Comments by "Todd Beamer" (@toddbeamer6131) on "Why The Birmingham Manuscript Proves Islam Is False" video.

Now in 2024 we know that a city of mecca never existed at the supposed time of (fictional) muhammed. The entire cult was a later fabrication. Scholars looking at the writing style of the Birmingham folio give it a date around the end of the early 8th century, and the content of these pages is Christian and has nothing to do with islam. Prof. Francois Deroche dates these folios to the early eighth century. Arab Christians probably wrote this, and then later the scribes who were tasked with creating the quran borrowed it (like they did almost all of the quran!). The folio has just parts of three surah, and the sources are listed, along with the dates of these sources: Surah 18:17-31 = The 7 sleepers of Ephesus, Syrian Bishop Jacob of Sarug (521 AD) Surah 19:91-98 = Proto-Evangelium of James (145 AD) Surah 20:1-40 = Story of Moses (1400 BC) These are all pre-Qur’anic, pre-Muhammad, and thus pre-Islamic. Much of the quran was borrowed from known sources - even popular stories like the Alexander Romance literature (Dhul Quarnayn story). The book is an obvious man-made fabrication. See Dr Jay Smith's recent lectures on the topic. The entire cult is based on lies.
1