Comments by "ShutTheMuckUp" (@ShutTheMuckUp) on "American Battlefield Trust" channel.

  1. If you guys ever want to hire a professional videographer for these videos, I'd love to help. I can eliminate all that wind noise, and other problems like the crackling. Looking forward to your coverage of the 159th! Keep up the great work!
    58
  2.  @AmericanBattlefieldTrust  I'll take that as a "maybe".
    31
  3. Being mindful not to disrupt the tour group was very classy. I like that. This channel is great, and I appreciate the effort and passion y'all put into these videos.
    14
  4. Moral of the story is war destroys everyone involved, including the people who survived.
    13
  5. You have been doing these videos for over 10 years?? Youtube's recommendation algorithm is garbage. Finally got recommended this channel a few weeks ago during the Gettysburg anniversary. This channel is great.
    9
  6.  @davidmurray5399  Your rambling is an example of why you shouldn't say anything if you don't know what you're talking about...
    6
  7. Man, these videos are great. Very informative, and Garry's quick wit is always spot-on.
    6
  8. If Garry shaved his chin, he'd have some sweet civil war era facial hair.
    5
  9. The passion these guys have for this is amazing. They do a great job of painting the picture in your head as to what was happening.
    4
  10. So who wants to team up and create the most historically accurate film in the history of film? I'm talking about creating a film about Gettysburg with battle scenes that last for hours...showing you in "real time" what was going on with decision making and troop movement for both sides. You'd see captured soldiers and how they were treated, wounded soldiers and the hellish fate they endured, dead bodies and what happened to them in the July heat. Each day would be it's own trilogy. I can't emphasize enough how in-depth I want this to be. I want the viewer to feel like they're there...like a ghost on the battle field who's able to swiftly move about and observe from inside the action. We could film this and have it done by the 160th anniversary. Obviously this summer is a bust with the virus, but we'd have 2 years to get it done. The people in these videos from the American Battlefield Trust obviously know exactly what they're talking about, and could easily position troops accordingly, and recreate the timeline of events. The only challenge I see is hiding all the monuments... Maybe tons of fake trees?? If you're not convinced yet that this is a great idea, just imagine the beach scene from Saving Private Ryan being set in 1863 and lasting for 3 days. That's what we should make about Gettysburg.
    4
  11. They aren't working for me, either.
    2
  12.  @AmericanBattlefieldTrust  Yeah, we're not getting ANY notifications. We should get them when you upload a video, or go live, or post a message...
    2
  13. And today we have an orange clown who throws fits while sitting in his soiled diaper...
    2
  14. I want to work with these people. You need a video editor or anything?
    2
  15. It's usually too hot in Wisconsin around the 4th of July to do anything outside, so I just stay in the AC and watch livestreams from Gettysburg.
    2
  16. Huh... I stayed in Murfreesboro when I was in Tennessee for the solar eclipse back in 2017. I had no idea there was a battle there.
    2
  17. Can you hire me to be your audio engineer? I guarantee crystal clear audio on all of your videos. No more wind distortion!
    1
  18. Yes! Do more driving videos like this.
    1
  19. Was this filmed with a camera from 1862? What up with the poor quality?
    1
  20. I forgot to buy a ticket, but had I won the billion dollar mega bucks drawing a few days ago, I would've paid for a bunch of land to preserve...as long as there were signs installed at the locations that said "This land was preserved by Muck, a true American hero who once met the 2nd drummer of Guns N Roses."
    1