Comments by "Max Smith" (@maxsmith695) on "Biographics" channel.

  1. Really? Nope.
    6
  2. 295,000,000 Christians massacred in 20th century.
    6
  3. he was a good looking man.
    5
  4. That applies to many people ,not Dr. Joe.
    4
  5. Dr Mengele legacy is fake. He was never accused of one war crime by the war crimes tribunal. That is why he was freed.
    3
  6. You cannot understand it because it is invented material. Here is a hint - 99% of what you read about WW2, is fake news, or distorted to the extreme.
    3
  7.  @heyysimone  If you have a question on some wartime related issue, ask away. I am a history professor. My relatives come from a village 3 kilometers from Auschwitz. I know everything about the camp.
    3
  8. Dr Joe was only in Auschwitz for 4 days. He worked Dachau.
    3
  9. That story makes no sense like all the others.
    3
  10. Why nobody speak out in 1940’s 1950’s.
    3
  11. If he repented of his sins, he is in heaven. Same applies to all the Baptized.
    3
  12. In America, it is the least discussed issue.
    3
  13. The US military arrested Dr Joe in 1945 and held him for a few weeks to question him. He was set free and not charged. There has to be a reason the military tribunal had no interest in prosecuting him. He lived in Europe for 4 years then moved to South America, where he changed his name as did 150,000 former Waffle SS who cameo America. By 1945, 50% of the Waffen SS were 7 to 17. That is NOT the image Hollywood wants to made public when they make fictional movies.
    3
  14. Hitler was a Socialist. NAZI is a word created in 1955.
    3
  15. totally false.
    3
  16. Fake news. Not one atrocity story of him, was ever heard of or published in the 20 years after the war. He only became a boogie man in 1985. Then 100,000 stories of him appear out of nowhere.
    3
  17.  @ryanmoore7283  - The actual experts from that era sought any evidence, and found none. I don't buy the created hearsay that surfaced 40 years after the era, and has grown into an industry.
    3
  18. And recall when you hear things, 99% is fake. You need to research to learn the truth. The publicly identified experts are often completely uneducated and those titles are more akin to political connections rewarding a person.
    3
  19. There is a lot of talk about Dr. Mengele and what he did in his laboratory, but when I look for the third party independent corroboration or forensic data, I find none.  The Red Cross had 15,000 boots on the ground in Europe and never heard anything either. There are no reports of atrocities  I have ended my unbiased independent forensic investigation of Dr. Mengele with a finding of no evidence found.
    3
  20. Once the war ended, the war ended. America became friends with Germany again.
    3
  21. He tested blood. Case closed.
    3
  22. Dr. Mengele was arrested , investigated and set free. The war crimes tribunal found no grounds to hold him or charge him. The case is closed. Stories that are reported after that fact had no standing. The War Crimes Tribunal placed ads in newspapers in 1947 asking for info on his crimes. There were no letters.
    2
  23. RED Cross published a massive report from 1936-1945 on the camps. Not one adverse word about Dr Mengele or Dr J.
    2
  24.  @heyysimone  My comments need no clarification.
    2
  25. God's ways are not our ways.
    2
  26.  @life-sf1oz  - Dr. j.
    2
  27. No citations. If you say it, it is real.
    2
  28.  @itzianasilvana56  LMAO
    2
  29. The War Crimes Tribunal arrested him in 1946 and held him for 9 months. They sought any witness of ANY crime he did. They found none. He was freed.  It was in 1985 stories were created about him. He ran a blood lab, nothing more.  Aside from standing on a platform 18 hours a day to greet 50,000 arrivals each day for 10 years.
    2
  30.  @bigdeal6852  Astonishing facts about Dr Joseph Mengele they try to keep secret. I here of this book from my friend.
    2
  31. History cannot be created by words. The stories were created 2 generations past his death.
    2
  32. THE US arrested him, investigated him and set him free in 1947. He lived in Germany for a few years and retired to Argentina. No claims were made against him in 1947.
    2
  33. The role of Dr. Mengele and his staff of 30 medical doctors at Auschwitz was to screen all incoming persons to the camp for medical issues. All those who were brought to the camp were required get a hair cut, take a shower and given new clothing. Delousing chambers for clothes and bedding were on site to rid them lice and other bugs that might be bought into the camp. This was the protocol in every labor camp. Dr Mengele was the medical doctor who ran the medical unit and his staff of 30 doctors and nurse assistants would be the persons to screen people. The idea every person had a face to face encounter and chat with Dr Mengele is information that appeared in public discussion after 1985.  Does every patient in a hospital today have a personal encounter with the CEO of the hospital.   There is no prior years corroboration of these encounters I can find.
    2
  34. The Germans won every Nobel Prize in Chemistry, Mathematics and Medicine, up to 1945. After 1945, the Nobel Committee under went a big change of seating, and they were awarded none.  Germans are exceedingly smart. Nobody can deny that.
    2
  35. It is used as a pejorative to silence people, but nobody knows what it means
    2
  36.  @gftk5566  1200 care packages sent into Auschwitz by family members each week, and they had food in them. They had plenty of food in them. Auschitz had a huge store and workers in the Buna rubber factory who lived in Auschitz earned a wage and could use script to buy items in the store, like candy, socks, combs.
    2
  37. the media says may things. 99% is fake.
    2
  38. The role of Dr. Mengele and his staff of 30 medical doctors at Auschwitz was to screen all incoming persons to the camp for medical issues. All those who were brought to the camp were required get a hair cut, take a shower and given new clothing. Delousing chambers for clothes and bedding were on site to rid them lice and other bugs that might be bought into the map. This was the protocol in every labor camp. Dr Mengele was the medical doctor who ran the medical unit and his staff of 30 doctoral nurse assistants would be the persons to screen people. The idea every person had a face to face encounter and chat with Dr Mengele is information that appeared in public discussion after 1985. Does every patient in hospital today have a personal encounter with the CEO of the hospital. There is no prior years corroboration of these encounters I can find.
    2
  39. Stalin killed 300,000,000. The history books treat him as a statesman.
    2
  40. blood experiments are research.
    2
  41. Maybe the story you are hearing is propaganda.
    2
  42. Americans dont believe the media.
    2
  43. Be what way. Dr Mengele was a high IQ intellectual who studied blood types.
    2
  44.  @CFAshow5359  Or this is just more invented hearsay. If Vrba story is hearsay and Wiesel completely made up his story...there is no end to the lies.
    2
  45. Where exactly did the Fuhrer ever say he wanted a MASTER RACE. Unless there are actual documents signed and authenticated then it cannot be considered a legitimate comment.  Maybe you should read the1946 RED CROSS report on the camps, review the actual camp entry log data, made public in 1991 and the 1978 declassified USAF weekly camp photos and see what those official sources show in terms of evidence.
    2
  46.  @ryanmoore7283  I am a researcher.
    2
  47. He was cleared by the War Crimes Tribunal AFTER his arrest.
    2
  48. The Fuhrer wanted to expel the Jews beginning in 1933.
    2
  49. He was free in 1947 when it was concluded he committed no war crimes. US told Israel keep your hands off him. or that western wall ( Fort Antonio in reality) will be no more.
    2
  50. He was a double doctor, MD and Ph.D. He carried out simple blood experiments in a lab with 30 other doctors, when he got a break from his 18 hour posting at the main gate where he inspected 25,000 arrivals each day.
    2
  51.  @gupadre8255  no receipts , no crime.
    2
  52.  @nopartyleftthatsworthit4330  I don't think the 98% were too concerned about the opinions of the 2%.
    2
  53. Bush Sr killed 1,000,000 and his son 2,000,000. They get a pass.
    2
  54.  @spacechip3386  - The War crimes tribunal cleared him of ANY crime. Someone is creating fake news.
    2
  55.  @jamesjameson2294  He field of expertise was blood testing.
    2
  56.  @spacechip3386  Said who ?
    2
  57. He was arrested in 1946 and held by police. The local war tribunal placed ads in the paper, asking anyone with information on HIS crimes to come forward. Nobody came forward. He was freed. He lived 3 years in Germany and moved to South America. He was not a war criminal. The stories that he WAS a war criminal started in 1985. There is no evidence to support him carrying out one crime. And it is only evidence upon which a person is judged. Not rumor.
    2
  58.  @gupadre8255  No receipts, no crime.
    2
  59. Are you denying Hell? Hell is real.
    2
  60.  @grandcanyon-fu9zt  You have no idea.
    2
  61. I had the impression the allies lost their minds.
    2
  62. Nobody can say
    2
  63.  @Sherrie510  I love Argentina.
    2
  64. He had 3 eyes.
    1
  65. All are true.
    1
  66. Wrong, he went to Argentina in 1956.
    1
  67. Before 1985 nobody had anything bad to say about him. Interesting.
    1
  68. The role of Dr. Mengele and his staff of 30 medical doctors at Auschwitz was to screen all incoming persons to the camp for medical issues. All those who were brought to the camp were required get a hair cut, take a shower and given new clothing. Delousing chambers for clothes and bedding were on site to rid them lice and other bugs that might be bought into the camp. This was the protocol in every labor camp. Dr Mengele was the medical doctor who ran the medical unit and his staff of 30 doctors and nurse assistants would be the persons to screen people. The idea every person had a face to face encounter and chat with Dr Mengele is information that appeared in public discussion after 1985. Does every patient in a hospital today have a personal encounter with the CEO of the hospital. There is no prior years corroboration of these encounters I can find.
    1
  69. Zero forensic or photographic records or corroboration of his work. Hearsay created 50 years later is not evidence.
    1
  70.  @son2025  The claims materialized after 1985. Why?
    1
  71. Imagine a biker club - Mengele Angels. MC
    1
  72. Humans cannot be demons, except in comic books.
    1
  73. Ariel Sharon took that title long ago.
    1
  74. Dr Anthony is going to be receiving the Nobel Prize in Medicine. This thread is dedicated to Dr Anthony.
    1
  75.  @LukasZ_77  -They are all fake.
    1
  76. Why would her breasts need to be pressed together?
    1
  77. The US military war crimes tribunal disagrees.
    1
  78.  @grandcanyon-fu9zt  The role of Dr. Mengele and his staff of 30 medical doctors at Auschwitz was to screen all incoming persons to the camp for medical issues. All those who were brought to the camp were required get a hair cut, take a shower and given new clothing. Delousing chambers for clothes and bedding were on site to rid them lice and other bugs that might be bought into the camp. This was the protocol in every labor camp. Dr Mengele was the medical doctor who ran the medical unit and his staff of 30 doctors and nurse assistants would be the persons to screen people. The idea every person had a face to face encounter and chat with Dr Mengele is information that appeared in public discussion after 1985. Does every patient in a hospital today have a personal encounter with the CEO of the hospital. There is no prior years corroboration of these encounters I can find.
    1
  79. The stories are quite diverse, except he ran 30 blood labs and was rarely in the labs. The labs tested blood for disease and infectious bacteria. Not one story of torture, or cruelty to humans was EVER reported until 1983. The Red Cross had FULL access to the camps and spoke privately with those in the camps. We are to believe all the victims remained quiet until 1983.
    1
  80. we learned about him in our class, American Monsters.
    1
  81. By that logic everyone with a tool is guilty of some sin. That is not a logical statement.
    1
  82.  @loganburntitus6948  You said anyone who owned gun in Poland was equally guilty. I say anyone who owned a tool was equally guilty. Same logic.
    1
  83. LOl
    1
  84.  @godzillavkk  I am reading the biography of Elie Weisel. He escaped the gas chambers 4 times.
    1
  85. US Military set him free.
    1
  86.  @TheDragon-v7d  They are one and the same. There was a little more discipline with Hitler.
    1
  87. Wrong. Fauci is a terrible tennis player. Dr J. was very good.
    1
  88. wow
    1
  89. Nobody speak out until 1983, mama mia .
    1
  90. He was an MD and Ph.D. He oversaw 30 labs in one region and the labs tested blood for diseases and infections. He was ARRESTED in 1946 and held for pending War Crime charges. Not one person came forward to accuse the Doctor. The War Crimes Tribunal placed newspaper ads in 26 papers asking those who had information to come forward. None did. He was freed in 1948. When he was reported to have died in 1978 and this was made news in Israel in 1983, there emerged one story after another of people who SAID they were his subject and were experimented on. These reports multipled and soon numbered into thousands with people appearing on TV talk shows and telling how Dr Mengele injected purple dye into their eyes, or sewed them together with a sibling. Dr Mengele spent 90% of his time at the front lines and rarely spent more than a few minutes in the 30 labs he supervised. Some people claimed they met him 5-6- times in the place they were held.
    1
  91. The role of Dr. Mengele and his staff of 30 medical doctors at Auschwitz was to screen all incoming persons to the camp for medical issues. All those who were brought to the camp were required get a hair cut, take a shower and given new clothing. Delousing chambers for clothes and bedding were on site to rid them lice and other bugs that might be bought into the camp. This was the protocol in every labor camp. Dr Mengele was the medical doctor who ran the medical unit and his staff of 30 doctors and nurse assistants would be the persons to screen people. The idea every person had a face to face encounter and chat with Dr Mengele is information that appeared in public discussion after 1985. Does every patient in a hospital today have a personal encounter with the CEO of the hospital. There is no prior years corroboration of these encounters I can find.
    1
  92. Russian Khazarian ethnics have no connection to Palestine.
    1
  93. i guess exceptions can be made for anyone.
    1
  94. Very common.
    1
  95. Or a Nobel prize winer in Medicine.
    1
  96. He was an MD and Ph.D. He oversaw 30 labs in one region and the labs tested blood for diseases and infections. He was ARRESTED in 1946 and held for pending War Crime charges. Not one person came forward to accuse the Doctor. The War Crimes Tribunal placed newspaper ads in 26 papers asking those who had information to come forward. None did. He was freed in 1948. When he was reported to have died in 1978 and this was made news in Israel in 1983, there emerged one story after another of people who SAID they were his subject and were experimented on. These reports multipled and soon numbered into thousands with people appearing on TV talk shows and telling how Dr Mengele injected purple dye into their eyes, or sewed them together with a sibling. Dr Mengele spent 90% of his time at the front lines and rarely spent more than a few minutes in the 30 labs he supervised. Some people claimed they met him 5-6- times in the place they were held.
    1
  97.  @js99852  That is the back story.
    1
  98.  @js99852  - Those are the fringe stories tat everyone knows are from cranks. The mainstream REAL story is what needs to be shared. He only became a monster because he was dead. Nobody bothered him from 1948-1978.
    1
  99. Do what?
    1
  100. fake news.
    1
  101. Elie sat out the war in France. His own sister out him.
    1
  102. interesting. Did you ever take his class
    1
  103. War Crimes Tribunal held Dr Joseph in custody for 18 months and carried out a massive search for victims or witnesses to any crimes. They found none despite placing advertisements in 26 newspapers. He was freed. Joseph moved to Argentina in 1956.
    1
  104. That statement of course is a lie.
    1
  105. When I go on vacation, I always comment on the older citizens.
    1
  106. I wrote a book.
    1
  107. US cleared him.
    1
  108.  @MsJubjubbird  There were none on the hunt.
    1
  109.  @unholyiiamas  Christ denier?
    1
  110.  @twall91  Pure speculation. He could also be in heaven. The war crimes tribunal sought input from the public 1946-1947, on his alleged war crimes and none were forthcoming. He was set free. People can claim Herbert Hoover or Abraham Lincoln were mass murderers, 50-100-150 years after the fact, but without forensic evidence it remains hearsay. He was a researcher. But having said that, he is accused of sewing people together and injecting their eyes with dye and other such actions. Believe what you want.
    1
  111.  @ladydeerheart1  The crimes of Dr. Mengele could not be documented despite pleas by the Government War Crimes Tribunal, asking for witnesses to come forward. None came forward.
    1
  112. 98% of Germans supported them.
    1
  113. Mama mia
    1
  114. I aways hear both sides of any issue.
    1
  115. wow !
    1
  116. Legend has it he had last rites before the stroke killed him.
    1
  117. Few were ever aware but Dr Mengele had a small zoo built near his laboratory. He had several snow leopards in his zoo.
    1
  118.  @robert_costello  The statute, enacted in 1917, allowed local governments to make laws and ordinances to license the various forms of transportation used by Gypsies, like horse-drawn carts, as well as their businesses, any goods they sold, places where they were entertained and where they could rent property.
    1
  119.  @lrc9304  -It was a law to regulate gypsies traveling from town to town in caravans, and what businesses they could set up. It was not a statute to ban them from living in the State.
    1
  120. Was that what kitty Harrt said ?
    1
  121.  @blublebe2738  God does not dispense Justice, that is for the lawful authorities.
    1
  122.  @tomselby24  He ate well, never smoke or drank and exercised daily.
    1
  123.  @zenxel  He was arrested in 1946 and held by police. The local war tribunal placed ads in the paper, asking anyone with information on HIS crimes to come forward. Nobody came forward. He was freed. He lived 3 years in Germany and moved to South America. He was not a war criminal. The stories that he WAS a war criminal started in 1985. There is no evidence to support him carrying out one crime. And it is only evidence upon which a person is judged. Not rumor.
    1
  124. He was cleared by the State Dept, Department of Justice and War Crime Tribunals, and there were no claims ever filed on him despite a 2 year window with many Governments asking for information from the public.
    1
  125.  @angeldoe1229  Then why have labor camps ?
    1
  126.  @yesno4364  - Wow.
    1