Comments by "" (@jmitterii2) on "Возможно ли путешествие во времени? — Колин Стюарт" video.

  1. ***** Space and time are aspects of the same thing. That's what relativity is based on. So time and space do exist, and time rate can slow or stop and space distance can contract and increase based on an objects mass or inertial mass (in the vector of the objects velocity).
    2
  2. Killua Zoldyck Relativity doesn't specifically reveal that such a thing is necessarily possible. If massive objects or non massive objects could go faster than the speed of light, in one of the formulas, you're rate of time is a negative square root. And to resolve negative square root you use complex imaginary number i. So your rate of time would be an imaginary rate of time. Whatever that means.
    1
  3. Zero Kelvin Relativity doesn't specifically state negative rate of time can exist. What it does state is rate of time between two objects can change, so can space for the two objects-- space and time dilation. Nothing in relativity violates thermodynamics. On the other hand, quantum mechanics concerning quantum tunneling kind of does, but it has a loop hole that it doesn't, because particles like electrons that quantum tunnel aren't necessarily fixed spacial point objects, rather those objects are blurred in both a wave and particle duality. And then there are virtual particles that under certain circumstances can become real particle by borrowing negative energy to become positive energy. The universe sum total of energy when dealing with negative energy and positive energy is exactly zero energy when balanced all out. Therefore thermodynamics is never violated in QM either.
    1
  4. Tyler Anderson Yes. The speed at which we're going through our galaxy is 1.3 million miles per hour. So if you stopped going at the speed relative to our galaxy, your rate of time compared to the frame of reference in our galaxy, your reference frame would tick by a little faster compared to our rate of time inside and moving with the galaxy. 1.3 million miles per hour is about .001951 or 0.195% of the speed of light.  I'm ignoring all the other motions of the sun orbiting the galaxy and earth orbiting the sun, and earth's rotation as those speeds are not significant to the large 1.3 million miles per hour the galaxy is moving. Especially considering orbits of the sun and earth and rotation of the earth vectors are not always summing in the same direction of the vector velocity of the Milky Way. So relative to the galaxy, galaxies, your time rate of passing would be about 1.0000019012554222 times faster than time passing in the Milky Way (excluding local effects objects near heavy masses such as near stars and black holes and effects of planets even earth sized planets because proximity to mass has an effect on time dilation, closer to massive objects and the more massive the object the slower the object's rate of time compared to objects farther away or with little mass). Also you must realize, all objects in the universe are moving at various velocities and vectors (directions). And being at rest position is always relative. Even in the above example with the Milky Way. So you're rest position in respect to the galaxy could still be motion relative to some other galaxy or object in the universe and is only at rest relative to the Milky Way. Relativity is relative to other moving objects, and those objects in the universe does not have a particular direction and velocity to be at a universal rest position in relationship toward. Hence the Relativity is named with the word relativity. What you're asking is can you move slower than our current rest velocity, sure. But all you're doing is making that object have the velocity in respect to you at rest to it. There is no universal rest velocity in respect to everything else in the universe. It's all relative to the direction of the object and the direction of velocity to something else.   All motion is relative. In examples where rockets are used and earth is then considered object at rest, is largely because the rocket or spaceship is the one expending energy for acceleration and it's velocity is faster relative to our motion remaining on the earth. Same when trains are used, you're just sitting in one location relative to a moving train which has a faster velocity in respect to you sitting at the station. It doesn't imply that earth has some universal proper rate of time. http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/relativ/tdil.html http://astrosociety.org/edu/publications/tnl/71/howfast.html
    1
  5. veda siva I suggest you read about Einstein's Relativity. Space-Time is a real phenomena just as much as water and air you breath and food you eat is real. I think you maybe mistaken various units of measurement and methods of measuring. As all units and methods of measurements are discovered and invented by people. Measuring a cup of flour, the flour is real, the unit of a cup is defined by us humans, but the flour in the cup does exist. We use the measurement we invented to describe the quantity of flour. And so does time, or more specifically space-time. Because space and time are aspects of the same thing. Like electricity and magnetism are aspects of the same thing.
    1