Comments by "Miriam Weller" (@miriamweller812) on "The New Atlas" channel.

  1. It's not just the numbers alone. Range is still king in warfare, from melee times to modern days and now even more. When you got a shortcoming in range, is it numbers or even worse the ability itself, you got a problem you can't really compensate for. Tanks are not useless, but the reason they lost quite a lot of their meaning is just that. Even modern tanks got a firing range of around 5km. While that seems far, it's already way inside the killing zones of many other systems and with modern day surveillance, sneaking in with something big as a tank is also not really a good chance anymore. Western media loves to talk about how our oh so superior western tanks will one shot the oh so crappy Russian tanks. But that's not even a fight that will likely take place all to often. When it comes to the main front lines, drones, air force and (missile) artillery, wil be the main threat for any tank that tries to even get the chance for a shot. Russia for example got a guided anti tank missile system, very close to the Pantsir system, that can rip you apart pretty much any kind of armored vehicle at up to 20km range with upgrades even 100km. And that's just ONE system. As soon as you get close enough to fire yourself as a tank, you are not only already far inside the range of these systems, but then the enemy tanks and of course infantery is also close enough to you and of course Russia also has anti tank RPG. Tanks are really the least thing that will gonna make a difference for Ukraine.
    260
  2. 179
  3. 158
  4. 142
  5. 83
  6. 63
  7. 60
  8. 57
  9. 48
  10. 45
  11. 41
  12. 41
  13. 36
  14. 34
  15. 30
  16. 29
  17. 28
  18. 28
  19. 27
  20. 25
  21. 24
  22. 24
  23. 21
  24. 20
  25. 20
  26. 18
  27. 17
  28. 17
  29. 17
  30. 15
  31. 15
  32. 15
  33. 14
  34. 13
  35. 13
  36. 13
  37. 12
  38. 12
  39. 12
  40. 12
  41. 12
  42. 11
  43. 11
  44. 11
  45. 11
  46. 10
  47. 10
  48. 10
  49. 10
  50. 10
  51. 10
  52. 9
  53. 9
  54. 9
  55. 8
  56. 8
  57. 8
  58. 8
  59. 7
  60. 7
  61. 7
  62. 6
  63. 6
  64. 6
  65. 6
  66. 6
  67. 6
  68. 5
  69. 5
  70. 5
  71. 5
  72. 4
  73. 4
  74. 4
  75. 4
  76. 4
  77. 4
  78. 4
  79. 4
  80. 3
  81. 3
  82. 3
  83. 3
  84. 3
  85. 3
  86. 3
  87. 3
  88. 3
  89. 3
  90. 3
  91. 3
  92. 3
  93. 3
  94. 3
  95. 3
  96. 3
  97. 2
  98. 2
  99. 2
  100. 2
  101. 2
  102. 2
  103. 2
  104. 2
  105. 2
  106. 2
  107. 2
  108. 2
  109. 2
  110. 2
  111. 2
  112. 2
  113. 2
  114. 2
  115. 2
  116. 2
  117. 2
  118. 2
  119. 2
  120. 2
  121. 2
  122. 2
  123. 2
  124. 2
  125. 2
  126. 2
  127. 2
  128. 1
  129. 1
  130. 1
  131. 1
  132. 1
  133. 1
  134. 1
  135. 1
  136. 1
  137. 1
  138. 1
  139. 1
  140. 1
  141. 1
  142. 1
  143. 1
  144. 1
  145. 1
  146. 1
  147. 1
  148. 1
  149. 1
  150. 1
  151. 1
  152. 1
  153. 1
  154. 1
  155. 1
  156. 1
  157. 1
  158. 1
  159. 1
  160. 1
  161. 1
  162. 1
  163. 1
  164. 1
  165. 1
  166. 1
  167. 1
  168. 1
  169. 1
  170. 1
  171. 1
  172. 1
  173. 1
  174. 1
  175. 1
  176. 1
  177. 1
  178. 1
  179. 1
  180. 1
  181. 1
  182. 1
  183. 1
  184. 1
  185. 1
  186. 1
  187. 1
  188. 1
  189. 30-60 bullets for unexperienced people who will likely miss 10 times more - or hit other targets. Friendly fire still a danger even in modern armies, and a desaster, when you just merge random, untrained people together. Don't want to know, how many civilians were actually killed by other civilians or militants, even more when looking at the propaganda about "Russian saboteurs". Seeing people comment on this, most of them sound like they imagine (especially) a (modern) war like a map in a shooter game and you start somewhere, got your rifle and 20 shots and then you just walk around and snipe enemies form the back who stand around there everywhere, pick up some extra ammunition and go on, clearing the map. Then in reality they are for example in Kiev, actually hundredthousands people in the city, while no 'marked target' anywhere, but they stand there, go no clue what is happening at all, because they are just a militia and everyone around them could, especially other people like them, could be an enemy. Their idea of their heroism is, what will likely make them kill just other people like them or civilians. As you described the tanks: a modern army got all kind of technology to see you way before you can with your own eyes and way more clearly and that from further away than in any game peopel for some reason got in mind. Most stupid idea were those molotov cocktails., more likely to burn down the city than killing a single Russian soldier. They can barely make an ambush with 2000m range Javelin. Imagine a 20m Molotov...
    1
  190. 1
  191. 1
  192. 1
  193. 1
  194. 1
  195. 1
  196. 1
  197. 1
  198. 1
  199. 1
  200. 1
  201. 1
  202. 1
  203. 1
  204. 1
  205. 1
  206. 1
  207. 1
  208. 1
  209. 1
  210. 1
  211. 1
  212. 1
  213. 1
  214. 1
  215. 1
  216. 1
  217. 1
  218. 1
  219. 1
  220. 1
  221. 1
  222. 1