Comments by "Jack Haveman" (@JackHaveman52) on "Culture Wolf" channel.

@sbor2020 Fortunately, I understand what nuances were missed in those failed Marxist systems. So, when I institute the new Marxist system, it'll work perfectly. I just know it. Believe me, it will work.
3
@sbor2020 In 1980, the Muslim population of Israel was 639,000. In 2023, the Muslim population of Israel was 1.782 million, an over 1.1 million population increase. That's one colossal failure at genociding. In the year 600 AD, almost everyone in the Middle East were Coptic Christian, Jewish or other smaller religions. Fifty years later it was almost ALL Muslim. It seems that the eradication of indigenous cultures, what you call genocide, of that area started with the Muslims but I suppose that doesn't count.
3
@ Ooooh....I see I'm engaging with one who likes taking part in intellectual discussions. I love the challenge. Here goes. As if the hard left needs another buffoon. Your turn.
3
@sbor2020 LMAO. I'm a capitalist. Blackshirts are National Socialists. Socialists hate capitalists. You don't know what you're talking about. Mussolini, even Lenin at times, have even been called "right wing socialists". They're Socialists, who are left of centre, but right of Marxists. That's not capitalism which in turn means I can't be a Blackshirt. In fact, it would be more accurate to call YOU a Blackshirt. LOL. You don't even understand your own ideology. That's hilarious.
1
@sbor2020 We did the same to the Nazis and allies in WW2. They started a war, and the Allies destroyed Germany because the leaders, especially Hitler, refused to surrender. On Oct 7/23, you know what happened. Hamas instigated a surprise attack on innocent civilians, killing over 1200 of them and kidnapping more. Women, children and even babies were targeted. Then they scurried back to Gaza to wait for the Israelis to retaliate. If you start a fight, don't start whining when you start to lose. Hamas and the people of Gaza celebrated the brutality of Oct 7/23 with pride and glee. Israel had no choice to believe that if they did nothing, this type of attack would happen again. It says a lot about those who defend Hamas when they absolutely REFUSE to acknowledge that brutal attack on Oct 7/23. Hamas started it. Gazans chanted "From the river to the sea" Why wouldn't Israelis believe that, if they could, Hamas would do the same to everyone in Israel? To use YOUR description, the military conquest of the 7th century was driven by religious ideals. The conquered lost their cultures and forced to submit to Islam, not necessarily convert but to accept Islamic rule over them. That is a dramatic shift in culture and it was forced through military strength. However, in Israel, the 1.7 million Muslims are free to go to Mosque and worship. Even the Dome of the Rock was set aside as an Islamic holy site even though it's also the site of the ancient Temples of the Jews. So how does that suppress the culture of the Israeli Muslims? Gaza, as of 2005, didn't have ONE single Jew living there. The Gazans could have celebrated their culture to their hearts content but it's not enough for them. Israel must submit to Islam and accept Islamic rule or else. Unfortunately for them, they don't have the military might to enforce it.
1
@sbor2020 Genocide definition: the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group. This is NOT what's happening in Gaza. Hamas, the rulers of Gaza, initiated a WAR against Israel on Oct 7/23 by killing over 1200 innocent civilians. They took over 200 civilians hostage including small children and refused to give them up. This was WAR. Hamas REFUSED to surrender or give up the hostages and when they did give them up, many had been killed and survivors severely abused. All Hamas had to do was surrender but they didn't care. They gladly offer up every Gazan to die in oreder to protect themselves and to further their own cause. They are casualties of war just like the people of Germany were casualties of war during the air raids of WW2 or any other war. If Hamas wanted the killing to stop, they'd surrender but they won't. They WANT the deaths. The more deaths, the more that they can use the deaths to receive financial and military aid from others. Hamas had a choice. They didn't have to go into Israel, killing civilians on Oct 7/23. They could have surrendered when the war was going badly but they won't. They're cowards and they see the casualties as martyrs for Islam. If you don't want a war, DON'T START ONE.
1
@sbor2020 Because that's what you're accusing the IDF of doing. Conquest and genocide. Strange, since Israel left Gaza in 2005 and forced all ethnic and religious Israelis to leave. How is that conquest and genocide and I'm using YOUR definition? I'll say it again. Israel LEFT Gaza....every ONE OF THEM. They didn't come back until Gazans, under the direction of Hamas, went into Israel and slaughtered over 1200 innocent young people at a music festival and taking 251 hostages. What did you expect Israel to do? Shrug their soldiers and say "Oh well". Of course not. They did what anyone with any backbone would do.
1
@haraldbredsdorff2699 I've actually seen people do exactly that. Apparently, we will never learn.
1
@therepublicofcynica My parents lived in a one bedroom shack when I was born. He worked 3 jobs at times, saved and invested wisely and now 70 years later, he's a millionaire. I know lots who've done the same. Marx was one of the elite, who used people to finance his hatred of the elites who supported him. Engels was his biggest benefactor, using the wealth of Engels's capitalist ventures as his "socialist" teat to nourish himself. Marx's beliefs are the ideology of envy and resentment.
1
@therepublicofcynica Communism definition: a political theory derived from Karl Marx, advocating class war and leading to a society in which all property is publicly owned and each person works and is paid according to their abilities and needs.......from the Oxford dictionary. Socialism definition: (in Marxist theory) a transitional social state between the overthrow of capitalism and the realization of communism.......again, from the Oxford dictionary. According to these definitions, you can't realise Communism without going through socialism first. No different than you can't become an adult without going through the teenage years, first. You can't have one without the other. That means that they have EVERYTHING to do with one another.
1