Comments by "Omer عمر" (@Omer1996E.C) on "Who Wrote the Qur'an? | What Sources Were Used?" video.

  1. Many are going to al-muqaddimah from here, in opposite, im here from al muqaddimah
    18
  2. By the way, in islam, hadiths are considered to be inspired by God. While quran is 100 percent authored by Allah in islam
    17
  3.  @romandacil3984  your claims have no basis
    16
  4.  @andrewwake8607  I think he just wanted to upload the video after "al muqaddimah" did
    13
  5. Inoffensive? It's not offensive, it's just ignorant about the vast differences of the quran and other books, I was just watching an old video from "many prophets, one message" on YouTube, and the quran and Bible can never be copy of one another
    11
  6.  @TheFreeThinkingMan  muhammad never got out of mecca before the first revelation except twice, in the first, he was a child who barely knew his town, and in the second, it was with his uncle and other members of the tribe, and he had no contact with other merchants without his uncle at this only time. And let me remind you that, he had no contact with others without his uncle and he was illiterate, and those who he met spoke different language in the first place. So, calling him a traveling merchant is like telling that a chinese person who only visited LA once in his life, that he always visits LA Edit : he also got out of mecca when he was 6
    10
  7.  @andrewwake8607  yes, he did
    7
  8.  @andrewwake8607  thank you, have a great weekend
    7
  9.  @ghazanfaryaq6776  first, Allah made many miracles and gave ton of prophecies that happened and is happening Second, who said that Allah responsible to give miracles to you? You're talking as if Allah needs you or he's liable to you Third, Allah said that only honest and determined truth seekers will believe, others will not even if all miracles happened to them, despite of the many miracles in Islam. So, if you don't study the Quran and Sunnah (Islam), it won't come to teach you by itself, make an effort before it's too late and eternal punishment comes, disbelieving and especially polytheism is what Allah dislikes the most. You can ask questions or make your researches, I'm not a professional, but I know alot about Islam, so you can ask me. But I recommend you to learn by yourself listening to imams and Muslim scholars
    6
  10.  @ibo9451  yes, that's a point too, thanks
    5
  11.  @markjapan4062  just give us one mistake, it's surely your mistake
    4
  12. That's not faiiiir
    4
  13. Well, usefulcharts is adding points from itself about the quran. A toxic additions to muslims, as if the prophet was trying to brilliantly copy the Talmud and gospel and add his spies into it. Something that we hear many times from evangelists. This raises our concerns about this videos. And also many other things like 'dhul qarnayn', who definitely isn't Alexander, but still, he's sticking it to Alexander.
    3
  14.  @TheFreeThinkingMan  I couldn't find any, can you send me a link please?
    3
  15.  @UsefulCharts  oh
    2
  16. @Stiffytheenlightened  for example...? For each "science" you mentioned, give an example. Outdated you said, what's outdated? Is anything your forefathers believed in and you don't considered "outdated?" Like how democracy was outdated during the byzantine era
    2
  17.  @TheFreeThinkingMan  yes he traveled many times, but after the revelation and migration, which cannot be counted
    2
  18.  @TheFreeThinkingMan  so, you are talking about when the prophet got out when he was 25, and I told you that he was under the supervision of his uncle and never had a chance to learn, but to trade
    2
  19.  @TheFreeThinkingMan  i don't mean literally, since he went for trade, of course he did communicate. But with different languages, how could he understand and study an ideology in few days where he didn't know anybody and nobody was there to talk to him in the first place
    2
  20.  @alangervasis  those claims he made are debunked many times by scholars, instead of repeating the same mistake, he could've changed it
    1
  21.  @mekhimkl2702  hadiths, sira and sunnah are different things that are all related to the prophet PBBUH. But actions of the people are termed as 100 percent authored by the people. Don't get confused, hadiths and actions of people or even the prophet PBBUH (sunnah) are different things
    1
  22.  @TheFreeThinkingMan  child? You mean when he was 6? Can we say that the prophet started his immense project when he was 6? Does this count?
    1
  23.  @naurahdeatrisyagitany8365  yes, this was the time he got out with his uncle that i mentioned earlier
    1
  24.  @CochinKerala  zul qarnayn is not a prophet, and he's definitely not Alexander
    1