Comments by "Dima S" (@dimas3829) on "What if the Soviets had joined the Germans in the WW2? Would Nukes save the Allies? (Part 3 of 3)" video.

@misterscienceguy by the time UK would prodiuce more plains, Soviet and German air strikes would destroy English airfields from which to use such. Germany produced super heavy tanks, Italy with Japan super light ones and USSR medium ones, if anything, their forces combined could defeat any sort of land force by covering for each other's weakness. Level of coordination enacted at plan Barbarossa have shown that Germans were more than capable of success of initial strike, they lost due to negligence of logistics (same negligence that this youtube channel have put himself into about the whole situation) a few months later, but UK is much much smaller than USSR and even if they could push some invading forces back into sea, it still worked against Allies cause destroyed infrastructure would still prevent them from receiving help from Canada and USA.
9
@arandommobilebc2046 1. Situation in Africa almost neglected after first episode as if combined forces wouldn't be able to push all the way to Southern part of it. 2. Soviet forces at the west of India - totally ignored. 3. Italy rarely remembered 4. Fleet construction made into some caricature of itself with unrealistic scale. 4. Fuel delieverd from USSR to Japan and Germany - mostly neglected. 5. Air forces that could be relocated from USSR to Japan - totally negleceted. 6. Reasons of Japanese atacking Perl Harbor due to oil embargo - totally ignored. 7. Lend-lease being paid initially by gold - neglected (in the manner that American industry had no as solid foundation to it's expansion as in our timeline). etc. It's shit
4
same as horror such weapon would instill on civilian British population whose relatives and friends would inevitably suffer from it first-hand. IF anything, this would lead to civil war on the isles with population desperate to eradicate politicians that led them to ally with such monstrous allies as Americans.
3
@marrvynswillames4975 that's taking into account all that gold that they got not only from UK, but from USSR too. The industry needs resources, lend-lease was not free and as more and more British land and colonies' would be taken - the weaker American industry would become.
2
No, just no, the only reason why USA successfully used atomic bombs on Japan is significant air supremacy at the moment, you, on the other hand have pictured a situation where Soviet and German iar forces would reign supreme over British isles. It's not fucking possible for allies to use nuclear bombs in this situation. Also, as if Axis and Comintern wouldn't bomb naval bases of the Allies themselves. Also, the fuck about breaking ties between UK and USA if USA drops atomic bombs on UK soil, eh? If anything, civil war in UK would occur in your scenario.
1