General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

DonXardas
Military Summary
comments

Comments by "DonXardas" (@DonXardas) on "Military Summary" channel.

 @BroadaxeGrizzlyJones nah, just remember the USA blundee in Vietnam.
6
@jamesmorrow1646 you do understand that the "слава украине" is a nazi slogan? I mean they directly copied the "Sieg heil" slogan. It is one thing to just support Ukraine as a country, which I would not suggest but hey it is your right but you are directly supporting ukrainian nazis if you just say that crap.
6
Why should they? Defending is always more easy and causes less casualties. They kill more ukrainians and destroy more tanks with less effort. And while they are defending they can train new troops and prepare their own tanks. Later after Ukraine will waste most ressorces Russia can just come in and swoop them. And they need the time to prepare their troops/tanks because of the last few decades of corruption in the russian army pretty much turned it into a joke (if we talk about the commanding officers). On the other hand, on the global level Russia has not that much to gain from ending the war quickly. EU/USA will not lift their sanctions even if Russia would make advances. But their sanctions are so stupid, that they are hurting themselfs way more. In Russia the only people who actually auffer because of sanctions are the middle class, which pretty much does not exist there and some oligarchs.
5
There is a big flaw in your assessment. Pretty much all population of Gaza supports hamas. So per definition, they can not be called civilians. Thats why Israel as per that definition can and will not bomb civilians. Only terrorists and their collaborstors will suffer. But that is not the point and not the flaw. Because the whole population does support hamas, there is no permanent way to deal with hamas, with exception of what that siege. Or well bombing them to hell. Israel tried it all. They offered them peace and land. They gave them their autonomy. They tried to just ignore them and waste millions on the ammunition for iron dome. When they fired back at hamas positions, they always warned the people there to minimize death. Israel provided water, energy, fiel, medical support to Gaza. But that did not stop hamas and nothing will. Antisemitismus, hatred of Israel, radical Islam (I would argue there is no such thing as peacefull islam, but that is not the point right now) became parts of palestinian culture. Even if Israel would somehow manage to kill all the hamas fighters and leave everyone else alive, in 5-10 years there will be a new generation of new hamas fighters. Sadly Israel does not have a magic lamp to wish to divide Gaza population in those who are truly innocent (a very small minority) and all the hamas people. So for Israel to survive they need to strike hard and mercyless. This is not a war crime, but the only way for Israel to survive.
4
He said they will take no prisoners on the battlefield. If ukrainian soldiers would surrender before the cladh with russian troops, they would be taken as prisoners. Prigozhin said that because he probably hopes that ukrainian soldiers are gonna run away.
4
 @louise_rose it is always like that. People who have no clue are the loudest.
3
@benjammin3381 nope both are full of crap. But the whole Kursk offensive is just stupid. While Ukraine did manage to take some ground and Russian did "wet" themselfs, this is not gonna change anything.
3
Dude not even 100 years ago there was a country called the Third Reich aka Nazi Germany. In comparison to what they did, what Russia is doing right now, is nothing special at all. Germany was deeated on all fronts. They were occupied, pretty much had to give up their whole identity and pride (even those that were not related to nazis). They were the black sheep in geopolitics. Today I a jew am living in Germany. Other jews, you know those people nazis did try to exterminate, were living here already few years after the war. To say Russia has no future because of a small regional war is just plain stupid.
3
 @Pedro-js5oq I think his point was, that Russia never intended to have big territorial gain.
3
@annapodpora5493 he has an education, but he never really worked in that field. And I would not be sure how good his actual knowledge is. He was popular in KVN a russian comedy shows for students. And the universities let them pass a lot of exams without actually test them.
3
 @seanniemeyer5437 I think what he meant, that the russian forces are gathering at the third line. And not that the russian counterattack will start when Ukraine reaches the third line.
3
Not really, if you listen to most pro-ukraine bloggers, they say that Moscow will fall tomorrow or even that it was already taken. There almost no objective pro-ukraine bloggers. Well I know only one who is not spouting bs.
2
@emmapile2627 that does not make it false.
2
@chrisoconnor6187 i wozld not say that. In Vietnam USA army, that is supposed to be the best military did bot manage to defeat some guys (oretty much just farmers) with AKs. They tried Napalm for friggs sake and failed even then. And dont forget when a whole platoon or whatever got new defect rifles and because oretty much not a single rifle was working they all got slaugthered by the vietcong. I mean Russia did lose face and showed how incompetent they are, but they were expecting to have no resistance and clashed with forces that were preparing to go to war for the last 8-9 years. So yeah Vietnam was more of a blunder.
2
Yep and they decided to be idiots and die. Great decision.
2
I fail to see how this is the problem of Israel.
2
 @gunterodim1535 no dude, standard of living in Siberia is nowhere the Level of Europe. And it will not be for a very long time. Dont kid yourself.
2
Lets hope Egypt is not stupid enough to let them in.
2
@terjeoseberg990 actually they dont target civilians on purpose. They hit some, that is true, but the reason for that is mostly old/faulty systems. If they were targeting civilians on purpose there would be hundreds of thousands dead civilians. But how many do we have? Just a few thousand.
2
There are no civilians in Gaza.
1
@TheIronalvarohide dont think, just because Ukraine does not have enough ressources to last that long. They probably gonna "test" russian defense lines for a week or two. After that, they are going to start an attack using a big chunck or even most of their forces.
1
@TheIronalvarohide because their "bosses" say so? Ukraine needs a win right. Without any kind of progress the west is gonna drop them. And because Zelensky and his government care even less about ukrainian people, they are gonna sacrifice as many soldiers as needed to get more money.
1
@petergreenwood7731 a lot of things regarding this war are a surprise to most people. Because most people are uneducated and just keep gobbling all the bs, that media (russian and western) is dumping on them.
1
@alexbayer2365 maybe the younger ones do not support Putin, but those who are oder do support him. That is why he keeps getting reelected. I mean obviously he cheats, but he would not need to, russians would still elect him. But that is beside the point. I for example do not support russian government. They are mostly a bunch of incompetent, greedy and corrupt idiots. But in this war I am absolutly against Ukraine. Not because Russia is great or anything, but because sadly Ukraine is a pile of crap. Around 10% of the populatuon are actually nazis, their government has nothing to do with democracy and ehat they do to those who do not agree with them is just barbaric. So I would argue they are way worse.
1
 @ProcaviaCapensis-ts8ub if you are succesfull, yes it will. That how it always was.
1
Oppai_connoisseur the mobilization in Russia ended long ago. Dont get me wrong, Russia is a crap country. Not much better in comparison to Ukraine, except Ukraine has a big nazi problem. But pls stop spouting bs. There enough real reasons to crap on Russia. Educate yourself.
1
@prosvet123 well the first few dozen who rebel will get a bullet in their head. The rest is gonna overthrow the military, but a few dozen/hundred or even thousand people gonna die. Nobody wants to take that first step, cause that would mean they will die.
1
Probably because there are reliable numbers.
1
 @Bishop46066 oh no they absolutly have the right to ressist. It is just absurd for anyone with even a miniscule amount of grey matter to be on their side.
1
Nice joke.
1
@rainieresguerra4780 why is everybody pointing to the length of the war? As if the length of the war is what matters. There are so many points where Russia did f up that can be pointed out, but you people are really bots, just saying all the same crap without ever thinking for even a minute.
1
@rainieresguerra4780 yeah it is Important if we are talking decades like in Vietnam for example. In this case the war started just around 1,5 years ago. That is not nearly enough time for most of the things you wrote. Russian economy is not great, but it is doing fine right now. Russia can finance the war for years to come. And the only thing the west is doing, is pushing Russia towards China. You clearly do not know how or what most russians think about the "Wagner coup". Nothing at all. They either dont know or dont care. Most are blindly following Putin. So there is not gonna be any coup. And what most people dont understand about Russia, there is no real opposition there. In best case you get Putin 2.0 and nothing changes and in worst and more probable case you get some hardliner like Prigozhin. And he would have made Ukraine bleed. But somehow everybody wanted that. Well Ukraine is getting stronger only in theory. Look male citizen were not allowed out of the country, so even if the 6M figure is true, which I doubt, it is mostly women, children or elderly people who came back. That is not gonna provide millions of soldiers. Especially when by far not every ukrainian wants to fight. Also weapons from West. They did send most of what they could provide already. At most they gonna send a few more dozen tanks or so. That is not gonna change anything. West is getting low on ammunition as well. Well the EU is. They do not have production lines to produce enough. To build those lines, they would need at least a year and last year they were yet to start building them. Probably gonna start sometime next year. Also while training of infanery can be done in a few month, not like that will produce any great soldiers, training for tanks and or Jets is gonna take years. Ukrainians were getting just half a year for those tanks. This is not even close to be proficient with those tanks. And tanks are only as good as the people who are driving them. Ukraine is getting money yes, that is true. But you should not forget, that Ukraine is bankrupt and the only thing that money does is keeping it alive. Without it, the whole apparatus would fall apart. Also a lot of that money, military aid and so on is being put in private pockets of Zelensky and other ukrainian politicians. I dont think you know the meaning of "bottled up". Ukraine is attacking russian defence lines and losing a lot of manpower. While Russia does lose people as well, they lose far less, just like any defense line has an advantage. The 350K soldiers were yet to be seen on the battlefield. And your condescending tone, calling russian mobics, just Shows how biased you are. You do understand those are frigging humans? If you think it is okay to not see them as people, it is totally okay for russians to not regards ukrainians as humans, yet I think you are offended by that. Ah yes, the counter attack that has yet to provide any success. So just like I said bots who are writing about the same crap, without writing about real problems of Russia. And who think Ukraine is a superpower now. This is just sad.
1
Not really. Russia can afford a lot of losses. And depending on what Russia is gonna use they can sustain this conflict for a few years. On the other hand EU is not gonna be able to support Ukraine the whole next year. And after the elections cycle in USA is gonna start, Ukraine is gonna lose majority of the support from USA.
1
 @buzzhawk are you crazy? That will never happen. That would mean WW3.
1
 @jeffnorris8848 000 dead each day? Where did you hear that crap. But there are between 100 and 300 dead on most days.
1
@hannibalwantsahuggrande3433 I dont support genocide. If the palestinians did accept peace, none of this would happen or be needed. They wanted war and genocide of jews. I mean that is litteraly the first few points of hams charta. Now Israel need to deal with them once and for all or attacks like last Saturday will happen every 5 years or so. For the last 2 decades, palestinians have been doing that like zwice a year at least. Just not on that scale. And Israel does not deserve to suffer because of those savages.
1
@lukedalton you do understand that those batteries have to be lockated first? It is not like Ukraine set them up and is not moving them. So until they know the exact location, they are not gonna send any missles. That is why they were sending a lot of drones and other subsonic rockets, hoping to pin point the location. That is why ukrainian government forbids putting videos of their air-defens shooting stuff down, online. And while Russia does exxagerate their reports, they do publish true staff as well. The same as any other country. If you would listen to what ukrainian government keeps saying you would laugh your socks off. They claimed Russia has no more rockets over a year ago and just kept saying, yeah the new attack was surely the last reserve. And they keep saying that even now.
1
Well that is lie. He was not opposed to it. He had an idea, which as assumed was better, but would have never worked in reality. That is all. He praised USA and Truman for recognizing the State of Israel. So dont spout bs all while you commit one the most basic logical fallcies ever.
1
Why?
1
1. Israel is not imprisoning them. They are free. 2. Israel suggested peace and was willing to give them land multiple times. They declined. 3. The moment Israel gave them autonomy they elected Hamas as their government. Hamas are terrorists. Their goal was never freedom, it was ganocide of jews. Just read their charta. There is absolutly no reason to have any understanding or pity for them. The only thing people should feel towards them is hate and disgust.
1
Yep Egypt does not want Gaza.
1
@sabprogroup8623 cause Gaza is not worth it. In exchange for just 360 km^2 you would have to deal with 1-2 million (depending on which time period we are looking at) who are not just radical muslims, who not obly have a huge terrorist organization which was founded by muslim brotherhood, but who support those terrorists. So in a nutshell you would need to deal with up to 2 million terrorists and their collavorators. And Egypt had their own experience with hamas.
1
@mr.ninetails1646 I think votong is the most logical choice. The only problem is, that american political system and the 2 parties are total crap. Democrats have nobody who has two working braincells. Republicans have only a few people who are better. And while I like Trump, he is not gonna be able to change a lot. He can only make a few symptoms go aeay at best. And the only few actually good politicians/candidates like Ramadwamy sadly is not gonna come very far.
1
 @Anashadk oh stop with that bs. Nobody is saying that.
1
@Anashadk 1. No I dont live in Russia and dont listen to their propaganda crap. 2. I still keep up with their rhetoric and what they are saying. Like once every few weeks I will watch/read a compilation of all the crazy shit they are talking about. 3. And no they never claimed to want to attack EU or any european country. 4. There were some stupid clips of idiots like Solovjèv or whatever saying stuff like "In WW2 we marched on Berlin, and we can repeat (the victory)". But those are taken put of context. Nobody there plans to attack EU. 5. If you take quotations/clips out of context, you could make a bunch of clips of Zelensky wanting a genocide of russians or clips of american or european politicians saying any possible crap. For example the famous american "killing russians, best money we ever spend". 6. If you are claiming that I am wrong, by any means provide the evidance. As soon as you do, I will aknowledge that I was wrong. Until then I call bs.
1
If it was beautiful or not is subjective. I for once found it quite dull with Krim being the exception. But peacefull? You have clearly no clue what ukrainian people are like. Especially those in western parts of Ukraine.
1
@Volkan-uh2by except it was not a surprise attack. Ukraine was warned by Russia days and even weeks in advance that if they do not stop their "anti-terrorist operation" in Donbass, Russia gonna do aomething about that. And US/UK intelligence did know the exact time of Russia starting their "special military operation". All the government officials of Ukraine managed to get their families out of Ukraine a day before it started. All the oligarchs were notified before it as well and got out a day before. So no, there was no surprise at all.
1
Yeah except Gaza is bordering Egypt as well. And there is a big freaking body of water there as well called Mediterranean Sea. But yeah Egypt is not stupid enough to let those terrorists in.
1
Just read the reports from the UN, like for the years 2014-2021. What ukrainians did even before the war started was just sickening.
1
@seanniemeyer5437 it probably is. I speak both eng and rus. It is not always possible to translate the meaning. And not even seeing the original text makes it even harder. How do you know that? Cause I dont know that. And I can not imagine you knowing that. Or are you gonna say you work for one of the intelligence agencies? Russia did mobilize 300K people. We have not seen them yet. There very well could be a force gathering somewhere behind the frontlines. While I dont think that Russia is preparing something like that, it is quite possible. And nobody was talking about fully manning three lines of defense. Dont know where you got that from. You do not actually think that russians did destroy the dam?
1
No humans in Gaza, so how can it be a genocide?
1
@jamesmorrow1646 nonsense is the crap you are writing. 1. It does not matter when it was used first. Because Ukraine right now using it in the same manner as the Germans used their slogans in WW2 and they use it in combination of praising Bandera as a hero. For friggs sake, they even made him a national hero. A frigging nazi who is responsible for death of thousands of jews and polish people is a national hero. 2. Do you even know the story of the ukrainian war of independece? It was actually a civil war because of the October Revolution. And while communists were a bunch of stupid assholes and I hate the USSSR, the "ukrainian" side were no sainsts by any means. Have you ever heard of Petlura and all the crap he did to jews? Probably not. 3. Btw. I find it funny how all the pro-ukrainian people praise that war, cause "Ukraine tried to free itself from the Russian Empire". But when talking about Crimea they somehow say that it is a bad thing, even though those events are pretty much the same. There was a revolution in the country and a forcefull illegal change of government. Part of the country decides to separate. Nobody until now managed to explain what is the difference?
1
But do you want those parts?
1
 @zharkoo not anymore. Now they are just bombing them. And yes it is too late, csuse palestinians already killed a few hostages.
1
Your source being you pulled it out of your arse?
1
Ok, just for a second turn on your brain and think about it. Bradleys: how many are there gonna be? A few dozens? Lets be generous and say 100. Does Ukraine have enough people who were taught how to use them? While I dont think so, maybe they have them. Are they proficient with those tanks? Maybe a few, but the pverwhelming majority is not. You need years of training to get there. They had what? Half a year? So those Bradleys are not gonna change anything. Too few, too late, with no experienced drivers. F16 are even worse. You need a bre minimum of 2 years of training to be able to just fly in those. They are way too different from the SU Ukraine uses. And there are no facilities where you can repair, fuel and just keep them in shape. There are no ingenieurs to do that as well. So nothing is gonna change with those. Ukraine would need at least a 2 year ceasefire to just get in shape to even use all those things.
1
 @ivansemenov3734 except the pro-ukrainian channels (that are reporting objectivly) are reporting pretty much the same.
1