Comments by "Scott Franco" (@scottfranco1962) on "Corey Gil-Shuster" channel.

  1. Simple logic defeats this idea of "self defense". A lot or even most of the rockets are fired by remote control. Thus the militants are not only putting civilians at risk, but they don't want to be hit by return fire.
    3
  2. So if a Palestinian could prove that he/she owned property in Israel proper before 1948, and wanted to join Israel and recover their property, vowing allegiance to Israel and whatever is required, could they?
    1
  3. Like the "dude, what do you want".
    1
  4. Don't ask that of the Palestinians. Don't ask that of the Israelis. Ask it of the Arabs living in Israel. They would just look at you confused. Since they already do live in peace with the jews.
    1
  5. Interesting how you got more pushback on this question than many others. Its the central question of Israel, isn't it? If Israel were a normal state, with normal immigration, the jews feel it would be overrun by Arabs and thus taken over. I think that is true, but I don't think its a bad thing if it takes, say, 100 years. The key is that by the time immigration made the jews a minority, the people living their would be Israeli, and have no interest in tearing up their own state. Ask the Jordanians how integration with the Palestinians is going. I guess I have a unique perspective on it, because my mother married a Jewish man as her second husband.
    1
  6. I couldn't watch it. An eye for an eye, tooth for tooth, soon a land of toothless blind people. There is no logic to hate, no logic to war.
    1
  7. Ok, then why don't you want Jordan "back"?
    1