General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Military Summary
comments
Comments by "" (@efghggdxlmfn33) on "The Russians Captured The Aggregate Plant | The AFU Entered Hlyboke. Military Summary For 2024.06.17" video.
The West is not prepared for this kind of war. To most Western experts, attritional strategy is counterintuitive.
71
@rogerlevy57 looks like you did not understand mu comment at all. Attritional wars require their own ‘Art of War’ and are fought with a ‘force-centric’ approach, unlike wars of manoeuvre which are ‘terrain-focused’. They are rooted in massive industrial capacity to enable the replacement of losses, geographical depth to absorb a series of defeats, and technological conditions that prevent rapid ground movement. In attritional wars, military operations are shaped by a state’s ability to replace losses and generate new formations, not tactical and operational manoeuvres. The side that accepts the attritional nature of war and focuses on destroying enemy forces rather than gaining terrain is most likely to win.
27
@rogerlevy57 epic b.s go and collect firewoods. "Russia will run out of money sooner." 😂 IMF: GDP Growth Russia 3.2% | Germany 0.2% World Bank has noted since the war started that Russia passed both Germany and Japan in economic size Russia's budget deficit in 2023 was a mere 1.9% and forecasted to be only 1% in 2024. Meanwhile the US deficit was 6.3%, Germany 2.1%, UK 4.2 %, France 5.5%, Italy 7.4% Russia's National Wealth Fund (NWF) is growing again in 2024 after being reduced by $70B from its peak but again remember much of these are paper losses owing to valuations in Russia's private industries being lower. Russia's income tax rate of a flat 13% has been adjusted to a progressive tax rate that will range from 13% to 22%. Increasing the tax burden for the rich but still being very low compared to much of the world. The increased tax revenue ensures fiscal stability in case of a fall in commodity prices. So what are the Russian problems they cite?. So they argue that since Gazprom lost $7.1B in 2023 that the Russian economy will collapse, ignoring that this is a trivial number in a massive economy or that Gazprom paid over $8B in taxes to the Russian government. Gazprom has about $18B cash in the bank and sells natural gas on the domestic markets for a pittance. Raising gas prices slightly would return Gazprom to profitability and consumers would still pay some of the lowest prices in the world. Russia's fiscal position is vastly superior to any country in the West, having little debt and running small deficits.
1