General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

Галина Брагина
1420 by Daniil Orain
comments

Comments by "Галина Брагина" (@user-iz9ge9xy1u) on "Should we return Crimea to Ukraine?" video.

always? Why was Kant a citizen of the Russian Empire?
16
@Northman-from-the-North I am a Karelian citizen ) my dad as a kid and my grandmother already heard it in finnish nazi concentration camp. there were 5 of them in Petrozavodsk, and some dozens in Karelia fo Russian people only. And Answer was given. Death rate was higher than in germany concentrations camp. About Russian in Karelia... there are chirches and monasteries very old. Solovetsky monastry is founded 1462, Kizhi from 17th centure - you can google
5
@TheZazatv he was ) it was when Russian army was in Berlin and after, and he never left tis citizenship
4
@hellion605 it was during 7yeas war when Russian army occupied Berlin, but Kant never gave up it.
4
@peter_meyer he was born as Prussian, but he wanted himselve and became Russian Imperia citizen, and never gave it up. It was after 7 year war after Russian army occupied Berlin
4
@Ikkeligeglad US and UK opened the second front when the Soviet Army already marshed in Europe!
4
the greate philosopher Kant who lived in Kaliningrad (Königsberg) was a citizen of the Russian Empire :) so go to study history. and... Germany MUST keep quiet
4
@hurairahabu24 it is joke ) Stalin was the first to annex Novorossiya to Ukraine on the map, he believed that the proletariat of Novorossiya must improve communism in Ukraine. Because farmers have their own bit of land, while proletariats dont have anything and are the base of communism. why - they were suppoused to vote, to create local goverment and etc. As Ukraine was a totally agricultural country, Stalin got an idea to give Ukraine this part of Russia (which was closest) where population was factorys worker mostly (proletariat) so how it was. All cities of novorossia were founded by Ekaterina the Greate in 18th centure
4
it is all translation, just the name of this region is NovoRossia, it sounds (and means) like new Russia, we have a lot of places names that starts from 'novo', Novgorod (859 year olds city)=New Gorod(city) NovoSibirsk = New Siberia huge city in Siberia is about 150 years old and etc. All cities in Novorossia were founded by Ekaterina the Greater - in 18th centure. Stalin was the first to annex Novorossiya to Ukraine on the map. At that time, Ukraine was a completely agricultural country, and the Bolsheviks believed that the basis of the communist system was the proletariat, so Ukraine needed the proletariat of Novorossiya/The proletariat are factory workers. All the main plants in Ukraine are Novorossiya.
4
@peter_meyer Kant was a philosopher, it is almost a writer, he wrote everething that was with him, and about everething
3
@jarls5890 yes Peter the Greate presented it to Prussia, but Kant saved his Russian citizenship
2
@joshhastieYT this video about the war, right? the reason, so find the reason,I alredy adviced American movie, where step by step the reason was showed. My advice was deleted because of the country name. this movie from Oliver Stone , it is from 2016, '---country name--' on Fire'. 2016 - but already 'on fire', check it.
2
@peter_meyer during 7 yeas war Kant became Russian citiezen, and never lost it. He wrote about Russia a lot. It was when Russian army occupied Berlin
2
@peter_meyer yes, and Russia army was in Berlin three times. By the way Berlin - berloga - a home of a bear )
2
@helgeschneider9069 if they are Russian, Russia has 100+ alive languages, and a lot of Germany people. We have Germany schools too. Now again Germany people come to Russia and they are very welcomed. If you don't believe, find here , just print in a search panel : 'из германии в россию на пмж' === from Germany to Russia to live. Ekaterina was a native Germany, yes. We are very proud of her, the second after the peter of Greate who got theis 'Greate'
2
@renemagritte8237 Ekaterina was a German Princessa who became a Grate Russian Imperator, and what? Historians wrote, Russia had not loved her, at first but she loved Russia. She made mistakes in Russian language, but wrote poems in Russian. We have 100+ alive language, it is not fault to have not Russian blood in Russia. Kremenchuk got a city status in 1765 because of Ekaterina order. Of couse Ekaterina was not founded all her selve, but all in the country was according to her will. And foundation of Sevastopol too. McKenzie was burn in Russia, Russian citezen, general of Imperator. What is wrong?
2
@Aksak012 he was a philosopher = writer, he wrote about Russia a lot. Later Peter the Greate presented this part with Kaliningrad back. But Kant did not give up his citizenship.
2
Vladimir who buptized ancient Russia was a Kiev prince, but before he was a prince of Novgorod, check on the map, where is it :)
1
@trevorsomers8344 we were the same nation, and Novgorod don't have any relation to modern Ukraine exept they are our common grat ancestors ) it is North
1
@trevorsomers8344 Ukraine - the country name speaks about itselve :) It means 'far away' or ' outskirts' , in old Russian -'окраина'. How it could be a root state? I stop, because I din't interested :))
1
@trevorsomers8344 history can't mention, fake source do it for you :) Founder of Moscow(1147) - Youry Dolgoruky was a son of prince Vladimr, it is all the same Russian people. And there was not Ukraine, Ukraine is ourskirt of ancient Russia - closer to Poland
1
@alsanchez5038 in google, they removed this information because of rusophobia, but there is documents. And you can check it with yandex . Yes, Kant was a Russian Imperia citizen and neve gavit it up
1
@hellion605 this 'crap' Kant wrote for everyone, he wrote a lot about Russia and Russians by the way, but you cant find it in google )
1
@viewtiful1doubleokamihand253 if you want understand how it works, you can watch American movie "Oliver Stone Documentary 'Ukraine On Fire" from 2016. And if you don't want to watch, at least pay attention : 2016 - but already 'on firer"
1
@rikibo861 Kant was a Prussian by bith, but he accepted Russian citizenship and never lost it. He wrote about Russia a lot by the way. He got this citizenship during 7 years war when Russian army occupied Berlin. Then Peter the Greate presented this city with a land around back. It was his will.
1
@triconte4418 I don't care :) may be from Mars?
1
@jansenart0 they will get :)
1
@peter_meyer Kant was a philosopher = writer, he wrote about all events himselve, about Russia a lot, and he never gave up his Russian citezenship
1
@peter_meyer Kant wrote with positiv way about Russia even after Peter the Greate presented this region back to Prussia, not about everething, but mostly. This time Russia was a huge power, Russian army occupied Berlin after 7 years old war. The statement we answer was that Kaliningrad was ALWAYS belonged to Germany. I decided to answer this with funny way with relation to Kant, to point that this statement is wrong. I see people can't get joke. But there is truth in any joke. this is historical fact, even if you don't like it. Kant was a Russian citizen and had good opinion about Russia. He wrote about it. He was a philosopher and writer
1
@peter_meyer not really, people know who he is. we have classical education, it means that any university education includes philosophy as a must. But there was a specific - it was marcsism-lenininsm. Kant was mentioned, and his ideas too among the others. But people know his name at least
1
@peter_meyer citezenship should be accepted. Kant accepted it. Moscovites don't. Why it is so important for you, Kant citezenship? Germany has a lot of great people. Kant spoke German, he was German, if he got a Russian citezenship does not change it. in Kaliningrad and in Russia he is a GERMAN philosopher
1
@AriesAstaroth which line ? I printed so much here about Kant..it was just a joke to stress that Kaliningrad not always belonged Germany. about Kant?
1
@AriesAstaroth I did not wrote anything about Roman Empire :) I wrote about Russian Empire.
1
@timonsolus I wrote about concentration camps in Karelia, which was occupied by Finnish nazi during World War II. Even Australia was at war with Finland that time.
1
@timonsolus the reason was that Finlandia wanted to take a land up to Ural. It was openly said to my family members in concentration camp in Petrozavodsk. And Russian people were supoused to survive like slaves of Great Finland only. There were a lot of kids by the way, and victims are still alive. in Karelia we have museums. Also Finish nazi kept siege of Leningrad where 1 million people died of starvation
1
@kostyash6549 I heard. this time your Mannerheim kissed with Hitler phisically (you can find photo), and planned the Great Finlandia already. Stalin did good thing, or Leningrad would not exist. According to your logic -> Finlandia did not have nazi , but concentration camps had, concentration camps for particular nation cant be without nazi. By the way do you know that before Russian Emperia Finnish people could not teach their kids in Finnish language, could not do documents in native language. only in Sweden. Finlandia got its independance easily, and before 1917 it was actually free, but could not have an army. As example, Finlandia under horrible Russian Emperia pressure became a champion on human right, the first country in Europe where women got right to vote. But after a week of Independance Finlandia attacked Russia together with US, Frnca and England. so... now you in NATO, ok
1
@kostyash6549 my message deleted. I heard. your Mannerheim already kissed with hitler and planned Greate Finladia this time. if there were not this move Leningrad would not exist. "There's no such thing as 'Finnish nazi'. Only Finnish nationalist" - no nazi, but there were concentrations camps? or no?
1
@guffenguffen8183 Do Swedens wants Finlandia back?
1
@etpashuijaa2106 my own dad and my grandmother were in finnish nazi concentration camp. The most horrible thing they saw when some hundreds of soviet soldiers were very slowly marched along the streets , soldiers were nake and it was lower -20C , locals had to stay along the streets and watch. My dad told this the same story to me every day his death. But a lot of victims are still alive. In the history of ocupation of Russia during World War 2 Finns and Hungarians are considered the most violent among the occupiers, it is common opinion.
1
@etpashuijaa2106 my dad lived in Petrozavodsk.- capital of Karelia There were 5 concentration camps in Petrozavodsk only. And in Karelia we have a museums, and a lot of people are still alive, because finninsh nazi put in concentration camps all Russian population including kids. They wanted to clean land from Russians. Everything is documented, and by the way finlandia payed reporation officially according Nurnberg court
1
@etpashuijaa2106 in Stalin's time international committee investigated anything in the Soviet Union? you kid me or something? a year after the war??? come to Petrozavodsk, visit museums better. there are a lot of facts and photos.
1
@hustensaftvernichter3785 I never wrote he was Russian. He was German or Prussian, for us he was German. But he accepted Russian citezenship officially. after 7 year old war Russian army occupied Berlin. A bit after Peter the Great presented this part of land back to Prussia, but Kant saved his citezenship. He wrote about Russia a positiv way, he was a philosopher = writer. I just decided to relate to Kant answering to the statement that Kaliningrad always was German. not always. It was kind of joke. But it is truth. In Kaliningrad all people think he was a great German philosopher.
1
@etpashuijaa2106 Finland paid reparations to the USSR in compensation for damage caused during the Second World War. Only 8,500+ Fins lived in Karelia before the war. this means about 4% .Russian people are native Karelian citizens. Petrozavodsk got status of a town in 1703. Kizhi from 17 centure, Solovetsky monastery from 1462.Russian built villages there from 11 centures or earlier. This time Finlandia was under Sweden, Finnish people were not allowed even to teach their kids native language and do documents. If it weren't Russian Emperia, all Finns would be speaking Swedish now,,
1
@etpashuijaa2106 1) I am native Russian, and yes, I heard Karelian languageS - a lot of them. I had two friends , I met them in summer kids camp, they were Karelian and did not understood each other. Almost every village has its own Karelian language , and they often don't understand each other. I was explained that before it was difficult to communicate because the deep forest , lakes and impassable swamps between vilages. If their languages are simalar, it means nothing. We and Poles have similar slavic languages , and what? 2) You don't know history at all. Peter the Great took Finlandia from Sweeden in 1714. And Finlandia was a part of Russian Emperia up to 1917. Everybody knows it except for you :) google at least before answer :)
1
@etpashuijaa2106 we wrote about WWII, why I would mention other one.Russians were 86%, and others were Veps, Karelians, and other may be not native nations. The fact that Russians are native in Karelia is that there are stone buildings from 14 century, cities. We also had with other slaves people one tribe centuries ago, and close languages, and what? Russians never had any problems with Karelian or Veps. They develop their culture and languages, nothing dissapeared as you suggested. During finnish occupation your nazi goverment tryed to free land from native Russian people, the same way as German nazi did.
1
@etpashuijaa2106 in 1918 -1922 Finland joined the interventionists - England, France and the USA. In the first week of its independence, Finland attacked Russia. And do not involve the citizens of Russia Karelians in the crimes of Nazi Finland during the Second World War.
1
@etpashuijaa2106 After Russia's withdrawal from World War I, German and Austro-Hungarian troops occupied parts of Ukraine and Belarus in February 1918, Anglo-Franco-American troops landed in Murmansk in March 1918; Finland entered Karelia, and Japanese troops in Vladivostok in April. These countries also imposed an economic blockade on Soviet Russia, seizing crucial economic areas, exerting political pressure on neutral states interested in trade with Russia, and imposing a naval blockade. There are many photographic documents, testimonies, captured guns and military equipment.
1
@etpashuijaa2106 on the morning of April 21, 1919, Finnish troops, who had already occupied, as mentioned above, Reboli and Porosozero, crossed the Finnish-Russian border in the Eastern Ladoga region and occupied the village of Vidlitsa in the evening of the same day, and two days later the city of Olonets, went out to the Yarn River, finding themselves 10 kilometers from Petrozavodsk, where they met resistance from the side of the Red Army units. The rest of the Finnish detachments at the same time cross the Svir and reach the city of Lodeynoye Pole. Anglo-French-Canadian troops are approaching Petrozavodsk from the north, the defense of Petrozavodsk lasted two months.
1
@etpashuijaa2106 1) my post you answered was about nazi concentration camps, nazists were in WWII, right ? 2) German, France, UK, USA, Austria, Hungary, Japan, Canada and Finlandia interventions - it was about 1918-1920 . last conversation was about this period. you asked to count the cities.3) it was not Finnish volunteers, it was an army - the proof is that the war ended with a peace treaty between the states. 4) 'in a week' - sorry for bad translation, I meant in a moment = very quickly. 5) People understand the current generation are not responsible for things that were in the past. But if there were concentrations camps, they existed, what to do? . But you tried to teach me that there were not any concentration camps, while my own family was there, and I am from the city where were 5 of them. And it is truth that Finnish people were not allowed to teach kids their native language before Russia came. Russian Emperia had 200 + languages, and only very small amount dissapeared, but this process is all over the world, and anyway we are proud still have 200+ alive languages, and 26 state languages (including Ukrainian)
1
@hustensaftvernichter3785 Пётр I принял императорский титул. Россия стала империей 30 августа (10 сентября) 1721 г Thank you for your answer
1
if Russia put army in Mexica... what a stupid question, it is not about territory, it is about surviving
1
@torkild8483 you can watch American movie, from Oliver Stone , it is from 2016. I cant print a full name of the movie or my post would be deleted. "-a country name- On FIre" instead country name put real name. Pay attention, 2016 - but on Fire. there is step by step explanation, it starts from a history, miss it, check what started in 2014
1
@torkild8483 you did not answer about Russian army in Mexica
1
@dixonpinfold2582 US army and other NATO are there. I know it is difficult and annoyng to invrstigate something. But I advice you just to watch American movie from Oliver Stone from 2016 . I dont print the name of movie or my .post would be deleted. But the end of name "On Fire". At least pay attention 2016 but already on fire.
1
@dixonpinfold2582 ok, he explained step by step with document. But shortly - after state cope in 2014 Russian speaking regions refused to accept it especially because the VERY first low of hunta was to forbide education in Russian language. Donbass bombing was an answer. so war started.
1
@dixonpinfold2582 one more my answer for investigation lovers. Donbass, the region which wanted independance after 2014, is very rich of gas. And the company Burisma was an owner of gas production factories there. And among the owner of Burisma - Biden son... so :)
1
@Debuskeur this movie starts as fiction, but then there are documents. you can forward it about 7 minutes. then it shows how it was step by step. And it is this historical truth that the VERY first low of 'new goverment' was to forbide education in Russian language. And think yourselve, have you heard about protests, demonstrations against this low? no, only first days in 2014 may be... then no(in country with 80% native russian speakers), but in freed areas there are found 200+ mass graves.
1
@TakAndrzejPolak if it was a part, it was not there? By the way as a main power.
1
@supahotfire9176 my answer was to the statement that Kaliningrad was aways German before, I answered that why Kant had Russian citizenship :) this funny way I just pointed, that the statement about Kaliningrad was wrong :) May be Kant had double citizenship , I am not sure, but he had, and he wrote good thing about Russia, he never refused,
1
@UncleBob-v6b I don't care about blood, she was Russian Imperator. point, British imperators have Russian blood, and what, they hate Russia
1
you don't know that before Russia Finnish people inside current Finlandia were forbidden to teach their own kids to Finnish language, they were forbidden to do officals docs in Finnish language. And only after the Russian Imperia took Finlandia under its wings Finlandia got it freedom. Afeer Peter tha Greate won Sweeden. In Karelia Russian churches amd monasteries are from 14th centuare, so.. Peter the Greate won Sweede in the beginning of 18th centire. So where is Karelia ... and were is Finlandia...in timeline
1