Comments by "Winnetou17" (@Winnetou17) on "The crisis in physics is real: Science is failing" video.

  1. Have you actually watched his video ? Because he totally didn't tell Sabine that her opinion about foundations of physics is wrong. When you see "Science is falling" absolutely everybody goes "foundations of physics, obviously". I'm a bit sad that Sabine didn't properly got Dave's message. You can criticise all you want, but make it about what you know about. Always provide context. And have a bit less click bait in the title+thumbnail for BigBang's sake. "Foundations of physics" and "science" aren't interchangeable. Not even close.
    2
  2.  @InternetDarkLord  Hmm, I don't remember what he said about it. You do have a point.
    2
  3. I'm a bit sad that Sabine didn't properly got Dave's message. It's not about censoring yourself. It's not about being a cheerleader for science. It's not about stopping to provide the criticism. It's about how you deliver this information. You can criticise all you want, but make it about what you know about. Always provide context, upfront. And have a bit less click bait in the title+thumbnail for BigBang's sake. "Foundations of physics" and "science" aren't interchangeable. Not even close. I'll still watch Sabine, and I am curious of everything she says about this subject. But this video gets a 100% dislike from me for widely missing the point. Hope she can course-correct (it's really not that difficult) but I thought and hoped that already when I watched Dave's video, so seeing this one makes me much less confident. In the end, I guess this is life, it can never be perfect. Compared to the dystopia forming outside, fortunately this is really minor stuff to be worried about.
    1
  4.  @InternetDarkLord  He didn't and he said so. He criticised what Sabine puts in her videos, not her book.
    1