Comments by "Military History Visualized" (@MilitaryHistoryVisualized) on "TIKhistory" channel.

thanks for the shoutout(s)! Just watched the first 9 minutes, so far, great work! Gotta get a stream ready, will watch the rest later!
795
well, about Lend-Lease I would recommend my video on "Why Lend-Lease is so complicated" and the follow-up video, because the "pure" numbers are really misleading (see Sokolov) in many instances, since the quality, timing, specialization in production, etc. needs to accounted for to put everything into a proper context. Good point with the turning point(s). I mainly agree with you (except the number comparison in the beginning), although I think it was a bit more important.
328
Nice one! I read the same a while ago in Germany and the Second World War (Das Deutsche Reich und der Zweite Weltkrieg) and was like "hmmm", but never took the time to re-read all the other books. Gave it a share on fb and rt, hopefully you get some new subs!
253
Sürprise! ;)
24
@Illya: I think your memory might have mixed me up with Chieftain here, or I said it on stream (I say a lot on those ;) referring to Chieftain. As far as I know, he said it in one of his Dunkirk videos. Although the Soviets were also drawing various lessons from the Winter War etc.
23
Cyberian Korninger not to mention that there is little consensus about Lend Lease at all, something I show in the video tomorrow.
18
yeah, well, almost, I guess you have the English version, whereas I use the German one. Yeah, I remember there was a line along "we can't be sure how it exactly happened or it can't be properly reconstructed". Not well-read on Jeschonnek, but ass far I as I remember he was rather young and Göring promoted mostly people that were no threat to him, so he probably just said what Hitler wanted to hear.
18
there is Hitler's militärische Elite by Ueberschär (editor) ironically, I got it today, I think Jeschonnek is in there and Paulus for sure, but I doubt many more involved with Stalingrad.
14
well, done, just wanted to record them, but you were faster.
3
not sure, either fish or fuel tank.
2
hehe, hopefully there will be a few more people showing up here besides me :) Nice, my video on the breakout was just the first in a longer planned series, as mentioned in the video a lot of other factors (exhaustion of troops, air power, etc.) I didn't take into account at all.
1
of course not, because they would be a different video too. I am not really sure what parts of the battle I cover when and with what scope. Ideally I have the book from Glantz then the book from Kehrig, which sadly doesn't really deal with the attack on Stalingrad than the book from Wettstein: Wehrmacht im Stadtkampf (recent phd thesis). Well, it is a pretty clear that the Germans had a lack of troops, why else were the Romanians, Italians & Hungarians helping out en masse. Then starting an attrition fight in a city with already stretched supply lines... after all, the Luftwaffe flew air supply even before the encirclement.
1