Comments by "Andrzej Barcelona FRLK" (@andrzejbarcelonafrlk6416) on "How is the war going? – Early October 2023" video.

  1. NATO isn't in war (if it were ...) - most of the members do provide aid to Ukraine, but not all. You can make similar list of Russia's losses, casualties, Sevastopol port isn't the base for the fleet anymore...
    5
  2. To Moscow? Have you ever talked to Ukrainians?
    5
  3. What is opposite? Isn't Russian army being destroyed according to you ?
    5
  4.  @chadhaire1711  Where did you get the 90% from? Where's the 1 million pls?
    5
  5. Thanks. mmmm... Do you realize that eg S. Ritter repeats Russian propaganda, at its worse version, calling for extermination of a nation ? Whatever happened on the battlefield, it was voicing Ukrainian defeat. BTW, is it one of these sources that claims 45:65=90% ?
    5
  6. And Russian losses pls
    5
  7. Being intelligent doesn't mean being wise. Vladimir Vladimirowich plays waiting for Western countries change their attitude, desperately imo.
    4
  8.  @S300V  me again, yes. What can I say - may be there's an element of wishful thinking, but this is the way I see it. The other is simply not compatible with last year and a half. We'll see after 15th October, it's soon.
    4
  9. Ukraine losing allies?
    4
  10. ​​ @claus-not-santa  What do you mean by 'all this' ? Lend Lease?
    4
  11. Well, if the guns are outside of the range of the enemy's fire (aviation?) If not, they need to be moved to avoid counterbattery fire.
    4
  12. What's Assange doing here?
    4
  13. S. Ritter the mouthpiece of Russian propaganda.
    4
  14.  @slimhope1  I don't question his service, also don't bring his problems with the law, but his attitude: calling for killing people because of their nationality, visits in propaganda shows on Russia TV... What's your opinion about it?
    4
  15. ​​ @chadhaire1711  Can you write where did you get it from pls?
    4
  16. Macgregor, the mouthpiece of Russian propaganda No, thanks.
    4
  17. Because you say so? You can be against, pro or indifferent, what you say it matters. Macgregor has been announcing Ukrainian defeat since the beginning, despite anything what's going on in Ukraine band in the world. His military career is gone long time ago, and he's not up to date (at least he says things that indicate so).
    4
  18. Where are the "new tanks" pls? And why Russian army use old ones, if "there are new ones" ?
    4
  19. You use to change the channel? Yet somehow you remembered to come here to write.
    4
  20.  @enriquelaroche5370  It looks to me you underestimate the US.
    4
  21. Who promised pls?
    3
  22. What makes you think so?
    3
  23. ​ @johnrr8854  Following this way of thinking, North Korea is at war against Ukraine, China is at war against NATO, and Turkiye is at war with itself, proving armament to both sides, Russia isn't corrupt at all, V. Putin is cristal clean ...
    3
  24. ​ @chadhaire1711 Where did you get this from? Is Igor 'Strelkov' Girkin and what he did in 2014 a joke for you? Do you know what happened to MH-17 flight ?
    3
  25. What is inaccurate pls?
    3
  26.  @andyhemmings7363  What's the basis of your claims then, pls?
    3
  27. Do the lives of soldiers of Russia's army matter?
    3
  28. ​ @Princip666  Do lives of the soldiers of Russia's army matter ?
    3
  29. Your post is a confusion (wishful thinking?) What arms are directed to Israel ? Artillery and shells ?Tanks ? F-16s? How many such president(s) has* been elected ? Poland isn't halting the support, it's PiS party blinking eye to the marginal voters before the elections.
    3
  30. How many such persons do you know? Because most of Ukrainians are in favour of fighting. You know that on areas where there's no fighting Russians kill, rape, torture, kidnap civil Ukrainians men, women, children , don't you?
    3
  31.  @AndersKittilsen  First, I wrote 'most' , not all. I realise someone may imagine that 'somewhere else' life is better, but in terms of corruption changing Ukraine for Russia wouldn't help, it not harmed. Your friends in Russia could confirm. BTW, anyone of them has/uses a car? Must have noticed fuel prices rising. But vegetables are cheaper, they say. I don't know whether this is the case in Crimea, thou. I read in Murmansk area oil used for heating is 3 to 4 times expensive- how is it possible ? So it looks much depends on the perspective . As it comes to mobilisation in Russia, it's officially partial, but hasn't stopped and continues 'in a silent way'.
    3
  32. ​ @S300V Do You know what's Godwin law ?
    3
  33. @S300V  Replacement? Are you new to YT comments ?  @Princip666  Do you think you can leave the troll thing and explain to a  @S300V  what Godwin's law is about ?
    3
  34. The question is how many can the mobilise this way.
    3
  35. Why?
    3
  36. Everything's going according to the plan? according to you?
    3
  37. Do lives of Russian soldiers matter?
    3
  38. Really? What's the "lie"?
    3
  39. President Putin said something opposite, do yo mind?
    3
  40. Look! President Putin can ousmart all and let Russian soldiers go home.
    3
  41. How is APN promoting war and death ? Who is the aggressor, killing, raping, torturing, kidnapping civilians, women, children...?
    3
  42. 4 years old?
    3
  43. What kind of stuff ?
    3
  44. What language do you speak in Australia pls?
    3
  45.  @merocaine  No problem.
    3
  46. What is your source pls?
    3
  47.  @chadhaire1711 Russia don't need? It's not coherent with what president Putin said (I know, he also had said Russia would not attack any country) How do you know the numbers? How could Russia increase tanks production ? You need specialists, and you need the same specialists to repair hit/damaged tanks, so there are less available, not more.
    3
  48.  @enriquelaroche5370  Corrected, 1942 - > 1941 My typo error doesn't change the heart of the matter. Without Lend Lease (L-L going to Ukraine), Russia's perspectives are dark , black. BTW, what American-delivered tank have you seen? It has been short time since they arrived, I think the crews are stil in training.
    3
  49. Arguments ...
    3
  50. What has changed since last winter, according to you, when Russia showed they cannot carry offensive?
    2
  51. What makes you think so? Do you know what are the goals of the offensive?
    2
  52. Anything aches ?
    2
  53. Russia stil keeps firing, but less and less, also worse.
    2
  54. Any basis for your claims?
    2
  55. Have you seen the other APN video (2 weeks ago)?
    2
  56. The war can end when Russian soldiers go home, don't you think so? They have a lot to take care there, btw. Also, may be you'd like to verify your information, as the Soviet Union wasn't defending US nor UK (instead, it was receiving Lend Lease aid) (The gas prices are at the same level as before Russian attack) You don't mention colonel Putin, why?
    2
  57. Any arguments?
    2
  58. * conscript :) Who?
    2
  59. It looks you confuse facts, dates and names. May be you could answer questions to clarify - who is I. Girkin and was he in Crimea and later Donetsk "before* Azov even existed? What is the definition of (pro)Nazi? How "overthrown" president can leave freely the country ? What are your source of 16 thousand casualties - who were they ? Are you saying colonel Putin is a puppet ?
    2
  60. What makes you think so?
    2
  61. Really?
    2
  62. No one. Yes, colonel Putin knows what mutual assured destruction is, he is not stupid .
    2
  63. In what way?
    2
  64. What's the situation, according to you / Duran?
    2
  65. Where are your numbers/ data from, pls?
    2
  66. Macgregor basically repeats Russian propaganda Ukraine lost, Ukraine lost, Ukraine lost despite anything that is happening in Ukraine and in the world.
    2
  67. ?
    2
  68. Russia suffers with logistics/transport, I'm not sure if they could move troops around (effectively) this way.
    2
  69. Russia started conscripting women with medical background some time ago, including midwives.
    2
  70. ​ @andykay2802  We in Poland haven't had enough supporting fighting Ukrainians, I don't know where did you get that from, perhaps you misunderstood the situation of transit and import of Ukrainian grain.
    2
  71. Do Ukraine recruit women to fight? You look ill-informed.
    2
  72. Really?
    2
  73. What makes you think so ?
    2
  74. What's the nonsense? Or, if you prefer, what is the reality, according to you?
    2
  75. Yes, lots of may be . The war. Can you make better?
    2
  76.  @KirbyAllen-s5l  What are the goals of this war, according to you? Because on the most important, political level Ukrainians won, they defended their independence, they have allies, then they have strategic initiative, on operational level Ukraine is carrying offensive... You say Ukraine is losing? Putin (Russia?) declared some phony aims, but none is achieved.
    2
  77. What's the sh*t , according to you?
    2
  78. The latter three are mouthpieces of Russian propaganda, despite anything that is happening on the battlefield and in the world. The choice is yours.
    2
  79. Anything to confirm this claim ? (ACC)
    2
  80. It looks you didn't understand what APN is saying. btw, are there any basis for your claims?
    2
  81. Slava Ukraïni 🇺🇦
    2
  82. Wait for future events
    2
  83. It depends on how the mobilisation is carried, I think. eg Russia took engineers and specialists, who are necessary now when expanding of the production is needed.
    2
  84. Really?
    2
  85. Really? Positional fighting? Like in Afghanistan? Really?
    2
  86. They?
    2
  87. ?
    2
  88. What's frequently for you? Where did you get the info, perhaps you could share the sources?
    2
  89. Any argument?
    2
  90. Pld share your knowledge, no Moscow propaganda
    2
  91. Any argument?
    2
  92. Everything's going according to the plan? You don't mention the wars Russia lost, why?
    2
  93. Everything like electronics chips, imported drones, trucks/lorries, satellite intelligence...etc etc etc?
    2
  94. Or to last Russian soldier.
    2
  95. What do you suggest?
    2
  96. What makes you think so ? Recent deliveries of air defence systems indicate the contrary.
    2
  97. Your source?
    2
  98. Really?
    2
  99. Negotiate what, according to you?
    2
  100. Why?
    2
  101.  @Princip666  What's that, according to you, in the first place?
    2
  102. Really? What is fake, for instance?
    2
  103. Destroyed equipment, Sevastopol ...
    2
  104. Could you share their social media, TLG, VKontakte , etc?
    2
  105. Have Russian troops been on offensive lately?
    2
  106.  @merocaine  Oh, "no idea" about Russian losses? Pity. I manage, you write "for the people". Pls. It's about the money your government lost. Do the lives of Russian soldiers not matter?
    2
  107.  @merocaine  It was not me, I don't know dimas blog.
    2
  108.  @merocaine  🤔
    2
  109. Why?
    2
  110. In a way, yes, but these are inexperienced, usually young, privates. They'll actually need help/attention/tome before they get used to real fight. You need officers and NCOs, equally if not more important. Not to mention eg tankers, artillerymen etc - you cannot train them on the go.
    2
  111. What's absurd pls?
    2
  112. Excuse me, they don't have enough. They haven't had since the beginning of the attack, so it goes.
    2
  113. Any unicorns in your fairy tale?
    2
  114. Oh, do you know when and why?
    2
  115. To do what, pls? I think sth is missing in your sentence.
    2
  116.  @enriquelaroche5370  We're going off topic off the OP. The US entered WW2 at the end of --1942--> 1941 after Pearl Harbour, Lend Lease had been going by then. What countries? S. Korea above mentioned , Japan. Germany, until 1990s West Germany in contrast of DDR /GDR - the same nation, how different achievements...
    2
  117. Artillery or ammunition shortage? It was in April.
    2
  118. What are those lies and nonsense, pls?
    2
  119. What it has to do with UA offensive pls?
    2
  120.  @claus-not-santa  And according to you it failed. OK.
    1
  121.  @claus-not-santa  if you put it this way, at Russian troops (as many KiA don't get their grave). At equipment losses - artillery, REW, tankers (lorries), S-300/400 systems... at airbases! at emptying Sevastopol port...
    1
  122. What's the lie, in the first place?
    1
  123. "the USA started this war" ?? Are you saying V. Putin is their puppet ?
    1
  124. Why do you think Ukrainians would consider cease fire now, when there hasn't been any since Russia's attack ? BTW you omit Russian bloodshed. It matters.
    1
  125. ​ @iainmac6136  Really? Any argument?
    1
  126.  @arturallay8116  Quan et va bé?
    1
  127.  @Flatpockets123   Thank you for your reply. What would it mean for Russia not to lose?  What are the goals of the war, according to you? Because on the most important, political level Ukrainians won, they defended their independence, they got allies, then they gained strategic initiative, on operational level they're carrying the offensive... The goals Russia /Putin declared are phony, but not accomplished in any way ...
    1
  128. 'RussiaToday" and 'Sputnik' propaganda much?
    1
  129.  @scottsmith9438  Thank you for your reply. Where's the first (main?) line going/situated? Also, do you know what are the aims of the operation ?
    1
  130.  @huntergatherer7796  Ukraine won because defended their independence. Apart of the terrain, mind the losses inflicted to Russian army, Sevastopol port unabled
    1
  131. Consider double checking your information before such hazardous exclamations. For instance, it has been some time even midwives are conscripted to Russian army,
    1
  132. ​ @andykay2802  What country do you live in ? What percentage of people cannot pay electricity bills? What was it before the war?
    1
  133. What's not real in APN's analysis? What's reality, according to you?
    1
  134. Yes, although APN doesn't analyse that in this video.
    1
  135. Poe's Law applied 🤔
    1
  136.  @Princip666  No, it isn't " banderovski slogan" and no, no oblivion, but third no - if you refer to Volhynya massacre, Bandera was in German prison, later concentration camp after July 1941. None of those is truthful, what I suppose you know - low you fall.
    1
  137. You confuse Danish Leopard 2 with German (Deutsch) Leo 1, I think.
    1
  138. I'd say heating costs and the aid, especially military part of it, are not related.
    1
  139. ?
    1
  140. Oh, MP or Senator do better military analysis than a military analyst?
    1
  141.  @barakau  Well, I don't know how you know what information I can see, but I know APN, being military, can see more than me.
    1
  142. Do you speak/read Russian, for instance?
    1
  143.  @frenchfriedtatr  The doctrine is a theory. All the attack on Ukraine is against Russian military theory, as it comes to preparation (lack of mobilisation, hence no 2nd troops deployment) and execution (eh number of troops), sorry...
    1
  144. What's the "lie" ?
    1
  145. Except in WW2 Lend Lease was aid to the Soviet Union , now it is directed to Ukraine.
    1
  146. Do you realize that "West" isn't an isolated island, don't you? Russia as well isn't - colonel Putin knows what mutual destruction is.
    1
  147. At what moment of this video you heard 'dictator' ?
    1
  148. Do you realize Ukraine switched to 155 mm? 3 times personnel? And surface ? Not to mention big part of the forces is dedicated to internal / security affairs.
    1
  149. Do you consider V. Putin Slavic ? and a brother? What's his role ?
    1
  150.  @paulbart3156  Well, you might get surprised, but for me it doesn't matter Slav or not , what he is doing matters here - you say nothing about Putin's role? Imagine Russia's troops go home and soldiers take care about the problem that there are there, Slavs or Asian or from Caucasus.
    1
  151.  @claus-not-santa  Thanks, I think we don't know each other.
    1
  152. Can I watch your vídeo?
    1
  153. What makes you think so?
    1
  154. Block letters do not help
    1
  155.  @Jasonmc1100  It's Ukrainians who decide whether they are neutral (actually they were - until this war) allied with West East or other, not NATO, Russia etc I think they showed that. President Putin said these days it's not about territory, so what for are Russian soldiers dying or getting disabled? They could go home to take care about their families.
    1
  156. Was it? Are you saying V.Putin is their puppet?
    1
  157. When did he do that, supposedly?
    1
  158. Do you know the aims of the offensive, that you claim they haven't been achieved?
    1
  159. ​ @Princip666 Do you mean the forest area near Kupyansk ? What are the actual gains? and costs ?
    1
  160.  @jamesedwards6173  Yes, I do not underestimate mass of 100 thousand. If the tsar makes his mind, they can be sacrificed as a gap filler, as horrible as it sounds, temporary one.
    1
  161. Didn't your sources mention only medical background women are in question? Also, what are the goals of the operation? What are Russia's losses?
    1
  162. You realize Russians kill civilians, don't you? The war may end when Russian soldiers go home.
    1
  163. Where did you get 9 regiments of 3000 from, pls?
    1
  164. Have you seen any evidence of Russian soldiers back at home ? Soldiers, not officers.
    1
  165. ​ @enriquelaroche5370  Mixed , in my opinion. South Korea not bad nowadays, Vietnam is capitalist... We'll see Iraq. Afghanistan as Afghanistan But those were wars where the US fought, not was helping 'from outside'. What's your opinion on Lend Lease in WW2?
    1
  166. *Kerch (bridge) It's a long way to go, though.
    1
  167. And your argument is ....
    1
  168. Yes, why do Russian soldiers not go home? There's a lot of problems to take care about.
    1