Comments by "Golden Croc" (@GoldenCroc) on "Joker 2 Trailer WOKE MELTDOWN! Lady Gaga OWNS Incels? Woke Media Suddenly Loves Joker" video.
-
12
-
1
-
1
-
You are free to like musicals all you want, more power to you. However, if they want to give it any tone close to the first one, how does the musical theme fit into that? I cant see it at all.
Perhaps those people want a similar movie to the first one, and dont see how thats possible with the musical element added? Sounds probable to me.
You will note the movies you mentioned are surreal comedys, and I have never heard of a musical being anything other than a comedy, intentional or otherwise, or what amounts to a stage play on celluliod, with all general categories of suspension of disbelief that necessitates, thats not normally a part of a movie. How does the first Joker movie fit into any of those categories?
Only possible solution I can see is if all the musical numbers take place entirely in his, as seen in the first movie, imagined "fantasy land". Even then it seems like a hard sell for a serious movie if they go on for more than a short segment, and more in line with the normal musical amount of time.
1