Comments by "" (@pwillis1589) on "Voice model result of 10-year process for constitutional recognition of Indigenous people" video.

  1. This $33 billion figure that is routinely thrown around comes from a 2016 productivity commission report that was quoted by Warren Mundine in an interview a few tears ago. It has been throughly debunked. What the productivity commission did was on a proportional basis of all government spending to total indigenous population. It includes all federal monies spent on Defence, DFAT, Foreign aid, industry assistance and subsidies, public roads, public hospitals, public schools, universities, Medicare, NDIS, absolutely everything that the government also spends on you. It is literally an idiotic figure to use in an a discussion on the voice and constitutional recognition. What is your real motive for using a false and throughly debunked funding figure, because it is a lie. Why are you lieing?
    2
  2. Tell me where did you get the $33+ billion number from? What is your source/reference?
    1
  3.  @robynhegwein1  It is well known myth. You are talking out of your lower colon. Once again what is your source? Is it the 2016 productivity commission report?
    1
  4.  @robynhegwein1  Currently the direct federal annual funding for indigenous people is $4.2 billion. This is direct from the 23/24 Treasurary budget paper. You are factually wrong. You quote data and you haven't got a clue what you are talking about.
    1
  5.  @robynhegwein1  And your evidence for this is?
    1
  6.  @robynhegwein1  Yes the funding for the NIAA funds those organisations. You really haven't got a clue about what you are talking about do you. Stop clutching at straws, just admit your ignorance and instead of sprouting mindless opinion go and do some proper research and reading on the subject.
    1
  7.  @robynhegwein1  Thankyou my spelling most certainly needs work.
    1
  8. Please inform me when Noel Pearson was an elected politician?
    1
  9.  @positivepawpaw7564  what a stupid comment. Read our constitution, section 25. It is called the race power. The Howard government used it legally for racist laws to be introduced into parliament. Are you even Australian as you clearly have no knowledge of our history or constitution.
    1