Comments by "Cyberfunk" (@cyberfunk3793) on "Andrew Huberman" channel.

This guy was a walking contradiction, talking for hours making statements that imply free will and then stating he doesn't believe free will exists.
3
real life results like another metabolic health expert selling books that is self overweight.
3
@lukaszpatman6936 I just simply don't find it credible when people that are clearly not able to achieve a healthy weight give advice on the topic to other people. If he understood how to not gain weight, he wouldn't be overweight. I don't think anybody disputes that adding simple sugars to diet is unhealthy (as in sodas etc), but I believe a lot of the danger from sugar is tied to the weight gain it causes in excess rather than it being harmfull in general like I believe saturated fat often to be. So I don't think people that have their weight under control need to avoid for example all fruit because they contain sugars.
3
@roguecloud8735 I don't understand why you think knowing requires a free will.
2
The guy says he doesn't believe in free will while talking for hours implying repeatedly that we do, he implies we are making choices and even implies culpability "heartlessnes". It's incredible that educated people like this can't see their own blatant self contradictions and how absurdly their claimed positions differ from what they actually say.
2
@roguecloud8735 I didn't say it was unrelated I said I don't see free will being a requirement for free will.
1
@roguecloud8735 Why are you going on these tangents? You said " Knowing requires a will", that is the claim you are not able to explain or demonstrate when I asked.
1
@roguecloud8735 So when others ask you to demonstrate your claims and you are not able to, it's other people engaging in sophistry 🤦🏼‍♂ I don't need more nonsense from you, I simply need you to demonstrate free will is a requirement for knowledge. What you said so far is total rubbish no actual philosopher agrees with.
1
@roguecloud8735 It doesn't require that much knowledge to spot you don't know what you are talking about when you try to assert some link between free will and knowledge. My standard of proof is irrelevant when you haven't even been able to present any actual arguments for that claim. I don't need counter points to non arguments.
1
@roguecloud8735 You still did not present any arguments, why do you keep talking if you don't have any? What is asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidense, so yes I obvoiusly don't need anything to dismiss your non arguments, nuh uh is more than enough to do that. All you have is empty claims, questions and appeal to ignorance.
1
@roguecloud8735 You think "what can be asserted without evidence can also be dismissed without evidence." comes from Dillahunty? 😂 And I'm the one with the "smooth brain"? 😂I also never even used the term "emtpy question", you can't even read basic English? If you had an argument you could present it without asking any questions so it is obviously you that is deflecting here.
1
@roguecloud8735 You keep asking more stupid questions because you don't have an argument. I also understand perfectly well what it means to have knowledge and you obviously don't because you thought it required a free will 😂 I'm not asking you to grant a single thing, are you drunk or why do you keep getting everything wrong? So if you didn't think Dillahunty came up with it, why would you object to it then?? Something is wrong just because Dillahunty used it? You are showing what a light weight you really are in the field of critical thinking.
1
@roguecloud8735 What part of: "stop asking stupid questions and backup your claim instead" are you not able to understand? If you don't even know what knowledge is, how can you claim it requires free will?? 🤦🏼‍♂ You are refuting yourself here and I don't even need to do anything.
1
@roguecloud8735 I didn't ask what you think the problem with Dillahunty was, but tnx for confirming you are stupid enough to think something is wrong just because some person like Dillahunty said so. It was not a "Dillahunty slogan", it was a Hitchens phrase Dillahunty and countless other people have used. The validity of the statement isn't any less just because Dillahunty used it and I couldn't care less if you think he moves the goal posts or not.
1
@roguecloud8735 Yeah keep going on tangents about Dillahunty when nobody asked about him and it's clearly off topic what you think about him. You are desperate to change the topic after you failed on the first one so completely that after dozen comments you still were not even able to formulate an argument 😂 You made claims related to knowledge and then ask other people what knowledge is after you had already made those claims 🤣
1
@roguecloud8735 And implying something is self refuting isn't an argument you idiot. Don't you even know what an argument is? Is your Google broken?
1
@roguecloud8735 So back to stupid tangents about Dillahunty and Hitchens. You really are pathetic 😂
1
@roguecloud8735 "Tangents?" Yes things like whining about Dillahunty because he used a known Hitchens quote and then proceeding to whine about Hitchens also. Talking about everything else except the actual topic and making the argument that backs up the claim you made initially about knowledge requiring free will.
1
@roguecloud8735 I never said that all arguments have to be formulated the same way but because you have nothing all you can do is try to misrepresent what I said and continue debating everything else than the actual topic. You got nothing so have you given up even trying to make an argument already?
1
He eats butter to get enough cholesterol, when the body self makes all the cholesterol it needs 🤦‍♂️
1
@neinbruderja7519 How can they be eating too many carbs when they have less diabetes than the carinvorres, and it's been shown that it's indeed animal fats, not the carbs that cause diabetes? The people who eat the least fats and proteins and something like 80% carbs seems to be living the longest.
1
How about the link between lots of fermented foods and certain cancers that is seen for example in some asian populations? There has been some speculation this might be due to salt.
1
He contradicted himself countless times implying we are making choices and even implied culpability by possible being "heartless" in some situations. He is absolutely talking from both sides of his mouth and not even even recognizing his own self contradictions. Unbelievable that an expert can be so inconsistent with his beliefs.
1
@klondike444 can you demonstrate that everything like our choices are determined?
1