Comments by "suraj s" (@surajs5913) on "Did Ayodhya verdict bring Hindus closure on historical wrongs? PM Modi to decide" video.

@Suresh_Kamath is this like the survey by "eminent historians" romila tharpar who claimed that there sas no ram temple ruins beneath the babri masjid and was later proven wrong by the presence of archeological evidence of a 11th centyry temple found by the ASI? Nevertheless, if it can be proven that such shrines were destroyed beyond the occasional ruler like skanda gupta, let them be rebuilt on the same spot. Hindus have no qualms in revival of buddhist culture to its full strength. The current generation can only be expected to say sorry and cooperate to the fullest extent by returning the land and even providing finances for such revitalization. That is the crux of the problem regarding communalism in India. Sime communities and historians are unwilling to even acknowledge the historical wrongs committed against hindus and claim that hindus deserve no compensation. Such a viewpoint is far from reconciliatory, it is more like saying " our ancestors defeated yours and it should remain that way. Your culture deserved to be eroded and does not deserve to exist or grow. " We need mutual respect between religions not mere tolerance. If abrahamic religions see dharmics as mere pagans to be converted by any means necessary, communalism is the natural consequence of such a regressive thought process.
13
@saptarshisengupta8235 the same sangh logic which led to the Ram Janmabhoomi trust reaching nearly double the target amount in 45 days. Only motivated people want to believe that hinduism is dying and hindus are poor. Fact is that with economic upliftment, hinduism is only getting stronger economically. The only logical step next is cultural revitalization. If you want employment though, support construction. Temple construction also classifies as construction, and pays a lot more than constructing a house. The amount of economic activity generated by the Ram Janmabhoomi temple after construction will be proof enough of that...
6
@saptarshisengupta8235 they cover the beating up of a 14 year old in ghaziabad in Modis Fascist India, but not the LYNCHING of Rinku Sharma and the recent Bhainsa riots where a AIMIM legislator has been booked for attempted murder. Good journalism is not selective and does not lie by omission.
6
@saptarshisengupta8235 given that 80 percent graduates are unemployable according to private companies, the solution to unemployment is NEP. No nationalisation of assets is sufficient to solve unemployment in a sustainable manner in a large country like India
4
As a right wing hindu i hoe RSS does not pursue the agenda of other temples.and focuses on character building. Since the banyan tree is now firmly planted, it should spread its arms and let its vines grow and thicken. Only then a single tree can bring forth a forest. Likewise, smaller organisations should be allowed to come up and saturate the political/social spectrum of India, and gain acceptance by pursuing such movements like Krishna janmabhoomi...
4
@saptarshisengupta8235 i believe judgements o implementation can be made only after it is implemented properly. But it isnt the only solution. The cause of this phenomenon is not just a bad educational system emphasising on rote learning, but also emphasis on quantity over quality of education. The above mindset is also due to thousands of people lining up for "government jobs" to "get settled" in life. This lack of ambition and desire for a secure job which requires zero competitiveness are all consequences of the license raj of the pre 1991 era. The best way to solve that is to make it clear once and for all that it is not the governments duty to run uncompetitive non essential businesses to provide jobs to people.
3
@SKYT123KH bro there is only casteism in india and no religious intolerence. Dont you know caste and religio of accused and victim matters in hatras but not in balrampur. India is a secular country after all, one so secular where govt controls temple funds. The knlg miracle is how hindutva didnt grow quicker as a mainstream ideology...
3
@saptarshisengupta8235 correction: no business is possible in regions of sustained prolonged communal violence. However if such instances are short sharp and sudden, they are generally written off by companies as a freak incident-like in gujarat 2002 or more recently in bangalore. Recently UP overtook Maharashtra in GSDP despite allegations of it being the hotbed of communalism and having severe law and order problems. As long as states implement law and maintain order in a deterministic way 95% of the time, and dont bother the companies too much, they will stay. They will stay as long as there is profit to be had.... they will leave only if 75 % local reservation or such bullahit is enforced.
2
@Suresh_Kamath not yet atleast😉
1
@Suresh_Kamath is this like the survey by "eminent historians" romila tharpar who claimed that there sas no ram temple ruins beneath the babri masjid and was later proven wrong by the presence of archeological evidence of a 11th centyry temple found by the ASI? Nevertheless, if it can be proven that such shrines were destroyed beyond the occasional ruler like skanda gupta, let them be rebuilt on the same spot. Hindus have no qualms in revival of buddhist culture to its full strength. The current generation can only be expected to say sorry and cooperate to the fullest extent by returning the land and even providing finances for such revitalization. That is the crux of the problem regarding communalism in India. Sime communities and historians are unwilling to even acknowledge the historical wrongs committed against hindus and claim that hindus deserve no compensation. Such a viewpoint is far from reconciliatory, it is more like saying " our ancestors defeated yours and it should remain that way. Your culture deserved to be eroded and does not deserve to exist or grow. " We need mutual respect between religions not mere tolerance. If abrahamic religions see dharmics as mere pagans to be converted by any means necessary, communalism is the natural consequence of such a regressive thought process.
1
Please also report on the state control of temple finances by state governments in India. It is illogical to expect the separation of religion from politics when the government intrudes into the religious institutions and their finances of just one particular religion. Such a system does not seem like "equidistance from all religions". Temples should be let free from the tyranny of the elected politicians and selected bereaucrats.
1