Comments by "kristine Sharp" (@kristinesharp6286) on "What Hasidic Boys Learn | Moshe Krakowski" video.

  1. You can have a private school, but you have to do the basics. It’s the same for the Catholic, Christian, secular private… One in a thousand passed a basic skills test? That is unacceptable. If that happened for a public school administration and even teachers would be shown the door and changes would be made.
    2
  2. What does graduation rates matter when 1% or less can’t pass the basic English or Math tests?  @cohenlabe1 
    1
  3. You have been lied to.
    1
  4. Someone is doing voodoo math to trick you. Most male Hasidic students of high school yeshivas will learn. No idea who all you are including in the total where the average income is 100K of male students having been through the Hasidic Yeshiva high schools. If the stipend is 80K sign my family up. If you are saying as a family they earn 100K then you are talking about the women working and that is where they have a working knowledge of English and most often university. If you are talking Yeshiva university graduates those enrolled had a secular program in a modern orthodox school. Further if you are talking Yeshivas you are limited to a handful of neighborhoods where people make 6 figures on average. Most parts of the country don’t make 6 figures. Comparing the average of someone in the few communities that have Yeshivas that happens to have a job and including someone outside Chicago and southern Mississippi is an uneven playing field. Cost of living and wages very different in both places. If you are saying NY Yeshiva graduates earn more than public school students in NY it would be closer except for the all the students from abroad going back and forth to their country or territory of origin meaning uneven schooling and not having the language or an abundant enough alternative language community or being unattended minors with all sorts of upheaval to their lives. So how many yeshiva graduates earn under 100K? That was not in your comment. It was written as a way to trick a person reading it. I’m sure you copied it. It’s called spin. 82% earning under 100K, if the 18% is earning high enough it also could average out to 100K a year when taking the entire 100% sample into account.  @sunshine6522 
    1
  5. Why are the schools taking Judaism out of the home?
    1
  6. If they are going to school early just to do more of the day’s portion of davening they are not doing so at home. Where is the portion of the day they learn at home among brothers and father?  @michellelansky4490 
    1
  7. They are at school until 7pm and Shabbos? That isn’t nearly enough time with family IMNSHO. It wasn’t that way 100 years ago and prior to that. Does dad go to the school and daven with them and learn late with them? The task has been put to others. I don’t know if that is a good or bad thing. It is a risky thing. Every observant Jew lives in walking distance to a shul. Why aren’t they doing it there? Why is the school not attached to it so everyone who lives near goes there? With separate classes of course, perhaps. Separate wings.  @beans4853 
    1