Comments by "False sects like shia are judeo ibn saba made" (@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543) on "Sabotaging effectiveness: destruction through distraction" video.

  1. No sis, Shahid calls to unity but brushes aside Aqida, our base is double speak, he wonders why ppl say you contradict & plays innocent... this mass weak misguided speech is foamy & holds umma back... Quran 2.137 says right belief is key to victory not numbers in Q 9.25, too much feeling talk & not nuanced structure from a guy just shows a lack of Rajulah i am sorry uncle. & this info does affect brotherhood, and direction on if the umma will have easier time worshiping Allah or not, one is taught the other is learned and hence entrusted. He brought up Athari and Kulabi/Ashari. Ok one says Allah's hijab is real which is asl the apparent and tafsir sahaba - Sahih Muslim Kitab Iman hadith Abu Bakr, kulabis say Allah's Hijab is figurative using greco bias they call kalam like Qadriya use local bias on Allah's ilm and end up out of Islam... Now where does the kalafi bias end, that a bint of nasawaiya I think it's called in Arabic, will also now use secular bias and say my hijab is figurative... There is no solidarity in bida... What kalam did in Aqidah Sophies did in ibada... everyone made up things until they divided, were over run and became secular just like Uthmaniya... he 100% wrong in real life... and he want to talk about salafis being theoretical? Lack of hikma/nuance maybe want those ci groups want but not lack of ilm. Be balanced. You want to build, build Aqida & usul... as that's a base. Fact he waffled on this topic shows you bro shahid try to convince yourself.
    3
  2. He is good at critisizing wst as he from them but critique and solution are 2 different things, the scholars of Islam will help us build solutions that are stable and long term insha Allah.
    2
  3. I agree Islamic knowledge is more important than secular knowledge and does require study, but I pray Islamic knowledge is more open and stays open. May Allah keep us sincere. And to be honest the way you word things did show disregard and to deny an obvious you stated right after that is combative yourself only even if you play the victim. & this info does affect brotherhood, and direction on if the umma will have easier time worshiping Allah or not, one is taught the other is learned and hence entrusted. You brought up Athari and Kulabi/Ashari. Ok one says Allah's hijab is real which is asl the apparent and tafsir sahaba - Sahih Muslim Kitab Iman hadith Abu Bakr, kulabis say Allah's Hijab is figurative using phiIo bias they call kalam like Qadriya use local bias on Allah's ilm and end up out of Islam... Now where does the kalafi bias end, that a bint of nasawaiya I think it's called in Arabic, will also now use secular bias and say my hijab is figurative... There is no solidarity in bida... What kalam did in Aqidah Sophies did in ibada... everyone made up things until they divided, were over run and became secular just like Uthmaniya... you 100% wrong in real life... and you want to talk about salafis being theoretical? Lack of hikma/nuance maybe want those ci groups want but not lack of ilm. Be balanced. You want to build, build Aqida & usul... as that's a base. --- - Historical review and connecting it to us again with Islamic vocab. In fiqh there is a bit more room. I myself am still learning but Quran 47.19 & 65.12 tafsir ibn Kathir & saadi said this, Aqida is fard al ayn. You are likely mixing up relief of severe simptoms like outer thulm like when kulabi Salahudin and Athari ebn Qudama fought jointly the xsades... With healing causes like bida for long term stability and internal health and growth. The dawah of right Aqida during Hudaibiya had Muslims take Mecca with no harb... umar returned 'you hood' who were now Muslims to Jerusalem with no harb and solid Aqida... yet some how we are to ignore this... Manhaj. Aqida is fard, usul ties this to fiqh, dawah to first two can help open people to build their lives in the right order or priority to gain more than we lose each step from an individual to society level which is a key from manhaj salaf differring from other groups. --- Perhaps inner and outer dawa can he 50 50. It should be organized. Like hadith Jibril. If I was to debate nasara I break it to 5-10 points. 1. Tawhid, Allah can forgive w/o sacrifice as all prophets said until paul. 2. Original text and nature of Jesus and progress doctrine change. 3. Original sin. 4. Iaw. 5. To avoid emotional distractions, history of hajj in 0ld testa and higher virtue of Islam including comparing prophets, this may mix in w/faqs. Avoid ppl if they too dishonest, If ppl don't care, even Muslims what can you do if not leave concise heart softeners & nasiha w/ directions while prepared to deal with triggering nonsense? Similar with other ideas. Allahu 3lim.
    1
  4. To shahid, my nasiha - Historical review and connecting it to us again with Islamic vocab. In fiqh there is a bit more room. I myself am still learning but Quran 47.19 & 65.12 tafsir ibn Kathir & saadi said this, Aqida is fard al ayn. You are likely mix up : relief of severe simptoms like outer thulm like when kulabi Salahudin and Athari ebn Qudama fought jointly the xsades... With healing CAUSES like bida divide for long term stability and internal health and growth. The dawah of right Aqida during Hudaibiya had Muslims of medina who left it all take the much wealthier Mecca with no harb... umar returned the prior 'you hood' who were now Muslims to Jerusalem with no harb and solid Aqida... yet some how we are to ignore this... Manhaj. Aqida is fard, usul ties this to fiqh, dawah to first two can help open people to build their lives in the right order or priority to gain more than we lose each step from an individual to society level which is a key from manhaj salaf differring from other groups. --- Perhaps inner and outer dawa can he 50 50. It should be organized. Like hadith Jibril. If I was to debate nasara I break it to 5-10 points. 1. Tawhid, Allah can forgive w/o sacrifice as all prophets said until paul. 2. Original text and nature of Jesus and progress doctrine change. 3. Original sin. 4. Iaw. 5. To avoid emotional distractions, history of hajj in 0ld testa and higher virtue of Islam including comparing prophets, this may mix in w/faqs. Avoid ppl if they too dishonest, If ppl don't care, even Muslims what can you do if not leave concise heart softeners & nasiha w/ directions while prepared to deal with triggering nonsense? But your talk trying to act deep without a solid base and direction on that is not seeing forest from trees. Islam is middle path in everything even when being simply general and being deep. Similar when opposing other ideas. Allahu 3lim.
    1