Comments by "" (@jmitterii2) on "Математика изобретена или открыта? — Джефф Декофски" video.

  1. Math is part of language. Therefore it is an invention to describe reality. Where words articulate descriptions of actions and units another vector can be added to provide in depth use, math provides quantity to a particular verbal unit and description. But we don't discover words any more than we discover a math symbol. We discover a relationship that happens in reality or in imagination as we do with words. Math is a label system and label system of quantifying numbers in a logical proof set. What we discover is from the outside and find the maths that are invented are useful in describing and predicting what we observed.   Math is a philosophy liberal art that allows us to think careful and discretely about an observation or experiment to attempt to describe as concise as possible a phenomena or an imagined phenomena and making predictions that may be validated. Depends how discovered is defined. If discovered means found how something works, than math can also be a discovery because its just a description. You don't get much with out the other.  You need to have reality observation and experiment that is occurring along with some methods of recording and describing the data. Some water in a pond/ can be 5.5 million gallons or 5 gallons. It makes no difference to the pond or puddle. Without providing some quantity its a very low resolution on describing the difference between a pond and a puddle. The various mounts of water that exists exists regardless if a number is assigned to them. So its both. An invention and reality I think. Its an invention to describe reality. Separate either, you still have reality but no invention to describe it well enough to do much with it. Take way reality, and you have undefined math logics (so you can't even tell if the logic is in fact logical or not as such math without reality would have on relationships to do anything useful or descriptions of anything, or experiment.  The become pointless without each other. As pointless as saying going further north at the north pole.
    2