Comments by "Ton Bong" (@tongobong1) on "Why did the Celts Collapse?" video.

  1. You forgot to mention western Austrians and Swiss people where Celtic genes are still dominant.
    5
  2.  @Qballycus77  Yea history is a big bad joke since only the winners wrote it and they wrote many lies about what really happened. This is why so many think Austrians are Germans while DNA showed that Austrians are mostly Celts and Slavs and have few German genes. Hungarians have close to zero Magyar genes and are mostly Slavs too. On the other hand Croats, Serbs, Bosnians, Macedonians and Bulgars are not Slavs despite they speak Slavic languages. Finally the big fat lie about nazis and fascists that socialist spread since the end of WW2. Nazis and fascists were actually socialists so they were leftish. They mixed socialism with nationalism.
    4
  3.  NFX  Austrians are NOT Germanic at all. They are Celts first with around 20% and then slavs 19% and then old north Europeans 12% and only then Germanic with around 10% and even a bit Anatolian, Greek and old European from balkan each around 10% Slavs originaly came from Ukraine. Hungarians are Slavs first around 30% and close to zero Magyars - those that brought them Hungarian language. Hungarians have some Celtic and very few Germanic genes. They have around 20% old European balkan genes.
    3
  4.  @Qballycus77  I am right or at least much closer to the truth than the "official" history that winners wrote. Imagine what kind of crazy history we would have if nazi Germany would win the war... I wish historians would do more to uncover the truth because it is quite easy. All you have to do is to study all sides involved and then logically connect the facts. Then it is quite easy to spot lies because it is hard to connect them to other facts...
    2
  5. The map is wrong. Celts also lived in modern Slovenia.
    2
  6. Celts were Slavicized in south and east Austria, Slovenia, Slovakia, Czechia and Hungary where they were first Slavicized and then Hungarized.
    2
  7.  @camerondon3712  you should start in Austria. Western Austrians from Salzburg and west are actually Celts first by genetics.
    2
  8.  @feontop8216  Slavs also invaded Celtic lands in Austria and Slovenia
    2
  9.  @jokerofmorocco  And Slavic invasion in Austria, Slovenia, Slovakia and Hungary
    1
  10.  @CIA.2024-u9b  Huge difference. Germanic is subgroup of R1b while old north Europeans haplogroup is I1. Germanic people are Indoeuropeans while old north Europeans I1 are not Indoeuropeans despite now they all speak Indoeuropean languages.
    1
  11.  @CIA.2024-u9b  no, Germanic people came from East around 4 thousand years ago while old north Europeans lived in Europe for 20+ thousand years.
    1
  12.  @CIA.2024-u9b  you can't mix haplogroups. You either belong to one or the other.
    1
  13.  @CIA.2024-u9b  just look for yourself if you don't have a clue about who is who.
    1
  14.  @accaciagame1706  italo-celts belong to different subgroup than germanic people. Celts are closer to Italic than they are to Germanic people also Celtic languages are closer to Romanic languages than Germanic. Austrians for instance are around 20% Celts, 20% Slavs and only around 10% Germanic.
    1
  15.  @user-dl1xz3mj3i  DNA evidence says that Austrians are Celts and Slavs far more than they are Germanic.
    1