Comments by "Awesome Avenger" (@awesomeavenger2810) on "Gad Saad"
channel.
-
10
-
6
-
5
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
''...This article says that 'queer theory' must stop stereotyping fat people. Even Professor Lauren Berlant does it in her critical essay about neoliberalism, Cruel Optimism! Fat people have been stereotyped. And its about time we stop doing that. Like those 'for and after' pictures of fat people. Or even Professor Berlant's own work when she uses the words 'a congealed form of history that hurts' [fat congeals]. The article instead highlights the often ignored work on the subject of fatness by [academic, author, essayist, critic, poet] Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick. Using Sedgwick's poem The Use of being Fat, this article argues the case for fatness. Leaving 'queer theory' with two questions...''
At about this point I realised I was wasting my life. And ceased to be interested in what the article, or the write up of the article, had to say.
This is a disastrous failure of both the write up of the article, and the article itself. Because if your whole career is based on ideas, then, in order to spread those ideas (which presumably you wish to do), you need to make those ideas easily understood. As there is no point being in the 'marketplace of ideas' if you don't intend to sell your wares (as would be the case in the real world).
But these are not ideas that the authors wish to sell. Outlining the basics of an idea should be of paramount importance. But instead we have deliberately incomprehensible (and grammatically bogus) writing. Designed to appeal only to (and be read by) an inducted elite.
There are only two reasons why someone would write as badly as this. 1) They wish to appear cleverer than they actually are. Or 2) They wish to disguise the fact that, despite all the work involved (and tax dollars received), they have very little to say.
4
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
Translation
''...This article says that 'queer theory' must stop stereotyping fat people. Even Professor Lauren Berlant does it in her critical essay about neoliberalism, Cruel Optimism! Fat people have been stereotyped. And its about time we stop doing that. Like those 'for and after' pictures of fat people. Or even Professor Berlant's own work when she uses the words 'a congealed form of history that hurts' [fat congeals]. The article instead highlights the often ignored work on the subject of fatness by [academic, author, essayist, critic, poet] Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick. Using Sedgwick's poem The Use of being Fat, this article argues the case for fatness. Leaving 'queer theory' with two questions...''
At about this point I realised I was wasting my life. And ceased to be interested in what the article, or the write up of the article, had to say.
This is a disastrous failure of both the write up of the article, and the article itself. Because if your whole career is based on ideas, then, in order to spread those ideas (which presumably you wish to do), you need to make those ideas easily understood. As there is no point being in the 'marketplace of ideas' if you don't intend to sell your wares (as would be the case in the real world).
But these are not ideas that the authors wish to sell. Outlining the basics of an idea should be of paramount importance. But instead we have deliberately incomprehensible (and grammatically bogus) writing. Designed to appeal only to (and be read by) an inducted elite.
There are only two reasons why someone would write as badly as this. 1) They wish to appear cleverer than they actually are. Or 2) They wish to disguise the fact that, despite all the work involved (and tax dollars received), they have very little to say.
3
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
You have to be careful when talking about gender dysphoria and the 'great distress and risk of suicide' that comes with it. Its very likely this isn't a symptom of gender dysphoria itself, but a result of the reality of having to deal with the world around them.
For example, personal relationships will be extremely difficult. I think you can imagine your own reaction if, after beginning a relationship with someone for a short while, you find out they are in fact physically the same sex as you. Rightly or wrongly, that would most likely be the reaction of the vast majority of people. You can't help how you feel about such things. But that is the reality of their personal life.
I don't know much about gender dysphoria or transsexuals. But apparently there have been studies done where kids who grow up with gender dysphoria and who are supported and excepted by their family and those around them are happier than those who, let's say, don't have such an understanding environment. To put it bluntly, apart from the inevitable relationship problems, its having to face a world that finds them odd, weird, and more than likely wants nothing to do with them, that gets them down and drives them to suicide.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1