Comments by "Tespri" (@Tespri) on "Was Joan of Arc Actually A Warrior?" video.

She was a mascot, nothing more.
1
@RayB1656 She captured or her men captured. As I sad, she was just a mascot.
1
@RayB1656 Jesters and mascots do in fact. Doing jousting for sake of entertainment of noblemen isn't really something so special. Winning actual jousting tournament would be something. Ownership of items doesn't make one miltiary genius nor even a good fighter. Too easy
1
@RayB1656 just stating facts. Keep on coping and thinking that some peasant girl who never had protein in their diet, could magically developed genius mind and strong body. Not to mention mysteriously getting educated in arts of war and martial arts 🤣🤡
1
@RayB1656 Traveling on horse back isn't same as having muscles and education. In order for brain to develop properly the protein is needed. Peasants can't afford it. Thus they usually ended up being bit like you. Aka having lQ same as my dog. Not to mention how sickly they were. it takes years of practice to become good with sword and even with warfare. She was way too young to have proper education or to even lift a sword. All what you said just reveals that you have never held a sword. Never fought any martial arts and never were in army. Too easy, she was just mascot to use to rise up morale of the troops. That's all she was.
1
@RayB1656 you clearly have no clue how many years it takes to master anything and even more so to build up muscles. She was way too young unless she spend her entire childhood training... which she didn't
1
@RayB1656 again it takes years if not decades to master ANYTHING. How is this difficult to understand? It's virtually impossible for peasant to be as good as her myth. It's nothing but false stories for morale boost
1
@RayB1656 1. "Joan was born to a propertied peasant family at Domrémy in northeast France. In 1428, she requested to be taken to Charles VII, later testifying that she was guided by visions from the archangel Michael, Saint Margaret, and Saint Catherine to help him save France from English domination. Convinced of her devotion and purity, Charles sent Joan, who was about seventeen years old, to the siege of Orléans as part of a relief army. " Straight from wikipedia. Scientifically speaking claiming to have visions from angels would deem one as schizophrenic. So We have already established that before age 17. Se was 100% peasant without any military or muscle training in the backround. We also have established by the sources that she was used to demoralize enemy. After all... she claimed she had visions from the angels themselves. Thus affecting morale of own troops and enemy troops. 2. Wikipedia literally states that she was from peasant family. Stop lying. 3. One still needs decades of training to become good and as established she was from peasant family. Thus no proper education, training nor meals. 4. Umm she was known as Saint because she claimed to see visions. 5. It takes years to learn how to ride and even more to do mounted combat. None of this would be possible for woman of her stature at the time. 6. They were if they were claimed to be saints that hear god. 7. They have when they are claimed to be saints. 8. This matters why? 9. They do if they are used as saints. 10. They do if they are saints. 11. Not until she was proclaimed as saint that gets visions from god. 12. I don't see how having bad temper qualifies one as warrior. If something it's the opposite since in military hierarchy and discipline is everything. 13. Actually they do. In fact canons and hand-canons were precisely taught to peasants because how easy it was to learn to use them. 14. They are if they claim to hear voice of god. 15. I don't see how that makes her a warrior. Spy at best. 16. She didn't have until she proclaimed to hear god. 17. She went only after being proclaimed as saint. 18. She didn't capture him by herself... Her men did. Too easy, her entire thing was that she was "messenger from god" if you don't believe in god then your story falls apart.
1
@RayB1656 1. "Joan was born to a propertied peasant family at Domrémy in northeast France. In 1428, she requested to be taken to Charles VII, later testifying that she was guided by visions from the archangel Michael, Saint Margaret, and Saint Catherine to help him save France from English domination. Convinced of her devotion and purity, Charles sent Joan, who was about seventeen years old, to the siege of Orléans as part of a relief army. " Straight from wikipedia. Scientifically speaking claiming to have visions from angels would deem one as schlz0-phrenlc. So We have already established that before age 17. Se was 100% peasant without any military or muscle training in the backround. We also have established by the sources that she was used to demoralize enemy. After all... she claimed she had visions from the angels themselves. Thus affecting morale of own troops and enemy troops. 2. Wikipedia literally states that she was from peasant family. Stop lying. 3. One still needs decades of training to become good and as established she was from peasant family. Thus no proper education, training nor meals. 4. Umm she was known as Saint because she claimed to see visions. 5. It takes years to learn how to ride and even more to do mounted combat. None of this would be possible for woman of her stature at the time. 6. They were if they were claimed to be saints that hear god. 7. They have when they are claimed to be saints. 8. This matters why? 9. They do if they are used as saints. 10. They do if they are saints. 11. Not until she was proclaimed as saint that gets visions from god. 12. I don't see how having bad temper qualifies one as warrior. If something it's the opposite since in military hierarchy and discipline is everything. 13. Actually they do. In fact canons and hand-canons were precisely taught to peasants because how easy it was to learn to use them. 14. They are if they claim to hear voice of god. 15. I don't see how that makes her a warrior. Spy at best. 16. She didn't have until she proclaimed to hear god. 17. She went only after being proclaimed as saint. 18. She didn't capture him by herself... Her men did. Too easy, her entire thing was that she was "messenger from god" if you don't believe in god then your story falls apart.
1
@RayB1656 1. "Joan was born to a propertied peasant family at Domrémy in northeast France. In 1428, she requested to be taken to Charles VII, later testifying that she was guided by visions from the archangel Michael, Saint Margaret, and Saint Catherine to help him save France from English domination. Convinced of her devotion and purity, Charles sent Joan, who was about seventeen years old, to the siege of Orléans as part of a relief army. " Straight from wikipedia. Scientifically speaking claiming to have visions from angels would deem one as schlz0-phrenlc. So We have already established that before age 17. Se was 100% peasant without any military or muscle training in the backround. We also have established by the sources that she was used to demoralize enemy. After all... she claimed she had visions from the angels themselves. Thus affecting morale of own troops and enemy troops. 2. Wikipedia literally states that she was from peasant family. Stop lying. 3. One still needs decades of training to become good and as established she was from peasant family. Thus no proper education, training nor meals. 4. Umm she was known as Saint because she claimed to see visions. 5. It takes years to learn how to ride and even more to do mounted combat. None of this would be possible for woman of her stature at the time. 6. They were if they were claimed to be saints that hear god. 7. They have when they are claimed to be saints. 8. This matters why? 9. They do if they are used as saints. 10. They do if they are saints. 11. Not until she was proclaimed as saint that gets visions from god. 12. I don't see how having bad temper qualifies one as warrior. If something it's the opposite since in military hierarchy and discipline is everything. 13. Actually they do. In fact canons and hand-canons were precisely taught to peasants because how easy it was to learn to use them. 14. They are if they claim to hear voice of god. 15. I don't see how that makes her a warrior. Spy at best. 16. She didn't have until she proclaimed to hear god. 17. She went only after being proclaimed as saint. 18. She didn't capture him by herself... Her men did.
1
@RayB1656 You clearly never read her history. She was from peasant family. This is literally straight from wiki. All the other things you refered here was after she had proclaimed to get visions of god. Your argument would make sense if she owned all of those things before she was 17. Which isn't the case. She got all of those privileges because they thought she was messenger of god. I had longer rebuttal but for some reason youtube didn't like me posting it so this one was summed up version. You don't become super genius general who can fight against stronger people within 2-years.
1
@Kensuke0987 name tactic she did
1
@Kensuke0987 We have witness accounts in today's world about miracles of Kim Yong Ill doing impossible stuff. Does that mean they actually did it? She had no martial training. No muscles etc... If it was skinny dude with same traits it would be BS as well She was just a mascot.
1