General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
josh thomas-moore
Drachinifel
comments
Comments by "josh thomas-moore" (@joshthomas-moore2656) on "SMS Seydlitz at Jutland - How to survive being a 25,000t Piñata" video.
I think its fair to say SMS Seydlitz was the German version of HMS Warspite and USS Enterprise.
668
@barbararice6650 The German fleet's mutiny was because the German High Command was sending them to fight the entire Royal Navy, a fight they knew they couldn't win, their entire stratagy in WW1 for the Germans was to avoid this very fight and try and take out chunkcs of the Royal Navy and then fight a weakened Royal Navy because they would lose in a head on fight, Jutland only happened because the Germans fleet didn't know the entire British Fleet was out. And then in 1918 the Germans high command wanted to send them to do as much damage as possible to try and strenghern the Germans hands in negotiation. They were sending the men and ships into a fight they couldn't hope to win or likely survive just to save face (Operation Ten-Go style) thats not a reason to fight or die for.
29
If Seydlitz is the German version of Warspite and Enterprise, i.e. ships to stubborn to die, who are the Japanese and Italian versions of Warspite and Enterprise?
15
@Ragefps I think its more accurate to say Warspite was the deity.
4
@Ragefps The UK lost the Warspite and the old woodern Implacable, because the politicians were wasting money on things that went no where, that if not wasted could have saved them both and possibily another ship, but politicians...thanks (Sarcasim)
2