Comments by "Ameni0" (@Layde36) on "ACAB: Why All Cops Are Bastards" video.

Typical rich shill, done enough bootlicking for your CEOs?
7
All cops are bastards for sure, those who leave the force are guilty too as they stay quiet about the crimes that law enforcement does against its people
3
Yeah pretty sure it's the inverse, stop villifying black people especially when they are discriminated against by society, cops aren't even needed especially when the problems are created by capitalism which cops desperately defend
3
@Gnashercide so Nazism ofc sounds good for white supremacists
3
Its just the bloodlust that these people get their kick in from, some of them actively enjoy torturing people for their own sick conveniences
3
Legalized organized crime who enjoy killing their "suspects" and they dont refer to us as humans wither
2
Law enforcement which protects the rich elites should not be encouraged, we the working class would prefer creating our own militia which serves our interests like the Red Army in the Soviet Union
2
Then leave the force for good
2
@juice-uj1le once a bootlicker always a bootlicker
2
Yeah as if people cant create a militia and deal with crime themselves in a civil manner not needing the oppressive state
2
In Russia honestly everyone knows its the bourgeois state and their military which is the one who always try to oppress the people, in fact the concept of police in the Soviet Union was very different as it was a plain militia run by the people i.e the Red Army than anything resembling the US regime which kept the police to policing African American slaves The only reason why the Soviet Union fell was because of bureaucratic corruption starting during the times of war which was completely chaotic considering they were threatened by Nazi Germany to be exterminated for being Slavic, so obviously the opportunistic assholes in the NKVD wrongly imprisoned many people and that is written by the colonial west as the whole state being authoritarian despite the fact it was chaotic times they were living in, while the irony of US doing nothing for their citizens while they were starving during great depression The Russian police even if they are authoritarian as run by the bourgeois elite still do follow Soviet doctrines which ensure that citizens have their problems dealt in a civil manner and not with aggression and having a warrior mentality around 24/7 It's something crazy thinking how Americans sleep at night after all the atrocities they committed in their lifetimes
2
 @johnathanthin doesn't matter all cops are bastards and this is a known fact, the only ones who are acceptable are militia run by the people and not by the state
2
The Soviets with their policing was only required against opportunists rich Capitalists and not the working class people, they called them Kulaks who had sufficient power and authority which the Soviets had to require policing to stop them from gaining monopoly over the working class The Soviets in the 50-60s after Stalin died changed drastically and ended up being vastly different with Capitalists gaining power in the state instead of the working class representatives Law enforcement in the USSR is far less violent and racially motivated than the US and with the circumstances like famine, two world wars and upcoming proxy wars there would be no denial life was harsh back then
2
 @sheevpalpatine2901 There's no such thing as Stalinism, it's just Marxist-Leninism, Stalinism is made up by Stalin's enemies like Kruschsev and many others like Trotsky
1
@sheevpalpatine2901 the definition of police rights that Angela Davis implemented did not mean many others like her were Marxists in any way She was a abolitionist and other than that she did not put forth theories of how abolition could have benefitted the Proliterian state The era Stalin and Lenin were in was such that rising Fascism really did create mass unrest amongst the populace especially during the 20-30s period where the Soviets had gone through famines and were just recovering from the civil war and in preparation of the second world war against Nazi Germany, the conditions were obviously not ideal enough for any kind of prison reform and even then it was miles better than what the US currently has and always has been continuing, hell the so called Gulags had free healthcare unlike the prison system of the US which could care less if you had any sort of life threatening disease especially if you are already in poverty Angela Davis was talking about an idealistic notion of prison abolishment which with the material conditions of those times wouldn't be possible
1
@sheevpalpatine2901 that's cause Hakims ideas basically come from anarcho-communism which does not believe in a states existence which already has been proven to be a failed idea based on individualistic ideals and lie more with petit-bourgeois beliefs more than with the Proliteriat
1
Exactly why people need to sort out their own problems by organizing for themselves and not rely on the establishment which essentially uses that power to keep themselves in power while creating new problems which they come as the saviors to fix the problems they created, workers need to establish their own foothold instead of remaining a slave to the establishment
1
Firemen are the true saviors who put their life on the line especially when considering that they are playing around with mother nature which never forgives anyone coming close to it, although I can understand there are shitty people in the world and they need to be stopped it also should not mean that the people defending us aren't shitty themselves
1
@YaBoiHakim honestly I'm disappointed that none of yall leftists ever mentioned the topic regarding deportations of US citizens born in US were being illegally deported to foreign countries violating the constitutional rights It's been almost a month and yet no coverage about the illegal birthright law which was introduced, when will leftists bother to address this issue or do they find it convenient to not cover such issues as they are anti immigrants too
1
@nerrler5574 well cause cops in any state are the same authoritarian force who abuse their powers against the working class
1
 @rivaraptor4277 no one is the enemy if they don't stand against the interests of the people which can be achieved by not supporting every single order that the police force puts out
1
The incarceration rate means they are jailed for crimes but they aren't kept in the prison for longer periods of time as they are granted bail or rehabilitated instead of being racially profiled or listed as a criminal after their rehabilitation like the US regime does with its citizens, hell even small scale crimes like burglary gets them into a offenders list which people can publicly view to humiliate and constantly remind the person of their criminal acts which they probably did out of desperation considering that a significant amount of black people suffer from racial profiling In Russia the conditions of the people are already poor and it's the state and their bourgeois bureaucrats who are the ones who keep the state in that manner while the system which they run in was from the Soviet Union which followed Soviet doctrine regarding rehabilitation, the offenders list being removed for most people ( except for serial criminals or people involved in organized crimes ) and many other methods such as less usage of firearms as much as possible,etc Russia even if the wealth inequality is much higher their culture and systems which the Soviets left behind is still practiced and there are many young adults who already wish the Soviet Union back as Putin is obviously whitewashing any history left behind
1
Russia puts a lot of people in jail especially minorities and other marginalized groups like lgbtq and other rights as they criminalized their culture but they do not profile the people who did such crimes for their lifetime for the police to arrest them again and in turn increase the prison population like the US is doing, the US makes a lot of bank out of slave labour prisoners for many developmental projects instead of hiring labour work
1
@cokrlicix lol imagine calling me a bot while i only reply back factual info
1
Yeah no thanks
1
I say it's a controversial and to be honest a predicament especially when we do require help against shitty people and their behaviours but the fact that the wrong people are put in charge makes it worse, we need a better system for the working class and not the capitalist system which created cops only to defend their property instead of protecting humans of all class, race, gender, ethnicity and age
1
@mami20855he's a bastard for sure
1
@outmywritemind1739 all cops are bastards and this is something that people should acknowledge as people rather solve their issues with community efforts instead of relying on the state which is run by the rich elites who parasitize off the hard work of the workers
1
@sourdough6490 well again you seem to forget the material conditions of the Soviets that they had during the times of the revolution and the great war, the NEP policies directly lead to the creation of the Kulaks which although was originally supposed to carry on a industrial revolution of their own which also includes collectivisation that Stalin did, so the Kulaks were opportunists who took advantage of a already agrarian country and tried monopolizing their resources which they should be held accountable for and you can't claim the Soviets methods were harsh especially when the Gulags they were sent in were much better than anything the US regime has with proper healthcare and basic necessities fulfilled You can't really call yourself a Leninist if you don't ever consider the material conditions that were present in the Soviet Union, the social democrats and the Mensheviks directly were in collaboration with the Tsars again the Bolsheviks which required the kind of policing against any monopolistic tendencies among the masses created by remaining Tsar royalists who were still not educated enough on class consciousness and had a lot of petit bourgeois class created cause of the NEP policies Again the NEP itself was a huge compromise done by the Soviets who were directly facing serious invasion threats from foreign powers and were exhausted fighting the civil war against the White Army Speaking of which you seem to forget the Jim Crow era where black people were literally lynched and hunted down for minor crimes especially when the KKK movement was much larger than today so the CIA is nothing compared to how the US was before the 1950s so there's literally no comparison made against the Soviets who actually tried to maintain a working class socialist state and tried to prevent any opportunists from gaining monopoly over especially when many of them were outright funded by foreign powers especially with the black markets always been a challenge after they abolished private property and carried out collectivisation policies There's literally no evidence of any kind of misuse of class power in the Soviet Union other than very rare cases which only happened during the harshest times like the famine, the war with Nazis and after the period following the civil war While the US regime actively chose to commit human rights violations and still do to this day and break the record against any country present, especially against black people and minorities and in foreign countries where their war crimes are infamous and documented already, the Soviets really had no serious history of human rights violations other than defensive and retaliatory measures they had taken while facing constant threats from the US regime and Nazi Germany which sought to exterminate their entire race I'm sorry but the history regarding red terror,the implementation of certain policies which you claim have been violent are all propagandistic made to demonize the Soviets as no different than the US regime which they are far from being called that
1
@sourdough6490 your last point about insistence on building socialism in an agrarian country is literally just dismissal of the fact that in developed countries, socialism was met with fascism like the video you see there, you seem to use the argument of socialism in all countries and claim that the Soviets should have kept waiting for the Germans and other Scandinavian countries to be successful in their socialist revolution, but the reality was far from what was idealised and only the Soviets went ahead with building socialism in one country as Marxism still never had a true answer towards Fascism Expecting socialism to be developed on advanced countries is still a pipe dream which socialists still fail to understand as Fascism at those times in every country crushed any serious revolutionary potential that was carried, ask the Paris commune how their revolution went and the German revolution too, they were met with fascists who completely dismantled their organisation all because they never built up any serious organisation and a sufficient military force or created any dictatorship of the Proliteriat to enact these forces Lenin and the Soviets were successful as they had developed a proper organisation which was harsh enough to combat Fascism which was exactly the solution back then and the same thing done by Stalin who implemented the teachings of Lenin into practice,Fascism crushed any serious Marxist movement and still does to this day put out any working class movement, and making concessions with the bourgeois never ended well for the revolutionaries and even small scale attacks towards the bourgeois is pointless especially when the bourgeois has always had enough military power to put them down too The Soviets had a stricter police force and anti capitalist ideology as they understood that any form of monopoly created by opportunists within the working class itself has in the past led to many socialist states collapsing like with Vietnam which turned revisionist after Ho Chi Minh died but even then their policies towards those arrested was not nearly close to being as worse as the US Empire which still to this day employs prison labour with no benefits, insufficient healthcare as prisoners usually die of curable diseases and serious gang violence within the prisons themselves which is encouraged by law enforcement within as to justify harsher sentences while for the Soviets the so called "Gulags" the sentencing did not even last 10-20 years and only worst offenders of the state actually got serious sentences and all the while they received free healthcare, education systems being employed and other stuff which never gets mentioned in the "horrors of the Gulags" The Soviets only had poorer conditions in the Gulags during the times of the famine or during ww2 where there was serious food shortages and thousands of prisoners died cause of it which these separate incidents are obviously propagandized to make the Soviets obviously look like the boogeyman, sure there were some serious flaws within the Soviet policing systems but considering the situations they were in and then claiming they should be held completely accountable for circumstances beyond their control is just false rhetoric used by the capitalists obviously to demonize any socialist states from the past
1