Comments by "adamnesico" (@adamnesico) on "Why is Every Society Religious?" video.

  1.  @mowgli5837  So, according to you, the glued union of Murica is a colony of the boyz of Jerusalem, rigth? You can’t differentiate between religious donations and tribute?
    2
  2. Is sad that people needs a state for live.
    2
  3. If have religion would be bad, a religiousless society would have triumphed. Money goes to who is succesful.
    1
  4. Ottomans had no indian colonies and the new route barely affected them. Ottomans were the most lasting islamic state, they fell simply by the pass of time, id say by conservatism that made them stagnate.
    1
  5.  @mowgli5837  So according to you USA is a colony of the mortal enemies of Palestine, rigth?
    1
  6.  @mowgli5837  Is religious donation from the pocket of the ruler for be the coolest man by being the best doner to the holy city. People made too personal donations, the sultan being the richest, made the highest. If it would had been colonial tribute, it would had went toIstanbul, not Makka. Why haven’t you admited ur status according to ur theory?
    1
  7. Did you ever decide d that? I once did. Im screwed, im convinced im a total loser.
    1
  8. Universe had a starting. That points to a initial cause. Proteins are incredibly complex. That they are a product of azar looks an explanation infinitesimally possible.
    1
  9. Ive read Mein Kampf, I don’t remember any apreciation to christianity, his way of speak and think were definitely atheistic.
    1
  10. Then why Einstein didn’t scaped to URSS? None if those were successful social leaders as many of the list.
    1
  11. Im not religious and I agree with that.
    1
  12. I guess he means China in the warring states. I don’t know about India.
    1
  13. Why?
    1
  14. Your religion days Jesus came to America. Nothing supports that.
    1
  15. Yes, and modern atheist religions like socialism do that too. Rules can be used for oppress, but that is a lame excuse for forbidding them, you can’t have a ruleless society.
    1
  16.  @Anonymous-sb9rr  Stalin didnt needed that, he had become the incarnation of the state, in a certain way, he was a living God. Well, more like a pharaoh. Sorry, the coincidences are so much that can be said well that socialism is just a materialistic abrahamic religion. If you don’t see them, u have purposeful blindness. I agree with Yuval Harari that we should reform the definition of religion for include all the humanistic ones who have shaped the world in their sacred struggle to submit world under their sacred values. See what is at arriving NY: a statue of goddess 🗽 the national goddess of USA.
    1
  17. China is based in confucian religion. Is a quite atheistic religion, but still believes in a trascendetal power that rules the world and moral rules for preserve the equilibrium. All states you mentioned were created imitating the chinese confucian model.
    1
  18. Who spoke of an invisible man in sky? Aliens exist, rigth? Why not some superior universe creator somewhere else?
    1
  19. Well, Yuval Harari thinks USA is a libertarian society. See the NY state. 🗽 is the national goddess.
    1
  20. Some substitute based in empirical observation? Isn’t the data of this video in favor of religions empyrical enough? How will you create one based in material and potentially changing and arbitrary elite? Marxists wanted to be the new religion, but i guess we can agree they are suceeding in control, but not in create a sustainable society.
    1
  21. Wich is?
    1
  22. Not late western romans. The romans from the Graci bros to Constantine were an agnostic society. The late republic and early empire.
    1
  23.  @无名氏-r5t  the damage was already done. Constantine, funding a new christian Rome, basically fosaked the original one.
    1
  24. Not rigth. The chinese empire fell before the roman one. It can be argued if maintaining their religion helped them to reunite later.
    1
  25. That is atheist doesn’t mean buddhist isn’t a religion, buddhism believes in soul, karma, ilumination, prophets, sacred, and the usual religious stuff.
    1
  26. Yes, but war always return, there is no postscarcity, there is always something people needs and lacks, and humans disagree violently in what is to be good.
    1
  27. What the video propose is to make society religious again, it never said to convert everyone to some specific religion. Im not religious, but I totally agree with the view, religion is a necessary ingredient for long time survival of a society.
    1