Comments by "Mel" (@Mel-wn9gb) on "Trans vs Conservative Women: Are Periods Essential to Womanhood? | Middle Ground" video.

  1.  @JenniferLovelace123  Yes, but female goldfish are not women. A woman is a female human being, not a female goldfish.
    71
  2. It's the ultimate in mansplaining. The pure hubris of these men.
    15
  3. Lol, too much irony. Take your own advice. And if you're going to label us 'cis' you made it our concern and our business.
    7
  4.  @Maksie0  They do. They choose to buy into the false idea that there's a 'gender' that's supposed to 'match' our sex. That's just sex stereotyping. They can choose to reject sex stereotyping, like women, gays and lesbians have been doing for centuries now.
    5
  5. They are, because they're male, not female.
    5
  6. Of course actual women are going to have something to say about men sex stereotyping, objectifying, fetishizing and dehumanizing us and violating our rights. A perfectly reasonable response.
    4
  7. No. They're saying men aren't women.
    4
  8.  @JenniferLovelace123  No really? I never knew. It's not like you never stop talking about it and trying to impose the ideological dogma of 'cisgender' onto everyone. And yes it would be a problem, just like it would be a problem if a christian insisted I say a prayer every time I speak to them. Keep your personal, ideological beliefs to yourself please.
    3
  9.  @Maksie0 They can choose to buy into the arbitrary, sexist expectations imposed onto their sex, or do the progressive thing and reject them, like women, gays and lesbians have been doing for centuries now. That should be their lightbulb moment - 'gender' is the entire problem.
    3
  10.  @JenniferLovelace123  At least you can admit that you're groomers, but you guys will never win because you can't control the thought and speech of other people. Sorry, not sorry. I call 'trans' people by their names. That's all they're getting from me. I'm not going to affirm regressive, sexist dogma just because they bought into it. You can't fine, fire, cancel or arrest me for that. Therefore you lose. Even the people who do submit to your dictates are just being polite, let's be real. At least you can also admit that you do have social and political power and are not the helpless, most oppressed minority eva as per the usual victim narrative. A rare moment of honesty.
    2
  11. Womanhood is not a belief. It's a sex and a species. A simple fact.
    2
  12. Why do they have to be beautiful? Well spoken and the ability to think critically is all you need.
    2
  13.  @catboyash  You can chant the mantra like you're in a cult as much as you like, but it still won't make it true. These men will just have to cope with their manhood. Women's and girl's rights are more important than their feelings.
    2
  14. All women.
    2
  15. Yes, but it's been appropriated for political and ideological reasons.
    2
  16. Women are not required to be 'feminine' so what's your point?
    2
  17.  @handletheseboltz  So now you're stereotyping both women and transwomen. Sexism AND transphobia. Well done.
    2
  18. It's sex stereotyping, ie. sexism. Just ignore it.
    2
  19. @R L It's not hard to grasp that that's literal sex stereotyping, which is ideology, not fact.
    2
  20. @R L The idea that we all have a 'gender identity' that 'matches' or 'mismatches' our sex, making us 'cis' or 'trans' is literal sex stereotyping. Sex stereotyping is sexism, ie. ideology, not fact.
    2
  21.  @katherinetanks632  I've already done research. I don't need to talk to 'trans' people to know the meaning of 'cis'. It's literal sex stereotyping, ie. sexism. Don't just recite ideological dogma. Engage your brain.
    2
  22. Yes, that's the entire problem with this ideology. These people take words and change their meaning to mean whatever they want them to mean, and take ideological concepts and state them as though they're facts, and then expect everyone else to quietly go along with that.
    2
  23. Which ways?
    2
  24. Which logical fallacies?
    2
  25. Women vs deluded, sexist men.
    2
  26. Men who think they're women.
    2
  27. What makes the ideology of 'gender' any different? Both are belief systems that belong in the private realm.
    2
  28. Irrelevant. These ideas have implications for the rights of everyone.
    2
  29.  @avery9239  So stop doing it fellas. 👍 You don't know what it is to be a woman because you're male, hence men. Men have no place dictating to women who and what we are.
    2
  30. What doesn't she know?
    2
  31. Why?
    1
  32.  @Guhgsaggio  Meanwhile, while you're being nice women and girls are losing hard won rights because of what other people are doing. Sometimes we need to use our judgement and show love to everyone, not just those that are fashionable to love and make us look virtuous.
    1
  33. Yes, one is an objective fact. The other is sexist dogma.
    1
  34. Transwomen are conservative men.
    1
  35. Everything you just said is innacurate.
    1
  36. No, it's men. Including men who 'identify as women' whatever that's supposed to mean.
    1
  37.  @handletheseboltz  Like hotdogs are dogs.
    1
  38. So is it that transphobia is so bad people are too scared to come out as 'trans', or that 'trans' is more accepted and no longer taboo now? So many contradictory narratives.
    1
  39. The point is that women and girls have female bodies, regardless of what stage of life we're at. Women are female human beings. There's nothing controversial about that.
    1
  40.  @katherinetanks632  Women are women because we're born female and grew into adults. Not because we "identify as the 'gender' we're born into". What does that even mean? You're just reciting demonstrably false ideological dogma.
    1
  41. @R L If it doesn't bug you then learn to think.
    1
  42. @R L People will reply to your comments when you engage with them on the internet. That's how it works. Don't flatter yourself. Lol.
    1
  43. @R L No it's not. You make comments on the internet, uou engage with people, they reply to you.
    1
  44. Nonsense. A woman is a female human being. We need to seperate transwomen, ie. men, from women.
    1