Comments by "Todd Beamer" (@toddbeamer6131) on "Fadel Soliman and Chris At Speakers Corner on Quran Preservation Full Discussion" video.

  1. They are permitted to lie to non-believers because we are enemies of islam (and so the rules of war apply). Without lies, islame dies.
    2
  2. Correct, but you don't see any of these mental gymnastics in countries like Pakistan or Afghanistan. If you were to try and ask intelligent questions they would just pick up some large rocks and prove you wrong, permanently. That is how rational discourse operates in cult majority countries.
    2
  3.  @allah_is_an_arab  Much of the quran(s) is borrowed from earlier texts: Christian texts, Jewish texts, even popular stories of the time (e.g. Alexander Romance literature). The borrowings clearly show it is a made up text. Even the chapters are not in their supposed chronological order. About 20% of the arabic is either grammatically incorrect or unintelligible (probably foreign words). The book is a disaster in all respects, and probably the most obvious fake in history.
    1
  4. The adbools all do the same tap dancing. Without lies, islame dies.
    1
  5. Yes, Uthman was a partner of al-lah, deciding for him what the exact text was and what was left out. The other major issue is who was responsible for compiling the quran into chapters that are not in chronological order (the order 'sent down' by al-lah). Apart from the first sura, the others have been roughly ordered by the length of text. How stupid. Presumably it was Uthman who decided that too, and garbled up the entire book.
    1