Comments by "adamnesico" (@adamnesico) on "What if Europe Was Wiped out by the Black Death?" video.

  1. So you are saying that the muslim golden age wasnt muslim but iranian? Anyways, even with Iran destroyed, what made Africa unable of follow they science advancement? I agree that what ended the musli mscietific age was the conservatist revolution that ended the interest or science. If not for that, it would had simply followed in Africa.
    3
  2. Guy, you said a great nonsense. Bagdad was destroyed be4 the plague. Science was already falling be4 the destructio of the house of wisdom. Africa and India werent affected by the mongols, they could had followed the science. So no, was an entire civilisational turn. Ruyard said that everyone invaded by mogls turned consevative. The damage was alreay done in this scenario, so, China would be consevative. In fact the song already banned their own industrial age be4 be conquered by the mongols.
    2
  3. I guess it simply: -Hadenosaunee expand until become too big and divide, creating a bunch of protostates with their contitutional govrn and culture in the forests of USA. - Possibly the missisipian mound culure would have resurrected wit the time. -Mexicas collapse. Northern invaders continue their culture. -Incas conquers all th andes excpt the araucans. They become stagnant and end invaded by barbarian neighbours, possibly the own araucans.
    2
  4. Why?
    1
  5.  @dont-rump901  Donkey brain, the gurkhanis invaded India centuries later in a more civiliced way, they were something diferent. You were the one who made a phallacy of reduction to the absurd. You are the one talking nonsense.
    1
  6. India and Africa werent invaded by the mongols, development could have continue in both of those, so I see it really was a "fuck science"
    1
  7.  @ladofthedamned7796  Ven more? He reads a lot. You didnt saw how many books he read for his research? Do your own channel if you think you can do better.
    1
  8.  @hishamalaker491  I asked him if he was saying that. I know the advances of alAndalus, Magreb and Sicily, I live in Andalucía. Sassanians had a house of wisdom. Abbassids copied it. We would know their advancements if the arabs wouldn’t have destroyed their culture and legacy.
    1
  9. Hhehehe, many point that in fact it wasnt destroyed in our ouwn timeline.
    1
  10. Guy, competition adn warfare promote innovation. This timeline more advanced? No way, asian cultures had already chosen stagnation.
    1
  11. No way, seen how hated they were, it wuld have colapsed in some centuries.
    1
  12. That timeline was creeated by Hitler.
    1
  13. I dont find hard to beleive, most cultures dont beleive in rpogress. Just see how they were stagnant in our own timeline. If the plague had affected just the islamics, the current development trend wouldnt had changed, west was already developing and the culture transfere had already happened.
    1
  14. Brits were affected too
    1
  15. When I hard of Rice&Salt at first I liked the idea. Then later I realised the stupid racism of the idea that bubonic plague would wipe Europe and not western Asia wich genically is basically the same race, Europe is both geographically and genically western Asia. Justifies it by having soulds destined to make discoveries. But the world behaving exactly the same as ours is crap. Seems that the book wanna sell the idea that the world wouldnt have been different and europeans are nothing specials and we dont have to care if they disapear. So I suggest to do a : What Rice&Salt would really be, suposing that the bubonic plague wiped all western Asia. The correct POD for this would had been simple the video of arabs take Constantinople, then Rome. With that you have western culture ended be4 born.
    1
  16. Yeah, and development lead to the destruction of nature, native peoples, cultures...
    1
  17. Why? They woud simply invade America.
    1
  18. They would be jus small cultural remains, so theey dont matter.
    1
  19. You are mistaking the cause with just another consecuence. Religious purity and crusades were caused both by the turk invasions, religious purity started with alGazali and Nizam alMulk. And aniwaysif true, that mistaken argument wouldnt had chamged his argumentation, cusades had already happened be th POD. So the fallacy is the use of ur argument. Europeans were continuously at war and that didnt stopped them of be advanced. I agree with the world 400 years back.
    1
  20. Wich ones? In the reality didnt happened.
    1
  21.  @imados21  ¿? algebra, logarythm and optics were already developed. Cosmology? What do u mean?
    1