquiring skill sets etc… rather than indulge in fruitless political debated and diatribes. The key is progress and development and job creation.
    1
  1468. Politics in India has been more “politics” than anywhere else in the world. Rather than on principles, policies and the Nation, every political party without exception (except the LEFT and AAP?) has embraced religious and /or caste based affiliations for votes and/or “regional Nationalism”….and 87% of the National media is perpetually discussing politics 87% of the time. What is new?
    1
  1469. Great analysis. For any magnificent structure to be made a stable and strong foundation is required. If you start building while the foundation is yet being build….wonder where this is considered in the GDP statistics. Statistics takes us only thus far….statistics is not a panacea. Tailpiece. This is a political view and not an economist’s view as this video, as stated by SG, is also a political analysis. The foundation can take only, say, 5 storeys . If more storeys have to be made the foundation has to be strengthened. At these times construction above may slow down. Simple logic. No arithmetic.
    1
  1470. Does a cause become right just by exercising a constitutional right in its cause, even as the exercised right is in violation of another greater constitutional right? Just asking
    1
  1471. Excellent. With permission of The Print, may I elaborate? Not every patient who is put on a ventilator survives (Corona patient or otherwise). Wonder whether a trial was conducted for all possible uses of a ventilator like it is demanded for possible LSDs in regard to corona affected patients. Given an option (of course, depending on affordability) a last ditch effort on a ventilator is the choice of patients with no other hope. So, there you are, don’t split hairs on LSDs – they are meant to save lives (like ventilators) which can’t be saved otherwise.
    1
  1472. Should we the woolen believe that all “raids” on tax evaders, mostly at the MSME level, politically motivated as alleged by almost always by opposition parties and echoed by mainstream media? Just asking. Tailpiece: That is democracy, right? Again just asking.
    1
  1473. A very pleasant conversation by pleasing (Sg, too) personalities. Knowledgeable talk. But I have a different take on this climate change debated. This discussion on climate change effects and carbon emissions should have started soon after the II world war. All the “energy” spent towards nuclear weapons should have been used for energy generation. All the money spent on ICBMs etc. should have been used for research on generation of clean energy. And so on.. and so forth… Tail piece: Discussion on panels and TV by “experts” now will yield little result. People have to cut down on their wants. Governments, now do not have magic wands for creating solutions in a jiffy. Every citizen of this world will need to sacrifice and contribute towards the efforts. As they say in Hindi, “Abhi, Kutch paane ke liye kutch khon padega” ( to gain something something else has to be lost).
    1
  1474. A dubious and devious offering. Just saying. Tailpiece: Longevity is depended on how one eats more than what one eats. We were told that The Mahatma subsisted on one meal a day comprising ground nuts and goats milk.
    1
  1475. Another one from ThePrint, making us sit up and take note of AAP and not mein!!!! My take , is it what it’s seems? A traditional coconut tree takes anything anytime between 6-10 years after planting and live for about 60 to 70 years. An hybrid variety of the same tree bears fruit in 1-2 years but ,lives for 4-6 years. If AAP has to mature into a pan India, sustainable alternative it has abide time, develop visible local leaders and present concrete plans for all round National development rather than ventilating about other political parties. Tailpiece: What you are/can do is more telling than talking only about what others are not doing.
    1
  1476. China has its fingers (pun intended) all over. Wherever there is a dispute (there sure is on the LAC, especially in eight locations) it is either settled by force or through negotiations. Negotiations means “give and take” without bloodshed. War also means give and take after wasteful expenditures and bloodshed. Points for consideration are: 1. War or negotiations. 2. Is India politically ready for negotiations? 3. Is China ready to negotiate? 4. Is India ready for war? 5. Does China want war? 6. Will internal bickering (in nIndian media and parliament etc…) on a well-known situation help India or China? 7. Is China aiming to destablise India politically (a sure enough aim of any Nation to destablise its neighbour), even proposed as an instrument of war by Chanakya. 8. Are there other options for India like Internationalising the dispute etc. (Not recommended due to obvious reasons as everybody involved will want their pound of flesh) and also extend their “help” all over piepecp:mmrmeettals = Vuei keaeae
    1
  1477. SG, do you approve sarcasm in quality reporting? Is is it politics getting into yo?
    1
  1478. I understand the compulsions of political journalism to mix up offerings with a little masala – the taste of the presentation will be directly proportional to the quantity and inversely proportional to the quality of masala used !!!!! Having said that, will it be wrong, to say even if ever so grudgingly, that in all three areas of Pakistan, terrorism and Bangladeshis matters are a bit more under control than it was, say, 3-4 years back? It just could be, because of various reasons – some obvious and some not so obvious. Tail piece: There are many sides to a prism.
    1
  1479. I differ in that the Chinese ambition is not territorial or military. It is just a veneer. So is this intelligence report. It will be naïve to assume this report by the US intelligence agencies placed in public domain will reveal all – an oxymoronic situation of sorts. I will add that given the global dynamics, China is definitely the strongest, not yet the most powerful, Nation by character and intend of purpose and is in a position to quickly act or react. Its sole aim is to dominate the world economically and later culturally. For India - all great powers to be always leave a window open somewhere. History is not a study of only the past; it is about the present and the future as well
    1
  1480. DK, it is not as if there is absolutely no advantage in ONOE. Debatable. But one aspect is sure that political commentators and psephologists may not have any work for more than four years… right? Democracy is governance and not elections
    1
  1481.  @skm460  Biswesh, yes. Question the Government and also all institutions of democracy including the media and the experts. My point is questioning is different from giving lessons. I will leave it at that. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    1
  1482.  @michaelinterlandi4231  True. But the language, how you say something, is more telling than what you say. Present your views as views. Not as lessons to people who are actually doing the job. Differing views etc. are surely welcome. The how is more important than the what. A know all attitude helps no one.
    1
  1483.  @vinaysharma5675  Vinay, thanks for your perspective. Respect it. The people (samaj?),including the vegetable vendor, have to be definitely told off when they repeatedly violate rules and instructions. In extension of what I said earlier consider the following with a non-partisan view. ( this is my complete observation commentated and published on the digital print platform on the same matter) Role of the media: When the media constantly berate only the politicians, specially from the ruling party (NOT A RECENT PHENOMENON BUT SINCE DECADES) for all ills, they do two things. 1. Abdicate the responsibility of informing the public of the reality of affairs. 2. Make the public complacent by exonerating them from all wrong doings (like not following road discipline, wearing mask etc.), by putting the blame for all wrongs on the administration, rightly or wrongly, always and every time. Choice with people in a democracy: In this instance, in our democracy, the people had a choice to attend or not attend the rallies and to wear the masks if they decide to attend. I will not blame the politicians that some people attended rallies without wearing masks. Choice with the administration in a democracy: Also, can somebody tell me whether the CEC has the authority (if not does anybody else have?) to prohibit all political rallies, in the wake of constitutionally mandated elections and conduct voting etc. without campaigning? Could the Parliament have taken such a decision with 2/3 majority (else, I know, majoritarianism and tyranny will kick in) Tailpiece: Such reports as this article are all old wine in old bottles and will serve no purpose in Nation building. I wish the media address real issues that matter. we all want a safe and prosperous India. Regards
    1
  1484. Why single out only some politicians? Should we the people be attending rallies when we have a choice? Should we the people be out without masks? Who forces us to behave like the way we behave when we can do better out of choice? - Where is the media on the roads and in the shops to show us our faults and castigate us? This is what makes such reports suspect. Is it to inform (as The Print claims) or to influence? A point about mask discipline: A few days ago, some weeks after my return from the US in Dec 2000, one morning in my locality, I found that about 60% of the 200 odd individuals I counted either did not wear a mask or wore them around their necks. These, I am sure is the case all over the country - rally or no rally. I don’t see media reporting these lapses on our, the citizens part, on a regular basis. On the same day, my "nukkad" vegetable vendor from who I purchase my daily veg needs (not from BIG or Small basket) too was not wearing a mask. When I asked him why not he said that what is the necessity now that the virus is going away. He did finally wear the mask when I explained the situation. Tailpiece: The media and "on the field" reporters will do a better service by repeatedly telling us the people to follow COVID appropriate behavior. The people too have a responsibility
    1
  1485. Not unambiguous politicians - uneducated ( in matters of Governence, diplomacy and National security) and self serving. Exceptions are present but the larger crop…..
    1
  1486. As usual a very realistic presentation. Truth and reconciliation. Wah!!! Accept the PAST deeds. I agree. The real “problem” in India, in regard to Hindu-Muslim or Hindu-Christian animosity is not in the present or the past. It is really the present (across religions, specifically with some) not accepting the past and striving for change. Briefly, let the atrocities of the past be accepted across the spectrum, just like the acceptance of subjugation of Dalits etc… MOST IMPORTANTLY, let ALL religions openly accept all other religions as at par with its own. Tailpiece: Methods are not important for those who already have the knowledge. The real knowledge is, what matters within and not without. The only permanence is change.
    1
  1487.  @pio4362  Thanks... Yes two languages. Greetings.
    1
  1488.  @oonaghanderson6993  Did I say that? Uhmm….
    1
  1489. As usual a pragmatic analysis. There are two important points in regard to the USA which will have a bearing on all the issues mentioned. 1. The USA may not always “Walk the talk” as SG did simultaneously, with NDTV. In diplomacy, where you can walk and talk in different places at different times, the talk may not be as important as the walk. 2. Biden may not have the unstinted support of all Democratic law makers at all times, very essential for a strong president in everything he does, as Trump enjoyed with the GOP senators for whatever reasons. In regard to India, It has to continue to do what is best for it immediately and in the future. Compromises are part of Nation building, but there has to be more “take” in the equation. India is just starting out as a Nation after decades of hangover from the happenings of last few centuries.
    1
  1490. After all the hype, the Presidency may be. Blinken and Biden time!
    1
  1491. Good analysis. I wonder why is the “civilized” world and human rights activists vociferously ask HAMAS ( I believe they have a political office in Qatar , a US ally) to release the hostages. I am yet to hear such an appeal…not even in the UN. Tailpiece: oh yes, the terrorists are not condemned by not even by the media.
    1
  1492.  @NA-mc4zq  yes. True, so what is new? But also be aware that by natural jurisprudence, those who can question can also be questioned. ALL are equally liable to be questioned and cannot every time escape quoting freedom of speech etc.
    1
  1493. Not in Defence, but in reality. The Language.....not a strong suit for many...he should have referred to the NGO rep as “NGO person” , I supposeI He surely had the jeans in mind and not the sex of the person, I suppose. Now twist it as you please... an example of where the media leads us.
    1
  1494. Let us take the case of the electoral bond issue. It is known and reported and crystal clear that the ruling BJP has benefited the most from the scheme. I am sure it is not a surprise and only to be expected that in such a scheme the ruling party will receive maximum “donations”. The media and the Justice system are handling the issues correctly. The real action will start once the list is released. In order to implicate any political party some quid pro quo will have to be established with irrefutable proof and proved in a court of law. Otherwise, the whole matter is only a procedural issue which will be corrected subsequently as per directions of the honorable courts., There is enough noise asking SBI to release the list. The media can’t force SBI to take immediate action. The colluded activity of the Government and the Bank is more than evident to the public. Tailpiece: Then what. Donations are not illegal unless a watertight of quid pro quo can be proved in the courts. In other cases just by saying data is wrong etc. does not make data wrong. Prove it…. Can’t the powerful opposition lay down “facts” in numbers and black and white. Else all is hollow propaganda.
    1
  1495.  @Deveshi.A.  OMG.Thanks Srikanth.Yes. Corrected.
    1
  1496.  @minnowbasher2015  (sane warrior) POK has to be returned to India. There is no doubt on that. Take care. Enjoy.
    1
  1497.  @minnowbasher2015  The bifurcation was done through legislation. The constitution did not intend to continue with article 370 forever. Moreover, Ladakh will get focussed attention as a UT.
    1
  1498. Do all institutions in India, including the media, always do the right thing to score a 100 / 100. Every institution, including elected Governments, of the country are often unethical and flout rules...EVERY.......and each one points the finger at the other....the people have to change...it will happen only when the rider on the road wears a helmet even when the police is not around....
    1
  1499.  @gulabh  Is it?
    1
  1500.  @hari8151  Hari, I missed the last flight to Mars. May be I will get the next one to Venus. My point is beyond Kishore P. While all over the world people go out and vote, it is only in India people cast(e) their vote! Yenjoy!,,, and pray tell me what is "professional" politician? Therein lies the problem
    1
  1501. The actual normal irritants of democracy… give a thought to the Nation…democracy is not synonymous with chaos I f RG or anybody has a half the acumen of Modi (with all his warts) India will be well served, alright… But… is there? “Democracy” is “back” in India. We will be able to witness the dance of democracy in social media and on the streets with false narratives, out of context comments, protests, hartals, road blocks (Rasta roko), bandhs, constant disruptions in parliamentary proceedings etc. Everything except policies, progress, development, economy, reforms etc. will be discussed in the media – all media. The West and all those who want India to stagnate will laugh all the way to the bank. Will India go back in time to be a subservient state? You got a ring side view to season 3 of the “India” series… Get your dinks, snacks and plonk on the sofa in front of your TV.
    1
  1502. As a neutral (world & Indian) observer, am I to believe that this religious play in politics is par for the course? Just asking. Also just the heading suggests, that this is what The Print believes and approves. Just saying. Disclaimer: My comment is not in support of any political party or religion.
    1
  1503. Pray tell me, which polls are not critical for N.Modi?
    1
  1504. This secularism (whatever it means) can’t really be a one way street. Can it be? Just asking.
    1
  1505. A very correct analysis. But to what avail? How does it help anything? Let me explain… In a diverse Democracy as India, these plays were, is and will be the order of the day to win elections. A deja Vu. Let us ignore these and hope they will disappear in favor of a good economy and living conditions for all. Let the media concentrate on living a life for all and not highlight such plays by political parties, only then we can hope to eliminate “cast(e)ing” a vote rather than go out and vote. Media has to take its share of responsibility for this to happen. Tailpiece: In India people go out to cast(e) their votes while in all other democracies people just go out and vote. I suppose we have to point fingers at ourselves rather than at the politicians, if this is to be corrected.
    1
  1506. *** Disclaimer: Not a statement of offence or in defence. I suppose SG has once again come up with some statistics by way of information. Whether and how the Government should react to these statistics is a moot point. We are now in a world where linear reading of data is passe’. We have technology to quickly process raw data with many variables peculiar to particular situations and geographies. You can’t expect that similar data from Bangladesh (a small largely homogenous Nation) and India (a vast heterogenous federal state), can be handled with the same logic. The variables that affect the raw data will be different in each case. As an example of differing situations et al... Something to chew on: An extract from Ruchir Sharma’s book “The 10 Rules of successful Nations” “When massive credit binges start to unwind, and credit growth falls below the rate of economic growth, the result is often a painful recession. But this is necessarily a cleansing step".
    1
  1507. US is 17 in 273 years after independence; India is 131 in 73 years . US has taken 200 more years to climb, if I may, 114 places. Besides US is also the largest economy by miles. Some more statistics for whatever it is worth.
    1
  1508. What popularity? In the recently concluded Presidential elections in the USA Biden won; he got 52% of the popular votes while Trump got 48%. what do we have here? A President who is 4% more popular? To 48% Americans he is unpopular. So much for "popular" leaders. If we do not separate individuals and policies in discussions we will not get anywhere.
    1
  1509.  @nijilanand  why should government regulate what is eaten by the citizens. (Now, don’t bring in the beef angle in this). Less regulation and more self discipline is what is needed.
    1
  1510. Riled up India or Indian media. Marking an objection is NOT Riki g up. Tailpiece: wonder whether media uses some misplaced words by default or by design…. Just saying…. Free press is what it should be…right?
    1
  1511. Made us proud. Congratulations.
    1
  1512. Tell me frankly, Is more than 3% of population really involved in this cock and bull story of hate mongering etc… A honest study will reveal there is more ~ mongering in some drawing rooms (over d*”*$s etc) and the media (by “angers” (angry anchors) and “experts”). Let us get real and get the economy moving. At the end of the day, it is only roti, kapda and makkan. Are the experts and the media up to conveying this to the public? As they ask soldiers aspirants - “Do you have it in you?” Tailpiece: Narratives often mislead.
    1
  1513. What about the role of the people in all this? To absolve religious leaders from finding a long standing solution and blaming the politicians fo these social ills is myopic. It is just the reason why the problem lingers on. If the media do not discuss this in such animated manner using those who do not know a thing of society, history and religion, as seen on some tv channels, people will find a way to solve the issues. There is an initiative by Mohan Bhagwat. Tolerance etc. is not a one way street. Religion is not essential for life. It is just a mirage used to exploit and blackmail people. Religion is not essential to reach GOD. And let not archaic beliefs hijack society. Tailpiece: Regimented religions have to come down from pedestals of “My way is highway”, even if scriptures have to be rewritten. A plain speak.
    1
  1514. Haha! Win win!!! If we reflect objectively, probability it was only during PM Narasihma Rao’s stewardship,the Congress Government (though a minority) acted with purpose and a long term view of the economy. For the rest of the rule of the Congress we had just reactions and no proactive or farsighted actions for the economy. The congress party can get out of this rut only with a leadership from outside the “family”. A view without any animosity towards anyone or love for some one else. Tailpiece: Congress will do well if interests of the Nation drive the internal dynamics of the party.
    1
  1515.  @Subhashish69  True
    1
  1516. Very refreshing programmes from the Print. Gotta get a wider reach. I am recommending… Tailpiece: May be it is time for media and senior political analysts to change the narrative to only discuss the performance, policies, etc… of political parties ad change the mind set of the people to development and progress. Else we will remain a laggard democracy. And one more point. It is time the congress party jettison the Gandhis/Wadras. The etching is in the wall. I wonder how it can be missed.
    1
  1517.  @zetaforever4953  okay let us talk about today. Let every Arab Nation accept that Israel has a right to its own territory in the region and come to the negotiating table. If even after that the Palestinians (Not HAMAS) - they are barbarians anyway - do not get a sovereign place within secure and defined borders (they surely have aright to it) I will go with you. Peace is a two way street . Not a one way road leading to a kind alley.
    1
  1518. The real issue in any action is not what is done but when and how it is done -even in murder the ‘how’ ranges from manslaughter to pre-meditated. That in this commentary politics is also explained, is there more to this than meets the eye? Disclaimer: Not in support of anything or anybody. Just a view
    1
  1519. YSR + BJP = win win for both.. elementary, I feel.
    1
  1520. Like the Nehrus and Gandhis dominating INC? Like the Karunanidhi family dominating DMK? Like Didi dominating TMC?Like Abdullah’s dominating NC?Like Yadavs dominating SP? Like LAlu clan dominating RJD? Like Thackeray dominating Shiv Sena? Like Shores…… and so on so forth…. May I request an answer from Mr Y. Sinha, if he has time to reply,y to a common man?
    1
  1521. Spin on spinners!!! Pun on spin? Intended or unintended? Enjoyed
    1
  1522. Made us proud. Congratulations
    1
  1523.  @parvadhami980  unfortunate
    1
  1524. It is all very well…. A thin line between free speech and freer propaganda etc…. If we have to bring peace in the Indian society between the two communities, the initiative undoubtedly has to be taken by Islam by its leaders and and not by Muslims or by Others. Muslims are people like anybody else. The leaders of “Islam” require to project Islam as a more friendly idea where the religious leaders and All India Islamic organizations (so many of them ….) publicly accept the methods of prayers and GODa of other religions as equals. I hope you get the drift….else it will take long to explain this line of thought. Tailpiece: The venerable Pope has/is revisiting archaic Christian laws or whatever, he is reaching out to all societies (including Native Indians in the USA and apologizing to them)….get the drift…. To move on history can be forgotten but the ideas need to be cleared.
    1
  1525. At last these stories are out on video. Good show SG. There is much more to soldiering than pulling the trigger.
    1
  1526. What is happening in Gaza, they say, will increase the resentment in Palestinians and create a generation of hate. Not helpful for a solution. What is happening in GAZA today is exactly what happened with the Jewish race for centuries. A race (jews) which was hounded out of everywhere, pilloried, massacred, etc.. for generations. These cyclic actions, for sure, will never ever bring peace. The cyclic will continue if judgements are made where loyalties “lie”. HAMAS is lying and so are her handlers. They do not act for Palestinians but act only against Israel….they do not want Israel…That is not an option Tailpiece: The media and the world should try calling out terrorists vehemently despite the lie of loyalties. Else it will be mayhem. Shouting from an ideal high pedestal will get humanity nowhere.
    1
  1527. Hypocrisy now has two aliases... 1. Diplomacy 2. Media
    1
  1528. A good overview. Tailpiece: AAP is NOT making politics any different. It is also raking up sentiments to influence the electorate. But the silver lining is that the Indian electorate is wiser, much much wiser now. Hope the mainstream media too realizes this.
    1
  1529. There is a funny feeling. There is nothing natural in the more than a year long behaviour of this virus. Is it another Frankenstein - this time knowingly created and released. Will we ever know?
    1
  1530. You can’t fault somebody for being pro Modi (bakht?) or anti Modi (secular?) – by the way both “bakht” and “secular” are the two most misused words in Indian public debates. That the two co-exist, amid slight tensions, is the USP of India. Even by the law of physics, there can’t be stability without tension! E.g. heavier objects are more stable as they exert more tension towards the resting surface. We can’t say this is right and that is wrong in the present. Right or wrong can be decided only in the future, always and every time. Tail piece: With special status based on caste and religion in the constitution and existing Government policies that discriminate based on caste and religion, how can India be a secular state. New political dispensations that clearly understands and supports real religious pluralism and willing to examine uniform civil code for better Governance is required to sustain democracy and challenge BJP if at all required.
    1
  1531. Peace comes not from the absence of conflict, but from the ability to cope with it.
    1
  1532. Deja Vu! With such responses by all politicians who face enquiries, it would seem that politicians always get away with anything. Not a new feeling for the exasperated electorate. Why can’t we trust the system ? If we can’t, we better change the way of our democracy. It would seem that our politicians will never change … hiding behind “harassment etc”.. irrespective of political parties.. Tailpiece: Can’t trust anybody eh? Do we change our democratic system? Just asking.
    1
  1533. Once upon a time, there were great people in the INC who could articulate well with purpose, lacing arguments with facts! When will we return to days of politics without ‘politics’. Will media take the lead for meaningful discussions?
    1
  1534. Obviously a political posturing. Can some one clearly explain how the rescinded farm laws do not benefit the farmers of India or any Nation which has such laws? Can that some one also explain why only about 30% farmers from 20% geographical extent of India were protesting? Tailpiece: The investments are flowing back to China because with all its warts the Chinese Goverment can take decisions and implement them. If India succumb to protests by minuscule population and vested interests and allow these agenda based “agitations” to derail its progressive policies, we will forever be a laggard democracy and remain the favorite place of the Western press and a large section of our own (mirroring) media to showcase our “backwardness”.
    1
  1535. Yes, Rice…well brought out..The biodiversity is against growing paddy in the Punjab? Tail piece: But then, it is all about money.
    1
  1536. Good that the media is coming alive to warn the public of inappropriate COVID behaviour. Better late than never. Keep it up.
    1
  1537. A super take on Banks. Good education for the public who are generally fed on insignificant (non essential for roti, kapda , makkan) matters of religions etc. Privatization is the way to go for services and personalization for religions. Tailpiece: Nationalisation of Banks is alright. But “Nationalisation” of the spirit and thoughts of a Nation for unity and strength is bad, right Congress, left etc…? Pathetic. Whose Nation is it anyway?
    1
  1538. Not in Defence, but in reality. The Language.....not a strong suit for many...the UK CM should have referred to the NGO rep as “NGO person” , I supposeI He surely had the ripped jeans in mind and not the sex of the person, I suppose. Now twist it as you please... and protest - an example of where the media and vested interest leads us. And the ripped jeans....there are still many (even among the protesters) who believe in dressing for the occasion. E.g. "Dek shaadi mein kya pahenke aaya?" Disclaimer: I respect women. My comment has nothing to do with gender. Please do not twist this comment too.
    1
  1539. SG’s different take on matters is refreshing. Imran: When cricketers / sportspersons make it to lead states they tend to approach governance as a sport. For example, downplaying the opposition, sledging etc. which was part of cricket in Imran’s time. I am not reading much into Imran’s diatribes except for entertainment. The real worry is the economic downturn of Turkey and Pakistan and with Afghanistan in the vicinity - tough times ahead for the neighborhood. Cricket: It is difficult to reach the pinnacle of any sport and it is more difficult to stay there for long, unless your are playing tennis or your name is Tiger Woods. Tailpiece: India won the Benson & Hedges World Series one day tournament in Australia in 1985. It was a commendable victory where all leading teams participated and Ravi Shastri was the Player on the series.
    1
  1540. Okay Sameer Wankhede allegedly creates a crime. If true law , as they say, has to take its own course. Does this condon the original criminal act, etc…. We the people should be clear on that. One criminal act should not condone another. Tailpiece: Everything else is story.
    1
  1541.  @priyanks91  okay
    1
  1542. Thanks
    1
  1543. “Free”. Nothing is free. Power (pun intended) does not come free. Somebody has to earn some money and pay for it. Who and whose money will be used to pay for it, Mr. Chief Minister. I suspect, I (a taxpayer) will end up paying for it besides paying for my own electricity. Just saying. Tailpiece: There is no free lunch anywhere. Not even in communicant China.
    1
  1544. Haha! An elementary Question. Who is responsible for Congress downfall from a high perch? To answer this Q, no scientific knowledge is required or as they say “ it is not rocket science” to find an answer. Tailpiece: It is highly condemnable that there are no congresspersons with gumption to throw out the Gandhis and save the party which still has gas to “serve the Nation”.
    1
  1545. What will,rally be achieved for the Nation with disparate unity of political parties most of who cannot keep even their respective parties United. Why is the media and experts not debating the de asking effect it will have on development, foreign affairs, economy etc. Can these parties become Nation first and party later. We all know that this is just a pipe dream. Change the congress leadership, follow a new Nation centric approach. Tailpiece: Here is where the media for most part is vow fully found wanting. Unfortunate, to say the least.
    1
  1546. It is unfortunate that a political party like the congress does not recognize the actual reasons for its downfall and its current floundering status. With no young leaders in its ranks, who can appeal at the National level, I wonder how redeeming lost causes will help. There is no doubt that the Nation is the loser. With fragmented dispensations (regional parties) ruling the Federal States, it will take much longer for the Nation to progress to the next level.
    1
  1547.  @DKSingh-wf8tn  yes, DK. May be people like you and we the people can get them to change.
    1
  1548. Too much credit to CIA (opponent) You do this to hide your acts. Tailpiece: So very traditional Chinese approach.
    1
  1549. Sg, pray who is NOT hurting? A section or a few do not make a whole. Tailpiece: It is because somebody or the other is always hurting the diversity persists. At times the Muslims, at times the Hindus, at times the Sikhs, at times the Defence forces, at times the traders in the market (both in stocks and otherwise, at times the Media, at times the corporate and at all times the common man (who is he?). Tough decisions are required if India is to progress and create wealth enough for a near equitable distribution. We all have to suffer for at least a generation more, starting today to achieve this.Reflect. It will take a few pages to explain/illustrate. Creating hysteria does not help. And Ah! Hysteria is the breeding ground of violence.
    1
  1550. Replace anybody. Nobody is indispensable. But it is obvious that in the short term the economy can be propped up only by spending money that we don’t have( print, cut taxes what ever). When the money comes in, by way of direct payment or whatever, it will be spent only on food and such necessities...which will not be much. Very few will buy a new tv, phone, house etc... a lot will be saved. Banks in any case have excess liquidity. We can go on and on...experts can go further. But in these times of a pandemic it is not only about the economy. It is also about the people; their psyche. You can’t find solutions in text books. So, let us cut the rhetoric and prepare for a long haul. It will be a while before it is ‘life as usual’.
    1
  1551. Here we go again. It is the defeat of USA not not of Biden. For the people of USA, Biden is the winner. Probably the biggest loser will be India, who I hope are proactive and will not be reactive with a “deckha jayega” attitude.
    1
  1552. Where are the liberals who ventilate on tolerance? Tailpiece: All emotions except pity, is a two way street. That includes tolerance.
    1
  1553. Voila! So Nitish in Bihar and Shinde in Mumbai are heroes, right? Both have reasons which of course is not to “retain power” but to uphold democracy and serve the people - politics is after all a public service. Right? There are better ways so that the electorate is not taken for a ride by the power hungry. In a multi split verdict, we can always devise a method whereby all parties get to be in the Government on a time sharing basis. This is what exactly happened in Mumbai and is happening in Bihar! If prearranged in this manner, the electorate will not be surprised with childish antics of political leaders mostly following agenda other than clean and efficient governance. Just saying. Tailpiece: The alternate is that once an alliance is formed, pre/post elections, it should remain so until the next elections. You can’t leave it to these guys (Honorable MLAs and MPs) to create havoc for five years between elections. Just saying
    1
  1554. Generally, Bollywood has degenerated to abysmal depths if we compare with the movies of the decades from 40s to 80s. As simple as they were then, they were more entertaining(what movies are meant to do) and left a nice taste in the mouth afterwards. “Jane Kahan Gaye woh din....” But then who will tell the Demi gods of the film world? SG, a connoisseur of movies, has attempted to do it. Is Bollywood listening?
    1
  1555. Please remember it is a PANDEMIC All day long the media is only showing--- hospitals full of patients, disadvantaged families, helpless families roaming around, suffering from hunger, dying people, burning pyres etc. This doesn't in any way conceivable help if fighting the Virus. It only creates fear among healthy and willing workers and makes them sick.. We all know that there is a PANDEMIC going on, we also know that it is enough to say that there is no control over the situation - and nobody knows what's the right decision!! NO country in the world small or big have taken correct decisions to fight the virus. The active cases in the USA today are more than in India. Not even Dr. Faucci, who I have been following since March last year (when I was in the USA) knows exactly what will happen. He has said so to the Senate panel in the USA in no unequivocal terms.
    1
  1556. Yes. A repeat….wonder how and why.
    1
  1557. China practices autocracy within and liberal democracy outside the country. It seems to be paying off. The rest of the world has to come up with a brand new ‘weapon’ (tactics, coalition, economic offensive – whatever) to tackle the rise of China. Unless…. China implodes from within. Elementary, Dr. Watson. Tailpiece: The Islamic world is, obviously, divided. It is time that right thinking Islamic countries are inducted into world alliances etc… With this formation a taboo which was removed by Trump administration by getting UAE and Israel on one stage, is totally eradicated. Good for the world.
    1
  1558. What in India does not stir politics? Politics is the eternal sauce for the media (and by extension to the people?) to be served with any piece of news. The Nation seems to slurp the offerings. Too bad for Generations to come. These days the whole garbage finally lands in the J…….. bin. Where is the laggard Nation heading?
    1
  1559. The need for leadership changes in Congress party (for God’s sake, it is our Nation which requires an erudite opposition). Just saying. Tailpiece: Is there a more obvious signal than “the writing on the wall”? After all whose Nation is it anyway
    1
  1560. A good subject to debate, amid useless political jingoing. India as a irresponsible democracy seeking outside help for internal governance will be exploited by this triad. Be warned. Let not misplaced sense of democracy only to seek power be our undoing. Tailpiece: In every battle (please check out) fought in India from the time of the Epics a side lost because someone from the inside opened the gates.
    1
  1561. Maybe a churn will bring out the cream. But these internal squabbles are not National news.
    1
  1562. Simple logic - For SS(and many other such rehonsl parties), congress is one party to ignore as long as Gandhis are at the helm.
    1
  1563. Congrats Yogi on your good study. Define common people….is common synonymous wit poor? You are the reason you were not taken seriuosly as you have a reputation of being a Modi hater. Be more equnimous
    1
  1564.  @yugantrane247  Yuhant, can you enumerate the errant policies and possible corrective actions?
    1
  1565. True. A good presentation, But I will disagree with SG - as mentioned in my tail piece. The Print is evolving as a unique source for “real” information. Not because I have been talking about economic colonization for some time now!!! But there are a number of Indians following this publication, if I may. Tail piece: That the judiciary in India needs some course correction is supported by events and past cases. In so much, there is no need to be apologistic to present this fact as an opinion.
    1
  1566. Yes, we Indians need to realize that politics is not the end...in way it is not even the means - except for some cartoonists and some media. The print is appearing to make a change. A change in the way we Indians should think; to think as individuals
    1
  1567. He had / has more to offer! Travelled with GNA in economy class some time in the late 1990s.
    1
  1568. Best use of the award....I say....!!!
    1
  1569. Indians traditionally were never at home in a swinging life style. They prefer a swigging style. But the the fact is, NZ we’re swinging it for weeks in England. Indians were not prepared, they did not have enough time to prepare. Wonder why Indians were not given a game or two before the test. They deserved that. At the end of the day, NZ played well in all departments. Jamison had all his limbs coordinating well for a tall man and bowled superb length and line. Congrats to the world champions led ably by Kane W. J&K is moving towards resolution, I suppose. Well done there too.
    1
  1570. Yes. The way the parliament has been functioning ( or not functioning) these past decades, The new generation of up to 20+ may not know the significance of a functional parliament in our democracy. I wonder whether the media or any other “pillar” of democracy are seriously attempting to help alter this state. Just reporting on the scuffles etc. is NOT enough. Disclaimer. Not judgmental, but a general observation not necessarily on any media house or organization in particular. You, the people, make your own conclusions.
    1
  1571. For data, the media is always there. Tell me honestly has e Indians, since Independence, ever believed Government data - and there are reasons. Tailpiece: The proof of the pudding is in eating. These days the people will vote out the Governemnt by feel ( living conditions, etc… in other words what they get and affects them in daily life)… so no worries there. Old wine in new bottle do not work any more. Deliver and come back to deliver more. In SGs words, walk the talk.
    1
  1572. Whither democracy. When the Nation is battling a once in a 1.5 life time Pandemic (by nature unpredictable), the constitutional institutions are busy apportioning blame. In a democracy, it is a given that the Government will be the punching bag. So be it. Governments change. But legacies left behind by constitutional institutions stay to haunt the Nation. It is damning to see that the even so called pillars of democracy are engaged in sparring, deflecting attention from the real issue of the pandemic. Tail piece: Not even once, not even a single time has the highest offices of justice admonished the public for not following COVID appropriate behaviour. Any one can become intelligent and know-all in hindsight! Even MLAS and party leaders and of course, also the media.
    1
  1573. Whatever is behind, should not the corrupt be punished? This issue should be highlighted more than I’d had udhar ki bata…. Not only here but in all cases of corruption and delinquency
    1
  1574. A nothing opinion. Who do they trust? Who should they trust? The media? The experts? Own governments? Or should they learn to trust Indians?
    1
  1575.  @abseiduk  Some pertinent points. But Abseiduk, you can’t fool all of the people all of the time and it has been more than 7 decades since Independence. We lost time till 1991 for various reasons. We must realize that no where in the world there is equality; Nowhere in the world does everyone gets what she wants. India is particularly different because of the size of population. Nothing can happen overnight. There is no place for pessimism. Tailpiece: Everything in the world including (especially) religious texts are a mix of fact and fiction. It is difficult to discern where fact begins and fiction ends and vice versa. That is how it is. Fact is not an absolute. For immediate facts wherever you are Smell the coffee and get the picture. We are moving. Enjoy. Forward Ho!
    1
  1576.  @chinmayshetye3  rest of the world. Been following for seventy years. I am not talking in absolute terms. Only rate of growth. To catch up with China or the West it will take a few decades more. Enjoy.
    1
  1577.  @kumar.193  Surely it should have been then too. I am not aware of such a case. Can you out me wise? AK is constitutional functionary , remember. Two wrongs do not make a right, anyway
    1
  1578. It is a technology event. The real problem lies elsewhere. Here is an African Proverb very apt for India. “ when there is no enemy within, the enemies outside cannot hurt you”. No, it is not about democracy and free speech…Events in the Indian history is replete with incidents where the losing side was always sold out by somebody from within….Take any battle starting from mythological times, Gupta, inter kingdom rivalries from 3 rd century BC to the 1800s, periods under British, Europeans, Mughals etc… Check it out.
    1
  1579.  @bangguyraj  Thanks. I love Bangladesh. I love the way they play their cricket. Was there a political angle in my comment? I wonder!
    1
  1580. All statistics during pandemic times will not follow the traditional paths. In any case the matter of measuring GDP - and handling statistics - et al is under review the world over. Probably we will have to lace logic with statistics. Data analytics has overtaken plain statistics. Be that it may... This whole revelation, makes me wonder, why then is there illegal immigration from BD into India? Just asking.
    1
  1581. Thanks SG. This is something I have been saying for long (in my comments too). That the LOC actions by China is just a facade. Tail piece: What this has revealed is what we see is not really what it is. Applicable to most of what we see and hear in public.
    1
  1582. Yes, training when setting out probably shapes a career....The Print seems to be doing it right...watching!
    1
  1583. In late 19th century, Sir John Dalberg-Acton, 8th Baronet. said, "Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Great men are almost always bad men...", Do you think we can, today modify it to also say “Pen tends to corrupt, powerful pen corrupts absolutely. Great Pens mostly tend to influence…..”
    1
  1584. @ahs pm a convoluted logic!!!! Regards
    1
  1585. @ahs pmAre you saying by highlighting the macabre things will become better?
    1
  1586. Can we have a cut the the clutter on media’s insensitive handling of the COVID disaster especially the deaths? You can also cut the clutter as to why a section of the Indian media is playing up to the Western media to paint the dark picture of our country?
    1
  1587. I wonder if "Modi" is looked upon as someone with all the answers, making the man (any (wo)man for that matter) bigger than a human. Some of the headings in the media seem to suggest this. Expecting all ills of the past to be erased, just by saying "abracadabra". We have to get real. This disengagement is but a short term goal, yet welcome. In its wake India has to persist to achieve the long-term objective to make the Chinese agree to delineation of the LAC on the maps; unless that is, these kind of intrusions and small actions that take place on the LAC will recur. It is obvious that “issues” along the LAC is not a thing of a few recent years; it has existed since our Independence and successive Governments have failed to resolve the matter of the undefined LAC with neighboring China. It is natural that intrusions and small actions will take place along this nebulous and undefined border in inhospitable terrain. It is infructuous to discuss these actions in detail in public because of the very nature that it happens along “claimed” and not defined lines. Tail piece: What the successive governments since decades have failed to do is take the Nation into confidence about the larger National Security issues like security policies, strategies and approach being taken to comprehensively resolve the matters of LAC with China and LOC with Pakistan. Hopefully actions by the Government now is a likely beginning of an end.
    1
  1588. Yes, Ila you are right; if we all recognise our responsibilities India is in a slightly better position to recover faster. It is very wrong to say that the econoimic situatuon caused by the “lockdown” world over is manmade. The “lockdown” may not have been necessary if there was no COVID-19 going around!!! Let the semantics be right. With COVID-19 a Nation has to fight a war on two fronts. Health and economy. Without a lockdown, the health may have been so badly affected that the fear factor would have kept the population away….even if the “workers” were ready to work for fear of hunger I am not sure there would have been work with dead bodies strewen on the streets. This is not in my imagination, I have seen it here in NY personally, first hand, where the lockdown came in late. A NY coped with it is and is slowly but unsurely trying to limp back. A NY like situation in Mumbai would have been disastrous for India. We have to take it from there. All stakeholders are equally responsible to get the economy back on track. We can’t Expect any Government to serve breakfast in bed. It can best help us to help the chicken lay eggs.
    1
  1589. Kudos to The print for such programmes. My take. For any big economy to sustain over long periods a robust indigenous Defence industry is essential. Simply put, the money (dollars?) does not go out, better management of balance of trade, money goes into local econmy creating jobs and increasing GDP and above all self reliance….. Tailpiece: Having a robust Defence manufacturing sector is like eating the cake and having too.
    1
  1590. And that, My dear Indians is National News!
    1
  1591. Do I see a bias in The Prints coverage of “important” news?
    1
  1592. Greta typo see you DK after a while….may be because I was away! Politics the cauldron of artificial uncertainty. In India, DK, emotions and symbolism is the resort of the politicians. Unfortunate. If you can do a program of the artificial and “natural” emotive issues of all those 365 days preceding all those general elections eclipsing the reasons why an electorate to chose for progress and development. Tailpiece: Let us, in this year preceding the general elections, expose the machinations of all political parties.
    1
  1593. SG, your forte may be politics. But be aware, you are doing well in real topics too. Maybe even a shade better!!!
    1
  1594.  @nrusimha11  Always thought print was neutral... Unfortunate For the print and Shekhar... This video
    1
  1595.  @nrusimha11  yes.unfortunate. all those who hold the megaphone are always advising the Governments what to do etc.. Is the freedom of press (((pun untended) Just asking
    1
  1596.  @PriyanshuChauhan  I'm entitled to my opinion or I have a right to my opinion is an informal fallacy in which a person discredits any opposition by claiming that they are entitled to their opinion. The statement exemplifies a red herring or thought terminating cliché’. Whether one has a particular entitlement or right is irrelevant to whether one's assertion is true or false. Therein lies the futility of opinions on matters of which one really knows very little. Public opinion does matter....on subjects close to them Priyanshu C, I support your right to have an opinion. No two views there. So, enjoy. Stay safe.
    1
  1597.  Kabir  if you say so,p. Fine. Respect your view. Great
    1
  1598. A good interpretation. India ignores anything coming out out of Pakistan.? May not be true. A saying in Hindi comes to mind. “Hathi ke do Danth hote hain; ek khane keliye aur ek dikane ke liye” translated…. An elephant has two sets of teeth - one for show and the other for chewing. Take it either which way. Tailpiece: What we see is not what it is. Either which way.
    1
  1599. Indian politics has never ever risen above ground level , including of the INC in its various avatars. Have been watching it for more than five decades. We request you not to fool around as usual. When the overall standard of politics of all parties is abysmal can any one party rise above ground level…haha.. Tailpiece: Tell us something new.
    1
  1600. More intriguing than the worst mishandles Bollywood suspense thriller, SG. A follow up:- This in quotes is a direct a pick out from the internet. “Despite their gung-ho style of robbing sea travelers, pirates needed safe ports to hide away and refuel for their next voyages. Some of the most famous pirate safe havens of the Golden Age of Piracy were found in the Caribbean, the Gulf of Mexico and the coasts of Africa. Pirates usually found refuge in concealed caves or make-do island hideaway as they waited for a chance at another loot. Over time, pirates slowly penetrated small cities and ports to create safe havens where they were free to enjoy the spoils of their battles.” Disclaimer: If there is a similarity of the then Caribbean to certain states up North (sea) now it is a mere coincidence
    1
  1601. Being a cricket fan SG should know that a Captain is as good as his team; especially when a key member of the team is media. Of course we understand the limitations of a career political journalist. Expert epidemiologists could have pin pointed the real reasons for the unprecedented spread of the virus. Putting things in perceptive even if the impact factor of Lancet Journal is 59.103. COVID pandemic is unprecedented . Factors affecting the spread are complex. India is a Nation with a population of 13664 lakhs; USA 3282 lakhs (all 2019 figures given here only for comparison). Per capita GDP (IMF data), USA $68319; India $2191. Total Covid Cases USA: 33,452,985:: India: 22,295,911: Total deaths: USA 595,587 India: 242,398 New cases yesterday: USA 35289: India 409 300. (COVID info from worldometer.info) I am not even talking percentages. I also wonder whether there is a lancet study on handling COVID in the USA, Europe, UK etc... It is a pandemic, not an epidemic or common flu. Things that will move the needle the most—are things that past events give us little to no guide about, especially a viral pandemic mutating fast and tomorrow it may mutate faster than the speed of light (figuratively) and be able to travel in the air. Hopefully it will not come to that and humanity will survive this pandemic. There will be unprecedented events. Their unprecedented nature means we won’t be prepared for them, which is part of what makes them so impactful. Tailpiece: Before I get the bricks, I often wonder who is a bakht and who is a Kambhakt?
    1
  1602. No proof enough to take a stand. Correct stand. But action against offending VIPs can’t be taken in anonymity with a “free media” around. You did not touch on this very very important point SG. Unless we assume that there are no VIP offenders. In a democratic-bureaucratic bureaucracy, such out of the box characters are a must for efficiency and exposing the VIP and money culture to escape the law. Sometimes the media exposure of such cases are used to claim “victimization” etc. by the corrupt and offenders. Tailpiece: Smoke without fire? Yet the Indian bureaucracy requires a major overhaul….so does the judiciary. Least of all for corruption but more for better efficiency and lesser red tapes.
    1
  1603. The statistics are at best indicative. The only statistics that matter is deaths. For instance If tests are done with proper tracing, the ratio of positives v tests will be high - e.g. good tracing and planned tests in Kerala .... Yes SG, this whole matter of “corona” requires detailed studies to be done by professionals as the spread characteristics has many variables. The analysis will have to be done using methods of regression. E.g. population of NZ is .25 of Delhi, density is also low, gdp high etc.. etc... Until then Ramu’s study is as good as Balu’s. This is a typical case where one size will not fit more than one size!
    1
  1604. We gotta get out of stereo thinking. Is cricket still an elitist sport? I wonder. . Even in golf, there are more ex caddies, their children and groundmen's children playing the circuits.
    1
  1605. Nice analysis. How hockey is a right example of inclusivity for India. I my school days, the position of players on the hockey field was set as – forwards- right out, right in, centre forward, left in, left out; and then threw er halfs, backs and goal keeper. The tactics largely depended on individual abilities to dribble past the defence. The game has changed – now nobody is left out right out of the game -It is (loosely) attack, support and defence with everybody generally capable of playing any role. And then, women are also included…. Total inclusivity? Tail piece: Inclusivity is Not a one way lane. Traffic has to move in both directions.
    1
  1606.  @abhimanyujha5550  uhmmm....
    1
  1607. The only permanence is change. Should religions also look to change? Touchy subject. No. It is up to us to change.
    1
  1608.  @reddragon100  you got it wrong. Totally wrong. That is the problem. I mean the concept of jihad, to perpetuate religion.
    1
  1609. If you know the card game Bridge - Is Trump Biden a scam or is the US Biden no Trump?
    1
  1610. DK, hook? Been fishing, it seems….in troubled waters? DK. Hat off to your analysis. Tailpiece: Alas! As elections get nearer, the waters will turn muddy. But the Q is will be “hook,line and sinker” agin? Interest g as you say,
    1
  1611. The need for leadership changes in Congress party (for God’s sake, it is our Nation which requires an erudite opposition). Just saying. Tailpiece: Is there a more obvious signal than “the writing on the wall”? After all whose Nation is it anyway
    1
  1612. Sorry SG. The heading is totally misleading... In gist the policy... The good At school level the major shift from present input driven assessment ( “do it the way I have taught you & don’t use your brains”) to learning outcome driven assessment is the proverbial paradigm shift that was much needed. This will make children understand concepts, question theories, hypothesis, postulates & brainmap what they have assimilated to be subsequently applied to finding a solution to the problems faced. No scope for rote learning here.  This is our chance to grab this NEP & make it our own. There will be far too much of opposition & every hurdle will be placed in its implementation. It will do us well to keep bureaucrats out of it, bring in genuine educationists to make it happen & steamroll every opposition & hurdle coming in its way. The bad Ruling dispensations in States hostile to the Centre May not like NCERT & HECI subsuming state Edn boards & Universities. Even the change in role of state govt Edn depts from lording over all Edn institutions in the state to being mere enablers of Edn entrusted with the responsibility of ensuring quality Edn in govt schools will not be taken lightly by power hungry & corrupt bureaucrats.  Politicians particularly the corrupt ones won’t like the general population to be well educated for they will be asked questions by their voters.  The ugly Left liberals given their substantially high level of intelligence will fight this policy tooth & nail for their mass base of uneducated / unemployed will further erode.
    1
  1613. Dictatorships? Well, it is the way how we look at matters. We have a WhatsApp group of batch mates, about 30 of us, going since years. We have never been able to reach a consensus on a date to get together physically ever or on Zoom these days. So the coordinator just announces a time, date and place to meet. Initially the attendance was thin. But now almost all have fallen in line and we get near 100% attendance on the “dictated” schedule. India is a large country and a very big Nation.
    1
  1614. A very good analysis of PSBs. No doubt in a capitalist economy privatization is the way to go. We all know that what is done is done and we are where we are. In principle - “privatize banks”. No arguments. Can it be done overnight with a press of a button? No. Can some “ expert” recommend a practical road map, considering ALL implications as on today, for its execution. Will be grateful.
    1
  1615. planet EARTH Because he is an expert on Indian economy
    1
  1616. Another peaceful protest..a constitutional right. Right?
    1
  1617.  @durranishaheer1538  enjoy. Stay safe
    1
  1618. Uhmmm… Indians getting back at West… so….. a counterattack by US, tilting at windmills a la Don Quixote . Tailpiece: I wonder why RSS statement of Not digging up mosques for idols” is not give the t action it deserves in the media. Build on it for harmony…I mean on the statement and on on the mosque!!!!!:)
    1
  1619. The whole discussion, even in the piece written by Shekar on ThePrints web site, the whole premise seems to be the the BJP is out to get AAP and AAP (including AK) have not committed any crime at all. Various (no one) court proceedings and documents suggest otherwise. But the media fails to highlight this aspect. Tailpiece: Liberalism I suppose
    1
  1620. also about cricket and Afghanistan… at that
    1
  1621. I suppose the world has to learn to play Chinese checkers and Mahjong. The advantage in the Chinese “democracy” is that the Government can do whatever it wants whenever it wants. This is a decide advantage when dealing with international affairs including economy. Be warned. China is prepared for the long battle. Tail piece: Ah! Perry Mason! And Della Street. Nostalgic.
    1
  1622. An apt assessment. History is not only about the past. It is about the present and the future. Historical events do not change. But the narrative changes with time as new knowledge and information evolve.
    1
  1623. I am at loss about what to make of this spectacle. It is obvious that the speaker knows very little of real India. invite of the walk. I am NOT making a political statement but a remark by a disappointed citizen of India. Tailpiece: Indian history is replete with instances where insiders have shaped (or attempted to) the downfall of a kingdom…. Just saying.
    1
  1624. Well. In late 60s, I joined a well reputed and then arguably the No 1 training establishment in India (and probably in the top 10 in the World then), Those days among those in the establishment, to those from North of Vindhyas all those from the South of Vindhyas were Thambis and K****s. Tail piece: It is the PRIME duty of the media to ensure authentic information about the Nation is disseminated to all. Have they been doing that well? A self examination by the media in this regard may be in order.
    1
  1625.  @kishoreroy6480  Thanks. Will do. Regards
    1
  1626. Strict lockdowns will affect livelihoods. That effect will last longer...more deaths because of hunger . A tough choice lives or livelihoods...you sure don’t want to be the one making the decision.
    1
  1627.  @Thecaptainblackadder  Getting philosophical….nobody is indispensable, world will go on….but living when there is life is important. Stay happy. Enjoy. Stay safe. Nice to get your views.
    1
  1628.  @Thecaptainblackadder  Abhi, I am concerned for India and all of us Indians, so I put out my views for whatever it is worth, where I have a reach. But I am definitely not worried. All is not doomsday. I have seen and felt Indian Governments for seven decades. And good people like you respond. Thanks. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    1
  1629.  @Thecaptainblackadder  I am not worried at all, Abhimanyu.Neither should you be. We have chosen democracy and political machinations are part of democracy. They always have been. China is a successful economy and an alternate midel, if you may. There never was, is or will be an utopia. At best we can perpetually work towards one. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    1
  1630.  @Thecaptainblackadder  Sure Abhimanyu, all “experts” and novices like me can also have “solutions”. But they should not be touted as THE solution. All of us may not have all the inputs of the dynamics of National compulsions and politics that go into decision making. Governments are also advised by experts, who have inputs from various departments and function collectively. Tailpiece: The tone of the “experts” should not be that the Governments of countries are wrong. The views should be put forth as a possible alternate course. What one says is less important than how you say it.
    1
  1631. Very progressive idea…for votes but not for safety, …three helmeted heads…the physics of the two wheeler also does not allow it. Pathetic promises
    1
  1632. I wonder whether the economy is suffering because of lockdown or as a result of an unprecedented pandemic about Which even today, the whole world has precious little idea to counter it. Is the use of the word lockdown to describe this force majure by design or by default?
    1
  1633. SG has rightly said at the beginning of his piece that a spoken word, like all else, is a matter of interpretation and perception. A balanced analysis. But is there something more to democracy than perception? For instance, constitutional rights will have a different appeal for me, a professional soldier, from SG, a professional political journalist. Also, language, even one’s own mother tongue, is a fascinating medium of communication for anybody. The same expression will convey differently at different times depending on, among many factors, the context, intention and tone. In these times, I see that most people listen only to what one wants to hear. When even in our hallowed Parliament it has been eons since we have had a meaningful democratic discussion on matters of National importance. In the media we can discern line of arguments just by knowing the author or commentator. Too much democracy or too little? Here are two examples. 1. In the USA schools do no mandate uniform unlike some school in India and the UK. 2. Unlike in the USA Indian parliament does not allow for conscience vote (they wield the Whip), so an elected member’s “freedom” ends there. It is for each one of us to discern where we should draw the line, to decide how much of democracy is not too much. There is a view that India is not progressing as it is a laggard democracy. May be democracy also does not mean that a Nation can never speak in one voice. In the circumstance to earn and spend as one entity is a far cry, though not impossible. Tail piece: Are hartals and protests which violate the freedom of millions of citizens by disrupting / destroying public conveniences, par for the course in a democracy? There has to be a limit to everything. There is an old saying in Malayalam – translated, “Too much of Amrit is poison”.
    1
  1634. There is little difference between a 5th class pass and a 10th pass or a 12th pass. In a sense, both become literate of varying degree, but remain uneducated (unskilled). The difference is only if one wants to pursue college education where 12th pass is mandatory. Higher education, like in the world over is not easily affordable. Hopefully the new proposed Education system will help remedy this and give a skill set to the student at the end of each important phase. In a Democratic “Socialist” Republic (Even after decades of education and work, I still wonder what this really means in a Capitalist economy) freebie(s) can’t be rolled back overnight, as AP points out. Direct money transfer after withdrawing relevant subsidies may be the way to go. Above all what we need are Governments and political parties who bat for the Nation rather than play a one-up-man-ship game. Regional parties have prioritized holding their local forts over National issues and National parties of standing are now trying to find their feet – ironic.
    1
  1635. Dear Mr. S. Tharoor, You talk about the recent misbehavior with a female colleague by the AAP in the office premises of the CM as a distraction. I fully agree with you though theoretically misogyny is a moral and criminal crime. If the AAP and its friends admit to that it will not be a distraction. So are the congress’s personal rant on PM Modi, Caste census, Muslim appeasement, lies about LAC positions hiding three decades of Indo-China history to spread canards etc. When the BJP started the campaign with matters of development and economy, the INC and your “coalition” invented the above distractions. I would like the opposition to debate reforms in agriculture, economy, ease of doing business, judiciary, police, direct taxes, bureaucracy etc. Can you initiate national debates on such policy issues, Mr. S Tharoor? Will this Mr. ST? I wonder. A common man - mango man - cattle class
    1
  1636.  john smith  i suppose chaff is part of all grains
    1
  1637.  john smith  user end computing has grown in geometric proportions in India in the past four decades. Also, shal I dare say that most SW developers around the world too are Indians.
    1
  1638.  john smith  All true John. My initial comment was related to Pitchai saying he had no access to computers in his school/college days in India.
    1
  1639. How I wish we had a proactive and constructive opposition rather than reactive and blinkered political parties without any vision! Looking for and finding faults (often with help from media) is not the way to go. The fledgling AAP is doing immensely good job. It will take at least a decade for it to make its presence felt Pan India. All other parties are either caste based and " local Nationalists" (regional bias). The LEFT is no more a presence in India or else where in the world. I do not see visionaries either in the political firmament, among intellectuals and high profile media personalities. Even if the ruling dispensation falls, be warned there is no safety net for India.
    1
  1640. Is it that we only want bring down Governments? We always want a fight, that is all; right? We do not want progress. Should not the media be giving ( not only now but since decades) more space what bills are not passed, what should be done for development and progress..and more importantly what has been done. The media, is playing the role of cheerleaders in the game ( non issues largely like suit boot, pappu etc..) between opposition and government. So much so the younger generation feels that this is democracy. Mudthha chahiye, sahi Ho ya nahin. We want a fight right or wrong. The real issue is that “failures” is a subjective matter in a democracy and has to seen in a context, as we have been doing for more than seven decades. Second, if the aim of small and regional parties is only to fell the BJP government, it is not something We the people should encourage or be proud of. Tail piece: Indian politics, is that people do not go out and vote but cast(e) their votes. We need to tell people to go out and vote (not caste) for work than for a living. If we encourage regional (read parochial) parties or caste based parties as cheer leaders, we will soon be a fragmented democracy rather than a federal democracy.
    1
  1641.  @Suresh_Kamath  Beware! A fool even after changing his mind may remain a fool. Bakht can also remain a bakht with a changed deity!!!!
    1
  1642. Baljeet Singh Rana Beware, sometimes fools remain fools even after change of mind!
    1
  1643. Input from one of the Sam uncles?
    1
  1644. Two points Shekhar. 1. Can in a democracy, one man dictate terms? Especially one man who does not seem to have enough legislators with him… you have not explained. 2. You skipped the to overseeing of etrrorist activities and killings perpetuated by Ismail H. Deliberate? Liberalism? Just asking
    1
  1645. Yes. A great series by Sandhya R and The Print. Any programme without “politics” and opinions is great for educating the society at large. Way to go. I wonder why politics is discussed instead of just letting it happen. Tail piece: By all means discuss Governance without political comments.
    1
  1646. Of course it is a matter of perception. Has Taliban being pushed back anything to do with Indian mission pulling out of Mazar… or vice versa. The heading suggests that. Or is it intended to convey that Indian there pulled out to safety in time? I think I need to take fresh lessons in English.
    1
  1647. Et tu SG.? “Always looking for a headline”. This is exactly why the media is not trusted, SG.
    1
  1648. DK, for once you are mostly off track… the aim is governance at the centre and assembly elections now… also MOS are posts, yes, just posts
    1
  1649. What we see is not always what it really is. Those familiar with the stock markets may remember How in Oct 1977 Mr. Dhirubhai Ambani (of Reliance, for the uninitiated) turned the tables on short sellers in a situation somewhat similar to where Mr G Adani finds himself today. Is the game yet to be played? Tailpiece: By ‘game’ I do not mean the political game which will continue to be played at least till the next general elections… I mean the ‘game’ in the markets and the economy…. Have to wait some more to find out who gets hurts…. Adani, Investors across the world, Hindenburg, Indian Public….. ah or the BJP (as some see it). Khel abhi baaki hain.
    1
  1650. Ni e take. Unity is diverse diversity. Opposition “unity as it could happen today will set the Nation back by a few decades in every field of activity. All of us Indians know it and the World know it. While Indians suffer the World will love it. We got to get real. Without crying wolf about democracy, in the short and long term, what is good for the Nation is a very strong centre and half the states being ruled by different political parties, probably as it is now in then South. Tailpiece: Let us and the media for once (and for all) not propagate election strategies and instead just concentrate on development and policies. Sorry SG, politics may be in everything but it is NOT the end all.
    1
  1651. Finally….
    1
  1652. Thanks, SG
    1
  1653. Change is inevitable is a universal dictum. The moot point is will these churning in the INC give India a focused and efficient opposition (as of now) with stated policies for development and progress except to repeatedly only say that its aim is to defeat BJP. It, of course, can be an aim. What are its plans for India? Tailpiece: INC can still get its act together if it is led by somebody other than a Nehru, Gandhi or wadra. Just saying.
    1
  1654. A bit faaaar fetched. It is preposterous to say that India tacitly recognised Portugal declaring its colony in India (Goa) as its own territory (by Salazar). Wither the Indian Independence movement, then? Portuguese should have been thrown out of Goa before Jan 26, 1950. Tailpiece: a wrong is a wrong. You can’t call a wrong as right for now calling a right as wrong. Just saying.
    1
  1655. Is that not natural to defend oneself against attacks - unless you are a Gandhi ( The Mahatma) ? It is not what you do ( criticism) that matters, it is how and why you do it that is critical - Constructive or destructive. We should all get real if we do not want to remain a laggard democracy. Tailpiece: Does democracy mean that we elect a Government (any Government) and then continually criticize it in the name of democracy and free speech? Get real again. India deserves better.
    1
  1656. The WORLD (NYT, Economist etc..) is aghast at India and is wondering how India can be pluralistic and Nationalistic at the same time. In a pluralistic (BJP has only 1,385 out of the 4,120 MLAs) democracy like India, it will be a surprise only if political parties do not leverage this sentiment one way or the other….by attending or not attending. The important point is the change in the “Establishment” and subsequent politics…. Tailpiece: All said and done, the “Ram Mandir” in Ayodhya will be a boost to the hospitality, travel and tourism industries while boosting the State and local economy. A Question. So, is the 10 years of BJP rule also included in the 1000 years
    1
  1657. @Shuaib Hussain oh! Hi Shuaib. When did India sign a defence pact with the US? Pak gifting away part of occupied Kashmir to China, exchange of stolen nuclear materials, Chinese loans, China defending Pak terrorists in the UN and many such bilateral activities between these two countries all took place recently, right?
    1
  1658. I agree. unfortunately, SG missed a major point. In all these past decades until US leaving Afghanistan, Pakistan had been an ally of the US in a contrived fight against “terror”. That prevented Pak sharing the same bed with China although they slept in the same room. The equation is a bit different now. Also refer to the recent Bonhomie between Russia and China; is there more danger there? The whole issue is much beyond India cozying up to Pakistan, which was SG's "final" analysis.
    1
  1659. Is signing MOUs with CCP by all major political parties in India, like it was done by a major political party in the past, an answer? Just asking. A poor and incomplete analysis. Tailpiece: unfortunately, SG, you missed a major point. In all these past decades until US leaving Afghanistan, Pakistan had been an ally of the US in a contrived fight against “terror”. That prevented Pak sharing the same bed with China although they slept in the same room. The equation is a bit different now. Also refer to the recent Bonhomie between Russia and China; is there more danger there? The whole issue is much beyond India (not) cozying up to Pakistan, which was your "final" analysis. Disclaimer: The positive is there is a “debate” on the issue in the Parliament. Way to go.
    1
  1660. Divisiveness in politics runs on a road that takes two way traffic, which is a function of time. In the mornings the the flow is towards downtown(business districts) and in the evenings the rush is towards uptown (residential areas). So the logic is if there has been traffic towards one direction it is bound to move back in the opposite direction. Tailpiece: The logic is not intended as a political statement but an impartial comment.
    1
  1661. I suppose we must first have appropriate vaccines before we start vaccinating children. Just saying.
    1
  1662. In the cCTC, I think, AP also highlighted some positives happening in the country!
    1
  1663. US position as a leader in any sphere is in the retreat not because of this one incidence of an "attack" on the Capitol. In widely diverse Nations such as India and the USA, such mob actions should be expected. I am not saying they should happen. But rest assured they will happen. The important point is to move on and not dwell on such incidents too much. Easier said than done, when the media too is diverse, what with expert opinions and views of “formers” etc. All Americans are not like those in the MOB that attacked the Capitol. Even some in that mob are not invaders – it was planned by a few and rest was mob frenzy. Here is something more dangerous that happens in the wake of such incidents. It is all too evident in India too. For instance, take this headline in an article in The Print. “Before desi cow exam, Indians should study how to not kill dolphins and elephants for fun”. This precludes that I and probably 135.16 crore Nationals like me are NOT Indians. We know where such devious thoughts are coming from. I fervently hope that “experts” and activists do not speak for me – I am also an Indian. Likewise, desist from painting all Americans with the same brush as those” rioters”.
    1
  1664. A very good analysis, DK. DK, could this be a ruse by BJP to perpetuate the perception of democracy, where a strong narrative was being formed internally and externally that democracy in India was at risk where governments ran the administration for a decade… unprecedented and false narratives were build around a failing democracy in India, just because a party with a strong leader was in charge in the electoral democracy. I do not see much discussions in the media on these false narratives (like EVMs and ECI etc.) which are more important for the Nation rather than any a party lost or won. Let us change that narrative fro only pure politics to Nation building in the real sense
    1
  1665. So is the action politically correct or incorrect? Just asking
    1
  1666.  @DhavalJangla  whichever be the Government…. The August house is made into a sham. It belongs to us, the people, being misused by all political parties (especially the opposition, whoever they may be) for party gains. A large section of the media is the cheerleader in this fixed match.
    1
  1667.  @amitrana-seeker  true Amit. I can speak only for myself and I know that it is not always I am right. But, it is important we (and the media and the politicians and the "experts" and ..... ) remove "you", "I" and "me" from debates. It is about the topic and not about individuals. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    1
  1668. Let us not assume that somethings are more right than the other. Everything is not always reflected in data in India, though data analytics is the go to mantra. It is OK if the data is OK. Consider this. As an example, let us take one aspect of women’s employment and look at some situations in India. One fact that is very important to note is that every citizen in the “developed world” has a unique identity and every employment even as a housemaid is reported through this unique identity such as a social security number, in the USA. The data is near dead accurate. The USA reports unemployment rates weekly to monitor its economy which is not done through measuring inflation as in India. In India, many employments, mostly of women, are not recorded. For instance, more than 80% of the house holds in Bangalore, my city, employ maids. Have you ever seen a database for such employment? About 30% of road side vegetable and fruit vendors in my locality are women. There is also an iron lady (a lady who irons clothes) in my colony. I play golf (which is an economy that affords employment to a considerable number of men and women) considered a sin by many and resented as a snobbish sport. There are many caddies (employed in golf courses) in Bangalore who hail from UP, Bihar, WB and Assam. Most of them live single with their wives tending the small plots of land back home, cultivating seasonal crops, some vegetables and rearing a cow (buffalo) or two. I wonder if these employments are accounted for. Nobody here reports these expenditures / incomes. Tailpiece: India is still unique. It requires Genius of a different kind to take it forward.
    1
  1669. I wonder why a section of media is sayingIndian media is gagged,there is no freedom of speech democracy is attacked etc. etc. just asking
    1
  1670. I wonder! An attack in Europe and many attacks here in India. At least now I hope the media realizes what an attack is.
    1
  1671. t is time ALL politicians realize that today’s Indian does not learn about their political and other leaders from what politicians talk about them. Original materials and contact information, as the case maybe depending on antiquity of leaders, is authentically gathered from various other reliable sources. It is also time that our politicians stop talking about themselves and discuss, development, progress, education, skill,development, employment, amenities, economy, security and such matters that matter to us. We want an erudite opposition. Tailpiece: Politicians will come and go, the Nation and its people,are forever. Don’t waste time and energy discussing inconsequential matters.
    1
  1672. As usual a different presentation from the drudgery of most main stream media. Refreshing. Disclaimer: My comments are to kindle a thought process and not a critical statement. No offence all around. Thomas A Edison. Einstein A., Curie M., Gates B., Jobs S. and the likes of them who have contributed quantifiably to progress of humanity were / are intelligent and not intellectuals. I wonder whether we can institute a system to measure the contribution of "intellectuals" to humanity. Tailpiece: For instance, do we need “intellectuals” to tell us China’s intentions?
    1
  1673. Nobody to beat SG in quality political commentaries. Just one point…though. It was nonchalantly mentioned that Owaisi’s Muslim party won some seats from the “Muslim dominated areas” of North Bihar - gave an impression that was a natural process and par for the course, giving an impression that some religion based parties are OK while others are not. So much for “secularism”. Tailpiece: My take is that Hindutva, secularism and majoritarianism are no longer issues in Indian politics. The opposition will do well to concentrate on development (economy, education, healthcare, infrastructure etc… etc… ) and progress (sans freebies). THAT will do our Nation more good than all else.
    1
  1674. Abysmal and pathetic. It is not RG’s fault. It is the assumption by many politicians in general, those well informed as well as I’ll,informed, that attacking the Government on anything and everything sans logic is very appealing and vote getting tactics…..not now but over all these decades since Independence by all opposition parties and leaders (refer the comments of “erudite”:Tharoor S, on the budget - no substance but just “attack”). This is precisely why India has not made progress as it could have and China has raced ahead. Tailpiece: If the politicians do not take note of this now, it will be a desolate and poor India for future generations. Elections do not make Nations. MEDIA too take note.
    1
  1675. Yes. That is the need today. But we are able to talk like this because of such actions. I am seeing it first hand in New York, where the lockdown was affected late. The economy here in USA is bad here too; in someways worse. To say what was done in India so far is not good is NOT correct.
    1
  1676. Also Shekar, what you say is what is being done now. So what is new?
    1
  1677. The media is strange. When the leadership is weak it is criticized. When the leadership is strong it is criticized. How is optimum leadership measured?
    1
  1678. It was once ‘Modi’s arrogance’ from media. Now you say Akhikesh’s arrogance’ . Make up your mind.
    1
  1679. Interesting aspects of Indian politics. Required discussion. There was never an utopia (Ramrajya or a rule by Mahabali in Kerala in the literal sense) nor is and never will be especially in a large democracy. So, why bring in morality in politics - an oxymoron. Tailpiece: A supporter will always back his party to be morally right.
    1
  1680. Good take on politics. Tailpiece: what I find in the mainstream media is that Political parties are criticized for not using a political moment and equally criticized for using a political moment….Is that free press and democracy? Just asking.
    1
  1681. Why the picture of the CDS? Will Snehesh or the Print answer. Not a straight bat….
    1
  1682. DK, is it not damning for the Nation that there are no young leaders, in any party, in the States
    1
  1683. The Print is doing fine. But glad to note there are alternatives available in fiction and on screen, just in case!!!
    1
  1684. If we are to read The Print, you have to read.
    1
  1685. DK. Do you invest in stocks? Just asking.
    1
  1686. Only that which evolves naturally endures. Anything that is propped up artificially will be short lived. Briefly, if women have to play a major role in Nation building, we have to change the way the society thinks. I believe the transformation is happening in India. By the way Indian women as a percentage of population are doing as well if not better than in many advanced countries. Tailpiece: But…. Do we, here, have a decent representation to showcase “democracy”? Just asking.
    1
  1687. Great approach to information. We can presume that our establishment already studies these and such information from the world over. If SG can do it India is already doing it. We have enough personnel trained in the Chinese and other foreign languages. Just to clarify...to create a symphony the orchestra has to perform in unison!
    1
  1688. In the subcontinent over centuries kings lost battles because someone from within opened the gates. When Soros tries to buy people to destabilize India from within by paying off gullible Indians (hungry for power), India has to be vary… not AFRAID….. Let us get the equation right. Stay well
    1
  1689. I wonder! An attack in Europe and many attacks here in India. At least now I hope the media realizes what an attack is.
    1
  1690. What are those green gadgets on your right, Swamy? Also are supporting illegal imitation to USA from Gujarat and Punjab? Also are you okay with illegal immigration into India. Please clarify
    1
  1691. In India, are there farmers only in the Punjab? No offense. just asking. Somebody rightly said that the bane of India is that it is a laggard democracy because the opposition (over decades) does not allow reforms and progress. The parliament does not function. The media, and the “experts”, are also for most part partisan. The honorable courts , already over burdened , have to adjudicate on anything and everything. It is time “We the people” of India get away from these political dramas and get down to business,. It is already late. Our neighbors in Asia are racing ahead. It is time we did something different than play only political games.
    1
  1692. As they say in the courts a leading question. Unnecessary, Shekhar
    1
  1693. True. Some points. 1. Reforms in the military are necessary with the tech advancements and changing warfare methods. 2. India can’t go thin overnight with two nuclear armed and belligerent adversaries on our 4000 Kms long land borders. Boots on ground is a must on these borders, at least in the short to medium terms. 3. Quality of intake and basic training methods have to change. 4. Tour of duty does not aim to reduce the strength of the Armed Forces. 5. The stated intention of reduction of pension bills should not be the primary reason for changes. Also have to look at organization and pension bills of Defence civilians employed, most of whom are redundant with use of technology for administration. 6. Change is the only permanence. Even “good old days” have a shelf life. Tailpiece: Fervently hope that the Indian opposition parties (now and forever) respond rather than react.
    1
  1694. “Spends” maybe more appropriate than “celebrates”. Just saying.
    1
  1695. True Shekar. In a democracy like India (and the USA where I am stuck now) the media resides on Fault lines. This has pluses and minuses. The greatest plus is that in such a scenario the Government has no where to hide for very long.
    1
  1696. Absolutely right, SG. Xi and CCP are most scared of the Chinese people more than USA or any other outside force. Taiwan is most important in the circumstance now that Hong Kong is out of the way. Taiwan inadvertently may be showing the way to mainland CHINESE for another Tianaman Square. China can’t afford that. As I had written earlier LAC , South China Sea etc… are just distractions. A show for internal consumption. Yes, we need not be impressed. Tailpiece: The most potent weapon to reign in China is democracy. Taiwan holds the arsenal. Chinese are desperate….but will it lead to war? Uhmmm..Ashvamedha Yajna..haha! Nailed it.
    1
  1697. Yes SG…our time music is sublime….BTW…Tamil film songs were also very melodious and meaningful and complimented Hindi songs… Tailpiece: Hopefully the synergies between SI music and Bollywood will sustain… ah! NPAs….Yehhhh Kya hula, kab hua , kyun hua was required; and what a better place than the LS to lay the cards on the table…..democracy lives on…., I suppose
    1
  1698. Great perspective. The hidden battle fields and the real war zones - the silent killers of economy. Tail piece: The clutter in these environs is such that it will take more than a handful of episodes to cut them…All the best
    1
  1699. What generation of warfare was the tape recorder at Kabbadi in 1990?
    1
  1700. Be aware that this is purely an American story, nothing Indian about it. Just saying
    1
  1701. As coronavirus sweeps the Gulf, its desperate migrant workers are stuck in limbo https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/09/middleeast/uae-migrants-coronavirus-intl/index.html Please read this and tell me how their plight is different
    1
  1702.  @RihanKhan-xi4pp  The pundits, though not wholly their fault, have expressed regrets many time over… it has been legislated too… expression of regrets by latter generations is symbolic and goes a long way toward reconciliation…. In case you don’t know. Such regrets have been expressed by old oppressors in the USA, Australia, Africa etc.
    1
  1703.  @RihanKhan-xi4pp That is the beauty of reconciliation and peace and acceptance, necessary for r the Nation and ALL its people to move forward with proper education and civility. Pundits have done it through words and action and legislation D
    1
  1704. Super…mainstream TV do not discuss governance matter…true….what a shame for the largest democracy… Tailpiece: My next article
    1
  1705. We must sometimes talk politically incorrectly to find solutions to social problems. This matter about communal disharmony is a bit confusing. The narrative going around is flawed. The problem is not with the Muslims. Wait, neither is the problem with the others. The basic problem is with Islam. Tolerance is respecting the way each religion prays etc. Tolerance is NOT tolerating intolerance. For instance, what has Islam (NOT MUSLIMs) done to reassure those who worship idols? Tailpiece: Islam and Islamic leaders, especially in India, should reassure all those who worship different GOD using different methods of prayer, that their God is as good as all Gods and their methods of praying is a efficient as any. I hope the spirit in which this is said is appreciated.
    1
  1706.  @anshuraj4277  fact is what you want to believe I made a point the burden of proof on the prosecution ever since 1947 has been very heavy. The percentage of conviction in criminal cases is just above 20%….. That is why many criminals including political ones get away…. I am repeating it so that you get what I mean…. If you want to indict agencies and governments go right ahead , that is your right…. Such political discussions are not my cup of tea… stay well
    1
  1707.  @anshuraj4277  fact is just what you want to believe
    1
  1708.  @anshuraj4277  exactly that is your truth.... May not be everybody's truth I think you are not getting it, I was/am not discussing a particular case.
    1
  1709.  @anshuraj4277  perceptions...make for differences in opinions / views Anush... Arguments are for the courts though inefficient in many ways. Discusions are here, which need not be conclusive. Anyway my comments were not on any one case, I was addressing the system.. Please read my originak comment once more.
    1
  1710.  @anshuraj4277  if that is how you perceive.... I see it as criminals fooling the system... Now this is not absolute... Nothing in this world is absolute... If you get what I mean. If you don't, It is as well... I respect your view in our democracy and move on...thanks for your input.
    1
  1711.  @anshuraj4277  that is exactly my point.... Heavy burden of proof for the prosecution... The term “innocent until proven guilty” is something we can easily take for granted within the legal system and, more specifically, the criminal justice system. We are used to presumed innocence in a modern courtroom where the prosecution has to work to prove a defendant’s guilt. enjoy...stay well
    1
  1712.  @anshuraj4277  that is why our judicial system takes decades to conclude cases.... The burden of proof is too heavy.... and all criminals including political criminals exploit it... Assisted by the liberal media by default or by design.... Reflect Whose country is it anyway?
    1
  1713. In the light of the G20 Presidency of India and connected events etc. I find that in every and all press interactions the big Q is about the consensus statement on Russia-Ukraine conflict. Is THAT statement all that important in the context of a flailing global economy and other more important matters such as debt, health, climate etc. Will a solution to these issues be obtained by the evasive “joint statement”? Or will the war cease after the joint statement? In a world with multilateral leadership environment, as envisaged for the next century, joint statements are unimportant. The rest of he world has to move on. Tailpiece: The media should smell the coffee and not try and make this non issue as paramount to success just to bring in the word “failure”. And in the context of the European War, it is obvious even to the uninitiated that the solution lies elsewhere than in “joint statements”.
    1
  1714. We must ask the USA and the “liberal” West, whether Pakistan is a democracy. They claim to know a lot on free world, liberty, freedom etc.. much more than a lot of us. Why don’t we? Tailpiece. Let us stop propagating a make believe world…etc… hope I convey enough to call out the hypocrite world
    1
  1715.  @Ranjankumar-ey1zb  Ranjan, it is ok you have attacked me personally, when I have only expressed a view - right or wrong. Ah. Yes, probably you missed my comments on the hunger index show aired on Theprint. Thanks anyway. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    1
  1716. Clearly, the media is making Modi a larger than life figure. History is replete with examples where heroes were created by perception only to be destroyed later. If China (arguably a world power) wants to humiliate Modi (as the the heading suggests) and not India, in the twenty first century, I would rate Modi as the greatest ever leader to tread the Earth. So, what is it?
    1
  1717. The crux f it all. Great. Tailpiece: Are we to believe this is democracy? What is in it for the “diverse” Nation? Parochialism?
    1
  1718. Shekhar Gupta, in an uncanny way, raises issues of expansionism reminiscent of eighteenth century and earlier. In many ways his (un)guarded insinuation is not misplaced. But there are differences. He has explained the major one – the “Akhand” aspect. While in the case of China it is a state policy, it is more an “idea” with India and only “Kashmir” as a sentimental issue with Pakistan. All other developments in this regard are fallout. In the case of Kashmir, I will say that it is important for India for its defence more than the sentiment. The strategic importance of Kashmir for defence of Indian mainland though not discussed(need not be too) in public, is a major factor in the scheme of defending our Northern borders. Letting JK go any which way is strategically detrimental to India’s Defence. With Pakistan, it is more of a matter of sentiment than history or geography. Sans ego and sentiments very easily resolvable. China, as evidenced by ts actions worldwide, is truly in the mould of real geographic expansionism. Between India and China it is the traditional border dispute – the only land border dispute in the World today. The border was never ever defined anytime in history. As mature Nations the dispute should and could have been settled in the past decades. For many varied reasons it was not to be. Rest assured, as is normal with negotiations, in any settlement with China, with or without war, notwithstanding the “winner”, a lot of give and take will happen in case of a border settlement. What do they say in business? Any crisis can be converted to an opportunity? SWOT analysis they call it - right?
    1
  1719. A fact check, SG. Tailpiece: The real problem is that with unplanned developments our cities do not suck (rain water) and with no drainage to speak of, the water does not know where to go. So they stay on roads and enter homes! Just saying.
    1
  1720. A fact check, SG. Tailpiece: The real problem is that with unplanned developments our cities do not suck (rain water) and with no drainage to speak of, the water does not know where to go. So they stay on roads and enter homes! Just saying.
    1
  1721. A fact check, SG. Tailpiece: The real problem is that with unplanned developments our cities do not suck (rain water) and with no drainage to speak of, the water does not know where to go. So they stay on roads and enter homes! Just saying.
    1
  1722. Good CTC. Well explained. All these aspects of politics and economy existed in this world even a few millennia ago - E.g. documented Egyptian and Indian history. The only difference is in the scale and reach afforded by the digital media. The world will move on.
    1
  1723. Good overbiew
    1
  1724. To be able to manage yourself, you have to ask, what are my values? This is not about ethics of which the rules are the same for everybody. Values will differ – over which you can’t put a template to decide good or bad. The variables in each case are too many and very different. Organisations like people have values – can’t sit in judgement about the quality, in a democratic society where one is free to choose. To be effective, a person’s values must be compatible with the organisation’s values; not the same but at least compatible. Else she will not produce results giving rise to frustration. It is then better for the person to leave without rancour and much ado about nothing. Throwing stones from the outside does not exude quality and exhibits weakness in character. Tail piece: It is not for either parties to decide whose value system is to be valued more. Each will have its own place and people are free to choose – is that not democracy?
    1
  1725. Critical of UPA, NDA and all Governments. Is it necessary to be always critical of Governments to be an intellectual? Just asking. Expert opinions etc. without responsibility always seems convincing. Only the wearer of a shoe knows how it bites. Just saying Disclaimer: with due respect to all intellectuals.
    1
  1726. It is good not to do overdo politics - especially local politics-.They teach us NOTHInG.
    1
  1727. SG, very informative as usual. My take. Meritocracy (ranking) may not be the way forward and most often fail to deliver in the larger scheme of things. For instance…Is it right that all currencies are “ranked” against the dollar, which by itself is perched on top against all the criteria for ranking? ($ is the most debt laden currency in the world). Tailpiece: Do you, or anybody, feel that with a population of 130cr+, there should be per capita ranking? Smell the coffee at home…. the aroma will indicate the mix. it is a much better way forward for India and not comparisons with Nations the size of one of its states. Was Salvatore also implying this?
    1
  1728. Between India-China experts want the Defence to assert…. But between Israel-HAMAS military is not the approach? Something wrong here. Tailpiece: For Gods sake discuss terrorists and their openly supporting Nations…. Condemn them unafaidedly (if I may)….The media is a very big failure here.
    1
  1729. Ms Mamata B, is this an attempt to curb free speech? In a democracy free press and free speech means continually finding fault with the Governments and perpetually criticizing them. Anything less will be an attack on freedom of the media and suppression of free speech. Tailpiece: Unless the pillars of democracy exert pressure in different directions and perpetually and weaken (in the name of strengthening) the system keeping a strain on the democracy and delaying decisions, the edifice will crumble. Right?
    1
  1730.  @nightmaregaming3160  How about thise out on bail?
    1
  1731.  @isbproductions5037  not only money but money too, in many cases
    1
  1732. The new frontier, surely.
    1
  1733. Actually, a great cut the clutter with essential information. But a good question. That we discuss this in this way is proof enough. We, of course can’t have a HOS and HOG working at cross purposes. Like does the Queen matter in Britain? We now find that there is a lot wanting in the system. Like the Queen the President may or may not contribute to administration or image. As simple as that. For e.g. The next titular head (HOS) of Britain may not be as endearing to the public as the Queen. We got independence from the British and that undeniably had an effect on how we framed our constitution and constituted a Government. The President of India has more powers than the Queen!!!. Okay Tailpiece: Yet do we need a new structure. There is still time to reframe our constitution and our federal structure. Just saying.
    1
  1734. @akshay de  possibly. All the best to you, though
    1
  1735.  @akshayde  thanks. Remember, you too will age.. and possibly will attain some wisdom too. Warm regards. Stay safe
    1
  1736. An apt heading to the show. My take:- Sample this. It is hard to find locals for manufacturing jobs. The psychology is that they do not want to get their hands dirty at home; dirty hands are alright away from home. In a business hub like Gurugram, there will be plenty of jobs for the locals away from shop floors as it is. Business organizations like FICCI, NASSCOM etc. should take up programmes for skill enhancement aggressively. a lot more than what is being done now. There is also a requirement to ensure the quality of engineers coming out of colleges. Tailpiece: As brought out, these unconstitutional legislations will only precipitate matters and not improve. Reservation of jobs that won't exist because of exodus of industries. The economy of Haryana will crumble.
    1
  1737. @Isabel Albert Whether I am aware or unaware is not a mattter for discussion. The point is, as an erstwhile Army Commander who was in charge here, he should desist. That is ethics. Period.
    1
  1738.  @bilalbaig8586  Two points. Firstly, It is not right to say just because JS (if he is corrupt) is not charged all others who are corrupt should not be charged. If JS is corrupt he should be charged too.. that brings up,the …Secondly, if anybody strongly suspects, any officer barer (including JS) is corrupt she should file a complaint and maybe approach the media even. Complaints of corruption was raised against officials in the Raffael,case and the SC did conduct investigations.
    1
  1739. Defeatist...and the Media including The Print playing it up. Trust the politicians to make our rights to vote a joke and trust the Indian Media to “Wah! Wah! their Quawali!!! Great trash entertainment. What else is all this? This is not a lone instance. It is the way of politics and the media in our country.
    1
  1740. Very true. It is all about only roti, kapda and makkan. If the society is strong, its religious leaders need to unite. The narration should be about progress and development. Tone down the politics in the media (not The Print, but the main stream media). Tailpiece: Let the media change the narrative and address the society and the religious leaders directly. Don’t expect that in a democracy the politicians will not create vote banks by pandering to the majority or the minority. Religious leaders are the key. The bottom line is after all politics can deliver only that much….but it is the Governance which matters-over discuss development and not politics.
    1
  1741. Great. What is the Government doing eh? Of course, to the media they are heroes. Right? Democracy at its best?
    1
  1742. At least the abbreviations and it’s expansions (you can’t always use expansions) give us a sense of what they are meant to be, (agreements, coalitions etc…). I wonder why ridicule them? Sarcasm? Just asking. Tailpiece: Questions. Do such introductions mislead impressions of subjects to be discussed in the video, mislead the audience? Possibly. Default or design? Food for thought.
    1
  1743. All of us go to town with what is said in the constitution. Is UCC also ordained in the constitution? Just asking. Tailpiece: Every organization including a large section of the media in India practice hypocrisy and double standards. Just saying.
    1
  1744. Diwali greetings to team , ThePrint. Forward Ho!
    1
  1745. Swami, but for theatrics…Don’t you feel the Indian story is a lot different…for starter there are boundaries and legal documents in South Asia. I wonder why…. To be a “ liberal”?
    1
  1746.  @sauron2000000  THTAT is a Q? My Q is beyond that. Thanks for response. Stay safe.
    1
  1747. For centuries religion has dictated, and humanity has accepted, when Muhurtams and horoscopes dictate how to do what even including daily chores, how to shave (or not to shave) and dress (gender based), what and when to eat, reveal sins for redemption and also controlled other behaviors of (wo)mankind to a great extent and continues to control and direct lives (and politics?) even in this digital era. In the past decade or so (wo)mankind has embraced digital environment for an easier and convenient life style (all, all too willingly) to the extent that Facebook chooses your friends, shadi.com tells you who to marry, amazon tells you what to buy, swiggy tells you what to eat, LinkedIn tells you how to work, Netflix tells you what to see, Twitter governs you and so on.... and of course, media strives to guide you how to think. Consider this; if it were not for the digital network, the world would have been much worse off, in this COVID19 onslaught, than it was during and after the Spanish flu of 1917-18. Don’t stymie the digital growth, especially in India, with unnecessary “concerns” about this new found “TRP” of digital security. In the wake of the foregoing, the unfounded concern (overplay) of data security in the digital environment (which will make living easier) is confounding. Unless of course you, including the media, have something damning to hide.
    1
  1748. As usual a “hatke” programme. Informative and each can form own views. My take. The middle path alone usually does not lead to anywhere. To reach some where a bit of left and a bit of right are essential. In other words not much is achieved in the middle path which is more of a “please all” approach, without thought to a structure. The edifice, without a strong structure is bound to crumble one day. Tail piece: Like in politics is there a left and right in religious beliefs too? Is THAT the real problem in our societies? jJust asking.
    1
  1749. Nothing personal. I have not heard Mr C Bhagat except here. It seems from Mr CB’s uttering that he has not traveled to know whether or not hate exists outside India and also, probably, he does not know what real love is. His writings, I think, too belie a bias or ignorance. A critical view. No offense.
    1
  1750. Kerrie the mystery deepens...you chose.... secularism Also found in: Thesaurus, Financial, Encyclopedia, Wikipedia. sec·u·lar·ism (sĕk′yə-lə-rĭz′əm) n. 1. Religious skepticism or indifference. 2. The view that religious considerations should be excluded from civil affairs or public education. sec′u·lar·ist n. sec′u·lar·is′tic adj. American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fifth Edition. Copyright © 2016 by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. Published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Company. All rights reserved. secularism (ˈsɛkjʊləˌrɪzəm) n 1. (Philosophy) philosophy a doctrine that rejects religion, esp in ethics 2. the attitude that religion should have no place in civil affairs 3. the state of being secular ˈsecularist n, adj ˌsecularˈistic adj secular (ˈsɛkjʊlə) adj 1. of or relating to worldly as opposed to sacred things; temporal 2. not concerned with or related to religion 3. not within the control of the Church 4. (Education) (of an education, etc) a. having no particular religious affinities b. not including compulsory religious studies or services 5. (Ecclesiastical Terms) (of clerics) not bound by religious vows to a monastic or other order 6. occurring or appearing once in an age or century 7. lasting for a long time 8. (Astronomy) astronomy occurring slowly over a long period of time: the secular perturbation of a planet's orbit. n 9. (Ecclesiastical Terms) a member of the secular clergy 10. another word for layman
    1
  1751. Krishna Venkata I am not sure....nothing is permanent in this world...it has been just a thousand odd years + for the religions, some changes can already be seen in one or two mordern religions
    1
  1752. Suresh Polali if you are asking me....I think I have said it very clearly....without discussing Hindus, Muslims, Christians etc...
    1
  1753. Krishna Venkata THAT is exactly my point. Secularism, if you want it, should be multilateral and never about majority and minorities.
    1
  1754.  john doe  we must thank The Print for facilitating this discussion!
    1
  1755. john doe they were caught unawares. For long they did not know or care what was happening there...busy as they were with Russia, Middle East, Libya, Iran, Afghanistan etc..etc..They realized that there was a country “China” only after their businesses (manufacturing) moved in there. By then it was too late. So now instead of prevention it is now redemption!!! I am not faulting anybody here...all Nations want to be on top one way or the other...stability accompanies tension...law of physics...
    1
  1756. A sincere and excellent assessment. Thanks Snehesh . Valid points. My take. Simply put, It has always been the tactics, since decades that Indian offensives have always preceded by heavy and effective bombardment of all available artillery…. And with great success for the records. So the lessons are not about use of artillery…. It is about the quality of Defence and firepower. So, it is all about the quality of weapons (which are the warheads in case of Artillery, and not the delivery systems)…. It is about technology…India has been upgrading even before Ukraine…a bit slow process… no,lessons in this respect for India from Ukraine. India is aware and upgrading. Tailpiece: Yes we require to upgrade…we are at it.
    1
  1757. Very informative. Exact status.
    1
  1758. There is this actor who excels in his trade but is also a well known philanderer. Then there is this golfer, arguably the best ever, whose personal conduct off the golf course was found much wanting.For the sake of their professional performances they still command respect in society. Kamala Harris is an American and all she will do, if and when she gets a chance, will be for America. But in many circles, as is fashionable these days, she also has managed to draw PM Modi ( like the ubiquitous Aloo (Potato) which can form part of any Indian dish ) into discussions on her, in India. I wonder if anybody has yet noticed “Kamal” in her name. Indians, please grow up. What matters is the Nation…the screen and the golf course and not the personalities – unless of course someone wants to propose to the lady (with all due respect and reverence, just to emphasize a point, and mean no harm).
    1
  1759. One swallow doesn’t make a summer - either which way
    1
  1760. Yes, mate this is a stale story… The electorate is wondering who is playing by the book and who is not. Are our August houses becoming a sham? This is another Q in the minds of “We the people”. Tailpiece: Request carry a story on this. Thanks.
    1
  1761.  @zanith6426  True…CBI ( caged parrot, remember?) and ED continue to work as they have been doing for decades. A drawback of Democracy? Suit the narrative as per preconceptions… agenda and support.
    1
  1762.  @zanith6426  Did you trust ED / CBI akk these oast decades.... Read up on democracy...... Also where big people are involved there can't be smoke without fire.... In a demicracy politically supported corruption requires politically initiated action to counter it. Enjoy
    1
  1763.  @mogleesh-22  absolutely true. If ED has evidence( evidently, it has in this case) the person can be arrested even after the first summons is ignored ... The discussion is not about pro / anti bjp.. That would be the wrong way to approach the matter. Enjoy.
    1
  1764. Apt heading. Burning deck and not a sinking ship. Remember the saying, “When the going gets tough p, the tough get going”. Let us gibpve the new PM of Britain some space. He has taken upon himself an onerous task…. Not for money, he has enough. Tailpiece: Wonder why a lot of the media is going ballistic on a new British PM, taking office in difficult times for the Nation. Give him space to do a job. The mainstream media need to down the rhetoric.
    1
  1765. In this case it may be more apt to say “ there is lot said by saying nothing”.
    1
  1766. And seriously If the Hindu - Muslim divide in politics (let us not beat around the bush) is referred as polarization…we may be barking up the wrong tree. The divide is because of religion and not politics. And we as a society, the self styled experts, the MEDIA and all those good samaritans are afraid to address head on. We as a society must learn to live peacefully so that vested interest do not exploit us. Tailpiece. Change the narrative.
    1
  1767. Should we want the Indian electorate to swayed by symbolism? Handling the case, all similar atrocities, to the ends of justice, I suppose is prime.
    1
  1768. A follow up illustration…. As of yesterday, hardly a few in India talked about SVB, USA. Today we have thousands of “experts” on the digital and other media telling us why the SVB failed. So much for the “experts”. Enjoy
    1
  1769. Who are those peddling a BRICS currency? Never heard it from a serious source. Re for $ is also just a dream now. But did not our revered ex President famously say that unless you dream you can’t achieve? Tailpiece: Nescafé with instant coffee have raised expectancy levels. It is not always chat mangni phat shaadi.
    1
  1770. Change is the only constant…..even in politics… I I say that it is mentioned in the Bhagwat Gita ….will it become a communal statement? It is always a time foe change …..change old Dogmas …. Life and living is least about religion and politics… Tailpiece: Always and everywhere we change as a positive
    1
  1771. Does this mean that Pakistan really wants PEACE with India and not a PIECE of India? Just asking. Tailpiece. Yes, I agree with SG. India keeps quite, as articulated in an old African Proverb “ You judge a man by the work of his hands”. Period.
    1
  1772. All governments need to be checked for wrongs (mostly perceived, as few have equal overall inputs like the Government). The tone of a “knowall”, like Ms Jyoti M takes, defeats the purpose as the intentions are suspect even just reading the heading. Ms Jyoti may be a veteran journalist, but out there, there are plenty of veteran readers and veteran commoners. Tailpiece: How you say it is more telling than what you say. Just saying.
    1
  1773.  @DKSingh-wf8tn  And one more point, it is beyond time that we the people of India recognise that the greater danger to our democracy is not a strong party or leader but the absence of a strong and erudite opposition at the National level.
    1
  1774. China the enigma. Catch the bull by its horns. A bit long, but necessary. China has its fingers (pun intended) all over its area of influence and possibly beyond in some cases. Wherever there is a dispute (there sure is on the LAC, especially in eight specific locations) it is either settled by force or through negotiations. Negotiations means “give and take” without bloodshed. War and /or conflict also means give and take after wasteful expenditures and bloodshed. In the circumstance, points for consideration are: 1. War or negotiations. 2. Is India politically ready for negotiations? 3. Is China ready to negotiate? 4. Is India ready for war? 5. Does China want war? 6. Will internal bickering (in Indian media and Parliament etc…), on a well-known situation, help India or China? 7. Is China aiming to destablise India politically (a sure enough aim of any Nation to destablise its perceived “unfriendly” neighbour), even proposed as an instrument of war by Chanakya. 8. Are there other options for India like Internationalising the dispute etc. -not recommended for obvious reasons as everybody involved will want their pound of flesh and also extend their “help” all over the place. Tail piece: I obviously, am no expert of any sort and have only put out my views as I see the situation. Well, like you, I sometimes wonder who are the experts? If we can get answers to the above Qs, we can get the monkey of China off our LAC back.
    1
  1775. I was told that Pak wants to “talk” (dialogue) to India. I wonder if it is to discuss Modi. The aim of targeting Modi is evident. Who gives them the space? I again wonder. Tailpiece: Mr Bilawal BZ is as yet a non entity…we have a lot to improve at home in public speaking by public personalities…. And a large section of the media too…
    1
  1776. Modi's India? You too SG? Give us Indians a break , please.
    1
  1777. When Modi (or any PM of India) does not meet the Pope on a visit to Rome : The Media : “ given the demography of India the PM should have met the Pope……. “ WhenModi (or any PM of India) meets the Pope on a visit to Rome: The Indian Media : “ why Modi (any PM of India) meeting the Pope will enhance her / his image…” This is negative reporting in the least. Tailpiece: If Facebook is attracting more clicks with its angry emojis, the media will attract more eyeballs/readership always by its contrary reporting”. What is Facebook doing differently to attract criminality/contempt?
    1
  1778. Knowledgeable insights from Ila as usual, loaded with facts as they are. Coordinated actions by various arms of the Government are visible only recently. Perhaps, the concerned ministries were consulting each other these past decades too; it definitely was not obvious optically or explicit in the decisions and results. Additional inflation would significantly reduce the debt ratio, even with some shortening of debt maturities or vice versa. In the circumstance, for the present, it may be to our advantage that RBI is addressing both debt as well as inflation.
    1
  1779. SG, Buddhism, before 300 BCE, preached that War is essential for peace, but only as the very last resort…. Just saying. Tailpiece: Are we at times over glorifying ordinary people who were mere products of circumstance, overlooking there monumental failures? Again, just asking
    1
  1780. There are two ways to settle a dispute, where legal recourse is not available. 1. Fight it out, with the winner deciding who gets what. 2. Negotiate an outcome, which will entail some give and take. I am interested to know the approach which the people of India ( I am an Indian veteran, trained to do that what is decided by the Nation) recommend.
    1
  1781. Politics does not matter Right or Left…. Don’t get caught up… The science will throw up more… There will be more RakhiGarhis… rest easy… Tailpiece: Who brings it to politics?
    1
  1782. It is sad. The Nation is shamed. My heart goes out to the family. It is sadder. As brought out, such a case is over played or other similar cases are underplayed? May not be so. In all cases mid-night burning of a body does not take place. There should have been an immediate explanation, in the least...why the family was excluded. The public sees vested interests. Subsequently discussion veers away from the core. Mummy’s of 5000 years ago...not 50000!
    1
  1783. A wonderful declutter especially for the uninitiated. I get a feeling The Print guided by SG is trailblazing a new path for informative journalism in India. Impressed. Tailpiece: The worst disservice to a Nation is when the media starts speculating and sensationalizing just for TRP and hidden agenda. I hope the rest of the media is watching ThePrint.
    1
  1784. SG, were they the coats to coat of arms? Probably coat of arms initially
    1
  1785. Pray, tell me when did India declare victory?
    1
  1786. SG, elections are an excuse for big players to manipulate markets without suspicion. In any case FIIs have been selling in the cash mart for a couple of years now. Tailpiece: Elections are a damp squib it’s time except for empty unpleasant rhetoric by political parties. I hope politicians realize this and media call the bluff of such rhetoric rather than add fuel to fire
    1
  1787. Wonder why the media is going ballistic on a new British PM, taking office in difficult times for the Nation. Give him space to do a job. Tone down the rhetoric. Tailpiece: Media is important but so are very many other issues in a democracy
    1
  1788. Good
    1
  1789. very sad and deplorable. A responsible society should never let such incidents happen. Did she meet this fate because she was a dalit or because she was a girl or because she was poor? Was the atrocity against a dalit or against a woman? Such reports should be taken to its conclusion to identify the real malaise in the society.
    1
  1790. Rain Mars? The match could as well have been held in Mars!!!!
    1
  1791.  @adarshverma2014  yes, agree. The govts should influence people. But that does not mean we glorify "separatists" (like maoists) etc...,
    1
  1792.  @anu-20-11  👍
    1
  1793.  @anu-20-11  The “problem” now is the digital media. Then Indira etc. was not used as much in daily conversations. Because communications have facilitated geometrical increase in the number of people expressing g instant opinions (like ours here) in the plethora of digital platforms (including unlimited TV channels etc) , the real issues are drowned in the cacophony. Media also participates similarly eclipsing critical issues behind names (Like Namo, Raga, Didi etc...). Who’s is discussing issues...except for people like ila, DK and most times SG? All mast heads are like Modi this Modi that instead of highlighting the matter under discussion. E.g. Modi let’s Nepal etc..... instead of India let’s Nepal..... It was always UPA and NDA even a decade back. The apparition of individuals is never ever created by the individual..it is the public and media who create Demi gods out of nobody
    1
  1794.  @manjulashanmugasundaram706  We the people, can’t just give up. Trying is always better than doing nothing😀
    1
  1795.  @manjulashanmugasundaram706  That is only a created perception or a false image propped up, either by the Government , opposition or the media. Any of these institutions may be doing it with vested interests. If everybody takes anybody’s name every time and everywhere it will become the default. That is what is happening. E.g. BJP thinks it may help them; Opposition thinks it may help them; media thinks it will create a shock and awe effect. In reality what matters is only roti, kappa and Makan. And of course sentiments at the hustings. Don’t perpetuate the mirage. Let us talk about GOI and its policies Not discuss individuals
    1
  1796.  @tomchristo  it is just a perceptive... Based on feelings and not on thoughts. A dispassionate observation.
    1
  1797.  @SSUNMEETS  Hanspal, bolne mein kya jata hain?
    1
  1798. A nuclear stand is better than a no clear stand! India is doing well. It is not always you have to take sides. Binary is only in computer language. In the real world and Indian politics there is a state outside the binary. Tailpiece: In short one need not be pro or anti in general.
    1
  1799. The basic reasons is that our companies are overvalued and as brought out here we are not there with our much delayed reforms in judiciary, economy, land, farm, labour and ease of doing business.. If we wait for consensus on these policies…. it will,never happen… media like the print have to repeatedly highlight these issues so that liberals and socialists voices are drowned… Tailpiece. Is the India media like The Print up to it? Can I have an answer?
    1
  1800.  @nrupensingh7995  That Nrupen is the innate beauty in multi party democracies. Some parties can be everywhere without being anywhere. Enjoy. Stay safe.
    1
  1801.  @anshuraj4277  oh Anshu, Where have I justified war crimes? Nationalism is not even remotely connected to war crimes. Read all I have written once more. Still enjoy.
    1
  1802.  @anshuraj4277  Anshu, you are getting personal. Not good during a discussion. Thank you. Take care. Still, enjoy.
    1
  1803.  @anshuraj4277  It is all a matter of perception. In my days, the soccer team was lined up in 5,3,2,1 formation. (Now the most common formation is 2,4,4,1). In the former the five forwards were Left in, Left out, centre forward, right in and right out). Now it is just forwards and defenders(interchangeable). But the field , ball and the rules are the same. You see, it is all only about playing a fair game. Names don't matter. Enjoy.
    1
  1804.  @anshuraj4277  Anshu, you have not got my point. There is no such thing as Far right, Left or centre Nationalism. They are coined by vested interests (political, religious etc…). Hitler was dictator etc… Japan at one stage was forced to go in the offensive because of invaders etc…. Nationalism is just that Everything in the Nation’s interest. It is that simple. Anything else is not Nationalism. It is a misuse of the term like the misuse of secularism etc…. Long story. Just chill and enjoy.
    1
  1805.  @anshuraj4277  Anshu, we give False directions like right, left and centre to Nationalism. Natiinalism is simp,y Nation and its people (ALL) first. It is that simple. In their wisdom “experts” aided by the media and some vested interests have coined this unnatural terms “far right” etc. Enjoy. Keep it Simple.
    1
  1806. Your coverage of varied topics and dissemination of information without any political tint, ( giving a message that there is life beyond politics (may be only beyond politics) is refreshing. Congratulations.
    1
  1807. may be trying to give very legal Indian a unique identity card / recognition....to prevent impersonation, say, in electoral rolls? Just asking
    1
  1808. Who imitates who? Do politicians follow the language of the media or is it vice versa? Just asking.
    1
  1809. Gaurav, the narrative of history will be ever changing. You have to separate the events in history from its narrative and decide for yourself the good and bad of the events. I can go on… but YOU be your own judge..
    1
  1810. Okay. Do not suggest that Indian Shias to take sides… else a good show
    1
  1811. True. The COVID deaths and cases are undercounted. It is bound to happen in India (may be elsewhere too) where in normal times the births and deaths are not counted. In a country, with a population of nearly 140 billion, where there is no Unique uniform identity for citizens, what else do you expect? Tailpiece: There are countries where even lottery tickets are sold against the Unique social security numbers of citizens. The buck (as somebody said lately) stops with us Citizens to decide whether we want to become a developed Nation or forever remain a developing Nation.
    1
  1812. If statistics is the key, here is a simple solution arrive at COVID deaths for a given period : COVID deaths for a given period = Total deaths for the period - number of deaths for the same period in 2019. That should give a near enough correct figure. Right?
    1
  1813. Very informative in a very non technical language…. The dogs tail saying in Malayalam is that “aayira varsham kuzhaliirunnoru nayudu vale valance theerum”. The meaning is the same except that it says a thousand years instead of just 12. Tailpiece: SG yes politics….. your forte…. It is the sentimental politics that is making India a laggard democracy…. I wish you change the narrative towards developmental politics. You have the mandate to do it and you must give it a try. Never discuss caste etc and politics even if it is so. When we stop talking about it hopefully the sentimental politics will go away. You, The Print can continue to make a difference….
    1
  1814. SG a good political presentation. The points made with “statistics” do not tell all. Ask TA. For progress and development structural changes in policies are those that matter for sustained growth. Traditionally coalition governments in India have failed to bring in such changes for sustained growth. If as you say , during the coalition periods, if structural changes were brought in the progress of development and poverty alleviation would have been in a much advanced place compared to now. The structural changes effected in the last 10 years and in the next five years is what will take India to a higher plateau with more equitable wealth distribution. Therefore the vision for 2047. Tailpiece: Unfortunately you missed this very very important point in your wholesome analysis. Politics is important but progress and development are not all about politics alone…it is also very much about a vision.
    1
  1815.  @Justandfair2392  Nuzahan, there are no divine laws, in any religion including mine. The methods and “laws” in religions were drafted by humans like us in another era. Sections of society (in ALL religions) exploit these “laws” and “rules” to control the society. Just reflect. Be happy. Enjoy and stay safe. Once again, my point is in regard to ALL religions. Tailpiece: The law like the IPC and constitutions are the law as that directs any society to live normally and peacefully. That is the only law not that ordained by religions.
    1
  1816.  @Justandfair2392  yes, there should be no law in religion. Methods (in all religions) and archaic rules should change. No offense to anyone please. I mean in ALL religions. Religious leaders should take the lead for reforms.
    1
  1817. I have heard many experts, Nations etc. ventilate in detail what Israel should not be doing after the Barbaric attack by terrorist outfit HAMAS ( any organization that murders civilians in barbaric acts, rapes women and behead children and take innocent civilians as hostages are by any definition terrorists). I am yet to hear some sane voices telling us what Israel should have done post that horrific event. I have not heard calls for HAMAS to release the hostages and at least regret their action of Oct 7 and call for Palestinians to ostracize HAMAS and come to the negotiating table etc…. Is Tia the way of “liberals” and “liberal” media…. A bit of hypocrisy to show a holier than thou face? Tailpiece: HAMAS and its handlers were / are best placed to halt the atrocities in Gaza…just give up the hostages and come to the negotiating table… Probably the Arab states and Iran etc. do not want that
    1
  1818. A unique programme to educate the uninitiated. Once the nuances are better understood the electorate, if I may (and if at all these are criteria for a people who vote with their hearts than with their head is a moot point), they can take better decisions. Tailpiece: More the finding critics we need to see the larger picture… like SG takes there is no “abracadabra” to economic growth of a “poor” nation with 1,4 billion people.
    1
  1819. Good The Print is also educating on the virus. Only sUch programmes will help the Nation to fight the scourge. Keep it up.
    1
  1820. The media playing up protests (mostly turning violent for whatever reasons) and downplaying other democratic processes, in the name of constitutional right (right or wrong) have set bad precedents leading to the Nation being a laggard democracy. This right (right or wrong) always eclipses the cause which is NOT always right. It just does not seem logical that all opposition parties and those traditionally inimical to the elected Government (since independence) "support " the protests just to bring down governments (to regain power etc.) and not applying mind to the real issue which does not get that much coverage as the ball ball commentaries on the protests. It is a bit strange that the media, farmers and the opposition parties encourages discussing the protests and its fall out rather than the farm laws itself. Ominous signs.
    1
  1821. Good points. And, of course, the one point you left out is that ONOE will render many political commentators and psephologists jobless for years .:)
    1
  1822. Isn’t the definition of ‘winning’ a bit macabre? Just asking.
    1
  1823. Is the Nation celebrating?
    1
  1824. Also… Iran accused (not credible allegations) USA of killing its General USA accused (not credible allegations) Saudi’s of murdering Jamal Khashoggi Israel faces multiple “accusations” of killings on foreign soil Many are accusing USA of committing murder in Iraq and Libya There is more to everything than what we see… Governing aNation is not easy Just saying
    1
  1825. ​ @sudhanshusrivastava1969  Oh yes. I do not disagree wholly. All religious texts have flaws because they were written / compiled by humans. Respective religious leaders fail in their duty to bring this up and make corrections. In the circumstance the media (as usual, the know all) assume the responsibility and do it all wrong. The untruth have a field day and laugh all the way to the Bank.
    1
  1826.  @neerfruu  The Print should not emulate the street media. It has high potential to change the outlook (pun intended) and improve media standards.
    1
  1827. The media playing up protests (mostly turning violent for whatever reasons) and downplaying other democratic processes, in the name of constitutional right (right or wrong) have set bad precedents leading to the Nation being a laggard democracy. This right (right or wrong) always eclipses the cause which is NOT always right. It just does not seem logical that all opposition parties and those traditionally inimical to the elected Government (since independence) "support " the protests just to bring down governments (to regain power etc.) and not applying mind to the real issue which does not get that much coverage as the ball by ball commentaries on the protests. Ominous signs.
    1
  1828. Let us give up politics as a hobby. SG? Sports is more invigorating.But yes, in India politics is one unending soap…no more mind you. Great coverage of Athletics - for the new generation especially. Nothing like sports, shall we say? So…… SG, with your experience in covering politics and your other good interests (you have), why don’t you make a rule book and scoring sheet for politics and politicians, not much different from , say, cricket? Hope you get my drift. Do it. Something new. It will help more than treating politics as a soap opera.
    1
  1829. We the people fail the democracy. Wisdom and philosophy will take us only thus far. Unfortunate. Knowledge is the awareness that Tomato is a fruit. Wisdom is not putting it in a fruit salad. Philosophy is wonderingly if that means ketchup is fruit juice. Are we using tomato as it should be? Or are we taking solace in philosophy and inaction? We have to come out from being a laggard democracy.
    1
  1830. Is there a S400 type RADAR system which the politicians and the political parties can use to defend themselves from the volley of attacks from fellow politicians. Tailpiece: we do not care for personalities. We want a progressive, development based policies which will ensure roti, kapda and makkan for all. Few politicians talk of these policies in detail in their election speeches. It is either about giving freebies, vengeance or just”attacks”. Very disgusting.
    1
  1831. Wow! Shame on us! A doppelgänger is National news!!! The Print can do better. Tail piece: whose fault is it if Namo is made out to be a bigger than life figure?
    1
  1832. A good presentation. Well researched statistics which may not tell the real story. The major problem in such circumstances is that the Maoist killer also operates the local Kirana shop, which means that he is an Indian like me. Yet, they take strength from the media sympathy too. I have had close encounters with Naxals, in the 1960s, who operated from the now famous, Wynad ranges in North Malabar, my former home district. Luckily the social interactions of the locals and the “Dubai” syndrome worked in a way to nip the movement in the bud there. There is no place here for details. Let me tell you , that these Maoists now operate for personal gratification than for any principles. Else, can you give me one reason why they can’t come out for assimilation into the society as promised by many Governments? Tailpiece: Please don’t make heroes out of them.
    1
  1833. Suggested name “The changing nation - for better or worse”. Or “Unmasking of a Nation”
    1
  1834. Tragic. Unfortunate. Sad.
    1
  1835. Your reality may not be the real reality. It is your perception. That may be the reason why rest of India and the World views in India differently. Friend don’t look at things with preconceived ideas. There are a lot of well meaning and experienced people out there. Ah, also depends where and how you are looking too. If people are unhappy in this democratic country, one can always throw out the Government. If want you say is true that will happen. So relax. Enjoy
    1
  1836. Like Amul? Great products piggy backing on an excellent brand name.
    1
  1837. I wonder! An attack in Europe and many attacks here in India. At least now I hope the media realizes what an attack is.
    1
  1838. The Qs we all should be discussing in the media, opinions, experts etc… is what is good for India and NOT what is good for Modi, Kejriwal or Rahul Nor we should discuss what is good for BJP, Congress, AAP etc. we the people of India are more interested in India and less in politics. Let us get the ratio right. Theprint is in a good position to take the lead in this endeavour as it has already distributed its time in favor of informing the people on varied subjects - economy, geopolitics, sports, society etc…. I wonder how we the people can convey this message to the mainstream media. I suppose they monitor the comment section in Theprint! Tailpiece: Politics and politicians however popular are transitory. The Nation and its people are permanent.
    1
  1839. Nayanima B was in a dangerous situation. We comment her courage.
    1
  1840. But SG, only politics does not make democracy. People have to eat, clothe and live. Politics of feelings, that is what you get from politics, politics and politics, which does not deliver anything to the people.People go out and vote on only feelings - like katputhlis. THAT my friend is NOT good for democracy.
    1
  1841.  @dhawal8261  thanks for the info and input
    1
  1842. Simple but true, once again ThePrint has LEFT some RIGHT thoughts in this presentation!!!! “Do not get caught on simplistic binaries” - a quotable quote by SG. Like it. My thoughts, I have written a lot on it. My two bit: What is Hinduism? A lot on this, including a treatise by our former President Dr. Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan is available in the public domain - worth a read even for "experts". Binary is far from anything this philosophy propagates. Ideology: When we know that change is the only constant, why do we seek ideologies? There never was, is or will be any ideals and utopia. Tailpiece: We must measure Governments only with the yardstick of economics (roti, kapda makan) – rest is just show (dikkawa)
    1
  1843.  @CosmicValkyrie  👍thank you for the reply. Yoy have your views for sure. By the way, i was not arguing. Best Regards
    1
  1844.  @CosmicValkyrie  greetings. The very fact that this post of yours, under a false name, i presume (i have no issue with it, you are exercising your freedom to do it this way) is proof of that freedom. All is not lost. For good measure, I assure you that I have not yet seen the inside of a prison for nearly seven decades of my life and hopefully going forward I will not do something to change that. Freedom always comes with a cost. It is not free With all regards
    1
  1845. Over thirty top companies of the World with a net value of over a trillion dolars are led by Infdian origin CEOs. Given the circustance, capabilities of Indians to acjieve is beyond doubt. Indian is changing WITH SUCH OPPORTUNITIES hopefully being facilitated in our country after many decades of decadence. My appeal to the Indian “Opposition” political parties is that for your dynastic, sectorial, parochial, power mongering agenda do not muddy the waters with a “fight” against nonexistent apparitions of ideology and “threat to democracy”. We Indians are aware that you are aware but blinded by lust for power. Do not upset the banana cart – be more erudite and fight on the platform of development and progress. Tailpiece: Humanity has tried for millennia and failed to serve the right food for the people through religions etc…. concentrate on getting the food on the dinner table.
    1
  1846.  @riteshsinghchoudhary115  That is a naive question. India is a vast country with over 1.4 billion population. Very difficult to govern and governments, state and center are always accountable for all omissions and commissions, always. But to answer your question directly I commend this government for vision, sincerity and action, without any hesitation. They do have some failings and many achievements too. Everything in this world is relative. In that respect this governments is doing a much better job than most previous governments. If you have a different view, you are entitled to it and I respect your right to have that view. Urban management is for the local governments within policies…. Hence I am dwelling on policies …. You can’t compare Japanese cities and American cities with that of India. Governance is not in silos it encompasses a whole lot of things…. Hence I veered. Rest easy….
    1
  1847.  @riteshsinghchoudhary115  Ritesh, this is what is meant by reforms Whoever comes, is a difficult 10 years.. Hope we (India) don't lose steam... Lot of structural changes yet pending.Reforms are required in Judiciary, Police (already suggested by SC in 2009 but not implemented by states), farm, land, education, labour, more in economy, direct taxes, citizen identity, criminal laws, national security etc. Our democracy is a laggard where traditionally (*since decades*) new policies are opposed for agenda based or parochial reasons. Enjoy, smile, laugh Forward Ho!
    1
  1848.  @surojeetchatterjee  The history of India and how its cities developed, the size and population of Japan( equal to a state in India) are all different. Do you really compare Tokyo with Indian cities in what criteria? Read Indian history between 1947 and 1992… almost five decades of inaction.More importantly what India needs now is a strong goverment for bringing in reforms in Judiciary, Police (already suggested by SC in 2009 but not implemented by states), farm, land, education, labour, more in economy, direct taxes, citizen identity, criminal laws, national security etc. Our democracy is a laggard where traditionally (since decades) new policies are opposed for agenda based or parochial reasons. Let us hope we get very strong governments for the next 3 decades…. The gibberish spoken by political parties these days is just that…gibberish Enjoy, smile, laugh
    1
  1849.  @surojeetchatterjee  can you explain your logic, Suro… I want to learn what I do not know
    1
  1850.  @johnstanczyk4030  that is the point John. It is not always only the political parties or the governments who carry a National. May it be green or red or white or saffron.. it is people… we will reach there… don’t think of only politics
    1
  1851.  @johnstanczyk4030  john one need not be a green party fellow to know and work towards a cleaner environment .. India is behind but is working to reach there, in its own way. Green is not the only thing in life... It is one thing among very many. Stay well... Bye
    1
  1852.  @riteshsinghchoudhary115  getting personal means bereft of ideas… I wonder…. For the future of our Nation… stay well
    1
  1853.  @amarsinghhembram4379  okay thanks. You be the brave one fighting the evil… stay well… getting personal is a weakness by the way
    1
  1854.  @johnstanczyk4030  so you feel that one Green Party meme Dr can make a difference…. Either you are not an Indian or you know very little about your country.
    1
  1855.  @johnstanczyk4030  yes, bhai.. Delhi is the oldest metro in the world, founded millennia ago. Also it is land locked by a distance in all sides... Yes, pure air is a must.... Attempts are being made to improve. It cant be done by comparing with the incomparable . Show me another democracy with 1.4 b people. Stay well John.
    1
  1856. When the dust settles down, it will be realized that the “tour of duty” is a good programme to enable the youth of the Nation and may be detrimental to the efficiency of the Armed Forces. It is damning to see how political parties do not see beyond the party and are ready to do anything, even destroy the fabric of society, for power and wealth? Hopefully the Nation will one day, soon, see through these machinations of vested interests. Tailpiece: Gotta see how a balance in the Agnipath can be stuck. May require mid term course corrections.
    1
  1857. Protesters destroy public property. Not soldier material anyway.
    1
  1858.  @bobfaam5215  Bob, the best for Defence and for the Soldier is achieved by thus scheme... Exactly as you want it... So, relax and enjoy.
    1
  1859.  @bobfaam5215  No Bob.. when they get out, they need age on their side too…soldiers are human too…they too have a right to a good future. THAT is important too. Like other things in this the twenty first century… soldiers can not be a use throw item,,, enjoy.
    1
  1860.  @bobfaam5215  Bob, when the Indian Army fought in the World Wars and the major wars in 1948, 1962, 1965 and 1971, the colour service of a soldier was just 7 years and when they were “retired” then it was without terminal benefits. The service was extended to 14 years in 1973 to make them eligible for pension. So, technically there should be no problem to fight wars with Agniveers. A bit complicated Bob. Read up for more information. Enjoy.
    1
  1861.  @bobfaam5215  Okay Bob. 1 The Indian Army is much more in disposition and bigger than just the agniveers. 2. The primary task of the Indian Defence Force is NOT repeat NOT to fight terrorism or terrorists, whether Islamic or others. 3. At no time will the Indian Defence force comprise of only the “4year” agniveers. 4. In contrast the Indian public will comprise of more and more well trained youth with purpose in life. Thanks for your inputs Bob. Enjoy.
    1
  1862. When the dust settles down, it will be realized that the “tour of duty” is a good programme to enable the youth of the Nation and may be detrimental to the efficiency of the Armed Forces. It is damning to see how political parties do not see beyond the party and are ready to do anything, even destroy the fabric of society, for power and wealth? Hopefully the Nation will one day, soon, see through these machinations of vested interests. Tailpiece: Gotta see how a balance in the Agnipath can be stuck. May require mid term course corrections
    1
  1863. SG, can you do a cut the clutter on democracies, bringing out whether Freedom (all types) and liberalism are absolute. Can they ever be absolute? There is a gap in understanding this phenomenon. Tailpiece: There never was / is / or will be a UTOPIA.
    1
  1864. Snehesh you are a super Defence analyst. But heading such as “Lessons… etc is unbecoming from a reporter on Defence matters. Reportage is great and do them as they are. But “Lessons” as you see it to whom? To the public or the professional soldiers. Tailpiece: A view/suggestion from a ThePrint fan.
    1
  1865.  @ajitpati9324  de·feat·ist noun a person who expects or is excessively ready to accept failure. adjective demonstrating expectation or acceptance of failure.
    1
  1866. A good programme Can you fault the RSS for anything?
    1
  1867. A Q. Is it Modi Governments quest or India’s Quest. If Indians feel or are made to feel that whatever is done or people are made to do is for political parties and Governments, we will forever remain a laggard democracy. I think the media needs to change the tone. Tail piece: In a democracy (with all its warts), politicians and Governments are transitory; The Nation and its people are permanent.
    1
  1868. I wonder. I am not yet convinced that a few farmers did this probably at the expense of about 80% other farmers, especially from three regions (other than extreme West) of the Nation. A There are a ,lot of Indians out there wondering about our democracy and progress. No wonder India is labeled as a laggard democracy. These farmers need to introspect rather than rejoice. Tail piece: Politically correct is an oxymoronic expression. Those who can influence (read media) should explicitly lay out the truth.
    1
  1869. Instead of vanishing incompetent leaders of the party are intent on varnishing…. Just saying. Tailpiece: The Nation is not even the in the horizon of INC schemes. A big fall from the decades of 40s, 50s and 60s. Makes us wonder whether those days were just an illusion.
    1
  1870.  @ojsimps701  me too!
    1
  1871. Oh! The Americans!
    1
  1872. I know the media always conducts itself for the Nation. But could the same concerns have been conveyed with some self esteem. The heading as given (for shock & awe) is grossly misplaced. The effect of the Aatmanirbhar initiatives to right the trade balance could also have been discussed in detail. Tailpiece: Whose Nation is it anyway?
    1
  1873. @ Did I say somewhere that Gujjus are doing right? Did I also say somewhere there there are enough jobs for Indians in India? Scammer stop this disiveness
    1
  1874.  @SameerPatra-ld1iu  haha..Sameer ... Did I say that the Gujjus were doing it right? If you are implying there are not enough jibs in India for Indians....You are damn well right...We never ever had enough... Gitta jeep trying....
    1
  1875. Hi Vir… it is simple… you just can’t say how much is enough. Talent and a sense for adventure can’t be confined in boundaries. Wonder why you should ask this Q ever….
    1
  1876. Presently, only the rain looks good for India!!!!
    1
  1877. As usual a different perspective to “news”…. Important indicators of international environment. But then so what? Are we formally viewing China as the enemy of rest of the World? Did I hear someone say “free world”. A bit complicated. Can the West stop China? Uhmmmm…. But India can (economically). Hence the Chinese pinpricks along the LOC. A distraction and threat - only a threat. China can’t get into a war situation with India. What we see is not what it is. Tailpiece: If the world continues to view China as the villain just because of their politics, we may be walking into the Chinese killing ground.
    1
  1878.  @PrashantBhardwaj13  Hear the opposition by all means. They should be heard when they make viable arguments. Let them discuss the issues sand not level unsubstantiated accusations at all and sundry. In this case 30+ adult MLAs of SS who are capable of forming their own views, have explained the reasons for rebelling. In response SS should be addressing those reasons and explain to the electorate whether the reasons are apt or not okay etc… Instead they resort to accusations like in this video.
    1
  1879.  @akashmihir84  No, I disagree. You have not got my point. No personalities please. That defeats my point. This is done across all media, not now but since decades.
    1
  1880. SG it is alright to discuss views of uniformed persons about warfare. My take. In this age of internet and digital media there are no secrets. The context has to be correct. A war, broadly, has two aims. 1. Defence. 2. Offence Defence is self-explanatory. There are two aspects to offence. 1. A deterrent 2. Occupation of territories. Equipping and strategies are different in each of these scenarios. The Russian invasion of Ukraine is for occupation of territory. India has a stated position of not occupying foreign territory (loosely said). Hence the “lessons” from the war and battles in Russia – Ukraine should be tempered. India strategies and equipping should be centered on defence on land, air and sea. Defence does have an element of offence but does not include conquering and occupation. Also, roughly three times more resources are required for offence than for Defence. Tailpiece: Let us not read too much into the lessons from Russia-Ukraine conflicts. Maybe we can learn from the efficiency of technologies employed on and off the battlefields. More specifically on those employed away from the battlefields.
    1
  1881.  @himanshuanshwani  Sure Himanshu. You may have a point. But let the courts decide the point of law.Meanwhile let us not make heroes of those who indulge in the Ds. They are all criminal activities to either blackmail or discredit or even terrorize and force the public into a particular line of thinking.
    1
  1882. It is true. Can humans ever be satisfied? The saying is that you can’t ever get a free lunch. Let us change the way we think.
    1
  1883. Understanding is not the problem. But when the opposition , read INC, refuse to understand the obvious and repeatedly flog the dead horse of “secularism” nothing will change. Just saying Ishtar or Allah does not deliver. Tailpiece: The issue is delivery…life and living
    1
  1884. He had / has more to offer! Travelled with him in economy class some time in the late 1990s.
    1
  1885. If our leaders feel anarchy is better than democracy, should we move to amend our constitution accordingly?
    1
  1886. You are doing somewhat ok. But pray, where is the exitement? In the media? I don't see any euphoria elsewhere. Besides these 5 aircrafts coming in is a process and not an end. So, please don't create artificial exitement like they do for a movie promo!!! These inductions (process) will be forever as long as we have hostile neighbours!
    1
  1887. Refreshing interview… frank and to the point DK and Poona,
    1
  1888. "India has been good at it, believe me.." SG. Yes. Spying has been part of statecraft from time immemorial. It provides valuable information which can win battles and wars – including the diplomatic types. The Arthashastra (I trust readers as familiar with the name, in the least) mentions using artists as spies to target another state. An extensive spy system is mandated by Chanakya (Kautilya) to maintain peace, law and order internally; and the use of clandestine services to create confusion within enemies and win wars against them. The secret agents were everywhere, both internally and externally; inside houses, in the city, in the countryside, forests, frontiers etc. They adopted a cover which was appropriate to the circumstances; 29 different types with 50 subtypes of covers have been mentioned in the Arthashastra. As a mark of Chanakya’s precision, the exact cover to be used is specified in more than a hundred places in the text. Such activities carried potential dangers. But, of course, we can never be complacent.
    1
  1889. A typical example of the following. All this talk of NO REAL consequence to anybody, except the media and some "opinionators" (if I may) who can "feel" they are doing something important. The real problem with democracy in India (also in all big democracies anywhere else in the world too) is, for good or bad, that elections are all about what we feel and not about what we think. The politicians and the media by their utterances channelize our feelings and not our thoughts. This reliance on feelings may be the undoing of liberal democracy in India and all over the world, which has even now degenerated into a puppet show controlled by emotional strings. The Governments, media and all other constitutional bodies are scared to tell the people to behave, especially in Pandemic times!!!! Tailpiece: Yuval Noah Harari says,".... feelings are not some divine qualities and they definitely do not reflect “free will”. I wonder where is democracy without thoughts.
    1
  1890. The two banes of Indian democracy are perennial elections and reservations, impeding homogenous and continuous development because the electorate vote from their heart and not from their head. Politics (part of everything, Shekhar) exploits this frailty.
    1
  1891.  @mthangzou5512 This is not the first case of snooping in the world or in India. A different tecnology is being used now, that is the only diferrence. If we have to live in a world with " What Ifs", nobody can help us. If we want democracy, we just will not get a system where one size fits all. We have to get along with all types. There never was a utopia and there never will be a utopia. We just got to find the best fit, and move on.
    1
  1892. Let us be honest instead of beating around the bush. Could J&K have progressed during the decades of misrule in the state by blatantly self serving politicians, largely ignored by the Central Government. Come on, give us Indians a break.
    1
  1893. Well! A panacea? The Armed Forces? If that is the role more have to be done for the Armed Forces during normal times; to prepare them to handle situations such as a pandemic!
    1
  1894. Is there a “The print” dynasty? Some fun!,,
    1
  1895. Additionally, the quality of FDI also matters. Any FDI that takes out more than it gives to the Indian economy is useless.
    1
  1896. Hey Shekar, Re trade with Russia for oil imports was snot to internationalise the rupee.. you know it we know it…So a wrong narrative probably used out of context to support your narrative on some other matter (it happens to everybody)…. Tailpiece: The Print standard is better. In fact it was a smart move by India to keep the oil flowing for you and us as normal as can be as cheap as it can be…. You missed that point
    1
  1897.  @Robertsmith001  yes, agree . China is not a democracy and let us be honest, that matters. Even US is keeping its nose above water because of lower population and greater resources. Per caita gdp $63453 against $2191of India with less than 1/3 rd the population. Africa is a Continent with many small countries. Where really is the comparison? I have lived in the US and in India and visited Africa and China. India is unique, believe me.
    1
  1898. The two states of TN and Kerala also went to polls. Could The Print cover how these two states coped with the pandemic in the second wave with State level actions? The Print Headlines for its video: "Rajasthan witnesses 10 times spike in Covid daily cases in one month" Rajasthan did not go to the polls this year. Just saying. Tell the people the real reason for the spread, which is improper COVID behavior. Save the Nation
    1
  1899. As usual a great logic. But are we to believe that if sacking Biren is a must, Modi and Sha do not realize if…..when you and me can see it? Is there something we don’t know., Tailpiece: when you do not consider elections….letting a crisis play thorough may bring lasting peace…. A weird logic I know…but a logic nevertheless less.
    1
  1900.  @sandeepshah105  yes, sandeep... Like in life... There is never easy money anywhere... People have to be more aware and take responsibility. Media lije the print too have a responsibility in putting part blame on individuals and not reference inconsequential tweets
    1
  1901. F&O is not a lottery. Rahul Gandhi has tweeted…. Come on Shekhar… you are better than this comment
    1
  1902. Haha! The Q should be who will win if the Parliament functions as it is supposed to be. Actually many MPs would not even know how the parliament should function. Either way the Nation is surely the loser (and the media a gainer? Just asking). Tailpiece. The Gen Z or whatever, must feel that this IS how parliaments function in vibrant democracies. The uncanny way controversies crop up just prior to Parliament sessions, I suppose, is a dead giveaway - since decades, I must add.
    1
  1903. A fair assessment. Not OK but OK. These are unprecedented times requiring unprecedented action. I place full faith in our system. I believe a logic has been rightly applied in clearing the vaccines. My request to media is to keep politics away from matters where it is NOT required. Like the ubiquitous potato in every curry, politics need not be an ingredient in every discussion.
    1
  1904. Should ThePrint show such a consternation when an Indian political party says ( with proof) that USAID is knowingly or unknowingly funding some anti India activities…? It is not earth shattering even if USA is a close partner in trade etc….
    1
  1905. Also, the World is angry with China and WHO because they could have carried out such studies and more long before the pandemic spread and informed the world. But they did not do it.
    1
  1906. All fine; People responsible (CEC, Parliament, Religious heads, Government?)should and could have acted earlier. But I wonder (am also aghast) why the ALL KNOWING MEDIA did not repeatedly warn the public about the dangers of attending the Kumbh and the political rallies? While blaming others be gracious to accept where you (media) have defaulted too.
    1
  1907.  @Cri-cater  I wonder, why INC does not realise this. INC is also a property of the Nation,... Etc... Etc...
    1
  1908. Pandora’s box….
    1
  1909. Cast(e)ing motives (unfortunately, not always misplaced) in political actions is another past time of us Indians and as an extension of the helpless(?) media. As long as we continue to cast(e) our votes instead of just voting, India will remain a LAGGARD DEMOCRACY. Tailpiece: It is for us, the people of India and the Indian media, to wake up to this reality. Caste based politics has not taken our Nation anywhere but backwards. Why don’t we just discuss economics? Roti, kappa , Makkan- isn’t that a common thread which will unite all?
    1
  1910. Oh yes.They needed a spokesperson?
    1
  1911.  @azeemsoona  True. They exploit because most wear religion on their sleeves. Keep religion private. "Religion" by itself is a misunderstood concept. Be less sensitive to religious issues. Then nobody will be exploited.
    1
  1912. Well analyzed Shekhar.
    1
  1913. संदिप मांडे yes. We’re they culprits, doing wrong, in both the instances? I thought SG said they put out the right study in the HCQ matter, with relevant Sydney data.(of course not trials)
    1
  1914. A bit confusing...did the three “Indians” default in both cases?
    1
  1915. A great presentation… Tailpiece: Maybe, just maybe, we now have a more pragmatic meaning of caste. Does it warrant a review here in India too? Just asking.
    1
  1916. This discussion on climate change effects and carbon emissions should have started soon after the II world war. All the “energy” spent towards nuclear weapons should have been used for energy generation. All the money spent on ICBMs etc. should have been used for research on generation of clean energy. And so on.. and so forth… Tail piece: Discussion on panels and TV by “experts” now will yield little result. People have to cut down on their wants. Governments, now do not have magic wands for creating solutions in a jiffy. Every citizen of this world will need to sacrifice and contribute towards the efforts.
    1
  1917. Why was INDIAN DEMOCRCY not discussed Zakaria? Hypocrisy? You can’t have a discussion on democracy without discussing India. Mark. my words
    1
  1918. Because he is Indian origin?
    1
  1919. It is time we divide the elected members of the houses as Governing members and co- governing members (now known as the opposition) so all the elected members know they have a responsibility to govern and some of them are elected NOT to only oppose anything and everything at the drop of a topi. Tailpiece: Whose people and whose Nation, anyway? The people are considered only as voters… unfortunate. Pathetic political drama
    1
  1920. Not in Defence, but in reality. The Language.....not a strong suit for many...he should have referred to the NGO rep as “NGO person” , I supposeI He surely had the jeans in mind and not the sex of the person, I suppose. Now twist it as you please... an example of where the media leads us
    1
  1921.  @niton3456  Natasha you said it... Boycot canada in India is different from celebrating the assassination of a democratically elected HOG of Canada... That is what the Democratically elected Government of Canada is also overlooking to the consternation of the free world. NOW you see the point, I hope.
    1
  1922.  @niton3456  point taken….but not about Canada but about another Nation…that up is the difference. That is where Canadian leadership is exposed. Think it over
    1
  1923. Ignore actors and concentrate on development. These “leaders” can’t contribute to development so not really important. Just saying.
    1
  1924. @Sooran Sooran, learning legacies, will help you realise that we are discussing a point in education system and not my "stupidity". Enjoy. Stay safe. Vanakkam.
    1
  1925. @Sooran Sooran, that is the point. India has its own legacies. Can learn ALL of them as sources of knowledge.. to include all INDIAN literary works.
    1
  1926. HT. I have said this earlier too. Watching this type of news presentation is torturous. For half the duration you kept saying Nirmala Sitaraman is hospitalized. During the latter half you repeatedly said she is fine. Why waste 2.5 minutes to say just this. You can as well say it in one frame. Bad journalism…. Sir/ Madam
    1
  1927. It is obvious that Mr Trudeau is NOT in control of his cabinet and parliament and as an extension has lost control of his Nation. Pathetic view of democracy and free speech by Canada… Are Canadians privy to all this? One wonders. How can one be part of a free worlds where criminals are given place in the par,iamb t and cessation activities against another democracy is openly permitted and abetted on its soil? Pathetic Canad and Canadians….pity them
    1
  1928. After so s so many many decades, are we still surprised about the nexus of terrorism on our West? Tailpiece: I heard some one say that Pak and China are coming “closer” because we are not cozying up to Pakistan. Ah!!!
    1
  1929. Deja Vu!!! Introspection and accountability….Nevr happen!!!!:)
    1
  1930. BBC needs to make sea changes in its work ethics to remain relevant in todays broadcasting ecosystem.
    1
  1931. I earn that there was a media house BBC in UK. True?
    1
  1932. Why do we lend credence to theses agenda based insinuations? There are internal mechanisms to address such issue of caste, religious and gender bias within our Nation. Probably, politicians in Pakistan, who do not enjoy real democracy, are not aware of such mechanisms here. Just saying.
    1
  1933. For Sunak to Captain the ship, later!
    1
  1934. A very annoying way of presenting news…. Ht May like to change to change the format. If not done I am shunning HT. Anybody else?
    1
  1935. Wonder why the media is going ballistic on a new British PM, taking office in difficult times for the Nation. Give him space to do a job. Tone down the rhetoric. Tailpiece: Media is important but so are very many other issues in a democracy.
    1
  1936. Agnipath. A unknown territory. We the people of India hope that the decision for “tour of duty” is deliberate with extensive brainstorming and active study by the Services HQ. We are a democracy and the elected Government has the right to shape the Armed Forces. We are here wading into unchartered waters which will have far reaching consequences for the sovereignty of India. Efficiency of the Armed Forces is not measured by pension bills; all the more so when Defence civilians take away more than 50% of the Defence pension outlay for less than 50% of veterans. Tailpiece: Does the Nation Nation have a right to the study after which this decision has been arrived. That, I suppose is an obligation by the Government to the people and a right of the electo
    1
  1937. Painful presentations HT, with absolutely no respect for readers’ intellect and precious time. Please change format to be more relevant and quick in your presentations. Thank you.
    1
  1938. The MOST powerful weapon of HAMAS are the civilians…..not their arsenal. If only the terrorists were not among the dense civilian population, it would have taken just one day to annihilate the, do not be mistaken by them, I mean HAMAS and Not repeat NOT Palestines. Tailpiece: Media should get its narrative correct…
    1
  1939. Does that means Congress is united now? I wonder why some senior leaders fool twelves too while fooling the Nation. The etching is on the wall. We can’t have a opposition of regional parties catering to parochial interests. Even a non initiated guy like me know that it is time for the Gandhis and Wadras to go. If not for the congress at least in the interest of the Nation and all Indians. Tailpiece: Never imagined that the wool can be permanent enough to permanently blind senior leaders.
    1
  1940. Will the WTO be buried? So many unilateral trade decisions these days. Just asking.
    1
  1941. Wall street journal has always been more about hype and less about truth. The hypocrisy is being unraveled as there are plenty of other sources for authentic news and those who were being unfairly targeted by Wall Street, now speak for themselves.
    1
  1942. I don’t understand…Are the police to just stand aside let the rioters run riot ?
    1
  1943. It is really amazing that somebody wants to be in the British PM’s slippers.
    1
  1944. Humbug. At this stage a delay of a few weeks is not going to make any difference in anything at all. Such expert opinions have no substance. It is not as if the enemy is forming up to attack. The changes etc are ongoing and, in Defence, there is always a hierarchy who ensure that such ongoing work never stops. Tailpiece: The media “experts” should not throw such non issues at an unsuspecting public. Moreover the CDS does not oversee any active Command.
    1
  1945. Wonder why the media is going ballistic on a new British PM, taking office in difficult times for the Nation. Give him space to do a job. Tone down the rhetoric. Tailpiece: Media is important but so are very many other issues in a democracy
    1
  1946. A pathetic way to present news
    1
  1947. Oh oh! Don’t worry, it is just freedom of speech practiced in Canada… a leading democratic state… except that these Canadian Nationals are targeting another sovereign state and not their own Nation, Canada. Haha! So free as free can be… Canada? Tailpiece: Funny democracy this
    1
  1948. Pathetic and time wasting way to present news
    1
  1949. Are they not Hindu deities, to say it correctly. Just asking
    1
  1950. INC’s reaction reminds me of the story of the ostrich which when encountered with danger buries it’s head in the sand and hopes the danger will pass by. Tailpiece: Yes the Nation needs a strong “opposition” … not in words but in deeds. I hope the INC during its course of agitations against the price rise etc., also tell us what has led to the price rise and recommended actins to curb the same.
    1
  1951. Is it absolutely necessary to react to everything Pakistan says in regard to India. Most times mere silence (ignoring) is enough to convey thoughts. Tailpiece: Pakistan, most times, uses India to fight internal problems, just by way of distraction. Let us not play their game and waste our time. Media should also recognize this.
    1
  1952. The opposition have to talk about food on the table and not on abstracts like non existent “vichar dara” (VD). VD is passe’. Tailpiece: Come on wake up and fight the reality and NOT apparitions.
    1
  1953. 😅
    1
  1954. The incident in Mon, is unfortunate and regrettable. The families of the victims should be cared for. The inquiry should not stop with the elite Army Unit, which has an exemplary record of operations and can’t be expected to kill civilians on purpose. Let me explain. The issue is more than that meets the eye. It has been more than seven decades since India is an independent Nation. In many areas in the North and North East the Indian Army has been entrusted with the responsibility of containing the insurgents. An unacceptable situation in a democracy, which clearly indicates that the democratic and diplomatic processes have not been employed efficiently by the elected Governments. The Nation can’t expect the Armed Forces to do that job ad nauseum. The responsibility for this unfortunate and regrettable incident lies even outside of the Army unit. Tail piece: While we have a bureaucracy with immense authority and no responsibility, we expect the Armed Forces to be responsible without authority. Let us accept that AFSPA is a sham as it provides no authority and very little protection to Armed Forces – remember they are dealing with their own country men as opposed to what they are trained to do on the battlefield.
    1
  1955. Great. It makes me wonder what were the “people” (the society) doing in Manipur during the despicable act by a crowd? Balme everybody in the world. But blame the society and the people of Manipuri too for not Thrashing the perpetrator but taking videos and cheering. Does anybody feel we the people are beyond reproach for such despicable acts in society. Tailpiece. There is lies a truth we feel that all odiferous us beyond blame for the ills in society whereas we should be the ones at the forefront to prevent such acts.
    1
  1956. Same story. Different roles, different centuries. Tail piece: Irony! Deja Vu! What is it? Your call, Home Secretary.
    1
  1957. This is a counter by India for its actions elsewhere. A clever, thought out strategic move. Note the statement by USA. “We treat both Pak and India as partners not inter-related”. So,India is also free to treat any countries as partners just like we treat the USA. The F16 help by USA does not change anything significantly for India. A well thought out mating move by India.
    1
  1958. Zara Hatke. I am reminded of a Shakespearean comedy " Much ado about nothing" India is a vibrant and super active democracy. Anything and everything that happens in this Nation will have a political hue. Ask the media stalwarts, they feed on it. The ruling party as well as the opposition will constantly play games with people’s sentiments. That is the lot for Indian democracy. Yes, finally the people will choose. That is another story. Sentiment is a type of illness, a medical condition. Like the ember it will create fire when fanned and die away when no attention is paid to it. So, with this issue of Parliament inauguration and many, many such matters in our chequered journey since Independence. Memory is short-lived, whether of the people or political parties who will oppose a matter while out of power which they had advocated when in power. The Nation sees all this like watching a soap opera. This new parliament thing is but another such instance of political play with sentiments. The Nation will move on. Parliament will function in its new place. Governments will come and governments will go, the soap opera will roll on. Whatever; there is a new India, which hopefully have realized this hollow games of the political dispensations. The New India will move on. It HAS to move on with the new parliament building, to survive. Forward Ho!
    1
  1959. This habit of wearing your religion on your sleeves should be curbed; especially in “secular” India (Bharat). Tailpiece: Freedom IN religion should precede freedom OF religion.
    1
  1960. Pathetic and irritating way to present new as as only HT can
    1
  1961. Do these photo op farewell etc.absolve the gruesome acts of the terrorists on 7 Oct? Will all that be forgotten? Just wondering
    1
  1962. This had to happen. Because, without India Pakistan will be a non entity. Tail piece: Mr. SS, the TV channels do not govern India.
    1
  1963. A hundreds of years ago when “visa” overstayers in India a Nation of people were enslaved. We, Indians are a lot better, and assure the Home Secretary of ,Britain, we will not enslave the British Nation. Tailpiece: A preposterous statement. God help Britain.
    1
  1964. Why make the statement at all? Who advices him? Pathetic public utterances. Earnestly hope the INC gets its act together fast. Democracy is not only asking others to act but to activate oneself too in the right direction. Tailpiece: I wonder why the “chintan shivir” does not see the writing on the wall. It is there in big BOLD letters for all to see. Congress can yet keep the remaining good will by changing the leadership… and the LOP too.
    1
  1965. Forever introspection…. Who really introspects? Just asking
    1
  1966. Whither Secularism, tolerance erc... Just asking
    1
  1967. Zara Hatke. I am reminded of a Shakespearean comedy " Much ado about nothing" India is a vibrant and super active democracy. Anything and everything that happens in this Nation will have a political hue. Ask the media stalwarts, they feed on it. The ruling party as well as the opposition will constantly play games with people’s sentiments. That is the lot for Indian democracy. Yes, finally the people will choose. That is another story. Sentiment is a type of illness, a medical condition. Like the ember it will create fire when fanned and die away when no attention is paid to it. So, with this issue of Parliament inauguration and many, many such matters in our chequered journey since Independence. Memory is short-lived, whether of the people or political parties who will oppose a matter while out of power which they had advocated when in power. The Nation sees all this like watching a soap opera. This new parliament thing is but another such instance of political play with sentiments. The Nation will move on. Parliament will function in its new place. Governments will come and governments will go, the soap opera will roll on. Whatever; there is a new India, which hopefully have realized this hollow games of the political dispensations. The New India will move on. It HAS to move on with the new parliament building, to survive. Forward Ho!
    1
  1968. The need for leadership changes in Congress party (for God’s sake, it is our Nation which requires an erudite opposition). Just saying. Tailpiece: Is there a more obvious signal than “the writing on the wall”? After all whose Nation is it anyway
    1
  1969. I hope these women are not intimidated on the quiet.
    1
  1970. Sonia Gandhi leads. As “leader” of the main opposition. Tailpiece: There have been over 500 such skirmishes and seventeen major actions (including 1962) along the LAC since 1947. Just saying.
    1
  1971. Wonder why much ado about mutter. Just a matter of mutter in the pods and not missiles!!!
    1
  1972. And seriously If the Hindu - Muslim divide in politics (let us not beat around the bush) is referred as polarization…we may be barking up the wrong tree. The divide is because of religion and not politics. And we as a society, the self styled experts, the MEDIA and all those good samaritans are afraid to address head on. We as a society must learn to live peacefully so that vested interest do not exploit us. Tailpiece. Change the narrative.
    1
  1973. The need for leadership changes in Congress party (for God’s sake, it is our Nation which requires an erudite opposition). Just saying. Tailpiece: Is there a more obvious signal than “the writing on the wall”? After all whose Nation is it anyway
    1
  1974. Why fight India? What has India done to Canada except further it’s economy? Just askig
    1
  1975. The need for leadership changes in Congress party (for God’s sake, it is our Nation which requires an erudite opposition). Just saying. Tailpiece: Is there a more obvious signal than “the writing on the wall”? After all whose Nation is it anyway
    1
  1976. Absolutely right about “Genocide”…. Unacceptable statements from the Presidents of the Universities,threatening is alright and only execution is punishable... . By the same token what do you do to people who call for blowing up flights and destroying Parliament buildings of democracies etc…. In the Western media, please do not practice hypocrisy.
    1
  1977. So, the requirement is to blame and not solve?
    1
  1978. Has NBC verified the HAMAS claims? Also, if the HAMAS laid down arms….there will be no more suffering in the GAZA strip…. Possible?
    1
  1979. It hostages “release” is played out in the media like an OTT serial..
    1
  1980. Uhmmm… Indians getting back at West… so….. a counterattack by US, tilting at windmills a la Don Quixote . Tailpiece: I wonder why RSS statement of Not digging up mosques for idols” is not given the traction it deserves in the media. Build on it for harmony…I mean on the statement and on on the mosque!!!!!:)
    1
  1981. In the frenzy to defend the agitators and public property damages, the media, AS USUAL ( thinking that they are the only defenders of free speech and democracy), are considering it as more important than defending the sovereignty of India. While the aenipath is a super programme for better distribution of wealth and empowering the youth who other wise may have languished ( they get a degree, possible skill set and 15-20 lakh by age 26). So some on, the media should concentrate on sending the agitators (who are once again exploited by interested middlemen) back home. Tailpiece: Don’t for God’s sake glorify agitations.
    1
  1982. True. Yes, all affected countries should make noise. Well done Palki.
    1
  1983. It is what the Chinese media does not report when India says it will defend all disputed territories…. Nothing much to read in it., really.
    1
  1984. Yet the congress has won one state and is second in two states…Do we get a two party democracy at National level ….hopefully..Google for Bharat… Tailpiece: Time for the “Gandhi to take a real backseat…. India hopes
    1
  1985. I have been hearing this for more than 10 decades in India. Before every reform some sections of the media, self styled experts and after the advent of the digit media anybody and everybody asking the question “Is. India ready….”. It because of this very unfounded doubt India has been labeled a “laggard democracy” and China, Japan, Korea etc sped past us in the past decades. And I a septuagenarian watched helplessly all this from the sidelines. Now, India has resolved to move ahead and try and catch up with the world. For God’s sake do not start this question “Is India ready….” Else it will be a case of waiting for Godot. At least let the next generation benefit from progress and development. Tailpiece: There was, is or will be an ideal time for anything.
    1
  1986. In other words spying on the spy ship? Just asking.
    1
  1987. Should we celebrate or ignore? Shahid Afridi also praises India once in a while. Just saying
    1
  1988.  @burebista11  A competition can't be violative of federal regulations. Human rights is not a preserve of only a few humans and can't be exercised in violation of other fellow humans’ rights- in this instance those who have a right not to contract the virus - prowess in a sport notwithstanding.
    1
  1989.  @burebista11  National regulations overrides ATP erc..., regulations. Regulations of Sports bodies in any country or international bodies should conform to federal regulations of tournament conducting Nations. Simple logic.
    1
  1990. India can ford the rough waters. It is time this Nation thinks at another level.
    1
  1991. In regard to the cyber attacks on Ukraine, Secretary Austin says, NATO elements have not been attacked, so no action. So when Russia invades Ukraine, it is not an attack on NATO. I am a bit confused.
    1
  1992.  @control4050  donot lose hope... Hope for a homogenous INC and efficient governance for five years. Enjoy
    1
  1993. Buying oil from Russia and Defence spares from Ukraine is neutral. Just saying.
    1
  1994. How about all the development work and policy changes? Don’t they figure in the Brand?
    1
  1995. Unfortunate. Shocking. Tragic. Heartfelt condolences to all family and friends of the departed soldiers.
    1
  1996. You can’t implement sanctions beyond a point without inflicting damage to self and others. Well and there is more…. Why is Ukraine in this predicament at all? No discussions on that?
    1
  1997. Young leaders,partying is a good scandal for a Nation than old leaders doing illegal and immoral stuff. Just saying.
    1
  1998. It is time the Western media stepped down from the high pedestal they have played themselves. The attack on the Capitol also does not support their cause of projecting superiority.
    1
  1999. Wonder how voting to suspend immediate military operations in Ukraine is a vote for or against Russia and / or Ukraine. Unlike the computer world The real world is more than binaries.
    1
  2000. Great. It makes me wonder what were the “people” (the society) doing in Manipur during the despicable act by a crowd? Balme everybody in the world. But blame the society and the people of Manipuri too for not Thrashing the perpetrator but taking videos and cheering. Does anybody feel we the people are beyond reproach for such despicable acts in society. Tailpiece. There is lies a truth we feel that all odiferous us beyond blame for the ills in society whereas we should be the ones at the forefront to prevent such acts.
    1
  2001. Throughout the 75 years of I dependence, under various Governments, there always were sections of society and regions pan India who were marginalized dissatisfied. They were not widely publicized in the absence of a medium like the electronic media. So much for change in whatever. So JODO seems to be something like Trump’s sham MAGA movement in the US. Tailpiece: Internal political shenanigans, plays and counter-plays do not reflect the status of a Nation. Wish the mainstream media were more honest.
    1
  2002. It is sad that the hostages “release” is played out in the media like an OTT serial.. season 2?
    1
  2003.  @MrWannabeartist  He left last time because of a cocktail party?
    1
  2004. Politics to the power of 2 in Maharashtra….
    1
  2005.  @imgood6535  oh Good. Why not? :)
    1
  2006.  @Cinematic_trendz  yeah... To get my view through for whatever its worth:)
    1
  2007. Protocols are different on different occasions in the world. The USA has a place in the World which is not compromised. Being civil and courteous and not blowing own trumpet could exemplify America’s greatness rather than riding rough shod like in the make believe Western folks. Tailpiece: Respect to the POTUS and the First Lady and the USA. Way to go. Nothing is diminished.
    1
  2008. Levy, the feeling has to be mutual. Try it
    1
  2009. Practice free and fair journalism
    1
  2010. Does Pro Palestine also mean Pro HAMAS? Just asking
    1
  2011. You talk of Wester media being partial….what are you doing? Tailpiece: Do what you preach….call out the terrorists
    1
  2012. No brainer…HAMAS who started it here and Iran who supports it to the hilt should pay for all damages… without doubt
    1
  2013. It is the way of existence that anything artificial is bad for natural processes, including all medicines which suppress symptoms and offer only temporary relief. Anything artificial is not foolproof and is “effective” for limited periods. These synthetic medicines and processes are partly destructive too because of side effects and varying action on different genetics. But waiting for natural processes to take effect to curb pandemics will be more destructive in terms to human lives and the economy, so essential for existence. Some vaccines, over a period extending to decades, have managed to curb diseases – polio, cholera etc… Civilisations over ages have made different choices (like farming instead of gathering and hunting, settlements instead of wandering, wars instead of peace, conquests instead of negotiations, travel and trade, use of nuclear energy for destruction etc..) which have had positive as well as negative effects on humanity. Vaccination against COVID is just one more decision to be made for posterity.
    1
  2014.  @gravel7614  uhmm.... I believe he was not allowed to execute his plans, so he quit. Plausible . He will now return as PM and carry out the plan. Good for Britain, may be.
    1
  2015. Rishi for PM is following a path much like the Indian victory over Pakistan yesterday, in a group match of the ongoing T20 World Cup - From a point of no rerun, so to speak. Could be the best bet for British economy, hopefully.
    1
  2016. This discussion on climate change effects and carbon emissions should have started soon after the II world war. All the “energy” spent towards nuclear weapons should have been used for energy generation. All the money spent on ICBMs etc. should have been used for research on generation of clean energy. And so on.. and so forth… Tail piece: Discussion on panels and TV by “experts” now will yield little result. People have to cut down on their wants. Governments, now do not have magic wands for creating solutions in a jiffy. Every citizen of this world will need to sacrifice and contribute towards the efforts.
    1
  2017. The USA prefer some autocrats and not some others…. Why?
    1
  2018. I have never seen the following "unbiased" reporting on your channel!!!! On my way from the airport on 26 Dec 2020, after spending over an in the USA, and seeing the plight of NY area in person, I was appalled by how the people in our country were taking it easy. It was as if nothing had changed since I left India in September 2019. All shops open. 50% were not wearing a mask, 30% were wearing it on their chin. Later in the week, out to buy rations, when I asked my vegetable shop fellow why he was not wearing a mask, he replied “Corona has gone, so why wear a mask?”. It was not as if the administration had said so. Because, on the same day while we were driving in our own vehicle, with closed windows and ac on, my wife and I were fined Rs 350/- for not wearing masks inside the car – I was told that it was mandatory. Tailpiece: The problem in our country is not the rules. It is the implementation of the rules by an inadequate, overworked police and paramilitary on a people whose standards self-discipline is abysmal. Let us admit it and strive to improve. I request the media too to highlight this aspect. This is not a cricket match; statistics in a pandemic are just that; just some numbers. Get real
    1
  2019. The ‘hum do, hamare do’ slogan has made a comeback as the country is today run by just four people, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi said in the Lok Sabha Thursday.” Not a political comment but simple arithmetic: The situation is four times better than being run by one (wo)man. Infinitely better than being run by a nobody. Tail piece: A view of “We the people”.. Let the parliament discuss the farm laws in the house clause by clause. Invite the farm “leaders” to attend the proceedings from the gallery. Live stream the discussions.
    1
  2020. Know this, the names of parties and politicians do not matter in the least. We will travel a blinkered path as long as long as people who work for a living are outnumbered by those who vote for a living. “We the people” have to get out of this rut. The general perception is that corruption always involves money. Even if all political parties dishonestly take Rs. 10,000 crores per year from the exchequer, it will not make any significant difference in progress or development. What hurts most is that all political parties are ethically corrupt and they carry practice into matters of governance as well. The modus operandi is not important to the point being made here. Also there is not enough place here to discuss the kaleidoscopic overt and covert unethical practices of these parties. The politicians and the media by their utterances channelize our feelings and not our thoughts. This exploitation of feelings may sound the death knell of liberal democracy in India and all over the world. Democracies are but a puppet show where the people are controlled by emotional strings. Feelings are not cosmic powers. They surely do not reflect “free will”. Tailpiece: In the wake of the aforesaid, the role played by the media in democracies is also suspect. You see, Caesar's wife has to be above suspicion. Is SHE?
    1
  2021. The incident in Mon, is unfortunate and regrettable. The families of the victims should be cared for. The inquiry should not stop with the elite Army Unit, which has an exemplary record of operations and can’t be expected to kill civilians on purpose. Let me explain. The issue is more than that meets the eye. It has been more than seven decades since India is an independent Nation. In many areas in the North and North East the Indian Army has been entrusted with the responsibility of containing the insurgents. An unacceptable situation in a democracy, which clearly indicates that the democratic and diplomatic processes have not been employed efficiently by the elected Governments. The Nation can’t expect the Armed Forces to do that job ad nauseum. The responsibility for this unfortunate and regrettable incident lies even outside of the Army unit. Tail piece: While we have a bureaucracy with immense authority and no responsibility, we expect the Armed Forces to be responsible without authority. Let us accept that AFSPA is a sham as it provides no authority and very little protection to Armed Forces – remember they are dealing with their own country men as opposed to what they are trained to do on the battlefield.
    1
  2022. On my way from the airport on 26 Dec 2020, after spending over an in the USA, and seeing the plight of NY area in person, I was appalled by how the people in our country were taking it easy. It was as if nothing had changed since I left India in September 2019. All shops open. 50% were not wearing a mask, 30% were wearing it on their chin. Later in the week, out to buy rations, when I asked my vegetable shop fellow why he was not wearing a mask, he replied “Corona has gone, so why wear a mask?”. It was not as if the administration had said so. Because, on the same day while we were driving in our own vehicle, with closed windows and ac on, my wife and I were fined Rs 350/- for not wearing masks inside the car – I was told that it was mandatory. Tailpiece: The problem in our country is not the rules. It is the implementation of the rules by an inadequate, overworked police and paramilitary on a people whose standards self-discipline is abysmal. Let us admit it and strive to improve. I request the media too to highlight this aspect. This is not a cricket match; statistics in a pandemic are just that; just some numbers. Get real
    1
  2023. Very briefly and loosely, only as an indicator to channelize your thoughts, who could have done what to prevent a surge in COVID cases? Let us take e brief look. 1. Constitutional authorities could have taken Suo moto cognizance at various stages and ordered a) rescinding polls b) introduction of lockdown c) Cancelling religious congregations d) closure of cinema halls or whatever, if they felt (not as an afterthought) any actions that could have prevented the spread of COVID. 2. Central government could have postponed elections and introduced Governors’ rule in the states due for a change of legislature. (I am not sure how this is possible; may be the parliament could have done it) 3. The oppositions parties could have demanded postponement of elections and introduction of Governors’ rule in the states due for a change of legislature. (I am not sure how this is possible; may be the parliament could have done it) 4. The media could have started a Nationwide discussion on postponement of elections and cancellation of the Kumbh. They did not do it though these were well within their capability and responsibility. 5. The hospitals (hats off to them, they are doing yeomen service) could have foreseen the requirement of remdesivir and oxygen and placed orders accordingly well in advance (say two months back) in their normal supply chain. 6. PILs could have been initiated for all or any of the above and more… 7. So many people could have done so many different things….. But none of these happened. It is a pandemic, not an epidemic or common flu. Things that will move the needle the most—are things that past events give us little to no guide about, when a viral pandemic is mutating fast and tomorrow it may mutate faster than the speed of light (figuratively) and be able to travel in the air. Hopefully it will not come to that and humanity will survive this pandemic. There will be unprecedented events. Their unprecedented nature means we won’t be prepared for them, which is part of what makes them so impactful. The choice is between a rock and a hard place - lives or livelihoods; both are important and both if not saved case destruction. What is your choice? Tailpiece: Anybody can be wise in hindsight. We the people expect maturity, calmness responsible behaviour from the media and all other pillars of democracy.
    1
  2024.  @ht5389  HT, you have misunderstood. My point is that you have no information to say that I form my views reading fake media. That I object and call it ignorance. Enjoy.
    1
  2025.  @ht5389  Gimme a second please. I get your point. But all the programmes you have cited are welfare schemes and do not relate to bettering the economy. My point is simple. A great bowler like Jasprit Bumrah is made the Captain of the Indian cricket team. While doing that the BCCI tells him “the manger will take all decisions and you will not bowl”. How do we then expect JB to lead the the team and perform? JB will still remain a great bowler. So was MM Singh under UPA. Enjoy.
    1
  2026.  @Chris_1979  Sure Darwin. . There is a world of difference between an idea and a deed . And don't ever forget the perpetual red numbers in the OMCs, not reflected in the budget but helped the economy . THAT is no great econimics. Is it?
    1
  2027.  @rakesharamaiah2737  uhmmmm... If you say so, Rakesh. Enjoy.
    1
  2028. Over thirty top companies of the World with a net value of over a trillion dolars are led by Infdian origin CEOs. Given the circustance, capabilities of Indians to achieve is beyond doubt. India is changing fast these days, WITH SUCH OPPORTUNITIES hopefully being facilitated in our country after many decades of decadence. My appeal to the Indian “Opposition” political parties is that for your dynastic, sectorial, parochial, power mongering agenda, do not muddy the waters with a “fight” against nonexistent apparitions of ideology and “threat to democracy”. We Indians are aware that you are aware , but are blinded by lust for power. Do not upset the banana cart – be more erudite and fight on the platform of development and progress. Tailpiece: Humanity has tried for millennia and failed to serve the right food for the soul of the people through religions etc…. concentrate on getting the food on the dinner table. With governments in more than half the federal states from parties other than one in the centre, democracy in India is flourishing. Your (opposition) recent meet is another instance of free speech and expression.
    1
  2029.  @raghuarmani8341  uhmmm…I am not sure “under” UPA. Records say other wise, demonetisation notwithstanding.
    1
  2030. Has any of the “victims” submitted their phones for forensic examination? They could give it to a court and demand action. At least one of the “eighty” should do it. Let us not have one more cat and mouse game.
    1
  2031. Haha! A non statement again from a “leader”. I suppose, Mr. Yogendra, like a universal leader he says he is, should read the riot act to all sections of the society. Tolerance etc. is not a one way street. Tolerating intolerance is not tolerance. Tolerance, for instance is also, respecting the way each prays ( idol or no idol) and proclaim ing it; tolerance is also, for instance, accepting that all Gods are equal and proclaiming it…. Tailpiece. Does NDTV have any comment on my comment. It is not about Muslims. It is about Islam.
    1
  2032. And one more point….. the great thing about the laggard Indian democracy is that for every good leader you get an equally good misleader. Validates Newton’s first law of motion.
    1
  2033. The whole pandemic has nothing whatsoever to do with religion; any congregation is a superspreader including rallies, Kumbh etc... This congregations have more to do with people and liberal democracy than anything else. To put matters in perspective. India is a Nation with a population of 13664 lakhs; USA 3282 lakhs (all 2019 figures given here only for comparison). Per capita GDP (IMF data), USA $68319; India $2191. Total Covid Cases USA: 33,452,985:: India: 22,295,911: Total deaths: USA 595,587 India: 242,398 (COVID info from worldometer.info) I am not even talking percentages here. I wonder what Lancet and experts have to say about the high percentage of infections and deaths in the USA, Europe, UK and such advanced Western countries. As per today’s statistics you are 12.5 times more likely to die living in the USA, Europe or UK than in India. It is but natural to blame the Governments for everything in a democracy. But the nature of the spread of the virus in India really tells another story. Let us not miss the wood for the trees Regards
    1
  2034. The medical fraternity are doing a yeomen service despite reduced resources - but then It is a war; as always resources are inadequate in a war. It is a pandemic - a strong and unpredictable enemy.
    1
  2035. Please remember it is a PANDEMIC All day long the media is only showing--- hospitals full of patients, disadvantaged families, helpless families roaming around, suffering from hunger, dying people, burning pyres etc. This doesn't in any way conceivable help if fighting the Virus. It only creates fear among healthy and willing workers and makes them sick.. We all know that there is a PANDEMIC going on, we also know that it is enough to say that there is no control over the situation - and nobody knows what's the right decision!! NO country in the world small or big have taken correct decisions to fight the virus. The active cases in the USA today are more than in India. Not even Dr. Faucci, who I have been following since March last year (when I was in the USA) knows exactly what will happen. He has said so to the Senate panel in the USA in no unequivocal terms.
    1
  2036. Please do not decry democracy without sufficient reason. An extract from the judgement in Disha Ravi’s case as published in sections of media… “…It is not mere engagement with persons of dubious credentials which is indictable rather it is the purpose of engagement which is relevant for the purpose of deciding culpability…” When there is a suspicion, as in this case where DR contacted persons of dubious credentials ( as established by the state) and tried to conceal her identity, there is always a case for investigation as to the purpose. We can’t say that such matters should not be investigated. In this case democratic ways as laid down was followed. Taking into custody, the courts, bail etc. is a process of investigation in a real democracy. So once again, please do not decry our democracy. Disclaimer: I believe in the innocence of Disha Ravi. But more than that I believe in the process of investigation, which is absolutely necessary here, is a democratic process. Tail piece: I want to believe Justice will prevail. When one attempts the extra ordinary, it is but natural to encounter the extra ordinary.
    1
  2037. In a federal democracy the buck has many stops: Parliament, Judiciary, Government, Opposition, States; In the case of an unprecedented PANDEMIC it also stops at , the scientific and medical fraternity, hospitals and not in the least at "We the people". Tailpiece: Blame game is not the way to go for the opposition. It will be seen as exploiting the people's suffering that goes with any Pandemic.
    1
  2038. Every point raised does not point to expertise on economy or religion…. Unfortunate
    1
  2039. This discussion on climate change effects and carbon emissions should have started soon after the II world war. All the “energy” spent towards nuclear weapons should have been used for energy generation. All the money spent on ICBMs etc. should have been used for research on generation of clean energy. And so on.. and so forth… Tail piece: Discussion on panels and TV by “experts” now will yield little result. People have to cut down on their wants. Governments, now do not have magic wands for creating solutions in a jiffy. Every citizen of this world will need to sacrifice and contribute towards the efforts.
    1
  2040. This discussion on climate change effects and carbon emissions should have started soon after the II world war. All the “energy” spent towards nuclear weapons should have been used for energy generation. All the money spent on ICBMs etc. should have been used for research on generation of clean energy. And so on.. and so forth… Tail piece: Discussion on panels and TV by “experts” now will yield little result. People have to cut down on their wants. Governments, now do not have magic wands for creating solutions in a jiffy. Every citizen of this world will need to sacrifice and contribute towards the efforts.
    1
  2041. Great. It makes me wonder what were the “people” (the society) doing in Manipur during the despicable act by a crowd? Balme everybody in the world. But blame the society and the people of Manipur too for not "thrashing" the perpetrator but taking videos and cheering. Does anybody feel we the people" are beyond reproach for such despicable acts in society. Tailpiece. Therein lies a truth that feel that all of us are the people are beyond blame for the ills in society whereas we should be the ones at the forefront to prevent such acts. Media should not shield the society.
    1
  2042. That does not suggest a fresh approach. Tailpiece: I suggest that the new President of INC Walkman unbeaten Ptah of progress, development, education,infrastructure, jobs etc rather than flog the “dead horse” of fascism,secularism, Nationalism etc… India has progressed beyond trivialities while the INC was reorganizing. This is not a political,statement but a statement for development.
    1
  2043. It is constitutionally, electorally, politically and morally ( Rey important) for any citizen of India to hold any office following the laid down procedures for selection or election. All discussion on such matters are by those who have nefarious aim towards power or are incompetent to hold power and have failed in the process of selection / election. Just saying. Tailpiece: There are more worthwhile matters on National importance for discussion by its leaders. For heavens sake, do not compare India with Nations who are less in size (geographically and in population) than many of its federal states. Grow up
    1
  2044. Two brave hearts…. Rishi Sunak taking over as PM, when he did and David C taking over as FS now,,,, For the Nation..both… take a bow.
    1
  2045. Dear CNN18, The political angle is all too apparent. No surprise at all. This will,pass. But what about the distorted version of history being taught in our schools? Any take on it, if you will. Tailpiece: Address real,issues.
    1
  2046. Childish. … As political parties DMK is no different from BJP. 1. DMK thrives on a platform of ethnic identity whole the BJP is rejuvenating the Bhartiya identity 2. Both seem to have alienated a part of their respective electorate 3. Both recall from old literature 4. Both are good administrators – recent chess Olympiad and foreign… conducted by DMK were as efficient as the G20 functions organized by the BJP. 5. Both are keen on development, progress and delivery to the needy The DMK should welcome BJP as the main opposition in TN, to start with. It will be good for democracy. DMK will be a good oppos ition at the National level… yes, for that they got to first learn Hindi alright. A small price to pay to lay at the National level.
    1
  2047. I am wondering why a lot of us common folk, experts, media, commentators, political party leaders and functionaries et al, waste a lot of time on non issues. For instance, take this matter of inaugurating the mew parliament building so essential for a growing, demographically and economically, India to progress from a laggard to moving democracy. Consider this: 1. The President is Head of State 2. The PM is the head of the government 3. The legislatures, physically and metaphorically, is the seat / function of the government and NOT of the state. 4. All MPs (RS & LS) dispense their duties in the name of the GOI and not in behalf of the State or party. So, all elected members irrespective of parties are part of the government. 5. I wonder why then PM should not inaugurate functions related to the government as was done ( or as has been the practice with precedence, as they say in law) by previous PMs, in connection with physical and metaphorical Parliamentary affairs. Nonpolitically yours
    1
  2048. Has any of the “victims” submitted their phones for forensic examination? They could give it to a court and demand action. At least one of the “eighty” should do it. Let us not have one more cat and mouse game.
    1
  2049. All said and done, The “Ram Mandir” in Ayodhya will be a boost to the hospitality, travel and tourism industries while boosting the State and local economy.
    1
  2050. You can’t increase wealth by dividing it. If major part of what one earns is taken away and given to those who do not work,,, one day no one will be working in the Nation. Deng Xioping of China realized this in the late 1980s and took China away from socialist economy and Mao philosophy towards capitalism and free market. The results are there for the world to see. Tailpiece: Astounded by kindergartenish statements fro INC and its cohorts
    1
  2051. It is constitutionally, electorally, politically and morally ( Rey important) for any citizen of India to hold any office following the laid down procedures for selection or election. All discussion on such matters are by those who have nefarious aim towards power or are incompetent to hold power and have failed in the process of selection / election. Just saying. Tailpiece: There are more worthwhile matters on National importance for discussion by its leaders. For heavens sake, do not compare India with Nations who are less in size (geographically and in population) than many of its federal states. Grow up.
    1
  2052. Wonder why give credibility to a corrupt politician like raja..Ignore him ahis igorant histrionics
    1
  2053. Please remember it is a PANDEMIC All day long the media is only showing--- hospitals full of patients, disadvantaged families, helpless families roaming around, suffering from hunger, dying people, burning pyres etc. This doesn't in any way conceivable help if fighting the Virus. It only creates fear among healthy and willing workers and makes them sick.. We all know that there is a PANDEMIC going on, we also know that it is enough to say that there is no control over the situation - and nobody knows what's the right decision!! NO country in the world small or big have taken correct decisions to fight the virus. The active cases in the USA today are more than in India. Not even Dr. Faucci, who I have been following since March last year (when I was in the USA) knows exactly what will happen. He has said so to the Senate panel in the USA in no unequivocal terms.
    1
  2054. That does not suggest a fresh approach. Tailpiece: I suggest that the new President of INC Walks an unbeaten Path of progress, development, education,infrastructure, jobs etc rather than flog the “dead horse” of fascism,secularism, Nationalism etc… India has progressed beyond trivialities while the INC was reorganizing. This is not a political,statement but a statement for development.
    1
  2055. It is time we divide the elected members of the houses as Governing members and co- governing members (ow know as the opposition) so the all elected members know they have a responsibility to govern and some of them are elected NOT only to oppose at the drop of a topi. Tailpiece: Whose people and whose Nation, anyway? The people are considered only as voters… unfortunate. Pathetic political drama
    1
  2056. The present Government visualized a future, planned the facility and supervised its construction while the opposition opposed its making just for opposing sake. Now when a fantastic facility for the future of democracy (which they say is dying even while winning few states and by elections to LS) the opposition is opposing PM inaugurating it only for the sake of opposition. When will the opposition realize their job is not only opposing anything and everything at the drop of a topi (whose absence is not noticed). Just saying.
    1
  2057. Why not a comparison of usefulness for progress and development…. Why bait the electorate, Media should answer why not discuss development as IMF terms India a star performer in economy front…. Get the point? Be useful to society not useless Tailpiece: It is the media who is divisive…. Not the politicians nor the people….. talk of development and progress not about caste etc…. If the media does not talk on these lines there will be no caste distinctions…
    1
  2058. A resident President? Just asking.
    1
  2059. Voila! So Nitish in Bihar and Shinde in Mumbai are heroes, right? Both have reasons which of course is not to “retain power” but to uphold democracy and serve the people - politics is after all a public service. Right? There are better ways so that the electorate is not taken for a ride by the power hungry. In a multi split verdict, we can always devise a method whereby all parties get to be in the Government on a time sharing basis. This is what exactly happened in Mumbai and is happening in Bihar! If prearranged in this manner, the electorate will not be surprised with childish antics of political leaders mostly following agenda other than clean and efficient governance. Just saying. Tailpiece: The alternate is that once an alliance is formed, pre/post elections, it should remain so until the next elections. You can’t leave it to these guys (Honorable MLAs and MPs) to create havoc for five years between elections. Just saying
    1
  2060. S. Gangaram Pitroda is only the tip of the iceberg. There is a concentrated effort by the West led by forces in the USA. Possibly with connivance of the State/Deep state, to keep India subservient. It is possible that there are forces within India (including political) who connive to these plans, by default or by design. Also, how can the “leader” of the free world allow cessation activities from its soil against the largest and most divergent democracy and a vociferous advocate of the free world? The USA has , only five hundred or so years back, annexed with force territories from neighboring Mexico and attacked Vietnam, Iraq, Libya and Afghanistan post WWI. Its hands are bloody. India, in its history of 5000 years or more, has never invaded another country. It is time Indian are aware and increase its Hard and Soft power with hardnosed diplomacy.
    1
  2061. The best approach is ignore the ignorant. Ignore this newbie who just wants attention and knows nothing about Santana or dharma….. ignore him and his ignorant remarks… it is just an attention seeking ruse. Tailpiece: THEY KNOW NOT WHAT THEY DO….PARDON THEM.
    1
  2062. A déjà vu. In India for decades, we see “raids” on politicians, especially on those who had risen from "humble" beginnings in the party cadre, and seem to have amassed wealth (in their name and the names of their near and dear ones). Nothing much comes out of these “allegations”, as very very unfortunately our judicial procedures give enough elasticity in its procedures and proceedings to take such cases to one’s grave. That such cases are registered with documentary evidence of such wealth is a reality. It is also true, that in a couple three decades these politicians could not have built such wealth from known sources of income. Such wealth will require political influences to raise huge wealth, the secrets of which are openly known but rarely discussed by the media (who may carry their own agenda in such matters). Tail piece: That which is built with political influence will require greater political influence to to be exposed and brought down. Like the straight drive through the V in cricket, in politics too timing is extremely important to beat the defenders and score maximum. And unlike in cricket this stroke need not always be played with a straight bat. Elementary Dr. Watson.
    1
  2063. You can’t increase wealth by dividing it. If major part of what one earns is taken away and given to those who do not work,,, one day no one will be working in the Nation. Deng Xioping of China realized this in the late 1980s and took China away from socialist economy and Mao philosophy towards capitalism and free market. The results are there for the world to see. Tailpiece: Astounded by kindergartenish statements fro INC and its cohorts
    1
  2064.  @aosaeanor  soldiering is a bit more complicated than that, Adl. I respect your. views. Enjoy.
    1
  2065. Fantastic…. I suppose the “United opposition” is also aware that elections is not an end and there is a Nation INDIA to be governed without discrimination of any kind.
    1
  2066.  @aosaeanor  adl* That is not the primary issue. The primary issue is the quality and motivation of the soldier to take a bulletin in the chest. If money were the consideration for the Indian soldier to fight, India would have lost more wars than just one (in 1962). Tailpiece: There is a Nation to be defended.
    1
  2067.  @miximumpop2278  “Article 44 contained in part IV of the Constitution says that the state “shall endeavour to secure for the citizens a uniform civil code throughout the territory of India”.
    1
  2068.  @Danishviqar  Article 44 contained in part IV of the Constitution says that the state “shall endeavour to secure for the citizens a uniform civil code throughout the territory of India”.
    1
  2069.  @YourManIsMe  Article 44 contained in part IV of the Constitution says that the state “shall endeavour to secure for the citizens a uniform civil code throughout the territory of India”.
    1
  2070.  @Danishviqar  thanks. Perceptions... Differ. Ti each his own.. Respect the right to your views. Enjoy . Forward Ho!
    1
  2071. INC’s reaction reminds me of the story of the ostrich which when encountered with danger buries it’s head in the sand and hopes the danger will pass by. Tailpiece: Yes the Nation needs a strong “opposition” … not in words but in deeds. I hope the INC during its course of agitations against the price rise etc., also tell us what has led to the price rise and recommend actions to curb the same
    1
  2072. The ‘hum do, hamare do’ slogan has made a comeback as the country is today run by just four people, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi said in the Lok Sabha Thursday.” Not a political comment but simple arithmetic: The situation is four times better than being run by one (wo)man. Infinitely better than being run by a nobody. Tail piece: A view of “We the people”.. Let the parliament discuss the farm laws in the house clause by clause. Invite the farm “leaders” to attend the proceedings from the gallery. Live stream the discussions.
    1
  2073. Where has India (or the world) “defined” middle class? Please clarify
    1
  2074. @ an assumption, at best
    1
  2075. Chess Olympiad is being in Chennai these days. It has been organized very well, technically, administratively and efficiently by TN Govt and Govt of India vividly showcasing culture. Chennai, TN and India are on the world stage there. Real federalism. Tailpiece: Now chess is a game of employing tactical moves vide a planned strategy. 32 pieces on 64 squares present immense variations. It seems, going by the moves, the BJP (I am not a member, but a common INDIAN) has learnt to play chess well. It may be well worth for the opposition MPs to visit the Chess Olympiad and learn the moves
    1
  2076. This debate is so widespread today after the black money deals of political parties for over seven decades was stopped the electoral bond scheme. So do not make the EBS the villain of the piece
    1
  2077. A very balanced logic in the letter. Is it only Yunus or are there other forces acting from behind? Something not considered by you, at least in your letter. The Print is doing a god job Keep it up
    1
  2078. Shekdar, I do not understand…. Do you really think that India can become Atmanirbhar in a decade… too bad a joke …. (Dardward or whatever) Gotta start some time…. China has been at it since late 1978 while India seems to have been sleeping on this issue all along. India has just woken up.. You can do better…. Are You ( and the Print) too becoming agenda based couched in bogus neutrality… I am an ardent fan of The Print Wondering….
    1
  2079. Please do not decry our democracy and attribute political motive to any and every investigation without sufficient reasons. An extract from the judgement in Disha Ravi’s (DR) case as published in sections of media… “…It is not mere engagement with persons of dubious credentials which is indictable rather it is the purpose of engagement which is relevant for the purpose of deciding culpability…” When there is a suspicion, as in this case where DR contacted persons of dubious credentials ( as established by the state) and tried to conceal her identity, there is always a case for investigation as to the purpose. We can’t say that such matters should not be investigated. In this case democratic ways as laid down was followed in the investigation. Taking into custody, the courts, bail etc. is a process of investigation in a real democracy. So once again, please do not decry our democracy. Also note that there have been hundreds of thousands of supporters for farmer protest etc. in social media and such platforms Disclaimer: I believe in the innocence of Disha Ravi. But more than that I believe in the process of investigation, which is absolutely necessary here, as a democratic process. Tail piece: I want to believe Justice will prevail. When one attempts the extraordinary, it is but natural to encounter the extraordinary.
    1
  2080. Good interaction… more emphasis is required in areas each Whenever Indian Defence is discussed by the “experts” of today, there is one major aspect conveniently avoided could be because of ignorance). Between 1972 and 2007 the only operates / addition to Indian military equipment were the BOFORS and replacement of enameled water bottles by plastic ones. Real efforts to modernize stared only about 10-12 years back. DRDO was not functioning well… Tiger was no metallurgical research (so essential for engines, aircraft’s, guns and ship building) carried out by either DRDO or the private sector…… one can react many reasons from experience) discuss what is to be done now… Root for more and more rye R&D and not just lament… we all know where we are And much is happening now. Only so much can be done happening overnight.
    1
  2081. Why not a comparison of usefulness for progress and development…. Why bait the electorate, Media should answer why not discuss development as IMF terms India a star performer in economy front…. Get the point? Be useful to society not useless Tailpiece: It is the media who is divisive…. Not the politicians nor the people….. talk of development and progress not about caste etc…. If the media does not talk on these lines there will be no caste distinctions…
    1
  2082. True. S. Gangaram Pitroda is only the tip of the iceberg. There is a concentrated effort by the West led by forces in the USA. Possibly with connivance of the State/Deep state, to keep India subservient. It is possible that there are forces within India (including political) who connive to these plans, by default or by design. Also, how can the “leader” of the free world allow cessation activities from its soil against the largest and most divergent democracy and a vociferous advocate of the free world? The USA has , only five hundred or so years back, annexed with force territories from neighboring Mexico and attacked Vietnam, Iraq, Libya and Afghanistan post WWI. Its hands are bloody. India, in its history of 5000 years or more, has never invaded another country. It is time Indian are aware and increase its Hard and Soft power with hardnosed diplomacy.
    1
  2083. Right. You ask Q when an answer is required. When a Q is asked assuming you know the answer it is that shows ignorance. Tailpiece: I would urge all reporters (especially from the “West” to read the 2004 book “Cold Terror” by Stewart Bell
    1
  2084. Economy will not recover just with a stimulus. Unless people work, produce, earn and spend there can’t be a cycle of economic activity.. The key to the cycle are the workers. How can manufacturing start and sustain without resumption of public transport, supply chain, paying guest accommodation and such?
    1
  2085. Okay AAP. Is that a reason or an excuse? Just asking
    1
  2086. What is a live catridge?
    1
  2087. Yet the congress has won one state and is second in two states…Do we get a two party democracy at National level ….hopefully..Google for Bharat… Tailpiece: Time for the “Gandhi to take a real backseat…. India hopes
    1
  2088. We the people send elected members to the parliament to do business on matters of Governance. When they renegade from this constitutional responsibility by walking out of the hallowed Parliament halls or boycott its proceedings, are they not committing an undemocratic act and trampling on the democratic rights of the electorate and the citizens of the Nation? It is time we the people demand real Governance from all our elected representatives. We request the media to highlight this issue.
    1