Comments by "Jovet" (@jovetj) on "Ground Neutral and Hot wires explained - electrical engineering grounding ground fault" video.
-
7
-
@Ironbuket
In typical DC wiring, yes, Red is (+) and Black is (–). In most automobiles, the frame (or frame ground) is negative. There is no neutral, but there could be if you connected two batteries or cells in series and had a third connection between them (e.g. here the + and – are connected). Electrons are negatively charged, so they are drawn to the positive terminal. May be weird to think about at first, but it's accurate.
With AC, there is no polarity, so (+) and (–) doesn't apply. Thus, wiring colors are pretty arbitrary. In North America, any wire color that is not white, gray, green, or bare should be considered a Hot. And a "hot" conductor is one that is not grounded. If it's grounded, then it is conducting current in the circuit, but it also is at the same voltage potential as the Earth.
3
-
3
-
2
-
A "Hot" or "live" wire is a conductor that isn't grounded. That can be earth ground, or frame/chassis ground. The term "hot" is not usually used with isolated DC circuits, although it can be. The majority of direct current (DC) systems people are familiar with are (–) ground, but (+)-ground systems exist, too. It doesn't really matter, as long as it's known and consistent within a system. Polarity matters in DC. Alternating current (AC) does not have static polarity, so the idea of (+) and (–) doesn't apply. Either a conductor is grounded, or it isn't. Remember that electricity only flows in a complete loop, called a circuit. If there is no complete loop, then electricity will not flow. DC always flows in a persistent direction, but AC changes back and forth (alternates polarity) and this happens throughout the entire circuit (not just the "hot wire").
Atoms cannot get a "surplus of protons." Atoms want to be neutral, which means a balance of protons (+) and electrons (—). Atoms can become unbalanced by temporarily losing or gaining electrons, and such atoms are called ions. Atoms can only gain protons by nuclear fusion, which is what happens in the core of the Sun, or nuclear decay. "Hot" or "live" conductors are special only because they are the parts of the circuit which are isolated from the grounded path. There is no voltage potential between the grounded conductor and the ground system itself because they're connected together. The "hot" or "live" is switched/fused because it's a lot easier to further isolate what is already isolated. Plus, it reduces further problems and dangers of accidentally interrupted neutrals. Not all AC circuits have a "neutral" as that really derives from the middle tap of a secondary winding on a transformer.
A power source works by inducing a voltage potential in a conductor through a complete circuit. On a battery, the positive terminal isn't more or less "active" than the negative terminal. The two terminals just have opposite roles. One is going to accept electrons, and the other is going to donate them. 9V or -9V is still 9 volts of potential, no matter how you measure it. No one terminal of a power source is "more important" than another, because there still has to be a loop.
2
-
@kal9001
Yep. Much safer to have a carefully-controlled "hot" and assume everything else is the same potential (ground, or negative).
@Pqrst Zxerty
Most general DC power source wiring is red and black, so by that logic, the white wire should be black, too. But, remember, that (+) is only the red wire in (–) ground systems. In reality, the black wire represents (chassis) ground, and the red wire represents not-ground. So, in a (+)-ground system, the (+) would be the black wire. So, the video is more-correct on that point, even if it's just something most people are not used to. Excepting it's a white wire, not black. I think it would be less confusing if the (+) and red/black wires were employed as usual, and the current was still just shown to flow (–) to (+).
2
-
2
-
Static electricity doesn't work the same as the electricity we generate with batteries and power plants. It's still a "flow of electrons" but that's about all they have in common.
When you use a power source, you're setting up a prolonged voltage potential between the terminals on that power source. For example, a 12 volt battery will have a 12 volt difference between the + and – terminals. That difference is maintained as long as the chemicals in the battery can.
When you rub a balloon on your hair, you're not creating or using a prolonged power source. You're causing electrons to be casually shed from one object onto another. This happens because all objects are "solid" because electrons (like charges) repel each other. The rubbing increases the chance that this electron-electron interaction will cause some loosely-held electrons to be ejected into the other material. Atoms want to stay neutral, after all, so when those few electrons leave, the atoms left behind become slightly positive. A static electric discharge is simply the return of those extra electrons back to where they belong.
As air molecules move around, they rub together, and rub against the Earth, they transfer electrons just like your hair and the balloon do. Lighting is the static discharge between the charged air molecules and the Earth.
So, in way, you can think of static electricity as a "flow of electrons back to its source (source atoms)," but it's more of a quick neutralization...not the sustained flow we typically think of as electricity.
2
-
2
-
2
-
The "hot" and "neutral" are not swapping places. Remember that a "hot" or "live" wire is a conductor that is not grounded. The neutral is not only the center-tap out of the transformer, but it also is grounded.
Remember that a battery has a static polarity. (+) is always positive, and (–) is always negative. The only way to reverse a circuit is to take the battery out and hook it in backwards. But, that is basically what AC does, 50-60 times a second. At one moment of AC, the "hot" may be (+) and the neutral would be (–). A few milliseconds later, the "hot" would then become (–) and the neutral is (+). And a few milliseconds after that, they switch back. The switch back and forth is not instantaneous. If you graph it out, it is a beautiful sine wave.
It is not important to know what the polarity of the circuit is, because it doesn't matter—it's constantly changing. It is only important to know which conductors are grounded. And then, if more than one conductor is not grounded, which is which (e.g. multiple phases).
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Your first paragraph is correct. The neutral essentially does double-duty. Because the voltage and polarity are constantly changing in alternating current, AC current is not as much of a demand on a conductor as DC is. The shared neutral can do double duty because both of the two hot wires are out of phase with each other.
Neutral versus ground is not too complicated. The first thing to remember is a circuit does NOT need a ground to work. All circuits are a complete loop, or path from the source, through the loop, and back to the source. AC or DC, makes no difference. All a complete loop. More complex circuits will have many branches and diversions, but it's still a bit loop. No complete loop, no current flows anywhere. You can think of it like the blood vessels in your body. They are just a big, complex loop. The major vessels carry a lot of blood, but they branch into smaller and smaller ones, only to come back together into larger ones and go back to your heart—the power source.
This means every basic circuit needs only two wires. One going from the source, and one going back to it. Usually the two wires are kept relatively close to one another, for safety and convenience, but they don't HAVE to be. A while back it was realized that it was safer if one of those wires is connected to the Earth. This eliminates the voltage potential between it and the ground, so it can't shock you. It still carries the same current as part of the circuit, however. But no matter what voltage it's at at that moment, the voltage difference is always the same as the ground, since it's connected to it. That means one of the wires is grounded (or earthed), and the other is ungrounded.
It was then realized that metal chassis and other equipment parts could become the same voltage difference as that other ungrounded conductor when they're not supposed to. If that happens, a person could touch those parts and form a new circuit path through his body and back to the ground or grounded conductor. So, it was decided to connect all those metal parts to each other and the Earth too. That way, if any of those parts got energized, the power would be easily taken down to the earth, back through the ground connection to the grounded conductor, and then back to the source. This would likely cause a short circuit (complete path with little resistance), resulting in a rapid overcurrent and a fuse or circuit breaker blowing. The wire that connects all the metal parts that should never carry current together is called the grounding conductor, or ground. The grounding conductor should never carry current except when something is wrong... and then, ideally, only for a brief period.
The neutral is the common conductor in your first paragraph, which is also grounded. The wire actually connecting it to the ground is the ground wire. The neutral is a required part of the circuit because it normally carries current. The ground carries current only when something is wrong, as a safety feature. Additionally, that neutral is only grounded at one spot: the main disconnect after the transformer. This prevents bad current interplay between the neutral and grounding, system which can happen otherwise.
Polarized plugs do not provide a ground connection. Since they have only two prongs, there is no ground prong. Remember, I said above that a ground wire is not required... only the two circuit wires are needed. What polarized plugs do do is make some electrical equipment safer, when it's important that the grounded conductor (the neutral) be connected in certain ways. A lamp is a good example. The screw base of a light bulb socket should always be the grounded neutral, never the "hot" wire. Polarized plugs ensure that's the case.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@John McDonnell
To expand on Steven's answer a bit...
Yes, DC circuits usually have Black as negative (assuming that's the chassis or ground), and the other color (usually Red) as positive. The battery circuits in this video are not designed to be illustrative of DC circuit practices, but merely to compare the straightforwardness of a simple DC circuit to how simple a home AC circuit is. DC circuits do not typically have a "neutral" and it's just best to not take that section of the video too literally.
AC wiring in homes and businesses generally has different conductors (wires) with three different roles:
— grounded conductors
— grounding conductors
— hot (or live) conductors.
Electricity must flow in a closed loop called a circuit. One wire goes from the power source to the lamp, and the other wire goes from the lamp back to the power source. Both conductors carry the current. If you also connect one of those conductors to the Earth, then you erase any voltage difference between that conductor and the Earth. This is called grounding the conductor, and that conductor becomes a groundED conductor. The wire connecting that conductor to the Earth is called the groundING conductor. In fact, any other parts such as a chassis or whatnot can also be connected to the Earth through a grounding conductor. This just leaves the "hot" conductors, which really is just any conductor that is not grounded.
In the United States, you can generally assume:
— grounded conductors (White or Light Gray)
— grounding conductors (bare, or Green, or Green/yellow)
— hot (or live) conductors (Any other color).
In the United States, Black is usually used as the primary "hot" line, Red as the secondary, and Blue as the tertiary. When three voltage phases are involved (meaning the alternating polarity changes at different times) there can be alternate color schemes in place.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Electricity always flows in a closed loop called a circuit. The lower resistance there is to that flow, the more current flows. At 8:14, he shows current flowing in the circuit, but there isn't any current flowing through the outlet because nothing is plugged into it. The potential is there (120 volts) but no current flows because there's no complete loop there.
The person then touches the "hot" terminal of the outlet. This can create a complete circuit from the hot wire, through the person, to the ground system, and back to the source. The amount of current that flows depends on all of the resistance offered throughout that circuit, including the resistance of other loads on the circuit (other outlets with things plugged in, lights, etc.), the resistance of the person's body, the ground or other surfaces he's touching, etc. It's mentioned that the person is barefoot and that the ground he's standing on is wet. Pure (distilled) water does not conduct electricity, but water is also really good at dissolving minerals and metals that will allow it to conduct electricity. Only as much current will flow as the worst conducting piece of the circuit will allow.
Electrocution is death by electric shock. In order for a shock to be fatal, it has to disrupt your heart's ability or desire to beat. That really depends on the voltage (how easy it is for the electric current to overcome the body's inherent resistance; dry skin, for example, conducts poorly) and where through the body the current travels.
1
-
1