Youtube comments of Dayannah Kali (@dayannahkali).
-
31
-
8
-
8
-
4
-
4
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Oooh this is really interesting because I can heavily recognize some of my own patterns there. I am have been convinced by anatmanism from a young age, and even when I were deep in monotheism, my major was negative theology, I would consider anything else bigotry. Now I gave-up all belief, which may be the core practice of anatmanisme. I became very much materialistic and therefore my major is nihilism, or more precisely absurdism. Of course, there are no concrete practice behind those concepts and wandering in the void is really depressing. Some times, and just for a few months, I would be very passionate about a particular subject or activity, so I dive in far and fast, but as soon as I am deep enough to the level of conversation of the experts on the subject, or have a kind of competence about a practical thing, it would immediately nauseate me, so I would give in a bad depression for a few months until a new object of interest hits me. As I refute all personal responsibility on that process, because self is an illusion and everything is deterministic, right, I seem to have no grasp on my life. I have a pension for being recognised with psychotic invalidity.
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
This story was sad. Idk what you are doing in the US, but here in France, we have transexuals obviously, but almost none of your problems. I think it can be mostly because the medical stuff is not as drown to moneymaking as it is in the US, although there is obviously money in that field. State money I may add. There is less incentive to get a vaginoplasty I think. For myself, I only take feminine hormones and have been castrated, and I find it sufficient. In reality, I may add soon a little bit of testosterone, in order to be in the normal feminine range and regain some desire, because it is currently very low. The world is being crazy around the trans question, but in reality, it is a very niche medical stuff, and not a very big deal. Caution is important of course, but almost every trans person is satisfied and live quietly, without any woke virus or whatever.
I think that the Right is surfing on something, and the more it rides the wave, the bigger the wave becomes.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
+1 for the sponsor. Not for the border-transphobic shit. Of course, there are consequencies to pre- and post- sex hormone exposure.
I'd say that both woke and conservatives tend to forgot that the primary thing is biologie and the secondary is behavior. That pseudo-consensual collective delirium that the civilisation is, with its own secular fashion, is not even fifth in this ontological list.
Gender, values, community, that's not solid...
So, this gender confusing discussion is taking soooo much space because there are strong emotions at play.
No need.
APART FOR A FEW EXCEPTIONS, you need female sex hormone exposure in utero, and during puberty and pregnancy. Some females can use testosterone and keep fertility, but the treatment should be stoped to ensure and already risky pregnancy.
In regard to the general aspect of the conversation, I'd say that there are around 2% of the people that are in need of hormonal substitution treatment, either intersex by birth or by artificial transition. The treatment give the desired puberty and generally offers sufficiant sex-specific traits, both physical and neuro-behavioral, to ensure the inclusion of the subject in the binary gendered humain comunities. Apart for a few terfs and some men craving for minority-arassment I mean.
And yes, I just said there are only 2 healthy sex hormone regimen and that it is in direct corelation with behavior. And that one can artificialy switch regimen and acquire secondary sexual caracteristics.
For the rest of it, that is just a matter of semantics... Yes, biological sexes and stereotypical gender rôles have been forged as one concept over history and cutting it in two may be painfull for conservatives and may provoque delirum of woke people.
That is however a necessary surgery for this minority that I am part of...
And for both sexes, with margins and in between (biology is fascinating indeed), to be able to express themselves out of the boring ordinary would be plenty.
If you wanna sell japanese knives, you have to tell the name and the hardness of the steel.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@YassenChapkanov I am East-leaning on this aspect of philosophy, so maybe a little biased towards anatmanism, which is to say that there is no being per se, only layers of illusion. As Y.Harari puts it, the self would be a brain algorithm, and as complex it may be, it would only be mechanical, entirely determined. So, basically not a "self" capable of "freedom" as we intuitively understand those terms. Language is the web of illusions, as medieval nominalists could have said.
So, also there are reasons in favor of the idealist approach, there are obvious ones too for the deterministic viewpoint. Even in various theology you can find both types of texts, and usually those claiming positive theology would be more secular (take responsability, honor society, etc) an those insisting on negative theology more mystical.
(Pardon my English, it's not my native.)
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Actually, it is not a very unified community and many mature trans people of both sexes think very differently. Differently from woke youngsters, but more importantly differently from one another. And they are the vast majority of trans people, the average age at transition being relatively high. For me, I would have very much preferred a female puberty in my teens. Having to play a father’s role in growing 3 kids was not in any case a pleasant experience for me or a sane balanced one for them. Would have been very glad to be sterile from the beggining. Fertility shall not be such a sensitive subject. Yeah, we have huge Darwinian drives, but modernity had hack surviving rate and now we are far too many people. More so, if an animal population is being too crowded, you’ll begin to see some forms of hormonal troubles, leading to both infertility and anomalies in sexual health or conformation. Nature regulates. Political views and trends are not a social construct or mental illness from bad people, they are mere consequences of the mechanical realities. And that desn’t make them of any particular values. We are humans, human hacks. We now have to hack nature itself.
I am an experiment on the biology of angels, the very embryo of the post-human androgyn, I am a feminized eunuch, a real transhuman hoping for further progress in bioengineering. Not for myself. The self does not exist per se. For the bettering of evolution itself. The form needs change or to meet an end. Change is funnier.
1
-
1
-
1
-
I have an issue with wokism, and it is existentialism. As a materialist, I am a pure essentialist, so I do not consider that any social construct, like gender, has any ontological value, or reality. The only difference between male and females is sex hormones regimen, wich influences both form and behavior. So I am very much against including testosterone driven bodies into the lady category and vice versa. On that point, I side with transphobic people's concerns. However, we need to educate very largely about the effect and role of hormones, wether endogen or bioidentical exogenous medical hormones, because that is all there is to understand about trans issues. The rest is cosmetic.
I am a trans woman, but I like to define myself as a feminised eunuch, the modest embryo of the post human androgyn. I can say that now that I am free from nature's tyranny that sex drive is, I side more with the transhuman agenda than with the queer theory I was so found of back when I had a sex life. I think this whole epoch and trans agitation is merely the premises of a big transhuman change of the entire specie I advocate for, while watching all this hysteria with great intellectual distance and ironic amusement.
1
-
1
-
Note that hormonal replacement therapy provoque a regular 5 years puberty, with tremendous changes both in the brain (drives, behavior etc) and in the body. Gender ideology and human phantasms are of no importance. After the second puberty, the individual is pretty much aligned with the "goal sex", dick or no dick. Trans' penises cannot, by any length, commit rape or abuse. I speak about real medicated transwomen here, or feminised eunuque, those with the tiny shrinked stuff, not the woke abomination.
Now, there is more and more people in between, what are we gonna do? Women spaces are safer until then, for all people with no testosterone and high estrogen, which are very binary.
1
-
1
-
People have no idea how estradiol makes an organism female. Not your classic female of course, that a kinda artificially intersex condition, but females in many aspects. I am forty, only 2 years in hormonal therapy, and people, mostly, strike me as a woman, same soft skin, odor, fat distribution, butt, boobs, same energy, sex drive... And that is absolutely without makeup or dresses, only a quick regular face shave and sportwear. So, we are as much female as many other intersex feminine people nobody has problem with. Is it too much to ask asilum in ladies room in order to be protected from those ugly rapist chimps that are in the other room ?
I too am bored with woke claims, they think biology is unimportant, I think biology is all there is, the rest being precisely a dream, a collective psychosis, an existential social construct.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1