General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Sky News Australia
comments
Comments by "" (@pwillis1589) on "‘Ugly and dangerous’: Indigenous Voice will ‘start apartheid’" video.
@vanya That's not an insult just accurate commentary.
2
@vanya Read the Uluru statement and its supporting documentation. It is fully explained there.
2
@TheRealBobSmith. Your argument that numerous groups are unable to produce a singler voice is just fallacious nonsense both in argument and reality. It is nonsensical to suggest 100% perfect representation is required for consensus both in principle and in reality. It is merely what you think is a clever way to delegitimize indigenous representation. In reality it's childish sticking your fingers in your ears and yelling I can't hear you.
2
Poor Andy terrified his white privilege is under threat.
2
This has been previously been explained to you in detail. If you are unable to understand it then just say so instead of this endless display of total ignorance
1
@TheRealBobSmith. oh for bloody sake. Over 70 years of debate and consultations. Specifically in the last ten, culminating in the Uluṟu statement co-signed by 250 aboriginal elders from every region in Australia.
1
@arroeducarlion4990 I can’t help your wilful ignorance. Attached to the Uluṟu statement was a 500 page detailed explanation. Read it.
1
@TheRealBobSmith. WTF, are you denying the consultation process and the co-signing of the document. In which case you are really off with the fairies.
1
@arroeducarlion4990 what insult? I directed you to a detailed document. If you are incapable of finding a public document that's not my fault. Constitutional recognition, a voice to parliament that has no veto power, no legislative capability, and no financial delegation. A Makkartta truth commission. Do you need it any simpler as you seem to not be able to grasp the detail.
1
@TheRealBobSmith. Nice try at obfuscation. Not all of the groups existing at the beginning of colonisation still exist and you are confusing clans within mobs/groups. You are just factually wrong. The indigenous community achieved consensus and your pathetic attempt to discredit their efforts has already been ignored. Your argument is fallacious nonsense.
1
@vanya Just a vacuous nonsensical comment.
1
@TheRealBobSmith. And the circle is complete. A voice in the constitution (which they currently are denied) is not the same a political representation. How hard is this to understand?
1