Comments by "Miriam Weller" (@miriamweller812) on "The Russians Storm Avdiivka, Spirne, Ivanivka. Military Summary And Analysis For 2023.11.17" video.

  1.  @edthebumblingfool  Move from Kherson? If you mean that going on the other side of the river: that was because the Nazis bombarded the dam. Too high risk to hold that position in that case and they had to evacuate the civilians anyway because of this. After that there was simply no reason to fight with a river in your back (= massive disadvantage) instead of using it as natural barrier (= advantage).
    8
  2. The whole "under control" thing is nonsense talk anyway. Under control means, that this zone is save and you can't be attacked there. If you can be attacked there, you are not under control. By that: pretty much whole Ukraine isn't "under control" of Ukraine, for sure not the frontlines. You can argue, that some attacks here and there are acceptable, but for sure not when the enemy can just obliterate you with bombs and missiles.
    6
  3. Whole map thing is pointless anyway. Just red or yellow is WAY to simple to show the situation in modern warfare.
    5