Comments by "Trevor Crook" (@user-ft2bt9kw7x) on "Ukraine war update" video.

The professor looks increasingly sad these days. Regardless of what he says he knows the real situation in Ukraine
5
Kursk has been a disaster for Ukraine . Huge losses and now Ukraine forces are surrounded . The reason for the invasion was unclear . Kursk is of no strategic value .
3
800,000 losses ? Russia only has 600,000 troops in Ukraine and for most of the war far less than that . Your number doesn’t add up
2
@TogtherWeThrive what did they say happened at Chernobyl then ?
2
@sardo.numspa Because it’s of no value militarily .
2
@ Give me a link to Russian soldiers complaining . I pay no attention on hearsay or gossip . Even if North Korean troops were fighting with Russia and there is no evidence for it ,so what . America fought the Iraq war with 39 other countries .Ukraine is using fighters from many countries
2
@ No you should explain how I debunked my own argument . Paraphrasing is good way to do it . Then it will be obvious if you understood my argument or not . The paraphrasing method is widely used in debates to clarify matters
2
@sardo.numspa Reading my own comments again wouldn’t explain how I debunked my own argument . I want you to explain how I did because you are making the claim . It should be easy to do if you know what your are talking about Then you use insults which is prime sign that you lost the argument Lost for words eh ? 😊 Did all the countries in the war speak English ? The main forces did . But they were all trained according to western standards and tactics which made them a cohesive group Russia and North Korea totally different in language , training and weapons . A big problem during combat . That is why it highly unlikely they would fight together . Russia doesn’t need them anyway they have hundreds of thousands of their own troops I see no contradictions in my argument at all Don’t know Russian MIA . Russia will not release casualty numbers for Russia till after the war The pentagon papers was big news at the time . Ukraine casualty numbers are in the papers . 7x. Confirmed
2
The war will finish totally under Russian conditions . Probably unconditional surrender by Ukraine
2
@sardo.numspa If they were replaced. Russia would have to have mobilised more than once . They have mobilised once in 2022 300,000 . To replace 800,000 they would need an army far bigger than they have . And they would still hundreds of thousands of troops to still defend Russia as well Your numbers still don’t add up
1
@ The increase in size when complete in a few years time , will be 2.4 million .. At the moment Russian army 1.2 million . Nowhere near enough for your unsubstantiated claims to be credible. 800,000 losses you say . 600,000 in Ukraine at present . Russia would hardly leave Russia undefended . Another 600,000 minimum needed for that but more like a million . . Your numbers still don’t add up
1
@sardo.numspa Russian army at present 1.2 million . I’m going on present numbers . What happens in the future Is irrelevant They have not mobilised again because not needed . If your claims were true they would have no choice but to mobilise . Your numbers still don’t add up
1
@sardo.numspa The mobilisation was only unpopular with a minority . Most Russians saw it as necessary . Otherwise Putins approval ratings would have reflected mass dissatisfaction with the Mobilisation. And it didn’t
1
@sardo.numspa Russian losses according to Mediazona is 85,000 dead . Those estimates are based on death notices within Russia , obituaries in social media. Satellite images of cemeteries . What are your numbers based on?
1
@sardo.numspa give specific numbers . How big is the Russian army at present ? Not big enough to accomodate your numbers .
1
@ I think if you read my comments and my numbers which are based on the total size of the Russian army at present. All substantiated . They make your800,000 claim physically impossible
1
@sardo.numspa The Russians don’t release casualty numbers . That will be done after the war . But the leaked pentagon papers and Mediazona put Russian deaths at below 100,000
1
@sardo.numspa But Russia isn’t being defeated . And Russian troop numbers in Ukraine are not three million
1
@sardo.numspa Russia doesn’t release casualty numbers. You are saying Russian losses are 800,000 out of a total number of 1.2 million the present size of the Russian army. With 600,000 of that army presently in Ukraine . That clearly doesn’t add up
1
@sardo.numspa Russia doesn’t release casualty numbers
1
@sardo.numspa You agreed with the comment that said 800,000. What is your source for the 800,000 losses ? Whoever they are are very poor source . Unsubstantiated tosh
1
@ No evidence of North Korean troops fighting . Of course both sides suffer in war . But Ukraine has far bigger losses and the country is in ruins. It has already been defeated though the fighting continues Ukraine has volunteers from around the world. To join the Russian army you must be Russian
1
@sardo.numspa Military doctrine
1
@ Two North korean troops ? How do you know they are North Korean troops ? Have their identities been confirmed ? Why only two ? And why would Russia need 10,000 troops from North Korea when they have hundreds of thousands of their own troops . Doesn’t add up You need to start thinking . Russians and North Koreans would not fight together . Language barrier , different training and weapons And 10,000 would make no difference
1
@ You agreed with someone who said 800,000. The actually number of Russian casualties confirmed by multiple sources is around 85,000 dead which would mean total casualties of around 200,000
1
@sardo.numspa Most nato countries speak English , use the same weapons and train the same. Nato is uniformed . Russia and North Korea are totally alien to each other . And Russia doesn’t need 10,000 extra troops they would make no difference
1
@sardo.numspa War is much more sophisticated these days. The lines of communication much more advanced technologically . A language barrier would make matters very difficult
1
@sardo.numspa The losses for Russia have been calculated by Mediazona using death notices in Russia , obituaries on social media , satellite images of cemeteries in Russia to see if they have expanded . Obviously massive deaths would mean massive funerals throughout Russia impossible to hide in the day of social media . According to those signs there is nothing abnormal to observe
1
@ There is no evidence for North Korean involvement. No battle footage no photos . And 10,000 extra troops would make no difference . So why would Russia use them when they have hundreds of thousands of troops of their own . Until you can answer those logical questions you have no case
1
@ I have no idea how many Russians are missing in action . However Ukraine deserters are around 200,000. Russian deaths around 85,000. . According to the leaked pentagon papers Ukraine losses seven times higher . That is documented According to me ? According to open sources and any serious Military analyst the fact that Ukraine has mobilised many times and are about to draft 18 year olds and suffer massive manpower shortages indicates huge losses
1
@sardo.numspa According to the leaked pentagon papers Ukraine losses are seven times higher than Russias . Russia has the overwhelming advantage in artillery, AirPower , manpower and weapons production. Logic should tell you what the truth is There is no evidence of North Koreans fighting in Ukraine . And even if there was it indicates nothing. Countries often use foreign fighters during a war it is quite normal . America fought the Iraq war with 39 other countries And my replies are based on information from credible military sources not gossip and hearsay
1
@sardo.numspa My information come from credible Military sources and even Ukraine and American sources . You have made an issue of the North Korean conspiracy theory that even if true is a non event . 10,000 North Korean troops would make no difference to outcome on the battlefield . You are desperate . It is over pal get used to it Ukraine and even America and Israel use fighters from other countries. It is totally normal . Nothing abnormal about Russia doing it if they want too . It indicates nothing
1
@sardo.numspa My replies come from credible military sources and even western sources . There is no evidence of North Korean involvement .in Ukraine . At least in a fighting capacity .And even if there was it indicates nothing . It is quite normal for countries to use foreign fighters . The America fought the Iraq war with 39 other countries
1
@sardo.numspa America fought the Iraq war with 39 other countries . Even if Russia was using foreign troops it is no big deal. Most countries do the same thing in a conflict You are desperate . The war is over get used to it
1
@sardo.numspa What is my argument ? Just checking to see if you actually know ?
1
@sardo.numspa What is my argument? Can you paraphrase it ?
1