Comments by "robs2020" (@sbor2020) on ""It's INHUMANE And Not What We Do In The UK" | Alex Phillps Rants About Halal Meat" video.

  1. It's important to approach this topic with an understanding of the facts surrounding halal slaughter and animal welfare legislation in the UK. First, halal slaughter is not illegal in the UK. The Animal Welfare Act 2006 provides guidelines that all slaughter methods must follow to ensure the humane treatment of animals, regardless of cultural or religious practices. Halal slaughter must comply with these regulations, including the requirement for the animal to be stunned before slaughter in most cases. Second, many argue that halal methods can be humane when performed correctly. For example, the method involves a swift cut to the throat, which, if done properly, can lead to rapid unconsciousness and minimise pain. Studies have shown that when carried out by trained individuals, halal slaughter can be just as humane as other methods. Additionally, banning halal slaughter would not only infringe on the rights of individuals to practice their faith but could also lead to a significant impact on the meat supply for various communities in the UK. It’s crucial to focus on improving animal welfare standards across all methods of slaughter rather than singling out specific practices. Engaging in informed discussions can lead to better outcomes for animal welfare while respecting cultural and religious practices.
    7
  2. Russia does not have the jurisdiction of the ECHR, go there and feel the freedom you so desperately seek.
    3
  3. Instead of a ban, we should focus on improving regulations and standards for all slaughter methods to ensure animal welfare while respecting religious practices. Educating the public about these methods can also help dispel misconceptions and promote informed discussions on animal welfare. A balanced approach is necessary to protect both animal welfare and cultural traditions.
    3
  4.  @AndrewCowell-sz9dx  That’s a ridiculous question!! There are over MCC Muslims in the world. The majority respect other religions, while a minority do not – the same applies to Christians. It’s time to move past this. And yes, I used Roman numerals instead of Arabic ones to avoid triggering an Islamophobe.
    2
  5.  @JoanBurke-qo2rx Indeed it is! But I am sure you are not so quick to factcheck your far-right brethren, are you?
    2
  6.  @JK-wi1ur  Authoritarian mentality in a nutshell.
    2
  7. In terms of animal welfare, the industrial practice of using high voltage to electrocute cows is far from humane. This method is not a traditional farming practice; it’s rooted in capitalist production, prioritising efficiency and profit over the welfare of animals. This biased discussion dismisses halal slaughter as “not a British thing” overlooks the key issue: the treatment of the animals. As someone who has been a vegetarian for over 30 years, I believe that neither method is ideal. However, halal slaughter is likely the more humane option, as it focuses on minimiing suffering through swift and respectful practices. It’s essential to prioritise animal welfare over cultural biases and recognise that humane treatment should be a universal concern, regardless of cultural practices.
    1