Youtube comments of Britta Kriep (@brittakriep2938).
-
I am not Britta herself, but her boyfriend. About 20 years ago, i bought a hat in a small and very oldfashioned shop, owned by an old lady, which looked much older, because of her oldfashioned dress and hairstyle. The lady told me about an incident with her blank pistol ( could be carried without licence up to 2008) , a policeofficer had asked her, why she correctly handled the pistol, and she told him , that she learned this in wwll german army. She showed me her lower leg, where she had a wound from a larger piece of shrappnel ( ?)/ Granatsplitter.
923
-
A small note from Germany: In time of Holy Roman Empire, Germany was split into more than 300 states. The smallest ones had often armies with lesser than 50 men. Military unuseable, only a police and ceremonial force. With exeption of this ,giant' armies, the noble or spiritual ruler had only the possibillity to mobilize the ,Landsturm', a levie of fightable, but badly trained or armed men. Those units, also called Landmiliz, Landfahnen ( rural areas) Stadtgarde,Stadtwache, Stadtmilitär, Bürgerwehr, Bürgergarde, Bürgermiliz, Bürgermilitär ( towns). Those town militias often, but not allways,had uniforms and slightly better training.
538
-
197
-
Some notes from Germany: For centuries you could write your family as you wanted. For example Meier, Maier, Mayer, Meyer. Mayr, Mair, Meyr, Meir, Majer. Also the same name could be different in another dialect, for example Schulz, Schultz, Schultze, Schulze, Schultes, Schultheiß. In second half of 19th century this ended, the people had to continue the version of name, used at the first day of new law, the reason, why in family names often the no more used ,th' still appears.
To the name Hitler. There is another possibility. The german word for hut/ cabin is Hütte, and the ,ü' is in swabian/and bavarian dialect ( Up to mid 12th century Austria was part of Bavaria) mostly spoken ,i'. So a Hüttner/Hüttler , a poor man owning only a hut/cabin could have become in dialect a ,Hitler'. I am no scientist, so i can be wrong, but in german also the family names Hauser ( literally Houser) and Hofer (Farmowner) exist.
179
-
Twenty years ago, the museum may had a different name, today it is simply ,Waffenmuseum Oberndorf' in socalled Schwedenbau ( Swedish building). It shows weapons from Königliche Waffenmanufaktur, Mauser, H&K and Feinwerkbau and civilian products of Mauser company ( When i, Brittas boyfriend, was young, Mauser caliphers had been not uncommon). The entrance ticket allows you also to visit Heimatmuseum/ homeregion museum in the same building, there is a good collection of sword-, seaxblades and spearheads from graves of alemannic warriors.
124
-
I am german. Perhaps 15 years ago, i saw in german TV a documentation, for some research in wwll U- Boot context, a british scientist dived with a small civllian submarine in a british port, inside the submarine was the driver, the scientist and a former german U- Boot man. During the diving an order from the ,Hafenmeister' ( don' t know english word, perhaps Port Commander?) came, they should stop using the submarine in the port without allownes of , Hafenmeister'. The former german navy sailor said: Its the second time, that i am here in a submarine without allowness of british Hafenmeister.
110
-
101
-
97
-
81
-
As a german Facharbeiter(trained worker) i must speak about a small mistake, unclear description Ian has made. The word Meister can mean a ,Champion' or a very talented craftsman, artist etc.. But in this case a Meister means a ,master craftsman' , a title which goes back to middle ages. Formerly a boy who wants to become a craftsman started his training at an age of 14 (my father was some weeks younger than 14 when he started in 1952) as a , Lehrling (today Auszubildender), today with 17 or 18 (the school system changed), after a training time of usually 3 to 3,5 years you are in Industry a Facharbeiter, in old style (non industrial) craftmanship/ Handwerk you are a Geselle, also a title which goes back to middle age. When you worked some years as a Facharbeiter or Geselle you can do a difficult and expensive training and you have to produce a Meisterstück/ mastrepiece. When everything is well a Facharbeiter becomes an Industriemeister, a Geselle becomes a Handwerksmeister. Whats the difference? A Handwerksmeister can open his own Werkstatt/ shop(??), hire some Gesellen, train new Lehrlinge as it has been for centuries, while an Industriemeister is ,only' the leader of a team of workers or a production room etc. in an industral factory, whatever products the factory produces. A Waffenmeister doesn't work in a armsfactory, thats an an armorer who has to repair and inspect the arms of soldiers, policemen etc. or this word is very rare used for a Fechtmeister/ maitre d'armes.
78
-
78
-
I am german, Brittas boyfriend, ln my swabian homeregion in nearly every village , especially when the name ends with -ingen, graves of our allemanic ancestors have been found. Depending on warriors wealth, you can find blades of seaxes and spathas, axeheads, and speartips, lesser arrow tips. Helmets or armour are rather rare, but shield bosses very common. For the case, some readers of my comment want to visit Waffen( weapons)museum Oberndorf am Neckar ( Mauser, Heckler & Koch, Feinwerkbau, Königlich Württembergische Waffenfabrik), pllease visit also the Heimatmuseum (Homeregion museum). It is in the same building, you can visit both museums with the same ticket. In Heimatmuseum there are the allemannic weapons relicts, found next Oberndorf.
72
-
71
-
70
-
@Kobe379 : Double Standards, yes, even you dont like this. One example: Russia was not punished for the Invasion of Poland in 1939 together with Germany, and also not for the attack on Finland , also known as Winter War. Or the american pilots which shot german civilians with their plane machine guns. Also german law was changed in late 60s: Formerly it was possible, that someone could not been punished, when the murder crime happened more than 30 years ago. For this reason, still a few concentration camp guards in their late 90s are waiting for their trial. And Erich Mielke, former leader of East german Stasi ( red painted Gestapo) came into prison not for his crimes done as Stasi leader , but for murdering two policemen BEFORE 1933. So are there any trials for allied warcrimes of wwll still now? Are the allied veterans, posing with their medals even today , really allways innocent angels?
62
-
61
-
In the german arms magazin ,Deutsches Waffenjournal' long ago, every year an ,April's fool' article appeared. One April you could read, that in the endtime of wwll the Wehrmacht tried to use the bulletshaped stonelike relicts of animals called ,Belemiten' ( don't know english name), died millions of years ago, as bullet substitute. This was of course April's fool fun, but perhaps 25 years ago i worked with my father on a field, when my father grabbed such a stonelke relict, which was much more symetrical than usual. It was a ball from a heavy machinegun, perhaps fired from a plane.
59
-
59
-
56
-
52
-
50
-
@randomdude2026 : As you surely recognized, i am german. I speak few french and for six times i visited France, without rifle and helmet. But it is simply annoing, always hearing that Germany invaded France three times. But , for example, i have never seen a French, english, german or US movie, which shows, what the French did. For not so well educated persons it seems , that the german hate against the French came , out of the nothing' as we germans say, but this is simply not true. When you are no german, you perhaps don' t understand it, how a german feels, when he sees, that nongerman nations allways cover their dirt, but point at my country.
47
-
47
-
47
-
44
-
43
-
40
-
39
-
39
-
There was surely a market for such small guns, but of course they are underrated. Here in Germany, I am german, during Napoleonic Era open carry of weapons by civilians was forbidden, with exeption of hunting or targetshooers Events ( Schützenfeste). So saddle pistol and smallsword had been replaced by pocket pistols, small daggers, knuckle dusters, Things similar to sap or Blackjack and of course canes, often with hidden blades' or steel rods, even hidden shotgun Barrels. Also in other european or european influenced countries this was the Case, that especially fine townsmen or Gentlemen no longer wanted to be Seen armed when civilian dressed. And up to 1960s pocket pistols and revolvers in .22, .25 or.32 had been popular and Seen as usefull weapon.
Here in Germany cheap boxlock muzzleloader derringers had been Sold into 1930s as wineyard pistols to scare annimals, and cheap single shot pistols in .22/ 6mm Flobert Had been sold as cheap target/plinking pistols Up to 1930s, and convered to blank pistols even in 1950s. And in some latin american countries, especially Brszil, small doublebartelled Garrucha pistols Had been produced Up to 1970. Strangely Ian has No Video about Garruchas.
39
-
A similar phenomeon exists also in Germany. There is a very small group of people , which are called , Jenische', they once also travelled like Gypsys ( once called Zigeuner in Germany, nowadays Sinti and Roma) around in horsepulled charts, why some people called this ,Jenische' also ,Karrenleute/ chart peoples'. This people once had been traders, pedlars, repaired things ( Kesselflicker), sharpened scissors ( knifes ...), appeared as travelling musicans or artists at fairs.... But ethnicly they had been german. Of course, because of their travelling lifestyle, even many owned a small house , to which they returned after every Journey, they often got problems, and large problems, especially from 1933 to 1945.
39
-
39
-
39
-
37
-
37
-
37
-
36
-
@adrienrassat1965 : I am german, and i haven' t heared such nonsens out of the mouth of a non- Nazi. I, and many other oft my countymen have dark hair, You perhaps don't know, that in southern and western part of Germany, the old romano/ germanic border fortification ,Limes' is partly still visible, there had been Roman provinces Germania inferior, Germania superior and Rhaetia? You don' t know, that in 30years war ( 1618- 1648) many italian and spanish mercennarries suported Catholic side. In late 17th century for religious reasons, many french people moved to protestantic countries ( England, Netherlands, Germany, Switzerland).
Also, all Europeans ( exept Finns, Estonians, Hungarians, Basques and Turks) are Indo- Europeans, so basicly white. And also the non indoeuropean nations ( with exeptions of the Turks, belonging to mongolian family of peoples), are also white. So, why should members of romanic nations ( in Europe!) be coloured people
35
-
35
-
35
-
35
-
I am german, in German TV there is since 1968 a Show called ,Xy ungelöst', where Police IS searching Missing persons, or tries to solve unsolved Dangerous cases of crime. Some cases are described with movies, some only with Photos or objects in Studio. Long ago a Case was , that a robber stole a parcel from a Woman, and Hurt a man watching the robbery by pistolshot. The wounded man was an elderly british Tourist, and Said to Police: Last Time i visited Germany was in 1945, IT IS Strange that i am allways wounded by Balls, when Being in Germany.
Excuse my writing, there is a Computer Problem.
35
-
Not really true. Maschinenpistolen had been forbidden for Reichswehr, only allowed for Police. Schutzpolizei units ( baracked Police?) had only the allowness of five submachine guns per Hundertschaft ( Hundertschaft means about , hunderd men', a purely civilian word). May be other branches of german Police also had few submachineguns. Not only military weapons had been regulated in Versailles treaty, also weaponry of Police. This means, for policemen, not belonging to Schutzpolizei units, ( Ordnungspolizei and Kriminalpolizei/ detectives, only pistols in .32 Acp or even .25 Acp had been allowed, also police sabers had been regulated. With some troubles, german Gouvernement could get the allowness that uniformed policemen on foot could carry a long saber,If they had the allowness to carry a long saber in Imperial Army or Police. Also for pistol producers Versailles treaty caused, that they could only produce pistols with caliber smaller than 8mm ( about .32), and no Barrels longer than 102 mm/ 4". Producing pistols may be in .380 Acp was possible, but mostly only for foreign Market.
34
-
The ,heavy cavallry' was so called, because they used the tallest horses, the heaviest equipment, and , in later centuries, also the tallest horsemen. Light cavallry used smaller horses, lighter equipment, and in later centuries, average or smaller horsemen. When Dragoner ( dragoons?) had been only mounted infantry, they bot horses of lowest quality, no matter of small or tall.
34
-
Napoleon Blownapart : During the Hitler era, the ,academic fencing' of german and austrian students was not allowed, so in these days only swiss students fenced in this way. Even today some students do this, but it is no more popular. Outside of the german language countries few students do this in Belgium, Poland and the three baltic countries ( in german Estland, Lettland, Litauen) , when it is true, also some chilenian students. Today this scars are no more wanted and the students prefer modern medicine/ doctor's work. And: from mid 19th to mid 20th century those scars had been a sign of the german language academics, for noblemen this was not common ( for them only scars from battle counted). The 19th century was a time, when the power of the nobility slowly declined, but the importance of non nobles began to rise. Those important non nobles had been rich persons, officals of higher rank and academics. In those days ( and up to the 1950s) only few pupils?/Schüler had been at the Gymnasium, they , and the students at university had been seen as the next members of the ,Elite' of the german countries, and with their scars they proudly showed ,I am a part of the Elite'. Today the situation in Germany is different. Today the Gymnasium is the most popular type of school, there are today more pupils than in Realschule ( middle education) or Hauptschule ( ordinary education). I am a Facharbeiter/ german style trained worker with middle education. I was born in the 60s, and i am rather shocked, what kind of idiots today leave the german schools, even the Gymnasien.
34
-
33
-
33
-
32
-
32
-
32
-
31
-
31
-
30
-
29
-
29
-
28
-
28
-
27
-
Task & Purpose : I am german, in a lot of museums and castles/palaces i have seen medieval plate armour. I have an Asperger disease and do not understand, if you mean this serious or as a joke. Camouflage, in german ,Tarnfarbe' was nearly useless up to the invention of modern nitro gunpowder, because of the blackpowder smoke clouds. Of course german light infantry (Jäger) used green jackets in 18 century, they had been in those days really forest officals, in my state he color of forest officals/ Förster uniforms had been green up to a few years ago. Those medieval plate armors had been very expensive, only counts, dukes or kings could buy decorated full armor, ordinary knights or men at arms , or rich town citizens not so much. And after 1500 pompeous armors were not for battlefield, but to impress other people, like many rich people today use an expensive car. For the case you visit the ,Zwinger' building in Dresden there is a very pompeous german armor made for a swedish king, who had the idea to marry Elizabeth l of England and wanted to appear in London with this armor.
26
-
26
-
25
-
@WingedAsarath : The Anglosaxons came from those regions of Germany, where today Niederdeutsch is still spoken. In early 90s i worked in a small company in Southwest Germany, i , Brittas boyfriend, am Swabian. One day a new coworker from Niederdeutsch region came, and , just for fun, he spoke in Niederdeutsch to an english coworker. I remember one sentence: Und dann bin ik fallen in de kold Water. A turkish worker, who had never heared Niederdeutsch, thought, this was english, what the new coworker said.
24
-
24
-
Some sidenotes from West Germany. Uniformed german policemen had PPs sometimes up to 1982/ 83. From late 70s into 1990s civilian dressed police officers, especially female ones sometimes still had been armed with PPK in 7,65/ .32. The reason: Compact or subcompact 9mm Luger pistols had been non existing/ being rare, so in some kind of dress, or at summer, a PPK was easier to hide/ conceal. PPKs had then also in german Bundeswehr been used. By pilots, and soldiers in civilian dress ( Military Police, miltary intelligence, couriers and socalled Wallmeister, as far as i know). In 1950s/ 1960s female detectives, small number, but in contrast to 1920s to 1940s regular detectives, had been armed only with 6,35/.25 pistols, at very first sometimes only with 8mm blankpistols, firing teargas cartidges.
24
-
24
-
23
-
23
-
23
-
21
-
21
-
Some notes from Germany: Zeppelin is spoken Tseppelin, not Seppelin. The Freiherren ( Baron is wrong, Baronet would be better) von Zeppelin came from a village Zöpelin in nortwestern Germany. There are descendents of Ferdinand von Zeppelin, their name is today ,von Brandenstein/Zeppelin'. One of this family lives in a small palace next to the town Ravensburg. During a daytrip with a small historic society, i could visit his castle/palace. He showed us the few things of his famous ancestor , he owned. A Zeppelin company, selling construction maschines is also existing in Germany. In 1996 i visited next to Niederstetten (?) a castle /palace owned by a branch of Hohenlohe Dynasty to visit both the ,Hunting Museum' and the ,Albert Samt Museum' about the Zeppelin pilot. Unfotunately, this museum no more existed. Sidenote: The guide of the ,Hunting Museum' was 96 (!) years old. He died in 2007 with 107 years and was the last german wwl veteran.
21
-
@adrienrassat1965 : Omelette is known in german as ,Rührei', so you are clearly german :-). But now fun aside. The inhabitants of Alsace are, like me as a Swabian, members of Alemanic tribe, those few people of Lorraine, who still speak german, speak frankish dialect like people from Saarland or Rheinland - Pfalz, the French have stolen this regions from Germany. Also the german name for France is Frankreich ( realm of the Franks), the descendants of those Franken, which don' t möge to France are still alive in Saarland, Rheinland- Pfalz, Hessen, northern parts of Bayern and Baden - Württemberg, parts of Nordrhein- Westfalen. And those Franken, which moved to current France in merowingian/ carolingian age became there only upperclass, like Normans in England after 1066. The ordinary people in csrolingian France had been latinized/ romaniced celtics, while the ordinary people in England after 1066 had been Anglosaxon. So, those people in France who are ethnic frenchmen, are also today mostly romanic persons, but some of them have also germanic ancestry. Same with Italiens ( few germanic influence by Franks, Langobards, Goths and later Germans/ Austrian) and Spainiards ( some few influence by Goths and Suevi). So the members of romanic nations have a part oft germanic ancestry, as we Germans ( in Germany) also have a romanic and slavic part of ancestry.
20
-
20
-
20
-
20
-
19
-
19
-
19
-
19
-
@AndrewAMartin : Excuse me, wrong button!. It is intressting, that Hafenmeister is simply Harbormaster. In contrast to german language, english language has two words for ,Hafen' - port and harbor, which i have forgotten. But attention! When you visit a town in my homeregion, where Swabian Dialect is spoken, don't be surprised when you read in a town ,Hafengasse', Hafenmarkt' etc. as street or placename. In swabian dialect, far away from the sea, a Hafen is a pot. So the Hafengasse has its name from the Hafner/pot makers who once worked here.
19
-
19
-
19
-
19
-
18
-
18
-
@lafeeshmeister : I am a man, only using my girlfriends account. I am 55 now, but for the reason of bad eyes, i had not to serve in the Bundeswehr as conscript, so i have no military training or expierience. But i think, i have the answer to your question, why about close quarter fights is more spoken and thougt about. Wien my father was young, he spoke with some veterans from trench warfare oft wwl. My father asked one time two of those men, which thing oft war was the most terrible for you? The answer of both men, was a thing, my father did not expect: The enemies assault! Most oft the wartime they could not see their enemies, but at an assault you see , like your ancestors centuries ago, an armed angry enemy with grimm face attacking you. And this thing, you don' t shot an unseen or faceless enemy in a distance, but an enemy next to you is the thing, why there are so much emotions about fights with knives or Pistole.
18
-
18
-
18
-
18
-
17
-
Ja volim Picke : Niemand , der vernünftig ist, hat etwas gegen redliche Leute aus dem Ausland , die hier arbeiten. Was hingegen Leute verärgert, ist : A) Daß Leute, die hier noch nie etwas gearbeitet haben, hier fürs Nichtstun mehr Geld erhalten, als schlecht verdienende Einheimische. B) Daß, egal welchen Mist diese Flüchtlinge machen, nicht die Flüchtlinge ,erzogen' werden, sondern Deutschen , die sich beschweren, rechthaberisch übers Maul gefahren wird. C) Uns Deutschen wird immer vorgegaukelt, wie reich wir seien, und wir seien im besten Deutschland aller Zeiten. Die Leute sind nicht doof, sie wissen und bemerken, daß unser Land nicht erst seit gestern im Niedergang ist. Meiner Meinung nach , gibt es für einfache , kleine Leute wie mich, seit mindestens fünfzehn Jahren keine Verbesserungen mehr. Die Politik unserer Regierung hat dazu geführt, daß ein loyaler Untertan wie ich, sich nicht mehr an seine Lehenspflicht gebunden sieht, um es altertümlich auszudrücken. Ich bin schlicht enttäuscht und habe keine Lust mehr.
17
-
17
-
17
-
17
-
17
-
17
-
I am german, Brittas boyfriend. The Postschutz ( postal protection) was intended to guard post buildings , post trains ( or single post wagons in an ordinary train) . Up to 1990s german post was a 100% gouvernement owned company, and not only letters and parcels had been post work, also telephone and postal bank had been formerly postal branches, also no more existing telegraph. So there had been a large number of buildings , vehicles, railway wagons, telephone and telegraph lines. And in wartime may be more things.
Also up to 1990s german railway was mostly gouvernement owned , with a Bahnpolizei/ railway police. In wartime also the Bahnschutz existed, as a guard unit only ( but not well reputated). So sometimes the ,soldiers' defending german trains in wwll had been in reality members of railway police, railway protection and postal protection.
17
-
17
-
@gambigambigambi : In german we call us germans , die Deutschen', with the word Germanen we mean either our ancestors in tribal age ( in my case the tribe oft Alemannen) or all persons from german ( including austrian and german swiss), english, dutch, flemmish, afrikaans, danish , swedish, norwegian, icelandic or Färöer islands language/ nation. Many people confuse german and germanic!
16
-
16
-
16
-
16
-
16
-
15
-
@herbderbler1585 : My comment was written more as a joke, than serious. I , german, simply wanted to make fun about the american ,oh our glorious Colt 1911 is in military use since 1911!'. A knife is both weapon and tool for thousnds of years. In very old ,warrior' times knives ( and daggers) had been important weapons also in battle. But with the rise of firearms, knives and daggers became a ,last backup' for soldiers, and when in early 18th century the daggerlike plugbayonnetts had been replaced by gripless spike bayonnets, daggers and weapon knives mostly disappeared in regular european troops. But in wwl , for trench warfare, knives appeared again as weapons. But , as a german arms magazine wrote, the trench knives have seen more saussage fat than human blood'. So most of the modern military field knives are dual purpose items, useable as a tool, but on rare incidents also as a weapon. But we should not forget, when used as a close quarters combat weapon , especially in a ,surprise attack', knives are very dangerous and often underrated!
15
-
15
-
A note from Germany. Current german word for war is Krieg, but old word Streit has survived in some cases. Streitross/ warhorse ( you also see here old word Ross for Pferd, which is similar to horse), Streitwagen means war chariot (in swedish a stridsvagn is a tank). But i assume war can also be related to Wehr. Wehr can be a weapon ( dated), an armed force ( dated ) ot sich wehren , to defend yourself. Knowing this, Wehrmacht could be translated as , warmight '. English warden exists in german as Wächter, Wärter or Wart. I am german of swabian tribe ( south west Germany). In my local variant of swabian dialect, the words for stapeln ( to staple)/ Stapel ( staple) are beiga/ Beig. For all my life, i an 59 now, i could not explain this strange beiga/ Beig thing. Half a year i noticed scandinavian bygge means building, to build/ errect ( errichten). This scandinavian bygge explains Beig/ beiga in my homeregion.
15
-
Nick Eldridge : You are a nationalist idiot, without any historical knowledge. From 1700 - 1806 there was the Holy Roman Empire of German Nation. This was a country of more than 300 states ( Reichsstände) with a seat in the parlament ( Reichstag). This had been states of nobility lords, the emperor/ Kaiser ( the emperors could only use their own teritory, because in the ,emperorles time' 1254-1274 the crown land disapeared), the noble electors/ weltliche Kurfürsten ( Brandenburg, Pfalz, Bayern, Sachsen, Hannover, Böhmen), dukes/Herzöge, counts and princes Grafen/ Fürsten of different ranks, and lords/Herren. This had been spiritual lords, spiritual electors/geistliche Kurfürsten (the bishops of Mainz, Köln and Trier), princed Probsts/ Fürstpröbste, princed abbots/ Fürstäbte ( in some cases female abbots of female monastries) and the territorries of the catholic knights orders ( order of St. John/ Malteser, Johanniter, Order of St. Mary/ Teutonic Order, Deutschritterorden/ Deutschherren etc.). Then there had been the Imperial Towns / Reichsstädte, from large territories like Ulm or Münster over important towns like Hamburg or Frankfurt am Main, to ,Metropoles' like Zell am Harmersbach. Then there had been teritories with no seat in the parlament, mostly imperial knights/ Reichsritter, but also imperial villages/ Reichsdörfer and at least one territory which consisted of a single farm (!). From 1350- 1648 the Roman (german) emperor was weak, but after 1648 the emperor lost most of his power over the other territories. He could NOT declare war / Reichsexekution, this was a thing of parlament and happened rarely. The most important states had been the ,Austrian countries' of the emperor himself, the Elector of Brandenburg ( inside of HRE the king ,in' not ,of' Prussia was technicaly only Kurfürst von Brandenburg, because Prussia was never part of HRE), and the electors of Pfalz and Bavaria, after the 1770s the same person, and the electors of Hannover, who was after 1714 also King of Great Brittain. And the smaller states? Some of them for example Württemberg or Hessen-Darmstadt could field few regiments, but for example the Fürstprobst of Ellwangen had 36 soldiers on foot and 12 men on horse
15
-
@Intelwinsbigly : I am not Britta herself, i am her boyfriend, only using the same Computer ,Anschluß', don' t know the english word. I am 55 and basicly a conservative / rural factory worker, and a ,nostalgic' supporter of ,parlamentary monarchy' as it is in Great Brittain. For decades/Jahrzehnte i voted for CDU Party, so when Angela Merkel became leader of CDU party and first female chancellor in more than 1000 years of german history, i had no problem. But after a short time i was very dissappointed, she does no policy for the ,average german on the street'. I personnally am very angry about her.
15
-
@makoffski5314 : Habe seit Jahrzehnten nichts von einer Vergewaltigung einer muslimischen Frau durch deutsche Männer gehört. Ich , Brittas Freund, kenne in meinem Umfeld aber zwei Frauen, die schon von ,Asylanten' belästigt wurden, eine Frau Ende 50 mit starker Gehbehinderung ( hat mir gesagt, daß sie zwar auch aufdringliche deutsche Männer kenne, aber selbst diese seien nicht so arg, wie die Asylbewerber) und ein Mädchen. Als dieses 14 war hatte sie mit ihrer Großmutter etwas in der Kreisstadt zu erledigen, die Zwei wurden unflätig beleidigt.
Auch in der Tanzlokal-, Musiklokal- und Diskothekenszene habe ich von Bedienungen und weiblichen Gästen schon Beschwerden über das Benehmen muslimischer Männer gehört. Das sind berechtigte Beschwerden, aber kein Rassismus. Anstatt Rassismus zu rufen, sollten sich speziell die Muslime fragen, woran es liegt , daß sie bei vielen Einheimischen unbeliebt sind.
15
-
I am Brittas boyfriend and german. About 25 years i ago wanted to buy a rarely used thing, i found it in a very oldfashioned shop, owned by an old lady. She told me , that some years ago, she heared strange noises in the night and wanted to look, what is happening. So she took her semiautomatic blankgun and went ot of the house. Someone saw her with the blanks pistol and called the police. When the patrol arrived, the officers wanted to know, what happened and to see the pistol. The old lady told me, that before giving the pistol to the policemen, she repeated the slide. The officers had been surprised and asked: Mrs ..., why do you know this? She answered: I learned this at the end of wwll.
15
-
14
-
Attention! Gewehr doesn' t mean rifle, this would be Büchse. Gewehr in civilian context is an umbrella word for all long guns , Flinte ( shotgun), Büchse ( rifle) , Büchsflinte, Bergstutzen, Drilling, Vierling (combination guns) and Wallbüchse ( wallguns) , Entenkanone (puntgun) and later Panzerbüchse ( antitankgun/ antimaterial rifle). In military context from early 19th century to early 20th century Gewehr was used for a fullsize battlerifle of lineinfantry ( and after 1870s also Jäger) in contrast to Karabiner of cavallry or artillry ( in Austria also Stutzen was sometimes used for shorter military rifles). And, in documents before 1800 Gewehr can also mean sometimes , weapon in general ', a bayonnet can be either Bajonett or Seitengewehr, only for example. Ge- means in german basicly a lot of. So Gesang- a lot of singing, or Geschrei- a lot of singing, and Wehr? Sich wehren/ to defend yourself, die Wehr is dated for weapon, mostly a bladed weapon , see Bauernwehr in HEMA circles. Formerly a pure Gewehr- or Waffenhändler was only a trader/dealer , no producer/maker. This term showed, that the business owner is no Büchsenmacher ( gunmaker/ gunsmith), Klingenschmied (bladesmith) or Schwertfeger ( sword finisher?).
14
-
14
-
14
-
14
-
14
-
14
-
14
-
13
-
13
-
13
-
13
-
Why do you not write the fact, that between 1815 and long into 1980s, no shotguns had been used as service weapon. Only in 1830s/ 1840s few of southern german states bought a small number of percussion side by side shotguns. They had been sometimes handed to the up to 1890s/1900s only saberarmed policemen, mostly when fighting poachery, or escort a large number of prisoners to a prison.
The 19th/20th century german/austrian counterpart to US Wild West literature had been novels, in which either a Forrest Service official ( Förster) or a lawfull licenced huntsman fights poachers , smugglers or other criminals in the Woods. The heroic characters are armed with rifles, while shotguns, when appearing, had been the weapons of the criminals.
Perhaps you now understand, that german soldiers of wwl saw shotguns not as service weapons, but as weapons, used by criminals, so the shotgun armed US soldiers, other ones don' t used them, as criminals.
13
-
13
-
13
-
13
-
13
-
13
-
13
-
13
-
To jaif: My mistake! The territories of current Brandenburg, Pommern and former Schlesien/ Silesia had been inhabitatet by germannic tribes. As far as i know, the romans called baltic sea ,mare suevicum'. But the germannic tribes moved away, to south or west, and slavic tribes came . About year 1000, german noblemen, mostly Saxons ( in old, not modern sense) and Thuringians started to expand eastwards. Sometimes they conquered land, sometimes they betrayed the slavic people, sometimes the german noblemen married the daughters of slavic chiefs/ chieftains. Sometimes the german noblemen and their servants murdered lots of slavic people, but sometimes poor germans, following the noblemen, became the majority or mixed with slavic people. The slow germanisation ended about 1400, but in 14th century had been last slavic rebellions. In socalled , Spreewald ' ( Forrests of Spree River) there still live people, who speak slavic language mixed with german words, the , Sorben ' . They now have the right to keep their language and tradition, and in Spreewald signs are in sorbic and german. In Prussia situation was similar. When Order of St. Mary ( Teutonic Order) conquered Prussia, more and more germans settled there , and was also germanized, but was never part or HRE. Accidently, i thougt, the Prussians ( Pruzzen) had been slavic people. In baltic states up to 1860s german was official language. From time of merchants union ,Hanse' and the fact that german dominated ,Order of swordbrothers' ruled over baltic states, even belonging to Russia, upper class was mostly german. A relict of german upperclass in Lativia and Lithuania is, that german accademic fencing is practiced in Lativia and Lithuania, also some belgian and polish students do this.
13
-
13
-
To the armed forces of imperial Germany. The german army consisted of four armies : 1) The royal prussian army, including the troops of the greatdukes and dukes, also the soldiers of the principalities and free towns. The non prussian troops had the right to keep their regiment flags and regiment names. 2) The royal saxon army 3) The royal wurttembergian army. The saxon and wurttembergian armies could keep their regiment flags, their regiment names and their Generalstab/ general staff, but their general staffs had been allways under prussian command. 4) The royal bavarian army. They could keep their regiment flags, tegiment names and their general staff. The bavarian general staff was only in wartime under prussian command. Also the jackets of bavarian soldiers had been in , bavarian blue', the non bavarian soldiers had jackets in ,prussian blue'. The helmets had been the same in all german armies, but the coat of arms and cocardes had been different. Also the leatherhelmet with point was only used by line infantry and dragoons. Artillery gunners used a similar helmet with a ball to prevent accidents, and light infantry ,technical troops and parts of reserve units used the Tschako. Hussars had a cylindric hussars cap made of fur ( See Feldmarschall von Mackensen) and lancers/Ulanen used a small leather helmet with a tip down pyramide to remember the polish origin of the Ulanen ( The polish ceremonial guard still uses caps with square/ quadratisch top). Heavy cavallry and palace units used pointed helmets made oft steel vor copperbased metal.
13
-
13
-
A few years ago in a german arms magazin there was an article about an Mauser M71 or M71/ 84 rifle. Usualy all rifles had been in 11,15 x 60 , only for Serbia in 11,15 x 62. Now a german antique arms dealer/ trader bought such a rifle for a normal price for the rifles condition. Some time later, when he had more time, he took a closer look and noticed , the dummy cartridge in 11, 15 mm did not fit. It was in 9,4 mm , after research in military prussian archive, he had the solution, about 200 or 300 rifles had been made in 9,4 mm for a test/ trial , after a german officer with lots of ,connections' had nerved the War Ministry.
13
-
13
-
13
-
13
-
In the early part of the video the ,Arbeitsmaiden' ( working maids) of ,Reichsarbeitsdienst' are noted. My grandmother ( 1910- 1995) told me , that one of such ,Arbeitmaiden' had to help her father ( my greatgrandfather) , who was ,Farrenwärter' ( breeding bull warden) of the village. His work was ordinary farmers work, but for bulls owned by village. One day my grandmother, her father ( veteran of wwl) and the young ,Arbeitsmaid' worked on a meadow to make hay ( sidenote: german Heu and Stroh/ hay and straw/ are spoken in my dialect like a mix of english and german). Suddenly a plane came, the three hide in a group of bushes., and the plane threw two bombs. Nobody was hurt, but the Arbeitsmaid was so shocked, that she fell into the arms of my greatgrandfather and cried: Mr.... we will die! The US pilot didn' t want to kill civilians, what often happened, he threw the bombs before an emergency landing , because his plane had problems.
13
-
13
-
13
-
13
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
I am german, from a region full of ruins of Burgen castles. Most of them had been very small. Those inner central wall ( innere Ringmauer), and especially the outer walls ( Zwinger) , when existing (!) often have no towers. Often there is only main towe ( Bergfried) , and on castles on narrow hilltops or rocks, there was no tower, only a strong build massive house, because when being on a high position, you can see over surrounding territory, so a tower was not necessary ( as i noted, many castles had been small, sometimes very small), but build in rocky terrain, where you are surprised, that medieval persons build a castle there).
12
-
12
-
12
-
The ,prussian' army? The army of the german states had been may be 65% prussian soldiers. You totally have forgotten the soldiers of Bayern, Sachsen, Württemberg, Baden, Hessen- Darmstadt, Oldenburg, Mecklenburg- Schwerin, Mecklenburg- Strelitz, Sachsen- Weimar- Eisenach, Anhalt, Braunschweig, Sachsen- Altenburg, Sachsen- Meiningen, Sachsen- Coburg- Gotha, Schwarzburg- Rudolstadt, Schwarzburg- Sondershausen, Waldeck- Pyrmont, Lippe- Detmold, Reuß- Greitz, Reuß- Schleitz, Hamburg, Bremen and Lübeck.
12
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
12
-
@kameronjones7139 : I am no gunowner. But i, Brittas boyfriend, am on the side of serious target shooters, hinters or weapon collectors ( firearms or edged weapons). I don't like violence, for its so bad results ( dead, cripled or mental hurt persons) . But not the existence oft weapons is the reason for violence. In three months we have national elections in my home country Germany. An election victory of the leftwing , Green Party' ( Die Grünen) is rather possible!!!!!!!!! They want to forbid to own , deadly shooting arms'. In german language , Schußwaffen' are not only firearms ( Feuerwaffen) but also bows, crossbows, strong airguns and slingshots. So it seems that in close future the greatest peoples disarming since 1525 ( beating down the great farmers revolt) is coming in my country. I think, i must not tell an US citizen, what it means, when ,democratic (?)' party wants to forbid modern weapons! ( In Wilhelm II era, we germans had the most liberal weapons laws of our history.)
12
-
12
-
11
-
@ThePreparedNorseman : Olympic pentathlon is assumingly ,Moderner Fünfkampf' in german. For political correctnes reason, and for whiny left wingers, firearms are replaced with ,laser guns' , why not with laser pointers? Cross country riding was replaced with ,Springreiten' ( don' t know english word), and olympic fencing is a total nonsens, if someone hits the opponent a 1/ 100 second earlier, he is the winner, but in reality there would be two dead fencers.In reality not the first thrust stops the attack of an enemy, good parrying protects life.
11
-
11
-
11
-
I am german, and Brittas boyfriend, i only use her Computer. May be 15 to 20 years ago, i visited a public health bath ( Thermalbad) next to my homevillage. In those days not common, i heared an old couple speaking in english about the ruins of a fortress , you can see there. As history intessted person, i told the couple, what i know about the fortress. This had been US tourists . The man told me, that his father a short time before or after wwl emigrated to USA from my homeregion, i know the village. He could speak only few words of german language, because it was unwanted when he was a child. But in correct swabian dialect he spoke the word ,Backhäusle'/ little baking house, because his father often told him about this, slowly coming out of use, public baking houses, and he was happy, that now as an old man, he could see this.
11
-
@ericoberlies7537 : I am german, and rather astonished too, that the grave still exists. My comment was intended, that i see in general a difference between stealing a sword from a grave, whoever is burried, and taking weapons from dead or captured enemies. For example, somewhere in southern Italy is the grave of German Emperor Friedrich ll, died 1250. The grave contains still his sword , broken in two pieces. But you can' t steal his sword, over 770 years after his last war, and say, its a wartrophy. Only this is my Point.
11
-
11
-
11
-
11
-
11
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
@adrienrassat1965 : Today in modern Europe the people are rather mixed. If you see an european person, you can only say, this could be a person from southern, northern, eastern or balkan part, not really more. I, Brittas boyfriend, don' t look like ,typical german' , there had been persons, which thought , i am French or from Georgien ( in caucasus mountains). We Europeans should be careful, that the age of wars between our nations has no ,Comeback'. To the many non european persons nowadays in Europe, i don' t know, if its good or not for the spirit of european life and culture, we can' t look to the future.
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
9
-
@ms.blackcat : I, Brittas boyfriend am also no Accademic, but it happeded sometimes that guides of museums or historical tours ( done by a small german historical society) told me, that for a trained worker my historical knowledge is rather good. At one historical tour to town Wertheim the guide was a princess of Löwenstein - Wertheim -... When we visited the ruins of medieval Wertheim Castle, where her ancestors once lived, she spoke only about histotry and artistical aspects of Castle architecture, but no word of intressting military aspects of castle architecture. For known reasons, military toppics are in Germany no more in favour. So i asked the princess if is allowed, to speak some words about rare to see Details of fortifications. She allowed this, and afterwards other members of tour said, it is rare, to hear someone who has knowledge about fortifications ( and tells this in slowly dying out local dialect).
9
-
9
-
9
-
One Inch is in Germany mostly called , englisches Zoll' or only ,Zoll'. We once had ,Zoll' also. ( One ,prussian Zoll' was 26,2 mm). The ,english Zoll'/ inch is 25,4 mm, so 1 cm/ 10 mm is in decimal writing about 0,4 ( .4 ) inch. This Inch system is in our country unusual, with exeption of pipes. For most pipe diameters EN and ANSI is the same, but for example ,2,5 " is in ANSI 73 mm and in EN 76 mm. , which sometimes caused problems, when i , Brittas boyfriend, worked in a small pipeline company.
9
-
@thif4722 : This had been civilian production, the armies of the four german kingdoms gave contracts to different arms companies, because the Revolver was not developed by a commercial company. But also other companies ,german and belgian , produced versions of this revolver. This versions had been often different to standardized military version. There had been versions with ejector, double action, trigger guard finger hook, different handles. In those days officers had to buy saber and revolver from their own money, so revolvers in 10,6 mm Deutsche Ordonnanz had been allowed for german officers, also if they had not been the standard model. So some officers had more modern revolvers. Same with their sabers/epees, the IOD 89. Rich officers, of high rank, nobility or factory owners background bought sabers with decorated blades and handles.
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
@Puffball-ll1ly : In my swabian homeregion in nearly every village graves of allemanic persons from 3th to 6th/ 7th century had been found, those grave items tradition of non christian reason ended in 7th century, noblemen practiced this after adoption of christianity some time longer than commoners. Those graves, sometimes large graveyards, are mostly found , when there are large constitution works, for example a new complex of houses, a new rsliway line or similar things. In many cases the use of old pagan graveyards ended, when churches had been build, and christian graveyards are , or had been until few decades ago, arround church. So with christianity the nonchrisrian gravesites had been forgotten, and are found now by coincience. Sometimes it also happens, that when old churches are enlarged, modernized or renovated, a grave with items is found. Assumingly the grave of a nobleman, who switched to christianity, ordered to build First church, but was burried in germannic tradition.
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
@ConradAinger : The english, dutch/ flemish, friesians, danish, swedish, norwegians, icelanders and faroese people are also germannics. But they are no germans. This is my point. In german language we call ourselves deutsch, when we speak of germanisch, we either mean all noted germannics ( including us germans), or our tribal ancesters up to 9th century. Before 843 ( Treaty of Verdun) it is totally impossible to speak of a german nation. As far as i know, it was in 10th century, when Regnum Teutonicum was in latin documents first used for Reich der Deutschen. The word theodisc - language of the people ( in contrast to latin of clergy , science or diplomacy) became over centuries first teutsch, then deutsch.
8
-
Please, don' t confuse german and germannic. We germans call us deutsch, when we use germanisch, then we mean all people, speaking a related language ( english, dutch/ flemish, swedish, danish, norwegian, friesian, icelandic , faroese and of course german).
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
@Serjo777 : I, Brittas boyfriend, have not watched the noted Video. Two notes. At first, to every historical topic, there are mostly two or more oppinions, you should know all, then you come next to historical truth. Second: When you read comments of any kind of Videos about minorities, you more and more find voices, which say, i once supported minorities, but now i no more support them. Their behavior is the thing i no more like . For the reason, that my knowledge of english language is limited, when comes to things, which exist only in brain ( you can' t grab), it is to difficult, to explain this understandable.
I try it. In Germany there are many choirs (?)/ Chöre in german. Most are mixed, some consist only of men, fewer only of women. Many of this choirs have been fouded in mid / late 19th century. Today, most of this , Gesangvereine ' have changed to a modern style of singing, the traditional ones slowly die. This choirs are organized in regional organisations, which are organized in a national Organisation. May be ten years ago a choir of homosexual men went to court, the Swabian Singers Federation is discriminating us, they don' t let us join their organisation. I No more remember, how this court trial (?)/ Prozess ended, but i remember the words of speaker of Swabian Singers Federation: The Swabian Singers Federation is an old Organisation for people, who like to sing in a choir, it is not an Organisation, which has anything to do with sexual things. We would have no problem with this choir of homosexual men, if they would use a traditional name, for example Männerchor Heilbronn 1998 ( Heilbronn Mens Choir 1998), but why do they use a name, which notes their homosexuality? That is a private thing, which has nothing to do with singing in a choir.
So it is often the behavior of minorities, allways claiming, to be the victim, which annoys more persons, than you may think. I don' t know the Situation in your country, but in Germany the modernlings think, they have eaten wisedom with a spoon and know everything, and because they are the flagbearers of tolerance, they want to ban every other oppinion than their own. I don' t think, the legendary men of great era of german science and education would like them.
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
8
-
@thorstenthiel760 : Ich kenne weder ihr Alter, noch weis ich, ob sie städtisch oder ländlich aufgewachsen sind. Es waren vor einigen Jahrzehnten tatsächlich andere Zeiten, ich kann mich noch bis etwa 1970 zurückerinnern. Von meinen Eltern , um 1940 geboren, und meiner Großmutter , 1910 bis 1995, habe ich in Gesprächen immer wieder erfahren, daß der Alltag, die gesellschaftlichen Normen etc. früher ganz anders gewesen sind. Das war teilweise schlicht Unwissenheit, aber auch, was ich an meinen Eltern noch immer bemerke, eine Nachwirkung des Württemberg Jahrhunderte prägenden Pietismus. Bei meiner Großmutter muß man bedenken, sie ist noch im Kaisereich auf dem Land geboren, es herrschte als noch Gedankengut des 19.Jahrhunderts!
Neue Ideen und Gedanken gibt es von Zeit zu Zeit, aber es dauert im Allgemeinen Jahrzehnte, bis es sich in Stadt und Land bei alt und jung durchsetzt, man wird im Allgemeinen vom Gedankengut seiner Zeit geprägt und kann oft nicht über seinen Schatten springen. Man sollte vorsichtig sein, die Menschen vergangener Epochen für ihre Fehler zu belächeln oder beschimpfen, denn man kann nicht sagen, wie man sich verhalten hätte, hätte man selbst in jener Epoche gelebt, das kann man nicht mit Sicherheit sagen. Mir sind Leute suspekt, die etwa sagen: Ja hätte ich in der USA um 1850 gelebt, hätte ich den Indianern geholfen. Woher kann man das wissen, wenn man damals nicht gelebt hat?
Richtig ist allerdings Folgendes: Früher haben sich die Menschen aus unserer Sicht oft falsch, zumindest aber unverständlich verhalten und zu wenig unternommen, wenn sich jemand auch nach den Maßstäben ihrer Zeit grenzwertig oder gar übertrieben bösartig verhalten hatte. Hier muß man froh sein, daß sich die Zeiten und Ansichten geändert haben.
8
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
@Darth-Nihilus1 : No! In civilian context Gewehr is umbrella term for long guns ( Shotguns, rifles, combination guns, lighter punt guns, wall guns, anti material guns, anti tank guns). In Military context a Gewehr was a full sized battle rifle, in contrast to shorter Karabiner ( or Stutzen in Austria). But attention! In older documents Gewehr also could be a bladed weapon , for example a Seitengewehr IS a bayonnet, or a Kurzgewehr was a kind of polearm, which was used by lowrank officers or sergeants long into 18th century. Why? Ge- means ,a lot of' ( Gesang- a lot of singing, Geschrei- a lot of shouting) and Wehr can be either weapon in general or a long knife ( see Bauernwehr). Sich wehren - to defend yourself. So Gewehr means ,a lot of defence ' and can be ( in older time) both a firearm or an edged weapon.
7
-
7
-
With the exeption of small bodyguard squads the ,fighters' had not been uniformed. Perhaps they had the same simple sign painted or sewed(?) on their jacket. When in late 17th century uniforms became common, there had been up to the end of colourfull uniforms arround 1910 in every army allways some troops, which had uniforms in other colours than usual. When now troops of the same army had different uniforms, it became a problem, when allied troops fought together, who is enemy and who an ally? For this reason, armbinds or sashes had been used, or simpler, the soldiers fixed, for example a little branch or a handfull straw as sign at their hats. I don' t know, if it is true, for a special ceremony the royal danish guard still apeares with some straw at their hats.
7
-
@s.w.4409 : For the case, you visit Germany, in the town Bad Mergentheim , in state Baden- Württemberg there is the museum of the ,Deutscher Orden', because this territory was the largest one, they had after the loss of Prussia. When i was there in 2019, i remember that they had a kind of uniform in Renaissance Time, depending on the rank ( for example Komtur), but in medieval time i don't remember, if they realy had a uniform in modern sense, or only of similar style and colour. Also in the same region is a museum of the Johanniter or Maltese Order, i think in the rather small town of Kirchberg an der Jagst (?) .
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
When in 1871 Second German Empire was founded, standard pistol was prussian M50 muzzleloader smoothbore percussion pistol, 15 mm caliber. In those german states, being in 1866 enemies of prussia ( Bavaria, Saxony, Württemberg, Baden and Hessen - Darmstadt) surely also rifled percussion pistols in austrian 13,9 mm existed. But only Bavaria had in 1869 decided, to buy centerfire 11,5 mm Werder rifles, carbines and pistols , all singleshot. When in 1870 war broke out neutral Belgium stopped trading firearms to Bavaria, only few bavarian soldiers had Werder weapons. After war, Mauser M71 became first german sevice rifle. Transforming Werder guns for 11mm Mauser was not good, so Bavaria canceled buying belgian weapons. A large number of carbines had been transformed into pistols, the rifles ( as noted only a part of ordered rifles came to Bavaria) was given to forrestry, prison, customs personal. In Saxony in 1872 or 1874 a strange Revolver in 10,4 mm was introduced, an enlarged S&W Nr. 1 or 2! Caused troubles with German Gouvernement, in Bavaria not , for reason of a bavarian privilege. But when Mauser offered a Revolver , german army decided, to create an own Revolver, the M79 was the result, the M83 the improvement. For test reason, a few Colt SAAs in 10,6 Deutsche Ordonnanz had been bought. The testing soldiers and officers said: A good Revolver! But for reason of either money or national pride, the german Army invention was bought. In german navy the Reichsrevolver replaced Colt Navy and british Adams Percussion revolvers in .36. Was in Prussia called.35, because english inch ( Zoll) is 25,4 mm, while prussian Zoll ( inch) was 26,2 mm. Handle of Reichsrevolver M79 had similar size and shape as M50 pistol.
7
-
Some notes: Not long ago, there was a Junkers company producing components for heating and hotwater equipment of houses. There is still a Zeppelin company selling / lending machines and equipment for road construction. The company, which produced the wooden Natter rocket planes still existed at least ten to twenty years ago as producer of camping vans/trsilers, using the Natter plane as Logo. And in wwll gerrman airforce used also gliders. Especially for paratroopers or invading forces in early stages, later the transport glider Me 323 (?) Gigant , from which also a motorised variant existed. I live next to german town Kirchheim unter Teck. This town and tegion has a long history of glider sport, and german glider pioneer Eolf Hirth lived here. There is still a glider company Schempp- Hirth existing. When you enter town district Nabern from west, you can still see a building from former Wolf Hirth company, producing components of wwll military gliders. Oh, noted MBB company had also buildings there, which are now used by different small companies, which are not involved in aircraft/ military production.
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
Sofus : I live in the german Landkreis Esslingen, Esslingen was a Reichsstadt. The capital of Landkreis Reutlingen, Reutlingen was a Reichsstadt. The capital of Landkreis Aalen , Aalen was a Reichstadt etc., etc.. Some of the former Reichsstädte are still important cities, Frankfurt, Nürnberg, Augsburg, but most of them are nowadays no more very important, only capitals of a Landkreis, which would be a county in USA, and some, for example Zell am Harmersbach are today rather small towns.
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
My father, born 1938, asked as young man veterans from wwl what they feared most. They told him, assaults had been fearfull, you see Like in long gone days an angry enemy charging you.
But pike didn' t dissapear in early 18th century. In case of pure pallace units , pikes existed in french royal guards until 1789. In case of lowtrained and bad equipped militias / Landsturm of many small HRE states, pikes and matchlock muskets had been used long into 18th century. During , Freedom wars' many prussian Landwehr units had few muskets, so many soldiers started the war with pikes or axes , until they could capture french muskets or got ones from Russia or Brittain. Also in 1813 württembergian King created four Landregimenter/ rural regiments, only half of usual size and only armed with halfpikes. A Police and guardforce only. During US civil war, thousands of pikes had been produced in Confederate states, there are interessting Videos, but the purpose is not exactly known. And during 19th century europe, many Rebel forces or semiofficical citizens units had been armed with warscytes.
7
-
7
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
Not much..From 1921 to 1933 ordinary Sturmmann had NO weapon, perhaps hidden a private one like Schlagring ( knuckles) or Totschläger ( related to sap and blackjack). Socalled officers, ordinary men of a bit higher rank or bravery the SA dagger in style of Schweizerdolch ( literally swiss dagger, but as far as i know, in english known as Holbein dagger). Then Germany had good knife industry, quality was surely good, but was intended more as dress weapon, than fight weapon, so don' t know, if every owner had a handle, realy fitting in his hand. Officers, and relative few men, for example SA Police ( counterpart of Military Police) different pistols , mostly 7,65 Browning/ .32 Acp, lesser 6,35 Browning/ .25 Acp or 9mm Luger. Rifles had been rare. When in 1934 the faked Röhmputsch ( Coup d'etat) was over, SA was reduced from four to one milion men, SA got other tasks. Real military rifles had been rare, but there had been also .22 lr training rifles in larger number. And before 1933, especially in early years, weaponry was everything but standardized. For reason, that before 1933 SA ( and SS)men got mostly no ccw licence, even guarding an important member, also obscure weapons like Nilpferdpeitschen ( hippopotamus hide whips/ Sjamboks) had been used.
I read magazines about military, weapons and history in general for decades, all kind of violent ideologists i don' t want.
6
-
@jrooney58 : I am german, and i have never done such deep research, But for about fourty years i read german language arms magazines Deutsches Waffenjournal, Schweizer Waffen Magazin and Visier, also for about fifteen years two german magazines of military history. In those magazines a number of times was noted, that only police was allowed to have a number of submachineguns. I don' t think, the magazines wrote this for no reason ( or in other words as a lie). Yes there had been only one company allowed to produce rifles for the Army and one company to produce Luger pistol for Army, if a replacement was necessary. According to german arms magazines, there was also a restriction for pistol producers that only barrels shorter than 4"/102 mm and max. caliber of 8 mm ( a tiny bit larger than .32, i am not familiar to for me unlogicsl US measurement system) was allowed, so that pistol producers could only produce pocket pistols, mostly.22, .25, .32. In late 20s some few .380 ACP seem to have appeared.
But i am no expert and can be wrong, i have not eaten wisedom with a spoon.
6
-
6
-
@GF-yh9tb : Before the Romans conquered current Spain and Portugal, there had been people of celtic and iberian ancestry, and of course the basques. In the battle of Cannae mercenaries of those people had been the center of Hannibals battle order, his cartagians had their Position at the flanks.
With the Romans ,roman' people and the Latin language came. But this ,Romans' could have been from all parts of Roman empire. For a short time also germanics, Western Goths and Suevi ( latin name of my tribe, i belong to the Swabians/ Schwaben in german). The germanic influence was short and not strong, but: Rodrigo for example is german Roderich, Hernan can be Hermann, Carlos is Karl, so some names have germanic roots. But what is with arabian influence, word relicts?
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
@ulfhedtyrsson : Please inform yourself, about shotgun Tradition in Germany. The First shotguns as service weapons for Police and Military had been introduced no longer than fourty years in Germany, causing loud leftwing outcry, even the guns are only intended for destroying Doors. And: Shotguns as weapons have not only no tradition as service weapons in Germany, they have from 19th century to now a very Bad Reputation as criminals weapons.
This psychological fact is allways either not noted, marginalized or used for making fun. The britisch troops in wwl also had sawbackblades in some Units ( according to Matt Easton from , scholagladiatora' channel, british troops invented ,Dum Dum' bullets by clipping the Tip away, and according to a german armsmagazine years ago, in early stages of war some british soldiers used , Manstopper' bullets, some similarity to hollowpoint.
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
In India a newcreated Webley company , claiming using leftover Webley machines , poduces tip down revolvers again. Also an indian state owned company produces a Webley style Revolver.. But for reason of indian gunlaw, only in .32 S&W long. I am german, and according to a german arms magazine, german forces of wwll used captured british revolvers ( Dünkirchen and Northern Africa) with 9mm Parabellum/ Luger as emergency weapon. The revolvers had .38 S&W./.38/200, and 9mm Parabellum/ Luger IS rimless. So some german soldiers used a Tool called Zange ( don't know english word) and transformed bottom of 9mm cartidge that IT don' t fall through chambers of cylinder. The writer of article assumed, that smaller Diameter of 9mm bullet caused a reduction of pressure. But, Germany was never a revolver nation, so i think , only few german soldiers used a captured british revolver.
6
-
6
-
6
-
Space Catboy : Good that i found another comment of you to answer. I could not find your full answer to my comment. What i wanted to tell is the fact, that if the Nuremberg court trials (Prozesse), my english is not so good, about war crimes would have been fair and corect, also the warcrimes of the allied soldiers and resistance/ partisans would have been punished, but this did not happen. Still now there are some few court trial in Germany against concentration camp guards in their mid/ late 90s, but i have never heard, that former allied soldiers had problems for doing warcrimes after WWll. To the SS: there had been correct military actions where the SS units fought with great bravery , but heavy losses because their staff had not the quality of the Wehrmacht. But there had also been very terrible things, done by men like Dirlewanger. But i must say, that also the resistance/ partisan movements did crimes , and so we come to the question of hen and egg, to use a german saying. ( What was first, the hen or the egg?) . In 1813, when the ,Great Army' of Napoleon had to leave Russia, there was the question in germany, shall the german civilians attack the backfloading relicts of the french army like the spanish ,guerilla'? The prussian king was shocked about this plans and forbid such actions. Also in this time the german ,education spirit' nearly reached its peak, an many artists, scientists and intellectuals said: No! Don't do this, we Germans are no unhonourus criminals! So the gerrman view of ,franctireurs' in the 1870/71 was : this are criminals! And this tradition still worked in WWll that armed people being no soldiers have been seen simply as criminals. Last point. In the 90s i was for a day trip in Alsace, where many people still speak german. I wanted to buy a hot saussage in french language, and the man answered in german : You want some mustard? So i don't think you really can fool someone with speaking a foreign language.
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
I am german, Brittas boyfriend, conservativbe/ rural backgound, germanstyle trained worker (Facharbeiter) , socalled middle education (Mittlere Reife). But this Mittlere Reife I got by leaving Gymnasium after 10th Grade. Perhaps you don' t know what Gymnasium is in Germany. It is the Type of high school which prepares for university. In my Gymnasium days, most teachers Had been what I call centrist ( moderate left, moderate conservative) , few really conservative/ left and one leftwing Idiot. This was a few years, before the leftwing teachers fully won, so I got , perhaps one of the last classes, a serious science based education.
But, when watching current students and younger politicians being Accademic, especially left ones, i sometimes have doubts about their knowledge. Absolutely only Ideology but nothing usefull, they often assumingly don' t know that you can spend a coin only, when you have earned one.
6
-
6
-
Chris A: He was interviewed after a leg amputation, so surely not in best health condition. And he spoke in ,Standard German' and in a Propaganda way. In those days Standard German was in daily life not as common as today. The ordinary man on the street spoke his local dialect, Standard German appeared in cinema and radio, and was mostly spoken by upperclass people, educated people/ academics or persons of high rank. There are Videos in you tube, in which you can hear german officers / generals speaking, in Standard German, but as a german it is not to difficult, to hear, who is for example , from the south.
So Mr. Rudel may spoke a bit unusual, because he needed some time, to switch in his brain from dialect to Standard German, a problem i also have, i am one of declining number of dialect speakers.
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
6
-
@JamieW-o7b : l am not Britta herself, but her boyfriend, only using her Computer too. Middle Education, german style trained worker, 59 Years, autistic problem. The answer to this question IS very difficult, and i can be wrong. The decline of Europe started , unwanted and unnoticed , before wwl, when Europe and european culture was on its peak. Nationalism, chauvinism, militarism, also colonialism had reached a until then unknown level, which poisoned the Interactions of nation, and gave first crack to european , culture nation'. The unneccessary wwl caused a Split in Europe. Russia got some territorial losses, and communism destroyed parts of russian tradition and culture. The Main loosers , Germany, Austria and Hungary ( mostly Germany) got political and economic crises, which caused the rise of circles, who obeyed only parts of german culture. But also the winners of wwl had not been realy lucky. On paper they had been strong , rich with greatest Empires, but in reallity the european ones had been outpowered because of wwl too, and became more and more problems, to Control and administrate their colonies. The real Power of european countries declined, while Power and influence of USA and USSR rised more and more. But even in Power decline, the cultures of european nations had been strong and proud. But then came wwll . As a german, i am of course not proud about this, the generation of my grandparents and greatgrandparents was fooled and betrayed by terrible criminals. That IS the tragedy: The man, who promised the german nation , to make german nation and culture great again, started to destroy german and aryan ( european) culture. After wwll most european nations thaugt : Such Things shall never happen, and tried to end nationalism. Even with losses, cultures of european nations had been still intact. But now in western Europe a series of terrible mistakes started. The former colonial powers slowly lost their colonies, and noncolonial countries, for example Sweden , Germany or Switzerland got wealth and needed more workers. The mistake: Instead of inventing automatisation, the westeuropean countries industry called for cheap workers from other countries. So former colonial powers let milions of former colonial people in their countries, other countries other people ( in Germany the Gastarbeiter/ guest workers Had at first been mostly from southern europe, Yugoslavia or Turkey).The mistake was , calling to much persons and to few Care for this persons ( in Germany the factories and politicians thougt, after some years earning money the workers return back). Now the second mistake : Starting in 1960s european universities a leftist movement appeared, becomming over the Years to much importance and influence. This leftist movement claims , european culture is Bad, the current europeans are guilty for centuries of slavery, the europeans should be ashamed about their cultures and History.... This movement successfull destroyed pride of white people of their own culture, they , leftist movement has created more and more ideas to destroy european tradition and culture. Also the churches ( at least in Germany) are now a part of this leftist Network of Universitys, Political Parties, NGOs etc.. They want to flood Europe with foreigners, they help them in everything and successfully scare and frighten , with violence or Moral, all persons , conservative minded. But i think, i tell. you nothing new.
The enemies of european culture are in my oppinion: The mostly unbrave nonleft political parties and politicians/ The leftist Network ( including church in my country)/Islamic radivals.
6
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
@superturkeylegs In Naziera , Westgermany, and since 1990 whole Germany, yes.. But in 1920s not. The Schutzpolizei was basicly this , what in Westgermany and now is called Bereitschaftspolizei. The Bereitschaftspolizei is called, when there are Riots, to seach for missing persons, to search an area next to a crime scene for Investigation ( things the criminal lost etc.) or otherways a large number of policemen is necessary. In Imperial Age such Units didn' t exist. The in Hundertschaften ( equivalent to military companies) organized Schutzpolizei men had a 9mm Luger pistol ( ordinary uniformed street cop a .32 ACP pistol, detectives sometimes only .25 ACP) and a short saber as everyday weaponry, in case of need also 8x57 Gewehr 98, submachineguns, and even handgrenades and a total of 150 Polizeisonderwagen ( armoured cars) with two machine guns.
I am german and read this years ago in an article in Deutsches Waffenjournal, a german arms magazine.
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
Fancy hats? I am german ( Brittas boyfriend). In german, a hat is a Hut. Which Cavallry units carried a hat/ Hut in 1914? US cavallry, in european standards dragoons / Dragoner, british Dominion troops (Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Canada - including Royal Mounted Police, by european standards a kind of Gendarmerie) and perhaps semiregular latin american Cavallry, see revolutionary Mexico. Then there had been caps, in german Mütze ( or dated Kappe). This headgear was common among british , russian, eastern european,french, austrian and italian light cavallry, Hussars and Cossaks. Third headgear in 1914 was the helmet / Helm in german. Sometimes made of leather, reinforced with brass, sometimes made of steel, brass, or Tombak ( don't know english name of this copperbased alloy). Those helmets had been used mostly by heavy, semiheavy or Guard Cavallry of european and latin american countries. Sometimes hats or caps had some reinforcement with cardboard or metal wires ( in german Drähte), but all cavallry headgear of 1914 only gave some protecion against swords or dated pistols/ revolvers with lead only bullets, but not against modern jacketed rifle bullets, similar to last cuirasses.
5
-
5
-
@nedludd7622 : I have nothing against current french people. What i mean, is not Thirty Years War. It was the 1680/ 1690s. In this time french troops burned and robbed lots,oft towns and villages in Palatinate and along Rhine. This, and also napoleonic era is not often shown in movies, so for not so informed persons it seems, german anger came out of nothing. A coworker of my father was as member of , Legion Etrangere/ Foreign Legion' soldier in french Indochina war of 1950s. This man told my father not so honourable incidents, and after his Legion time, this man had seen enough, he didn' t want to also go to Algeria, he leaved Legion. I have read, that a native french soldier, being in Algeria wrote, we didn' t liked german SS, but now it seems, some of us do step in this direction.
I am not wellinformed about french after wwll behaviour, but this is not what i mean. I only meant german/ french problems. As i noted, i have no problems with current french people, and the few trips to France i could do without helmet and rifle.
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
Soap Maker : Königreich- kingdom. Kaiserreich- empire. In case of kingdom: Royal ( in german: königlich, königliiche, königliches, königlicher). In case of empire: Imperal ( in german: kaiserlich,kaiserliche, kaiserliches, kaiserlicher). But after the revolution of 9./10. November 1918 the emperor, the kings, greatdukes,dukes and princes( Fürsten) had to leave their thrones, Germany became a republic, but keeped the name , Deutsches Reich'. When in 1938 Austria was annexed, Hitler changed ( for historic reasons of the 1840s) the name into , Großdeutsches Reich' (1840s: Kleindeutschland , Small Germany, Germany without Austria/ Großdeutschland, Great Germany, Germany with Austria). So when after the last monarch, who was an emperor, the german republic keept the term Reich, Reichs.... must be translated with Imperial, Royal would be totaly wrong, because Germany before 1918 was no kingdom and Hitler no king or , Reichsverweser' like hungarian Admiral Hothy. In german Reich means either kingdom or empire, another translation is not possible.
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
@ExRhodesian : I am Brittas boyfriend, conservative/rural in my late 50s. When i was at school, from 1972 to 1982, Most of teachers had been either centric- conservative, or centric left. Very few of those nowadays typical leftwing teachers. History education started , i was after elementary school for six years at Gymnasium ( but was not sucessfull, to finish), at 7th grade. The first two years we had a strange old teachers for History up to 30years war, the next two years a midaged teacher for History starting with absolutism. But this one talked so much about every toppic, that there was at the end to few time for the worldwars. In Jobschool, i am Metall worker, there was talked more about dangers of Fascism than of Communists, and arround 1990 those Nazi Hysteria we have now , started to the unbeliebable hight of today. My oppinnion: What happened between 1933 and 1945 was a terrible, i don't think that there is a serious German, who is proud about this time. But: Being sad about an era of German History , and don't wanting a Comeback is correct reaction. But: I, born 1965, was not allive before 1945, and my parents born 1938/1942 had been small children. So, being not ivolved into the crimes, because age, means not guilty. This means for me,i have allways to fight a Comeback of Mr. Hitlers ideas. but I don't have to do a bow, when foreigners, minorities etc. start whining. To much of try, to grab Money and privileges, because wwll happened. Such people, and the circles which Support such people and their behaviour, i don't like. And i don't t Like our current politicans: They travel to foreign countries, and want to teach them about morale! They ( the foreign countries) don't t need ,Besserwisserei' of German politicans.
5
-
5
-
5
-
@dwarow2508 : I have to addmit(?)/ muß zugeben, that when i wrote the comment, i was angry, and anger is not a good adviser. But i think you can understand it. You are surely, like the majority of persons all over the world ( including me), a person ,who likes his country. I like my country, Germany, but i am no nationalist, i speak some english and few french. For reasons, i can not explain in few words, i was not so often outside of Germany than many other germans. But i was for short trips in Italy, France, Belgium, Netherlands, England and Hungary. This was intresting and i have no hate against other nations. There is only one thing, i don' t like. There are still lots of movies made , which show us germans as bad people, but movies, in which non german nations show bad things of their history are much rarer, either they are rarely made to hide bad things, or this movies are not shown in Germany. One example: Some time ago, i noticed in Internet a short clip of danish movie/TV series about the german- danish war of 1864. You can find lots of movies with a story plaiing in US civil war 1861-1865, but few about 19th century european wars, so i watched this clip, to see, if the movie is good. After a short time i stopped watching the clip. Why? A small danish patrol on foot was captured by a larger german patrol on horse. For no reason the leader of the german patol, a big , fat , baldheaded man with a partly burned face full of scars, wanted to execute the danish soldiers. I became rather angry, that such an anti- german Propaganda was produced few years ago! Now perhaps you understand my too angry comment, you rightly critisized.
5
-
5
-
@teyrncousland : In HRE the Emperor was elected, but only by nobility and bishops. After the 1340s only seven Kurfürsten / electors could elect the Emperor, after the 1650/1660s nine Kurfürsten. From late 15th century to 1792 the Emperor was allways a member of Habsburg familiy. Today we habe no Mord Kurfürsten, but we have the Bundesversammlung, 1200 persons, mostly members of federal or state parlaments and some celebreties( artists/ sport stars/ scientists) invented by political parities (!) to elect the Head of State/ Bundespräsident. And about two vor three weeks before the Election you know, who becomes the next Bundespräsident. Both HRE emperors elections and Bundespräsident elections are simply unnecessary show events, the german citizens have no influence, who is Head of State. So i , as a nostalgic person, would have no problems with an new emperor, if he is elected by the citizens and only parlametaric system.
5
-
@kovalsky7620 : It happens sometimes in firearms construction, that Something seems new, but then IT IS noticed, that decades ago, an unknown inventer used this , but produced only a handfull prototypes. Years ago i read in a german language weapons Magazine, that workers in a Swiss weapons factory had to remove old stuff from a rarely used room. They found a strange looking pistol, which was the toppic of the article. When in late 1890s Swiss Army tested the available selfloading pistols. an unknown inventer Claus Clausius send a Selfmade pistol to the Test, but was not sucessfull, and the noted workers found his may be only produced pistol. Nerely nothing is known about Mr. Clausius, but His pistol of late 1890s had a Detail, which became important for pistols in 1930s.
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
@garypulliam3740 : After 1934 the number of about 4 million SA men, from which not all had full uniform, declined in few years to about 1 million remaining. The remaining SA had become trainers/ officers for Hitlerjugend ( for the boyscout part as you noted) and perhaps some organisations, who did covered military/ war preparing too. There had been car-, boat- or gliderbased ,sport' organiations who did first steps in technical troops, Airforce and Navy training. As you correct said, they collected money for social things. At at civilian or political events they appeared to give a pompeous or spectecular propaganda show, with marching units, bands, flags etc.. And when necessary, they arrested or frightened those people, which not liked Hitlers ideas. When war broke out, the fightable men had to serve in Wehrmacht etc.. The older, or otherwise not so fightable men, remained in doing the same things as in peace time, but collecting money for example changed in collecting other things, for example collecting hair from ,Angora' rabbits for pilots winter dress. Also the remaining SA men had to support police, firebrigades and Luftschutz ( air raid protection service ?). When the Volkssturm was formed, the relicts of SA men and equipment was integrated. The only organisation which was founded in the thirties, and after some changes, still exists is the ,Technische Nothilfe' , which is today the ,Technisches Hilfswerk' / technical aid service. This organisation consists mosty of blue uniformed volunteers. Usually in peacetime firebrigades and ,Red Cross' help, when there is an accident etc., but in dangerous catastrophies, for example an earthquake or a strong flood firebrigades and ambulance system is too weak. The Technisches Hilfswerk, has trucks, bulldozers, all kind of maschines, tools and equipment to help in such situations, they can repair bridges, electric energy lines, pipelines for water etc., without the nonsense of the Hitler era, this organisation is one of the few good ideas of this time.
5
-
5
-
Norwegians, Swedish, Danish, Icelanders, Faroese- Northern Germanics. Germans( Austrians, Swiss), Dutch, Flemmish, English- Western Germanics. Vandals, Gotha, Burgundians, Langobards- Eastern Germanics ( extinct).
5
-
@AndrewAMartin : Sometimes you notice words, that are not the same, but in context. For example lake is in german ,der See', the sea is ,die See'. And the today rare used ,Lache' is a puddle. ( Lache is today only used in standard german for a puddle of blood after accidents or crimes, in my dialect for all puddles). So both a lake and a Lache ( in my dialect) contain water, only the size is different. Or cave is in german ,Höhle', because the rock is hollow/hohl.
5
-
You have forgotten, that the British troops had been professional soldiers for years in constant training, while the German troops had been conscript/ reserve soldiers, where the last longer training was perhaps some years ago. The british system was only possible, because Great Brittain is an island country. If Brittain would be a continental country, where an enemy, perhaps with allies, could invade with full speed and from many directions, the situation would have been different, because in such a case, a huge number of quickly mobilizeable soldiers is necessary, to train all in a high standard , would habe been impossible.
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
@xxvvkx9312 : Otto Skorzeny was Austrian. In 1918/19 Austrian Gouvernement tried to become again a part of Germany ( after the incidents of 1866), but this was not allowed by Allies, so the ,Anschluß' of 1938 happened. ( In my eyes a great mistake, a peacefull reunition of Germany and Austrian would have been a great ceremony which would have ,sweetened' the defeat for Germans and Austrians) . Skorzeny was not the ,Secret Missions Expert' , but an expert of his own PR. Also german academic fencers of today say, the scars in his face show, that he was a bad fencer ( they say, when properly trained, injuries/ scars are rare). Also in german military history magazines ( i am german), Skorzeny is seen as a ,Showman'. After wwll he mostly lived in Francos fascist spain, but astonishingly he did a mission for israely Mossad (!!!!). Perhaps ,schlechtes Gewissen' ( don' t know english word)?
5
-
@redwaldcuthberting7195 : Standard German: Gabel/Low German: Forke/ english: fork. Standard German: klein/ Low German: lütt/ english: little. Standard German: Seil/ Low German: Reep/english: rope. Low German ( Lowland German) is spoken there , where some Anglosaxons once moved away. For people of southern Germany, I am Swabian, still an english sound. Thirty years ago, I , Brittas boyfriend, Had both an english and a lowgerman coworker ( who usually spoke Standard German). One day the lowgerman coworker spoke in Low German to the englishman. Both He and I Had been surprised, but WE could understand. One sentence I remember was: Und dann bin ik fallen in de kold Water! ( Und dann bin ich ins kalte Wasser gefallen/ And then I was fallen into the cold water). A nongerman coworker, who never Had heared Low German asked: Why do You speak english with Robert, he speaks german well?
So this nongerman worker thougt, Low German is english.
5
-
5
-
Some notes from Germany. I am Brittas boyfriend, only using her Computer, only during hiking tours in Swabian Alb i use a 120 to 130 cm wooden staff. The paths sometimes cross clifflike ground, so a staff is helpfull. Hikers rarely meet criminals, so the staff is only intended to scare dogs away. In 1970s some men in their late 40s or older , still carried a cane when hiking or walking ( doing a Spaziergang), especially when accompanied by their dog. Those men carried their cane not as walking aid, but traditional mens item, when necessary as weapon. An old man told me some years ago, that when his father , a farmer, was young, the cattle market in town of Schorndorf was an important event for local farmers. In those days few persons Had a car, so they walked to Schorndorf, crossing a large Forrest, the Schurwald. A long walk through a lonesome Forrest , with money to buy a cow, goat etc. was risky, so the Farmers walked only in groups of three or more men, everyone with a cane.
5
-
Ich bin Brittas Freund, nutze nur ihren Anschluss mit. Ich bin jetzt 56 Jahre alt und bin der Meinung, seit meiner Kindheit/ Jugend hat sich einiges geändert. Während früher Gewalt aus Weltanschauunngsgründen, kriminellen oder asozial/nichtigen Gründen als schlecht und böse galt, und man wenig Verständnis oder Mitleid mit Verbrechern hatte, ist es heute, nach meiner persönlichen Meinung so, daß man generell für unberechtigte Gewalt zu viel Verständnis hat und es bei der Härte des Vorgehens/ Bestrafung des Täters darauf ankommt , zu welchem Milieu er zählt. Dies halte ich nicht für richtig. denn meiner Meinung nach sind die Opfer eines Verbrechens diejenigen, die oft ein Leben lang leiden, während bei gewalttätigen Personen oft ,polizeibekannt' etc. zu lesen ist.
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
Regis : In the 19th century after the napoleonic era, more and more german people, especially educated ones, wanted that the small german states unite. But there had been two positions. One wing meant, Austria should also be in the new Germany because the german language is spoken, this wing was called ,die Großdeutschen' ( the Great germans). The other wing thougt, Austria should not be a part of the new Germany, because there had been lots of non germans in Austria. This wing was called ,die Kleindeutschen' ( the Small germans). So i think, when in 1938 Austria became a part of Germany again, Hitler simply used a 19th century word.
5
-
5
-
@tanne8436 : Die Leute, die wie ich, Brittas Freund, Arbeiter oder Handwerker sind, sind nach Feierabend müde, und wollen ihren Feierabend, bzw. Freizeit. Auch muß man nach Feierabend noch Einkäufe oder Termine erledigen. Da kann ich irgendwelche , Diplomsozialimwarmenzimmersesselfurzmaulaufreislinkesprücheklopfundausderstaatskasseleb' Typen, die mir meine Freizeit stehlen, schlicht nicht brauchen. Die genannten Gestalten haben doch keine Ahnung mehr , woher das Steuergeld kommt, wer es erarbeitet ( sie selbst meist nicht). Auch bin ich auf dem Land aufgewachsen, mein Vater hat bis 2001 noch eine kleine Nebenerwerbslandwirtschaft betrieben. Ich habe noch den allerletzten Rest der alten, vorindustriellen Landwirtschaft miterlebt, da gab es keine Romantik a la Landlust, und aus den Erzählungen von Eltern und Großeltern habe ich noch eine Ahnung, wie es früher war, daher habe ich gewisse Zweifel, ob es gelingt, Deutschland, das schon in der Kaiserzeit Lebensmittel importieren musste, heute bei deutlich kleinerer Ackerlandfläche biologisch/ ökologisch zu versorgen ( und nach Möglichkeit ohne klimaschädliche Traktoren und Zugtiere).
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
There are two of them in the Oberndorfer Waffenmuseum in a former building of the Mauser company. There are also weapons from Mauser, Feinwerkbau, Heckler und Koch, and Königliche Waffenfabrik Oberndorf ( Royal Arms Factory Oberndorf). There are also other civilian Mauser products, measure control devices or bureau machines. When you are there, visit als the Heimatmuseum ( home region museum), next door, there are some allemannic grave finds (spearheads, seaxes, spathas, shieldbosses). And when you are in this region, the famous arms collection of Sigmaringen castle is not too far.
5
-
5
-
For this reason, in 1930s Germany the experimental cartridge 9x 18 , called 9mm Ultra was developed, but not used. After wwll West German Police forces had been equiped mostly with pistols in 7,65 Browning/.32 Acp. But in late 1960s crime rose/ raised and also communist terrorists appeared. A stronger cartridge was necessary, but especially the more left politicians didn't want , military ' 9mm Parabellum, so for a short time this 9mm Ultra appeared as 9mm Police again in Germany, but not all policemen had been equiped with PP- Super pistol, pistols in 9mm Parabellum replaced 7,65 Browning pistols. Few SIG pistols had been produced in 9mm Police for Swiss police. Also Austrian police, and perhaps also Dutch police tested weapons in this cartridge.
5
-
5
-
@malcolmanon4762 : In the time of Julius Caesar there was a germanic tribe called ,Suevi' , Caesar noted them in his script , The gallic wars'. Some time later the romans build their border fortifications ,Limes', which was an obstacle for the germanic tribes. For this reason, the Suevi', Semnonen and small tribes and clans united to a new tribe called Alemannen, it is unclear if this really means ,alle Mannen' ( oldfashioned for ,all men'), but Allemagne, Alemania etc. still means Germany in french and spanish language. They settled between Vosges Mountains in Alsace to Lech river in today Bavaria , and from Heilbronn Region to St. Gotthard pass in Switzerland. In 496 they lost the battle of Zülpich and became a part of the frankish empire. When in 911 Germany became Germany, the alemanic tribe became Herzogtum Schwaben/ duchy swabia. From 1150-1250 the Dukes of Swabia , the Hohenstaufen dynasty , also had been emperors oft the Holy Roman Empire. After this family died out, the duchy broke into more than 100 pieces and ended. ( Also the Habsburg dynasty and the Hohenzollern dynasty had their roots in swabia) . In the 16- 18 th century there was a Reichskreis/ military district swabia, but without the german parts of Switzerland and Alsace. Today the Swiss germans speak Swissgerman ( the older dialect version), the people between Black Forrest , Lech river, Heilbronn Region and Danube river speak swabian dialect ( the younger dialect version) , and the people of Alsace, Black Forrest, alomg the lake of Konstanz, Allgäu and Vorarlberg in Austra speak a ,between' version of dialect. Because Swiss german and swabian dialect is different to standard german and other german dialects, people with ungentlemanly behaviour make a lot of fun of Swabian or Swiss people.
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
@Sapoman2211 : Especially when nongermans write, the second ,s' is often forgotten, you are not the only person , making this mistake. Volksturm would be ,Tower of the people' , which makes no sense. Usually Volkssturm is translated as ,Peoples Storm' or ,Peoples Assault' and seems to be a pure Propaganda term. But i would translate Volkssturm as ,Peoples Levie", because in 17/18th century Germany ( HRE) Landsturm was used to describe not the professional standing armies of the mostly small german states, but the levie of fightable, but poorly equipped and trained men, only mobilized in emergency. (And in absolutistic age the german princes did not want well armed and trained men , because this men could do a Revolution.)
5
-
5
-
@amandaburnham8626 : In contrast to french, english was for me , Brittas boyfriend, only using her Computer too, not so difficult, because ,everydax words' are similar, also english words for things, existing / invented before 1066. Years ago in local TV in german language an Interview with a then wellknown painter from Alsace was shown. As a man from Alsace he fluently spoke german and french. He told, that in early 1960s, when ,Swinging London ' was wellknown, went to London for artists inspiration, without speaking english. The man said: What is english? A Mix of 1500 Years old german, and 1000 Years old french. So he learned english rather fast, because of his knowledge of german and french.
5
-
5
-
@dolsopolar : Matchlock ( Luntenschloß) is umbrella term, as you correctly described, there are Luntenschnappschloß and Serpentinenschloß, which was usually used. In german collections you sometimes see percussion rifles, with noted oldfashioned stock, and a cook, which turns/beats in , wrong ' direction, this are converted wheellock rifles. And sorry for my writing error. Breastplates, not breastblades. In my german dialect, t k and p are spoken as d g and b.
5
-
5
-
5
-
5
-
4
-
@Stillga : Force would be Kraft ( in scientic sense) or Macht ( might) , an old word , sometimes meaning ,an army' or ,armed forces' , depending on context is Streitmacht/ warmight . Streit is in current german a quarrel, but in old days Streit meant war. A mace is in german a Streitkolben, a warhammer a Streithammer, a war charriot is a Streitwagen ( swedish stridsvagn is a tank). A surprise, was also for me , when i translated Streitmacht into warmight - the unexpected similarity to Wehrmacht. Remember, our languageges are related. Old english Here is german Heer, either army , or , after 1800, ground forces.
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
@crackula7958 : The European people are, witn exeption of Finns, Estonians, Basques , Hungarians, members of indoeurupean family of peoples. This means, parts of indian, afghan, persian and irakian persons also belong to ,white' population. What you describe for your person, has this reason.
4
-
4
-
4
-
@pirig-gal ln Germany we have Pils ( Lager), Pilsener, Export ( Spezial), Hell, Dunkel, Märzen, Kölsch, Alt, Schwarzbier, Bock, Doppelbock, Weizen, Weizenbock, Weizendoppelbock, Gose. In bright, dark, filtrated and unfiltrated. :-)
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
Big Wheel : Sie Volltrottel! At first planes are brain- and soulless machines, so they can not have a political belief. Second, in 1936, fascist Italy, not Germany attacked Ethiopia/Abesynia. In 1936 there had been the ethiopian imperial guard, which was seen as being the best africana led troops, the imperial main army (mahel Safari) and the levies of the princes (Ras) and their vassals. The princes had been vassals of the emperor, the noblemen had been vassals oft the princes, and the ordinary warrior was a vassal of a nobleman. So the ethiopian army had been basicly a medieval feudal army with all the problems, for example loyality, medieval armies had. But third, this doesn't mean, that the ordinary warriors (not the imperial soldiers) had been armed only with spear, leather shield and ,shotel' sword! Even in 1896, when ethiopian troops won the battle of Adowa against (royal) italian troops, only 20% of their troops had no firearms! 20% had muzzleloaders ( mostly flint- and matchlocks) , but 60% had breechloaders of different models. Mostly singleshot, fewer in number repeating rifles, also hunting rifles and shotguns. So in 1936 there had been some poor warriors with spears and muzzleloadets, but the large majority was armed with all Kind of breechloaders. Some of the leviemen had their own weapons in 1936, some got their rifle from their feudal lord, because the emperor, and with bis allowness also the Ras, imported rifles for their vassals. Where i know this from? From two books of the Osprey Military Brooks company.
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
Hema is simply an umbrella term! In old days some of the masters of european martial arts wrote treatisites. Sometimes only about one special weapon, in which they had skill and knowledge, sometimes about a number of weapons, common for the time. This means: In late 15th/ early 16th century a man, who had the money to hire a fencing teacher, should know longsword, dagger and polearms ( long staffs had been training substitute for polearms AND civilian defence). In late 16th century, the dagger lost its importantce and the longsword was replaced by rapier, and polearms, with exeption of pikes also lost importance, so a wealtier man had no more the necessary to train very often with polearms. In late 17 th century the rapier was replaced by smallsword and some wealty men never served as officers., so the fencing trainer had not the neccesarity to train his client with polearms. Those wealtier men, who still served as officers on foot still dif some polearm training, but their spontoons, halberds, partisans etc. had been shorter and weaker than formerly , still useable as weapon, but more a sign oft rank. After napoleonic era, the cane ( and Terzerol/ derringer), perhaps swordcane, replaced the smallsword. So in 19th century most traditional european martial arts dissapeared or became competition sports. Now Hema is a recreation based on old treatisises and relicts of surviving local styles. Because in many european martial arts the tradition line is broken, an interpretation of old texts is necessary, for example because language changed. So, if , for example, the firearms use would not have raised in Europe, we still would have the old martial arts in use, and the same styles myths than in Asien martial arts.
4
-
4
-
According to a german weapons magazine years ago, Mr. Flemming was a man of gentry, but lowest possible rank. He was at q wellknown school or even university, but had no realy göod degree. He had officers training, but after becomming Lieutenant, he ended his service a few months later. He did before 1939 some trips to Germany, Switzerland and perhaps other Continental european countries. According to the magazine , Mr. Flemming was part of british Military Intelligence Service, but more as a Staff member, whos job it was, to visit the conferences, where British Armed Forces, Intelligence Services, Police and for example, British Railway or Postal Service... coordinated their actions. So Mr. Flemming was involved in MI , and knew, how Commandos, Spies , Intelligence/ Secret operations worked/ had been done, but more as a Staff/administration memnber.
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
A small note from a german native : German ch sound is not spoken k! It spoken similar to the noise of an angry cat, but slower and softer. Then Natter is the name of one of the three snakes existing in Germany, the other ones are Kreuzotter and Blindschleiche. One of the three concrete ramps between Jesingen, Nabern and Holzmaden, i once have seen all three, seems still existing, the others have been destroyed during construction of a new railway track.
What you may not knew, the region arround Kirchheim unter Teck was and still is a centre of glider Sport. Next to Teck Castle, at Teck Mountain, there are relicts of a glider hall and a glider lift, which could lift a glider for 70 Meter! Build in 1930s to train glider pilots, which was a preparation for building the Luftwaffe.
And in Kirchheim unter Teck, the glider company Schempp- Hirth still exists, while from Wolf Hirth company only buildings remain.
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
Some months ago a german military history magazine wrote about this topic. It was written two things: At first that german troops misinterpreted well hidden French or belgian regular soldiers for partisans, that especially at night accidently german soldiers fired at each others, and german soldiers had not been trasined in anti- partisan warfare , so they feared them ( partisan warfare is NO german tradition). Second: Belgian authorities often gave order to unregular partisan warfare, there had not enough belgian uniforms for all belgian volunteers, and there had not enough military weapons to equip all belgian volunteers, so that many of them used shotguns, shotguns had been seen as criminals weapons in Germany, even today only few shotguns are used by german army and police, it is not allowed to shoot at persons, only to destroy things.
So, it would have been necessary to also show view of wwl germans about unregular troops.
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
@dwarow2508 : During wwll many crimes happened, which is true. So i have no problem, when german soldiers are shown as bad in context of wwll, especially in movies made a short time after this war. But also german soldiers of wwl are mostly shown bad, for example in ,African Queen', the fictional story plays in Eastern Africa. The wwl had other reasons than wwll (in 19th century in nearly every country a wave of nationalim, chauvinism, militarism and colonalism started, and everyone wanted to be the best). There ars movies of non german countries, which show german soldiers even of 19th century in wwll style. You know the movie Waterloo from 1970? The fact that perhaps 70% of british troops had been belgian, dutch and german soldiers is not so loud told. And without the appearing prussian troops, Wellington could have lose the battle. How are the prussian troops shown? A caricature face shouting: No prisoners and for some seconds you see complete black(!) uniformed soldiers. Such things are not ok. The same with the noted clip of danish 1864 movie. After seing this clip, showing german soldiers as criminals, i doubt that the movie shows the reason for this war, in 1840s royal danish Parlament made a law, to annex the duchy Schleswig, which was like duchy Holstein governed by danish king, but no part of Denmark. Why do the danish make no movie, how the mighty danish kings conquered farmers republic Dithmarschen? Or why are there few to no french movies about the destruction of german border regions during the reign of Louis XIV? For people without historical education it seems, that out of the blue Germany attacked France for no reason. And this behavior is the thing , i don' t like. In other words, i think the non german nations are pointing with the finger to us, and try to hide their own not so good parts of history, they mostly show only the shining side oft their history and this is Propaganda.
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
Filipe Amaral : ln internet i watch also jmantime, military history visualized (not visualized), metatron, scholagladiatora, skallagrim, shadiversity. I read three german military history magazines and two german arms magazines. I have vistited a lot of castles( palaces) and museums with arms collections. And on my holliday trips and hikingtours i visit the relicts of all kind of fortifications, in my home region there sre a lot of medival castle ruins and town walls, some Renaissance fortress ruins, some fortified graveyards, some celtic oppidi ( Heidengraben, Heuneburg and the Ipf) and a few kilometers away are the relicts ot the roman border fortification ,Limes'. So in the last four decades i have got a lot of military history knowledge. I personally prefer the military history before 1900. When you do so in Germany, you have rather few problems, but when you are interessted in military history of the second world war, you are soon in trouble, when you are not very carefull!
4
-
4
-
4
-
@WhiteCheddar. : I am german, from the southwest. In HRE era, my homeregion was the most divided region of Germany. In great age of Hohenstaufen dynasty 1150 to 1250, german Knights culture had its highest point. My homeregion is fillled with hundreds of castle ruins. But few had been large castles of Imperial Crownland (Up to 1253) or mighty families of high Nobility. Most had been small, and very small castles of Knights and socalled Noble Free ( Edelfreie) families. Most had been stone made, but some had been still wood/ earth buildings, or just lightly fortified manour Houses. Those ones, between Neckar River and northern end of Swabian Alb Plateau used small hills and the ditches of very small rivers ( Bäche) as natural fortifications, but at the clifflike northern end of Swabian Alb Plateau many, mostly small ruins are at places on rocks or ,Cliff corners', where an assault was nearly Impossible.
4
-
4
-
No. In my german homeregion such castles are nearly not existing, even the region is full of castle remains. The castles between Neckar river and Swabian Alb plateau have some elements of moat and baily castles, there are no man made moats. The region is full of mostly soft hills large Bäche ( Brooks?), ground Level/ height diffences, some of thause Bäche/ brooks are little ,glenns', so many points with light natural fortifications. The clifflike northern end of Swabian Alb plateau ( Albtrauf) and the valleys ( Täler, see dales) have stone ground, so building a moat and baily castle is difficult, and often not necessary, because Rocks, corners at ,cliffline' exist, where you can reach the Castle only from one or two narrow points.
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
DebatingWombat: Among the calibers/ cartidges i noted for wwll, i made a difference between cartridges which had been common, and such ones, being lesser common. As you clearly recognized, for the lesser common cartridges, ammo supply was more difficult, so this weapons had not been usefull for frontline troops, but for rearline or auxillary troops acceptable. In case of wwl Austria - Hungary you only have forgotten the 11, 5 mm black powder cartridges for M70 and M74 revolvers. In general the older revolvers of black powder era had been in wwl still common for rearline/ police forces. But in case of Switzerland the cartidge 7,5mm Swiss Ordonnance was until 1970s produced with black powder, and in service from 1882 to 1975. Last service Users in 1975 had been elderly Military craftsmen, elderly auxillary policemen and elderly railway guards. Another revolver of those era was in service until 2013, russian railway and postal guards used still Nagant revolvers.
4
-
4
-
4
-
What happened after M71 introduction? Bavaria had Gendarmerie, Border Guards ( Customs Service), Prison Guards and Forresty officials for the rifles. Before 1879 ( introduction of M79 Revolver), there had been in service of german armies ( Yes, armies: First Army- Royal prussian army,incuding troops of grandduchies, duchies, principalities and free cities, second army- royal bavarian army, three corps, third army : royal saxon army, two corps, fourth army: royal Württembergian army , one corps) as Pistols: Bavaria noted Werder pistol, Kingdom Saxony: A Revolver in 10,4 mm looking like an oversized Smith & Wesson Nr 1, navy : Colt and british percussion revolvers, other troops : Smoothbore prussian M52 percussion pistol. So Bavaria had before M79 revolver noticed, we nned more pistols, so some Werder carbines had been converted to pistols. When after wwl Bavaria became a Republik, some of Werder pistols had been still used by bavarian rural policemen. ( Perhaps more modern pistols had been given to army, also in other states some modern police pistols had been given to army, which gave dated M79 and M83 revolvers to police.)
4
-
4
-
@andrewshaw1571 : You have forgotten prussian breech loader field cannons! Also Austria , since 1867 Austria - Hungary had a problem, Prussia had not. Austrian soldiers spoke german, hungarian, czech, slowakian, slovenian, croatian, polish, romanian, bosnian, ruthenian or italian in 1866! In Vienna i, german , and Brittas boyfriend, have visited Military Museum in former Arsenal, there i have seen a book for German officers in Austrian Army. At first the military call was written in german. Then the same call was written in hungarian, czech etc. language. Behind the call, written in a nongerman language, it was written, how a german language officer of austrian army has to speak it. To explain it: If english speaking soldiers would have served in Austrian ( or Austro- Hungarian Army) behind the call : Draw your saber! There would have been written: Droh jor Seiber! And our languges are both germanic laguages, so the problem was not easy. Also in 1866 Prussia did the ( River) Main campaign against prussian allies Bavaria (30000 men) , Württemberg ( 13600 men) , Baden ( 10000 men) and Hessen- Darmstadt ( 6400 men). On paper a force of 60000 men in two of German Confededation Army Corps ( Nr. 7 and Nr.8). But instead of uniting, every southern army tried to defend its country alone. So it was for prussian Mainriver Army rather easy to defeat every southern army in a small fight, we Germans call Gefecht ( not Schlacht/ Battle), but much larger than a skirmish/ Geplänkel. Only much larger Bavarian Army did more than one Gefecht, and outdated Fortess Marienburg ( in Würzburg) was Shot with cannons. And the southern armies , both soldiers and officers, had not the Training quality of prussian troops. For example in Württemberg, where i come from ( nowadays state Baden-Württemberg), there was a serving duty/ Wehrpflicht but similar to Switzerland it was only a rather short Training. And in 1866 the troops of duchies, principalities and free Towns, from 55 men ( Liechtenstein) up to may be 300 men had been only usefull as guards, escorts or Fortress personel.
But in 1866 Austria fought also against prussian Ally Italy, here the Austrians won, most famous Battle of Custozza and ( naval!) Battle of Lissa.
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
@riccardodececco4404 : The system of Reichskreise and Reichsarmee was created by emperor Maximilian l, as far as i know in 1496. Every Reichsstand/ territory with a sest in Reichstag/ parlament ( imperial diet?) had in case of war to sent a contingent of men , the number of foot- and horsemen was regulated. Artillry was owned by Reichskreis , in reality mostly loaned(?)/ gemieted from largest Reichskreis member. The contingent size varied largely. In Reichskreis Schwaben/ Swabia, to which my homeregion belonged, there had been 100(!) small states: About 20- 30 spiritual lords ( princed bishops, princed abbots, one Fürstpropst) , about 30- 40 imperial towns ( from large ones like Ulm and Augsburg to Bopfingen or Zell am Harmersbach) and 40- 50 noble lords ( one Duke, one marquis, some princes and counts of different rank), largest contingent was Württemberg, about 1000 men, smallest ones imperial towns Buchau and Buchhorn ( today Friedrichshafen) with four (!) men each. This hodgepodge was a problem, companies had to be formed from five or six contingents, they rarely trained together on company/ battailon / regiment level, and after reformation half of regiments had been Catholic, other half Lutheran. Swabian Reichskreis allways mobilized correctly , last time in 1790s. But in other Reichskreise, at the end only dominsting member mobilized, the in this case much smaller members paid money to the largest member as support ( Subsidien). This was the case in Bavarian Reichskreis, where only Bavaria and on smaller level Archbishop of Salzburg realy had troops at the later time, or in Electoral Rhinish Reichskreis only Elector of Palatine and, on lower level, Spiritual Elector ( bishop) of Mainz had troops.
In Swabian Reichskreis, where in a ( for US citizens) small area, between rivers Rhine and Lech, Bodensee/lake of Constance and a line from northern end of Black Forrest eastwards, had been 100 states, only the largest (Württemberg) had in peacetime a small army, one of two existing parts of Baden had in mid 18th century in peacetime only about 120 soldiers, or the noted Fürstpropst of Ellwangen had 36 men on foot and twelve on horse, which did police and ceremonial service. In other small states the situation was similar, so that in wartime a large part of Swabian Reichskreis troops had been in reality only militia men , policemen or ceremonial soldiers. The quality of militias was often bad, because in absolutistic era noble and spiritual Lords don' t wanted armed and trained citizens.
Not included in the Reichsarmee and Reichskreis system had been the only in swabian, frankonian and rhinish area existing Imperial Knights/ Reichsritter. They mostly owned only one village. They where, in contrast of ordinary knights no vassal of a Lord, but had no seat in Parlament/Reichstag. There had also been few other imperial territories , imperial villages or Reichstal ( imperial Valley) Oberharmersbach, but i can only asume, their situation was in military case the same than Imperial Knights.
4
-
@jkkennedy9280 : I am german, in the 90s the , Deutsches Waffen Journal', i think i must not translate, wrote a long article about the ,Osteraufstand/ easter uprising ' from 1916. When i remember correctly, from the english conquest of Ireland , which was complete after Cromwells cruel campaign, onwards the catholic part oft the irish population was not allowed to own arms. This situation had not changed in 1913. Note: Colonial tribes loyal to british rule could own percussion muskets, not so loyal tribes flintlock muskets and their traditional weaponry. So the most common weapons of irishmen , which not liked british rule , had been Hurling bats and Shilleilagh walking canes. Also irish sailors bought in harbours outside of Great Britain cheap revolers, mostly belgian or spanish ( basque region) made. In those days most european countries had liberal weapons laws. The money , the irish sailors used to buy revolvers, had been their own saved money for money collected by the ,Irish National Brotherhood'. By the time, this Organisation had a number of stolen or smuggled, mostly civilian firearms. Also irisch soldiers of the irish regiments in wwl smuggled captured german pistols to Ireland. Now to those german M71 blackpowder singleshot breechloaders. Irish persons , members of
4
-
4
-
4
-
@axolotl-guy9801 : In Germany there are still descendants of those frankish tribesmen, which not moved to France/ Frankreich. These are the inhabitants of Hesse, Rhineland- Palatinate, Saarland, the southern part of Northrine- Westphalia and the northern parts of Bavaria and Baden- Württemberg. They speak fränkischen Dialekt. So the german version of Frankish ( the Fränkisch of today) can' t be wrong. And we germans speak names ending with ,rich' , for example Erich, Roderich, with a german ,ch' sound and not as ,k'. The two families ,Merowinger' and ,Karolinger' should not been seen as french or german. They belong to both nations, but not to a single one.
4
-
4
-
4
-
@elcondor7627 : I personally don' t know. Soldiers of German Imperial Forces, Reichswehr or Wehrmacht perhaps had a Nickname. Also among firebrigades in territory of former Westgermany helmets of this Look had been the usual fireman helmet until may ten years ago, but made of Aluminium, may be firemen had a Nickname for this helmet. In after wwll Military of East and West Germany this helmet was Not used, so i think, their perhaps used Nickname possibly had nothing to do with wwl or wwll helmets, i, Brittas boyfriend, have Not served in Westgerman Army , my eyes are Bad, so i can' t say anything.
The only Thing, which comes into my mind in context of German wwl or wwll helmets is, that people meaning the German Steel helmet, they pronounce the ,der' in ,der Stahlhelm ' stronger, sharper than necessary, they want to Show, that they mean the old style German Stahlhelm, and no other one. ( For the reason of four grammar cases in german language dem Stahlhelm, den Stahlhelm or des Stahlhelms would also be possible.)
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
@danielnorman2725 : I am not Britta, but her boyfriend , only using this computer too. I speak german, usually my swabian dialect, Standard German only when realy necessary, i understand enough english to speak of simple everyday things and also few french. My girlfriend speaks a mix of hessian dialect and Standard German, english and french better than i and few Latin. When german dialects are properly spoken, it is often nealy impossible, to understand them as a stranger. So i don' t really understand, why native english speakers so often can not speak a foreign language. English is basicly a mix of 1000 years old french and 1500years old Low german ( from the lowlands). So i assume, you would have no problems with german and french.
4
-
4
-
4
-
The Titanic accident happened in 1912. In those days gunlaw was in european countries much more liberal than now. A serious lawfull man could buy a pistol , but more paperwork, than buying a rifle or shotgun. For carring in some countries a licence was needed also in those days ( in my country Germany called Waffenschein). So i think/. assume, that in addition to the revolvers, belonging to the ships equipment, also some of the ships officers also had their private pistols on board. In case of civilians , open carry of weapons was in 1910s , even USA , Seen as unusual/ strange, but in this days there was annother ,honor' code than now. There had been laws about weapons, but in case of Noblemen or Gentlemen, authorities then often closed both eyes. The german word Kavaliersdelikt is a relict of this era.
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
With exeption of the few owners of a Waffenschein ( german 'CCW licence), german hunters (who are allowed to carry a pistol for Fangschuß/ final shot during hunting), and target shooters using central fire pistols in combat pistol look for competition, H&K has nothing to offer for german civilians, owning an ordinary gun licence ( Waffenbesitzkarte). No hunting guns, no rifles or pistols for traditional german target shooters. But in Oberndorf am Neckar, there is also Feinwerkbau company, which produces only airguns and .22 guns for traditional olympic target shooters. Mauser produces still hunting guns, but no more at Oberndorf, but in a small town Isny , where also Sauer and Blaser hunting guns are produced. In Oberndorf, in socalled Schwedenbau ( Swedisch Building), once owned by Mauser company, there is the Waffenmuseum ( weapons museum). There are weapons, produced by Mauser, H&K, Feinwerkbau and Königlich Württembergische Waffenmanufaktur ( which later became Mauser). For the reason that Mauser collection was in 1945 stolen by US and French troops, the shown Mauser guns are not from former collection and in bad condition. There are also civilian products of Mauser ( socalled bureau machines and measurement instruments, but also a Mauser car). With entry Ticket , you can also visit Heimatmuseum ( homeregion museum with an Intressting collection of allemanic swordblades and spear tips).
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
@LuisAldamiz : I don' t want to say, that all french or italian nobles are of germanic ( not german!) ancestry, but when Roman Empire collapsed, many germanic tribes conquered the territory, and had been the upper class. So it is possible, that the oldest french noblemans families, for example, are the romanized descendants of a frankish clan chief, or other frankish ,Edeling'. Also the ,Rus' ( the Rowers/ die Ruderer) which gave Russia its Name, had been vikings and southern italy was for sometime ruled by Normans (Nordmänner) , romanized vikings. And for a short time also by german Hohenstaufen dynasty ( sidenote: I can see Hohenstaufen mountain from my village).But especially in Italy, especially in and arround Rome, there are surely nobles, who are descendants of roman/ latin upperclass/ nobles without germanic roots.
4
-
4
-
4
-
@gregeoryl : Don' t tell nonsense. In ,Weimar Republik' only paramilitary police ( Schutzpolizei) of the different states had been allowed to own pistols in 9mm Parabellum and MP 18, in a Hundertschaft ( police equivalent to military Kompanie) only one of twenty men had a MP, for other police units or even Reichswehr MP had been forbidden by Versailles treaty! Rural police ( Gendarmerie/ Landjäger) of the states, Town police of larger towns and Kriminalpolizei ( detectives branch) had been armed with pistols in 7,65 Browning/.32 ACP, the detectives or other civilian dressed law enforcement often only 6,35 Browning/.25 ACP . May be rural police had some 8x57 IS rifles to fight poachers, and may be there had been some flare guns. Postal Protektion, railway police , customs service and central Bank / Reichsbank had been payed by German Gouvernement, but as far as i know, also no 9mm Pistole. Prison and Court guards i don' t know, and forrestry officials had rifles and Drillinge, but pistols as service weapons, i don' t know.
For Versailles reason, also the sabers had been regulated ( in late imperial/ early Weimar time not every german policeman / law enforce man had a baton/ truncheon). And Forrest officials had their traditional long ,Hirschfänger' knife.
In addition to regular police, the towns and villages had relicts of , medieval police': Town criers , field guards and sometimes very last nightwatchmen.
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
Cristi_ Energy : I am german, and want to tell you three stories. 1) In the Alsace the people speak french as the offical language, and because it was once a part of germany still now many people can speak also german. Some years ago an alsacian artist/writer spoke about his halfyear living in London. He arrived there with no knowledge of english, but learned it fast. Why? He speaks german, related to old anglosaxon and modern french, related to old french of the normannic conquerors. 2) Some years ago a romanian truck driver arrived at the factory i worked. He could no german, english or russian ( some factory workers could speak russian) so we could only speak with some french and hand signs. 3) When i came to this factory, there was an english coworker. For fun a coworker who could speak lowgerman, which is spoken by the descendants of those anglosaxons who not moved to england, spoke some sentences in low german to the english worker. He looked surprised, but could understand it. A turkish worker heard this and said: Mr. Roberts speaks german, you must not speak english. So the turk thaught, lowgerman is english. Have a good time!
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@johnnyearp52 : In Germany there are some German people, which are whites and ethnic Germans, but have darker skin and hair as usual. The reasons are rather simple. West of Rhine and south of border fortifications ,Limes', similar to Hadrians Wall in Scotland, current Germany ( Austria, Switzerland) was part of Roman Empire, some Romans survived the conquest by germannic tribes. In Middleage some italian Traders, clerics, specialist craftsmen remained in , Germany '. During Thirty Years War many Italians, Spainiards and Croats served as mercennaries in catholic troops, some remained in , Germany '. In Baroque/ Rokoko era many French and Italian artsts and specialist craftsmen came to , Germany '. Those French, Italian, Spanish or Croats of old days are the ancestors of those Germans, whose hair and skin is a bit darker.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
German Person here. Not totally true. After 1919 civilian sport and hunting guns could be still owned. Target rifles in .22 ( socalled Kleinkaliber) or 4mm rimfire ( Zimmerstutzen) and traditional 8,15 x 42 (46?) / Feuerstutzen ( in USA known as Schuetzenrifles) had not been the problem for german citizens. But the Wehrmannbüchse, looking like a military rifle , but singleshot in 8,15 x 42 had been unwanted by allied powers. Hunting shotguns had also no problem like traditional combination guns or nonrepesting hunting rifles. Could be still owned, but more paperwork. Pistols could be produced ( and new bought) when under 8mm caliber. In 1928 there was a restriction, especially for pistols, from now a licence was necessary under all circumstances. For selfdefence a ccw licence/ Waffenschein is necessary since about 1900, the reason why licencefree ( up to 2008) blankguns , firing pepper or teargas became popular. Also up to 1939 cheap percussion derringers had been sold, to wcare away animals from wineyards and fields. After wwll from 1952 to 1971 a denazified version of 1938 gunlaw existed in West Germany. Rimfirerifles (.22 , 6mm, 4mm), Shotguns and Muzzleloaders ( including Percussion revolvers) could be bought without a licence.
3
-
3
-
@DeusMalleus : In early 1890s, the highest real policeman of Prussia, largest state in Imperial Germany 1871 to 1918, hold a speech in prussian Parlament, that prussian policemen, usually armed only with a short saber in ,Briquet' style, more and more have to face pistol armed criminals, so that they often can' t do anything. This speech caused three things: Up to 1912 all policemen had pistols, a ccw- licence ( Waffenschein) was introduced, in 1900 licencefree ( up to 2008) blank/ gas guns appeared.
3
-
3
-
@samsote : I am german, and for about 50 years interessted in military history. I have never heared of a ,nazi uniform'. What is this? There had been uniforms of german military, german police, german railway, german post, technical emergency aid, red cross, fire brigades, customs sevice, organisation todt, transport corps Speer, and uniforms of NSDAP Party organisations, for example SS or SS or HJ. But the Wehrmacht was not a party organisation! This was the official army of Germany. Or is the army of your country part of a political Party?
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@mikelastname1220 : Duchy Swabia ended in 1268, when the last Duke of Swabia , Konradin' ( also last male of Hohenstaufen dynasty) was executed in southern Italy, which for some decades was also ruled by Hohenstaufen dinasty. The Duchy Swabia included german part of Switzerland, Liechtenstein, austrian state Vorarlberg, bavarian district Swabia and middle and southern part of Baden- Württemberg. Currently in german part of Switzerland ,Swiss German' is spoken ( the lowland Swiss are better understandable than highland Swiss), the people in middle and southern part of Württemberg and northern part of bavarian district Swabia speak swabian ( but after belonging 200 years to Bavaria, you hear bavarian influence there. In middle and southern part of Baden, in southern part of bavarian district Swabia, also in Liechtenstein and austrian Vorarlberg, Alemannisch is spoken, it is a mix of Swabian and Swiss German, so easy understandable for both Swabians and Swiss Germans.
3
-
3
-
porus the great : In case of Elsass/Alsace you are complete right, in case of Lothringen/ Lorraine, the Situation is a bit different. When in 1740 emperor Karl Vl died, he had no son, and in Germany, both Empire and monarchial ruled part states, usually only a man could be ruler ( See also in 1839 , when Queen Viktoria of Great Brittain from Hannover dynasty, could rule Great Brittain and colonial empire, but no more german Kingdom Hannover, from where her family came). So the husband of Karl VI daughter Maria Theresia, the Duke of Lothringen, became new emperor, but french king Ludwig / Louis ( XV or XVI ?) could force the Duke of Lothringen to give him his country to be recognized as new emperor. Today Lothringen is nearly totaly french speaking ( according to a former coworker, who had relatives on french side of border), while in rural Elsass most people still speak german , when necessary. Their german has today a slight french sound, but as a swabian i can still understand my alemannic tribal brothers. Once Swabians, Alemannics and Swiss Germans had been the same tribe.
3
-
3
-
3
-
@davidtuttle7556 : I am Brittas boyfriend. I am a traditional ,Southerner' , Swabian , and i don' t like the in my eyes prussian beer type Pils, so i have to admit, that i don' t know the taste both of ordinary Warsteiner and the never heared Warsteiner dunkel. Also Warsteiner is one of the TV beers, beer brands which produce TV spots, the socalled TV beer companies are not liked by every german. Many germans, like try to feel the spirit of german beer the following way. Travel though Germany, for private or professional reason. At every point, you make a stop, ask for beer, brewed no more than 30km/20 miles. So you get totally unknown beer brands, and often a quality surprise.
3
-
3
-
3
-
@ThorstenBecker441 : Ich bin nicht Britta selbst, sondern ihr Freund, benutze nur deren Anschluss mit. Als 1965 geborener, ländlich/ konservativ geprägter Mann lese ich seit 1976 die örtliche Tageszeitung. Seit bald dreißig Jahren fällt mir aber etwas auf, das mir nicht gefällt, wenn es um Ausländer geht. Ausländer hat es in Deutschland schon immer gegeben, allerdings nicht in der Zahl, wie es heute der Fall ist, dies ist nicht grundsätzlich etwas Schlimmes, das es erlaubt, Ausländern böse gesonnen zu sein. Dazu gab es vor der Wende auch keinen Grund, ich kann mich auch nicht erinnern, damals in größerem Maße Personen getroffen zu haben, die Ausländern gegenüber böswillig waren, lediglich gelegentlich Leute, die diese oder jene kleinere Sache kritisierten. Da ich, was ich damals nicht wusste, an Asperger erkrankt bin, bin ich damals nicht ausgegangen, und hatte nur am Arbeitsplatz mit ausländischen Kollegen zu tun ( durch meinen Asperger hatte und habe ich keine Freunde).
Seit Anfang der neunziger Jahre hat sich meine Meinung über Ausländer geändert, ich bin ihnen , wie schon zuvor, nicht grundsätzlich feindselig eingestellt, aber misstrauisch und verärgert geworden. Weshalb? Es hat Anfang der neunziger Jahre mehrere rechtsgerichtete Anschläge gegen Fremde gegeben, daß seither gegen Rechtsradikale vorgegangen wird, ist richtig, aber schon damals fiel mir Folgendes auf: Wenn rechtsradikale Deutsche einen Ausländer angreifen, verletzen oder gar umbringen, wird ein großes Spektakel aufgeführt, wird aber ein Deutscher von Ausländern angegriffen , verletzt oder getötet, geschieht fast nichts. Ich fragte mich vor knapp dreißig Jahren. Das kann doch garnicht sein, daß nur Ausländer von Deutschen geschädigt werden, aber nicht andersherum. Es erregt mein Misstrauen, daß ich nie in Zeitungen erfahre, ob denn mehr Ausländer durch Deutsche oder mehr Deutsche durch Ausländer bei Gewalttaten geschädigt werden. Auch habe ich bei Besuchen in Diskos, Gesprächen mit Besucherinnen etc. Dinge erfahren und gesehen, die immer etwas als Lügen abgetan werden. Es ist nicht immer so, daß Ausländer immer die ,armen Opfer' von rassistischen Türstehern sind, sondern ich habe schon oft auch Beschwerden von Frauen 18 bis Anfang 70 über das aufdringliche Benehmen von Männern aus dem muslimischen Kulturkreis gehört, und selbst gesehen, wie junge Ausländer mit der ,Ich armer Ausländer, du böser Deutscher' Masche versuchten, in eine Disko zu gelangen, bei der niemand mehr eingelassen wurde, auch ich nicht ( in konservativem Stil gekleideter Deutscher). Bei Berichten über angeblichen Rechtsradikalismus, Rassismus etc. muß sorgfältig, nicht einseitig pro- Ausländer berichtet werden. Denn nicht nur ich bin verärgert, wenn alles was Ausländer machen kleingeredet wird, und Deutschen, die etwas am Verhalten von Ausländern kritisieren, über den Mund gefahren wird. Es gibt bei einigen Ausländergruppen Verhaltensweisen, die bei Deutschen Ärger und Ablehnung erzeugen, dies muß man zugeben und Ausländern, und deren Verbandsoberen unter die Nase reiben, sie sollten bestimmtes Verhalten unterlassen. Nötigenfalls auch mit Druck ausüben. Es sorgt , nicht nur bei mir , für arge Verärgerung, wenn man als Deutscher bei berechtigter Kritik an einigen ausländischen Dingen in die rechte Ecke gestellt wird, während man bei Fehlverhalten von Ausländern stets um den heißen Brei herumredet.
Sie verstehen vermutlich, was ich meine. Ich bin nicht grundsätzlich gegen Ausländer, aber daß man zu wenig gegen jene unternimmt, die sich so benehmen, daß sie ihre Landsleute, Glaubensbrüder etc. in Verruf bringen. Diese Leute, und die hier tatenlosen Behörden sind meiner Meinung nach mitschuldig, wenn es Propaganda oderVerbrechen gegen Ausländer gibt.
3
-
3
-
@nutzeeer : Es gibt auch linke Hetze und Gewaltanwendung! Dagegen wird in den letzten vierzig Jahren von linker Seite nichts unternommen, zumindest nicht hier in Deutschland. Ich bin Brittas Freund und zumindest ich mag keine politischen und religiösen Idioten aller Art . Ich vergleiche Politik immer mit dem Auto fahren. Wenn ich mein Ziel erreichen will, muß ich das Lenkrad mal nach links, mal nach rechts drehen um dem Straßenverlauf zu folgen und Hindernissen auszuweichen. Drehe ich das Lenkrad nur nach rechts oder links, so Lande ich im Graben oder fahre im Kreis. Aus diesem Grund ist mir der heutige ,Nur links nur links' Zeitgeist suspekt. Die Zeitungen etc. als Lügenpresse zu bezeichnen, würde mir nicht einfallen, aber wenn, je nach Angabe, 60-80% der deutschen Journalisten links stehen, so kann man von einer nicht neutralen, sondern linkslastigen Berichterstattung ausgehen. Was nun diese Verschwörungstheorien angeht, so halte ich das Meiste für Übertreibungen und aufgebauschtes Zeug, das entsteht, weil es derzeit viele Dinge gibt, die man nicht richtig einschätzen kann.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
Leopard 2A7V : Not totaly right. Gewehr is used today for every long firearm, this means rifle (Büchse), shotgun (Flinte) and combined gun ( Büchsflinte, Drilling Vierling). In the years before 1914 Gewehr was used in military context for the infantry battle rifle, which was long to become a polearm for bayonnet fencing or to fight against mounted enemies. The Karabiner, used by cavalry and some non frontline units, is in fact a short Gewehr. The Stutzen is also a word for a shorter Gewehr, but usually used for hunting rifles (not shotguns). Do not confuse Stutzen with Stutzer, thats the swiss word for a competition/sport target rifle. And up to 18th century Gewehr could also simply mean ,weapon', why the bayonnet is also called Seitengewehr. Ge- means in german language simply ,a lot of'. (Gewässer- a lot of water, Gesang- a lot of singing, Geschrei- a lot of shouting, etc..). And of course i know, that , i have taken owls to Athens'!
3
-
3
-
3
-
@gorgonzola86 : A german speaking person of this time, don' t knowing what SS is? Being german, may be the engraver accidently used his dialect. In german language we have three genders ( male/female/ neutral) which was regulated to Standard German in 1873. But: Even today ,especially in rural settlements, people speak in their local dialects. Now in some dialects some words have a different gender than in Standard German. For example Standard German: Die Schokolade ( chocolate), der Teller (plate) die Butter is in swabian dialect der Schoklad, das Teller, der Butter. So in Standard German the words ,des SS' must be , der SS'. SS means Schutzstaffel ( Protecion Squad), a compound word consisting of der Schutz and die Staffel. For german grammar ( four grammatical cases) der Schutz would become des Schutzes, and die Staffel would become der Staffel. In german compound words the words like der , die das....change depending on important part of of compound word, the lasr one.
So i see this pistol as dubios, can be simply an error of engraver ( but as former quality control man, Britta is my girlfriend, i can' t believe that in those days a pistol with wrong engraved words would have passed quality control for a present gun), so a fake by a non german speaker is plausible.
3
-
3
-
@pedrotome9119 : When you are able to speak english, then you know some german words: Gold, Ring, Hammer, Hand, Finger,Wind are the same in german and english, and when you know, how to speak beer and wine, then you know exactly how to speak Bier and Wein. Both german and english are westgermannic languages, so many words of germannic part of english language are rather similar to german or in context related. Forgotten Weapons is about firearms, but also edged weapons exist. Sword/ Schwert, shield/ Schild, helmet/ Helm, axe/ Axt, spear/ Speer. Tools: saw/ Säge, spade/ Spaten, showel/Schaufel. Coach, waggon/ Kutsche, Wagen, boat/ Boot, ship/ Schiff. Bear/ Bär, fish/ Fisch, cow/ Kuh, bull/ Bulle, calf/ Kalb, weazle/ Wiesel. Words in context: Cave/ Höhle, hollow/hohl, hole// Loch- a Höhle is a hole in a rock. Lake/der See, puddle/ Pfütze or Lache- both a lake and a Lache are waterfilled. Meat/ Fleisch, but flesh is human meat and Mett is fine minced raw meat. Try to learn german, If you want, you can be successfull!
3
-
@makipri : English is not my native language, when you write in german, you surely have problems to find correct words. A few weeks ago i was in medical Recovery (?) in a hospital. There i spoke with a woman, who is ,male' part of a lesbian couple. She said to me, she simply wants a quiet , normal life ( what i believe), but this Queer Modernlings provokant behaviour is not her thing, because provocant, or even aggressive behaviour causes, that other persons also become aggressive, which nobody realy wants. This is my point.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@DandyLion2024 : It is realy unbelieveable, what nonsens some people write. When somebody speaking about history and confuses (?) two Kings with the same name (for example last Prussian King Wilhelm ll, last Württembergian King also Wilhelm ll), this is no Problem, the problem is caused by often ideologic idiots. The Vikings are only this group of germannic people, which had been those, who practiced germannic religion and Lifestyle longer than other germannics.
A note about the asianlooking germannics. In contrast to north and westgermannics, the eastgermannics no more exist, and very last speakers of their language died on 18th century Crimea. It was long forgotten, that a part of the Goths once settled on Crimea. So an english monk who traveled there ( for to me unknown reason) was in early 16th century surprised: I traveled through a few villages, where the people spoke German. The last report about ,german' speaking people on Crimea was in 1780s from a russian Bishop .He wrote : It seems that the Crimea Tartars now only speak in their own language. Many years ago, some people, who traveled there, told me, they have seen Tartars speaking with many german words mixed in.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@nedludd7622 : In 17th century the ,thirty years war' killed about 30% of my nation, in my region perhaps 60- 70%. I noted the wars of Louis XIV only, because they are often unknown outside of Germany. This and events in napoleonic era ,caused in nationalistic 19th century a lot of antifrench Propaganda, only this is my point. What Napoleon wanted for german nation? A lot of vassal states, which had to pay money and field troops for Napoleons dreams. The long wartime cost ( not only in Germany) a lot of tax, to field and equip the,lots of soldiers, Napoleon always wanted ( or needed), for Napoleons unnecessary Russia campaign Baden and Württemberg, i come from german state Baden- Württemberg, had to field 20000 to 22000 men- 700 came back. The napoleonic age was not so liked by german ordinary people. And , many intellectual persons started with Propaganda, for example, how was it possible, that German nation, about 30 millions, could be conquered by France, with about 20 millions. When someone of a foreign nation claims, he wants to do something good for another nation, thats in my eyes doubtfull.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@frankberry6220 : I am no member of a target shooters club ( Schützenverein), hunter or collector, but the situation here in Germany is similar. In Austria and german part of Switzerland we have the german language, nearly same culture, democracy in federal country, industrialised countries. But different gun laws. German law is restrictive, austrian law is ( even after restrictions caused of EU) more liberal, swiss law ( after invention and diplomatic force by EU) still most liberal law. Crime: In Germany higher than Austria or Switzerland ( which are also no more as safe than this countries had been). In case of liberty in gunlaw, we germans strangely had this in Imperial Germany, but not in democracy . Our current Federal President ( head of state) Steinmeier spoke some years ago: We have currently best Germany of all our History! ( ???)
You are correct, in both our countries law makes life unhappy for lawfull citizens, who own weapons, but crime is rising.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@meenki347 : Strangely some very old people in my region use the word Schindmähre for a not wellliked older woman. I explained that Mähre means an old or bad quality horse. A Schinder was once a person, whos job it was, to take away dead annimals from the houses and settlements. The meat could not been eaten, but the Schinder cut away the skin for producing leather, bones or Horns could be used for different purposes, and the man cooked the uneatable meat, to get fat for technical or chemical use, for example smearing wagon axles (?). So a Schindmähre IS a nearly dead horse, only usefull for a Schinder. For an elderly lady, who overestimates her importance , influence and stylishness in my younger years also , frigatte under füll sail' ( aufgetakelte Fregatte) was used.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@tinman9738 : On occassion, former officers of imperial army or the former Kings, Greatdukes, Dukes and Princes ( both Fürsten or Prinzen) wore their old uniforms. Also in 1918 ( and after the new republican constitution also on paper ended nobility privileges in 1919) all noblemen, including the former ruling houses, could keep their private lands, only the stateowned lands they had to give new gouvernement. So Wilhelm, even living in the Netherlands had still lots of farmland, meadows and forrests, he was still a very rich man. He allways hoped for a Comeback as emperor, so he still had a small ,operetta' court, with some few men, keeping former important court titles.
3
-
3
-
@duicic8541 : I don' t know situation in 1980, but as far as i know, in 7,65 Browning era the PP/ PPK had been made by Manurhin, so allowed ,french " pistols. As far as i know Bereitschaftspolizei formerly had also assault rifles, ( few) machineguns and ( few) handgrenades, but a non military force, in wartime they could only fight in wartime against ,unknown' Banden ( gangs?). I can be wrong, perhaps i don' t remember correct.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@gibraltersteamboatco888 : In case of colonial cruelty, Belgians should be quiet, see belgian king Leopold and his Kongo colony. Also the French should be quiet, in case of fighting partisans: Napoleons troops in Spain, and in Germany the tyrolian rebellion of Andreas Hofer and Major von Schill in northern Germany, also the burning down of german settlements in Palatine and along the Rhine by Louis XIV troops is a thing, which not appears in movies. With exeption of noted Hofer and von Schill, i don' t know partisan warfare in Germany. When in 1813 the Landwehr units had been formed, there was also planed, to form Landsturm formations, to fight french troops in partisan manner in civilian dress, but prussian king didn' t allow this.
3
-
@gibraltersteamboatco888 : There had been crimes, done by german soldiers in wwl Belgium, this is true. I only noted, that in the history magazine was written, what had been the reason. I wrote of german and belgian mistakes also. And one reason was, that this partisan thing was mostly unknown to german soldiers, but officers or other persons told them wrong (?) stories about the danger of irregular troops. Also i allways have doubts, when i hear fairytale stories oft angellike heroic partisans. They also did cruel things, which had been not heroic, but nearly nobody asks about. That is my point. Now, when i spoke oft French fight against spanish or tyrolian rebels. The French had invaded foreign soil, and fought, especially in Spain rather cruel against people in their own country, also in 1950s/ 60s Indochina or Algera. Now please tell me, why french call german invaders cruel, when did similar things, when they invaded other countries? Isn' t this a double standard? That' s the second point. And: I mistrust people, who say: It is allways the others fault, this is simply impossible, that it is allways the others fault.
3
-
@stephenremington8448 : In my german region, there are descendants of people living there for centuries, and germans of other regions/ tribes, who moved to my region for good ecomony reason. When you come in my region into a village, among the persons of first group, allways some family names appear more often than others, in my village this are the names Eppinger, Deuschle and Bosch. Formerly it sometimes caused confusion, when there had been for example three Friedrich Eppinger, about whom is spoken? So the people formerly, and some old people do still so, used a ,housename' for the different families. So this people still call one family with name Eppinger ,Hauptmanns' ( Captains), but their ancestor, who was once a Hauptmann, was not an Army Captain, but first Firebrigade Captain ( nowadays Kommandant) of the village.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
I am a german man, only using my girlfriend's account. Mr. Guderian was not the inventor of the german tank tactics. He was only this one, who took together existing ideas to a useable and , for some time, succesfull way of fighting. There had also been a number of other german officers from different branches of the Reichswehr, and later Wehrmacht, who also had ideas of motoriced warfare. These other officers supported Guderian with ideas and influence of their high ranks. Also, what is described in other comments, he (Guderian) was influenced from foreign, mostly british ideas. At the end one point about the german Blitzkrieg concept. This was not a mysterious, secret wonderconcept, it was, very simplified, the old prussian ,Kampf der verbundenen Waffen' extended with planes and tanks. One last word: The Tankgewehr is in my eyes only a newmade wallgun.
3
-
@_levi07 : German word is Pfalzgraf, there had been in early years of HRE many ( for example the Pfalzgrafen of Tübingen), but as longer as Middle Ages lasted, nearly all dynasties ended, and their territories came under rule of other Houses. Now, what was a Pfalz? From start of HRE until the end, there was no official capital! So medieval german emperors and kings travelled through the Empire, with a large Gefolge ( don't know english word), snd at places, where the Emperor and his Gefolge did a longer stop, local nobles, officials, clerics, judges etc. came to speak with the Emperor ( and officials travelling with him) and all kind of things had been done , nowadays being done in capital. Those Pfalzen had been mostly only lightly fortified groups of houses on crown land. In those houses , surrouded by the fortifications, food, firewood, eqipment etc. produced on crownland was stored. The Emperor and his Gefolge travelled from one Pfalz to the next, there they could resupply and doing some necessary repairs and spend a few days of recovery (?) / Erholung. In socalled Interregnum, ehen between 1254 and 1274 HRE had no real Emperor, most nobles and knights ( up to 1496 no part of german nobility) grabbed the part of crownland they had to administrate , as their own territory, but this is annother long (!) story.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
For most time of History, german language was not regulatet, the people spoke and wrote in their local dialects, which often caused confusion in trade, science or diplomacy. Still today, when speaking in still existing dialects, we have problems to understand each other. So in 1873 german language was standardized/ regulated by german, austrian and swiss scientists into Standard German. This is the reason, why the allways only t spoken th disappeared in usual german language and remained only in names or words , orginating from other languages , for example Theater. But a german saying: There is no rule without an exeption! Thron ( throne) kept its th ( according to legend, by demand of Wilhelm ll).
3
-
Ianweir: True, but after three bottles of strongest type of german national drink, a correct answer is difficult. In german tradition, before 843 , Treaty of Verdun, where Frankish Empire was cut into three pieces, any use of german meaning deutsch is completly wrong. East Frankish Empire is seen as first forerunner of Germany. Last carolingian king of East Frankish Empire ( Ludwig das Kind) died in 911. Some historians say, now elected king Konrad l was first deutscher ( german) king, elected, because East Frankish ( deutsche/ german) noblemen noticed, West Frankish ( french) noblemen no more spoke germannic. But Konrad l was of Frankish tribe, so some german historians think, Heinrich l of saxon tribe, elected in 919 is first german/ deutscher King. But , when in 1806 HRE ended, few German people had been sad, since 13th century, especially after Interregnum ( Emperorless time) 1254- 1274 HRE was so divided, that national spirit disdappeared, especially after 1648, end of Thirty Years War. In last years of HRE only Imperial Towns/ Reichsstädte and Catholic Spiritual Lords , lmperial Knights and obscure semiindependant territories respected orders of HRE Emperors. In 1806 Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, german counterpart to Shakespeare, and minister of small state Sachsen - Weimar - Eisenach noted: End of HRE was no problem for me, but my old mother, still alive in Imperial Town Frankfurt send me a shocked letter: HRE has ended! Who will pray now for future of Emperor and Empire?
3
-
3
-
@dflatt1783 : There was a naval blockade against Germany from the Britisch Channel to the coast of Norway, so Germany could not import food. On paper Germany could import food from neutral countries Switzerland, Denmark, Norway or Sweden. But: Because of the war of 1864 Denmark was Allied friendly. Up to 1903 the king of Sweden was also king of Norway, a socalled ,personal union'. But from 1903 to 1906 the Norwegians tried to get an own king and had sucess. In this non violent fight for total independence from Sweden, France and Great Brittain supported Norway, Germany supported Sweden. So Norway was Allied friendly, Sweden Germany friendly ( When WW l started, a large number of swedish officers wanted, that Sweden enters the war on german side to reconquer the in 1809 lost Finnland, but the swedish King and Gouvernement had been more intelligent than the officers). Switzerland had a food problem in both world wäre, they could not sell food to Germany. In policy the swiss gouvernement had agreements with France and Germany: In case of a german attack the swiss army would follow the French High Command, in case of an allied attack the swiss troops would follow the German High Command. So there was a great food problem in Germany , the people had not enough food and lots of germans died. The people had to eat ,Steckrüben' , i don' t know the english name of this plant. It has rather few calories and is today sold as ,weight losing diet food'. In one of the german language military history magazines i read, the toppic ,Steckrüben' was also noted.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@mrnygren2 : Was a different thing, than you expect. In late 1918 there was a ,revolution' in Germany, and after more than 1100 years, monarchy ended. In 1919 Versailles treaty came. A british army officer, who was periphery involved in this treaty wrote: I doubt, if this treaty gives a long peace. Germany and its citizens was taken away any kind of honour, they lost much. I fear, if any obscure ,halfgod' will come, and promise german nation, i will give you back honour and pride, the Germans will follow him with all their discipline and knowledge. This officer was wiser than most people of allied nations. For majority of german people, 1920s, democracy or not, had been a terrible time. In 1923 Inflation destroyed all saved money of lower class, the people had been very poor ( my grandmother, 1910 - 1995) often told me the poorness she had from 1910s to about 1960) , there had been up to 1923 uprisings of Communists and Nazis. Democracy, Democracy, Democracy, but a mix of poorness and uprisings, we germans never had in such a way during monarchy. So in 1945 a lot of western allies feared: In 1919 we destroyed the lifestyle , the germans had for over 1000 years, and Hitler was the result. What happens, when we destroy 2000 years of japanese lifestyle and japanese economy fails?
3
-
3
-
3
-
@DirtyDiksgunoroma : Well i am german. No gunowner or collector, but intressted in history of weapons in general. In german language arms magazines, we have three german ones and a swiss one ( which is now only a shadow of former days), sometimes rare weapons of german language countries appear. A few months ago a revolver of Austria - Hungary was noted, which was introduced in early 20th century for Austro- Hungarian for some Police, Prison and Financial officers in limited numbers, for an unusual 9mm cartidge. After wwl no more production of the weapon, but even in 1950s some of this revolvers had been still in service, very last ones had been in inventory in 1960s, Austrian Gouvernement somehow was able, to have ammunition even in 1960s.
3
-
3
-
@charliewenthe4411 : I am german, and i think, i know , what i write. Fritz is short of Friedrich, Heinz is a short of Heinrich, Ulrich is a short of Huldrich, Klaus/ Klaas is a short of Nikolaus, Willi/ Wilhelm, Bernd/ Bernhard, Siggi/ Siegfried, Siegbert, Sieghard, Sigurd, Ekki, Ecki/ Eggebrecht, Eckbert, Eckhard, Ekkehard. So Nazi was simply a short of Ignaz. In wwl Nazi was simply a nickname for austrian soldiers. Note: During wwl the NSDAP did not exist! So in 1920s the use of Nazi changed from , Austrian Soldier' to member of NSDAP.
And Ignaz Eisele, an austrian bandleader, was known as Nazi Eisele only for reason of his name.
3
-
@Aquilius_Caesar : In current german a fortress is a military fortification only ( may be some pompeous rooms, if the monarch flees to this fortress. A Schloß/ Palast is an usually unfortified building, for representation an luxury live. A Burg is a medieval fortified building, which was both military foetification and representstive residence. Well, in Renaissance era, many medieval castles / Burgen had been transformed into a fortress or a Schloss/ Palast ( depending on wealth of owner), in my region most of castles, destroyed in farmers rebellion of 1525, had not been transformed, are still ruins, and remaining noblemen build New, but smaller Schlösser or Herrenhäuser, without fortifications.
In case of Hohenwerfen, i thought it was one of the few fortresses of Fürstbischof von Salzburg, so a small garrison in HRE era.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
Ian Macfarlane : Mauser ( the au is spoken more like ow in Owen than ou in mouse) means in Englisch simply mouser. I come from Württemberg , nowadays a part of the german state Baden - Württemberg. My father, born 1938, told me, that when he was a child, there was a man called ,der Mauser' , his , not fulltime, job was to hunt a special type of mice ( Wühlmäuse) with traps, and to give other persons advice, how to do so.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
Being german a note: In ,Kennblätter für fremdes Gerät' ( description sheets for foreign equipment) captured equipment got a german designarion, for example Colt 1911 became Pistole Colt (a) Kaliber 11,5 mm Colt , the a means amerikanisch. When german troops captured french arsenals , these contained also Gras M74, converted to 8m Lebel. Those rifles had been used in wwl by french troops for use in Hinterland, far away from frontline by transport troops. Those converted Gras rifles had been given in wwll to french Gardes Champetres ( field guards) by german occupation troops. How could german forces know about Owen guns? Believe it or not, Germany had intelligence services, and Japan was a german allie. Also ot is possible, that german soldiers/ sailors captured in northern Africa or on sunk Allied ships newspapers etc., showing photos with Owen submachine guns.
Btw., use a map of german state Baden - Württemberg. Look for the town Kirchheim unter Teck ( see Mary von Teck, grandmother of Elizabeth ll) and look in the south of this town for the name of a small town, you will be surprised:-))
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
I don't know from which country you are. But i as a german use a language, which has four grammar cases. An old joke(!!!)for this grammar cases is Werwolf: Der Werwolf, den Wenwolf, dem Wemwolf, des Wesswolfes . For obvious reasons, no problem for me, but for foreigners. Especially non european foreigners try to simplify german language by using NOT the german grammar cases ( or wrong) ,but to tell what they want to say in simple words/ sentences, so that the context explains the thing, what they mean. I hope, you understand my words, surely in old days ,non latin' speakers also tried to simplfy Latin.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@DarkKnight-yz2wg : As far as i know, Ethiopia is the oldest christian country. The people, which have brought christianity to Ethiopia, came directly from current Israel, or at least from this area, so this rather first christians had been jewish influenced. Germany was, perhaps curious for you, christianized mostly by irish monks. In Ireland the cross was a holy symbol in celtic time, and also some parts of celtic religion made it easier to christianize the celtics, than germanics. I can understand why Hitler was succesfull in the age of my grandfather/ grandmothers time, but he was really not good for my country, but what happened, happened. Hitler a Jew? I doubt . The name Hitler ( Hüttler/ Hüttner/...) simply means in english , a poor man who lives in a hut/ cabin ( Hütte means hut/ cabin). In austrian/ bavarian region ( i am member of swabian tribe), the common name ,Hofer' means ,owner of a large farm', Huber means. owner of a small farm, so a ,Hitler' had no farm, only his hut/ cabin, while a ,Hauser' had a house and at least a garden.
For jewish people it was until age of Napoleon not allowed to own farmland, or to do usuall jobs in Germany. Also you often recognize them at a german, but unusual name which starts with a colour ( mostly Grün/ green), Gold or Silber ( gold / silver) , the name of a flower, and ends with berg ( mountain) , tal ( valley) vor stein ( stone). And Hitlers name doesn' t sound jewish.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
Also in german language dialects ( unstandardized german) exist, but they are slowly diying, most children speak Standard German today. I, Brittas boyfriend, born in 1965, still speak in swabian dialect, but you hear it rarer and rarer, even in smaller towns. When i at the age of eleven started to learn english, i was surprised , when i heared the word ,barn', in my local dialect a Barn is the upper part of the building , while english speakers mean the whole building. Also in Standard German umrühren means stirr, and in my dialect ( only in one context) stieren can mean to stirr.
For being related languages ( also german and english dialects), it is now for me no more a surprise, finding related words : hole/Höhle ( cave) or lake/Lache (puddle).
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
The vault Tech: Luxemburg was from middle age to 1866 a part of Germany. In 14th century the original Luxemburg dynasty had been also for some time Kings of Bohemia and Emperors of HRE, this means they had been, long ago, important. Later the capital ( also named Luxemburg) was a strong fortress , which was important. After 1815 , until 1832, the Dutch King was also Great Duke of Luxemburg. And the town was a German Federation Fortress of second class, during the time of the German Federation the Luxemburgian contingent of the German Federation Army served as fortress troops for Luxemburg fortress ( together with 2000 prussian soldiers). After the Innergerman war of 1866 Luxemburg ( together with Austria and Liechtenstein) leafed Germany, and became independent and neutral. They destroyed ( schleiften) the fortress, that Luxemburg was no more interessting for France under Napoleon lll, and Prussia gave up the right, to have 2000 soldiers in Luxemburg. I hope, this not so necessary knowledge helps.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
Most of the Conqistadores had not been knights or real noblemen. Perhaps some of the leaders had been members of the highest class of nonnobles, we Germans call , Patrizier'. But after the conquest, some of the spainiards became knighted. But in case of Inka empire, some village/town chiefs keept in place/ in work / in office and became members of ,colonial spanish' nobility. In the ,Lindenmuseum' in Stuttgart there had been large exhibition events both about Inkas and Atztecs. In the Inka exhibiton, some paintings had been shown, with ,knighted' Inka chiefs, wearing spanish cloth of the time, but an Inka cap instead of european hat vor berret. To the weapony, it was basicly the usual european equipment. But i don't think, that the men at arms on horse had really full suit of plate armour. Also the number of siege artillery pieces was surely small. As far as i know, in Cortez' first campaign, most of his footmen had not the european footmans armour, but only helmet and shields as protection. In those days , first half of 16th century, the medieval swords had been in southern europe earlier replaced by rapier than in northern europe. For having no own armor, many spainiards took atztec padded cotton(?) Jacketts, similar to european gambeston. As far as i know, i am no expert, the Atztec warriors knowing only cutfencing , had problems with quick spanish rapier thrust fencing, and against the pointy rapier blades the padded jacketts had not been best protection.
3
-
3
-
@TacgnolSimulacrum : To some degree you are right . In case of 8 (7, 92 ) x 33 reloading empty brass, or using obscure surplus is possible. Also a jugoslavian /serbian company Prvi Partizan has assumingly produced this cartridge after wwll, also it is possible to transform 8x 57 IS Brass, in german language culture circle still popular among hunters , is possible. I, german, Brittas boyfriend, am no weapons expert, but somewhere i read, that in Germany, either in Saxony or Thuringia, there is one day every year a , Dreyse Rifle Meeting' . The paper cartridges are handmade by members of Target Shooters Club. Also years ago, i read in a german language arms magazine, an article about an african craftsman, who has a licence for producing muzzleloaders. He spoke about Kunstdünger/ chemical fertilizers (?) and oil as substitute for Black Powder. Also, here in Germany still today, blanks in 6 mm Flobert, 9 mm R, and 9 mm PAK are licencefree to buy.
3
-
Büchse can mean three things in german language.1) A tin can, the other word is Dose. 2) Rifle. 3) Unofficial (!!!!) : The part of a womans body which is at the frontside between belly and legs. Flinte is a shotgun. Büchsflinte, Drilling (tripplet) and Vierling (quatrupplet) are hunting weapons with rifled AND smoothbore barrels. Gewehr (nowadays) : a fire arm which is not a pistol and can be carried by a single man (including some wallguns, puntguns, antimaterial rifles if they are not cannons). Gewehr (very oldfashioned): all kind of weapons. In some 18. century texts you can read of ,Obergewehr' / upper Gewehr for weapons carried on the shoulder ( polearms/muskets) and ,Untergewehr' for weapons carried at the belt (sabers and hangers). Ge... simply means ,a lot of', Gesang - a lot of singing or Geschrei- a lot of shouting. Here in Germany weapons are seen mostly as a bad thing, and most of the do not know the difference between knife and dagger, saber and sword, rifle and shotgun or pistol and revolver and use the words rather wrong. I am a man, only using my girlfriends account.
3
-
@JKNat9004 : Sau/sow, Hahn (Gockel)/ cock, Ziege ( Gais)/goat, Kalb/calf, Pferd ( Ross)/ horse, Bulle/ bull, Stier/steer, Hund (Dogge)/ dog (hound), Aal/awl, Bär/ bear, Maus/ Mouse....
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
I am german, and not Britta herself , but her boyfriend. I like museums, and also castles/palaces , because i am interessted in history. Weapon based museums exist in Germany, but for reasons of german history of 20th century , not much, for example the Wehrgeschichtliches Museum/ museum of military history in Rastatt or the Waffenmuseum/ weapons museum in Oberndorf am Neckar ( weapons and other products of Mauser, Heckler & Koch and Feinwerkbau). In both museums there is no guide ( in german ,Führer' ;-)), the ladies at the entrance don't know anything about weapons . The director oft the museum in Rastatt knows much, i saw him as guide of a historic tour to the battlefield , Hartmannsweiler Kopf'. In Vienna i visited the Military Museum in former Arsenal, a staff member, seeming soldiers, talked long with me, but in Hofrüstkammer in former imperial Hofburg, the staff persons had been unfriendly. Then you can find in Germany Museums/ palaces with large arms collections. For example the Reichsstadtmuseum in Rothenburg ob der Tauber ( no guide), Sigmaringen palace ( the guided tour does not include the famous weapons collection. During my last visit in the weapons collection room i was mistaken for a guide, when i spoke to some visitors, they thanked me for answering their questions) . Also visit Baldern castle, the weapons collection is the former armoury of a typical HRE small state, Düring my last guided tour, the female guide told mostly nonsens about weapons. Then there are a lot of Homeregion Museums/ Heimatmuseen or palaces with small colections of weapons. For example rusty relicts of germanic warriors graves, from 1848 revolution attempt or some smallswords of the palace owners ancestors. But either there are no guides, or they know nothing, it happened, that i gave answers to questions about weapons. Here it often happens, that the weapons ( Bad , Bad things!!!) disappear, when you visit the museum/ palace the next time. One day i was nearly thrown out of a civilian Museum, when the guide claimed , a noodle cutter is a tobacco cutter.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
A note out of context: At start of Video a man was noted, who was a motorcycle inerested person. Due to , Administration Reform ' in german state Baden-Württemberg, the Gemeinde ( Village) Fachsenfeld became a district of the town Aalen. ( May be the town has its name because in time of Roman Empire a cavallryunit ,Ala' was there.) . Inside the village there is a small , Schloß ', in this case ,Palace'. The last noble owner , a Freiherr von König - Fachsenfeld died in 1994, being not married and no children. This last nobleman of his family was a rather excentric , rural nobleman '.. In his younger Years he wanted to become a famous motorcycle race driver, but after an accident He switched to a theorethic. How to drive faster with a vehicle which has a weak engine? So in the cellar of his small palace he did aerodynamical experiments and wrote a book. In 1933 to 1945 He didn't support Hitler and refused to work for aircraft companies. After WW ll, he was involed in supporting Refugees from areas , Germany lost, and he supported local school and Kindergarten, when Money and Support was necessary. When He died , all His employees got Money for annother year. This man was really a noble man.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@billyfoster1868 : I am german and in daily life i prefer my swabian dialect over Standard german. But the people, prefering dialect become in all regions of Germany fewer and fewer. In my swabian dialects, such long , for non swabians sometimes funny ,swears/ Flüche, are common. My english is not so fluent, but i try to explain some. ,Dir henk e s' Kreiz aus' ( Standard german: Dir hänge/ henke ich das Kreuz aus) means in english about: I will remove your backbone. , Wenn e mid dr ferdich be, kaaschd da Asch en dr Schleng hoimdraga'( Standard german: Wenn ich mit dir fertig bin, kannst du den Arsch in der Schlinge heimtragen).In English about: When i have finished you , you can carry your arse home in a ( medical) sling ( like a broken arm). ,Di vrhopf'e' ( Standard german: Dich zerhüpfe ich). In english about: I jump on until you die. ,Dir schlag e d Laif aa, daß' d of de Stomba hoimmausla kaasch' ( Standard german: Dir schlage ich die Arme und Beine/Läufe ab, daß du auf den Stümpfen heimkriechen kannst.), Läufe is the huntsman word for animal legs, so in english: I cut away your arms and lege, so that you can crawl home on the remaining arm and leg pieces. So this swabian swears/ curses sound funny, but would be a cruel thing if done in reallity.
3
-
@malakas3808 : Zu meiner Zeit, auch von 1982 bis 1985 in der Berufsschule ist fast nichts ernsthaftes geschehen. Habe in Schulen zwar auch einmal einen ordentlichen Schlag auf die Nase bekommen, aber das war ein Versehen. Privat war ich , Brittas Freund eher Einzelgänger und bin selten an bei Teenagern beliebten Orten gewesen, bin also nicht in irgendwelche Streitigkeiten hineingekommen, und wenn, so waren keine Waffen im Spiel.
Woran die Veränderung hin zum Schlechten, die in den 90er Jahren langsam auch für mich (Asperger erkrankt) erkennbar wurde, kann ich nicht mit Sicherheit sagen. Auf psychischen Erkrankungen und traumatischen Erlebnissen wird meines Erachtens zu sehr herumgeritten , ich halte eher Erziehungsfehler und schlechte Vorbilder für die Ursache, sowie den Schund in Filmen und Internet.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
I am Brittas boyfriend, german, no accademic, never been at Universität, 59 now. But i am german style trained worker ( Facharbeiter) and have ,Mittlere Reife' ( middle education). Ten years school/three years of job training, was for twenty years quality control man of a small german metal company. Quality control needs serious work. In 1970 i saw Lichtenstein castle and was astonished: A castle not being in ruins! My interesst in History as Hobby started, and when a slightly autistic person does a Hobby... I live in a region of Germany full of castle ruins, roman/celtic relicts, about 30 km away was formerly Roman/ Germannic fortified border. I live in those region which was in HRE divided in 100 microstates. Visited dozens of museums , castles, historical sites, reenactments, took part in lot of historical tours, spoke with museum staff, tour guides, antiques Dealers, reenactors, even few words to a relative of Charles Ill. Read many books and magazins. Real History experts told me, for a nonaccademic my historical knowledge is good/ over agerage.
Well, idiocracy seems to be on an unbelievable level rise. Being no accademic, but i notice when someone tells dubious things about History, my advise: Watch a historical thing from at least two directions.
3
-
3
-
3
-
A longer time ago, i, Brittas boyfriend, visited this museum. Rather intresting for a person interessted in older military things. What i liked, had been the friendly employees. In ,Hofrüstkammer' in ,Hofburg', the employees had been very unfriendly.
A small mistake of Ian, who is not an edged weapons expert, in contrast to Matt Easton, the long anti armour swords ( in german Panzerstecher) had been used only by horsemen.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@CtrlAltRetreat : To a lower degree also. Postal horse wagons ( and the passengers) had sometimes also robbed, but as far as i know, last robberies had been in 1830s. But up to 1840s in my state ( formerly Kingdom Württemberg) a rural policeman escorted the wagon, when passengers wanted this and paid a Gebühr ( fee?). The fact, that distances between german villages are much shorter than USA , and the fact, that 19th century Germany consisted of 36 states , in contrast to more than 300 in HRE time made it for ,road robbers' difficult. Horse pulled freight wagons had also sometimes robbed, but this happened not to often, but in a not so inhabitated region of Germany still a series of freight wagons happened in 1910s/ 1920s. It happens sometimes still now that postal offices are robbed, so i think, this happened also in Germany/ Austria before 1914. I have heared, that in some regular postal offices had been revolvers, but i don' t know, it this is true. Also after 1871 a ,Reichspost' existed, but the smaller kingdoms Bayern, Sachsen and Württemberg still had their own postal and railway service. That some postmen had pistols is possible, but i know only, that they got a truncheon/ baton when transporting money or other more expensive things. Protecting postal railway wagons was as far as i know, a thing for railway police. But up to 1890s most german policemen had only sabers.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@saarbrooklynrider2277 : Have you cattle? Have you sheep? Have you fields? Have you a Streuobstwiese? In case of Streuobstwiese the owners have to do hard work,earn five Euros for 100 kg apples, while the nonowners have the lovely view of Streuobstwiesen, would you do the work?. Wild annimals cause damage, they steal fruits, crops, potatoes, vegetables, who pays it, you? The trees in forrests are today planted trees to get ( and sell) wood, the father, perhaps grandfather of the owner has planted it decades ago, for decades there was no money earned. Now the Rinde/bork (?) is destroyed, the tree CAN die and the log perhaps worth fewer money , is it your damage/Schaden ? The sheppards need today wolf protection fences, do you pay the fences? Is it your time and work to errect the fences? It is allways easy to say : Oh this hillbillies should be quiet . ( When it is not your time, work , money and trouble!!)
3
-
Grimmwoldds: I am german. It is true, that german regular troops ( together with semi- regular troops) killed a lot of people outside of Germany. But it is also true that during the 30 years war, in the Louis XlV and Napoleon era and in WWll millions of germans have been killed by foreign armies in germany. Now, how many people have been killed on US soil by foreign regular troops? The war of independence and the secession war do not count for being civil wars. There had been a short war with Great Britain in 1812. The Texas war does not count, because Texas/ Utah/ New Mexico/ Arizona and California had been regular mexican teritory. In 1898 as far as i know, no spanish troops reached US teritory. The 1916 Columbus town incident does not count, because this had not been regular mexican forces, but simply a bunch of criminal throatcutters. It is possible, that german warships (all kind of) reached US water teritory and sunk US ships in WWl. In WWll german and japanese warships reached US waters and sunk US ships. There was the japanese Pearl Harbor attack and japanese ballon bombs killed few people on US soil. But the US invaded Mexico in 1848, where Mexicans have been killed on mexican soil. In 1904 in the US occupied Philipines there was a revolt against US troops and the US troops killed a lot of phillipine people on philipine soil ( are not the US lovers of heroic freedom fighters?). During the 20s and 30s a lot of caribean and central american countries have been invaded by US troops and citizens of this countries have been killed on their own soil. In WWll hundredthousands of german and japanese citizens have been killed by US troops on german or japanese soil. After WWll thousands of vietnamese people have been killed on vietnamese soil by US forces. In Irak and Afghanistan many people have been killed by US troops on their own soil ( are not the US lovers of heroic freedom fighters?). The number of US citizens killed by foreign regular forces on US teritory is MUCH smaller than the number of non US citizens killed by regular US forces on non US soil. I hope you understand, why i do not like the US morality loudmouthery.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
Schulz, Schultz ,Schulze, Schulzen, Schulte, Schultes, Schultheiss, Schultheis, Schultheiß. Variatione of the name, for reason of different dialects and the fact, that before 1873 german language was not standardized. Btw., it means a village mayor, lesser a town mayor. In time of HRE a Schultheiß was in socalled Imperial Towns an official in service of Emperor, not mayor.
3
-
@04279 : The actor Hans Albers, who played Münchhausen was from 1920s to early 1940s seen as , the german action Star ' , similar to John Wayne. With Münchhausen and Große Freiheit Nr. 7 ( literally Great Freedom Nr. 7,), he switched from ,young lover' and ,Action hero' to movies better suited to his age, but still some action, for example a retired detecive involved into a murder Case, or an elderly innkeeper, who has troubles with violent drunkheads.
A Baron von Münchhausen realy lived in german village Bodenwerder (?). To his guests he often told his adventures at hunting rips and during his voyages in Russia, where He for some time served as officer, in a funny way. But not as we know it today. This was done by a writer, who heared of the funny lies Stories.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
@theultimatefreak666 : After 1806, or better 1815, the Heads of Houses who lost their countries between 1803 and 1806 had been known as , Standesherren ' with some remaining honory rights. Some time ago , i read, a quarter of those Standesherren died out. Also mostly in swabian, frankish and rhineish region, there had been the Reichsritter ( Imperial Knights), who had been Independent Knights, who could reign their Village like a Monarch. Also from this Reichsritter, many families no more exist.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
In military german a Gewehr was usually a fullsized battlerifle. A Karabiner ( in Austria also Stutzen was used ) was a shorter rifle , mostly for cavallry. After wwl ( Allied nations made trouble) the rather long fullsized battlerifles and carbines been standardized to one model 98k. Was shorter than wwl Gewehr and longer than wwl Karabiner, but called Karabiner. That those shown rifle was called Gewehr is indeed unusual, i only can assume that someone ordered this name ( in reallity the important Nazis often had not been realy correct in traditions) or because this rifle was the battlerifle of the Gebirgsjäger. Today in german Military nearly everything traditional is forbidden, or german terminology is replaced by english words.
In civilian context Gewehr is umbrella term for all kind of long gun, when a correct description is not necessary. But attention! In old texts, before about 1800, Gewehr is also used as umbrella term for all hand weapons, even swords or spears. Reason: Gewehr consists of Ge- ( meaning a lot of/ for example Gesang - a lot of singing, or Geschrei - a lot of shouting) and Wehr ( meaning weapon or defence/ sich wehren - to defend yourself).
Btw., bayonnet is in german language either Bajonett or Seitengewehr.
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
3
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@MrPanos2000 : On paper, the Reichswaffengesetz of 1938 was liberal. When in 1951(52) it was again allowed for german civilians, to own weapons again, a denazified version of Reichswaffengesetz 1938 was used, and up to 1969 or 1972, .22 rifles had been allowed, perhaps also shptguns. Göring was a hunter, and had been ,Reichsjägermeister', so i think, for hunters , being in a hunting Organisation, there was no problem. Members of target shooters organisations i think had also no problems, but target shooting was militarized. Also blankguns and cheap muzzleloaders could be owned. I think persons, the Nazis did not like or persons , which wanted to be new first time owners of weapons got the largest problems.
2
-
@roskcity : For german grammar reason, there must be a ,s' after Volk . The only exeption i know, without using the ,Duden', a semiofficial german wordbook for correct writing, is Werkschutz, factory(works) protection, which means security guards, being member of the company, which owns the factory, and not from a private security company. Volksturm would be peoples tower, which makes no sense. In current german Sturm means , depending on context, either storm or assault, but in former centuries Landsturm was used to describe a levie of fightable, but not trained men, mobilzed in case of real need. In 19th century/ wwl Landsturm was the name for rearline units of elderly, but trained men, supported by younger trained men, which had been no more frontline able ( for example after being wounded). So the word Volkssturm was not only used for Propaganda reason, similar Landsturm was known for centuries .
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Even in the second Italo/ abbesinian war of 1936 only a part of ethiopian forces had been forces of the central/ imperial gouvernement. This had been about 100000 men. This was the perhaps 25000 men ,Royal Guard' with the best uniforms, hand arms, few heavy equipment ( machineguns, some anti- aircraft, anti- tank and other modern cannons, a handfull of civilian aircrafts, few lorries , some of them lightly armoured) and the best training by belgian, swiss and swedish officers ( small or neutral countries, for no diplomatic problems with the ,world powers) . Tourists/ Observers said the , Royal Guard ' seem to be the best african forces, and the Emperor tried, to build at first the guard as core of a new ethiopian army. The Main Army , perhaps 75000 men had been equipped and trained on low level. The reason for so many different types of rifles, is the fact, that still in 1936 in wartime the nobility moblized their feudal levies. So the Lords had to equip their leviemen, and in peacetime the noblemen bought and stored weapons, they could get. Also lots of feudal leviemen came with own weapons, the poor ones still with muzzleloaders and few with spears.
2
-
@donjones4719 : I am german, and for german law reason , no gunowner. But i visited a number of museums, castles, historic sites ( in my Landkreis/ Arrondissement/ (US) county there are fortifications from bronze age, celtic, roman, medieval and Renaissance age) and some events, US citizens would call ,Gun Show'. About 20years ago, i noticed at such an event the ,books' of a british company ,Osprey' about military history. With the years i bought a number of this books, there are two , which are about the two italo- ethiopian wars of 1896 and 1936. Thats the reason, ,why i know something about this unusual toppic.
2
-
@nqh4393 : In Germany it is said, that French citizens ( Staatsbürger) don' t want to speak german, even if they can speak german. But i noticed when i was for few times in France , without helmet and rifle, that when you try to speak in French language, those frenchmen who can speak german, talk in german with you. A simple trick. When i, Brittas boyfriend, was about ten years ago visiting a french ,Square Dance Special' i noticed, that there are more frenchmen knowing german than you expect. Yes, i can do ,Modern American Square Dance', but only Mainstream level.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Maestro Classico : For the reason that the Teck family changed their name into Cambridge, i as a german mistakely thought, Price William could also use the name Teck again. I was born , and live still there, in the region which was formerly the Lordship of the original ,von Teck' family. This family was of very noble and respected ancestry , but totaly unimportant. In early 14th century they became poor and had to sell their territory and died out in the third quarter of 15th century.. ln 1496 there was a comeback of the name Teck. For political reasons the House of Württemberg used the name , Herzöge (dukes) von Württemberg und Teck' in the time before becoming kings. You have an italian sounding name. About 20km from my home village, there is the mountain Hohenstaufen, with the relicts of Hohenstaufen castle. With their italian name ,Ghibelines'/ die Waiblinger you surely know them.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@RiderOftheNorth.357 : Perhaps you listen to a german citizen. The model , PP' , which is the older one, means in german , Polizeipistole' ( police pistol) , both Polizei/ police and Pistole/ pistol are no words of germanic (!) origin. The younger model of this pistol was called PPK, for concealed carry the grip / Griff and barrel / Lauf was shortened/ gekürzt. So the K could mean kurz/ short because it was shorter than a PP. The word Kriminalmodell is also possible, because a ,Kriminalpolizist' is a detective in civilian cloth. The cartridge .22 lr was up to about 20 years ago in Germany , Austria and Switzerland called 22 lfB, which means ,lang für Büchsen' ( literal translation), the cartidge . 32 ACP is in German ,7,65 Browning' , no lang or kurz ( 7,65 lang is the german name for the french military pistol cartridge introduced 1935). And the .380 ACP is in german mostly ,9mm kurz' but really correct ,9 mm Browning kurz' , because there is also a ,9 mm Browning lang' which was in 1903 introduced by the swedish military, i don't know the english name. So the k in PPK doesn' t mean the cartridge.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
In wwl, there had been in early stages the prussian ( bavarian, saxon, württembergian) Fliegerkorps. Of course, the Fliegerkorps of smaller Kingdoms had been small. On paper there Had been in wwl four armies. Prussian Army ( 19 corps, including the troops of Greatduchies, Duchies, Principalities and Free Towns), Bavarian Army ( 3 corps), Saxon Army (2 corps) and Württembergian Army (1 corps), so 25 corps, when wwl started.
2
-
2
-
2
-
Mr..Metatron! If you come to german state of Baden - Württemberg, please visit the countiies ( in german Landkreise) Göppingen and Aalen. Why ?.Between current towns Lorch and Schwäbisch Gmünd was border between provinces Germania Superior and Rhaetia, also at this towns was fortified border Limes between Imperium Romanum and Germania Magna. You can find relicts of watchtowers, and mostly small Kastelle ( german writing) for Kohorten or only Zenturien. In Germania Superior the borderline was fortified with Palisadew, rampart ( in german Wall) and ditch, in Rhaetia a stone wall, in county Aalen you can see relicts of this stone wall for kilometers, a perhaps 30 cm rampart. Now in town Aalen, there was ( great surprise) a Kastell for a cavallry unit , Ala'. The museum about this ( Römermuseum) is well known. Not far away from Aalen in town Ellwangen there is an intressting museum ( Alemannenmuseum) about alemannic tribe ( see allemand) , which conquered the Region after 260. In HRE time Aalen ( and noted Schwäbisch Gmünd) had been Imperial Towns, Ellwangen was capital of microstate of a Spiritual Lord ( Fürstprobst). And : On current territory of Göppingen there is mountain Hohenstaufen. You are well informed about middleage, so you surely know Emperors Friedrich I ( Barbarossa) and Friedrich ll , who was also King of Naples and build Castel del Monte. Both had been of Hohenstaufen dynasty. What Ghibellines ( die Waiblinger) and Guelfes ( die Welfen- still ruling Great Brittain) had been, you should know as Italian.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Before relyable percussion revolvers became common, both in pepperbox or in nowadays common style, the user of pistols for selfdefence had two possiibilities. Either using a pair of singleshot pistols, of a size, usefull for the owner, or using a pistol with two to four barrels, Hightech, but not allways relyable. And, in those days a backup with a dagger, swordcane, brass knuckles, black jack, a vest of chainmail, or at least thick leather, and a large dog was no mistake.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@BoudewijnvanHouten ???. A) Up to 1866 the German Federation consisted of the Empire of Austria, the Kingdoms of Prussia, Bavaria, Saxony , Hannover and Württemberg, the Greatduchies of Baden, Hessen- Darmstadt, Luxemburg, Oldenburg, Sachsen- Weimar - Eisenach, Mecklenburg - Schwerin, Mecklenburg - Strelitz, the Electorate Hessen- Kassel, the duchies Braunschweig, Anhalt, Nassau, Sachsen- Coburg- Gotha, Sachsen- Meiningen, Sachsen- Altenburg, the Principalities Liechtenstein, Waldeck- Pyrmont, Lippe - Detmold, Schwarzburg - Rudolstadt, Schwarzburg- Sondershausen, Reuß- Greiz, Reuß- Schleiz and the free Towns Frankfurt am Main, Hamburg, Bremen and Lübeck. So your words ,Germany fought against Austria, Bavaria and Denmark is complete nonsens. B) In case of declaration of war ( Bundesexekution) , every memberstate of German Federation had to send troops of 1/100 of its Population ( Austria and Prussia could mobilize additional troops from country parts, being not real part of German Federation). So in case of war a German Federation Army of 300000 would have been mobilized, ten Army corps formed by the larger states, and the Reserve Division, formed by the Military useless troops of the small states. So, in 1866 Austria ( Corps 1 to 3, and the noted nongerman troops), Bavaria ( Corps 7) , Württemberg, Baden, Hessen - Darmstadt ( Corps 8), Saxony and Hannover ( Parts of Corps 9 and 10), and Liechtenstein (part of Reserve Division)had been Allies, the other states prussian allies . Frankfurt and Luxemburg i don' t know ( Frankfurt Contingent was intended as Staff Guard of German Federation, Luxemburg Contingent was intended as Garrison of Federal Fortress Luxemburg, together with 2000 prussian soldiers). C) In 1815, when German Federation was founded , British King was as King of Hannover a german, Bundesfürst' ( up to 1839, Victoria was female), Dutch King was as Greatduke of Luxemburg german Bundesfürst ( Up to 1831), Danish King was as Duke of Holstein ( Up to 1864) also german Bundesfürst. In 1815 there had been good relations between Denmark and German Federation. Danish officers visited small german states, to inspect ? (abnehmen der) parades, officers of small german states die the same. C) The troubles with Denmark started in 1840s, caused by danish Parlament. The Situation was: The danish King was King of Denmark ( and the colonial Empire: Iceland, Greenland and up to 1917 one of the caribean Virgin Islands), Duke of Holstein ( german Population, part of German Federation), Duke of Schleswig ( Mixed Population 60 per Cent German/ 40 per Cent danish, No part of German Federation. Schleswig and Holstein had been no part of danish Kingdom, only ruled by danish King as , Personal Union'. And there was the Treaty of Riepe from 15th century, that in both duchies must be same law.
From 1815 to mid 1840s german people saw in danish people good neighbors, the danish King ruled Holstein and Schleswig, but he did nothing against the Germans living there. This changed in mid/ late 1840s, when danish Parlament decided, to include Schleswig into Denmark and no more respecting the traditional rights of the Germans there. This was reason for a first German/ Danish war in 1848. German forces had been sucessfull, but Russia, France, Brittain and Sweden diplomaticly helped the Danish, which was in 1864 Not the case.
So Bismarck intriqued the war of 1864, but the conflict was caused by Denmark.
And don' t forgett, that for centuries non German Powers did all they could, to weaken the splitted HRE as much as possible, to steal away large territories ( See Alsace in 1680s) and inform yourself about the terrible burning and robbing french General Melac did in Southwest Germany. What right had the French to do so?
2
-
@BoudewijnvanHouten In case of Gouvernement of my country, i, Brittas boyfriend, 58, middle education, trained worker, conservative with rural background, notice a decline of Germany for about 25 years now. I, a man who likes his ountry, culture and tradition, would not act in the way, my Gouvernement acts. The foreigners are more important than Germans, the members of Religion of Worldwide Troublemalers are more important than members of other Religions, lazybones and people getting social Money are more important than working taxpayers, minorities are more important than majority, townspeople more important than rural people, leftwingers are more important than conservative people, criminals more important than orderly people. Every year or Gouvernement has a record income of tax, but the tax money is not used to support Germany, German people , German Economy or Infrastructure, it is used to throw it out of the Window for foreign nonsens. And after two failed Times, that , am deutschen Militärwesen soll die Welt genesen ' our Governement tries ,am deutschen Moralwesen soll die Welt genesen ', and they are wondering that after 1914 and 1939 other nations don' t want to do what German Gouvernement wants. But with my Asperger disorder i don' t realy know, what to do, i have problems to notice and counter intriques.
ln Goethe' s Faust the words , two Hearts work in my chest' appear. Thats what i feel. German loyality or ungerman rebellion?
2
-
2
-
2
-
@Hrimadur : Intressting! Because my name first appeared in my village in late 1600s, i expected a french name (Pharion ?) because my name would sound French, when french spoken, an lots of protestant french came to Germany in second half of 17th century. Also i expected Fährmann or Fuhrmann , and an italian woman told me , in her italian homeregion, Fahrion ( perhaps different written) means race/ type of fish. For the case, you travel between Heidenheim and Geislingen , in the village Steinenkirch there is a large inn, where the owner has the same name, and the waitress asked, if i am related to her Boss, but of course, i don't know.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@jorannielsen4213 : I am german, and i know, that the german grammar case and compound word system is difficult for foreigners. For the dass, that you think, Volkssturm is an unusual name only for Propaganda reason, no . In prussian army the word Landsturm appeared in 1813, it first was used for not uniformed groups of elderly / young/ unfit men , which had not been in the army and should support the regular troops by unregular warfare, but in reality, the prussian king wanted no irregular ununiformed forces, so this men had few appearence. Later up to WWl ,Landwehr' was used for midaged reserve soldiers, and Landsturm for the eldest reserve soldiers. Before 1800, in HRE there had been , especially in small german states, militia units for local defence. There had been many names for this units, including Landsturm. In some cases this militias had a basic training and useable equipment, but mostly this militias had been simply a nearly untrained levie of fightable men.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
machintelligence : The german word ,stutzen' means in english about , to cut'/, to cut down'. About 1700 with ,Stutzen' a short hunting rifle was meant, perhaps the first ones really had been full size rifles, where the barrel(?) was cut at the end of the stock. Today ,Stutzen' simply means a hunting rifle with a stock to the muzzle, they are today a bit shorter than an ordinary rifle, but no more so very short as in former centuries. Attention! In Switzerland ,Stutzer' means a competition/target rifle.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@bouchacourtthierry8506 : The actor Horst Tappert was a former SS soldier, he became famous as ,Inspektor Derrick'. Before, in bis cinema movie appeariances in the 60s, he was mostly seen as the bad guy. For the reason, that he was in SS, the TV show , Derrick' is no more shown in german TV. But on the other hand, there was a rather left wing writer Günter Grass, this man was rather liked by the mostly leftwing art commuuniy , by left wing politicans etc.. A short time before he dies, the writer, who was known to be left wing, had to admit, that he was an SS solider in ww ll. But been known being left wing for decades, this man got no problems for the short time, he was still alive.
2
-
2
-
2
-
Why has AFD so much success? There are people, which are conservative and angry , that formerly conservative CDU made under Merkel a large step to left. There is nomore a realy conservative party here. The SPD was formerly working mans party, but today? No high rank SPD person has a workers background. SPD doesn' t notice, how leftwing their party has become. They totally have forgotten their election poster from 1920s, which shows two men, having Soviet Star / Swastika on headgear, text was: This are the enemies of Democracy. Danish social democratic party solved migration problem, in a way , which german SPD also could do, but SPD refuses.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@Lee-vk1xy : In older texts, for example Landsknecht era, also Haube is used for a Helm, the german footman helmet was , Deutsche Sturmhaube ', spanish Moiron was , Spanische Sturmhaube ' and Zischägge ( from Poland with oriental/asian influence) was , Orientalische Sturmhaube '. Skull cap ( literally Schädelkappe) was Hirnhaube ( brainhood). Some helmets had also been called Beckenhaube. Some people claim Pickelhaube comes from Beckenhaube of former times, but i doubt, because Pickel ( Pickaxe) clearly means the pointy spike, and Helm mit Spitze was official term. In current german the word Haube is rarely used , for oldfashioned womens headgear in headgear context, mostly Haube is today a protection cover, for example for cakes, other food or technical items, to be protected against dirt or falling objects. In case of workers head protection there are mostly plastic protection helmets, but for some workers stiffed caps / Anstoßkappen are enough.
2
-
2
-
2
-
In german language a ,V'is mostly spoken ,F' ,so ,Folkspistole' not ,Wolkspistole'. It seems, that many english speakers don' t know this. And ,Volkssturm' is mostly seen as a Propaganda name, but for centuries the word ,Landsturm' was used for traditional levies of fightable, but not good trained and armed men.
2
-
@JustRememberWhoYoureWorkingFor : The austrian Admiral Tegethoff knew that italian fleet was better. So he decided, to order his Fleet into three V formations behind each other, and used not the usual battle line of ships. He basicly attacked in old style of rowed warships with old ramming tactic. He succeded, by a mistake of italian Admiral Persano. Without correct flag signal communication he went away from his flagship to a newer ship , also he forgot taking the Admirals flag to other ship. After the unusual austrian attack, the italians had been surprised, and not knowing, that the italian Admiral was now in another ship caused confusion/ chaos among italian fleet, so the italians lost the battle. But austrian Admiral knew, even after winning the battle, the italians still had more and better armed ships, he sailed away as fast as possible. He feared, after their surprise, the italian Fleet could follow him for a second battle.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@nedludd7622 : The thing is a) Asperger, my brain works slightly different than normal people. b) I am intressted in all kind of military history, from ancient egypt to now, so it is for me not possible, to be wellinformed about all wars/ armies of all times very deep. c) I come from an area, which was in HRE time the most split area of HRE, a few kilometers, and you are in next former HRE state, visiting the museums ,and informing myself about the curiosities of HRE is for a curiosity lover intressting. d) There had been in HRE times states, ruled by spiritual Lords, and partly democratic free towns, but everywhere the ruling persons had a better life and more power than average person. (Also poorer englishmen could not vote, and in nonaristocrstic Switzerland had been revolts) . e) As a nostalgic person , i would have no problem with a parlamentary monarchy ( no absolute or constitutional monarchy) f) And HRE is not totally dead: Head of state is not elected by citizens in current Germany, but by Bundesversammlung , a gremium of members of federal and states parlaments, in HRE times seven , later nine electors. In HRE days after 1450, you could be sure, the next emperor is from Habsburg dynasty, today you know two weeks before the election, who is next german federal president. An unnecessary and expensive show. Also, with exeption of doubleheaded imperial eagle, Federal Presidents Standart is like HRE Emperors standart. I am not against democraty, but current politicans in Germany are , in my eyes, no more the politicans i knew, when i was young, don' t know how to describe this feeling.
2
-
@frankberry6220 : In Germany ( Austria/ Switzerland) a rifle is called Büchse, and has a rifled ( gezogenen) barrel, while a shotgun is called Flinte and has a smooth (glatten) barrel. A combined gun with one rifled and one smooth barrel is a Büchsflinte ( rifleshotgun). Every long gun, including wall guns, puntguns, antitankrifles, antimaterial rifles, are, especially when manportable , are Gewehre. Is strange, that in Great Brittain a rifle doesn' t need a rifled barrel.
2
-
2
-
@frankberry6220 : Good question, because totally unusual. I personally have nothing to do with this topic, so i can only assume. German authorities are mostly antiweapon and antigun. For them, it would be best, when only military, police,customs service, some Justice personal and Forrest service would be armed ( See 1933 to 1945, or in eastern Germany up to 1990). So i doubt rather stong, that german authorities would give people, who feel temporary unsafe for whatever reason, the allowness for a defence weapon and allowness for Combat Shooting Training, As i know spirit of german authorities, i think they would say, a pistol is useless for personal security of civilians, they are to lowtrained to handle a firearm propperly, the danger of hunting undangerous people is to high, ..... The noted licence Waffenschein is still existing, but rare. Even jewelry dealers/ goldsmiths or other people, where robbery is often happening, have problems to get such a licence. And : When you have such a licence, every three years, authorities will Proof, if the danger is still existing. They don't want persons, carrying a firearm , so often they say,hiring guards is better. And for my lack of vovabulary, i can't describe IT better. But i hope, you understand, what i want to explain.
2
-
@frankberry6220 : I am no gun owner, and not realy well informed , how to get a Waffenschein, a licence to carry a pistol for defence. Majority of german legal gunowners have only , Waffenbesitzkarte ( Firearms Owning Card), which means you can only transport an unloaded gun in a locked box, ammunition in a different locked box, and shoot at shooting on shooting range or in your hunting district. Without ammunition you also can transport your gun for example to gunsmith/ gunmaker ( both is in german Büchsenmacher) for repairs, or other events in context to your licence type. Now to Waffenschein again. In case of armed personal of civilian administration, this are mostly persons like police or customs service officials, where a weapon is part of job equipment. But there are some officials, who have a pistol on Waffenschein Basis. For example (at least ten years ago) judges could get such a licence ( sometimes revenge acts happen), officials who work / do their job alone at a lonely location, officials who work with large sums (?) of money or things, interesting for criminals etc.. But also in court/ law context sometimes lawyers, who work as , Verteidiger' ( defender ? of arrested criminals) got such a licence ( when revenge acts are seen as possible), formerly also high rank Bank employees could get such a licence, or people Like jewelry dealers or weapons Traders ( which are currently mostly Büchsenmacher) for transporting firearms or in Case of jewelry Dealers, transporting jewelry, gold or diamonds. Also people, who are for some reasons more in danger of being attacked more than average citizens, can get such a licence. But currently authorities like it more, when persons who work with things , liked by robbers, should hire guards, or let weapons, gold etc. transported with armoured vans and guards. And people, who are in danger of being Kidnapper or Assasinstions should hire professional Bodyguards. So, as far as i know, currently authorities don't really want it, that people in danger of being attacked, try to defend themselves with an own firearm, but it is still possible, but rather difficult to get a Waffenschein. The other side is private Security business. When i, born 1965, grown up in a then semirural, now urbanising region, was young, private Security personal was rare to see. In large Towns sometimes private investigators existed ( in contrast to british ones, german ones have low reputation), sometimes you saw an armoured Cash van in front of a Bank in next town, in some music Locations there was a strong man as bouncer ,when necessary , not so much in rural areas. Once this oldstyle bouncers had been called simply ,Rausschmeißer'( Outthrower), and few large companies had their own Security branch called Werkschutz ( works/factory protection) or a single nightwatchman. Today situation is totally different. Those traditional Werkschutz became rare, but is still existing, especially in large chemical factories, factories producing Military goods, or electric power companies ( only four large ones still exist, and a large number of microcompanies, surely without Werkschutz). For 26 Years ( btw. , i am Brittas boyfriend only using her Computer too) i worked for a small pipeline company, producing special pipelines for chemical industry. But from time to time, this no more existing company produced special parts for a coastal shipyard (?)/ Werft- U- Boot components. One day our busines Leader had the posibility to visit this shipyard. When he came back, he told, a man in civilian dress accompanied him and the guide, under the shoulder of this man was assumingly a pistol. In music Locations, visited by mostly Younger or foreign persons, bouncers/ Security men are today normal, also in malls/ large shops , especially in evening. When i was young, there was No Security personal at traditional German beer tents ( perhaps the local firemen came in nonservice uniforms and used their then existing authority, now more and more. Also in some large shops, you see today a man in suit standing next to main entrance.
Most of those Security men ( sometimes also women) are unarmed, or only pepper Spray/ collapsible Baton, rarely a dog. But some Security guards are armed with pistols ( 9 mm Luger/ 9mm kurz) or revolvers ( .38 S&W Special). This are Bodyguards, escort of armoured vans, and guards of factories producing expensive, dangerous, Military or otherwise important goods. If those Security guards, patroling at night all kind of factories, shops, buildings...with a Car to get to the Locations allways have pistols, i don' t know. So those Security persons, you see currently everwhere more and more are usually unarmed, but a large number is armed with pistols. As far as i know, inside Germany no private Security personal is armed with shotguns or rifles. Other weapons than pistol/ revolver, pepper/cs spray and mostly collapsible batons i don't know.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Hitler wasn' t shot, so good protection. Fun aside. Of course the roof was complete unarmoured, someone could fire from a building, see Kennedy assasination, or somebody could throw a handgrenade into the car. But on other hand, Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria, and in 1930s, have forgotten the year, King Alexander of Jugoslavia had been assasinated by a pedestrian with a pistol. About the second event, you can see old newsreels. In such cases, the armour helps. In Technikmuseum Sinsheim there are two Mercedes of this era. One Sedan/ Limousine with hard roof,( no convertible), the sidewindows are estimated 5 cm/2" thick, if the large sixwheel convertible is also armoured, i have forgotten.
I regularly read a german magazine about military history. In one ,Special Edition' of those magazine about Hitlers headquarters, there was an article about security, when Hitler travelled by car. According to this article, in Hitlers car there was usually only the driver and a bodyguard/servant, a second car with SS bodyguards and a third car with expierienced police detectives.
A Sidenote: A driving licence is in Germany called Führerschein, but the Führer had none!
2
-
Diese Trichtermündung, bei indisch/ orientalischen Stücken größer als bei europäischen, hatte eigentlich nur den Sinn, daß der Benutzer die Waffe auf schwankendem Schiffsdeck oder Kutschbock leichter laden konnte, da das einführen von Ladestock, Pulverhornstutzen oder des Schrotbeutelstutzens leichter war, als bei der Mündung einer üblichen Waffe. Es ist ein Unterschied , ob die Mündung trichterförmig und 50 mm hat, oder zylindrisch und weniger als 22 mm. Die eigentliche Streuung wurde durch den Trichter nicht beeinflusst, sie war genauso wie bei einem normalen Karabiner gleicher Länge. ( Karabiner waren kürzere Gewehre für Reiter und Kanoniere , welche bis in die 1840er Jahre ebenfalls glatte Läufe hatten.)
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Basic difference: Heavy cavallry: Tall men on tall heavy horse, armoured man. Light cavallry : Smaller man, lighter horse, light or unarmoured man. Tasks: Light cavallry: Reconnaisance, fighting against enemy light cavallry, escorting slow moving artillry/ supply colums, commando raids, terrorising/shocking enemy civilians, plundering, messengers, surrounding own troops on march and camp (a) to catch desserteurs ( b) to prottect own troops against surprise attacks, when necessary, charging as second or third charge wave. Heavy cavallry: Waiting in good possition in close formation until there is a gap / weak point in enemy formation / battle order, then attack the gap / weak point in steamroller frontal charge to break enemy formation/ battle order ( of course assaulting infantry has to follow charging heavy cavallry to throw back the enemy, fighting enemy heavy cavallry. I hope, you understand. So heavy cavallry strong and heavy men and horses , armour and weaponry for close quarter right, few carbines intended for one heavy attack. Light cavallry opposite for fast movements and maneuverable, lots of carbines.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
schrodingers cat : As a german citizen i only know that the Department of Homeland Security is a US Federal Agency, which has to guard, bridges, damm?, electricy and water supply buildings etc.. Because i am NOT so much interessted in WWll, i am no expert, which security agencies had been a central headquarter in the RSHA. Police, SS, SD and Gestapo. The other agencies i don 't know. There had been prison/court guards, customs service, railway police, post protection and smaller, not so wellknown police/security and intelligence agencies, for example the Reichpost Forschungsstelle or a non uniformed rural police called Landwacht/rural guard. And not to forget, the relicts of medieval community security forces:,Town criers', the very last nightwatchmen, field guards ( in french: gardes champetres) etc..
2
-
KKona : I write in english, for the other readers. In my last comment i said, it seems to be a problem, for the reason of , Feinheiten' in the english language, which i do not know, because my english is not so good. You described it better, Reich means in Germany usualy a country ruled by an emperor or king, countries ruled by nobles of other ranks are called different. As history interessted germans, we both know, that the ,Holy Roman Empire' is a subject/ topic (?), which you can't describe in a few sentences. For the nongermans i try to explain the military situation of the HRE after 1496. There had been about 300 nearly independant states, which had been called ,. Reichsstände', simplified every Reichsstand had seat and voice in the , Reichstag'/ Parlament. And there had been territories with no seat and voice in parlament, mostly the Reichsritter/ imperal knights, those territories had to send no soldiers to the ,Reichsarmee'. But the ,Reichsstände' had to do so, and in 1496 a treaty was signed, how many men the different , Reichsstände' had to send, because they had different size. The territory of the HRE was split into ten districts/ Reichskreise. The emperor could only mobilze his own troops, the ,Reichsarmee' was only mobilized after a parlament order.
2
-
2
-
Ich bin Brittas Freund, Jahrgang 1965, und habe noch den letzten Rest der alten Landwirtschaft erlebt. Mein Vater hat bis 2001 eine der für Altwürttemberg früher so typischen Kleinlandwirtschaft betrieben , wie es in den ,Bilderbüchern' heute sehr beliebt ist. Nun , mein Vater hat aufgegeben, weil sich eine so kleine ,Bilderbuch Landwirtschaft ' nicht mehr rentiert. Die in meiner Kindheit noch sehr gepflegten Streuobstwiesen verwildern besonders arg, da sich dies überhaupt nicht rentiert.
Als geschichtlich interessierter Mensch weis ich, daß es Zeiten gegeben hat, in denen die deutsche Landwirtschaft tatsächlich ohne Dünger und Spritzmittel arbeitete, aber das war vor 200 Jahren, da hatte Deutschland 30 Millionen Einwohner und war größer. Das kann heute nicht mehr funktionieren. Und, wer soll die im Vergleich zu heute größere Handarbeit erledigen? Thunberg & Co?
2
-
Being german, from a region where in nearly every village graves from alemannic warriors have been found , 3th to 6th century. Even some centuries later most warrior graves contain only spearheads, seaxes and iron shieled center ( Schildbuckel). Spathas , similar to viking era swords had been owned by richer wariors, and helmets/ armor is nearly unexisting. So during first half of first century, very few warriors owned a sword, and armour was nearly unknown by germannic warriors. It seems , you confuse germanic warriors with celtic warriors, which had at least in Julius Caesars time, much better arms and armour.
2
-
@d10s_ad : This depends to the time. At first 1st century before and after Jesus Christ there was in fact a lack of iron and good weapons and nealy no armour. In third century, when my tribe conquered north half of current area, most Romans have left this region, many troops gone away for innerroman civil war reasons, and the civilians fled for reason of alemannic raids. So not much military quality was necessary. By the time roman border fortifications had been an obstacle, small tribes united to larger tribes, which basicly still exist, so much larger tribes had been more dangerous to Romans. Also with the time the number of seaxes, also swords became larger ( selfproduced, captured or bought even in nongermannic regions), also germannic tribes learned more how to counter roman troops and tactics. By the time there was also a decline inside roman troops, and as longer time lasted, Roman Empire had no more enough money to enlarge army and build up a large enough cavallry force. So with the time, the time worked against the Romans.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
I am german. In 1980s/ early 1990s i often used socalled S- Bahn ( regional train system for short distances). Was then rather safe, one day i , Brittas boyfriend, got troubles with two german drunkheads, which, don' t know english word, had , belästigt ' women, girls and elderly people with awfull words. Doctors had to sew my face, lost the fight, but honourable. Was in early 1990s unusual, but nowadays? Violence in trains and railway stations, and girls and women sexually attacked ( a women of my age i know for over twenty years now, disabled legs after an accident, is so angry now) . Allways the same human crap , but protected by german gouvernement, churches, media and leftwing NGOs.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@bosknight7837 : Hm, difficult to answer. I assume, in context of weapons, manufacturing and military terminology, he has some knowledge to understand and translate german words, when sees a german document or book. But i don' t think, he really learned german.. Knowing more german , than average US citizen, seems not difficult, some years ago, in front of a german museum i waited to meet someone. When sitting there, an US Lady sit down next to me, a tourist. Using the for me rare possibility to speak english, i noticed, the woman couldn 't speak any german. The Anglosaxons once came from northern Germany, but the Lady didn't recognize Forke, Reep and lütt- fork, . rope, little! As a person from southern Germany, i was totally surprised!
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@KR-jt4ut : So in 1618 to 1648 there had been no french and swedish troops in Germany? In reign of Louis XlV 1648 to 1714 the french did nothing in Palatine Region , Rhine Valley and other South West Regions of Germany , so what troops plundered my village in 1683? Napoleon was never in Germany? Current french and swedish people have nothing to do with this. But: I have never heared, that there had been ( with exeption of noted Hofer and Schill) a partisan movement in Germany, so from 1870 to 1845 saw this persons simply as criminals ( also i noted that using shotguns is in Germany seen as criminals work, for shotguns being never in the noted time, and also not today, a weapon of armed forces). But of course, invading other countries in Hitlers style, is simply a crime, and i can' t understand, how someone can have such ideas like Hitler and his supporters.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@SavageArms357 : In german language countries of 19th century the people of course also liked stories with heroes fighting criminals. In second half of 19th century some Wild West novels had be known in german speaking countries. James Fenimore Cooper for example, or Friedrich Gerstäcker , a german who lived some years in USA and decided to return home. Also saxon novelist Karl May 1842 -1912 wrote a large number of rather fantasyfull adventure novels, where the Stories play everywhere on the planet.
But of course, the people wanted to hear also stories which happen in german countries, where the readers had been familiar with the situation. Life was similar, but not the same in every german state, in Switzerland a bit more different to current Germany and Austria, for reason of centuries of republican Tradition. In contrast to USA open carry of weapons was no more allowed since Napoleonic era ( why people switched to swordcanes, short daggers, Derringers- in german called Terzerol, knuckles or things known in USA as sap or Blackjack), monarchs contolled weapons hard. Revolution of 1848 was not sucessfull, but in case of owning ( not carrieing) weapons most liberal time in Germany ( Up to early 1920s) started. So in german language countries civilians caried weapons when hunting or a shooters event visible.
Starting in late 17th century, ending in Napoleonic era, also in HRE gangs of robbers ( doing also poachery, smuggling, burglary etc.) existed for different reasons , often simply poorness. Some of this historical robbers, for example Schinderhannes or , Bayrischer Hiasel' had been romanticed as , German Robin Hoods', because some of their ,dones (?)/ Taten had been seen as acts of ,rebells/ revolutionaires'. Those Gangs existed mostly in current South West of Germany, because the over hundred (!) small german states could not fight this mobile Gangs. If a crime was noticed, and the small Security force mobilized, the Gangs fleed to annother German state, or to nearby France or Switzerland. After Napoleonic era those Gangs no more existed, and got replaced by single criminals or only small groups, some, like bavarian poacher Jennerwein had been still romanticed as folk heroes.
So novel writers wrote many novels , Theater authors Theater pieces, painters painted paintings, in which a heroic Forrest official ( Förster) or a Brave licenced Hunter fights poachers, smugglers , sometimes other criminals. Also in those days, up to 1970s/ 1980s socalled fieldguards existed ( in France still known as gardes champetres), which had to guard fields and fruit trees from food thieves.
When in 1950s there was great US wave of Wild West movies, there was a wave of Heimatfilme ( literaly homeregion movies) in Germany, Austria ( lesser Switzerland) with lots of poachers and forresters/ hunters. Most known one seems to be , Grün ist die Heide./The heather is green.' Sidenote: Both Heide and Heather are also women names
Those poachers used everything from wire slings, to traps you can see with former fur Trappers, shortened rifles ( muskets/ shotguns), also large pistols, sometimes guns, which can be Put into small parts easyly, and hidden firearms Like caneshotguns.
Many of those poachers guns are simply to weak for lawfull hunting, also poachers hunting methods are not lawfull, and German gunlaw has a Paragraph about poachery guns.
Fight against poachers is no thing of hstory, last year two Police officers had been shot by a poacher
Oh, when you visit museum of Königsbronn, a large Village, there is a room only about poachery.
2
-
@2fwelding842 : I am german, Brittas boyfriend, and for reason of my Asperger disorder pedantic. Being a pedantic Asperger person was good in the twenty years, i was quality control man of a small german company. Please stop to use the word , Pickelhaube', this was in Second German Empire never an official term. Both the leather helmets used by line infantry and dragoons, and the steel or Tombak versions used by prussian and bavarian cuirassiers and Saxon , Heavy Riders' had been called , Helm mit Spitze '/ helmet with point. So french , casque a point' is corect. Pickelhaube was in Germany only a nickname, only a similar helmet, used by policemen in German part of Austria - Hungary was officially called Pickelhaube. Nothing against you, as nongerman this is surely unknown. Oh, inform yourself about helmets used by US state militias in 1880s, you will be surprised about Photos, showing Indian Scouts.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Mr. Mc Collum! Why didn' t tell you the full story? In time of German Federation (1815 - 1866) only few of South German states bought a rather small number of side by side percussion shotguns, Württemberg, as far as i know, 100 guns. In those days german policemen, especially the ,town payed' ones, usually carried only a saber. The state paied rural police ( Gendarmerie or Landjäger), basicly soldiers doing policework, as paramilitary force had when necessary access to military firearms. The noted shotguns had been handed to policemen when they had to escort prisoners to annother prison, when fighting poachery etc.. In 1866 German Federation ended, Austria, Luxemburg and Liechtenstein became Independent countries, with own armed forces history.
In Imperial Germany ( 1871 - 1918) shotguns had been nowhere in Germany service weapons, may be in very early years of german colonies, when they had been private owned territories of merchants, members of their Private Security Forces had shotguns.
Then from 19th century, long into 20th century in Germany/Austria Wildwest novels had been known and popular, but an indigenious genre of adventure novels was popular: Novels in which Forrest Service officials ( Förster), sometimes also lawfull licenced huntsmen, fought mostly poachers or smugglers, sometimes other criminals. The Heroes of this novels are armed with their hunting rifle ( and Hirschfänger knife), shotguns, when appearing, had been the weapons of criminals in popular literature.
Now, is it astonishing, that German soldiers, don't knowing shotguns as military or civilian service weapons, but knowing shotguns from novels as criminals weapons didn' t saw US soldiers with shotguns as honourable enemies?
Even today use of shotguns in Germany is rare, SWAT Teams of Police and few soldiers use them to destroy doors etc., but firing at persons is strictly forbidden. And shotgun use is carefull watched by journalists and political left circles.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@virginiaoflaherty2983 : The reason , why in former Kingdom Württemberg public baking houses exist, is the danger of fire . The houses had been timberwood (?) houses / Fachwerkhäuser, and in most village houses, owned by farmers, hay and straw ( Heu / Stroh in german) was stored. It often happened, that a baking oven set a house on fire, the burning house set the whole village on fire, and before firebrigades existed, whole villages or towns burnt down. So in last years of 18th century Duke of Württemberg ordered to build stone/ brickmade public baking houses to prevent fire, but for Napoleonic wars reason , most houses had been build in 1820s to 1840s. When i, born 1965, was a child/ Teenager, this baking houses had been common and still in use for bread baking, but times have changed. Fewer and fewer people bake their bread self, so it is to expensive to repair the oven from time to time with public money for fewer and fewer users. Also when the fire in the oven, heated with bundles of thin branches( Fascines, in my dialect Krähla) is starting, a lot of dark smoke comes out of chimney. For the reason, that more and more urbaniced modernlings with fine noses live in villages, they run to townhouse to send mayor a letter: Stop this terrible smoke, vor i call my lawyer. So many of this public baking houses had been closed by courts and judges.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Coperlite Consumer: l personaly would say so., became Roman culture dominated appeninian peninsula. and was oldest part of Roman Empire. But of course in about 50 before Christ, in parts of current italy still greek or etruscian speaking persons had been. Of course this is simplified, people of non ,roman' Origin could also move inside Roman Empire and / or get the ststus of , Roman Citizen '. The people in former Roman Empire, but outside of current Italy, are in german also called Römer, but in this case meaning Inhabitants of Roman Empire, living the roman culture. My History teacher said: When you read, that romans moved / came into a nonroman part of Roman Empire, for example Egypt or England, in this case, you should not think , those romans had been Itslians, this had been in this case romanized persons from all parts of Roman Empire, only perhaps high rank , knights ' or ,senators' had been , italians'. To different the people, living in Roman Empire outside of current italy, especially far away from Rome, the term Provinzialrömer is used. This had been more or less romanized local people, more or less romanized persons from other parts of Roman Empire, and few ,real romans: (you could call italians). When we germans mean all current living europeans , speaking a latin based language as whole, they are called Romanen ( Rumänen are inhabitants of Rumänien/ Romania). And inhabitants of Rom/ Rome, are , from founding the town by legendary Romulus and Remus until now, called Römer.
Btw., there is an old Joke in Germany: What is the difference between Römern ( Inhabitants of Rome) and Parisern ( inhabitants of Paris)? Solution: The Römer drink their wine from Römer, but the Pariser don' t drink their wine from Parisern! ( For information: A special type of wineglass is in Germany called Römer, while in german slang Pariser means condom.)
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@jamieleepescini2675 : I had six years of English and four years of French at school. English was ( is) more easy for me, some words are rather similar ( for example : Bier/ beer, Ochse/ ox, Leiter/ ladder, Bär/ bear, Haus/ house), also word order for example german Handtasche, english handbag, but french sac de mains. A great problem for me had been the endings of french words, you hear ,e', but -e, - ee, - es, -ez, -é, -è is possible to write. In daily life i rarely need english vor french, same with Standard German, i usually speak my swabian dialect.
2
-
2
-
My father, born 1938, told me, the first american soldier he saw pointed a pistol to him, his brother, his sister, his mother, grandmother and another woman and shouted: Wo Ring, wo Gold? (German,wo'- english,where'/ german,Gold'- english,gold'/ german ,Ring'-english ,ring'). I am sure the soldier was one of this heroic amercan soldiers seen in every war movie.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Both my girlfriend Britta and i are members of a german Square Dance Club. A number of years ago, an elderly german ,Caller' told at an event, that he doesn' t want to offend saxon persons. When he learned Square Dance, his knowledge of english was rather low, so he had problems, with US callers coming from different states, because they spoke english a bit different. The US dancers, in those days mostly US soldiers, didn' t believe him, that this is true. So when he learned to be also a Caller, he surprised the US dancers by calling in english, but with saxon style of speaking, they could not dance. At the noted event i saw this caller, the dancers had all been german, but with exeption of a single saxon man, nobody could understand his dancing calls.
2
-
@albertmarnell9976 : He is austrian, most austrians speak a dialect belonging to bavarian dialect group, up to mid 12th century , current Austria belonged to Bavaria. The inhabitants of austrian state Vorarlberg belong, together with swabians, swiss germans and alsatians to alemanic dialect group. When speaking in dialect, we german speaking people get problems to understand us propperly, so Standard German was created. You are right, when someone speaks strange, but it is a good person, his strange speaking is no problem .
2
-
@albertmarnell9976 : This is no wonder. When your german ancestors came from Hamburg/ low german area, they spoke in their dialect, Standard German was up to 1960s, even 1970s not as common as it is today. When you want to hear a german speaking his dialect, you have to speak with germans in rural areas, and there with old farmers and their wifes. When i, Brittas boyfriend, born 1965 , was a child, nearly everybody spoke the swabian dialect of my region, today many children no more know it , and in 40000 inhabitants neighbor town, you hear the dialect today rarer and rarer. For me as a german from the south, Lowgerman/ Plattdeutsch has an english touch, for example : English little/ low german lütt/ standard german klein or english fork/ low german Forke/ standard german Gabel or english rope/ low german Reep/ standard german Seil. The reason is, that the Anglosaxons came from Lowgerman region.
2
-
@albertmarnell9976 : As i noted, i am from the south of Germany, so i am not so familiar with Lowgerman / Plattdeutsch. But in case of ,the little one' it cgraould be , der Lütte' ( in Standard German : der Kleine) . But in the case, that your parents/ grandparents spoke in dialect, i can only assume, that it was , de Lütt' or , de Lütte'. Like english speakers ,the' , low german speakers can say ,de' both to male or female persons and it depends on word ending, to describe it clearly. But for being from the south, i can be wrong. A note: Today majority oft germans use Junge for boy. But when i was younger , here in the south Bub was usually used, i do still so. Bub/Boy ,yes germanic relative. And boy, in case of Cowboy, Hotel boy, Liftboy can also mean ,servant'. When i was at school ( in USA you would say Highschool) the theater piece ,Wilhelm Tell' from Friedrich Schiller was for some time the toppic of Deutsch/ german class. At the end, we hat to witte a test/Aufsatz. The next day the teacher asked astonished to my class: Why did you wrote Mr. Gesslers son died in the burning castle, it was his servant! We pupils didn' t knew, that in 1790s/ early 1800s Bub ( like boy) also could mean servant. Why i know this? I am only a german style trained worker / Facharbeiter, but i am not uneducated, i am intressted in history and to low degree also in things at Peripherie (?) of history, for example art, traditions, mythologie, old coins, evolution of human being , i speak ,rather bad, some french. So when you have a good basis of knowledge and education, some things are no mystery and easy to explain.
2
-
2
-
@albertmarnell9976 : Bub is usualy not used als an insult. But it depends on context. Spitzbub/ Spitzbuben was formely in 19th and before, used for criminals. This word is today rare used, today it means no more a real criminal, but someone with creative ideas to do something not allowed, but in an unexpected way , which surprises( baffles?) other persons. Not a real insult, but a sign: I don' t take you serious ( Ich nehme dicht nicht ernst) is Milchbubi ( milk boy) . This means literally , you are so young, you still drink mothers milk . It can be a light insult, but usually this Milchbubi is used to say: Because of your ( young) age, i doubt, you have much experience.
2
-
2
-
@Ruhrpottpatriot : After the spectacular defeat of 1806 ( Jena and Auerstädt), Prussia lost a lot of territory and the army was limited to 42000 men by Napoléon. So the prussian army analyced the mistakes ( to old officers in high ranks, only noble officers, to much parade training but to few field training, training and thinking only on regiment level, recruting etc.), this change was one of the reason, why prussian became so good in many military thngs after 1813. In the time of German Federation (1815 - 1866) only Austria,, the kingdoms and great dukes had the money and capability for usefull troops. The contingents of the Dukes, princes and free towns, often fewer than 300 men, had so low training, that they could only be used as guards, escorts, patrol men or fortress men.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Nick Eldridge: Before 1525 Prussia was Country of the Order of Teutonic Knights, and after the battle of Tannenberg/ Grünwald in 1466(?) it was a puppet state of the polnish kingdom. Even the majority of inhabitants had been german, Prussia was no part of Germany/ HRE, so the Hochmeister/ high master of the teutonic order was the ruler. But with the tme the german people of Prussia fewer and fewer liked the , Teutonic knights' and in the reformation age in 1525 the high master switched to protestant religion, called himself duke, and prussia remained a puppet state of poland. This noted man was of the Hohenzollern dynasty, who, inside of the HRE, had been electors of Brandenburg ( the swabian branches remained being unimportant counts). In 1701 elector Friedrich lll of Brandenburg called himself ,king IN prussia' ( a trick for not having juristcal problems), and could stop being a puppet state of poland ( Prussia), the teritories inside of HRE had been of course never puppet states of poland. I have no accademic degree, i am only a trained worker ( Facharbeiter).
2
-
@MsMesem 1) In my homeregion a lot of non gouvernement organisations have a lack of documents before 1947, because occupation troops confiscated archives and documents- true fact. 2) From about 1300 - 1871 Germany was weak for being devided into more than 300 ( after 1815 about 35 states) without a stong central gouvernement like other grand power- true fact. 3) This weakness was used especially by the French to steal a lot of german territory ( Alsace and Lorraine), also the minor territories in the ,Franche Comte' the Dukes of Württemberg got in medieval times. Also in the time of ,Sun King' Louis XIV the frech troops burnt and robbed lots of german villages and towns. - true fact. 4) Also the Danish tried to conquer as much of german territory as possible . For ecample in 1500 they tried to conquer the Dithmarschen region, one of the few german territories outside of Imperial Towns/ Reichsstädte where there had been NO noblemen. - true fact. 5) I have seen no movie, neither french, danish or from another nation, which show french, danish or other nongerman troops doing crimes in Germany, AMD no movie, which show the reality that after 1300/1350 Germany was a weak country. - true fact. 6) I don' t like nationalists and i geht angry, when nationalists tell wrong nonsens, natioalist poison is the seed of hate.- true fact 7) I try to explain the german history as good as i as a non academic can do this, to close education gaps, because i know, that most
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
In late 1970s/ early 1980s on german TV sometimes 45 min ,Specials' appeared, showing three 15 min stories/ episodes, in all three episodes the same popular german actor was the main character, in the next ,Special' another actor appeared. One time the actor Heinz Rühmann was the main actor in such a Special', all three stories played in Great Brittain. In one of this 15 min stories, he played the railway station man of a very small railway station in a rural area. Somehow he knew, that this day the Royal Train will pass his little railway station, and for being a patriotic british citizen, he ordered a teenager, to wave a british flag, when the Royal Train passes. To his surprise, the Royal Train came earlier than expected and stopped at his station. As the only railwayman here, he went to the train and asked, which help the Queen needs. But the railwayman opening the doors, answered, the Queen is not in the train, it stops only for being to early. But i see, you are a dutyfull railwayman, so you can enter the Royal Train and drink a cup of tea with us. In this carriage, where the tea was drunken, there was a cleaning lady sitting in a chair, having her hair covered with a piece of cloth, looking like a ,Turban' ( asian headgear). The Teenager looked through a window, to see what the railwaystation man does. He saw him speaking with a lady, from which he could only see from behind head and headgear. The boy was surprised, let fall bis flag and run to the next pub, where he shouted: The Royal Train has stopped and Mr..... drinks tea with the Queen!
A nice short story of german TV, noting british Royal Train.
2
-
2
-
I am German. In my language we use the latin alphabet like the English, with some in english language unknown letters. Ä, ä (Ae, ae)/Ö, ö (Oe, oe)/ Ü, ü (Ue, ue) and ß. In words of german origin you speak like it is written ( in swiss german some words are pronounced a bit more oldfashioned, so that many germans and austrans have a problem). The speaking- writing difference is mostly in words of non german origin. But the fact, that we write with the same letters than the english, this does not mean, that we speak it the same way. In spoken language V and W are different, or let members of this two nations speak ,th' or ,ch'.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Wasn' his name Lichtenfeld , many jewish people have a german family name. As far as i know, in the interwar periode a stickfighting manual for indian policemen, written by a british colonial officer ,Long' , inspired by Barton- Wrights ,Bartitsu' , was popular among jewish people in nowadays Israel, because unter british rule in interwar time it was difficult to own firearms legally, so also arabian attackers often only had daggers, sabers or clubs.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Georges Sheffield: Before wwl , as far as i know, officers of every nation had to buy their own equipment. In case of Imperial Germany, i am german and read german language arms magazines since 1982, the officers could buy before 1914 every firearms they wanted, but : The pistol/ revolver had to fire service cartidges! This means in time , when M79 and M83 revolvers ( socalled Reichsrevolver) it was 10,6 Deutsche Ordonnanz, and in time of Pistole 08 ( by Navy 04) it was 9mm Parabellum ( Luger). In case of Pistole 08 officers could only buy Parabellum pistols in luxury variants, or for much money a different barrel length, but in case of revolver? Larger or smaller variants, luxury variants, different grip scales, trigger guard finger hook , double action ( ordonance model was single action only), unloading mechanism ( ordonance model had a small rod in holster pocket to stick out empty cartridges). In case of sword, the officers had to buy the official model of their branch. But: A fresh created Leutnant of a commoners middleclass family bought cheap standard model, while an Oberst ( colonel) of a rich noble familiy bought a sword of official look, but with damascene blade, or blued blade with golden decoration, and goldcovered silver guard and ivory grip. The only officers weapons the different german states bought, had been the socalled , Kammerstücke' ( chamber pieces) in Standard ordonance version. They had been intended for seargeants, when acting as Offiziersstellvertreter ( doing officers tasks, when no officer is available), for example, during a peacetime officers meeting in barracks, the Offiziersstellvertreter had to observe the soldiers, that they do no nonsens, or when during officers meeting an unexpected messenger appears.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@catriona_drummond : For the reason, that English is the ,lingua franca' of Internet, i use it . I am Brittas boyfriend, 56 now,no academic, and my englisch is not the ,yellow of the egg' when it comes explain not so easy things. Hauptmann was formerly, perhaps in 14th century, not a rank in modern sense, it was simply used for the leader of a unit/ levie (Aufgebot) , no difference if this had been 20 or 150 men. And the Oberst ( colonel) was once the Oberster( highest) Hauptmann , when a number of units fought together. The Feldwebel was once the Waibel ( a kind of administration official) who did his job in field among Landsknecht mercenaries. In Switzerland officials with this title still exist as Bundes(federal)waibel or Kantons( cantonal)waibel, for ceremonies they appear with a Zweispitz/ two corne (?) hat and a coat in coat - of - arms color. During /after 30years war, a lot of german military words switched from german to french, ranks , but also a Fähnlein became a Bataillon. During napoleonic age, some german words came back. I think, the extraordinary ranks of SS was an experiment, for a Comeback of germansounding ranks.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@Jean-vr7vj : A longer time ago, my parents, born 1938 and 1942 , entered an inn in a rural village. There had been a funeral in this village and a number of persons had been there for the ,Leichenschmaus' ( don' t know english word for this german custom after a funeral). A man in the age of my parents came to the table of my parents and said: ,I want to sit to you, because you are strangers. When sitting together with the older men of the village, it is boring, they allways tell their war stories. One day, when the elder men only told , where they ,layed' ( in this case ,liegen'/ to lay is an oldfashioned term for , to be stationed at ....') i got angry and said them: No wonder, that Deutsches Reich lost the war, when you only layed arround everywhere.'
2
-
2
-
@AdmV0rl0n : Before 1914 there had been three types of armies. 1) Professional armies: As far as i know, this had been volunteers, who served 20-30 years. This had been the best trained armies, but in comparison to population, rather small. In USA there had been State Militias ( today National Guard), but i don't know about their equipment and training. In Great Brittain, as far as i know, also some semi- official militias existed. 2) Countries , in which every young man had the duty to serve in the army for some time, perhaps two years, and then they became part of the reserve, from time to time, they had to do some training again. In german language Wehrpflicht, isn' t this called conscript army? The german version of this seemed to be the best one, but only the professional officers had those wellknown quality of training, the reserve officers not so much. Also the reserve soldiers had not the knowledge of a professional soldier. And the units called Landwehr , this soldiers had been older than Reserve, had not so modern equipment. The units of Landsturm, the oldest soldiers, had in 1914 rather old equipment and also their training was not so modern. In other continental armies it was similar. 3) Militia armies. In few countries, for example Sweden or Switzerland, the young men also had the duty, to serve , but only few months. So it is doubtable, if this only rather short trained soldiers could sucessfully fight against better trained troops. ( In 1912 Wilhelm ll visited Switzerland, watched a great Manöver / training of Swiss troops , and said: The Swiss officers and soldiers seem to know their job.).
So, every system had strong and weak points.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@Soundbrigade : Austrian or German? He was born in Austria,, lived most of his life in Germany and became german citizen in 1933. An Answer is not so easy. In 1866, after being for centuries part of HRE and then German Confederation, Austria was foced to leave ,Germany' ( in 19th century socalled ,Small german solution'. In wwl allies, after wwl austrian try, to reunite with Gemany was not allowed by allied powers. Today a reunition seems no more possible, the split is too long. I, as a southern German, allied with Austria in 1866 would like a reunition, but as more you go to north in Germany, badminded jokes about Austria are growing.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@albertsmyth9616 : I, Brittas boyfriend, am from Württemberg, last württembergian king had also the name Wilhelm ll, but was a complete different man. He was no Fan of english Style , Parlamentary Monarchy ' but in 1900s he did some changes in württembergian Constitution and Administration, with which he , unwanted' caused, that Württemberg was wellprepared for democraty. He didn' t like , Royal ' Lifestyle, he prefered ,rich citizens ' Lifestyle and wore uniforms only when it was necessary for tradition. Among last german monarchs, he was the most popular Monarch ( in His own country). Hunting was a thing, he liked, so after Revolution/ Abdicstion he lived up to his death in 1923 in a Castle next to Tübingen, in his prefered hunting region , Schönbuch '. In a small Museum, i saw württembergian Wilhelm ll s hunting suit, but i don' t know, If this was original or Copy. I remember, that the Buttons/ Knöpfe of the Jacket had been Made of a Green Material, perhaps early plastic, because the King feared, Buttons Made of shining Material could frighten the Game, when there is bright shining sun.
A sidenote: I have seen a photo of prussian Wilhelm ll, on which he carried an ,overlong' Version of Hirschfänger knife. This knife type was Up to 1848 only allowed for noblemen, Professional hunters or forresty officials.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@jkkennedy9280 : Sorry , wrong button! Irish persons, when i remember right from this noted organisation, came to a german military surplus trader, Benny Spirro, and ordered a large number of M71 rifles, because the other rifles he offered had been to unmodern. Later in the Hitler era this trader got problems, he did not survive. The sending to Ireland was made by two ships. The British authorities noticed this, so they could overwhelm(?) one of those ships, and also the second ship could not give all weapons to the irish buyers. In this magazine article there was a photo of civilians with rifles. The Text was: Some of the men carry the rifle in their right shoulder, some on the left shoulder , others carry it like an umbrella under their arm, but you can see their proud faces, being the first armed irishmen since 1798. Also a Denkmal/monument(??) was shown, where one of the figurines (?) carried a M71 rifle and the other one a C96 pistol.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@thomasbecker9676 : Both Thomas and Becker ( a dialect version of Bäcker/ baker) could be german, so i was not sure, if i could write in german. Those saussages made of wild boar or a mix of wild and house pigs taste good. I personaly think, during my childhood( late 60s/early 70s ) saussage tasted better than now, so i like to try saussages, made of unusual meat ( sheep, goat, house rabbit, buffallo, ostrich, deer, roe) only one time i was dissapointed. A canadian sausage made of American Bison was of low quality..
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
German ,ch' sounds not ,k', it is a sound similar to the noise an angry cat makes, but softer and slower. Bezirk is not spoken Bizirk, the ,e' is spoken like ,e" in ,bed'. Ziel is spoken ,Tsiel', not ,Siel' , a Siel is a kind of ditch in german coast region. But this is not important for the video.
2
-
2
-
@Inflator82 : You can be translated in german as du or ihr. Du means a single person, ihr is a group of any size ( rarely used, because now a republic, to honour a ruling king, visiting Germany).So Mrs. Merkel was chancellor for four election periodes..l am Brittas boyfriend ( only using her Computer too) and a rural/ conservative/ patriotic man. From late 1970s , when i election age ,onwards i voted for CDU party, like many conservative germans. Then , then, CDU was the party for conservative democrats , conservativer than then centrist liberal FDP party and more liberal/ democratic than NPD ( founded in 1960s by former NSDAP men!). When you see and read old election posters or CDU from about 1990, both National or state elections, the then slogans/ ideas of CDU had been often similar to slogans/ ideas of current AFD. When you know this, you can which ,jump to leftwing' CDU has made under Merkel. At first i voted for her, because i didn' t knew her and thougt, she is only new head of CDU. For reason that i have Asperger Autism, it needed time for me, to notice the change, was in second election periode, when i noticed, the box painted with CDU no more contains CDU. Became angry when i realized, i was betrayed (betrogen). I am only factory worker, who knows, there are more intelligent people in Germany than me, but those Migration Idiocracy shocked me, my respect for politicians dissappeared. When a conservative/ patriotic german doesn' t want to follow his leader, you perhaps understand, what hour the bell has rung/ was die Stunde geschlagen hat- a german saying.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@Fuzz32 : I am german, in 1990s I watched in german TV an Interview with an artist from Alsace, who was an elderly man. During the Interview, the Artist told, that he in 1960s lived for half a year in London, to get artists inspiration from , Swinging London '. When he traveled to London, he spoke no english, but he learned fast. Why? He knew, english is a Mix of 1500 Years old german, and 1000 Years old french, so it was for him easy, because coming from' Alsace, He fluently spoke french and german. Believeable.
2
-
I am german of swabian tribe. Until 1950s the rural people of my homeregion didn' t knew italian food. But : For generations the people of my region know noodles, in only few variations: Very narrow fine noodles for soup, wide noodles for meat dishes and filled noodles ( Maultaschen) , which are large Ravioli or Tortellini. But most common swabian noodles, Spätzle, are different to italian Pasta, in contrast to italian pasta the dough(?) , in german Teig, is put rather fluid directly into boiling water. In late 1980s, was in my early 20s, i eat my first italian Pizza.and was a bit dissappointed: This is simply an italian Dätscher ! What is a swabian Dätscher, in other parts of swabian region known as Bätscher, Deie, Dennet...? It is basicly a small Pizza, but a bit thicker than a Pizza in center part. Instead of cheese and tomato like italian Pizza, a swabian Dätscher is covered with a mix of raw egg and fat sour cream, the dough (?)/ Teig is nearly the same. Showed such a Dätscher to an italian coworker, he was only surprised about unknown egg/ cream cover, not about look and taste .
Now, that swabian people know some food similar to italian food can be simply a coincidence. Other posibility: From 1190s to 1260s swabian Hohenstaufen dynasty ( ending 1268).had been also Kings of Naples. Btw., Hohenstaufen dynasty is in Italy perhaps better known as Ghibbelines ( die Waiblinger).
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@TE4358g : Many english words contain a ,wh' , so accidently writing wher instead of wehr is understandable. I am german, Brittas boyfriend ( using her Computer too), i write comments either in german or english ( et très rare en francais), but sometimes the Computer doesn' t recognize the language, with strange results- similar, but wrong words appear. In case of Wehr, die Wehr is a dated word for weapon, especially a bladed one ( so the military context , also Feuerwehr/ firebrigade) and sich wehren means to defend yourself. But das Wehr is somethng quite different. A kind of small dyke with a small door, to open or close a small waterway for using water power. In german language the change of der, die or das sometimes changes the meaning of a word, can't explain this phenomeon.
2
-
2
-
@m0-m0597 : Compared to europeans from middle or north europe, the europeans from southern europe have a darker skin tone. Some of them have a skin tone like people from current north africa or eastern mediteranean region. So i think, that the former egyptians had a similar skin than current egyptians. Most had surely a ,brown' skin tone, darker than southern europeans, which are white, but much lighter than people from real , black' part of Africa. But: Some of ,old' egyptians had ancestors either from southern Europe or from Africa south of Sahara, which means, a part of former egyptians of pharaonic era had been white or black persons. They had been regular egyptian citizens, but both white and black egyptians had been not the majority. Here in Germany, i am german, you can see ethnic germans, which have a skin and hair colour like Italians or Spaniards from the far south of Europe. They are either descendants of Romans ( south of Germany and areas west of Rhine had been Roman Empire), or descendants of mercenaries of ,Thirty Years War', or descendants of italian/ french artists or craftsmen comming to Germany in Renaissance or Baroque era. So there allways had been persons, don' t looking like majority.
2
-
Conservative Agnostic : This story is doubtfull. I am german, and i think, i am fluent in german language, even i speak swabian dialect, but no Standard German in dayly life. When non germans claim to speak the german language fluently, this simply means that they speak german with no word or grammar error/mistake. But most foreigners have a foreign accent! Many germans have a problem with the english ,th' sound and speak it as ,s' or ,t', but english native speakers often have a problem with the german ,ch' sound and speak it ,k' ( french native speakers often speak this sound ,sch'). US citizens, even with german ancestors, mostly have an US/ american accent. Not long ago i (german) watched an old german 60s movie, in which the story played/ happened in Great Brittain. I was astonished, that one actor had a british accent, it was Sir Christopher Lee speaking german with his own voice. Also in the 1930s/40s Standard German was not as common as it is today, most german people in those days spoke their local dialect. So i think, in those days it was not so easy to fool a german with german language. I speak swabian dialect, which has the same roots like swiss german, and in Vienna an austrian man thougt, i am swiss, so i perhaps can fool non german speakers, being swiss ( i also speak few french), but i think it is impossible to fool a swiss person.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@dpeasehead : In my country, Germany, after reformation in 16th century, there had been for decades some tensions/quarrels between the protestantic and the catholic states. In 1618 a violent event in Bohemia, in those days a part of Germany, escalated to a war. It was rather long, many parts of Germany had been involved, but it was an ,average' innergerman war ( the last one was 1866). In 1630 the war was basicly over with a victory of the imperial / catholic side. But now France and Sweden intervented with troops, the war lasted until 1648. Most parts of Germany had been destroyed, and diseases, hunger and the fury of war killed 30% of german population, in some regions nearly 90%. And Germany had up to early 18th century problems with rebuilding. So the intervention of foreign armies into a german civil war caused the greatest destruction of my country, not ww ll.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Just Your Friendly Neighborhood Chaplain : Thats true, but not new in 20th century. I am german and i do not know what you know about the most destructive war for my country, the Thirty Years War 1618-1648. When the war started, the soldiers used peacetime made armor of good quality. The footmans armor was cheaper, like light cavaly armor but heavy cavalry armor was expensive, the breastplate could protect against muskets ( musket fire distance) and pistols(pistol fire distance) and good helmets could protect against pistols. But the armies soon became larger than in 16 th century, so that it was impossible, to equip every man with armor. As longer the war lasted, the quality became worser. The craftsmen had o produce masses of armor and wartime production is not as good as peacetime production. In this war a third(!) of the population of germany died, and of course, like at the end of WWll economy, food production was destroyed, so that untrained crraftsmen with bad tools , lack of steel and with bad quality materials made crap armor. It was not only the change of weaponry and tactics which stopped using armor, with the exeption of cuirassiers and some sappers in sieges.
2
-
2
-
@zefft.f4010 : From 1815- 1866 the German Federation existed, including Luxemburg, Liechtenstein and the german part of Austria. This federation consisted of about 36 independent states at the start, later fewer for historical reason. The federation army consisted of 300000 men, plus the Reservedivision ( about 12000 men). Every state had to send a contingent of 1% of population. So the coningent size varied from 90000 men of german austria, 80000 men of german prussia ( the parts of prussia and austria with no or few germans had not been in German Federation) at one end, and 180 men of Hohenzollern- Hechingen and 55 men of Liechtenstein. So only Prussia, Austria, and to a lower degree, Bavaria,Saxony, Württemberg, Hannover and some greatdukes could field usefull troops. The contingents of the dukes, princes and free towns had only low training and equipment. So Prussia realy had the best army in the german language countries. After 1866 Austria, Luxemburg and Liechtenstein ( Army disbanding 1867) left Germany and the remainng german Staates adopted prussian army training. In 1648 Switzerland left Germany, during an offical visit in 1912 Wilhelm ll watched swiss ( militia) soldiers and said to Swiss Gouvernement: Your soldiers are well trained.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@hansulrichboning8551 : I, Brittas boyfriend, am a nostalgic. I also would prefer parlamentary monarchy over a democracy, where the head of state is elected not by by the ,free citizens', but by ,electors/Kurfürsten ' like in HRE days. Difference? Bundesversammlung has 1200 members, Kurfürstenkollegium had seven , after Thirty Years War nine members. When democraty, then Switzerland must be watched, for my understanding, i have Asperger disorder, Switzerland has knowledge of democraty for more than five centuries.
2
-
2
-
2
-
I am a bit sceptic. For producing raw iron , you need Erz/ ore? and a lot of coal, either wood coal or stone coal. I don' t know, if there is stone coal in Iceland, so in later Viking era, woodcoal was necessary. When first Viking settlers came to Iceland, there had been here and there forrests, mostly Birken/birch?. But what i have read, the trees had been cut in a rather short time, and then wood became rare and expensive. Up to 1940s many rural Icelanders lived in houses dug into hills, the front wall made of stones, the roof made of expensive timbers, imported or swimming on sea ( Schwemmholz), covered with earth, so gras grow on roof. If there where arroud 1000 so much remaining trees for making woodcoal for raw Iron production and blacksmiths fires?
2
-
2
-
For armour, you need metalls? Modern ,bulletpdoof' armour is made of high quality ,plastic' fibres , strengthened with ceramic plates. In pre wwl and wwl era there had been armour made of silk and other cloth/ textile, as far as i know, rich indian noblemen used thick silk vests for centuries. In middlrage europe padded ,Gambeston' , made of cloth was used, and on some ,South Sea' Islands padded armour made of Coconut fibres was used.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
I am Brittas boyfriend, german , no accademic, and 59. I live in an area full of medieval Castle ruins, celtic oppidae , roman Villae rustica, Roman forts, fortified border between lmperium.Romanum and Germania Magna, relicts of town fortifications. And i live in those Part of Germany, which was in HRE time split into dozens of those fairytale microstates. After 50years of being a History nerd, i simply can shake my head .
One example, size of castles. Im movies, especially this Fantasy nonsens, the castles are gigantic. But in reallity the castles ruins of my homeregion are between small and tiny.. But: The smallest Natural obstacle was used for defence. Hills, small glens of creeks (?) / Bäche, unbelieveable positions on rocks, at ends of plateaus....
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@trevorochmonek833 : Ever heared of ,sich ergeben '?.After Thirty- Years War , in Baroque era, especially when ,sun king' Louis XIV ruled, everything had to be french, so many french words came into german military language. The Oberst/ Obrist ( oberster Feldhauptmann) became a Colonel, the Hauptmann ( Main man/ head man) a Capitain , a Feldwebel ( Swiss Feldweibel is more correct) a Sergeant, a Fähnlein became a Compagnie ( or Battaillon- battle, battaile?), and the Zimmerleute Sappeurs, and so on. Changed after 1815 slightly to german words again.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@doctordoggo8604 : Not wrong, but not totally true. Some higher rank men of SA wanted a compromise. Those wanted that Reichswehr, somehow extended, became professional core of German Armed Forces, while SA becomes the Reserve Force Milita. At first SA was armed wing of NSDAP party, to fight against armed wings of other political parties ( for example communist KPD had Roter Frontkämpferbund), to fight police or officials, to frighten/ scare persons, parties , organisarions with different ideas. And: At first some SA members joined SA because they liked the ideology, others joined the SA , because it was organisarion of conservative fellow wwl Veteran. In 1920s there had been many SA members, who had been no members of the polical party..
2
-
@dogmosatchmo : When in 1815 the German Federation / Deutscher Bund was founded, three foreign kings had been Bundesfürsten/ Federation princes: The british king as king of Hannover, the dutch king as Great Duke of Luxemburg, and the danish king as Duke of Holstein and Lauenburg. In 1839 Victoria became Queen of Great Britain, but by law a woman was not allowed as ruler in Hannover , so the head of a sidebranch Hannover- Cumberland became king of Hannover as Georg l, in 1866 his son Georg ll lost his country. If Hannover would have been ruled by Victoria, Bismarck would have had a problem. The german Jägerbüchse/ huntsmans rifle is basicly the ancestor of Pennsylvania rifle, it was taken to America by ,german' immigrants and adapted to America, smaller Bord, but longer barrel to safe lead and gunpowder. The german Landkreis Esslingen ( county? Arrondissement?) i live , was once divided: Most of the territory was once Duchy Württemberg, the smaller part was Reichsstadt ( imperial town) Esslingen and three villages had been owned by Reichsritter ( imperial knights).
2
-
@dogmosatchmo : I am not Britta herself, but her boyfriend, i am no academic, only trained worker . At a Kindergarten daytrip, visiting the Bärenhöhle/ bear cave ( Höhle and hole seem to have the same root) and nearby Lichtenstein castle in 1970 was the start for my history hobby, I have read many books and magazines, i visited lots of military and civilian museums, palaces and historic towns and sites. My homeregion is full of this, celtic ,roman and and allemanic relicts, medieval castles and monastries , Renaissance fortresses ( and castle, monastries and fortress ruins). Also i took part at the historical daytrips of a small historical society. The tour guides had been book authors, former museum directors , etc. and in one case a real Princess. With this society i could visit buildings, usually closed to ordinary tourists. So after five decades, i have got some knowledge.
2
-
2
-
@Rusty Shackleford : In Switzerland about 65% speak german, about 25% french, about 9% italian and perhaps 1% ,Rhaetoromanisch' ( don't know the english name) this is a mix of Latin and a language of people living there before both romans and germanics.
I do ,Square Dance' ( no joke, but only mainstream level), at such an event i noticed a lady with the name ,Beatrice Dupont' and spoke french to her, she smiled and said, she has the french family name from her ancestors, which left France in 17th century.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Untrue Lie : Genau! Wir lachten, als er Käsar sagte, aber der alte Geschichtslehrer meinte, diese Aussprache könnte stimmen , da Kaiser von Caesar kommt, sowie auch der russische Zar. Ich weiss dies also schon lange, sage aber wie die meisten deutschsprachigen Leute ,Zäsar' Nicht deutschsprachige Personen wissen evtl. nicht, daß ,c' in der deutschen Sprache manchmal k, manchmal z gesprochen wird, daher erwähnte ich dies.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@TheEvertw : There are sometimes defenceable storage/ administration buildings. When i , german, perhaps 15 years ago visited Vienna, i visited , Heeresgeschichtliches Museum'/ museum of armed forces history. The museum is in a building of former Vienna Arsenal, and other buildings, used for other purposes, also exist. The complex of former Arsenal buildings is not a fortress, there is no Umwallung (don't know correct english word), but from air/ sky perspective , the Arsenal complex has similarities to an older fortress. The buildings have strong walls , gunports/ Schießscharten and along the roofs are crenelated walls. So, manned with soldiers, some machineguns, sandbag walls and barbed wire a light fortification.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@theblackhand6485 : When you read ,die Wehr' ( das Wehr is something quite different) , mit blanker Wehr', ,die Seitenwehr' ( sidearm, can be pistol or sword) in older texts, then it means a mostly bladed weapon. In case of Wehrmacht, Reichswehr, Bundeswehr or Feuerwehr ( fire brigade) it means a trained unit, which defends against enemies or fire. Btw., i am german.
2
-
2
-
2
-
@LuisAldamiz : I don' t habe such fine ancestry, my ancestors had been farmers, craftsmen, workers, hands and poor traveling traders (pedlars?). From non german ancestors/ relatives i don' t know, what doesn' t means, that the they don't exist. I am german, but i don' t look, as foreigners think, how a german man looks. I am not tall and have black hair ( becoming grey now). But here in Germany you not so rare can see german people (who are german for generations), whos skin is a bit darker than average germans, like italian, spanish, or southern french persons. This germans can be descendents of old romans or spanish / italian mercenaries from 30 years war (1618-1648). A sidenote: In Spain the name Diaz is popular, in my swabian region the name Die(t)z.
2
-
@LuisAldamiz : When i was at Gymnasium ( is in Germany the ,highest' school, which prepares the pupils for university) , but only for six years, there was a girl in my class, which had a ,von' in her name, which is usualy a sign of nobility. But there are also non nobles with a von ( which simply means ,comming from....) and some noblemen have no von in their name.
Sometimes i ,with my girlfriend Britta, take part at historical daytrips of a small historical society. During this trips i could see the castles of lower noblemen/ Freiherren ( with the owners as guides!). I also saw members of High nobility, the prince of Hohenlohe- Langenburg ( who was guest at Pricne Phillips funeral), one historical trip was guided by princess ,von Löwenstein- Wertheim-.... and a member of House of Württemberg. Today younger noblemen, even in High nobility, are often married with non noble wifes.
The name Die(t)z, Ditz, or Dieter are common ,shorts' of Diet(e)rich. But some spanish names, not coming from Bible context, have germanic origin, Rodrigo is in german ( today rare) Roderich. In Italy it is more visible ( Carlo, Federico, Ildebrando...) , as far as i know , even my german first name Werner exists in romanic as Garnier, Varnier, Guernard, Guernario etc..
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
Firearms appear in cavallry in 1520s as wheellock pistols. I am german, Brittas boyfriend, and born 1965. As far as i know, in 1520s the Lanzierer ( Gendarmes/ men at arms) simply added one or two pistols to be modernized. But the Kürisser ( cuirassiers) , a new created category of heavy cavallry , used 3/4 armour and two or more pistols and used ,caracole'' tactic. This meant ,they attacked in rolling salvo tactic, similar to tactic of rowed mediterranean warships. At this time, carbines had been rare, but as longer as 16th century lasted semiarmoured ,light' cavallry appeared and Dragoner ( dragoons) appeared as mounted infantry with badest riding horses.
In 18th century , there came a switch. Armour was nearly out of use, cuirassiers used still cuirass (often only breastplate) and a leathervest, the head was rarely protected by a helmet, but more wore a hardened hat , strengthened with sheetmetal and thick wires. This caused a change in pistols. The caliber/ bore was enlarged for logistics reason, the Barrels became shorter with thinner walls, and Powder Charge was reduced, so armour Penetration was reduced. In 18th century HRE , i am german, the Dragoner had been used often as heavy cavallry , second Attack Wave, their armament was heavy cavallry sword, often only one pistol, Not the usual pair ( in german Paar), and a Dragonergewehr, a slightly shortened musket, for the case of fighting as infantry. Prussian King Frederik ll wrote: Don't forgett infantry Training of Dragoner! They are mostly used mounted, so the Training must Not have quality of line infantry. In 18th century heavy cavallry used only few carbines, carbines had been used by cuirassiers, lancers, Gendarmes in small Numbers, mostly only for guard duties. But light cavallry, Hussaren/ hussars had mostly a carbine. Why? In Germany a ,Husarenstück' ( outdated) is a heroic adventure , like the events modern Elite/ Commando troops. So the hussars did a lot of Things in ,small war' , where they had to be on foot, so for them the carbine was important. In 18th century HRE lancers had been rare, May be few units formed by hungarian/ polish mercennaries.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@aarongreer7621 : I, Brittas boyfriend, am no expert in this topic, only interessted in weapons/ military history, since i have seen a ( fairytale) castle during a Kindergarten trip in 1971. ln 9th to 10/11th century the swords based on roman spatha had been , as far as i know, the most used sword type in ,germanic' countries, in ,romanic' or ,slavic' countries i don' t know. So i think the main reason for the disappearing of spathalike swords was simply the evolution of weapons, armour and warfare, which allways causes changes in equipment. What also could be a reason, in Germany/HRE, was the fact, that armies for larger campaigns also in most german regions, with some exeptions in swiss or frisian regions, switched from classical tribal levies ( Stammesaufgebot), see Culloden 1746 , to armies of mounted Knights with their retinue , Lehensmänner ( don' t know english word) and only some picked men on foot, so the need for long bladed swords declined. Also in year 1000 a process slowly started, which caused, that in 1525, the year of Bauernkrieg, the greatest farmers rebellion in Germany, only few farmers had been freemen, most had been unfree men. And in medieval Germany, still in old germanic tradition, only free or semifree men could own weapons. In medieval time also the seax came out of use in Germany, but the Bauernwehr noted in 15th/ 16th century ( you may have heared of Langes Messer in HEMA circles) can be a descendant of seax, or the billhook . In german language no everywhere used word for this tool exists, only different dialect words. When it is true, in some regions of Switzerland ( or Black Forrest?) the billhook is called Seisle , in standard german Sächslein'- little seax.
2
-
2
-
2
-
@margoolf9567 : Sie vergessen bei ihrer Aussage aber folgendes: In Großstädten ist trotz üblicherweise strengerer Waffengesetzgebung die Kriminalität üblicherweise höher als in ländlichen Gegenden.. Zweitens : Die US Waffengesetzgebung, was soll das sein? Die gibt es nicht. Was es gibt, ist ein Flickenteppich aus Bundesgesetzen, Gesetzen der einzelnen Bundesstaaten, Countries und Gemeinden.. Wenn zwischen zwei Siedlungen eine Grenze liegt, können die Gesetze arg unterschiedlich sein. Auch vergessen sie folgendes: Die USA sind viel größer als Deutschland. Üblicherweise hat jede eigenständige Gemeinde ihre eigene Polizei, das bedeutet, jeder Ort hat ein Police Departement von einem bis knapp 40000 Beamten. Wenn nun in einer abgelegenen Gegend der Polizist, in ländlichen Gegenden sind Ein Mann Streifen verbreitet, erscheint, sind oft Stunden vergangen, sodaß hier eine Bewaffnung verständlich ist.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@I HATE YOU- : The german name for France is Frankreich ( realm of the frankish tribe). The german tribe of Franken is still alive, they are living in german states Hessen, Saarland, Rheinland- Pfalz, southern Nordrhein- Westfalen, northern Baden- Württemberg , Bayern also Luxemburg. In the years of Karl dem Großen/ Charlemagne , the Frankish Empire was on its height. In 843 the frankish empire was split in three parts: West ( nowadays France), East ( nowadays Germany, Austria, Switzerland) and Middle ( Nowadays Netherlands, Belgium,Luxemburg, Rhone valley in France and northern Italy). By the time, the frankish upperclass in today French and Italian regions also used the latinbased languages of lower classes and could no more understand germanic.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@nzs316 : What i know about my grandfathers and greatgrandfathers in wwl or wwll, they had been ordinary enlisted men. In private life they had been owners of ( for my homeregion typical) small farms. But those farms had been for historical reasons so small, that this was not enough for life. So they also worked also as factoryworkers, craftsmen ... They had been everything, but nothing full, and mostly poor. I only know that the husband of my ( fatherly) grandmothers sister was Feldwebel/ Sergeant, i saw his Iron Cross second class, Close Quartier Combat badge in silver , the Moscow medal and a badge, that he worked in building the Westwall ( he was in service of Railway, repairing wagons) . A relative of the noted grandmother was Hauptmann/ Captain, but my father told me , he became Hauptmann with a lot of tricks. My fathers grandfather got a collarpin showing a Swastika with a ,Weizenähre' ( the piece of wheatplant, with the ,corn'?). He got this from agricultural service, because he was the ,Bull warden' of my village
2
-
2
-
@stijnVDA1994 : I am not Britta herself, but her boyfriend and 55 now. When i was a child, many midaged rural men owned a,singleshot rifle in . 22 LR or 6mm Flobert to shoot rats. In current days, gun owners in Germany have a problem with new gunlaw of European Union. One problem is that german gouvernement allways tries to make Weapon/ Gunlaw as hard as possible, so they add things to European Union gunlaw, which are not intended to European Union gunlaw. In case of Airsoft ,weapons(?)' we in Germany can buy copies of full auto firearms, but even in as weapons not useable Airsoft ,weapons', full auto is not allowed here. I am no gunowner, i am only interessted in historical weapons shown in museums, castles/palaces, but i don' t believe that our current german law, about weapons really protects someone of being a victim of crime.
2
-
Dan Nick : Not fully true. Ethiopia was a feudal state. This means: In peacetime the emperor, the princes ,Ras' and important noblemen had only bodyguards, the emperor perhaps a small guard/ household unit. In wartime both the emperor and the princes mobilzed their noble vassals, and they mobilized their nonnoble vassals. So the ethiopian ,army' was in fact a union of noble or tribal levies. Some warriors stil came with spears and shield (20%) or muzzle loaders (20%), but nearly 60% had all kind of breechloaders ( military and civilian, rifle and shotgun, singleshot and repeating). But many of these breechloader had not been the own arms of the warriors, but the weapons given by their lord. Different thing than your law. But in such feudal levy armies there is allways the problem of loyalty between the emperor and the princes, between the emperor / princes and the noblemen, and tensions between the leaders of the same rank. Those loyalty problems and tensions/ quarrels between the leaders had been the reason for many lost battles in medieval time.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@Second Chance : The noted assasination attempt showed later a problem in guarding the Emperor. In those days at Imperial Main Palace the outer end of palace area was guarded by policemen, the building by soldiers. But there was a medical doctor, who was coincidently next to the location, where the farmer fired his shotgun, he did some first aid and escorted the emperor back to palace in emperors coach. The doctor could pass without problems the policemen and the soldiers. But in the emperors private rooms, a there serving ,Leibgendarm' pointed at the doctor: Who is this man? He doesn' t belong to Imperial court! The Leibgendarm was correct, for him the unknown stranger could be a danger for the Emperor. Those ,Leibgendarmen' , wearing a police ( Gendarmerie) uniform and a Metall helmet of cuirassiers, are often misinterpreted as bodyguards, but their job was only to escort the emperor and being the messenger, if he wanted something.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@AAArnold : Please calm down! It is true, that Ian likes french weapons and has visited France several times. In some oft bis videos he says, that he can not really speak german . So i think, his french is better than his german. Before i come to the Gebirgsjäger, something in general. What is english language? Very simplyfied: A mix of normanic french (french with viking influence) and a very old version of low german (A region in the state Schleswig-Holstein is still called Angeln, and the state Niedersachsen has its name from the saxons). So theoretically it should be no problem for an english speaker to learn both French and german. Jäger means huntsman vor light infantryman, the first units in early 18th century had been really professional hunters and forrest officals. When WWl started, the german army had no mountain troops. In the Vosges/Vogesen, not in the Alps, the german mountain troops began to exist, when german Jäger soldiers noticed, that the french ,Chasseurs Alpines' hat been better equipped and trained for mountain warfare. Two years ago i took part in a guided tour to the Hartmannsweiler Kopf, a mountain in the vosges, wäre you still can see the trenches, especially the german ones. The guide was the director of the ,Wehrgeschichtliches Museum Rastatt' himself.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
As far as i, german, Brittas boyfriend, know, the Norwegian man who realy existed had the name Haakon and was a socalled Jarl. Here in Germany there are movies, showing the years between 1933 and 1945 as good for Germany. But in movies, where the story plays between about 1848 and 1945, to many Charakters appear with a behaviour of current people, not with behaviour of people of the shown era. This is the reason, why i have many doubts when watching such , historical movies' about german history. And for years i no more watch movies about medieval era, to much nonsens.
2
-
2
-
@aidanfarnan4683 : This autocorrection thing is also a problem for me, when i want to write when it writes ,Wien' ( Vienna), when i want to write of it writes ,oft'(often) or when i want to write or it writes vor (before), etc.. The family name Schull can be german, names like Scholl or Schill exist, by i know nobody with this name. But we have in Germany names, which are popular everywhere in Germany, but also uncommon names, or such ones, which you find only in some regions.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
When a war ,or a regime ends, in every part of the world documents are burnt, or destroyed in other ways. There are still now lots of bags with shreddered documents of ,Stasi' ( Staatssicherheit) , red painted ,Gestapo' of former communist East Germany. But when Allied troops , in case of my homeregion US forces, occupied Germany, they confiscated not only official documents, but also private documents or archieves, the reason, why many societies/ Clubs, i don' t know how to translate ,Verein' correctly, for example the , Club of rabbit breeders' have rather few documents from before 1947.
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@BelosnezhkaSnezhka : The problem is, that here in western part of Germany, the Wisent was extinct for many centuries. Now the animals are here again, the ,anomal protectors' are happy, and other people have damage. This conflict must be solved. It is the same thing with wolves. The cattle and sheep owners must spend a lot of money for special fences and dogs, which is expensive for the owners of only few cows or sheeps. I come from the country, my father stoped farming 20 Yeats ago, so i know, how much work and few money you have , i can understand non animal protectors, when they are angry, because they have more work and costs but earn fewer. There must be a solution.
1
-
@macnutz4206 : Your comment clearly shows, that you know nothing about german thoughts about service weapons and ,honourable' weapons. In 19th century most policemen in the different german states had only a saber as weapon. In rural areas the Gendarmen/ Landjäger had sometimes muskets/ rifled muskets and bayonnet, or when mounted, a carbine or a pistol, because, similar to current italian Carabinieri or french Gendarmes, they had been officially soldiers, doing police work. Policemen of towns, or sometimes rich villages, usually had no firearms. And the lowest level of german policemen ( town/ village payed nightwatchmen, town cryers or field guards) had often only a baton or in case of nightwatchmen, a polearm (!). In late 1820s up to 1840s some of the small german states bought few muzzleloader side by side shotguns, given to policemen only for fighting smugglers, poachers or escorting transports of prisoners. What happened with this shotguns after 1871, i don' t know. If you are US citizen, you know Wild West novels or in more modern times, movies. German/ Austrian ( to loser degree Swiss) counterpart are Poacher and Forrest Official novels ( or movies from early 1950s to early 1970s). In this 19th century novels, for example by bavarian writer Ludwig Ganghofer, the heroic Forrest officials ( Förster) had been armed with rifles, shotguns had been the weapons of poachers, woodthieves or smugglers. Also boarder guards ( customs officers/ Zollbeamte in current german) had been armed with sabers and carbines, but not with shotguns ( the outdated singleshot rifles of german border guards/ customs officers had been in 1913 replaced by Pistole 08 /Luger). So in imperial Germany shotguns had not been service firearms of armed forces of german civilian administration. Also shotguns had been no part of weaponry of german armies. ( Yes, there had been four german armies : Prussian Army including the troops of grandduchies, duchies, principalities and free towns, Bavarian Army ,only in wartime under prussian command, Saxon army and Württembergian Army, the smallest, only one corps). In wwl shotguns : a) had not been used as german service weapons. b) had been seen by most germans as ,unhonourous' criminals weapon, a psychological thing you perhaps underestimate. There are photos of german soldiers of wwl with side by side shotguns, but showing them hunting and presenting shot game. May be for additional food (german soldiers of wwl had mostly a lack of food, the theater comedy ,Der Etappenhase/ The rearline hare' shows this). After wwl for Versailles treaty reason, remaining small ,Reichwehr' had few ammunition, but a lot of time. A german inventor named Becker showed his semiautomatic/ revolving shotgun in 1920s german army testing soldiers/ officers: Please do a test, when my shotgun is tested by officers, it is good for my reputation. German officers did a ,military' test and told Mr. Becker: Good weapon, but german army needs no shotguns. Even today, only very few shotguns are used by german police ,SWAT teams' and military special forces, and it is for german policemen or soldiers STRICTLY forbidden to fire a shotgun at persons. I hope, that you now understand something!
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@AlexKS1992 : You are simply lyars. The Lusitania had ammunition on board, that ,unloaded' was written in freight papers ,was only for US Harbor Regulations , that when loaded ammunition was loaded, unloaded' must be wrritten for neutrality reason. But in case of neutrality, USA lyed, they said armed german freighters are warships, but armed british freighters are civilan ships, who needed cannons against german U- Boote, but USA said nothing against british Q- ships who tricked german U- Boot crews attacking with rules of prisal order. Be quiet and ask american and hawaian natives about their thought of moralic USA. Also what gave you the right to steal mexican territory in 1840s? Texas was regular mexican territory . And which right had american settlers in 1892 to overthrow hawaiian monarchy?
1
-
1
-
@thescatologistcopromancer3936 : WW l was for years in the air. There was after Napoleonic Periode an unknown rise or Nationalim, Chauvinism, Militarism which caused hate among european nations, the Colonialism gave more oil into fire, the Sarajevo assassination was simply the fire on gunpowder barrel match ( Lunte). Would not say , that Germany caused WWl, there had been diplomatic alliances, treaties etc., and the noted ,isms' which made policy difficult, when a great war is for years in the air. If in 1914 better quality diplomacy could have stopped outbreak of wwl, the next political crisis could have been start a war. But: As German i have to admitt, that german Gouvernement was not good, both in acting persons, and in organisation. My point was: Allways Germany since 1870 is portraited as militaristic, but, how many times HRE or German Federation declared war against foreign countries?.When Germany before 1870 was so powefull, how could the poor french could steal Alsace and Lorraine? How could in second half of Thirty Years french and swedish troops do so much destruction in HRE? This, is in non german movies never shown - everything has a historical reason, and i am simply annoyed of those warmovies.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@juliettsolit7918 : Das ist Unfug. Die Uniformen waren bei Mannschaften , bis zu den Feldwebeln , wurde die Ausstattung staatlich beschafft, das heißt, die Uniformen wurden in verschiedenen Größen beschafft. Es war allerdings möglich , daß sich bessergestellte Soldaten ihre Uniformen und Stiefel selbst beschafften, das war erlaubt. Da damals Kleidung oft noch handwerklich gefertigt wurde, sind maßgeschneiderte Uniformen in solchen Fällen verbreitet. Offiziere mußten sich ihre Ausstattung grundsätzlich selbst besorgen. Diejenigen, die aus höheren Schichten stammten, hatten selbstverständlich maßgeschneiderte Uniformen,oder auch höhere Ränge, aber ein frischgebackener Leutnant aus wenig wohlhabenden Kreisen, war bei seiner Erstuniform möglicherweise auf einfach gefertigte Uniformen angewiesen. Bei selbstbezahlten Uniformen war dann aber auch mehr Luxus, etwa weicheres Stiefelleder erlaubt. Zur Bewaffnung: Mannschaften erhielten ihre Waffen vom Staat, Offiziere mußten Pistole und Degen selbst besorgen. Auch hier war es erlaubt, statt der Standardausführung prächtigere Versionen zu kaufen, etwa Degen mit gebläuten oder gravierten Klingen, oder vergoldeten Griffbeschlägen. Eine Ausnahme gab es lediglich bei einigen Feldwebeln. Für diejenigen, die bei bestimmten Zeiten/ Anlässen als Offiziersstellvertreter galten, wurden einige Offiziersdegen staatlich angeschafft, und bei Dienst als Offiziersstellvertreter kurzzeitig ausgehändigt, damit die einfachen Soldaten die zeitweilige Offiziersbefugnis erkennen sollten.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@atlas567 : The man meant, his father , being of german ancestry, was in Mexico mistaken for a native Mexican, because he doesn' t looks ,german'. In fact, i am german, there are some ethnic Germans who look a bit like Italians or Spainiards from the north of this countries.I think this are the descendants of Italians, French, Spanish or Croats coming to Germany as mercennaries during Thirty Years War , or as specialised craftsmen from Middleage to Rokoko era.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Excuse me, wrong Button! This name is a shortened Diet(e)rich, and it is spoken as a swabian would speak spanish Diaz. Surely coincidence. But don' t underestimate the number of italian craftsmen who came to current Germany when large stonechurches came in favour, or when Renaissance and Baroque reached Germany. Many ruling noblemen, we had Lots of them, wanted new palaces, spiritual Lords ( Princed Bishops, Princed Abbots, in few cases even Princed female Abbots, and the Knights Orders wanted new churches, often also palaces, and even the rich upperclass of Imperial Towns build rather impressive Palais. Then after Thirty Years War many French Protestants came to Germany , not to far away from my Homevillage is a Village with typical german name Perouse! And as a sidenote : I grew up in a then semirural area, as child of aborigine farmers. In those days, i didn' t knew italian food, my parents also not. But i knew traditional swabian food. So i was rather surprised, when i in 1980 for the first time ate Tortellini and Ravioli, was only a tiny Variation of swabian Maultaschen. Italian Pizza? A Variation of swabian Dätscher ( name used in my Village, different in other villages) and italian Pasta? A lot of more complicated versions of the , breite Nudeln' i knew from my mother. A possible reason that the noted italian dishes had been no surprise for me: From 1190s to 1268 swabian Hohenstaufen Dynasty had also been Kings of Naples.
1
-
@johnnyearp52 : With a genetic test (DNA) specuations could be proofed. But the fact , that in Spain and Italy germanic tribes had been for some time, and later Germans (including Austrians, which belonged up to 1866 regular to HRE/ German Federation) and Normans ( Nordmänner/ Northmen, romanized Vikings) ruled parts of Italy. So i think, germanic DNA, if such is existing , could appear in Spain or Italy. But : When germanic tribes conquered Italy or Spain, they became the upper class/ Nobility. So i would not be surprised, when in Spain , Italy, May be Portugal and France too, among old Nobility families, the germanic DNA part is a bit Higher than among commoners.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@ChauncyFatsack : Up to 1900/1920s French was the , Lingua Franca' in diplomacy etc.because from late 17th century to early 19th century France was seen as the strongest european country, in islamic world persian had a similar respect. In 19th century Great Britain became the strongest power, english language became more impotant, and after wwl the english speaking nations USA and Great Brittain had been the mightiest powers , so English replaced French. And perhaps in 50years Chinese replaces English. Now to the Kaiser. The rank Kaiser, Czar, Tenno, Shah in Shah, Negus Negest ... formerly used in Germany, Austria, Russia, Iran, Ethiopia, China, Brazil, Turkey and still in Japan is higher than a king. Up to 1806 in HRE the emperors had been Roman Emperors, in the first centuries they had been only german kings and got the rank Kaiser in Rome by the Pope. After 1806 the austrian emperors called them emperors, because in HRE era, for many centuries the emperors had been men of Habsburg family. In 1871 the rank , Deutscher Kaiser" was New created, for tradition and AS sign for the highest german monarch ( there had been also kings of Bavaria, Saxony and Württemberg). Napoleon l and his nephew Napoleon lll called them emperors, because after French Revolution king was not liked, and Napoleon l saw himself as the highest european ruler, mightier than all european kings. In early 16th century the Greatprince of Moscow called himself Czar, because he was the mightiest russian Greatprince, and also married with the granddaughter(?) of last Eastern Rome/ Byzantine Emperor. The Chinese Emperor was for centuries one of the mightiest rulers on earth, but why the iranian, ethiopian and persian rulers are called emperor i don't know. So: Emperor is in rank higher than King. Mostly the language of the mightiest country becomes Lingua Franca, this can last for centuries or not. Don' t ask an Autist/ Asperger person. Don' t be too proud of speaking english, je aussi parle un peu de français ( ne pas tres bon) und als Deutscher selbstverständlich auch Deutsch.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@I3shob : Ich, Brittas Freund, bin jetzt 56 Jahre alt, und kann mich noch an waffenrechtlich liberalere Zeiten erinnern. Und ich kann mich ebenfalls erinnern, daß das Sicherheitsgefühl damals höher war. Zum Vergleich der Wirksamkeit von Waffengesetzen eignet sich der deutschsprachige Raum sehr gut. Deutschland, Österreich und die Schweiz gehören zum gleichen Kulturraum, sind wohlhabende Industrieländer und Demokratien mit mehr oder weniger föderalem Aufbau. Seit 1997 bzw. 1999 sind auch die Gesetze unserer südlichen Nachbarn verschärft worden, aber immer noch gilt: Das deutsche Waffenrecht ist das strengste, das der Schweiz das liberalste. Seltsamerweise ist aber die Kriminalität in Österreich und der Schweiz etwas geringer als bei uns. Auch in Großbritannien wurde nach dem Dunblane Massenmord das seit den 1920er Jahren eh strenge Waffenrecht deutlich verschärft ( es ist für Briten praktisch unmöglich, irgend einen Gegenstand zur Verteidigung mitzuführen), trotzdem gab es einen deutlichen Anstieg von Gewalt . Auch sind sie über die Gesetzgebung der USA schlecht informiert. Genausowenig, wie es eine ,amerikanische Polizei' gibt, gibt es ein ,amerikanisches Waffengesetz'. Es gibt einige staatliche Vorgaben, die Details werden dagegen von den Bundesstaaten, sowie den Counties und Gemeinden festgelegt, wobei die Vorschriften der höheren Verwaltungsebene beachtet werden müssen. Das bedeutet, das US Waffenrecht ist ein arger Flickenteppich und in einigen Großstädten durchaus so wie bei uns. Auch kann nicht jeder US Bürger einfach so eine Waffe mitführen, im allgemeinen ist eine CCW Lizenz , also im deutschen Sprachgebrauch Waffenschein ( nicht Waffenbesitzkarte !) nötig, die aber in den einzelnen Bundesstaaten unterschiedlich ausgegeben werden.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
A note to the man shown in this video. There is a channel , Scholagladiatora' run by Matt Easton. He is a trained archeologist, dealer of antique weapons, and very knowledgeable about fencing and using bladed weapons, where he is also a trainer. Some of his many videos have the toppic of ,defeating' Medieval/ Rennaissnce armour with weapons of this time periode. What many modern people don't know is the fact, that then also soft armour, similar to modern civilian Kevlar vests, worn under jacket and shirt. This medieval soft armour is called Gambeston and looks like a padded coat. So a Gambeston, made in modern tailors cut, would be not recognized as armour, but as a winter coat. Those in old days relatve cheap Gambestons gave more protection against medieval weapons, than modern people expect. The protection against cuts is relative good, but thrusts with spiked or very pointy narrow blades can penetrate. This problem exists also for modern civilian undershirt Kevlar vests. Like medieval Gambestons those Kevlar is fabric/ cloth, only modern material. There is a Video of the noted Matt Easton, where he appeares in the channel ,Tods Workshop ' run by a craftsman Tod Cutler. In this Video of this britsh gentlemen, they show Mr. Easton testing a medieval Rondelldagger, made by Ted Cutler. The Rondelldaggers had been medieval antiarmout weapons. So in my oppinion a test in which medieval antiarmour dagger is used against modern day battle armour would be Intressting. Cold Steel company, as far as i know, produces replicas of such Rondelldaggers. A Video, perhaps also intresting for you is made by Joerg ( Jörg) Sprave of , Slingshot Channel '. He tested a cheap modern antistab vest with a selfmade dagger, and got into troubles for his Video.
I hope, my long comment ( i am autistic) gives you usefull information.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@sabinegierth-waniczek4872 : Ich bin Brittas Freund, benutze nur den Anschluss/ Rechner mit. Ich stamme aus Altwürttemberg, durch Erbteilung waren die Höfe daher sehr klein, meist nur eine bessere Selbstversorgung, die meisten waren zum Lebensunterhalt zu klein. Auch waren die Bauern meist Knechte bei größeren Bauern, Gesellen oder Handlanger bei Handwerkern, Helfer bei den Holzfällern oder übten ein kleines Gewerbe aus. Daher waren Pferde oder Ochsen als Zugtiere selten. Das war im Grund genommen noch in den 1950er Jahren so, sowohl in meiner väterlichen, als auch mütterlichen Familie. Das ,Angewöhnen' junger Kühe war nicht einfach, aber die Leute hatten Erfahrung und die Kühe wurden paarweise eingespannt. Das heißt, die neue junge Kuh hatte ein erfahrenes Tier zur Seite, was aber ein unwilliges Verhalten/Durchgehen des ,Lehrlings' nicht immer verhindern konnte. Auch Stechmücken sowie Bremsen ( auch Rinderbremsen genannt) sorgten immer wieder für ein Durchgehen der Tiere. Pferdegespanne waren allerdings schneller als Kühnespanne.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@Dr.Schiwago88 : Ich bin Brittas Freund, einfacher Arbeiter. Bin 1965 geboren, in einer damals noch halbwegs ländlichen, seit ca. dreißig Jahren aber immer mehr verstädternden Gegend. Als ich 1976 auf Anraten des Klassenlehrers mit dem Lesen der Tageszeitung begonnen habe, wurde hauptsächlich über Einbrüche, Diebstähle, Betrug oder Sachbeschädigung/ Vandalismus berichtet. Schlägereien gab es gelegentlich. Überfälle? Gelegentlich abends oder nachts in der Kreisstadt, manchmal auf Banken oder Tankstellen. In den kleineren Städten oder Dörfern geschah fast nichts, wenn, dann waren es Streitigkeiten innerhalb von Familien oder Verwandten. Das bedeutet, damals brauchte man sich tagsüber kaum Sorgen machen, und auch nachts reichte es, aufmerksam zu sein, und einige Orte, an denen sich allerlei Suffköpfe etc. herumtreiben, zu meiden. Das war bis Anfang der neunziger Jahre so. Im Verlauf dieses Jahrzehnts kam es weit häufiger als zuvor an Bahnhöfen, meist in Richtung der Kreisstadt, bzw. in Richtung der Landeshauptstadt, zu Schlägereien, auch in kleineren Städten kamen nachts gelegentlich Überfälle vor, was zuvor eine Seltenheit war. Gefährlich, daß man sich ernsthaft Sorgen machen musste, war es allerdings nur in der Kreisstadt, und nachts an einigen Stellen der kleineren Städte. Seit etwa 2010 ist es allerdings mir, ich bin Brittas Freund, kein sonderlich kräftiger Mann, abends in größeren Städten oder einigen Stellen der kleineren Städte nicht mehr wirklich wohl. An Bahnhöfen oder großen Bushaltestellen kommt es häufiger zu Schlägereien, , Jugendliche Gruppen geraten in Streit' ( was für Jugendliche, oder wer mit der Gewalt anfängt erfährt man aber nicht). In der Kreisstadt kommt es manchmal auch tagsüber zu Gewalt, Überfälle und Schlägereien sind in kleineren Städten häufiger, und kommen nachts inzwischen auch in kleinen Orten deutlich häufiger vor als vor dreißig, vierzig Jahren. Auch werden seit dieser Flüchtlingsherbeilockerei seit 2015 offenbar mehr Frauen belästigt, als ich es von früher her kannte. Habe seither jedenfalls mehr Frauen über Belästigungen klagen hören als früher, und eine Frau sorgte sich um ihre Töchter.
Wirklich gefährlich ist die Lage noch nicht, aber die Lage ist nicht mehr so sicher wie in meinem jüngeren Jahren, es gibt zuviele gewalttätige Spinner. Gegen dieselben wird nicht entschieden vorgegangen, und Leute die sich fürchten, werden als Angsthasen abgetan.
1
-
1
-
@steroidbaggins2936 : The roman borderfortification ,Limes' was an obstacle for germanic tribes, so a number of smaller tribes united, and became basicly the tribes, which still exist in Germany ( a note: Every german in his fourties or older still knows, to which tribe he belongs, and speaks his dialect more or less. But german population mixes more and more, the dialects are declining, more and more foreigners come, and young people have mostly lost the sense of tradition, ) The Suevi united with one or two smaller tribes, also homeless germanic persons/ families joined, and new tribe used the name Alemannen. The tribe Name explains itself : Alle Mannen ( in current german ,Alle Männer'/ all men). This tribe was in 260 after Jesus sucessfull to overwhelm the weak defended Limes, and conquer the area, where we still live today. No real conquest, most of ,provincial romans' moved/ fleed away, when germanic raids became more dangerous. A part of Alemanics, calling them Suevi moved in fact to the land north of Portugal. When in 843/911/ 919, we germans are unsure, when HRE started, the Alemanics switched to old name Suevi ( Schwaben). Nowadays, Schwaben means the swabian inhabitants of Bavaria and former Württemberg, Alemannen means! the inhabitants of french Alsace, Black Forrest, Allgäu and austrian Vorarlberg, and the others are the Swissgermans and the people of small country Liechtenstein.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
The word as Stutzenkarabiner . The german verb ,stutzen' means to cut away a piece to shorten it. A Stutzen is today a hunting rifle with a stock of full barrel length, once a Stutzen was a shortened hunting gun, where the barrel was cut away at frontend of stock. A Stutzer is either the swissgerman word for a target/ competition rifle, or a dated word meaning Dandy. A Stütze , my english is limited, is either an Item, which prevents a heavy object from falling down, or ,Slang' for social money in case of unemployment.
The fact, that german troops between 1919 and 1933 ( the Reichswehr) used .22 training not only for money saving or noise reducing. For reason of Versailles treaty, the ammunition stock was so small, that under wwl conditions it would have been to few for a single day. So german forces simply had to few ammunition for propper training, so they had to use unregulated .22 ammunition, airguns and even ,Nadelstichgerät' ( needle stab device).
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
In fact. I am german, Britta is my girlfriend. When you are interested in police history, it is not so easy . In the german state Baden- Württemberg, where i live, there is the ,Museum of Military History/ Wehrgeschichtliches Museum' in Rastatt, but Police or other armed branches of civilian administration? For some years you could visit the private collection of a now passed away former ,special constable' , in some ,Home Region Museums/ Heimatmuseen' you can see the polearms of former nightwatchmen , the bells of former ,Büttel/ town criers' or old handcuffs or tortouring equipment of shocking old days justice, perhaps century old prison cell doors and in a small local museum in eastern Württemberg there is a room about poachery, thats nearly all.
I own a book, printed in small numbers, about the police history in my Landkreis ( county? / Arrondissement?), and from Osprey company about german police in WW ll days and german colonial armed forces. Also i know some things about armed personal of civilian administration by reading newspaper, german arms magazins and german magazins about military history ( in continental europe the policeman is basicly a descendant of soldiers, on british Islands and iceland a descendant of nightwatchmen/town criers).
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@andrewpeterson1551 : Brittas boyfriend, native german here. Don't tell nonsens. Most German beer is clear, but this means filtrated. In Last decades, more and more unfiltrated Beers appear. They are marketed as Tradition, quality of old days, revolutionary Spirit. Nonsens. For thousands of years, from the days of pharaonic and babylonic Beers to 19th century beer was unfiltrated. One day, someone had the Idea of filtrating Beer to have Something Special, other brewers don't have. By the time, more and more brewers entered the ,running train of filtrated beer'. Today unfiltrated Beer is unusual, so more and more brewers enter the ,running train of unfiltrated beer'. All Marketing, nothing else. To craft Beer. Of course, you can Drink it, but as conservative Beer drinker in my late 50s, i prefer traditional south German beer types, i am a southerner, no prussian. This craftbeer is in my eyes simplly an excuse to sell strange tasting Beer.
1
-
@curtzeek8818 : Attention! In 1516 HRE bavarian law was only law in Bavaria, so other about 300 ,reichsunmittlelbare' territories could do what they wanted. In case of Neuzeller brewery, i live in a different Region of Germany. A former coworker gave me a bottle of this Beer, and told me this is rather rare, they have an allowness to add suggar, because they once added honey. I have never done a research, because in Germany we say: Keine Regel ohne Ausnahme/ No rule without exeption. On the other Hand, during a dancing event in a park i noticed a bee owner selling honey, wax candles etc., also Beer bottles , showing a ,germanic' Warrior, but the fluid was called Beer- Mix- Drink.
1
-
German: Oxford/ in Bavaria Ochsenfurt exists. Old English here- german Heer. In german Weiler is a small settlement- see ville or village. Burgh in english town, see Burg ( castle) in german town names, Münster in german a large church, see minster. lngham- settlement of ...s men, this is in german the ending - ingen. Nottingham is english - a german village Notzingen exist( - ingham/ -ingen!).
Homestead- Heimstatt/ Heimstätte, for this reason not every german settlements ending with -stadt, -stett, -stetten, -stätt is a Stadt ( town). When in Germany a Gemeinde/ village grows to over 10000 inhabitants, and some things exist there, then this Gemeinde gets town rights ( of course today no fortifications are build). Town rights of Monarchy era are still town rights today, so some towns with lesser than 10000 inhabitants exist, few lesser than 2000
1
-
This was rather common in former times. I, german, have read in a book of the british ,Osprey' company, that in the Culloden battle 1746 in the scottish clan levies even 12-13 year old boys fought, and also men in their 70s ( imagine a man in his 70s in 18th century!), even madmen! But of course at the end of wwll this was unneccessary. In the last weeks of wwll there was a fight in the forrest of my homevillage. Three german soldiers died, they are burried not in regular graveyard, but at their own grave. One man was about 40 years, the others younger than 20. They died in an age, when you usualy start into your ,own' life.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I, Brittas boyfriend, am german, but for bad eyes reason, i never served in german army. Years ago, two coworkers, one from Western, one from Eastern Germany had a discussion, which german army before 1990 was better. The one, who served in Westgerman Army, thought, Bundeswehr was better , because of more modern equipment. I , as a pure theoretic, didn' t thought so, because russian equipment saw combat everywhere between north and southpole, westgerman equipment never saw combat. Russian trained soldiers knew field service problems of their equipment, Western soldiers often Not. I noted also mentality differences between westgerman and eastgerman soldiers/ forces. At the end of my ,speech' the coworker seving in Westgermany became silent, the one serving in Eastgermany smiled.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am german, and Brittas boyfriend. I want to note, that this irregular warfare has no tradition in Germany, so it is no wonder, that german soldiers hat been angry about ununiformed fighters/partisans, who, what is mostly not told, also did not respect war laws. This is no excuse for unnecessary cruelty, but the truth is, this partisans had been the reason for lots of murdered persons. Of course, the german attack on russia was also done for unhonourous reason.
1
-
1
-
The Video title is wrong! This is no real armour, but cheap unhistorical decoration scrap ( Schrott in german). The first handguns in 14th century had been pipes fixed on a pole, you could not realy aim to the opponent, matchlockmuskets with similarities to modern rifles appeared after 1450, and wheellock pistols in the 1510s. The best suits of armour had been made between perhaps 1460 to 1630, the peak about 1510 to 1560. In german museums, castles or palaces , i am german, you see lots of breast plates with a dient(?)/ Delle from the test/ proof shot. So in some distance this breastplates could protect you from round lead balls . Helmets and backplates had been also wellmade, but this pieces had mostly not the breatplates protection stamdart. Arm and leg armour or rather cheap armour could only protect against bladed weapons. And the wheellock and early flintlock pistols had for penetration reasons smaller bore than muskets, and rather long barrels with strong walls for strong powder charges. In early 18th century , when even heavy cavallry used no more the helmet but a hat with some thin sheet metal strips or thick wires, and sometimes only the breastplate of cuirass, the pistols changed to shorter barrels with thinner walls in musket bore, and weaker powder charges. The penetration of military firearms rised with rifled muskets using , long ball' in smaller bore. The protection of cuirasses against this new rifled muskets balls, not to mention modern smokeless powder driven jacket projectiles, declined, and as far as i know only fremch cuirassiers went to battle with cuirass in 1914. In US civil war, some soldiers used privat bought vests with an iron breast Imlay(?) which could protect against rifled muskets Projektile in 100 vor more yards. Some soldiers in colonial Mexico had leather hats, jackets and shields in late 18th century. In napoleonic time helmets of metall or leather came back and had been used up to wwl, but could protect only against sabers. In the 1870 a rich farmer fired with a shotgun at german emperor Wilhelm l, the shot Pellets(?) went through the emperors leatherhelmet with point, but had been slowed down, so he survived.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@jrooney58 : I am Brittas boyfriend, only using her Computer. Born 1965, socalled middle education and german style trained metal
worker. When i was a child i watched in TV Wild West and swashbuckler (?) / In german Mantel und Degen movies. In my Homeregion there are lots of Castle ruins, so i was very intressted and wanted to know more. So i am no accademic and no expert of a Special era, country, weapon type, but after decades of reading books and magazines, visiting castles, all kind of museums and historic sites ( in my Homeregion from Celtic age onwards), speaking with Museum staff, collectors, hunters, target shooters, reenactors, policemen, security guards etc., i have a serious Basis of knowledge about arms, armour, fortifications from ancient days to now. It is totally Impossible to know everything, but: When you compare new heared facts with knowledge you have, to some degree you can notice, when something is to doubtable.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@kohinarec6580 : Klein means small in english. So you are right, this is in this case a lmited/ reduced licence. The mayor differences are: With a ,kleiner Waffenschein' you can carry only a blankgun ( with german authorities ,PTB' stamp, but this is currently changing for European Union reason) to fire rather weak blanks , ,gascartridges' with CS, pepper cartridges, in some blanks, the gunpowder is mixed with chemicals for either more smoke or a stringer flash of fire. With an ordinary Waffenschein you can carry real pistols for selfdefence . Second difference: A ,kleiner Waffenschein' is easy to get, you usually get it , when you had never been involved in crime or extremism ( Zuverlässigkeit/ relyability). For a real/ full Waffenschein, the authorities proof more carefully, if you have problems with alcohol, drugs, mental problems, and more carefull if you are involved in crime or extremism. ( Zuverlässigkeit), also you have to show, that you have knowledge about weapons, ammunition, safety rules, law etc.. ( Sachkunde) and the most difficult thing is, to show the authorities, that you habe the need ( Bedürfnis) for a pistol. So today i think, most oft owners of a Waffenschein' are security guards.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@kleinweichkleinweich : In 1815, when German Federation was formed, there had been two ( catholic) swabian Principalities of Hohenzollern dynasty. The principality of Hohenzollern - Sigmaringen ( which was the larger one), and Hohenzollern - Hechingen ( where Hohenzollern castle really is). In 1849 both Lines gave their territories to their mighty prussian relatives, who saved their Thrones in 1848. Today only branch Hohenzollern - Sigmaringen is allive. Two sidenotes: It is strange , that Habsburg, Hohenzollern and Hohenstaufen dynasty had their root in former Duchy Swabia. Next to Hohenstaufen, i live in this Region, there is the small castle Wäscherschloß, inhabitated up to 1857. As far as i know , Wäscherschloß and Wäscherhof had been in HRE time no part of Württemberg, but owned by Habsburg dynasty from 15th century to 1857, when they sold it to nonnoble owners, last Person living in Castle, seemed to be a Förster.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@myteebrown7876 : In absolute numbers for example 130000 is much more than 100000, in MY eyes. I stopped watching movies about war, because , i am german, it annoies(?) me, that rather often german soldiers from 1870 to 1945 are shown either as criminals or idiots, who follow oders without thinking, or being arrogant, while allied soldiers are nearly allways the heroes. There are lots of movies about US civil war 1861 to 1865. Some time ago i noticed a short clip of a movie/ tv serial show ,1864' , a danish production about the german/ danish war of 1864, made some years ago. After a short time, i stopped watching the clip, because i was angry, and decided , not to watch the full movie. Why? A small patrol of danish infantry was captured by a german cavallry patrol of double size. For no reason the german patrol commander, a tall, fat, baldheaded man with a partly burnt face full of scars, wanted to execute the danish soldiers. You perhaps understand, why i got angry for seeing such anti german Propaganda in a relative new movie. In a movie of 1949 i would have had no problems, but so?
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@MrDogmash : Formerly Mauser company had a famous collection. Was stolen by french and US soldiers. When you come to Oberndorf am Neckar, and visit Waffenmuseum in last existing Mauser building ( socalled Schwedenbau) it is a shock. The firearms of Heckler & Koch shown are in good condition, also the weapons of olympic competition weapons company Feinwerbau are in good condition, both companies, located in Oberndorf are founded after wwll. But weapons of Mauser company? The stolen collection no more exists, And the shown substitutes? Some weapons are in good or at least acceptable condition, others in bad condition, the wwl Tankgewehr looks like a dugout of the ground and sandblasted. Also few weapons ( including lance tips) produced by forerunner of Mauser company ( Royal Württembergian Arms Manufaktur) are shown. One of first directors of this company was a famous württembergian gunsmith or gunmaker ( in german both is Büchsenmacher). He had allowness to produce in factory civilian firearms under his own name, a pistol made by this man is shown, excellent crafted. Also civilian products of Mauser company are shown. Two cars, bureau machines and measurement Equipment. When i was starting my german style jobtraining in 1982, every young job trainee was proud, to show his Mauser calipher (for gunlaw reason a Mauser rifle is out of reach). With ticket of Waffenmuseum you also can visit Heimatmuseum/ homeregion museum about history of town Oberndorf, showing rusty sword blades and spear tips of alemannic warriors graves. Btw., when you visit Oberndorf in July, you have the posibility to visit Oberndorf Square Dance Special.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
In contrast to most German jouralists, politcicians and leftwingers, i , Brittas boyfriend, am informed about USA laws about weapons. There, there are federal laws about weapons, those laws must be respected everywhere in USA. An example IS a Federal Gun law of 1968, which forbiddes rifled barrel firearms with larger caliber than .50"/12,7 mm, or vest pocket pistols being very small ( this regulation was for Economy protection of US gun companies, their vestpocket pistols had lower quality and higher price, so importing foreign vestpocket pistols was forbidden). Then , respecting federal laws, every US state can introduce adding laws. Inside every state every County can add more laws, respecting state and federal laws. Inside a County/ Parrish in Louisiana, every community can add additional laws. So, crossing a community/County/ state Border the weapons laws can Change very strong. So weapons law is in reallity a Flickenteppich. Or: There is NO general weapons law in USA.
Second point: In US cities and states with hard law crime is higher than in liberal regions. Same thing in german language countries. In Germany/Ausria/ Switzerland the countries are rich Industrial countries, the countries are federal democraties, all countries are from same culture. Weapons laws: Hard in Germany, middle in Austria, liberal in Switzerland. Crime: High in Germany, middle in Switzerland, lowest in Austria.
Feli, you are not aware of rising knife crime in Germany the last years, also the number or illegal weapons is at least Double the number of legal weapons, there is also a large rise in gun smuggle ( open EU borders) and selfmaking of guns by criminals, this includes transforming blank guns into real guns ( which is aleo Dangerous for the user, because blank guns are mostly Made of casted zinc only), or producing firearms and silencers in legal mechanical Workshops/ companies owned by criminals. According to german armsmagazines(?) / Waffenfachzeitschriften Visier and Deutsches Waffenjournal, we have currently the most wellarmed criminals in german history. Also you may be not aware of the unbelievable mild and soft sentences., some criminals got last year after doing stabbings and massrapings.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@shake4259 : I am german, Brittas boyfriend, no gun owner, and for reason of my bad eyes i had not to serve in Bundeswehr in 1980s. Now as an older man in late 50s i theroreticaly would have to serve in third line Landsturm. My knowledge about weapons? Reading german language magazines (?)/ Zeitschriften about weapons and military history since 1982, visiting dozens of weapons collections in german museums and castles ( also in Brussels, Vienna and London), speaking with policemen, Security Guards, Antiques Dealers, hunters, target shooters, collectors, Reenactors, Museum staff. And : In my homeregion for historical reasons, you can find lots of fortifications relicts. Celtic, Roman, medieval, Rennaissnce, Baroque, 19th century ( Fortress Ulm) and Interwar era ( Neckar - Elz line, Westwall). Also two hours of Krav Maga (!), two hours stick fighting (!), ten minutes rapier fencing (!) and by current german governement in future Impossible: 15 shots .22 lr (!), 5 shot .38 S&W Special (!), 5 shot .357 Magnum , 3 shot .45 muzzleloader rifle, 3 shot .36 muzzleloader pistol. In US context an impressive knowledge:-)). At staff building of local Newspaper there is a large glass Show box (?) which contains a Newspaper, so that also poor people can read it, giving poor people the possibility to read the Newspaper IS a good idea. One day i passed the Newspaper building, Reading the Newspaper in the glass box. There was a Photo of a man, holding a russian Ppsh 41 submachine gun . The Text: The Leader of County gun controll authorities shows Newspaper employe a confiscated Kalaschnikow ( german writing). A Ppsh 41 is no AK 47!!! I entered the Newspaper building to tell the noted mistake. The Newspaper Lady had absolutely NO knowledge about weapons!!! She spoke with me in a such arrogant tone, that i became angry. Being a conservative man, it is impossible for me to not respect courtesy rules, when a Lady is next to me, so i left the Room and the building. Sometime later, i visited Garrison Museum in town Ludwigsburg. I was the only visitor, so i talked with the two Museum men. The older one told me, that in 2009 ( Winnenden school Shooting) the female leader of Ludwigsburg Ordnungsamt ( in Germany the Ordnungsämter are responsible for gun licences).asked the Museum Leader to show the handfull of historical military rifles. The Museum man told me, he was shocked! He showed the Ordnungsamt Lady a single shot rifle ( either Dreyse needle fire or Mauser M71) and the Lady asked: Where is the magazine,? If someone would have photographed me in this Moment, my face would Look funny.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@joereu4510 : German here, Brittas boyfriend. Nobody needs firearms? Why is then the number of illigal firearms doble sized than legal firearms? Why ( open EU borders) is smuggling of guns into Germany so high? Why do criminals produce firearms in mechanical workshops/ factories they own? Do you think, the Hobby drill/ turning/ milling machines of today have lesser quality than machines, being used before 1930 in Belgium or Spain, where then cheap firearms had been massproduced? Is 3d printing of firearms controllable? Gouvernement is not intressted to dry out illegal swamp, you need personal, time, allowness to search houses etc., doing restrictons for legal gunowners is much easier. According to german weapons magazines, who often do Research about restrictons and authorities, the school shootings in Erfurt/ Winnenden, the Policeofficers murder done by a poacher and many others are caused by unprofessional Police and other authorities. Currently we have most restrictive gun law since unification of Germany in 1871, but the most wellarmed criminals in german History.
1
-
@sherlockwho5714 : In german weapons magazine Visier there was a short time ago an article about the illegal guns in Germany. The number of illegal weapons is estimated twice the number of legal firearms. Where do those illegal weapons come from? Out of the blue? To some degree this are old weapons bought, when firearms could be bought without registration. Before 1972 some kind of Long guns could be bought. Before 1928 also pistols could be bought easier than now. Many of this nonregistered pistols, which survived wwll ( and allied bringbacks), and hidden wwll Wehrmacht guns appear sometimes. But most illegal firearms are smuggled ( open EU borders). Then there are homemade guns, and craftsmsn made guns in not so small Numbers, even semiproffesional gunfactories run by criminals exist. Of course this illegal Workshops don' t produce modernest high end pistols or polymer pistols, but this is not necessary for them, a simple blowback/ Feder- Masse pistol is easy to produce, and copies of old designs, for example FN 1910/22, are common. The quality of relative cheap milling/turning / drilling machines, you can buy at a Tool shop, is Not lower, than the before wwl machines to produce the orginals. And 3D printing technology is also used by criminals for firearms.
1
-
I am german, Brittas boyfriend. In wwll eastern Europe german governement build a forestry unit, i think ,Forstschutzkommando', this had been soldiers, forresty officers ( Förster) , woodcutters, sawmill workers, transport workers. A military organized organisation under supervision of Wehrmacht. Most uniforms had been like Luftwaffe, perhaps because Göring was head of german hunters organisation. Their task was producing wood in german forrestry style, so also trees had been planted. The firearms had been usual firearms, but to the bayonnets there had been also a special type of knife, useable as tool and weapon. Those officers which had been real forrestoficials / Förster carried their Hirschfänger as bladed weapon.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
When in late wwll somewhere in Poland ressistance fighters entered a building, where a bureau of SS was. One of the men, who could read german, picked a document from the floor. To his surprise, all the documents had been about whitches ( Hexen in german). At first he thought, SS used old torture methods of former ages, but he noticed, that Himmler himself ordered research about whitches, because he thought, witches knew relicts of old germannic religions and customs, from before Christianity.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am Brittas boyfriend, german . For about 40 years now i read the weapons and military history magazines in german language. Some first information: There is an intressting You Tube channel ,jmantime' . The creator has lots of videos of all kind of military equipment from 19th century to now. There are a number of videos about swiss weaponry , please watch them. The man writes and speaks german words rather terrible, but thats not the problem. The only toppic he doesn' t cover is as far as i know swiss navy ( no joke) , this had been in wwll 5 or 7 patrolboats, each armed with a swiss made 20mm anti tank gun and a twin machinegun in 7,5 x 55 , one of this boats could be still in service.
In 1930 Switzerland noticed , french Ligne Maginot and german Westwall. Also building a border fortification line? They noticed the danger of Germany and Italy, but relayed at first on the not so high number of rather modern or only slightly dated fortifications. But when the danger was clear they started a large fortification program, which ended in 1990s. The lower part of Switzerland was transformed into the light fortified ,Glacis' and the high part into heavy fortified ,Reduit'.
In Switzerland there had been the Army, the unarmed Militärhilfsdienst and local ,Ortswehren' ( town guards?) and a number of armed civilian offices of central governement. The cantons and towns only their police. Armament: Regular Armament, but sounding curious, the weaponry was different, depending on age of armed men. Of course all stored weapons and also civilian owned military style weapons had to be used.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@DerDrAndroid : Mit kommunale Sicherheitsleute meinte ich jene , meines Wissens den Ordnungsämtern der Kommunen unterstellten Leute des kommunalen Ordnungsdienstes, seit einiger Zeit ist auf deren Autos oft Polizeibehörde XY zu lesen. Diese Leute sind im Grund genommen die modernen Nachkommen der früheren Büttel, Amtsdiener, Nachtwächter und Feldhüter.
Mit privaten Sicherheitsleuten meinte ich das Personal von privaten Sicherheitsfirmen. Daß die privaten Sicherheitsunternehmen keinerlei hoheitlichen Befugnisse besitzen, ist mir klar.
Ich wollte aber nicht dies beschreiben, sondern nur mitteilen, daß es auch bei kommunalem Ordnungsdiensten und privaten Sicherheitsunternehmen Mitarbeiter gibt, die im Gegensatz zur Mehrheit mit Feuerwaffen versehen sind, und nicht nur mit Pfefferspray oder heutzutage überwiegend zusammenschiebbaren Schlagstöcken. Ganz arme Hunde sind diejenigen für Sicherheit oder Aufsicht zuständigen Leute, die überhaupt keine Verteidigungsgeräte mitführen dürfen.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@gt2x446 : Es ist für mich, Brittas Freund, angenehm , zu erfahren, daß ein , Berufshistoriker' die Ansicht eines , interessierten Laien' wie mir bestätigt. Mein Interesse für Militärgeschichte begann im Jahr 1971 mit einem Kindergartenausflug zum Schloß Lichtenstein. Jetzt , fünfzig Jahre später, ist nach etlichen Büchern, Zeitschriften, Museen, Schlössern, Ruinen und Führungen ein geschichtliches Wissen zusammengekommen, daß man mir keinen Grizzlybären aufbinden kann. Nun bin ich kein Historiker, aber um ein historisches Ereignis einzuschätzen, sollte man mehrere Ansichten dazu kennen und überlegen, was dran sein könnte, so kommt man in die Nähe , aber nur in die Nähe , der Wahrheit.
1
-
1
-
In my swabian Homeregion in south west Germany, there both modern appletree plantages with rather small trees, but also traditional appletree meadows with rather high trees. For harvesting the apples of modern trees you need no tool, but for oldstyle trees you need long ,Applehooks' a three to six meter long pole with a small iron hooh, with a small iron forming a very small fork. Usually you take the hook, catch a branch and shake it, most apples fall down. But those ones, not falling must be ,spearer' down with the long pole. It is rather difficult to take down this apples. The pole is allways to short, and it bends under its own weight, so precise stabbing down the remaining apples is not easy, the poles become heavy by time. I can see from this work, that handling the long macedonic pikes needed skill.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@tanne8436 : Weniger Kunstdünger, weniger Pflanzenschutzmittel ergibt aber auch geringere Ernten. Dies ist auch zu bedenken, hier muß man eine Lösung finden. Sie vergessen, daß Deutschland seit 1918 rund ein Drittel an Fläche verloren hat, aber keine geringere Bevölkerung hat. Das Ackerland reicht nicht zur Versorgung der Bevölkerung, man könnte Grasland umbrechen, da ja die Viehhaltung mehr oder weniger verteufelt wird, werden weniger Weiden/ Mähweiden gebraucht, aber ob das ausreicht? Die Lebensmittelpreise werden eh steigen, denn die Erträge werden geringer, die mechanische Unkrautbekämpfung muß oft durchgeführt werden und ist arbeitsintensiv. Wenn man die klimaschädlichen Traktoren und methanausstoßenden Zugtiere als Kraftquelle nicht haben will, ist, wie im alten Rom menschliche Arbeitskraft nötig , was die Erzeugung verteuert. Auch die, von Nichtbesitzern so gelobten Streuobstwiesen sind unrentabel, vermutlich werden deshalb stets den Besitzern die arbeitsintensiven Hochstämme vorgeschrieben, Halbstämme ( die auch schon reichlich Arbeit machen) oder Plantagenbäume hingegen nicht erlaubt. Man muß etwas tun, das ist richtig, aber man muß überlegt handeln, das ist nicht ganz so einfach, wie es sich städtisch/ linksgeprägte / wohlsituierte Leute vorstellen.
Ein weiteres Problem ist die, gerade in ärmeren, nicht mit fruchtbarem Ackerland gesegneten Ländern herrschende Überbevölkerung, diese wird oft von Religionsdeppen mit ,ihr Kinderlein kommet' Propaganda angeheizt.
1
-
@marcbartuschka6372 : Oh, Allied Powers are the headlights of Moral! Why i as a german neither know or believe this? If the former Allied Powers would be really moralic, they would produce much more movies about the crimes, they have done in their History. But: In era of French , Sunking Louis XIV , the southwest of Germany was burnt, plundered and destroyed by french troops. I have never seen a french Movie about this, only french movies of being the poor victim. This lies of nongerman nations about their crimes must be punished. The french are allways whining: oh how terrible the Germans had been against our heroic freedom fighters! But what did the french with Résistance fighters during Napoleonic era in Spain, Tyrol or some north German regions? Have the french a right to whine about German troops killing non uniformed criminals, when french troops in Napoleonic era killed Résistance fighters of other nations? They have no right! Have the US, a Nation of landrobbers, a right to Protest against other nations? A Nation , who killed more people on foreign soil, than foreign Nations killed US citizens on US soil should be quiet!
1
-
@BoudewijnvanHouten : In Germany we say: Von nichts kommt nichts. ( from nothing comes nothing), this means, everything has a reason. In case of historical Events, the reason dates sometimes decades, or may be a century back, it is often necessary to go to lesser known things too.
But : German History is complicated, and for my oppinion sadly, many people are not very informed, what happened in HRE before about 1750. I am ordinary factory worker, Brittas boyfriend, so i am also no real expert and can also be wrong.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I , Brittas boyfriend, am german, no accademic, but a conservative, rural , patriotic factory worker. When i hear the nonsens, spoken by accademics, politicians and other persons with power and influence, i allways get angry. My respect for those ,elites' is long gone Stay the openeyed person , you are.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@AlexAlexon3897 : At fiirst i am german, so i am not offended by english words. i know what Communisn is. The ideology which killed more people than Nationalsocialism, and usually caused bancrupt countries. Former Communist East Germany needed hunderds of billions ( in German Milliarden) of Mark from West Germany in 1990s. Hunderds of east Germans had been shot or otherwise been killed, when they wanted to flee. No , i am Not uneplployed, i Work for 40 years as a trained worker, i am Facharbeiter with degree/diplom(?). Current german Governement consists of three Parties. Social Demokrats / Liberal Party ( means in german Sense a Not right, Not left Party, who wants good Economy, science,etc. but No strong Gouvernement) and Green Party ( leftwing/libeal in US Sense). The important members of Green Party mostly have never worked in industry or any kind of Business, but mostly in positions/ Jobs payed by taxpayers. An astonishing number of the important Green Party Personal , especially women, have lazyboned for years at university, but No Accademic degree, neither learnd an Ausbildungsberuf an ordinary trained job. Such persons want to teach me? Their Policy is pure idiocraty.
1
-
@AlexAlexon3897 : Studieing Without any degree , why are they in University. And that Communism killed more people than Hitler is no lie. Also no lie is that noted Social Democratic Party in early 1920s had an election Poster , showing a man with Stahlhelm and Swastika, and a man with pointy russian military Cap and Red Star . Text of Poster was: Dies sind die Feinde der Demokratie / this are the enemies of democraty.
And, don' t be too angry, If someone doesn' t shares your oppinnion, Oh, a coworker of me, Born and grown Up in former GDR told me, that Communist FDJ was simply Red painted HJ, with paramiltary Training for war. Now you can use your time for rescuing the world and space.
1
-
@AlexAlexon3897 : Yes i am very conservative. But when my country gets bancrupt, then Not for reason of people Like me. Current relative left Gouvernement doesn' t know, that when you want to spend Money, you must earn the Money before, and you can spend it only once. That Gouvernement has Money, taxes are necessary, but to earn taxes, Economy and industry must earn Money, so that also working Citizen has Money. But: Current Gouvernement, especially left Green Party, do Everything possible to destroy industry. To produce trade goods, Energy is necessary, but current Policy causes high Energy prices, especially here in Germany, we have highest Energy prices in Europe, so that those parts of industry needing Energy, for example Aluminium industry, but also Bakers, Beer breweries, Transport companies have proplems, stopping Business or try to produce in other countries. But also private citizen need Energy for heating in Winter, which became very expensive. The Economy Minister ( Green Party) wants to forbidd oil and Gas heating in some years, the people should use ( don' t know Technical english word) Wärmepumpen ( literaly Heat Pumps using warmth of inner earth). But this is expensive, the Technologie is currently Not totally relyable. Also number of available resources, for example needed Pipes and trained craftsmen is to small. So it is a Thing , where inhave doubts. And ,so rich, as politicans Tell us that we are, we aren' t. So many people fear, they lost their Houses, because they can' t pay this forced modernisation. Agriculture Minister wants for Nature reason Stop agriculture/ Farming on half of Farmland, and only biologicsl Farming. Hm, harvests of biological Farming are smaller than harvests of traditional Farming, and harvests of half of Farmland are only half of harvest. How to Feed German Population, with to small harvests? Stealing food in other countries? Even in wwl, when Germany was much larger, Germany needed food from other countries, so britisch,Hunger' naval Blockade caused half a Million dead. Also German social system, founded by Wilhelm ll together with Otto von Bismarck, is at its ,border'. Fewer working taxpayers, producing Something, have to Feed and pay for an enlarging number of unproductive persons, getting social money, or are people who Work in any Form as ,state servants'. It IS totally Impossible, that good social social system, as i know it, survives. Who will be the betrayed ones, when social system collapses? Those ones, who have worked, saved their Money, and/ or bought a house.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@Burner01-my7vz : Of course this is relevant. There are two types of vegetarians. With one type i, Brittas boyfriend, have no problems. They are vegetarians, and thats all. For example in the circles of my Hobby there is a man, who eats no meat for medical reasons, he has stomach problems. He eats no meat, and thats all. But there is a second type of vegetarians, about which am terribly annoyed, the moralic missionaries. They in every sentence tell others unwanted, how supermoralic on highest level they are, because they eat no and are so good people, the best people ever living on earth. As an Atheist, rural man and non supporter of political correct woke urban Mainstream modernlings, i simply don' t like people, who think, they are Superior because of their political, religious or other believe. There are among the ,One god religions' such ones, who think, they are ,gods own people', they are , the believing masterrace' etc., i don' t like or need the people with such behaviour.
So: A numerous part of vegetarians want to teach me, how good and moralic they are, but strangely they don' t speak about the work of Mr. Hitler, so i mistrust those part of vegetarians. A Note: I have Autism on Low Level.
1
-
I Mistrust persons, groups etc., who tell me, with my ideas, we get a better world. Arround 1520 people in german town Münster had problems with the Catholic Bishop, they got ,Wiedertäufer ' Republik. In 1640s England people had been happy : We no more have a King! They got Cromwell. In 1789 french people had been happy: We no more have a King! They got ,terreur' and Napoleon. In 1917 russian people had been happy: We no more have a Tsar ! They got Lenin and Stalin.
Then, i , Brittas boyfriend, am rural man with farmers background. In my homeregion for centuries the farms had been very small, only few acres, one to three cows, only enough, to have enough food for Family. To earn Money, the people had to work in factory, as craftsmen, as helpers, sevants, auxillaries etc., so every Farmer was also a craftsman, and every blacksmith, carpenter etc. had also a cow. This was still common in 1980s, but today my region is urbanizing very quickly, the people lose farmers knowledge faster and faster. This lost of farmers knowledge and rural Spirit causes success of idiots. They teach the people, how good Farming in old days was. Nobody speaks, that cow breed , Süddeutsches Fleckvieh' once was used for three purposes. Less important: Meat. More important: Milk. Most important: Towing annimal ( until 1960s). Pigs had been in very narrow stables ( in 1820s it was forbidden to Put pigs into Forrest to eat fruits of oaks or Buche). I saw live , and in colour, Last relicts of old Style Farming, with traditional Hand Tools, and few Machines. Farming is, in traditional way, hard Work. In my youth i saw Last old farmers working without Traktor, but with horse, and my parents often told me how they , for poornes reason worked not with horses, but cows, and how hard cereals harvest ( wheat, barley, oat ) was without modern Machines ( but they No more know, how to use a flail). But using annimals ( horses, cows, oxen, donkeys) IS this annimal abuse or Environment friendly Farm Work? Using tractors : Dangerous for Environment for gasoline smoke? Electric tractors? Most of my german countymen mistrust both electric powered vehicles and environfriendly electric Energy. What is the solution for this problem? White inhabitants of former Confederate States may remember ....
Next Problem: Not every soil is usefull for agriculture. In Mountain regions, for height or thin soil ( but Stones few Inches under grass), in Arctic or swampy/ moorish areas,or Semidessert the people could only survive, by hunting, fishing and having cattle ( cows, sheep or goats), so when forbidding hunting, fishing, cattle in many regions of world people No more could live, and you modernlings ( in this Case racists) would destroy cultures.
Next Point. Here in Germany, don' t know your country and Situation there, many people, mostly with leftist/Green Touch, want food being , biologic' without fertilizers(?) /Kunstdünger and without chemicals/ poison Killing rodents (?)/Schädlinge or Unwanted plants. And current german Federal Minister of Agriculture ( Green Party/ leftist, being as , Kindergarten educator' an expert for agriculture) wants, that German farmers Work , biologic' and reduce the agricultural used space every year for four per Cent for Environment protection. Hm? In 1820s , German Confederation' had Thirty millions inhabitants. The Farming / Agriculture was really biologic'. But agriculture production of food was only in ordinary years enough. Hunger was still a fearcausing danger. So german rulers did everything possible to enlarge agricultural production , using fertilizers and ,poisons'. But this could Not realy solve all food problems of Germany, the allied Hunger blokades against Germany in wwl and wwll Had been sucessfull. So: In biological agriculture the harvests are smaller. Hm ? Due to bilologic production and reducing agricultural space Nature is protected. But food? Unimportant! When there is a Lack of food, we steal IT in foreign countries, Like wwl and Ii. Am deutschen Wesen wird die Welt genesen! ( Friedrich Nietzsche, German phiosopher).
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
This staff officers had not the task of being bodyguards, but in case of danger all men, escorting a prime minister, president, king etc. should do something. I am german , Britta is my girlfriend, from about 1830 to 1918 there was in Berlin the small palace unit , Leibgendarmen', because Leib means body and Gendarm is a french word after 1800 meaning policeman, this palace unit ,Leibgendarmen' is often missinterpreted as bodyguard unit, but this was not their task. But if the prussian king/ german emperor or high rank german or foreign guests had been in a dangerous situation, they had to protect . In 1870s/ 80s an angry rich farmer fired a shotgun at Wilhelm l, he survived . A medical doctor, who was coincidently there escorted the injured emperor to his palace. Inside of the palace it was a Leibgendarm, who stopped the doctor: Who are you? You don' t belong to imperial court! ( The soldier simply did his duty, that strangers should not enter the private part of palace for security reason).
1
-
There wasn' t much. The german colony ,Tsingtao' in China was well fortfied, so the german garrison could resist for about three months against mostly japanese troops. The ammunition run out, and the japanese reached the weakest point of german fortifications, so the german troops surrenderd. In the South Sea there had been only few german soldiers and policemen, some hundreds of indigenous policemen/ soldiers divided to a lot of islands, japanese forces took it without resistance. From Tsingtao the german East Asia Navy Squad tried to reach Germany via Cap Horn, they won a small seabattle against a british squad of elderly ships, but lost a second battle at Falkland Islands, all german ships sunk and Admiral Graf( Count) Spee died in action. Another single german warship ,Emden' die some merchant raiding, also merchant raider ,Seeadler' a ship of sail ( !) under command of Graf Luckner reached Pacific.
1
-
A lot of different things. As a german i am astonished with the problems native english speakers have with the german ,ch' sound. In Oberndorf/Neckar please visit the Waffen (weapons) museum there. It is in a former building of the Mauser company. You can see weapons of the Royal Wurttembergian Arms Factory ( the forerunner ???) of the Mauser company, products of the Mauser company (weapons, a car !, measurement tools, steel furniture!, bureau machines), weapons of Heckler & Koch and target arms of the Feinwerkbau company. The opposite door of the weapons museum is the door of the Heimatmuseum/ home region museum. Please visit it also! There are blades of seaxes and spathas, spear and arrow points from alemannic graves, drums and pictures from the former town militia and photographs from a world war I air raid done by british airforce. The photographs show the graveyard ceremony for two shotdown british pilots . A german priest and in the background a number of german soldiers with spiked helmets. Those elderly german non frontline soldiers visited the burrial of two enemy soldiers, a sign of old style courtesy. Note for american readers: In Oberndorf an american square dance club exists. Note for british readers: Near Oberndorf the Teck family had a castle, Mary von Teck was the grandmother of current queen Elizabeth Ii.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@WilTK4 : Bahnpolizei is armed. The men , in 1975 still armed with this old revolvers had been elderly auxillary railway policemen. Being german, i don't know current situation at Swiss Railway. In Germany first armed guards/ railway policemen with short sabers appeared in 19th century. In Imperial Germany there was Reichsbahn, but at least Bavaria and Württemberg, perhaps also Baden, had their own State railway ( after wwl) in 1920/21 this State railways had been included into Reichsbahn. Tasks of Railway Police: Protecting travellors in trains and stations, guarding freight in waggons and storage buildings, guarding trains, rails, and railway equipment. Until 1990s, when German Federal Railway ( Deutsche Bundesbahn) became semiprivate German Railway, a Railway Police, payed by Federal Republic existed). Then in early/ mid 1990s Federal Border Guard was transformed into Federal Police and Railway Police was included into Federal Police. So nowadays you can still in Germany see armed Federal Police in trains and stations, not allways and not everywhere. German Railway as a semiprivate company has also unarmed Security guards,but the have no police rights, other private Security guards also not.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
In traditional german military terminology, there is a difference between Gewehr and Karabiner. A Gewehr is a full length musket ( flintlock to wwll), while a Karabiner is a shorter long gun , in black powder era used mostly by cavallry , artillry and transport/supporting units. In black powder era often in the muzzleloader and singleshot cartidge carbines used lighter powder charges, often only pistol loads ( At first austrian M70 revolver and Werndl carbine used same cartidge, but different charges. But: When revolver cartidge was used in carbine, only Power and accuracy was smaller, but carbine cartidge version in revolver caused accidents, at least Magnum feelings. So for a long time fullsized Gewehre in musketsize had been the battleriflles. Most fighting men had been up to start of wwl infantry units, only armed with musketsize rifles and bayonnets, the few officers, flagbesrdrs, trumpeters with pistols and swords had been not important. The role of sniper rifle was long done by Jägerbüchse, at first civilian rifles, later standardized rifles with civilian features. Last Jägerbüchse was M71 Jägerbüchse. Ordinary M71, only traditional length ( between carbine and infantry rifle), a finger hook at trigger guard and more carefully produced barrels and Iron sights.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am german, Brittas boyfriend, only using her Computer too. Next to my home village there is a former monastry, founded in middleage, the time between 1000 and 1100, even after protestant reformation, the monstry had been owned by lutheran church, but of course no more monks. This monastry has some historical importance, because it was the grave monastry of some members of Hohenstaufen dynasty, which had been HRE Emperors between 1138 and 1254. From about 1200 to 1268 they also had been Kings of Naples. Two years ago i visited noted Lorch monastry and a small group of Hohenstaufen dynasty reenactors did some fencing training. One of the reenactors looked a bit arabian , and my girlfriend thought, this arabian looking man would be wrong. But: When Hohenstaufen dynasty ruled Kingdom of Naples, there was realy a small number of arabian muslims, living there as descendants of muslim invaders of 8th/ 9th century. Emperor Friedrich ll, who was als King of Naples realy had a small bodyguard unit, formed of muslims, living in southern Italy. The noted Emperor and King had lots of troubles with popes, and a bodyguard unit of muslims had no fear of papal , church ban'.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am german, Brittas boyfriend, Born 1965. Arround 1970 at german TV Station/Company ZDF started the tradition of ,Friday Evenig Crime Show'. Over the years some crime TV shows came, others came'. True fact is that in Germany ( both east and west) in 1950s to 1970s few women worked in police, mostly in detectves nranch, arround 1990 also in uniformed branch, women appeared, nowadays women in Police are normal. But in german TV crime shows for about a decade women are overrepresented. In former decades some nonethnic German actors appeared as policemen, which is correct, there are persons of nongerman ancestry, but now in some TV shows there are more nongerman qctors than german. Last year q TV crime Show appeared, only ethnic, sexual, social minorities. The Story/ plot was also not good, so after half the Episode i was very angry about this nonsens.
1
-
1
-
@neildiamondo6445 : Stuart, not Steward! This are two different things. I am german, nostalgic, and a Comeback of german monarchy ( in parlamentary version only) would be better than idiotic german republican policy of last twenty years. I , Brittas boyfriend, am rather dissappointed about the dangerous nonsens of Angela Merkel and the antigerman, antipatriotic behavior of German Federal Presidents Gauck and Steinmeier. They have totaly forgotten, that, AS german head of state, they are descendants of Charlemagne, Otto the Great and Frederik Barbarossa.
1
-
1
-
@letoubib21 : The next german gouvernement under Olaf Scholz will also not do much for the average german ( Social Democrats, Greens and Liberal Party/ liberal in german sense).
To the frankish tribe, those ones, which did not move to ,Realm of the Franks/ Frankreich', still live as Franken north of the Schwaben/ Swabians. And Karl Martell ( Martel - Hammer both in german and english) was Hausmeier/ Major Domus, the highest rank at court lower than the king, at he , not the merovingan king led the Army ( Heer/ here in old english). The other court offices (?) / Hofämter had been Mundschenk, Truchsess , Marschall , and perhaps Kämmerer. As longer as middle age lasted, this Hofämter had been more ceremonial and in case of Holy Roman Emperors election, done by electors/ Kurfürsten. The today high rank Marschall was once simply the Roßknecht/ horse servant ,Marhalasc', Mähre means in german ,bad horse' ( word has survived). That a Major Domus/ Hausmeier becomes king, no problem.
To Friedrich Barbarossa. I can see Hohenstaufen mountain from my village and was often there, few relicts of 1525 destoyed castle, but a beautifull view into landscape. A sidenote: Hohenstaufen and Hohenzollern are belonging to former duchy Swabia, same as Habichtsburg at Aargau / Switzerland. So Staufer, Hohenzollern and Habsburger have swabian roots.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
As a german, Brittas boyfriend, some notes. The german nickname for Junkers 52 was , Tante Ju' ( aunt Ju). Hitler was vegetarian, nonsmoker and antialcoholic, so not extraordinary, that no alcohol was served in his plane. ( And also no wonder, that i mistrust missionary hipsters/ modernlings who are vegetarian , nonsmokers and antialcoholic and tell me, how moralic they are.). In 80s i worked in a smaller maschine factory, at the end of finishing the maschines i build, i had to fix a small plate with a short instruction. German language for Germany, Austria and Switzerland. French language for France , parts of Belgium and Switzerland. English language for other countries. I had never heared of the in the video noted town Pocking, so i did not knew, which language for the plate. Peking ( Bejing), Nanking sounds similar, so i thougt, it is a chinese town, my coworkers laughed, when i asked them.
1
-
@mathiasbartl903 : a) My english is limited, i had to use a translation to understand your comment. b) Who do you mean, Horst Tappert or Günter Grass? c) Horst Tapperts most known TV show , Derrick' no more appeares in TV , but i can ' t remember, that there was so much trouble/ scandal about Günter Grass. But i have to addmit, that i am not so interessted in such intellectual ,high end' artists, their kind of art is not my thing, decades ago , one oft the pupils of my class said: When you read in the newspaper, a movie is ,künstlerisch wertvoll/ in artistic sense worthfull(?)' then it's boring shit'. I , Brittas boyfriend, think similar.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@kingrama2727 : So a german person like me is not able to notice a grammar mistake? A pistol, ordered by one of highest ranking german men as a present /gift is delivered with a writing error? The honoured soldier, reading the wrong engraving would have thought, Himmler is an idiot. Being a german metal worker myself, i know traditional german workers mindset , Sauberkeit der Arbeit ', i sometimes had to make items for first time customers/clients. This PR /presentation items had to be produced without any mistake. Then for about twenty years i was quality control man in a small metal company. A product ordered by an important, mighty client, delivered with a writing error? You think, the client is amused? In worst case, the customer is angry , and no more orders a product of your company. Sometimes i made a mistake when stamping type plate/ Typenschild, and had to use a new type plate. But a pistol slide with wrong engraving IS given to Himmler, or in his name to a soldier ? Come on, when you are no german / austrian, what do you know about german mentality? And papers and research? German Federal President Heinrich Lübke , was President in 1960s was a trained architect. One day architects drawings appeared, showing a simple wooden house / in german Barracke, drawed by Heinrich Lübke, with an ink stamp ,KZ ...' At first a scandal , but : The drawing was done by Heinrich Lübke, but the ink stamp was added by east german Stasi (red painted Gestapo). Weapons owned by famous people, with correct papers? You know the buckets of nails from cross of Jesus? And when an idiot of a nongerman nation spends a large sum of money for a fake? Good so, why are , in contrast to majority of german people, non germans so obsessed of Nazis? What would Hollywood do, if Hitler would have died in wwl? Telling the truth of overthrowing Hawaiian Monarchy? Telling the truth of , opening ' Japan?
1
-
1
-
1
-
@sjaakzwart6001 : At first, Britta is my girlfriend, i only use her computer also. At first, we germans have a saying: Wie man in den Wald hineinschreit, so hallt es zurück. My english is not so good: The way you shout into the forrest, the echoe comes back. So i had never problems with police or private security guards. The only time i had problems with police, was my own fault, i used my car being drunken. So it is possible , to have no problems with police and justice. For about 40years i hear leftwingers whining: Oh , we didn' t care about laws and order, and the terrible bad police is so bad against us best people of human history. Your fault, yours, not fault of others. I hate people, who don' t respect law and order for political or religious reason , and then cry, when they are in trouble. Especially leftwingers allways think, laws are a thing for other people, but not for us ethical/ moralist, political/ correct noblehumans.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@Intranetusa : A curved sword is in german usually called ,Säbel' ( saber) , when it is an european, indian, arabic, turkish or persian weapon. For weapons SOE decades ago not so known, we use today the word from the region, it comes from. When i, born 1965) was young, nobody said ,Machete', this tool was called ,Buschmesser' in contrast to billhooks ( most common german words for this tool are Hippe or Gertel). Also the word ,Hauer' ( hewer?) was formerly used for heavy , but not to long knifes , for example german hunting knife ,Waidblatt'.
1
-
1
-
@Intranetusa : The terms Kriegsmesser or langes Messer had been in my youth nearly unknown in Germany for weapons, may be historians/weapon collectors. What i, Brittas boyfriend, didn' t knew, is that in some german regions, for example in this part of Hesse Britta was born, a small kitchen knife is a ,Kneipchen' vor ,Kniep', clearly a german version of english knife. And the ,Messer' weapon. I think a german hunting knife ,Hirschfänger' is the still produced descendant of this weapon. Mostly single edged blade, and a shell like part of guard seems to be former Nagel. Some few companies still produce it, but today it is no more used for final stab of wounded game, but for hunters ceremonies or as present/ gift for wellrespected hunters. What is for german native speakers a bit funny, is the wrong use of ,langes Messer', because nongermans mostly do not know german grammar cases and plural ( das lange Messer, dem langen Messer, des langen Messers/ die langen Messer/ den langen Messern, der langen Messer).
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am german, born 1965. For reason of my Asperger disorder, i don't t like to speak to people if there is no need. So when i was younger, i rarely spoke with older people, who had been adults in 1930s. What i heared from my grandmother ( born 1910) was, they had been poor in 1918, they had been poor in 1920s, they had been poor in early 1930s. Mega Inflation of 1923 caused trouble, Black Friday at Wallstreet 1928 caused economic and political troubles.
If after 1918 the life of average german citizen would have becoming better, Democracy and Republic would have seen as a lucky gift, but If nothing becomes better ?The ,Golden Twenties' had been golden only for rich germans. This of course is only my oppinion, which can' t explain everthing.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@drox3992 : You are not the only non german , who makes this mistake with the forgotten second ,s'. As a german, Britta is my girlfriend, i use in daily life Standard German only for writing, i belong to those people who still prefer local dialect, in my case Swabian ( so i have fewer problems with Swiss german than most of my countrymen) . I speak Standard German only, when it is necessary. For the reason, that i can understand Standard German, Swabian dialect and some English, i can often understand the sense of a dutch sentence in written Dutch, but in Scandinavian languages i can mostly understand only some words, so i have to guess. From Icelandic language i have nearly no knowledge, it is told, that it is the oldest still spoken germanic language , but it seems also not easy.
1
-
1
-
1
-
RavenAdventwings: ??? I am german, Brittas boyfriend, only using her Internet Account. I am 59, middle education, german style trained worker, as you noticed i speak some english and few french, sometimes i write comments in french. As an Asperger person, i have few friends, but those people, who know me, know that i am a History Nerd. About ordinary History: As Kindergarten child my parents showed me Castle ruins in my homeregion. In 1971 a Kindergarten trip to a fairytale castle was first time i saw a Castle Like palace and real old weapons and armour, and was fascinated..ln elementary school i liked to watch Wildwest and Swashbuckler movies, got many books with such topic. For example Ivanhoe, Treasury' Island and lots of books from international unknown Karl May. But even being elementary pupil, i noticed differences in descriptions of Wild West guys armament in US movies and Karl Mays novels. Also hitting a large tin can, as substitute for a Great Helmet/ in german Topfhelm, showed even thin sheetmetall withstands heavy stickblows. I became scepticsl and wanted to know more. In later higher school time i went to public library and read all possible books about weapons, wars , hunting and expeditions of european explorers. In 1982 my jobtraining started, and i noticed , Arms Magazins exist, so i read them for 42 years now, about twenty years ago , i noticed, Magazins of military History exist. My homeregion is full of fortifications relicts from Celtic, roman, medieval, Renaissance , sometimes even baroque era, even, towns Ulm and Rastatt mid 19th century, and along rivers Elz and Neckar, some wwll fortifications relicts. Have visited much of them, often during hiking tours, for example i hiked some kilometers along former border between Imperium Romanum and Germania Magna. I read a Lot of books about military and civilian History. My homeregion is those Part of Germany, which was in HRE devided into 100 microstates, so every few kilometers was another souvereign state. To learn about this historical mess, i visited dozens of museums, collections, castles , palaces, monastries. Made a lot of guided historical tours ( in one tour, guide was a real princess). Met a number of noblemen, including a close relative of Charles lll. Spoke with guides, museum staff, historians, antiques Dealers, archeologists, reenactors, huntsmen, target shooters, former soldiers, policemen, security guards .... And for years i watch YouTube. So you think i am an idiot? Wallbüchsen ( in old days also called Hakenbüchsen) had been in use for fortifications ( wagonforts/ ships) defence from perhaps 14th to 19th century. They had been used as compromise, wider Ränge and power than a musket or rifle, but lesser recoil Power and weight than a cannon. Last use of German Wallbüchsen was in 1870/71 to shoot french gunboats on Seine River. Then in 1917( 18 ).the Tankgewehr appeared. An oversized rifle with oversized ammunition. So the same Idea than Wallbüchse. Lighter and more mobile than a cannon, but more powerfull than Standard rifle. So: Similar problems cause similar solutions. In early stages of wwl Trench warfare, a british unit took muzzleloader Coehorn mortars into trenches, gues why?
1
-
1
-
1
-
@DebbiesSanctuary49 : As a german person, i am Brittas boyfriend, born 1965, twenty years after end of wwll, next to Stuttgart. Why i tell this? For being born in 1965, i have heared, what happened in the time between 1933 and 1945, not honourous for my nation. It is a duty of german authorities, to speak about this, but in my eyes, they do it for the last 20 to 25 years in a such penetrant way, that it is to much, a german comdian said, they do it , that every german knows, how to do warcrimes, so they work more efficient the next time. But on the other hand, we Germans say: Von nichts kommt nichts ( Nothing comes from nothing = Everything has a reason). The reason, why there was so much hate in Germany against France formerly, is here nearly not told here, and perhaps not known outside of Germany ( The age of Napoleon and especially the brutal wars of french king Louis XIV), the events of this two times, which caused german hate, are nearly not the toppic of newspapers, TV or politicans speeches. In my eyes not good.
Another thing is watching war movies. I have no problem, when in nongerman war movies produced up to 1980s german soldiers are portrayed as bad persons, because i know the reason. But in an unbelievable way i was angryly surprised, when i watched a You Tube clip about German/ Danish war of 1864. At first i was interessted, oh a movie not about US civil war 1861 to 1865, but a movie about an european war. But after a few minutes i became very angry. Why? In the movie, produced not long ago, the following incident was shown: A danish footpatrol of a handfull soldiers was captured by a german horsepatrol of double size . For no reason the commander of german patrol, a tall, fat, baldheaded man with a partly burned face full of scars, ordered the execution of the danish soldiers. I think you can understand, that i as a german was angry about such an antigerman Propaganda scene in a movie produced only a short time ago.
But i don' t see myself as a nationalist. For different reasons, i traveled not so often in nongerman countries, than many of my countymen, but every trip ( journey?) was intressting for me, and in contrast to my grandfather and my greatgrandfather i could do this trips without rifle and Stahlhelm. I think, the times have changed in a good way, we should never return to nationalism, we should remember mistakes of history, but don' t use it again to produce hate.
1
-
1
-
@Simon_Nonymous : Former German Chancellor Bismarck once said: The greatest lies you will hear before an election, during a war and after a hunt. True. In a german military history magazine there was years ago a statement printed, a german General did 1913. When the General in 1913 retired, a Journalist asked him some questions. One was: What do you think about Propaganda? The General answered: Propaganda has reached a level, which is very bad. Modern Propaganda causes, that brave fighting enemies compleatly loose the honour they deserve! The General was right. Up to first half of 19th century war Reports often contained sentences etc. in which was written, it was difficult, to fight against such brave enemies, during second half of 19th century this behaviour of ,old days' ended, but modern hate Propaganda started.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
German/ English: Helm/ helmet, (der) Schild/ shield, Speer/ spear, Lanze/ lance, Schwert/ sword, Axt/ axe, Sattel/ saddle. Also Gabel ( Forke)/ fork, Hammer/ hammer, Schaufel/ showel, Spaten/ spade, Raspel/ rasp, Feile/ file, Stock/ stick....
1
-
@Lee-vk1xy : In YouTube there are videos where some ,jokelings' speak german with english grammar/ word order , or english with german grammar/.word order. Both sounds strange/ unusual, but having a brain, not totally ununderstandable . The astonishing thing is:: ln comments of english speakers, when hearing english spoken the ,german way' often you read: Hearing english spoken with german grammar gives me Shakespeare vibes. Also in videos about Old English you can read comments: I am english native, but in case of Old English my knowledge of current german helps more than speaking current english. My english is surely not perfect, but the fact that german and english are both westgermannic languages, helps a lot , anglosaxon part of english vocabulary has still so many similarities to german , that it is easy to learn , especially when you are intressted in outdated words or are a dialect speaker.
1
-
@Very_Silly_Individual : Wessex/ west saxons, Sussex/ southern saxons, East Anglia/ western angles. Angeln is still the name of a part of german/ danish borderland. Saxons? Niedersachsen is still named after the Saxons. So : The Homeland of Anglosaxons/ Angelsachsen was those region of Germany, where currently Low( land) German is spoken, which has still similarities to english ( for example: Reep/ rope, Forke/ fork, lütt/ little, but that was to high science for an US tourist i asked). So the Anglosaxons had been german? No, the move to Angelland Engelland England was in tribal age, when the tribes, forming the german nation had not been united, so no serious german would call the Anglosaxons german.
1
-
In 1945 famous Mauser collection in Oberndorf was stolen by french and US soldiers. Current Waffenmuseum ( weapons museum) is a very sad shadow of former times. A modernisation would be great, and especially the weapons, made by Mauser from mid 1880s to end of wwll are often in low to bad condition. There are few, but mostly well preserved weapons from Mauser forerunner Königlich württembergische Waffenmanufaktur ( Royal württembergian weapons manufacture). This state owned company was founded 1812 in a former monastry, because Württemberg in HRE and napoleonic age had no large gun company/.arsenal to arm its forces. The first two directors of Royal Weapons Factory had been two localy wellknown gunmakers/ gunsmiths ( in german this is only Büchsenmacher). Both , of course one , then the next one, had the right, to produce in addition to military weapons, still their known quality civilian firearms. So at least in ending flintlock era, you could order an expensive civilian firearm in Royal Weapons Factory, this was done by director himself . To Finish my description about museum. In addition to weapons of Mauser and Königlich württembergische Waffenmanufaktur also weapons of Heckler & Kock and Feinwerkbau / FWB ( a pure olympic competition weapons producer) are shown in good quality, some strange target pistols selfmade by Mauser workers and civilian Mauser products: Two different cars (!) , bureau machines, and measurement Equipment ( when i started my joblife in 1982, every Young Metal worker proudly showed his Mauser (!calipher). The entrance price IS cheap, and with the same Ticket you also can visit Oberndorf homeregion museum. Two parts are inressting : Rusty sword blades and speartips from germannic warrior graves and a picture from a funeral of 1916. It shows a german priest and a group of german soldiers at the funeral of two british pilots, shot down,, when they attacked Mauser Factory. Far away from wwl frontline, elderly soldiers still respected a brave enemy.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@Aiel-Necromancer : German here. Nazis exist in Germany, the NPD , which changed its name one or two Years ago, was in late 1960s founded by former NSDAP members. In early 1970s, this party came at one election in a single state over 5%. But since then , this party is no more important. Not long ago , german Gouvernement tried to forbid this party, but it was a total disaster for Gouvernement, because very lot high rank NPD members had been disguised inestigators of (Not centraliced ) interior intelligence service!!!! Also a party ,Dritter Weg' ( third path) exists. Then there is the astonishingly successfull party , Alternative für Deutschland ', a rather rightwing party. In my oppinion populist right. But those party is Not very liked, and has realy influence. In national and states Parlaments, in town or County councils they have members, but only less than ten mayors and only one Landrat/ Leader of a County.. Whom have you to blame for the unbelievable events/ incidents in current Germany ? Of course a large part of fast growing muslim population. In context of muslim SS Division Handschar, Heinrich Himmler noted: Islam is a religion, which creates brave warriors , and has some similarities to NS ideology. Main field imam of noted SS Division was a palestinianan man named ,al Hosseini'. Then the leftwing, woke, political correct mainstream. Including parties SPD, Grüne, die Linke, parts of FDP , CDU/ CSU. Also Protestant church ( Evangelische Kirche) is basicly a leftwing party today. Then typical leftwing circles of newspaper, TV, Art, universities, NGOs, sports, to some degree also Catholic Church. Germanys spirit is so dominated by described mainstream idiocracy, that you can see the result even outside the borders. I hope you can translate: Über Italien lacht die Sonne, über Deutschland die ganze Welt.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@panda756 : Being Brittas boyfriend, only using her Computer too. I am conservative rural German, 59, factory worker. For reason of my salary , and grown up in traditional swabian Spirit of my homeregion ( understatement), i can and want not to buy a Jaguar. From time to time a company needs to be , on height of the time' ( as we germans say), a new image is often no mistake. But: A new image affording traditional buyers ( Stammkunden) is in my personal oppinion unwise. The transformation to success in future must be done soft, but believeable. For example in an arms magazine i read an article about a luxury traditional austrian gunsmith ( gunmaker?) craftman. His hunting guns have modernest material ( including carbon fibres), modern technical features, but still craftsman made in old spirit, stock is a combination of traditional and modernist elements.
My oppinion is, when Tradition Companies want to change their image, then by modern up to date products, with a modern Interpretation of traditional elements, for example still keeping some small parts of wood Interieur as relicts of old days. I have Asperger disorder, and my english is limited, i hope you understand my thougt (?)/ Gedanken.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@joshuawinstead7621 : Swords of Spatha type had been used by every germannic ( including german) tribe. Being member of alemannic/ swabian tribe, i can say , from warrior graves of alemannic warriors, found in nearly every swabian/ swiss german village, seax ( in german Sax) was weapon of average/ poorer warrior, while Spatha was , in context of my tribe, from 3th to early 7th century an upper class warriors weapon. Being member of a germannic tribe, i don' t understand this Vikings nonsens. This had been germannics like me , similar customs, only being last germannics, praising germannic gods. Nonsenical hype.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
This Oriental prime ministers ,vizier' are in german language called ,Wesir'. When i, born 1965, you could sometimes read the word ,Verweser', which is nowadays no more used. I didn' t understand this word at first, because,verwesen' means, the dead body of a human or annimal is rotting. A Verweser is a person , which acts as substitute, when a Person , who is regular ,in office' dies, and the next Person, being regular , in office' is not yet elected or introduced. So a Verweser acted only in the time between the death of an important Person and the introduction of the next regular Person in the Position. May be the word Verweser is related to Wesir.
1
-
1
-
Flinte is shotgun in german language, rifle would be Büchse, here Mr. Felton made a mistake. Weib ( see similarity to english wife) is more difficult. Pike Fräulein, the use of Weib is today unwanted in Germany. 50 vor 60 years ago, Weib was often heard, mostly used by elderly people, as a word for a married woman (wife) for an elderly woman. In this case, Weib was nothing bad, simply outdated. But when an angry man shouted : Weiber or Weiberleut, then he was not amused about women, and some words had a negative sense, for example Mannweib ( which means a tall, strong woman, which looks not pretty). So in few words, it depends on context, if Weib is simply outdated for wife, or clearly has a negative sense.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
A note from Germany..From about 1200 to 1850 Holy Roman Empire of German Nation, and later German Federation had been no Great Power. Germany, until 1866 Ausria , Luxemburg and Liechtenstein had been part of Germany. A total nonsens of Video creator is, that Leopold of Hohenzollern - Sigmaringen was a prussian prince. Prussian dynasty was in reallity protestsntic branch of Hohenzollern dynasty, Hohenzollern - Brandenburg. Mountain and Castle Hohenzollern is not in former Prussia, but near Hechingen in Swabia, today State Baden-Württemberg. There had been two catholic swabian branches of Hohenzollern dynasty, Hohenzollern - Sigmaringen ( still existing) and Hohenzollern - Hechingen ( died out in 1857). In 1848 , during revolutions/ rebellions in Germany, the princes of swabian branches had to flee, and gave their territories to their mighty prussian relatives.
A note: From 1200 to 1871 the french where used to beat nonunfied and weak Germany, but in 1870/ 71 after six centuries they faced united power of german states and claimed german people are bad persons, a great french lie.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
When i , Brittas boyfriend, started in early 1980s to read weapons magazines in german language, i saw a similar gun in .22 Hornet, described as , Schonzeitbüchse'. Büchse means rifle, and Schonzeit is the time, when by german hunting law hunting is not allowed. In this Schonzeit the regular hunting guns are not in use, because hunting is not allowed. But when german hunters in this time do something in context with hunting, they carry a small rifle in .22 or shotgun in .410, for the case, something unexpected happens.
1
-
@roentgen571 : Some rich persons of noted graves had been burried with their items, but could be identified as christians: A cross, made of thin gold foil/ Blattgold was found on their face. And during a historical daytrip with a small historical society, the guide, a historical educated man, said, that some churches/ chappels outside of villages or town, have forgotten which saint, could be locations of former germannic religion. See St. Olaf in Skandinavia, he carries on statues hammer (!) or axe, similar to Donar.
1
-
One note from Germany: Up to mid 12th century, current Austria, with exeption of Vorarlberg state, was a part of Bavaria. In the first time of HRE the german part was divided into tribal duchies, todays Austria was the borderland (Mark, also in english/scottish borderland used) of Bavaria. This is the reason , why people of Austria ( except Vorarlberg), Oberbayern, Niederbayern, Oberpfalz and Südtirol/ Southern Tyrol can easily understand each other, the dialect of alpine regions is so similar, that nonbavarians can not say Bavarian or Austrian. I, Brittas boyfriend, am a member of swabian tribe, so it is for me easier to understand Swiss German than for other germans, because Swabians and Swiss Germans once had been the same tribe, same thing like Bavaria and Austria.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@frankberry6220 : When i was younger, there had been jokes about a (fictional) russian radio station. They started , that someone sent a question to the Radio Station: Is it possible, that...., and the radio station answered: In theory yes, but... That describes the situation about german , Notwehrrecht'( litealy Right of defence in emergency). On paper you can defend yourself when your honour, posesses (? Things you own), freedom, health or life is in danger, but not with unnecessary overpower. But, duels are as far as i know forbidden ( with exeption of Mensur fencing, which is by law no Duel) , but i never have heared, that you realy get punishment, when defending your honour with violence, was perhaps different in 1950s/1960s. When defending yourself in other four noted cases, it is in theory allowed, but: In contrast to earlier decades, today criminals are Holy, and when you hurt a saint, you are often in trouble, current judges in Germany are to criminals friedly, i think, you know this from your country and are not surprised. Weapons? Currently you can carry pepper or CS Spray, smaller Kubotan, socalled tactical pens and knives ( single edged, fixed or twohand opening up to 12 cm ( 4 and 4/5 ") blade. In rural areas no problem, in urban areas causing more and more trouble. Currently, you know it perhaps from TV, we have a large problem with knife attacks/ murders, caused, similar to your country, often by foreign chirurgical experts ( Irony!). Our Gouvernement knows, what to do, and coming soon, Daggers, Fighting Knives and automatic are forbidden, and only knives with 6cm ( 2 and 2/5") are allowed to carry.As a Brit, you know, how well this will work. Since 2008 a licence , Kleiner Waffenschein ' is necessary for carry a blank gun, firing CS or pepper blanks. A note: Up to early 1890 ordinary german policeman had no pistol, only a short saber ( similar to 18th /early 19th century infantry saber, or the british police saber Matt Easton showed in one of his videos), but more and more criminals used pistols. Had three results: a) Up to 1913 every german policeman had a pistol b) a carry licence for pistols was introduced ( Waffenschein) c) About 1905 licencefree blankguns appeared. So blankguns no licence from 1905 to 2008 ( Wilhelm ll, austrian painter). The noted carry licence Waffenschein still exists, but is rather difficult to get. According to german language weapons magazines today most owners of this licence are armed Security guards, private citizens, in contrast to former decades lesser.
Licencefree ( as i noted, law restrictions will come soon) are currently airguns lesser than 7. 5 Joule ( in german i would use , instead of .), bow/ crossbow, for a loophole some airpowered small harpoons, match-, wheel - and flintlock muzzleloaders, singleshot Percussion muzzleloaders, blankguns, teargas/ pepperspray , Police batons ( No Blackjack/ cosh), and Most nonfirearms, if they are not concealed, for example in a cane. But: Licencefree weapons must be locked away in a box or similar. So you are defenceless against a sudden intruder. So basicly german population is defenceless, and Gouvernement tries to make lawfull people totally defenceless, and when a person successfully defends himself or a person in danger, what do you think, who gets troubles? Arms of all kind (especially in civilians hands) have a bad reputation among policy, media and the very onfluntial leftwing circles. Those three groups allways say, only ,State' is allowed to use violence, but the , immerwährender Landfrieden ' of 1496 only means, that disputes must be solved by judges, lawyers, law and court, not with violence, especially the Fehderecht ( Right of Feuds) for Knights and Nobles had to end. As far as i know, in same time periode, there was a similar thing called , Yeomanry Act' to reduce armed retinue of nobles. Both Landfrieden and this Yeomanry Act was about personal defence of civilians.
1
-
@frankberry6220 : You can still buy batons in police style, but since 2008 it is for ordinary civilians no more allowed, to carry them. Only licenced private Security personal on duty can still do this (there is an exeption, in cases of Theater the actors can carry them on stage, in March i watched a theater comedy, in which the actor, playing the policeman,was armed with a baton), also when you are in your own garden with a Baton, because you heared strange noises, usually trouble, but no real punishment. Pepperspray and CS ( still produced) can be carried by ordinary civilians, exeption: Sport events, political events, parades , festivals, in current time also Sprays in Public transportation or City centers can cause trouble for the owner. By law pepperspray is in Germany only allowed as defence against dogs ( or other dangerous annimals), but using pepperspray in real danger is often not seen as unlawfull. To those airguns, firing rubber- or pepperballs, i can write nothing, other thay you currently can buy ( but not carry) weak versions, but i can't speak about usefullness of this items. But now i am tired for today, have a nice evening!
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Matthias Behrendt: Da mein Kommentar inzwischen gelöscht ist, weiß ich nicht mehr, was genau ich geschrieben habe. Es ist richtig, daß Deutsche ( hier mit Österreichischern und Schweizern), Niederländer/ Flamen, Engländer und Friesen, Nachkommen der Westgermanen sind, die zur Zeit des Römischen Reiches die Bewohner von Germania Magna, zum Teil auch der Provinzen Germania Superior und besonders Germania Inferior waren. Aber man kann die damaligen Westgermanen doch nicht als Deutsche, Niederländer etc. bezeichnen. Der englische Sprachgebrauch ist verwirrend, während wir deutschsprachigen Menschen sorgfältig zwischen Deutschen und Germanen unterscheiden. Darauf will ich hinaus, und nicht auf eine völkerkundliche Sensation.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
At first, don' t underestimate training and skill of former craftsmen! I, german style trained worker, am allways astonished , what my ,coworkers ob the old days' could do, when i visit a museum. First anti tank weapon : Mauser Tankgewehr from 1918, first anti air weapon: A handfull 37 mm Krupp anti ballon guns of 1870/71, but unsucessfull.
This Fliegerfaust was also, like noted weapons, first step of rocketbased man portable anti air weapon. But, according to german arms/ military history Magazins, the Fliegerfaust was nearly useless against ground fighters, may be against spotter planes or similar non fighters.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am german and Brittas boyfriend, only using her Computer. I was born in 1965 in an ( in those days) rural area, as son of of a man, who was both factory worker AND part time farmer ( in german Nebenerwerbslandwirt). I have ,middle education' and a german style trained metal worker (Facharbeiter).
This means, i am no accademic or scientist, History is for me only a Hobby, in dated german a , Steckenpferd '. But living in a Region, where you can find relicts from Celtic, Roman , Alemannic and medieval/renaissance era, also few stone- and bronceera relicts, i am intressted in History since i have seen Lichtenstein Castle ( and Bear Cave) at a Kindergarten trip. So, after fifty years of historical interesst, reading many books and magazines, visiting lots of museums, castles , collections and historic sites, i think , i have a solid basic knowledge of History.
But: For about twenty years i more and more get angry. Why? It is the political correctnes/ woke Nonsens. In ,historical ' movies to much of of the appearing Characters act as political corect woke persons of today, but not like persons of the era, in which the movie plays.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
When in the years after 1867, when Shogunate was abandoned, the now again ruling emperors wanted a modern army, at first they asked the country , with the strongest army, in this days France,, after 1871 Germany , for instructors. The Japanese noticed, that the use of bajonett, formerly unknown in matchlock era, had similarities to Yari and Naginata polearms, so a bayonnet technic based on Yari and Naginata was created.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@d10s_ad : A difficult question. Before the Romans conquered the region i live, it was settled by celtic people. May be you can inform yourself in Wikipedia about celtic settlements ,Heidengraben', ,Heuneburg' or ,Ipf'. I live about 30km/20 miles away from former Roman/Germanic border ,Limes' and also from Norder between roman provinces ,Germania Superior' and ,Rhaetia', border between this provinces was between towns Lorch and Schwäbisch Gmünd. So when my alemannic ancestors overrun Limes in 260 after Jesus Christ, i don' t know how romanized the celtic people had been, or how many ,Romans' from all over ,Imperium Romanum ' lived there. I also don' t know, if there was any hate between celtic and germanic people. A may be curious fact for you : The germanic English called the people of Wales welsh ( non germanic), the alemannic Swissgermans call the nongermanic people of Wallis welsch. Formerly in german language ,die Welschen' meant nongerman people, for the last time i heared this in 80s by an elderly coworker.
1
-
In the three german language countries Switzerland has still the Most liberal gun law, but was restricted in 1999, and few years ago by force of EU. Austrias gunl: aw was restricted in 1996 and again when joining EU ( Switzerland IS No member of EU), in 2015 posssibilty of licencefree buying of side by side shotguns ended, but law is, according to Austrian citizens still ok. Germany: Hardest gunlaw in german language countries (and much harder than other european countries) In 1971 licencefree buying of singleshot .22 rifles ended ( licencefree buying of pistols for microcartridges 4mm rimfire and 4mm M20 ended 1975- Gouvernement has forgotten this cartridges in 1972!), carrying a blankgun without CCW licence ended 2008, was allowed from Kaiser Wilhelms days!). In case of guncrime Austria IS safest country, Switzerland slightly Higher, Germany with highest guncrime.
Don' t knowing Swiss and Austrian situation: It was from Kaisers days to 1980s difficult, but not Impossible to get a CCW licence in Germany, from 1980s to 2000s more difficult, and from 2000s to now nearly Impossible, with exeption of some Security Guards.
The Royal Armoiries Channel (from Great Brittain) some weaks ago showed an 18th century Fencing book, from an italian, living in London. A commenter wrote : Intressting, a book Made in London, by a french educated italian fencer. Annother commenter: London is still a place to find bladed weapons experts from exotic places. Same Situation in Germany: Since 2015 ( Merkels migrants nonsens) WE have rising knife and rape crime by migrants. There have been cases, Muslim imigrants Gang raped a fifteen Years old girl, without getting Put to prison! Gouvernement , Judges, politcal Parties ( with exeption of one), churches, artists, media are supporting criminals ( especially when nongerman and Muslim), problems only for germans and people, defending themselves.
I am 58 now, but I have never Seen and expected such an Idiocracy in Germany. And politicians are so surprised, that a right - Wing Party is sucessfull.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@admDanRyan : I use a ,tablett' computer with touchsceen, so èéêėë,üûùúū,öòóõōøœ,äâàáæãåā,ßšś,ñń are no problem, to find ç i have to use a trick. For my german i only need ä, ö, ü and the slowly dissapearing ß. But you can write ä as ae, ü as ue or ö as oe, this is also correct german.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I, Brittas boyfriend, am no expert. Not only Lange Pistole 08 ( intended for artillrymen), also Pistole 04 ( for Imperial German Navy) with 15cm Barrel ( artillry Modell 20cm Barrel) had such a Stock Board ( Anschlagschaft). According to german language arms magazines, the reason was, that german Navy Headquarters knew, that most sailors or Navy personal was low trained with rifles, and bad with pistols, so they hoped , the Stock and 15 cm barrel helps the Navy soldiers, when serving as Boarding party, harbour patrol or similar Things, when they have no rifle, but need something more than bayonnet or cutlass. Not long ago Matt Easton of ,scholagladiatora' channel made a Video, that on many british warships of wwl ( and even some old ones in wwll) there had been Boarding pikes ! Those stocked pistols in metall cartridges era had been a substitute ( don' t know, how to translate, Behelf'), when a soldier, who had only a pistol, had the necessarity to fire at longer distance, than usual. In time of flintlock/ percussion pistols, the situation was different. With exeption of may be officers, flagbearers or musicans, soldiers on foot had no pistols, and no need for a stocked pistol. May be artillry men, transport , or engeneers/pioneers, or medical personal. But giving them stocked pistols? To expensive, older, a bit worn out muskets, cut to carbine length had been cheaper. So sometimes stocked pistols had been given to cavallry. While US cavallry consisted only of dragoons ( Dragoner) and perhaps ,mounted rifles, european countries had in flintlock/ percussion era different classes of cavallry, with different roles. In flintlock era the dragoons started a mounted infantry, being able to serve as ,auxillary heavy cavallry ', in 1760s they became heavy cavallry, being able to serve as , auxillary infantry '. So they had often no pistols ( or only one) , but a slightly shortened musket and bayonnet, similar to sea soldiers/ marines, and a heavy sword. Hussars had sabers. some had only a pair of pistols, but most also carbine. Hussars needed carbines, because as spies, scouts, escorts or , Special operations men' , they often had been on foot, and the enemies in distance. On other Hand, in flintlock era, there had been cuirassiers. Work as Scout, spy , escort, Special operations men, or military Police was not their Task. They had been tall, strong men, riding tall, strong horses, wearing cuirass, hats, reinforced with sheetmetal or thick wires ( sometimes still helmets), and had been armed with a heavy sword and a pair of pistols ( few had a carbine). Their Job was, to a attack a noticed weak spot in enemies Battleline in frontal , Steamroller attack' to break a hole in enemies battleorder. So in flintlock/ percussion era, those stocked pistols had been often given to such cavallry Units, having few carbines .
Civilian context. I am german, so my comment is about german Situation. A sidenote: Up to 1866 Austria was regular part of HRE and later German Federation, Switzerland was in reality up to 1499, in theory up to 1648 part of HRE. It is possible, that german nobles, or wealthy towns citizens traveled from second half of 16th century up to Napoleonic era with a pair of long , Saddle pistols ' in saddle holster (wheellock, then flintlock), and that few of those wealthy men bought a stocked pistol pair, in case, a Kind of carbine is necessary against robbers. It is also possible, that a german language wealthy
It is also possible, that in flintlock era a wealthy german language Gentleman bought a stocked pistol, for the case, being surprisingly invented to a Parforce hunt. With exeption of these two cases, using the pair of saddlepistols with a Stock as substitute for a carbine in selfdefence, or as substitute for an ordinary hunting gun, i can in german language context only Imagine one context. Poachery, where a poacher splits His shortened gun into pieces, to hide them under a coat, or the opposite. A wealthy , Herrenjäger' with a hunting licence, who carries a stocked pistol under his coat, for surprisingly appearing Game.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@Ukraineaissance2014 : A) With exeption of German Empire, the four (!) Axis Powers had No colonial troops. B) The German colonial forces had been, compared to colonial troops of allied forces in colonies of same size rather small, and, before 1914 in Kamerun and Deutsch Ostafrika half of troops had been Schutztruppe ( Military), half Kaiserliche Landespolizei ( Police). In Togo there was only Kaiserliche Landespolizei, in Deutsch Südwestafrika there had been only White men in Schutztruppe and Landespolizei, in chinese Tsingtao had been with exeption of German Port and fortifications Garrison only a weak company of chinese policemen. And in german Südsee territory there was only the Polizeibataillon, formed by natives. So: The German colonial forces had been weak, and could not reinforce German Main Army. But for their small size, they did a good Job. C) Why do you count Austria- Hungary and Croatia, Slovenia , Czechia??? Czechia was as Böhmen/ Bohemia a part of HRE since 10th century ( when in 955 for the first time an Army appeared , consisting of levies from all german ( not germannic) tribes, the Bohemians had been the rearguard), in 1914 Czechia was part of Austria (together with Mähren/ Slovacia and parts of Poland, and Croatia/ Slovenia was part of Hungary, together with Bosnia- Herzegowina and parts of Romania. D) None of Axis Powers had free Access to sea , so they had a Lack both of food and raw Materials. A sidenote to US behaviour in wwl. From 1914 to 1917, US Governent lied about neutrality. They had NEVER been neutral in wwl, they allways supported France and Brittain by delivering weapons and ammunition, they said Britisch armed merchant ships, they need an armament for defence against U- Boote and german Raiders, but they declared German armed merchant ships as warships.
Don' t belief all Allied Propaganda! Remember Saddam Husseins atomic bomb rockets and mobile chemical weapons production, both never existed, but was used as Propaganda for an Attack war. US Economy and Hollywood are experts in PR, so Propaganda lies are an easy thing for them.
1
-
@mailforbid1989 : Before German troops used Poison Gas, nearly every nation tried something chemical, but not deadly in small number. Teargas was used, according to a german military history magazine, the french started teargas use. Usually teargas is not deadly, but when soldiers are next to an Explosion of a teargas Grenade the in this moment rather concentrated teargas is possibly deadly. According to the noted article in the german Magazine, also grenades filled with ,Juckpulver' had been fired. I don' t know, how to translate Juckpulver, it is a powder usually sold in small paper bags. You open the small bag, and secretly fill the Powder from behind in the collar of a Person, shortly later the Person begins to Scratch himself. This Powder, popular in my youth, has now become rare, because Humor Style changed.
1
-
1
-
@LeeroyJenkinss : I am german, Brittas boyfriend, a conservative, rural , and nostalgic man. This means , i like my country like you like your country. I personally would have no problem with a parlamentaric monarchy. The change of systems in 1918 was no benefit for my country and Nation. It caused uprisings of communism , Bavaria (!), Saxony and Ruhr Area, Nationalist uprisings , Hitler- Kapp Putsch. If possible, i would give you a slap as powerfull as possible for your moralistic ignorance. Constitutional Monarchy was not ideal in Germany, also Constitution of 1871 caused problems, unbelieveable to US citizens. Then after the to early death of Friedrich ( Frederik) lll, Wilhelm Ii was a bit to young as new Emperor. Also, Wilhelm was not ideal for the position of German head of State, for reason of his Person. His younger brother Heinrich would have been , in my eyes, the better Emperor. He was no loudmouth and was very interessted, to hear, what other people think. If Wilhelm ll in 1913 died by falling from his horse at a hunting Trip, everybody would say, oh Wilhelm Ii was a rather strange man, but he was not involved into wars. But did German Population had a better life after 1918? A clear NO! My grandmother ( 1910- 1995) allways told me, when speaking about the time before 1950s: Oh, we allways had no Money! This poorness didn' t change from Imperial Age to , Economic Wonder' ( Wirtschaftswunder) of 1950s. Democraty didn' t change in 1918 life of German citizens into a better direction! You are a rarely seen uneducated Person. Please inform yourself what good moralistic Americans did after 1830s! Please inform yourself about the numbers of US citizens killed on regular US soil by foreign troops to the number of non US citizens killed by US forces on Non US soil. You notce something? Yes , the truth is hard.
1
-
1
-
@catbear3294 : The most common name in german for an ordinary tie being used with a shirt is nowadays , Krawatte ', and those different looking tie, which doesn' t hangs down to the belly, usually when fine dressed Gentlemen wear a Smoking ( Tuxedo?) is usually called , Fliege ' ( Fly). When i was young, for ordinary ties also the words Binder or Schlips had been used. In an old TV clip from late 1960s a traditional correct old Swiss detective asked german TV viewers , if they know something about a murderd German, they found in Switzerland. The policeman used the word ,Querbinder' to describe a tie of ,Fliege' type. Before and after i have never heared someone using this word. So, you sometimes find someone, who uses a totally unexpected word.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I come from Germany, may be 30km/20miles away from former fortified border line ,Limes' between Imperium Romanum and Germania Magna. Not to far away is the town Aalen , in local dialect Åla,, there was once a fortified Roman Garrison for a pure cavallry unit called Ala ( town name Aalen/ spoken Åla!). In museum ( Limesmuseum) is told that in roman time also mixed infantry/ cavallry units existed.
To the ,Legion Cavallry Unit': From 19th century up to 1920s, in adition to Swiss dragon regiments, there had been small groups of horsemen called ,Guiden', added to every brigade/ division.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Spinner und Verrückte gibt es überall. Aber die Tatsache, daß es seit 955 ( Lechfeldschlacht) eine deutsche Militärtradition gibt, ist nun einmal so, Es wäre meines Erachtens sinnvoll, Dinge die schon vor 1933 da waren, nicht so zu verdammen, wie das heute der Fall ist. Meiner Meinung nach sollte auf üble Dinge hingewiesen werden, aber nicht so zu tun, als sei die Bundeswehr aus dem Nichts entstanden. Ob dies hilft, Auswüchse zu verhindern, weis ich allerdings nicht.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@TheSfoil : I can understand you, this is the reason , why i wrote about such blank guns, they look like a PPk, use blanks and give the ,feeling'. Thats in my country, Germany , the only thing you can buy, lookalikes of wellknown guns. How long this will be possible?
I don' t know the laws of your country about such blankguns, and if the cartridges are sold there, but logic is often not to be found in laws about weapons.
1
-
1
-
@lordvetinari6057 : With the correct licence, you can own a PPk, but for Fangschuss in 9 mm kurz, 7,65 Browning is seen today too weak. In my former comments, i meant licencefree ,weapons. I, Brittas boyfriend, read Visier, Deutsches Waffenjournal and Schweizer Waffenmagazin since early 80s And i know , that BOTH. groups with green flags are dangerous for Germany.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@marietteestabrook4098 : Is in those areas of Germany ,which had been in time of Imperium Romanum the roman provinces Germania Inferior, Germania Superior and Rhaetia nothing uncommon. For example in region Ellwangen/ Aalen you can walk for kilometers along former fortified border Limes, similar to Hadrians Wall. Was formerly a stonewall , the relict is a well visible little rampart (?) ,covered with many bushes. Strange (???) coincidence: In Aalen once a large roman cavallry unit Ala had its fortified barracks. A note: In english wall means a wall of stones, bricks or concrete, in german a Wall is made of wood, earth or sandbags. And in addition to Roman relicts, alemannic relicts , my homeregion has relicts of celtic fortifications/ Towns, inform yourself about Heidengraben, Heuneburg or Ipf. But thats not all, there are dozens of medieval Castle Locations. So finding relicts, being very old is in european countries nothing unusual. A huge problem are this Treasury hunters with metal detectors, this criminals destroy historical sites for their greed for historical items, they make historical sites often worthless for serious scientists.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@michaelpettersson4919 : Today most fortresses are out of use.but up to early 90s this was , for example in Switzerland ,still a thing. You also know Westwall, Atlantikwall , perhaps also Ostwall ( englisch wall is german Mauer/ german Wall is english rampart). The Maginot line in France or the greek Metaxa(?) wwll line is also knowm. The Chinese Wall , the roman Limes ( including Hadrians Wall) and perhaps the austrian ,Militärgrenze' to the Ottoman Empire is perhaps also known or the Danewerk. Here in Germany some Reichsstädte/ imperial towns surrounded their territory with a Landhege/ Landhag. This had been two manmade ditches, the removed earth became a rampart between the ditches, and trees , hedges and thorny bushes had been planted on the rampart. Not a military obstacle, but trsvellers and merchants were forced to use allowed roads and border stations. Also against french attacks a lot of Linien/ lines existed especially in south- western Germany, this was a chain of wood- earth fortifications, wooden watchtowers, little rivers,, fences, earth ramparts, palisades, pointy poles etc., some obstacles to slow down enemy advances, and often not manned by trained soldiers, but by untrsined men with improvised weapons.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@Jim-6million : My point was, those persons, comming from european countries centuries ago, have still their foreign name, but are totally integrated and feel themselves as german. The european foreigners from western, northern or southern europe make few to no troubles, people from Russia or Balkan states sometimes. Noneuropeans from Eastern Asia, India or Latin America are not to much and cause rarely troubles. South Sahara africans cause more troubles ( some are dangerous), but Muslims are most unliked foreigners here, l am Brittas boyfriend, only using her Computer, i personaly assume, that when i get as old as my parents currently are, i die in 2050s in a Muslim country. But here in Germany working class people like i am , are seen as idiots ....
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@DieGoetterdaemmerung : Oh, the ones on northern end of Schwäbische Alb, are often build at impressive places fortified by nature, but very small and only one Tower. Most of them are today only ruins with small walls, few are still with large standing Walls, but many are nearly unvisible today, only flat, nearly filled ditches and a one foot high rampart, being once the Wall.
Some had been after 1500 transformed into modern Fortress or palaces/ manourhouses, but most castles had been in my region either destroyed in 1525 farmers revolt, or had been simply abandonned in late middleage, when especially owners of small castles became poor and could no more care their castles. They sold it to richer nobles and became mercennaries or went in service of high noblemen as diplomats, officers or officials. But the new owners had not been intrssted in a castle in bad condition, they only wanted the land and rights belonging to the Castle. The castles became ruins, and had only one necessarity: If there are doubts about the rights of new owners Family, they could show: Look i have the rights, See the former Castle.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Luís Andrade : Before 1556 the Reichstag was a ,meeting' of men from all german states ( few women from imperial womens monastries) which happened unregularly and not at the same place. After 1556 the ,immerwährende Reichstag' / continuing Reichstag ' took place at Regensburg, so in my eyes ( i am no academic) it became a kind of Parlament. Now the german Parlament is called Bundestag, while the Bundesrat is a descendend of oldstyle Reichstag, here from every state some members come, depending on population. Same was in ,Weimar Republik' , the Parlament was called Reichstag, and current swedish Parlament is the ,Riksdag'. So medieval Reichstag is different from former Reichstag of Weimar or current Bundestag, in Germany the old word .....tag has changed its meaning, but the word itself is still in use. Also the Parlaments of german federal states / Bundesländer are called Landtag, which was in HRE time also different.
1
-
The prussian army had been in fact the troops of Kingdoms Prussia and Saxony, Great Duchies of Oldenburg, Hessen- Darmstadt, Mecklenburg- Schwerin, Mecklenburg- Strelitz, Sachsen - Weimar - Eisenach, Duchies of Braunschweig, Anhalt , Sachsen - Coburg- Gotha, Sachsen - Meiningen, Sachsen - Altenburg, principalities of Lippe- Detmold, Waldeck- Pyrmont, Schwarzburg- Sondershausen, Schwarzburg- Rudolstadt, Reuß- Schleitz, Reuß- Greitz, the hanseatic towns Hamburg, Bremen and Lübeck. Also the ,Felddivisions' of Württemberg and Baden seem unknown to you.
1
-
1
-
As far as i know, the man who killed Philipp of Swabia with a mace (?) was the Burggraf/ Castle Count of Nuremberg, this possition was hold by a branch of Hohenzollern dynasty, which later became Brandenburg/ Prussian branch. Arround Hohenzollern Castle, on Swabian Alb, up to three swabian branches existed, today only swabian branch Hohenzollern - Sigmaringen exists. In 1849 the King of mighty prussian branch got the two Principalities of small swabian branches as new province, the two Princes noticed during Revolution, that they needed Help from their mighty relatives. In late HRE the prussian Hohenzollern sometimes in wartime with Habsburg dynasty, used their swabian relatives for diplomacy. The swabian Hohenzollern had been related to prussian branch, but being powerless and catholic, they had good relations to Habsburg dynasty. A Last sidenote: Habsburg, Hohenzollern and Hohenstaufen dynasties came from medieval duchy , Swabia '!
1
-
1
-
1
-
A) At late wwl Allied Powers promised the Arabs an own large kingdom, and betrayed the Arabs, they got no own kingdom, their land became british and french protectorstes. B) Since First century after Christ no lsrael / jewish state existed. The Arabs , since 7th century population majority , and they saw, that now, protected by christian colonizers , a large number of jews arroved and got special rights, both caused anger. C) After wwl , life of german citizens became not better. My grandmother , born 1910, often told me about the poornrss of those days. So the people had been as poor than before, and the Versailles Treaty caused that lots of german money went out of country , and could not help own country or nation. D) From 1792 to 1815 France caused millions of dead peoples outside France, poorness and suffering of many nations. But : After 1815 no loss of territory, no loss of colonies, no reparations, no military restrictions. Caused much anger in Germany ( but also in Austria - Treaty of St. Germain, or Hungary- Treaty of Trianon). E) Spanisch Civil war: Socalled Democrats/ Republicans are wrongly heroised and praised by Hollywood, Allied Powers or artists like Ernest Hemingway. But: 1930s Communists/ Socialists had been simply red painted Nazis, and Soviet Union, supporting the socalled Democrats/ Republicans was a dictatorship like Germany and ltaly , supporting the Nationalists. And the on socalled democratic side fighting paramilitary Assalto units did lots of crimes. F) The role of Franctireurs, Partisans and Freedom Fighters. Such persons fighting against german forces 1870/71, 1914/ 18, 1939/45- bravest herores of all time. Such persons fighting against nations of allied powers ( for example spanish guerillas in napoleonic spain, irish 1916/ 1921, or in conflicts after 1945, for exeption decolonisation)- Gangsters, terrorists, bandits. A strange difference. G) SS Commander Heinrich Himmler noted: Islam is a religion, which creates brave warriors, and contains some similarities to National Socialism. Pure nonsens, or a grain of truth ( compare : Masculinity, warriors spirit, hate against jews, men and women, humans of different worth)? H) A radical palestinian muslim , Mohammed Amir al Hosseini, fled from British protectorate Palestine to Germany, because member of Allgemeine ( general) SS, became highest field imam of muslim SS Division Handschar , and flooded Balkan and egypt/ palestinian/ syrian region with loads of very radical muslim Propaganda, with wooven in some Nazi ideology. The man died in early 1970s and heavy influenced Jassir Arafat. I) When i , Brittas boyfriend, born mid 1960s in rural West Germany, was young, we had three important polical parties. The CDU , supporters of economy, traditions, and liked by all conservatives, wanting a conservative, but not nationalist Germany. The SPD, classical workers party ( since imperial days), supported by persons , who wanted a Germany with lot of social ideas, but no Communism. And FDP, a between party. In those time, you could be sure, you know what you get, when you vote for a Party, you prefer, but the politicians of other Parties are also serious persons. But arround 1980 this system got a crack, which turned Germany 's policy and country into the worse condition, we have now: A new political movement appeared : The Green Party. J) ln german national and state parlaments a bunch of leftwingers, unshaved, long hair and beards, no formal dress , respectless behaviour appeared..l was shocked about this persons, and from first hour of appearing, i , conservative/ rural worker dissliked them ( until now, no change). Why? This are intolerant leftwingers, not respecting other ideas, and they Claim to be peacefull and don't support political violence. A total lie! Up to now, they never did anything against leftwing violece. In 1980s , members of traditional Parties didn' t like Green Party too, see YouTube clips from 1980s with speeches of Helmut Schmidt (SPD) or Franz Josef Strauß ( bavarian CDU called CSU). But Green Party was heavy supported by leftwingers, especially from university or art context. K) Communist SED party of Eastern Germany was never forbidden or destroyed, under name ,Die Linke' the party is still in bussines and Parlaments. In contrast NSDAP is never existing , current Nazi Party ,Die Heimat' ( formerly NPD) was founded in 1969 by former NSDAP members. L) ln 1970s/ 80s the three old West German parties warned against Communism and Green Party. This totally stopped in early 1990s, when there was a number of crimes, done by rightwing nationalists. Since now you have an anticonservative/ antipatriotic wave of Propaganda from united political Parties ( of course not AFD) , christian churches, leftwing dominated newspapers, TV, universities, NGOs. Believing them, behind every bush a Nazi IS louring and end of world is comming soon. But on other hand: All the noted orgasations hide/ Cover the crimes , murders , rapes done to German citizens by foreign, often muslim criminals. I notice this for over Thirty Years now. The point is reached, where i get angry. The formerly conservative patriotic CDU is , caused by Merkel no more patriotic, SPD became heavy leftwing ( danish similar party not), and with Green and Linke we have two Parties openly against german, european and christian traditions. They Work together as United Standard Party. As a midlevel / Mittlere Reife educated person, trained worker / Facharbeiter i am shocked, that especially in Green Party people are in Parlaments, with No sucessfull accademic or traditional craftsman training . In your result, that many germans are idiots, supporting criminals, leftwing and Muslim extremists, you are absolute correct. But when you openly say the truth, you are called here a terrible Nazi and idiot. Nothing against you, but send your Video to all political German parties, Gouvernements, Media, Universities, NGOs and Churches. Not every german is so brainwsshed Like them, ordinary man on sidewalk IS often more intelligent! And: Am deutschen Wesen soll die Welt genesen, is a behaviour, german Gouvernement should Stop at once, even they do IT for 150 years.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@speedofbra9104 : Nun ich, Brittas Freund , Jahrgang 1965, bin im schwäbischen Geist erzogen worden . Ich stelle mir eher die Frage, ob ich all dies was es gibt, auch tatsächlich brauche. Obwohl ich noch nie eine Fernreise gemacht habe, lebe ich noch ( bin noch nie in einem Flugzeug gesessen und damit weniger umweltschädlich als Grünenpolitiker), in den 70er Jahren haben meine Sommerferien aus Heu- bzw. Öhmdernte in der Nebenerwerbslandwirtschaft meiner Eltern bestanden. Reisen? Drei Mal eine Woche Vorarlberg, und 1980 kam der Umbau des Hauses. Ich benötige vieles nicht. Früher war nicht alles Gold, aber wenn ich manche Menschen höre, wie schlecht alles früher war, da Frage ich mich, wie die Menschheit seit dem Australopithecus überlebt hat. Jene Modernlinge, die kein Verständnis für Tradition haben und nur alles über den Haufen schmeißen wollen, verstehe ich nicht. Und noch ein Wort zum Frauenbild der 70er Jahre. Die oft als Goldstücke, Merkelgäste, Vollpensionsgäste etc. bezeichneteten Menschen haben ein ähnliches, oder schlimmeres Frauenbild , werden aber nicht kritisiert.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@donwyoming1936 : As a real Revolver for current .22 short with smokeless powder , surely. I am german, Brittas boyfriend for reason of our gunlaw, in Germany only few collectors would buy such a small pistol. But when you watched all of Ians Videos, you may remember the Scheintodrevolver. From ca. 1905 to 2008 you could buy and carry without a CCW licence/ Waffenschein a blankgun. Since 2008 a CCW licence , light ' is necessary, pure buying is still allowed ( but German Gouvernement tries to end this). Currently those pistols are made of zinc alloy, with few steel parts, to make it difficult , to transform a blankgun into a .25/.32 gun.
Most of this pistols are , lookalikes' of modern designs for 9mm PAK ( semiauto) or 9mm R for revolvers. But: Sometimes you find strange constructions for cartidge 6mm Flobert, a cartidge produced since 1840s. Basicly grandfather of .22 short, rimfire , no powder charge, only primer. In this 6mm Rimfire Flobert there had been, no more in production, lookalikes of Remington/ Sharps and singleshot Derringers, and NAA minirevolvers. Of course: For selfdefence this 6mm Flobert blankpistols are useless, both with blanks or ( If still produced) with teargas loads. But for Theater/ Reenactors perhaps usefull.
The 9mm blankguns , firing blanks, extraloud blanks, flash blanks and CS/ Pepper cartidges are perhaps usefull to scare dogs or unarmed or not very brave persons.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Michaeljames: I had one, made of a broken shaft/ pole of a farmtool, with a mild steel tip, blacksmithed by my father. But i have to admitt, that this year my father throw away many old things, He never needs, so i have to look , if my primitive spear is still there. Nor if Germanen realy means Ger Mannen ( Mannen is a very dated version of Männer) is unclesr. Note : In germanenic languages, man is Mann, man..., while in romannic languages (can' t speak latin) man is uomo, homme, .... I personaly am menber of Swabian/ Alemannic tribe. But : I can' t realy say, that the Swabians are realy descendants of Suevi Caesar noted, and if Alemannen realy means Alle Mannen ( Alle Männer in current german) .
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@albertmarnell9976 : In poetry often grammar is uncorrect/ unusual and sometimes strange words appear ( For example in poetry der Löwe, the lion, is written Leu, or Adler ,eagle,is written Aar). The part of Gedicht is out of context, so i am also astonished. My english is not as good as you think, but i try. The sense of the words at start: ,You speak' is a bit unclear to me. The rest makes sense: Look down to me , who i am whining at your grave, forgive me that i harmed your soul with my words, oh God, this bad result was not intended. ( Translated not good / literaly, only in my words). It is unclear to me, who is the ,you' at the start, and if the ,oh god' is spoken to god himself, or as mourning/sad words in general. A note: In contrast to my girlfriend Britta, i am not religious, perhaps the reason, i understand the words, but not the sense.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@HistoryHustle : In english language Wikipedia is only a short description, when you look for ,Crailsheim' , and read about the history of this town. In german language Wikipedia you have to look for , Schlacht um Crailsheim' ( if you can read german). What happened in April 1945? The US forces which wanted to conquer Württemberg and Eastern Bavaria had been stopped by german troops, defending the Neckar- Tauber ( two Rivers) line. The US Dorfes tried to do a circular move arround the Neckar- Tauber line, to encircle ( ?) / einkesseln the german forces This seemed to be a fast sucess and the US forces advanced so fast, that the surprised german soldiers in town and airfield went away. But a rather fanatic SS General lauched a counteratack, surprisingly the Avantgarde of US forces had been encircled in Crailsheim, and after hard fighting they could reach the main army. Some acts of terror by SS had the result, that a hard battle between US and German forces started, tanks, artillry, planes ( including Me 262 Jets)... After nearly two weeks the fights ended, and nearly the whole town was destroyed.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@ScottKenny1978 : For german law reason, i, Brittas boyfriend, am no gun owner or hunter. We currently had national elections, and it seems that new gouvernement, consisting of Social Democrats ( german counterpart of your Democrats), The Greens ( a rather left wing party) and Free Democrats ( german sense liberals- not left nor right) start to do the same, as nobles did after 1525 farmers rebellion: To forbid all weapons in citizens hand.
In current law, german hunters have no restriction in number of firearms, but when they want more than a largebore rifle for large game ( Hochwild), a shotgun for small game ( Niederwild), goose, ducks, doves, smaller birds i don' t know english name ( Fasan, Rebhuhn) , hare, rabbit and fox. A ,Schonzeitgewehr' ( small bore rifle or shotgun for the ,non hunting time') and a pistol for final shot of wounded game, you have to explain, why you want more hunting firearms. Those formerly more common german/ austrian combination guns ( Büchsflinte, Drilling, Vierling/ four barrels! ) are also seen as standard equipment of a german hunter.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@ChrisHodgsonCorben-Dallas : I am german, patriotic, but no nationalist, Times have changed into a good direction. The fact , that in european part of war territories the use of 9mm Parabellum and 7,65 Browning weapons and ammunition is more practical than using ammunition, which is uncommon, is obvious. Also use of .45 Acp shows everybody USA is involved, while use of .32Acp or . 25Acp could also be a private affair of dead person.
What i as german citizen see as dubious, is portraying franctireurs, partisans, freedom fighters allways as heroes, when fighting against german troops. But after war , the heroic persons are No more portraied as heroes , when fighting against troops of former Allied countries. This is in my eyes a double Standard. Those partisans, are they realy heroes? They cause brutal revenge by occupation troops, the are hiding behind civilian Dress, attacking soldiers clearly visible by uniform and foreign look, do warcrimes .... I am no Fan of them. Armed civilians with clear visible badges, sashes or armbands can be used as rearline auxillaries as guards, transport , Ingenieur troops helpers, guides, perhaps manning fortifications, but should not been used as field troops, partisans or terrorists, they create lot of hate, especially currently.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@josega6338 : There are here in my german region ( state Baden- Württemberg) people with family name ,Schweizer' or ,Elsässer' , and with french names, there is even a village , founded after ,Thirty Years War' with the name Perouse! I of course know the reasons for this war.
There are, also in Germany , not many movies with the toppic of ,Thirty Years War'. I noticed some days ago, but had no time to watch it again, that in YouTube the four episodes TV show ,Wallenstein' from late 70s is shown. But i don' t know, how good your german is, because today no more all people from Alsace can speak german.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@blastulae : Mistakes: In 1840 the Dreyse rifles had a kind of bolt action. Under the name Drehling revolverlike weapons had been produced in the 1520s in Germany, Colt and other english/US inventors did not invent revolvers in 19th century, Colt was only the first one, who produced a useable revolver. And also that Germany did few naval inventions is no wonder. From middle age to its end, the HRE was devided into more than 300 souvereign states, the Reichsritter/ imperial knights not included. An imperial navy did not exist, and the HRE did not try to conquer colonies. In middle age the Hanse, a large federation of Reichsstädten/ imperial towns, was basicly a large merchants federation. In case of war, they armed their ships and hired mercenaries. But in 16th century the time of Hanse was over, and the last Hanse meeting was in 1648. What came then? The emperor had in 18th century only a small danube flottilla, prussia had a small fleet up to the 1720s, Friedrich- Wilhelm l ( the founder of famous prussian army), decided to sell the colonies and fleet, because he saw both as waste of money. The remaining Hanse towns ( Hamburg, Bremen and Lübeck) had up to mid/ late 1700s a large frigatte each, but more for representation than really for protecting their merchant ships. When in 1840s there was nearly a war between German Federation and Denmark, there was no german navy. Prussia had some warships, Austria a small mediteranean fleet, the Hanse town few corvettes for habour defence and Hannover one old british ship ( from 1714-1839 the british king was also ruler of Hannover. So before the 1860s there was not really a german navy, so it is clear, that there had been not so much german navy weapon inventions.
1
-
@blastulae : The Lebel was the first magazine battlefiield rifle? It had a tube magazin, like Kropatschek, Winchester , or Mauser M71/84, so the smokeless powder was the only really new. To the Revolver: percussion system, rifled barrels, cyilinders and Ratschenkupplung( the anchor wrench mechanism) had been known before the 1836 Colt Patterson, but Mr. Colt was the first, who combined this to a useable weapon. Also this Blitzkrieg nonsense is not true. After wwl the german military theorists simply used the prussian doctrine ,Kampf der verbundenen Waffen'/ fight of combined army branches' and added the before unknown tanks and planes. Thats basicly all, and many german officers had been surprised about the success.
But now another thing. I am not Britta herself, but her boyfriend. I am german, 55 years, factory worker, and a conservative/ patriotic man. I am interested in military history for about 50 years, at a Kindergarten day trip i saw Lichtenstein castle, and thougt : Oh a not destroyed castle, i had seen a number of ruins before. Now, 50 years later, i have seen dozens of fortifications, from celtic age to wwll, i visited dozens of military and civilian museums, read for nearly 40years arms , civilian or military history magazins, and took part at historical daytrips. For about 20years i was quality controll man of a small company and have an Asperger disorder. There are a lot oft idots , german and foreign, who speak of ,Best military' or ,besteht weaponry' when there is spoken about Germany or german army. This is simply nonsense. The german armies of 1870/71, 1914/18 and 1939/45 had been good, but the other , non german armies, had also been good. The truth is, that every country, every army had a great and a bad time, every army had a strong and a weak point. I personally don' t like persons who/which say : The army of country ... was the best, then this are idiots, nationalists or simply not very uneducated persons.
1
-
@blastulae : I clearly said, that every country and army had good and bad times, strong and weak points. This should be a sign , that i know something about weapon/military history. I have no reason to say, that Germany was allways superior etc., because i know, this is not true. That is all, what i want to say. And i would say this to everyone, who seems to be an nationalist, extremist or simply an uneducated person. I simply don' t like it, when persons lie. I hope , you unterstand me, english is not my native tonque, my english vocabulary is limited, and for the reason of my Asperger disorder, i have also a problem, to tell my oppinions so, that german people understand it exactly.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@MsMesem : After 1898 Cuba was no real independent country, US companies had a lot of plantations ( ?) and factories there, the cuban people, felt themselves as colonial people of USA , which helped the communists. In early 1890s on the Hawaii Islands US fruit companies forced the indigenous hawaiian kings, no absolute monarchy, but since the 1830s a constitutional monarchy, to abdicate and two years later the Hawaii Islands had been occupied by USA. Also in the interwar time and early postwar periode US companies had been no angels, especially in latin american countries, this was perhaps not so bad than the slave labour of Hitler era, but no fine gentlemans behaviour for profit on the lifes of non US citizens. And US companies made no profits in the wars? They did not support the gouvernement? The US fought no wars ? The real owners of US territories, the native amercans gave the USA their lands, because the US gouvernement sung ,Cumbaja' and waved rainbow flags? The US citizens did respect mexican territory and gouvernement in Texas and California? The US opponents in the,Banana Wars had been worldwide feared superpowers, the ,Nobel prize for peace' winner Obama ordered no drone assasinations and Bush jr. started a war with Irak with the lie, Saddam Hussein has atomic bomb rockets. So , please no double Standards!
1
-
Agro: In ltaly Muslim forces of french Army raped lots of italian women, also the massrapes of german women in southern Baden / Black Forrest ( for example in Freudenstadt) Had been done by muslim.french troops. SS Commander Heinrich Himmler noted : Islam is a religion, creating brave warriors, and has in some context similarities to national socialist ideology. Was Himmler wrong? No! In case of masculinity and warriorism Islam and National Socialism are the same. Where in sports do you find muslim athletes? In ,male' sports : Martial arts, power lifting, and team sports. Do you find muslim athletes in gymnastics, art jumping ( water sports), sport Dancing? Both Muslims and Nazis (also leftwing university circles) make hate Propaganda against jews. Both muslims and Nazis make a difference between worthfull humans Muslim belivers/ Herrenmenschen and worthless humans nonbelievers/ Untermenschen. Both muslims and Nazis say: Women are not important, women are only on world for serving men, Work in House and give birth to children.
Am i wrong? There can be an error in my oppinion, i didn't noticed.
1
-
Similar to japanese edged weapons, a lot of nonsens flows throug Internet about Viking weapons, due to this ,Fantasy ' shit. The Viking weapons are no Wunderwaffen, simply the most northern variant of germannic weapons. In my swabian ( south west Germany) homeregion lots of graves from alemannic warriors from third to sixth century ( few even seventh century) Had been found, which contained weapons. Average warrior had a seax, a circular shield with iron boss, and one or two spears. Rich warriors had in addition a Spatha sword, similar to Viking swords, and one of his spears had a large tip. Helmets and armour was very rare. Poor warriors, or rather young warriors, had only axe/hatchet, slings or bow/ arrow.
1
-
1
-
I am german, 57 now, and in 2016 it was noticed, that i have, on low level, an Asperger disorder. My mother told me , that in my years of german highschool counterpart, a teacher told her, i should by examined by a psychatrist/ phsyoligical doctor, something is unusual with me. Often coworkers or people in daily life called me an idiot, or at least a strange person, so now i know the reason, in my case Asperger, which is related to Autism, seems to be true.
1
-
When in 1867 the German Federation / Deutscher Bund no more existed , Liechtenstein disbanded their army. Up to 1924 the main residence castle of the princes / Fürsten of Liechtenstein had been in Vienna , because their main forrests, farmlands, castles, cattle etc. was inside the Austro- Hungarian Empire ( they lost this propeties with the end of WWll). The reason was, they had been high noblemen inside the Austrian countries, and got the title ,Fürst' and the Grafschaft Vaduz in the 1770s, when the last Count of Vaduz died. When now a man with the family name ,von Liechtenstein' and the title ,Fürst/ prince' was the new ruler,, the country name changed from Grafschaft (County) Vaduz into Fürstentum (pricipality) Liechtenstein. And to the young man at the end: Plesse don't tell nonsense! Liechtenstein means ,lichter Stein' - bright rock. This means, the first castle the family ,von Liechtenstein' owned, was build on a large bright rock.
1
-
1
-
I am german and watched this video by mistake. For reasons, you surely know, i have only very few knowledge about firearms. I doubt, that an ,armored cap or hat protects the head well against bullets, especially, when the armoured part protects only the front of skull over the eyes. There is not only the energy reaching skull and brain, but it is also possible that the bullet force impact throws the skull side- or backwards and hurts the neck. For combat /selfdefence it is perhaps not the best, but as a riccochet protection for airgun- or .22 competition shooters it could be a good thing. Remember: Also the suits of armor , made in 16/17th century , the breastplates had often been bulletproof, but not the helmet. So in my opinion a partly bulletproof cap is a doubtfull thing, but a stab- and cutproof ,also padded cap against knives or batons seems in my eyes more sensefull.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Knut Der Große : Britta is my girlfriend, i also use her account. I know, that in case of weapon and hunting laws, the federalism in the USA is stronger than in my country ( Germany). The weapon law is the same everywhere in Germany, but as far as i know, there a few minor differences in hunting law between the german states. What is not allowed? All kind of shot for nonbirds larger than rabbit, hare and fox. Parforce hunting, hunting with bow, crossbow, spear, pistol or muzzle loaders. Pistols, boarspear, knives or hunting daggers are only allowed to kill wounded animals. For animals larger than , Reh' , for example wild boar and , Hirsch' (deer?) you need calibers with an energy of more than 2000Joule at a distance of 100 or 200 Meter.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am german, and Brittas boyfriend. I understand that in older european movies noneuropean persons/ caracters are played by ,painted' europeans, because up to 1960s noneuropean persons had been rare. In my german homeregion, a semirural region arround a large city, up to 1990s noneuropean people had been really rare. There had been other european people , mostly italian, jugoslawian, greek or spanish, and also turkish persons. In german TV in 70s/80s i remember only a handfull of black actors, mostly childs of black US soldiers and german women. So in those days, when i was younger, german TV shows or cinema movies mostly told the truth. But today, especially black and ,arabic' persons are overrepresented, epecialy in PR(?)/ commercials. In contrast to persons of east asian countries, here the apperiance of such people is realistic. This change started in 2000s.
In case of movies or TV shows, showing historical events or the story plays in a clearly recognizeable time periode, historical reality should be a ,must be', i am rather pedantic in this case. Of course, if a woman is dressed in a style and haircut ten or 20years distant, no matter, or a soldiers has a sword a bit to old, no problem, but when unrealstic things are shown, it is not good. While equipment in Wild West movies has become more realistic over the decades, the ,swashbuckler' movies ( in german Mantel- und Degenfilme) became nearly unwatchable.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am Brittas boyfriend, german. I visit , together with my girlfriend, regularly a traditional dancing hall (?)/ Tanzlokal in german, sometimes also alone when she is ill . A traditional dancing hall for couples dancing, i appear there sometimes alone, but only for dancing and speaking with people i know. The in this Video noted women are there also, but i know them and, being no idiot, i ask ( as only dancing partners) the older or lesser attractive women. I also visit ( usually with my girlfriend) events of traditional folk dance. Only for dancing and fun. When i .had no girlfriend ( autistic disorder) i often visited also this modern clubs/ discos. But: Was mostly disappointed because,as noted in Video, the younger ladies, was also younger, only wanted an idiot, who pays drinks and drives them home.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@harrylor66 : In 1864 with exeption of germanspeaking cantons of Switzerland all german speaking countries formed up to 1866 the Deutscher Bund/ German Federation. A loose federation, where Austrian Emperor had the rank of German President, not German Emperor. In case of military engagement the german Bundesheer / Federation Army had a size of 300000 men in ten corps. Corps 1- 3 had been austrian troops, 4- 6 prussian troops, 7 bavarian troops, 8 Württemberg, Baden and Hesse- Darmstadt, 9 and 10 had been based on Saxony / Hannover, with added troops of Greatduchys and Electorate Hesse- Kassel. The nearly useless troops of Duchies and Principalities formed after 1830 ( 32?) the Reservedivision ( no translation necessary) , only intended, as guards, escort troops or to strengthen fortress garrisons. Exeption: Luxemburgian contingent was intended to defend Fortress Luxemburg town together with 2000 prussian troops ( Luxemburg town was seen as German Federation Fortress second class), and contingent of Free Town Frankfurt was seen as Staff Guard . Note : In HRE german Emperors had been elected in Frankfurt, in German Federation Frankfurt was town of German Federation institutions. I hope , my comment clearifies something. Greetings from Germany!
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
You write nonsens. Also in flintlock era, some german, or better HRE cavallry men used ,Kartätschenpatronen' with three small balls, and few austrian, hannoverian and palatine soldiers had been equipped with Blunderbusses.
But : After flintlock era only few small states in southern Germany bought a small number of side by side shotguns , only for police use. What after 1871, or introduction of.breechloaders happened to this guns, i don't know. With exeption of those Percussion shotguns, shotguns never had been service weaponry of Army or Police. The opposite, shotguns users, had been seen as criminals, when Shooting against persons. In Poachery or smugglers novels/ movies ( german language counterpart to US Wild West stories) the Hero IS armed with a , honourable ' rifle, only the criminals use shotguns as fighting weapons.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Yes, prussian soldiers invaded France. But you have forgotten the soldiers from Bayern, Sachsen, Württemberg, Baden, Hessen-Darmstadt, Oldenburg, Sachsen - Weimar - Eisenach, Mecklenburg - Schwerin, Mecklenburg - Strelitz, Anhalt, Braunschweig, Sachsen - Coburg - Gotha, Sachsen - Altenburg, Sachsen - Meiningen, Waldeck - Pyrmont, Lippe - Detmold, Schwarzburg/ Sondershausen, Schwarzburg - Rudolstadt, Reuß ( older line), Reuß (younger line) , Hamburg, Bremen and Lübeck :-))))
1
-
Nationalist American! You biased slavedrivers and Red indians slaughterers , overthrowers of christian hawaiian constitutional monarchy, forcefull intruders of japanese harbors in 1855 and invaders of many countries, should be quiet. Compare the number of US citizens killed on US soil by foreign troops to the number of non US citizens killed by US troops on non US soil. In Germany, from HRE to German Federation until 1866 including Austria, shotguns had never been common as service weapons. Only in 1830s/ 1840s few small south german states ordered small numbers of side by side muzzleloader shotguns for Police,, note: Until 1890s most german uniformed policemen only had a saber. What happened to this shotguns i don' t know. After 1871 no shotguns had been introduced by german Military, Police, Border Guards/ Customs service or Forrestry service. German/ Austrian counterpart to Wild West novels Had been Poachery or Smugglery novels. But here rifles had been shown as heroic weapons, while shotguns had been shown as criminals weapons. So in wwl german soldiers saw shotgun armed opponents, partisans, franctireurs, US soldiers simply as criminals. Oh a note to wwl/ wwll partisans. When fighting against german Forces , members of allied nations like partisans. But strangely, when fighting against them, Allied nations don' t like partisans. A fact ,i don't understand. Oh in Imperial Germany a company Gaggenauer Eisenwerke produced for a short time a slide action shotgun in 16ga.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
No. The real founder of prussian army was his father Friedrich- Wilhelm l, ruling from 1714 to 1740. This king had a problem, when he started his reign. His pompeous and warlike ancestors had nearly bancrupted Prussia. So he did changes. He replaced pompeous french lifestyle with moneysaving prussian lifestyle. He sold expensive and useless african colonies. He changed administration: The official became wellpaid, and for this the king wanted loyal, disciplined and busy officials. He stopped all costintensive things, when you can not earn money with. He thought: A country without an army is a garden without a fence, everybody comes to steal. So he enlarged prussian army from 38000 men to about 70000 (or 80000?) men and spend lot of money for bis army. But he knew: a) An army is expensive. b) Warfare is more expensive. c) A defeat in war is much more expensive. So Friedrich- Wilhelm l, known as Soldatenkönig/ soldierking was militaristic, but was never involved in a war ( to expensive). But in contrast to his son , he was not interessted in art or philosophy, he was a simple man and described as a rather unfriendly, to some degree brutal man, so he is seen mostly negatve in Germany. But: Not wanting colonies and selling them, being not involved into war, and a money saving lifestyle is realy different to other monsrchs.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
godsgod: Edda can be a germannic ( this means not german), or a book written arround 1300 by icelandic poet Snorri Sturlison. In year 1000 icelandic Allthing (Parlament?) decided, that in public and as community only christian god should be praised, but in privat life ( many icelanders lived in single farme) praising germannic gods is still allowed, if someone wants to do so. Was the reason that until 16th century icelandic christianity was different. Until 1912 Iceland was a danish colony, from 1912 to 1944 Iceland was a danish , Dominion'. In his book Edda Snorri Sturlison noted all stories/ tales about germannic gods, still known by icelandic population. This was 300 years after official switch to Christianity, so some of germanic gods Tales got perhaps misinterpreted ( Sturlison was christian), but : If Sturlison would not have noted this tales, germannic religion would be nearly unknown to modern scientists. Roman historian Tacitus wrote about 100 after Jesus Christ his book/ script Germania, as first scientific book about germannic tribes. He noted, the germannic tribes have the same gods than the romans, but they praise and worship them in a different way. Tacitus was right, 1900 years later, we germans still drink large quantities of beer and wine. Now i assume, this Edda guy is a supporter of paganism.
1
-
1
-
Das liegt meines Erachtens aber nicht an der Polizei selbst, sondern an der Politik, die der Polizei Anweisungen und Vorschriften macht. Aus dem Vereinsleben kenne ich einen Polizeibeamten, der, als er noch im Streifendienst tätig war, sich immer wieder über Politiker, sowie die Justiz beklagt hat. Allerdings in seriösen, nicht derben Worten. Eine Zeitlang, ich bin Brittas Freund und nutze gerade ihren Anschluss, habe ich einen rangniedrigen Polizisten recht regelmäßig in meiner damaligen Stammkneipe getroffen. Er hat in einer Großstadt Dienst getan und war recht verärgert.
Ich habe in meinem Leben, bisher Glück gehabt, und nur zweimal mit Betrunkenen Ärger bekommen, mit der Polizei eigentlich nie.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
As a german i do not agree with all facts of this video. At first, we do not know in which year Germany started! Was it in 843(?) when the carolingian empire was divided , and one part became the east franconian empire? Was it in 911 when the last east franconian king of the carolingian family ( Ludwig, called ,the child') died? Was it in 919 when the first non-frankonian king Heinrich (Henry), the duke of saxony was elected as king (the king between Ludwig and Heinrich, Konrad I, was a franconian and could have been a very last carolingian)? Then i do not like it, when Karl der Große is allways called Charlemagne. Also the franconians are not french! The Franken, as this tribe calls himself in german, is one of the tribes which are now united and are known as ,the Germans', other tribes are for example the saxons, the bavarians or the swabians. The Franken are still alive in the states of Hessen, Saarland, Rheinland -Pfalz, the south of Nordrhein-Westfalen, the north of Bayern and Baden-Württemberg, also in Luxemburg and Lorraine. The truth is, that this tribe conquered the area which is now france, the german name for france is Frankreich/kingdom of the franconians. But i think the number of franconian settlers in nowadays france was not so high, but they became the upper class/nobility.
1
-
I am german , and Brittas boyfriend. A longer time ago i visited music locations for younger people, in german called ,Disko'. One day i watched this: At 2 o ' clock nobody could enter the ,Disko" and the Türsteher/ bouncers said this. Also i , german, conservative dressed, and in my late 30s could not enter after 2 o' clock. One day a group of young foreigners tried to enter, but the bouncers refused. So they tried , Oh, i am the poor discriminated foreigner, and you are the bad racist'. When i saw this, i thought, it would be good for them, when there was a time machine, and real Nazis would give them, what they deserve. I don' t agree , that i as. an ethnic german in my country should do a bow for foreigners , why? If you are mexican, keep your traditions, but i would be carefull about majority of living place.
1
-
@ARVETDEG : Those noted foreigners i saw years ago , went into a , Diskothek', at a time, when nobody could enter anymore, also i , german, not. Why did they try , to use the racism card to get into those music house?? This is the point! The bouncers did nothing racist, they simply did their job. Why did this young foreigners try, to speak of racism? For this reason , i said, it would have been good for them, to see real Nazis of 1933 to 1945, then they could think, if the bouncers had a racist attitude. I have nothing against ALL foreigners, but i don' t like it, when there are foreigners, who don' t want to assimilate. About 300 years ago, many French protestants came to Germany, with the time they became Germans, and today you only see their french name, i have never read, that foreigners, who came in former centuries to Germany, had a behavior like today. Of course not all, but to many think, their religion is more important than german law, they don' t respect german lifestyle, but want, that we germans should respect their lifestyle? Why should i respect this, when they don' t want to respect my lifestyle in my country? When i travel to another country, what happens not often, then i have to respect law and tradition of this country, what do this noted foreigners think, who they are? I am Brittas boyfriend, and especially after 2015 migrants wave , but also last 20 years i heared many women, from teenage gils to elderly ladies, being angry about men of the noted foreign religion, but not as much about men of other religions, and i don' t think the women lied. I myself was in a ,music pub' attacked by a foreigner, i don' t know why, also a former coworker, who is stronger and taller than i, told me, that he together with friends for years visited the same Bar, but now no more, because in last months often drunken russians are in the Bar , he ( the coworker) said, i fear this aggressive men. So, when i shall be friendly to foreigners, then i also want , that they are friendly to me in my country. So is it racism, when i don' t like foreigners, who come to my country, don' t respect law and are aggressive, when a german has no reason for being aggressive? No! Peacefull foreigners, who busy work, respect our law and tradition are not the problem, then i have no problem, when they do some things different, but the noted other foreigners? No, they are the problem, both for Germans and those foreigners, who do nothing wrong.
When i said, keep your mexican tradition, then i mean, you are mexican, so you can do your tradition everywhere, i hope you do so, but outside of Mexico, you should be carefull, to do no tradition, which makes the inhabitants of another country angry. I also try, to do so., When a traveller makes a mistake, he doesn' t know, this can happen everybody, but doing something not liked not accidently, then i think, nobody likes this, that is no racism.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@tpl608 What you have forgotten: The Switch from Monarchy to democraty brought nothing for German people. They had been as poor than before, nothing changed. In 1923/24 the people lost their saved Money by record Inflation . There had been such a large reparation pay, that even i would have had to pay ( what i in reality still do with german EU Money). The black Friday of US Wallstreet caused in Germany, when First signs of Economy growing appeared, a great Economy crisis with six millions unemployed persons. The people in 1920s Germany had nearly nothing from democracy , they had many uprisings ( nationalistic and communist.), Inflation stole away saved Money, economic crisis caused poorness and suffering, and German Gouvernement had to pay large sums to foreign countries, the Money was Not available for German Gouvernement or people What do you expect? The people voted for radical Parties, also communists got in elections more votes than in ordinary times. May be a Communist Germany allied with Communist Russia would have been great joy for France and Brittain. Then in 1936 a Communist Spain, contralling the street of Gibraltar, the way to Suez and Crown colony India?
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@TheKinzlerBros : I am german, Brittas boyfriend. Today this oil is sold in spray cannisters, but I have a Ballistol glass bottle, my father bought in early 1970s. Of course this bottle is nearly empty today, only few drops of oil are still existing. The reason I didn't threw the bottle into glass recycling contsiner, is the PR paper , which was once placed between bottle and the protection Cardboard (Wellpappe) piece , This PR paper, today only partly readable , was written in a rather dated Style, which was for the boys of my Generation a piece of ( of course unwanted) comedy. We Boys knew the oil and the noted PR paper from our fathers and laughed: You can use Ballistol for everything, exept of drinking.
You can read, for example: To protect your dogs ears from dangerous insects you can use Ballistol, or you can use Ballistol, when after a day of riding, you have pain at your arse. No Joke! But now you understand, that we Boys laughed after Reading such obscure thinss.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@historyandhorseplaying7374 : When a german town name ends with - burg, then this means that there was once only a fortified castle ( Burg) and a small settlement for the castle owners servants. Often still now, there is next to a for centuries destroyed castle ruin a farmhouse ( today often an inn and no more farming), the former farm of the castleowner. Sometimes german towns and castles have the same name, what causes confusion. When in an old document, Oldenburg, Königreich Preußen is written, then the Oldenburg in former great duchy Oldenburg can not be the right town, because town and territory in northwest Germany never belonged to Prussia. So the second Oldenburg must be the former home of your ancestors. Oldenburg can mean in current german ,Alte Burg' vor in english Old Castle. The version of german language spoken in the north of Germany, called Niederdeutsch ( , from german lowlands') has similarities to english, the Anglosaxons came from there.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@darthhodges : Before we gemans used metric, we also had other units. The Zoll is former german inch, the Elle is cubit ( never heared before), Klafter was the length from one middlefingertip to the other , when a human has both arms in 90 degree angle to body. In case of hollow measurement there had been for example Simri for things like wheat or barley, for fluids the Eimer ( bucket) , and for farmland the Morgen ( acre). But: Holy Roman Empire consisted of about 300 souvereign states ( socalled Reichsstände) and a lot of very small territories, being no Reichsstand . Every territory had its own measurement! At some old townhouses you can see still see iron bars representing the local Elle. As you can assume, merchants didn' t like this, also money system caused problems, there had been Taler and Gulden in variants.
Now Napoleon reduced the number of states to 40, and first steps of metric system entered Germany, and was finished in early 1870s . So in Germany metric system was also seen as a sign of german unification.
1
-
1
-
Vor kurzem wurde, entweder in , Clausewitz ' oder ,Militär und Geschichte ' ( zwei seriöse militärgeschichtliche Zeitschriften) ein mehrteiliger,von Herrn Gast geschriebener Artikel über seine Zeit bei der französischen Fremdenlegion. Seine militärische Laufbahn begann mit seinem Wehrdienst als Fallschirmjäger bei der Bundeswehr. Als Wehrpflichtiger war damit ein gewöhnlicher Soldat, wenn auch bei einer etwas besser ausgebildeten Truppengattung und ohne Kampferfahrung. Anschließend war er für siebzehn Jahre bei der Fremdenlegion, also ein Berufssoldat ( professional soldier) , mit Kampfeinsätzen. Daß Profi eine Eindeutschung von ,profession' etc. aus den romanischen Sprachen ist , sollte ihnen eigentlich bekannt sein. Anschließend war Herr Gast noch langjährig im privaten Sicherheitsbereich tätig, und zwar dort , wo man mit Piraten und anderen militärisch bewaffneten Halsabschneidern rechnen muß. Als Amateursoldaten kann man die nur kurz ausgebildeten Milizsoldaten bezeichnen. Aber bei klassischen Milizsoldaten, etwa den österreichischen oder schweizer Soldaten, der US Nationalgarde ( ehem.Staatsmilizen) oder der norwegischen Heimwehr, ist in den letzten Jahrzehnten Bewaffnung , sonstige Ausrüstung und Ausstattung deutlich verbessert worden, daß man sie mit den Milizen von einst, Bürgerwehren, Landsturm, Landesaufgebot. Landesdefension etc. nicht mehr vergleichen kann. Aber noch immer werden in Notfällen sehr kurz eingewiesene Soldaten in den Kampf geworfen, das sind dann wirklich Amateure.
1
-
1
-
Mick Hawford : I am german. In the small company i worked 30years ago there was an english coworker, what is not common in southern germany. One day a new coworker came and just for fun, he spoke in his ,Low German' dialect to the english man. One of the sentences was , Dann bin ik fallen in de kold water'. The english worker looked surprised, i , whom i speak swabian dialect , could understand it, like the english man, but a turkish man thougt, the Low german dialect is english.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@BUSHCRAPPING : I was born in 1965, my village was in those days more rural, not semiurban as now. So i heared swabian dialect words for rural things Wien i was a little child, my father stopped farming in 2001 ( but like most farmers of his generation, he was in reality factory worker and only ,weekend farmer'). So while i knew Schuir ( sometimes Schuira) as building, and inside of the building Barn was used for the part of building, mostly upper part where hay and straw ( in my dialect Hai/ Schdrau) was stored. So you surely can believe my surprise. Another thing is ,to stirr' , umrühren in Standard German. But in some context in swabian dialect ,stiera' is used in the meaning of ,to stirr'.Also in english you can say ,a car' or ,one car' this would be in Standard German ,ein Auto' in both cases, but we Swabians say ( similar to english) ,A Audo' or ,Oi Audo'. ( It becomes a bit funny for other germans, when we say ,ein Ei ' in swabian, because we use different sounds when speaking ,Oi Oi').
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@garypulliam3421 : For customs of the time, Wilhelm ll of Prussia ( not Wilhelm ll of Württemberg) was ceremonial Regimentschef ( in German Chef is not a cook, but for example your employer) of some Regiments, but not the real Oberst ( colonel), also more ceremonial Highest Warlord. So for his many appeareances in military context, owned and wore many uniforms, those often in summer/ winter/ field / Parade/ Gala Variation. His Uniforms had been Uniforms, not costumes, because he was no actor, Opera Singer etc., and also no carneval costumes. Only some uniforms, in no more used, even then historical style could be called costumes. And compared to our days, wearing uniforms was for ruling monarchs more common. But even for his time, he liked uniforms rather much, this is true. Current german huntsmen wear modern hunters cloth, made from modern materials, tailored in modern style and often for security in orange colour. Only few parts of their dress/ cloth is in traditional style, with exeption, when there is a more ceremonial Event. When i was a child, the hunters dress was more traditional, the huntsmen also had been dressed more similar, that their dress really could be mistaken for an uniform. When i was younger large hunting knifes had been not common, after two lost wars the huntsmen don' t wanted to look like a warrior. But the wild boar problem of last twenty years caused a Comeback of long hunting knifes ( and even boarspears , sometimes even Dog Packs!). In monarchist days the situation was different. Uniforms had been a common thing , also civilian target shooters, in some german regions still today, wore a huntsman like uniform. In those days Germany Military had a good Reputation, so many men used every possibility to wear a Kind of uniform and a sidearm. In those days of course smaller hunting knifes like the Nicker ( Genick- neck) had been common tool, but many hunters carried a Standhauer/Waldblatt, a mix of small Machete and cleaver, or the Hirschfänger ( i think last descendant of late medieval/ early Renaissance Langes Messer) , which was for centuries only allowed for noblemen, Forrest officials and Professional hunters. So it was nothing unusual, that Wilhelm ll of Prussias hunters suit was in uniform Style. I have seen last württtembergian King Wilhelm ll s hunting suit, also in Uniform Style. There is a Photo of prussian Wilhelm, Standing next to a horse when hunting, here his Hirschfänger is unusual long.
1
-
@garypulliam3421 a) It is a sign of bravery to fight people who are dead for decades. b) If you are english: Did Victoria, Edward or George fought on Battlefield? Which right did english Kings had to conquer Wales, Scotland and Ireland? Why are historical movies about Glencoe , the aftermath of Culloden, or Ireland when Lordprotector ( Dictator ) Cromwell - there are not enough trees to hang all the irish- so rare? What right had the British to conquer the largest colonial Empire and Plunder a quarter of world Population? Who started Boer Wars and invented concentration camps? Why is british colonialism good, german one Not? You British allways think, when you do harm to Others, it is fine, but it is not allowed for Others, to hurt us. c) If you are US citizen: Who gave the White intruders the right, to break nearly every treaties with native Americans, to kill them , rob their Land and Put the legal owners of US soil into reservations - Ulysses S Grant: Only a dead native is a good native? Who gave you the right to intervene in so many Latin American Countries? Who gave you the right to settle in Texas, but don' t respekt Mexican Gouvernement ?
Who gave you the right to intrude into japanenese harbours in 1855 without allownes of japanese Gouvernement? Why acted you in Cuba in Style of a colonial Power, while Cuban Gouvernement after Spanisch - US war of 1898 ( started by USA by claiming, the Explosion of an US warship in a Cuban Port was spanish Sabotage, it was a construction error) was only US puppet? Which right had US settlers and fruit companies to finish Hawaian Monarchy in 1892 and occupy the Islands in 1894? Why did USA from 1914 to 1916 claim to be neutral, when it was allowed for european Allied Powers to send armed merchant vessels to US Ports, while armed German merchant ships didn' t had this allownes? Why do US movies Show US troops between 1888 and 1918 are allways shown as Heroes in movies? What right had US troops after Spanisch - US war to occupy Philippines? c) If you are french: Which right had , Sunking' Louis XIV to steal German Allsace? Which right had this King to terrorize , burn and Plunder South West Germany? Which right had Napoleon to conquer Germany, German Population suffered under occupation? Why did french troops killed tyrolian Rebels or the northgerman Rebels under Captain Schill, but are whining when German troops killed armed french civilians 1870/71 or 1914-1914? Why i See no french movies, showing what they did in Germany between 1680 and 1814?e) If you are Norwegian: Why is Invasion of Norway by german troops a crime, but raids of Vikings in Northern Germany not ( pre 1914 in Oslo ? a Statue was errected, which Shows a Viking, is Standing still today).
If Wilhelm ll would have not existed, on whom could you Point with your Finger?
1
-
1
-
: Seit Jahren gibt es eine Erhöhung von Messer- und anderer Gewaltkriminalität, aber nichts geschieht. Außer dummem Gefasel, wie etwa der Armlänge Abstand kommt nichts. Weshalb kommt nichts Vernünftiges? Man darf sich nicht wundern, wenn Leute aufgrund des amtlichen Nichtstun auf seltsame Gedanken kommen. Übrigens : Wenn Waffenverbote etwas bewirken würden, wäre Großbritannien ein sicheres Land, denn dort darf man überhaupt nichts mitführen, was man zur Abwehr von Verbrechern nutzen könnte. Das Gegenteil ist leider der Fall. Wenn man zu englischsprachigen Videos zu diesem Thema fie Kommentare liest, stellt man fest, viele unserer Nachbarn sind ähnlich verärgert wie die Leute hierzulande. Um ein Beispiel zu geben: Ich , Brittas Freund , der den Rechner mitnutzt, habe das Video eines britischen Museums angesehen, das ein prächtiges Fechtlehrbuch zeigte, das ein in London lebender Italiener im 18. Jahrhundert geschrieben hatte. Ein Kommentarschreiber meinte: Das ist nichts ungewöhnliches. Wir haben auch im heutigen London in großer Zahl fremdländische Klingenexperten.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Auch in der HEMA Szene ( Histical European Martial Arts) beschäftigen sich die Teilnehmer damit , Texte alter Fechtbücher zu lesen und die alten Techniken wieder zu rekonstruieren, beziehungsweise zu überprüfen. Es werden auch die alten Techniken im Umgang mit Dolchen geübt. Gelegentlich machen die Internetstars dieser Szene auch Gedanken zum Thema Selbstverteidigung. In solchen Videos kommen auch diese Leute zu dem Schluß, daß die Abwehr von Dolch / Messer schwierig ist, und empfehlen, sich eilig davonzumachen. In diesem Zusammenhang möchte ich erwähnen, daß ich kürzlich die Vorführung einer seriösen Historiengruppe gesehen habe. Es waren keine dubiosen Mittelaltermsrkt Phantasievögel sondern kundige Männer, die Schwert , Langes Messer ( eine Art Kurzschwert), Dolch , Hellebarde und ,halbe Stange' ( ein leicht übermannshoher kräftiger Stock ) aufführtrn. Mit dem Dolch waren die beiden Männer so schnell und flink, daß ich, ein Laie, erkannte, wie gefährlich Messer sind.
1
-
Al Caulique : In middle age there had been also noblemen in the part of the Holy Roman Empire of German Nation, which is now Switzerland, but compared to other regions, there had been few, and so in Switzerland the nobility had been not so dominant, and relicts of germanic/tribal traditions survived. In the canton Aargau you can still see the ruins of the Habichtsburg, which was the namegiving ,rootcastle' of the Habsburg family. And in the first half of 16th century the Counts of Gruyere/Greyerz died out , the last count became poor and had to sell his county. As far as i know, there are still two swiss noble familes existing, but for the reason that Switzerland is no monarchy for many centuries, these families have for centuries no special rights, they have only survived.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@janosmarta8258 : I only wanted to say, that Augsburg and Nürnberg had not been part of Bavaria in HRE time. As a non expert, i try to give an answer. At first, watch the Videos of Matt Easton from ,Scholagladiatora' channel, in one Video not long ago, the toppic was, where did medieval people buy their weapons. Then noblemen of high rank, or very rich nonnoble men of citystates had the money to buy new equipment from famous craftsmen. Low rank noblemen, for example knights, or ,average' members of citystates' upperclass had also money to buy good equipment, but men of this class had often been not as rich as we think today. Also this men had often to use parts of armour from their fathers or new, but not so decorated pieces of equipment. In 15/16th century there had been different kind of armies: Mercenaries Armies, mostly the troops with highest fighting power, traditional militias of towns or districts fighting power depends on training and equipment, and in case of emergency levies of all fightable men. I start with the traditional militias: Some of the men bought their weapons with their own money from craftsmen or traders, but mostly the town or the district nobleman bought weapons and armor with tax money, and stored this equipment in a depot/ in german Zeughaus. In most cases the armor was only helmet and upper body protection without arm and leg pieces Sand like the weapons of useable , but cheap second class quality. Some of this equipment was locally made by not so wellknown craftsmen, or bought/ purchased(?) in weapon and armor production centers. Most of those luxury armor and weapon producers had also ,second quality production line' or sold used pieces of good quality. And there had not only luxury producers, but also producers of good reputition,who produced useable weapons and armour of average quality to equip militias and mercenaries in mass production, in a few sizes , not so comfortable than ,bespoken tailored' luxury armour. This mass producers did exist in large numbers in armamemt centers, There had been dozens of small craftman's shops, in which a Meister worked with a number of trained men and auxillary hands. With mercenaries the situation was diffetent. Untrained new men had to be equiped by the man, who hired the men, they mostly got the cheapest equipment and started to train with the simplest weapons, and got the lowest pay. When they had some experience they got better equipment and pay, and some became horsemen or heavy armoured men at arms. This had been mostly cheap , but useable things made by mass producers and bought by the nobleman, who hired this mercenaries. But there had also been mercenaries with own equipment. Some of them , who had not been poor at the start of their military life , bought not so expensive basic equipment from travers or craftsmen , others upgraded their eqipment by saving their pay and buying more or better equipment, others upgraded their equipment by taking equipment from dead enemies. Mercenaries with own equipment got better pay. Those emergency levies of fightable men had in my opinion the worst weaponry and few to no armour. There was not much time and fewer money to buy or produce weapons for them, so this men had been the Volkssturm of their time. They often had been to poor or not allowed to own weapons, so they had to use oldest weaponry found at the attic, cheap and fast made weapons of low quality from the mass producers or made by nonweapon craftsmen, for example simple pikeblades made by ordinary village blacksmiths and poles made by woodworking village craftsmen. And sometimes they had to use dangerous tools or simple selfmade weapons.
1
-
@janosmarta8258 : Singular Landsknecht/ plural Landsknechte, but there are also the four german grammar cases, but that is now not important. In 15th century the number of men at arms was perhaps higher than the number of knights. In 16th century / early 17th century the heavy cavallry , both traditional Lanzierer with full plate and Kürisser with 3/4 armor used pistols, especially the Kürisser, and they before charge used Caracole tactic with pistol salvos, and Knights became officers. The quality of armor, als footmens Halbharnisch/, half armor' declined after 1540, but was still good up to early 17th century. So, for many decades, good armor and wheellock pistols, carbines lesser, had been used together. Also up to early 17th century well made pomp armours had been produced. The great decline of armor quality and use came in my country as longer as the 30years war lasted, the war tactics became faster, and the armies became a size, that it was no more possible, to produce so much good armor. And after the 1680s ,german troops, with exeption of Kürassiere, stopped using armor. But up to the end of HRE all remaining pieces of armor had been taken out of depot, when there was a war against Ottoman empire.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@genericpersonx333 : I noticed your answer today. As i said, after the war of 1861-1865 the US army was reduced to a peace time stength of about 30000 men, plus the State Militias, which are today the ,National Guard'. I simply wanted to note the not so known fact, that, on paper, Ludwig ll had the same number of soldiers than the United States. On paper, between 1871 and 1918 there had been four german armies. The prussian army, 17 army corps including the troops of the Greatdukes , Dukes, Princes and Hanseatic towns. The bavarian army, 3 army corps. The saxon army, 2 army corps. The wurttembergian army, 1 army corps. But of course, this was only, to keep the small kingdoms quiet. But secret weapons transports for rebellions etc. are allways a difficult thing. In the 1860s a high rank german nobleman bought a lot of not so modern belgian firearms, because he wanted to become Duke of Schleswig- Holstein. But the belgian weapons traders noticed, that something was not not OK, and told the incident to prussian authorities and the plan failed.
1
-
In Imperial Germany company Gaggenauer Eisenwerke produced for a short time also a pumpaction shotgun, but became not popular among german hunters. In Germany shotguns had been nearly not used as service weapons.ln 1830s/ 1840s few small southern german states bought small numbers of muzzleloader side- by- side shotguns, intended mostly to fight poachery , ordinary german policemen had into 1900s only a saber. What happened to those shotguns after 1871, i don' t know. German counterpart to Wildwest novels or movies, had been poachery/ smuggling stories, in which a forrest official ( Förster) fought criminals. In 1950s, and again early 1970s there was a wave of such movies. Now, the heroes of novels/ movies used ,honourable' rifles, ,unhonourable' shotgun was seen as , criminals weapon'. Perhaps you now understand something.
And a note to this Résistance fighters, partisans, franctireurs. Strangely members of former Allied Powers don' t like this ,heroes', when they fight against former Allied powers.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@bukelos2804 : I am Brittas boyfriend, only using her Computer too. I am rural/ conservative metal worker, so basicly patriotic. But i am, unusual for a factory worker, not uneducated, i have socalled , Mittlere Reife ' ( middle education). After elementary school ( four years), i was for six years on Gymnasium, highest german school type, preparing for university, but was not intelligent enough to get , Abitur ' so i finished after ten years of school with Mittlere Reife and started a german style jobtraining ( Lehre) as metal worker ( machine fitter). So to use the words of Germanys greatest artist Goethe from his theater play Faust: Two hearts are in my chest! On one side i am the disciplined conservative patriotic german, who respects law and order and follows the leader, on other hand i have education, know the difference of patriotism and nationalism, truth and lie ( Propaganda), peace and war ( hate between nations). An unhappy struggle between national duty and duty of humanity. I hope, you understand my soul. Truth , peace and culture are in my oppinion the best options for future, but the ghostly shadows of history / past must be put into a strong Cage.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@hobmoor2042 : At first be carefull what you say! At first , english speakers are the greatest liars on earth!!!! Which right had the english to conquer Wales, Scotland and Ireland??? The irish had been humans of second class for centuries. Which right had the english to conquer and rob a quater oft worlds territorry? Which right had the British to attack Oranje Freistaat and Transvaal? Which right had the British to kill the cattle oft the Boers, to destroy their farms and harvest storage? Which right had the British to put the Boer families into concentration camps , about 20% oft the people prisoned there died? Which right had the British to use Q-ships and calll german wwl U Boot crews criminals? At the Start of wwl german U-Boot crews fought with traditional sea law against merchant ships ( in german Prisenordnung) but british navy used traps to sink U - Boots . There had been double crews on prepared british ships. When a german U-Boot attacked a merchannt ship and came next to this ship on surface, then the first crew leaved the ship in boats, and the hidden second crew attacked the U -Boot with hidden cannons. Now the english, and their american allies, praise this as a clever heroic trick of the brave angellike british, but when german U - Boot crews angry about the behaviour of the british gentlemen attacked ships without warning they are criminals, a typical example of english speakers double standard perfide Albion! Now the Americans. They made treatises with Red Indian tribes, lied oft peace, broke every treaty, killed thousands oft Indianns, stoled their Land, put them Ingo reservations and forbide them to speak their language. They settled in Texas, which was not their Land, did not respect mexican law and stole the mexicans Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, Utah and California. The kingdom of Hawaii, a constitional monarchy was overthrown by american settlers.The amercans betrayed the cuban and phillipine people, but when the cuban people rebelled againtst the american puppet Battista, the amercans are the poor victims. In the Nuremberg war criminals trials no Allied warcriminal was sentenced, but the Allies, said ,attacking wars are crime'( with the exeption, when Russia attacked Poland in 1939 and Russia attacking Finnland in 1939 and Britain and Russia invading Persia). With no declaration of war 2003 USA and Britain attacked Irak, with the liegt, Saddam Hussein has Atomic rockets. Oh yes, the french in all their history only player music, danced, painted pictures, drank wine, have eaten luxury food and fucked beautifull woman. Napoléon? Louis XlV, who burnt down palatine Region? Only fake news! The French do not know what war is! The german hate against the french came out of the blue! There is no French, british vor French movie about the time between 1630- 1813, so it is clear , the french did nothing bad. And in Allied war movies the german soldiers are allways shown as idiots, but the clever(?) Allied soldiers needed six years to beat such idiots??
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@AbenZin1 : Before wwl infantry rifles/ muskets had been rather long , 130- 140 cm had been not uncommon, and bayonets had also been very long, so that they infantrymen had a replacement for the pike, which dissapeared from european battlefields in 1690s. Short rifles/ muskets ( Carbines/ Karabiner) had been weapons of cavallry, artillry, engineer and transport soldiers. Before 1914 german cavallry men had no bayonet, so when the cavallry men had to fight on foot in the trenches, they used the carbine to shoot and their lances as bayonet substitute , until the carbines got transfered to fix a bayonet.
Side note: Cavallry was seen as the aristocratic branch of army, even the commanders of last german cavallry divisions in wwll had been noblemen with the rank Fürst.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
robert colbourne : In those days french was, in western world, the ,lingua franca'/ international language, it needed some time to replace french with english language. And the , Friedensklasse' of the , Pour le merite', the ,Pour le merite für Wissenschaft und Künste' (for science and art) is the last prussian medal, which is , very rarely today, still sometimes awarded, as far as i know!
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
A few years ago , during a historical tour of a small german historical society, i met an, at this day 81 old member of Stauffenberg family ( forgotten the branch) , he showed us his palace, which was once a castle, and told us , that he knew his famous relatve ( when he was a child), and after the assasination atempt , it was a dangerous time for all ,von Stauffenberg'.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Ich, nicht meine Freundin Britta, deren Account ich nutze, habe keine Geschwister und auch keine Kinder ( als ich noch im entsprechenden Alter war, wollte die Damenwelt wenig von mir wissen). Bei meinen Eltern, die Geschwister haben, höre ich immer nur Geschimpf, welchen Ärger man mit diesen wegen ihrer Unzuverlässigkeit, Unpünktlichkeit, Nervigkeit und auf den eigenen Vorteil Bedachtheit ( schwäbisch Vordlhäftdichkeit) hat. Auch von Leuten die Kinder , eigene oder Adoptivkinder, höre ich des Öfteren nicht so amüsante Dinge. Eine verheiratete Dame aus meinem Bekanntenkreis beklagt sich des Öfteren über ihren Mann. Ich bin daher nicht so ganz überzeugt, daß die Beschäftigung mit der Familie für den Seelenfrieden immer das Beste ist.
1
-
1
-
German here. When wwll ended, 11 to 15 millions or germans had to leave their home in different east european/ balkan countries. This people often had suffered terrible things. But i never read in books or tv, that this german refugees killed or attacked people in mainland Germany for no reason, and claimed to be mental ill. And: For over thirty years, you hear here in Germany, behind every bush a Nazi is louring for foreigners, to murder them. But: A) You never read, if more foreigners had been killed by germans since 1990, or the other way. B) You never read , when there is violence between germans and foreigners, who started it. C) You never hear numbers of killed germans, or raped german/ non muslim girls. List goes to Z), but i am tired.
1
-
@Intelwinsbigly : The current heads of Wittelsbach and Württemberg are wellreputated gentlemen, but older than 80 years now. So for an emperor from formerly royal families, the heads of Hohenzollern or Wettin have a better age. But like in HRE time, the new emperor should be elected, but of course no more by electors/Kurfürsten, but by the people. Even our Federal President/ Bundespräsident as ,Head of State' has very few power, he is not elected by the people!!!
The political parities in federal Parlament: The oldest party, founded in the 1880s /90s is the SPD ( Sozialdemokratische Partei Deutschlands). They once had Bern the ,working mans party' , and after removing communist ideas arround 1950, they became a mostly moderate left party, but in 1970s many nonworkers entered the party, and they became leftwing again, but has forgotten the working man. The FDP ( Freie Demokratische Partei) was liberal in german sense, not really right or left, they are interessted in free economy, this was formerly the party of shopowners, rich farmers, owners of small factories. This Party has lost its former importance. The CDU ( Christlich Demokratische Union), in Bavaria CSU ( Christlich Soziale Union) was once the conservative party, from moderate conservatives to patriotic ,but not really right wing, conservatives, supported by industry, banks, farmers and the churches. But in the time of Angela Merkel the CDU (and also CSU) did a step to left to be centric, the patriotic members and ideas are mostly removed. The Party calls itself still conservative, but the conservative part of US Democrats are more conservative/ patriotic than ,conservative' CDU. A sidenote to the churches: We also have some smaller churches as it is common in USA, but most germans are members either of Lutheran church ( in Germany known as Evangelisch) or Catholic. Formerly the Evangelische/ Lutheran church was moderate left and Catholic church conservative/ moderate right, but today Lutheran church is liberal in US sense and Catholic church moderate left. Nest Party is the Grüne, this Party is this what in USA is seen typical/ totally liberal. The Party ,Die Linke' is basicly former communist/socialist East german ,SED' ( Sozialistische Einheitspartei Deutschlands) painted with democracy. The AfD ( Alternative für Deutschland) is a patriotic/ conservative Party, but they have a problem : Inside oft this Party there is a strugle between conservatives in Old Time CDU style and real right wingers, and it is unclear, who wins.
I ( not my girlfriend Britta) am 55, german style trained worker/ Facharbeiter and born in the area arroud Stuttgart. When i was a child, you could say ,rural area' but today the rural element is nearly disappeared. Formerly the workers, craftsmen, hands and many Bureau employees still had the very small farms of their ancestors. In those Region ( Altwürttemberg ) there are the smallest german farms. My father, who was trained worker like me, stopped farming and sold the last four cows. So i know also something about farming.
But when you look arround, the ,liberal' lifestyle ( US sense) is growing more and more, in newspapers, TV and politics the working man ( Farmer, craftsman, worker, ordinary employees) appeares rarer and rarer, the persons liked by liberals more and more. The working man is more and more the uneducated and unneccessary hillbilly/ Hinterwäldler, while the liberal townsman is described as ,crown of human development'. So i think you are not surprised, when i don' t like the Situation in my country.
1
-
@nichderjeniche : Das ist im Rahmen des möglichen. Ich selbst bin Brittas Freund und wohne mein ganzes Leben im selben Haus. So glaube ich zu wissen, was sich in den letzten knapp sechzig Jahren verändert hat. Früher war mein Heimatort ein ländlich geprägtes Dorf, in dem die einheimischen Familien eine kleine Nebenerwerbslandwirtschaft hatten, oder sie hatten diese erst kürzlich aufgegeben. Dazu kamen die aus den verlorenen deutschen Ostgebieten vertriebenen Leute, eine Anzahl Menschen, die aufgrund der guten Wirtschaftslage aus anderen Teilen Deutschlands zugezogen waren, und eher wenige Ausländer, meist aus Südeuropa. Es ist kaum etwas vorgefallen. Während meiner Schulzeit gab es im Ort einen Ehestreit, bei dem ein Mann seine Frau niederschlug und und im Glauben, sie sei tot, Selbstmord begiing. Drei Landstreicher haben die Bäckerei überfallen, und ein enweder betrunkener oder geistig kranker Mann ha eines Nachts gelärmt.
Heute ist die Landwirtschaft fast Geschichte , der Ort verstädtert und man kennt die Leute nicht mehr ( Anmerkung: Durch meinen leichten Autismus bin ich eher einzelgänerisch und rede mit nur wenigen Menschen). Es werden immer mehr Ausländer und auch Menschen, für die Medien, Politik und normale Bürger unterschiedliche Worte benutzen, um es vorsichtig zu formulieren. Von diesem bin ich nicht so begeistert. In den 90er Jahren wurden solche Leute in einem Haus untergebracht, dessen alte Bewohner kurz zuvor gestorben waren. Als diese weggingen, war das Haus voller Müll und die Einrichtung komplett ruiniert. Einige Jahre später wurde ein solcher Mensch erschossen, auch slte Leute wussten nicht, wann zuvor das letzte Tötungsdelikt im Ort geschah. Es stellte sich heraus, daß der Mann in drei Orten unter Falschnamen Geld kassierte und im Drogenhandel tätig war. Bei den Leuten die seit 3015 mutwillig hier hergelockt werden, war ein Jugendlicher im Freibad der Nachbarstadt in einen Aufruhr, bei dem die Bademeister bedroht, und zwei elfjährige Mädchen belästigt wurden, beteiligt, und die dreizehn und vierzehn Jahre alten Jugendlichen, die eine ältere Frau im Ort beraubt haben, soll es sich gerüchteweise um den Personenkreis gehandelt haben. Es KÖNNTE stimmen, denn in der Zeitung wurde arg wenig genaues und im Amtsblatt gar nichts berichtet.
Seit 2015 fällt mir , leichter Autismus, auf, daß unter den eher wenigen Menschen, mit denen ich rede, daß häufiger als zuvor, Frauen sich über Belästigungen beschweren , vor allem durch Afrikaner und Araber/Muslime, beziehungsweise sich um ihre Töchter fürchten. Auch unter Deutschen gibt es Sexualtäer, auch in meinem Ort wurden in den 90er Jahren zwei junge Frauen angegriffen - von einem arbeitsscheuen Assozialen, aber ich habe die meiste Zeit meined Lebens nie soviele Beschwerden gehört.
.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@sebe2255 : Hohenzollern Castle is owned to 2/3 by prussian (protestsntic) Branch, to 1/3 by swabian ( catholic) branch. Current head of swabian branch owns some factories, and as far as i know has not really economic problems, you hear few about him in public, and when, mostly positive things, Like his distant relative Friedrich der Große, he is known as a good musican. His prussian counterpart Georg tried to get something of former family owned extensive things back. It is not forbidden, to do so, and many persons try to get money etc. from Federal Republic or States. So what?
I personaly , Brittas boyfriend, autistic, rural backgrond, conservative have met some noblemen during historical guided tours of a small historical society. Mostly of former knights class, but also a rather close relative to british Royal House. Most of them are serious people, either classical owners of farmland, forrests, wineyards, etc., other ones are lawyers, construction ingenieurs, brewery owners, only one seemef to be still really rich. Tradtonal dress, in british or german vountystyle. Tradtonal behavior? One day, during a historical tour to an undestroyed medieval looking castle, the owner waited in Hunters dress in front of his castle, in his early 70s. One old man in his 80s , was in the group of travellors. When the castle owner saw this old man, hr lifted His hat , did a slight bow and said: Your Royal highness hasn' t visit me for a long time! The old man with hat , coat and umbrella, was realy a member of former royal House of Württemberg. Most of current younger noblemen are married with women of nonnoble families. Last year i did a series of photos with two ladies in the besutfull park of a count. One of the ladies personally knee the counts wife, so i got the key to park and Garden house for free. After the photo Session i gave the keys back to the ( USA born!) countess, i thanked her for using the Park for free, and Just for fun i said: Ich möchte mich bei Ihrer erlauchten Gräfin bedanken! The Lady looked rather surprised for using old Style words.
Monarchy? For me no problem, why? We have a Democracy, but like a Monarchy i can not elect head of state.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Sorry, wrong Button. Vollbier/ Full Beer, 4,5 to 6,5 per Cent, usual type of german Beer. And Starkbier, stronger than 6,5 per cent. I think, the Einfachbier was the once common type of Beer. I think, if medieval German craftsmen, drinking 3 litres of beer would drink 3 litres of modern Vollbier, they would roll arround on the floor.
1
-
@dravenocklost4253 : Up to 16th century levies ( in german Aufgebote) had been common a part of armies! It was 17th century ,Absolutism' which caused the final decline of levies ( in german Landsturm, Landmiliz, Landfahnen, Landessufgebot, Landesdefension, Bürgerwehr, Bürgergarde, Bürgerwache, Bürgermiliz, Bürgermilitär). Absolutistic monachs didn' t want armed and trained citizens.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am Brittas boyfriend and german. You perhaps don' t know , that in case of partisans, this case of warfare has no tradition in Germany. Either soldiers, or civilians. For example: When in napoleonic wars after Napoleons russian campaign, Prussia moblized regular ( secretly trained) reserves, formed fast trained and bad equippet Landwehr units, it was also planned that the Landsturm, formed of rather young, eldery or not really fit men should do Guerilla warfare without uniforms. Prussian king was shocked, and forbid the use of Landsturm in Guerilla style. Also in this age of highest point of german education and spirit, most german intellectuals had been against Guerilla warfare. So in case of nonuniformed civilians, they had been simply seen as criminals in Germany for decades, when german troops noticed ununiformed civilians in 1870, wwl or wwll.
This is no excuse for too cruel things, but those armed civilians caused the life of thousands of innocent civilians. So i don' t see them as heroes. The other things, killing persons simply because they are jewish etc. was , and still is, with no doubt a terrible crime.
1
-
1
-
axolotlguy: a) Before 1873 no Standard German existed, only german dialects, forming three dialect groups. My ( i am Brittas boyfriend) dialect is swabian dialect , which belongs to Hochdeutsch or Oberdeutsch dialect group ( bavarian dialects in Bavaria, Austria and Southern Tyrol in ltaly, swabian - alemannic dialects in parts of german states Baden - Württemberg and Bayern, austrian state Vorarlberg, german part of Switzerland, french Alsace and Liechtenstein. When i travel with my car an hour northwards, i am on fränkisch tribal territory, they speak a different dialect. Fränkisch is spoken in parts of Bayern, Baden - Württemberg, Nordrhein - Westfalen, mainly in Hessen, Saarland, Rheinland - Pfalz and the few remaining Lorraine german speakers ( if there are still ones). B) Frankish empire before split in 843 included current France, Belgium, Netherlands, Luxemburg, Switzerland, Austria, Liechtenstein, northern Italy and Most of current Germany. In this territories had been spoken forerunners of current french/italian/ german/ dutch ( flemish) languages, and latin as clerical/ administrative language. German Name for current France is for centuries Frankreich ( realm of the Franks).
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@vincentb9827 : The mens names is in this case Wilhelm ( William/ Willem/ Guillaume/ Guglielmo), while Canaris, if you mean the german intelligence officer of wwll, is a family name. Some germans have foreign names, because their ancestors had been, for example, french. In second half of 17th century a lot of protestantic French persons had to flee and moved into protestant german regions, a neighbor of me has the family name Jourdan. Also, especially in 16th century educated non noble germans translated their geman family name into greek or latin. So a Hans Bäcker ( Baker) became Hans Pistorius, which was possible in those days. Arminius is the name, how Romans called this historical person, but even still today some midaged german men have the name Armin, i doubt that this is really a germanic mens name, it was either a ,romanisation' ( in german : Verballhornung) of a similar sounding germanic name, or could be a kind of translation , because german mens name parts have often a ,manly' meaning, so perhaps Arm... is a translation of a germanic name , containing ,weapon'. Also womens names contain sometimes ,military ' words, Brünnhilde for example , contains Brünne ( shirt of mail- or scalearmour).
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@82ismi : As far as i know,, it was replaced in 1904 by Navy, and 1908 by Army with Luger/ Parabellum pistol. So i assume, that after 1908 the production of this revolvers for officers and civilians by german and in smaller numbers also belgian companies slowly ended. For civilian/ officers market also versions in double- action, ejectors and fingerhooks at trigger guard existed. But at this time the Reichsrevolver was really dated, so i assume, not sold Reichsrevolver became what we germans call , Ladenhüter ' ( literally shopguard- meaning an Item, nobody wants to buy anymore) in some gunstores Up to end of wwll. During wwl Reichsrevolver was used for rearline units, Police ( and other armed Personal of civilian Administration). Cartidges ( only blackpwder) have been, according to german arms magazines , produced Up to may be 1930. Also according to german arms magazines, last Reichsrevolver being in DARK corners of Arsenals Had been given to Volkssturm. Also according to german arms magazines, 10, 4 mm Italian, in small numbers sometimes produced by Fiocci company , can be used as Substitute for 10, 6 mm GERMAN. BUT: I DON' T know IF THIS IS TRUE.
FROM A REPLICA OF THIS REVOLVER I HAVE NEVER HEARED. WHO WOULD BUY THIS? IN GERMANY GUNLAW BECOMES MORE AND MORE RESTRICTIVE, MORE AND MORE GUNOWNERS FEAR, IN SOME YEARS GUNOWNING COULD BE FORBIDDEN. ( AM NO GUNOWNER). IT SEEMS, MY COMPUTER HAS A PROBLEM, SO I STOP MY COMMENT.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am not Britta herself, but her boyfriend. Most of the commenters have perhaps never seen a Kastell, as we germans call it. I come from a village perhaps 30 km away from the point, where between the current towns of Lorch and Schwäbisch Gmünd, formerly was the border between Germania Superior ( wood / earth Limes) and Raetia ( stone made Limes). Along the border fortification Limes you can find a lot of watchtower relicts ( and more or less good reconstuctions). Along this Limes there had been also Kastelle in different sizes, for Auxillary units, not for full legions. Those border Kastelle really have the same size and plan/structure, they are really similar. Not far away from my village are the relicts of Kastell Köngen( Grinario in roman days) , the relicts of a Kastell near Buch are nealy the same. Both sites have original relicts, reconstrucions, the walls are simulated with earth ramparts ( wall in englisch is Mauer in german, rampart in english is Wall in german), and trees are, where formerly towers had been. There had also been simply build rather small Kastelle, which had not been build in the usual system. In the town of Aalen was a larger Kastell for a large cavallry unit called Ala, perhaps the reason for current town name, there is an interessting Museum about Romans. In the nearby town of Ellwangen is a museum about the Alemannen, but they things shown there, are from a later periode. Near the noted village of Buch you can follow for kilometers the Limes, you can still see a small rampartlike line with bushes.
1
-
Toyguns for selfdefence? After lost wwll Germany and Austria was under Allied occupation, and for a number of years german/ austrian citizens could buy no selfdefence weapons ( in communist Eastern Germany until 1989). What was produced and sold as substitute? In Austria a company for bureau items and miniature model produced a hollow basicly pistol shaped Item, which could not be mistaken for a real pistol. A pink paint, stinking strong and rather difficult to wash away from skin and cloth, was filled in. With a bycicle tire pump the pistol was put under pressure. Pulling the trigger- the stinky pink paint came out. A german producer of water toy guns sold his pistols with a container of chemicals. Mix some chemicals into the water in the watergun, and you had weak teargas. Another german company of sheet metal toys produced a pistol, containing a strong spring. The spring was put under power , a thin walled plastic Egg was put into muzzle. After trigger pull, the spring jumped, destroyed the plastic Egg, and a chemical mixed water ( weak teargas) went out of muzzle.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@michaelmcgovern8110 : A) Those partisans mostly didn' t respect international war law too, but had not been punished after war. Fun fact: When those partisns are so good people, why soldiers of former allied nations had been so cruel against partisans / resistance figjters in Kenia ( british), Indochina and Algerie ( french), Vietnam ( US) or Afghanistan ( russian)?b) Especially in russian Propaganda there had been lots of hate and uncovered advices to kill as many german people as possible , the russians also killed in Katyn (?) thousands of polish officers, claiming this was done by Germans, even jugoslawian partisan leader Tito protested against russian behavior of raping also jugoslawian women. c) russian hate Propaganda was surely the most worse, but propanda of other nations resulted also crimes of allied soldiers. d) When freefrench troops ( often colonials from Northern Africa Colnies) conquered / ocupied black Forrest , thousands of women had been raped, alone in Freudenstadt a female doctor noted, when french troops arrived , she had to look in first two days after 100 raped women. This is nearly forgotten, because it is not much spoken about it. I doubt, that this could happen in such large numbers, without ,looking away' of french officers After war first chancellor Adenauer let collect a list of warcrimes, done by Allied troops under latin name ,Tu coqui' ( you also), but for political reasons, he never used the list. e) I never said, that number of Allied warcrimes had been larger than Axis . f) First US soldier my father, born 1938 saw, aimed with a pistol on him, his sister, brother, mother, grandmother and a neighborwoman and shouted: Wo Ring? Wo Gold? ( Ring and Gold mean the same in english and german).
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
In 1871 a goldbacked Mark was introduced. It was either called only Mark or Goldmark (once a Mark was a halbes Pfund/ half pound). After wwl the no more goldbacked Mark became more and more worthless, the highest inflation was in 1923, so for about a year the Rentenmark was introduced. A thing similar to ,old' and ,new' francs of 1960s, but in Germany much more ,0' disappeared. Then, i think 1924, the new Reichsmark was used. The ,Kleingeld', the coins lower than 50Pfennig looked rather similar than westgerman Pfennig coins after war. Neighborchildren and i found in early 1970s a 10 Reichspfennig coin. We did not know, what a Reichspfennig is, for us it was more important, that we could get with this coin chewing gum out of a chewing gum selling machine.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Was from early 10th century to 1806 regular part of HRE. In 955 Lechfeld battle, first campaign where a realy german army appeared on battlefield, bohemian levie was rearguard of german army.. And from about 1400 to 1918 part of Austria/Habsburg territories. So starting in middleage, when a native dynasty ruled, to wwll a large german minority lived there, and some bohemian towns ( Städte) had a germanstyle lawset. When in 1918 Czechoslovakia was founded, there had been in reallity a bit more germans than slovacs, and german people had been, at least in first years threated bad, was one of the reasons, why a man named Henlein (?) a supporter of Hitler was successfull among german inhabitants of Czechoslovakia. When in 1919, treatises of Versailles and St. Germain, the Allied nations would have used their brains better, wwll surely would not have happened.
1
-
1
-
@causewaykayak : Glasbläserei was once in german regions full of Woods rather common. On german side of german/czech border ( Bayrischer Wald) glass and porcellain production is still wellknown.
A note to german job training/ craftman system ( perhaps also Austria/ Switzerland), dating back to middleage. Formerly with 12 to 14 Years, nowadays ( change of school system) with 16 to 18 years, boys ( of course nowadays also girls) start the jobraining called Lehre. After usually 3 to 3,5 years this Training time is over, and after a successfull test ( practical and theoreitic) in industry you.are Facharbeiter, in traditional craftmanship ( Handwerk) you are Geselle ( like middleage). Those craftsmen, who learned their job in traditional Handwerk, often, but not allways, follow an old tradition called Wanderschaft: For three years they travel through the world and join for few weeks the craftsmens shops of a Meister / master craftman. When you are a Geselle/ Facharbeiter after three years you can do an expensive test, producing a Meisterstück/ masterpiece. In traditional Handwerk you become Handwerksmeister and like in last 1000 years you can open an own workshop, hire Gesellen, train Lehrlinge. In Industy you become Industriemeister, here you are only the leader of a team of workers, or, leader of a production room.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am german, Brittas boyfriend, born 1965. I live in an area, full of ruins of medieval castles, celtic remains ( oppidum/ oppidi?) and , not far away , relicts of fortified borderline between Imperium Romanum and Germania Magna. So as little child i have seen historic relicts, and thought, life in castles was like swashbuckler movies ( Mantel - und Degenfilme) in TV. In 1971 i saw Lichtenstein castle, and was happy: First castle not destroyed ( didn't knew , this is a fairytale castle of 1840s). Now , over 50 years later, after reading books, magazines, visiting museums of all sorts ( Roman, celtic, allemanic, medieval content, weapons, home region history....), castles, palaces, monastries, fortresses, Westwall, Atlantikwall, Ligne Maginot, Stone age sites, reconstructions, real relicts, town walls. I spoke with hunters, collectors, target shooters, Reenactors, museum/ castle staff ( lot of this persons are surprisingly uneducated), security guards etc.. So, being a factory worker, no accademic, i think, i notice when someone tells nonsens. And: I refuse to watch all this modern ,Fantasy' shit.
1
-
1
-
1
-
You are comming from Munich, where today standard german is spoken, and only few people speak watered down upper bavarian dialect. So it is rather clear, that you have problems with older words from franconian ( Palatine/ Hesse) and allemanic ( Swabian/ Swiss) region. For me, Brittas boyfriend, who speaks in daily life swabian dialect, rarely Standard German, it was a bit easier. The for you unknown ,äbbas' means simply ,etwas'. And in first clip with the ,pumkin eater' i could understand ,Fresser' , which is still used for a person, who eats an astonishing quantity of food, the word ,crip' could be Kripp ( Krippe in dialect). The clip with the american women and her german boyfriend or husband i saw some time ago. When i remember right, he is from Saxony, so it is rather difficult for him, to understand an oldfashioned version of Southwest german dialects. The word ,Schuir' ( Scheuer) i still use, and in swabian dialect of my region ,Barn' is used for this part of Scheuer/ Scheune, where hay and straw ( spoken similar to english) is realy stored.
1
-
There are similar rifles in Germany, at least in South West Germany, but made from swiss 1911 rifles. In some german towns, especially in such ones , which had been in HRE time a ,Reichsstadt' ( Imperial town) , historical militias exist. They wear uniforms, mostly of 19th century, have a small band, sometimes a mounted detachement and they sometimes apperar on various events. They do a little march and drill show, the band plays and as a spectacle they fire some blank salvos. Up to about 1848, this militias really sometimes supported army and police, but afterwards to now, they only do some drill and try to keep the tradition of former HRE Reichsstadt. A Sidenote: This Imperial Towns had for centuries been the only places, NOT governed by nobles in Germany. There was only an imperial official , the Schultheiß ,in town, but he was not with the centuries mostly weaker than major.
When Germany lost wwll, the allied occupation forces confiscated all rifles , muskets, sabers and polearms of this militias. When this militias had been allowed again in early 1950s, uniforms and sabers had been no problem, but rifles. In those days, Switzerland sold its 1911 remaining 1911 rifles out of armoury. This militias heared this, and bought some hundred of this swiss rifles, to convert then into blankfire only. Swiss authorites noticed this, they did not know this german historical militias thing, and warned german gouvernement: Attention! Someones tries a coup d' Etat!
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@janushahn6950 : As far as i know, it was then allowed to call yourself, King in ...' without diplomatic problems, but not usual. In 1470s Last Duke of Burgundy, known as Charles the Bold, had territories in France and HRE. He asked Friedrich lll, as HRE Emperor on theory highest european ruler, if he can give him the rank of King, but Friedrich could not do so, he could not create a new Kingdom.
A sidenote: What many people don' t know, the namegiving Hohenzollern ( mount and castle) is not somewhere in Brandenburg or Prussia, it is in southwest of Germany. Under best weather conditions i can see the Mountain from my Village. No problem is mount Hohenstaufen ( dynasty noted in Video), which is perhaps twenty kilometers away. One swabian branch of Hohenzollern dynasty is still allive.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Some small notes from Germany: The german ,ch' sound is not a ,k' . German ,th' is spoken ,t' , not the english way ( When Standard German was created in 19th century, and was officially adopted in Germany, Austria and Switzerland in early 1870s, the former custom of writing a ,h' after every ,t' ended, so today a ,th' appears only in in names or nongerman words, the only exeption is Thron/ throne, because Wilhelm ll in 1901 saved the ,h' in this word.) Also calling von Richthofen a Baron is not correct. In british nobility rank system Baron is the lowest rank of high nobility, while german nobility rank Freiherr is highest rank of low nobility ( knights), so Baronet would be more correct. Baron is in Germany often used for Freiherr, but only in Austria or Bavaria some few noblemen bot this title officially.
1
-
Iceland, Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Färöer Islands: North Germanics. Germany (Austria/ Liechtenstein/ two thirds of Switzerland), Luxemburg, Netherlands, flemmish part of Belgium, England: Western Germanics. Goths, Vandalic, Burgundic, Langobatds: Eastern Germanics / extinct. As a German ( and also germanic) person i know, what i write.
1
-
1
-
@veronicalogotheti5416 : Spaß beiseite/ fun aside . At first it would be good to describe more clearly, what you realy want to say. I am german, more precise, member of Swabian/ Alemannic tribe. And i know my tribal history. My tribe once lived in todays Mecklenburg ( northeast Germany) and moved southwards. In 260 they moved into Roman Empire ( the fortfied Limes border was no more full manned with Auxillari troops), later in 4/5 th century they crossed Rhine and Danube and conquered the rest of nowadays territory of my tribesmen. So my tribe is a mix of germanic majority and ,colonial roman' minority. About the same with our eastern neighbor tribe, the Bavarians ( Bajuwari). The germans of former Eastern Germany are a mix of slavic people, which settled there after germanic tribes moved away, and Germans ( Germans!!!) , who conquered this area in 12th to 13th century. But that Scandinavians are no Germanics is the greatest nonsense i have ever heared. We Germans call us ,die Deutschen', when we ,rarely today, speak of Germanen, then we mean either all members of germanic nations, or our ancestors before the german nation existed.
1
-
@veronicalogotheti5416 : How often must i repeat , that the Scandinavians ( Icelanders, Norwegians, Swedes, Danes, Färöer) are the northern subgroup of germanic people ( Nordgermanen in german). The Germans ( Austrians, Swiss) , Dutch, Flemmish, Friesians and English are the western subgroup of germanic nations (Westgermanen in german) they moved from Scandinavia/ Northern Germany/Poland to those parts of western europe ,where they live today. The Goths (perhaps from Gotland), Burgundians ( perhaps from Bornholm), Vandaliic and Lombardic are the eastern subgroup of germanic nations ( Ostgermanen in german), they moved from Scandinavia, Northern Germany/ Poland to eastern europe. For the reason of arriving Huns the Eastern Germanics fleed mostly to western europe. They had not so much good luck, so Lombardy region in Italy and Burgundy region in France and some ,germanic heroes tales' like Nibelungenlied remember the Eastern Germanics. Some of those tribal moves happened, when Roman Empire existed, some when only Bycantine Empire remained. That all Germanics are related, you can see in written languages , some nordic words are recognizeable to me.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Mein Heimatdorf wurde nicht mit Bomben angegriffen, bei der Feldarbeit fand ich aber ein übergroßes Geschoß, das wohl von einem Flugzeug MG stammen dürfte, hielt es zunächst für eine Versteinerung, einen sogenannten Belemiten. Bunker gab es im Ort nicht, lediglich gewölbte Keller wurden etwas abgeändert. Meine Großmutter erzählte, sie sei mit ihrem Vater und einer ,Arbeitsmaid' vom Reichsarbeitsdienst bei der Heuernte gewesen, als sie ein Flugzeug hörten, und sich im Gebüsch versteckten. Um eine Notlandung vorzubereiten, warf der Pilot des kleinen Flugzeugs zwei Bomben ab, die beide explodierten, die drei Leute aber nicht verletzten. Beim Anblick der Explosion wusste meine Großmutter, die Hauskeller schützen bei einem Treffer nicht. Sie selbst sei ziemlich erschrocken, aber die Jugendliche habe sich vor Schreck an meinen Urgroßvater geklammert. Dieser war als Veteran des ersten Weltkrieges nicht so sehr erschrocken.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@LiterallyWho1917 : Not totally true, in case of line tactics. Both in Italy 1859, in Denmark 1864 and Königgrätz 1866 the Austrian troops used many parts of old napoleonic tactics. The problem was , that in the austrian army soldiers with german, hungarian, czech, slowakian, slowenian, croatian, italian, polish, ruthenic, romanian etc. native language served, so before 1867 ( the year of military, civil and administration reforms), commanding the modern tactics was a large Problem, so that Austria used old tactics, easier to command , longer. In the very informative Army Museum in the former Arsenal buildings of Vienna, i saw a manual for german language officers, how to speak orders for nongerman soldiers. The orders had been written, for example , in correct hungarian and then in a way , how a german would write it.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@DestinationBarbarism : As i noted, in case of war, every weapon which is still working, is given to those persons, for which they can be still usefull. For guarding prisoners, you can still use wooden clubs, invented in stone age. Older, even oldest weapons are still nowadays existing in stock , for the case of emergency. For frontline use mostly to old, but in case of noted french fieldguards of wwll, they had a rifle, when food thieves had been armed with firearms, but not ( from german perspective) to fight good against german troops. Older weaponry was not only given to armed security personal not, or rarely fighting on frontline, older weaponry was also given to not so thrustworthy allies.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am german, living about thirty Kilometer/twenty miles away from the point, where wood- earth made ,uppergemanic' Limes met stone made ,rhaetian ' Limes, the borderline between Imperium Romanum and Germania Magna. In the years after 260 my swabian/alemannic ancestors conquered their current tribal area. But this was not realy a military conquest. For inner roman reasons, most of regular Legionaries had left the region, only auxillary units remained and more and more raids of Alemannics came, so many roman civlians left the region, the remaining bougt weapons for selfdefence. So starting in 260, the remaining auxillary troops and civillians simply rather fast fleed and this was not an Alemannic victory over Roman troops.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@petyrbaelish007 : I am german. It seems that Propaganda Minister Göbbels Washington among ,first row' of important Nsdap members the one, who used his position the most, to come into bed with good looking women. In his position he was in charge of german movie, theater, music, opera business, so he had access to actresses and female singers. I often read , that Göbbels had the nickname , Bock von Babelsberg'. Babelsberg was location of most famous german Film Studios ( german Hollywood) and Bock, that is buck in english.....
1
-
1
-
@christianweibrecht6555 : Yes, the german name of the war of 1870/71 , Deutsch- Französischer Krieg' ( German- French war) is more exact. In 1866 Österreich, Luxemburg and Liechtenstein left ,Germany', Hannover, Hessen- Kassel and Frankfurt ( Main)also Schleswig, Holstein, and Lauenburg had been annexed by Prussia. So the remaining states which took part in the war of 1870/71 had been: The Kingdoms of Preußen, Bayern, Sachsen and Württemberg. The Grand Duchies of Baden, Hessen- Darmstadt, Oldenburg, Mecklenburg- Schwerin, Mecklenburg- Strelitz and Sachsen- Weimar - Eisenach. The Duchies of Anhalt, Braunschweig, Sachsen- Coburg- Gotha, Sachsen- Altenburg and Sachsen- Meiningen. The Principalities of Waldeck- Pyrmont, Lippe- Detmold, Schwarzburg- Rudolstadt, Schwarzburg- Sondershausen, Reuß- Greitz (?) and Reuß- Schleitz (?). The Free and Hanseatc towns of Hamburg, Bremen and Lübeck.
1
-
I am german, and Brittas boyfriend, only using her Computer too, born 1965. What is my education?.In german my education is called Mittlere Reife ( middle education) and i am german style trainer worker (Facharbeiter), and a conservative/ rural man. I live in a german region , where you can find celtic forts/ oppidi, Roman Forts/ Vilae Rustica, about twenty Miles away, there was fortified Imperium Romanum/ Germania Magna borderline called Limes. On many hills, small River bends, the clifflike northern end of Swabian Alb plateau, you can find lots of medieval Castle ruins. My homeregion was in HRE era most divided part of HRE. To give you an example. The Kreisstadt / county town of my Landkreis/ county (?) is Esslingen am Neckar. Was in HRE era an , Imperial Town '. Other territory of Landkreis Esslingen belonged mostly to Duchy of Württemberg, but two villages belonged to Imperial Knights, and one village belonged to a bishop of Rhineland . For a person like me, the current nonsens in historical/ costume movies IS unbelievable. It seems, the leftwing, political correct, woke persons of university background are complete idiots.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@SurajSinghTomarArya :Your Name Sounds very indian, so your comment is believeable. I also have noticed that there , that an assumingly private company started production of pistols ( revolvers are a dibcategory of pistols) in India under name Webley. I am no expert , german gunlaw is restrictive, but: A pistol in.45 Acp with only seven cartridges seems a bit dated. Pistols in .32 Acp are also dated, and revolvers in .32 S&W Long are also dated ( in late 1940s FBI ended use of .32 S&W ). In my oppinion the .45 Acp pistol of , Webley ' company is totally outdated for modern civilian use. The .32 Acp should be replaced by .380 Acp, and .32 S&Wlong should be replaced by .38 S&W, .38 Special or .32 H&R Magnum., or .455 Webley. The ( to few!) indian citizens who can buy firearms should be able to be equiped with with firearms, useable for selfdefence.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@TheFalseShepphard : I, Brittas boyfriend, never saw Universities from inside. I am trained worker ( Facharbeiter), middle education ( passed 10th class of Gymnasium) , rural/ farmers background. I once respected accademics as welleducated , elite'. But in last twenty years this respect declined. Why? To few Natural and Technical scientists ( Naturwissenschaftler und Ingenieure) , but to much leftist , Laberfach' idiots, who don' t understand, that Germany is funded and feed not by leftist , Laberer'. Leftist , Laberer' ( University students, University Professors, all kind of Ideologie , Beauftragte )' are feed by tax money, which is stolen the WORKING part of population to feed leftist lazybones. In my oppinion all those Gouvernement feed , leftist Laberer' must be forced to work, so that they learn reality, what is important, and what not, because i have no mercy
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@caspar_van_walde : I am a rural man, i only use the Computer of my girlfriend too. I have an Asperger disorder, and don' t like to travel much, because i need a standardiced life for my psychical health. In case of writing, ii of course only use Standard German. But in daily life, i use Standard German only, when foreigners ( including , Prussians' ) don' t understand me. My swabian dialect is NO wrong german, IT IS only unstandardized German. I , being at Gymnasium up to 10th Grade/ class, hate it , when Standard German speaking people , especially from the North think, they are better than i. I hate it, when Towns folk, thinks, they are better than me, a man of farmers background
I hate it, when , elite' lazybones think, they are better than ,working class' people, and i hate it, when left idiots think, they have eaten wisedom with a spoon and are better than a conservative, tradition respecting man.
For this reason, respecting my ancestors and tradition, i continue to speak my dialect. I know, in may be ten years, i can sit in Stuttgart Zoo ( Wilhelma) with a sign : Swabian, dying out species', but that' s my, not your problem.
1
-
@tatumergo3931 : So in Iceland this, what i call stonecoal ( Steinkohle in german) exists, then a small scale Iron production is possible. When in 960s the neighboring Village to my one , was first time noted in a document, a territorial change between a bishop and german King, iron production could have been a reason. Wood for making woodcoal was enough here, a few years ago some kilometers away last woodcoal burner of my region stopped production, but there was no Iron ore in the Stonepart of nearby mountains, it was socalled Bohnerz ( Bean ore?) which could be collected, this small, but in 10th century important Iron production stopped rather fast in 11th century. The people still knew,that the small Stones of max. beansize can be used for Iron production, but by the time collecting came to an end for small quantity reason.
1
-
1
-
1
-
Max Schultz : My english is not so good as you perhaps think, but it seems that think the same as i. I also see the danger, that enemy troops take terrible revenge for the actions of non regular fighters. In wwll for this reason the Swiss governement gave order, that civilians should not fight invading troops, every man, who was no member of the Swiss army, who wanted to defend Switzerland, should become a member of the local ,Ortswehr/ settlement defence. This had been small units of not so fightable men , uniformed, to support the army. When armed men with only an armbind, sash or badge as uniform are used as guards, guides, escorts, transport personal, military workers, or fortifications defenders under command of regulär soldiers or officers is in my eyes okay, when they do their work regular. But irregular fighters with really no basic kind of uniform, hidden weapons and using no regular way of war are a great danger for peacefull civilians, who simply want to survive a war.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@glenngilbert7389 : Attention what you say! I am Brittas boyfriend, simple worker, conservative rural backgrond. In last three decades education system ( shools/university), Newspapers, TV, Mainstream, church (especially Protestant church) became unbelievable leftwing, woke and political correct, also policy and gouvernement. It is not my fault, that here is idiocracy ruling. Everybody who critsizes this dangerous nonsens here is called by noted circles, authorities is called a Nazi/ Rightwinger to keep critics quiet. When a conservative, rural, patriotic German Like me, becomes unwilling respecting Chancellor and more representative Federal President, and is unsure , if defending Volk and Vaterland under current circumstances is my duty or not,you may understand my sadness.,
1
-
@ursulastaempfli759 : I am Brittas boyfriend, only using her Computer too. I don't know history of Germany? Before 843 ( Treaty of Verdun) there was Frankish Empire, ruled by Merowinger dynasty, then Karolinger dynasty. In 843 Frankish Empire was divided into Westfrankish Empire ( mostly current France, with exeption of Lorraine, Alsace, Burgundy ,then simplified Rhone valley, Savoy. Middle Frankish Empire ( with Emperor title, consisting of current Netherlands, Belgium, Luxemburg, Lorraine, Alsace, parts of Switzerland, noted Burgundy and Northern Italy) Sand East Frankish Empire ( German part of Switzerland, Austria and former West Germany). So this East Frankish Empire could be , with some stomach ache, called first German Empire. But in 911 last carolingian King of East Frankish Empire died, officialy ( Treaty of Verdun) now carolingian King of West Frankish Empire should have been new king, but east frankish noblemen noticed: The West frankish King no more speaks ( germannic) frankisch and electded a noncarolingsn nobleman as new King of East Frankish Empire. But this man was of frankish tribe, so could have been related to last carolingian King. In 919 East Frankish Empire the first non frankish King was elected, a Saxon. So when ended East Frankish Empire, and when started German Empire? Oh in 962 Otto l, King of German Empire was in Rome crowned as Roman Emperor, not German Emperor. Before 843 it is uncorrect to speak of Germany , because only the germannic tribes, which later formed german nation. Yes, i have no clue.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@StillAliveAndKicking_ : German is not alien, as german speak it for 58 Years now, I learned it as little child :-))). English is no problem, because for talking about everyday things, you need words, being recognizeable enough for German persons. Also german Handtasche/ english handbag, but poche de main. Annother thing which is for us germans Impossible is in frech language the difference between speaking and writing. When someone speaks Standard German ( No dialect) you know, how to write the word. But ,Büro' or ,Rondewu' are written,bureau' and ,rendez- vous'! Or when i hear ,visite' ,hm, visite',visitee, visiter, visites, vistez? Sounds all the same. The french nasal Sounds are for me No problem, I use it in my german dialect too.
I know, in contrast to my grandfathers and greatgrandfathers I need No rifle and helmet for traveling, History changed into a better direction. But I think you understand, that i don't t Like it, when someone speaks bad about my language, only because it is different. It seems to me, many nongermans are to lazy or believe the , being to complicated ' nonsens. But on other hand, I was surprised, when a female US tourist , speaking english, was not able to understand some words from low(land) german, which is spoken in former homeland of Anglosaxon: Reep/ Forke/lütt- rope/fork/ little!
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@flyboymike111357 : I am Brittas boyfriend, german, and for reason of my bad eyes i didn' t serve in Bundeswehr ( German armed forces). May be ten years ago in the former company i worked, there happened a dispute between two coworkers . One served in Bundeswehr ( West Germany), the other one had only East German ,Vormilitärische Ausbildung ' ( premilitary Training) of FDJ ( HJ painted in red).
They had a dispute, which Army , Bundeswehr or Nationale Volksarmee, had more power and was Superior. Those , who served in Bundeswehr, thought, Bundeswehr was Superior, because of numbers and more modern equipment. But i told my doubts. Basicly East German Army was Red painted Wehrmacht, and Wehrmacht was Variation of German Imperial Army, and Imperial Army was Prussian Army. So basicly, East German Army was basicly in its core the Prussian Army. For centuries a sign of quality. But Bundeswehr, Army of citizens in Uniform? Westgerman equipment seems to be more modern, but eastgerman ( russian equipment) was combatproofed and easier to repair. Also East Germans had a lower Life Standard Level, in fieldlife a person used to have a low Level of Luxus is a better soldier. Etc. Etc. After my words, the east German coworker smiled, while westgerman coworker had a ,thinking face'.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@philipphermann9454 : My girlfriend Britta knows a woman from Vietnam and asked her if Backnang makes sense in her language, it does, but i have forgotten, what Backnang would mean in vietmamese. ( You surely know the old joke, that some german traffic signs must be for chinese people, you can read Um Lei Tung) .But now fun aside. I am also Swabian, and was rather surprised, when i learned the english word for Scheune/ Scheuer- barn, here in my homeregion a Barn is this part of a Scheune, where hay and straw ( also nearly the same sound like german) is really stored. And when your grandmother is swabian , you perhaps know, what in swabian ,stieren' can ( can !) mean. If you don' t know, what is english ,to stire'? .
1
-
1
-
@marwaattar9846 : German Straße, dutch straat, english street. German Weg, english way, German Pfad/ english path. Field is in german Feld, Hill is german Hügel. Fight is in current german kämpfen, fencing is in german fechten, but once fechten meant to fight. In context of things, existing before 1066 english and german words are similar, and in german dialects ( i usually don' t speak Standard German), some dialect words are closer to english than ones of Standard German. For example: Standard German: Hahn, swabian dialect Gockel , english cock. Or Standard German umrühren, english to stirr, in some context swabian stieren means about the same. I know, i am a bit ( ein bisschen) autistic.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Ich kenne ihr Alter nicht. Seit Ende der 1970er Jahre gibt es das Phänomen, daß linke Kreise Krawalle anzetteln, bei großen Bauvorhaben waren es teilweise an die 10000 linke Randalierer. Hinterher behaupten linke Kreise immer, sie seien friedlich gewesen, aber Polizei, Nazis, Marsmenschen, Heiliger Geist oder sonstwer seien schuld. Seit rund 45 Jahren warte ich darauf, daß linke Kreise endlich mal etwas gegen Linksextremismus und Gewalt unternehmen. Auch wird von linken Kreisen, für mich unverständlich, der Islam hofiert, obwohl die Ansichten des Islams für mich keine Ähnlichkeiten zu linkem Gedankengut erkennen lassen, meiner Meinung nach stimmen Teilaspekte des lslams eher mit dem Nationalsozialismus überein.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
In Germany we don' have this ,prince' problem The son of an emperor, king , great duke, duke, or ruling prince is a Prinz, but a ruling prince, today only in Liechtenstein and Monaco, is in german a ,Fürst'. This appeared in 17th century (perhaps late 16th century) as a real rank/title of noblemen, before this time it meant simply ,rich and mighty ruler'/monarch in the style of this video, and sometimes it is still used today with the old meaning.
1
-
Carlos Marte : When in 1618 the thirty-years- war started in Germany, the heavy cavalrymen called Lanzierer used full armor and helmets with visor, the heavy cavalry men called Kürisser used 3/4 armor and a helmet with visor (hands and lower legs protected by leather gloves and boots). Light cavalrymen had also been armored, with 1/2 armor, open or visored helmets, chain mail, single plates, leather vests, brigandines padded jackets etc.. The infantry men had been like light cavalry or nearly unarmored. In 1648 heavy cavalrymen had open helmets, 1/2 armor or only leather vest and breast - and backplate. Light cavalry and infantry had only leather vests and sometimes a light open helmet . Why? Two reasons. The armies had become larger than former, it would have been to expensive to produce enough good quality armor (protection against pistol or musket fired from long distance). A lot of armor craftsmen died in thirty- years - war, the quality became worse, and also warfare changed to a more quick style. In 18th century only cuirassiers used armor: a leather vest and often only the breastplate and a ,cap' made of tin under the hat. In Germany of 18th century there had been still stored helmets, plates some arm and leg protection pieces- for the case of war with the Ottoman Empire, the german cavalrymen feared the arrows of light turkish cavalry. Armor in America: in late 18th century there had been the ,leather dragoons' in Mexico. Leather vest, hat and small shield (ardaga?).
1
-
@Project_Future : When i, mostly together with my girlfriend, want to dance, i visit Tanzcafé Bamboleo in a perhaps 50000 inhabitants german town. Was for over 30 years run by a man named Renz. When he retired, two ,modern' guys tried to transform it into a club. They failed. For about two years now, a married couple runs Bamboleo. Mostly a waitress is also there, and sometimes a DJ. This Tanzcafé is intended for persons older than 50, who prefer couples dances , either , Standard ', ,Latin' or german Discofox ( based on Foxtrott basic.step). Rarely drunkyards, and more rarely violent idiots. That is the Entertainment my girlfriend and i prefer. Music, Dancing, talking with serious people. Those Ladies, described in this Video, can be a pleasure for a Professional Photographer, but that is all.
1
-
@jsholmes03 : Rausschmeißer is a dated, no more common term ( i am older). Currently bouncers are called Türsteher ( literally doorstander) , english Doorman or ( wrong used loanword) Security. The term Rausschmeißer was common, when private german security companies ( existing since 1901) and the Werkschutz/ works protection of large companies only had uniformed personal to guard factories or patroling buildinge at night. In those days, may be into 70s/ 80s, you could not hire in Germany bouncers from Security companies, so formerly strong men, often of dubious background, had been hired. Law has changed, today every unarmed security person needs a basic licence, as far as i know, this basic licence is only bottom end of knowledge and more for law reason, than education.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@doctordoggo8604 : About 42% of Reichswehr officers had been part of former nobility, but only 0,42 % of population. This was critisized a lot. I personaly also think, that most Reichswehr officers, also nonnobles, had doubts about a Reserve formed by SA units. The older SA members had been veterans of wwl, some well reputated, the SA was organised similar to Reichswehr or any regular Army, but there was too much ideology, unfine behaviour and a lack of officers knowledge/ education among most SA ,officers'. But the sheer (?) number of four million men in 1933 and the attitudes of SA Commander Röhm had become dangerous for Hitlers plans. So the fake coup d' etat ( Röhmputsch) was used, to murder SA staff and reduce number of SA members to about one million. After 1933 SA was involved in sports and miliitary training of HJ and untrained men, after 1939, those SA men not taken in Wehrmacht, SS or other organisations, had to support Police, fire brigades, Air raid protection and lesser visible support of wareffort.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@hersirivarr1236 : I also have heared , that finnish people call Germany Saksa, because from finnisch view , the Sachsen,Saxons are the next german tribe. From french or spanish/ portugese view, the Allemanen ( Alsace/ German Swiss/Liechtenstein/ austrian state Vorarlberg/ bavarian district Schwaben, mid and southern part of Baden- Württemberg) are the next german tribe. Note: The by Caesar noted tribe of the Suevi was stopped by the roman Limes border fortifications and united with smaller tribes to the Alemannen ( which could really mean Alle Männer/ all men). When the frankish empire was divided the name Schwaben was used.We ourself call us ,deutsch' so there is often a confusion ,deutsch'/,dutch'. These languages are similar, and the Netherlands had been part of Germany up to 1580s , on paper up to 1648, and Belgium was as ,austrian Netherlands' up to 1790s a part of Germany, so the confusion is understandable. Deutsch, up to the napoleonic time often written teutsch ( see italian tedesco) comes as far as i know from ,theodisc'( language of the people) . Priests or monks wrote in latin language, and to describe the language of non clerical ,Germans' the word theodisc was used. Possible is also, that non german writers of latin language used the word Teutones, appearing in roman documents, to describe the theodisc speaking persons.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
There must be seen a different situation. There had been knights, some mounted rich nonnobles of towns, some few professional nonnoble soldiers ( mercennaries, mostly specialists, bodyguards). Then there had been semiprofesional soldiers, this had been miltias, both town militias ( often with good bowmen or crossbowmen) ,but equipment was different, for wealth of town ( fortified town is in german sense a town only), some town militias of middleage still exist as ,Schützenverein' today. Also the ,main servant' of a knight (castles in my swabian homeregion are small) had some military knowledge and equipment. Also the knights had a small militia group of trustworty men ( equipment on Knights weslth). So this professional fighters and trained militias had been best possibility for a campaign. I think, only in case of real emergency the levy/ Landsturm was mobilized. While townsmen ( as freemen) often had a communal arms house, and the right ( but if poor not the money) to private own weapons, the situation in country was totally different. With exeption of Switzerland or frisian region of HRE, most countrymen had no more been free or semifree, but unfree, which meant, without allowness of a Knight or noblemen, no real weapons, and also remaining free vor semifree men often had been poor, so versions of Bauernwehr or langes Messer surely had been more common than swords, and simple spears/ Spiesse had been more common than real polearms. Also tools and clubs had been used. But i think, this unarmored emergency levies/ Landsturm men ( outside of Swiss and frisian region) had been used more for auxillary service than battlefield ( small war, plundering, transport, work). Also the ordinary commoner had no military training, but some expierience in streetfights, brawls, disputes, etc..
1
-
Schwabe is a german name, which means translated Swabian ( member of the swabian tribe), this means, his ancestors had been swabians of southwestern Germany, which moved in a time, when family names started to appear to another region of Germany.This phenomeon is the reason , why in Germany many people have namess like Schwab, Bayer, Sachs(e), Frank(e), Schweizer or Elsässer . Greetings from Germany.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am german. At the start of the 30 years war (1618-1648) armour was common not only for heavy cavallry, but also light cavallry and infantry had light armour. Good armour pieces, especially breasplates, not so common, helmets and backplates , have some protection against Pistole balls, and on longer distance, also musket balls. But the problem was, the armies became larger than in former times, so it became very expensive, to equip every soldiers with good armour. A second problem was the decline in quality. The craftsmen had to produce more armour in a shorter time, and as longer as the war lasted, the knowledge of the craftsmen declined, because many welltrained craftsmen died, because of war, Hunger and disseases, also the iron/steel quality declined. So at the end of the 30years war, fewer and fewer armour was used in my country. But up to the 1790s the remaining pieces of armour had been kept in stock, for the reason of a war against turkish troops with lots of mounted archers.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
washizukanorico : It is late now, so i will do only a short answer, in english , parce que je ne connait les mots francais. The german nation is tecnically a union of tribes, which no more fight each other. The ,German War of 1866 ' could be descibed as the last tribal war. You are right, the swabian dialect, swiss german and allemannic, spoken in .Black Forrest, Alsace and , Allgäu' once had been one dialect, pre 1500. Bavaria, Austria and Southern Tirol are a dialect region etc.. Everyone of the former tribes still has its own dialect, nowadays young townpeople prefer Standart German, but elderly countrypeople still prefer regional dialect. For me as a swabian, i can understand bavarian or frankonian/hessian dialect , but only in a soft version, the ,hardcore version' is for me impossible to understand, but bavarians or frankonians have the same problems with me. And also the dialects from northern germany are nearly impossible to unterstand for me. The Plattdeutsch for example has a lot of similarities to Englisch, the ancestors of the english people came from there, Plattdeutsch: lütt, English: little. That 's the reason , why Standart German exists!
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
A person calling himself , Carl the Adopted Yorkshireman' asked, why i think, it is funny, that the town Owen ( spoken Auen) has three whisky destilleries. In the swabian region between the Neckar river and the ,Swabian Alb/Jura' mountains there had been formerly a lot of very small destilleries, which produced traditional fruit spirit/Schnaps. Some years ago in the small town Owen (3600 inhabitants) there had been more than 20 of such destilleries, and today fewer people drink , Schnaps' , so many destillers switched to whisky, a trend, 25 years ago nobody thougt about. So i think that is an extraordinary story.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@letoubib21 : You again :-). Neubreisach was build in Vauban era, so much of the fortificstions had been about 200 years old. In 1866 Marienburg, the fortress over Würzburg was shelled a short time by prussian artillry ( as far as i know only field artillry), the in 17th century last time modernized fortress could not withstand. A totally different thing: Perhaps ten years ago, during a historical tour i visited Lichtenberg castle, no more really fortified, last modernisations perhaps 15th century. The owner , who was a teenager in last days of wwll, told the visitors that the Bergfried/ Keep was damaged , but not totally destroyed by few hits of US tank cannons. So you can not really say, how strong old walls are , when facing modern weaponry. But a location, at which one a castle was, is often intressting also for modern soldiers. For example : Until 2004 not far away from my village was large Truppenübungsplatz/ military training ground Münsingen. On the territory of this training ground is a place, where once was a Burg/ castle. There are no ruins, only some relicts of ramparts and ditches. The medieval relicts are nearly destroyed, because soldiers do their training, dug modern foxholes there. So this place must be for military reasons still important in our days.
1
-
1
-
@felixmervamee7834 : At the end of wwll many people in Germany or Austria tried to put gold, jewelry, weapons away to a hidden place, this is true. The allied soldiers stole more than you think. So the qusstion, who in Austria or Germany in 1945 looted things is simply not intelligent. I am Brittas boyfriend, german, my father often told, how he saw first US soldiers in 1945. He was seven years old, together with his brother, sister, mother, grandfmother, a very old related man, and a woman of neighborhood had been in the cellar, when US troops entered the village. The noted soldier broke the small window of frontdoor, unlocked it, entered house and cellar, draw his pistol, pointed it to the people and shouted: Wo Ring? Wo Gold? ( Ring and Gold means the same in german and english.)
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
In late 70s to 80s in West Germany , young men/ teenagers had, compared to now longer hair. I, Brittas boyfriend, had allways hair shorter than average young men. One day is visited a kind of show/exhibition of tools and things you can need at home. I payed the entrance fee (?) and noticed later, the woman gave me to much coins back. When leaving the event, i noticed why. There was a sign, that ,among some others, soldiers had to pay a reduced entrance fee. Now the woman saw a young man with a for the time unusual short haircut and thought, i am a soldier.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Heinz76 harald: : Austrians ( with exeption of Vorarlberg), german speaking South Tyrolians, inhabitants of bavarian districts Upper Bavaria, Lower Bavaria, Upper Palatine and the few inhabitants of a small italian valley , who call themselves Cimbri are speaking bavarian. Up to mid 12th century ( 1160?) current Austria was a part of Bavaria. Current Austria was before 1160 the ,Mark' ( borderland) to nongermannic ( slavic) people. Austrian state Steiermark still has Mark in its name. Also english/scottish borderland is called ,the Marks/ Marques'. I, Brittas boyfriend, only using her Computer too, know that both bavarian and swabian/ alemannic dialects form the , upper german ' dialect group and share some features. Btw., as a swabian nostalgic i refuse to speak , prussian Standard German '.
1
-
1
-
@quintrankid8045 : My english is not so fluent as you might think. Here in Germany military things are today mostly seen as a bad thing, when you visit a military museum, for example the ,Wehrgeschichtliches Museum' in Rastatt, formerly financally supported by the german armed forces, then you never will find patriotsm. So i was rather surprised, when i visited the ,Imperial War Museum' in London in the early 90s. To me , used to see german museums, this museum seemed filled with a patriotic spirit, which you don't find here. I have no problem, when in old nongerman movies of the 40s to 60s german soldiers are allways shown as bad people. But i have a problem, when i see this in modern productions. You perhaps know, there are lots of movies, in which the story plays during the US civil war 1861 to 1865, but rather few about the european wars of this peride. So i was at first happy, when i found in YouTube a clip of a movie with the german/ danish war of 1864. After a short time i angrily stopped watching the clip and don' t want to watch the full movie. Why? A small danish patrol of danish infantry was captured by a larger patrol of german cavallry. For no reason the german soldiers wanted to execute the danish soldiers , and the german commander was shown as a Fall fat man with bald head and a partly burnt face full of scars. When i saw this in a modern danish movie, i became rather angry and i doubt, that the reason for this war, dating back to incidents in the 1840s , are shown correctly. Such a movie should not be produced in our days. In this comment i tried to explain, what thing i don't like. The other nations make, for my opinion to few movies about the not so good parts of their history.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@jenniferpearce1052 : The german dialects are in heavy decline, but still spoken. Even today, most Germans know, to which tribe they belong.I am a member of the Swabian/ Allemanic tribe. So Allemagne, the french word for Germany or Alemania is simply the name of my tribe. The Alemannen had been, for french or spanish persons, the next Germans. In Finnland Germany is called Sachsa, because for finnisch people the Sachsen( saxons) are the next Germans. The tribal name Alemannen means in current german ,Alle Männer' ( the tribe of the Suevi/ Schwaben, noted by Julius Caesar, united with smaller tribes ,clans vor families)
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
The German empire between 1871 and 1918 consisted of Kingdoms Preußen, Bayern , Sachsen and Württemberg, Great Duchies Baden, Hessen- Darmstadt, Oldenburg, Mecklenburg- Schwerin, Mecklenburg- Strelitz and Sachsen- Weimar- Eisenach, Duchies Anhalt, Braunschweig, Sachsen- Coburg- Gotha, Sachsen- Altenburg and Sachsen- Meiningen, Principalities Lippe- Detmold, Waldeck- Pyrmont, Schwarzburg- Rudolstadt, Schwarzburg- Sondershausen, Reuß- Schleitz and Reuß- Greitz, Free Cities Hamburg, Bremen and Lübeck, also Imperium Territory Elsaß- Lothringen. So Prussia was a part of Germany. The Fleet was run by complete Deutsches Reich, while Prussian army included all soldiers of german Staates, being no kingdom . Saxon Army ( 2 Corps) and Württembergian Army(1 Corps) hat their own General Staff, allways under command of Prussian General Staff, Bavarian Army (3 Corps) had their own General Staff, only in wartime under prussian command, and the privilege to use jackets in bavarian, not prussian , blue.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@BlackWhiteCater : German person here. For reason of our gunlaw, i don' t own firearms, for reason of my bad eyes, i, Brittas boyfriend, didn' t serve in german armed forces. So yes, i am a pure armchair expert.
Remembering my knowledge of physic science, a pistol Projektile will have , when hardness and Type is similar, more Penetration, when the Power per square mm is Higher. A .45 Acp bullet, in , Kennblätter für fremdes Gerät' called 11,5 Colt (a) has , over the thumb' about 100 square mm, a 9mm Parabellum , also ,over the thumb' about 65 square mm . So a . 45 with about 500 to 540 Joules has about 5 to 5,4 Joule per square mm. A 9 mm Parabellum with 470 to 500 Joules has about 6 to 7 Joules per square mm.
Both in wwl and wwll a lot of pistols in .32 Acp/ 7,65 Browning had been used by german forces, often this pistols had been also produced in .380Acp/ 9mm kurz, but the 9mm kurz versions had not been liked by German forces. A) Cartridges was lesser popular/ produced. B) According to German Arms Magazines, 7, 65 Browning had better Penetration against wood. And field fortifications had often been wood- earth fortifications.
When hunting Bonnie and Clyde, Frank Hammer used still his SAA short Barrel in .45 LC, but against Bonnie & Clydes cars, he also used a Colt 1911, but in .38 Super Automatic for Penetration.
Nobody used Armour then? Hm. Yes, before ww I armoured civilian cars for Monarchs, Presidents etc. had been very rare, see Sarajewo 1914 ( have seen the car in Vienna/Militärhistorisches Museum), also in interwar Periode they had been rare, but existed. Unfortunatly, 1934 (?) , Videos exist, jugoslavian King Alexander was assasinated through an open Car Window. But not only Kings and Presidents had armoured civilian cars, also US Gangsters like Al Capone had armoured cars. Some of this cars , like the one of Al Capone had been fine crafted, as a german Style trained metal worker i am allways astonished about the craftsmen' s skill decades or centuries ago, but some armoured Gangster cars had been crude improvisations. When USA entered war in 1941, there was no armoured civil Car for US President, so as substitute during construction, the one of Al Capone was used. In a german Museum i have seen two armoured cars of this Periode, used by supporters of Austrian Charlie Chaplin, who was not as fine than US one.
But i think, with Armour, you mean Body Armour. When wwl started, many cuirassiers and heavy cavallry men still wore cuirass and Metal helmet. But this could protect only against edged weapons, may be shrappnell or older big bore Revolver cartridges, weak Powder Charge and uncovered lead bullet. During war, soldiers got Steel helmets, and the different armies tested hard and soft Body Armour. But in interwar era, this Armour Experiments ended, so in wwll only US Flak jackets and a russian Steelplate Armour was used in noteable quantities. In civilian context also Lots of protection vests had been build and tested, some had been good against weak cartridges.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@rob5944 : I am not Britta herself, but her boyfriend, only using her computer. Artillrymen used nearly the same helmet, but with a ball, for not having accidents. When i in late 1970s visited a for decades now no more existing military museum, there had been two intressting helmets. When the leather stored in depots run out, Ersatzhelme/ Substitute helmets had been produced. Both had only a small spike, and one of the helmets was made of stamped sheet metal, the other one from felt. I hope, this information is new for you. There is in german language a Video series about german wwl helmets, made by ,Panzermuseum Munster'.
1
-
1
-
1
-
The persons in country are different than town people . The country people have more work, more costs and more problems. The town people are not the ones, who have to repair the damage, the town people have not to pay for wolf protection fences or dogs ( in formerly wolf free regions), it are not the fields of town people, where wild animals steal fruits, crop, potatoes, vegetables... It is allways easy to say , other people should be quiet, when you have not their problem.
1
-
Franco Prussian war? Have you forgotten the soldiers of Bayern, Sachsen, Württemberg, Baden, Hessen- Darmstadt, Oldenburg, Mecklenburg- Schwerin, Mecklenburg- Strelitz, Sachsen- Weimar- Eisenach, Braunschweig, Anhalt, Sachsen - Altenburg, Sachsen - Meiningen, Sachsen- Coburg- Gotha, Lippe- Detmold, Waldeck- Pyrmont, Schwarzburg- Rudolstadt, Schwarzburg- Sondershausen, Reuß - Schleitz, Reuß- Gretz, Hamburg, Bremen and Lübeck? :-))
1
-
1
-
1
-
To Mussolini: His pistol in 9mm was surely 9mm (Browning) kurz/ .380 ACP. Pistol carry by german officers became duty in 1944, before in theory also Saber and dagger was enough. Hitlers closer body guards , the Führerbegleitkommando had been half SS men, other half police detectives. In his personal car, there , when no parade, was a driver a personal servant and an added SS man. Driver, servant and SS man had all pistols, the last one also a submachine gun. Before 1933, when Hitler was no official chancellor, minister etc., his bodyguards mostly had no ccw licence ( in german Waffenschein - other terms in Austria and Switzerland), so a large part of his bodyguards before 1933 had been a group of motorcycle drivers in uniformed motorcycle Dress of those days, armed with Hippopotamus hide whips. ( According to a Sonderausgabe/ Special of a german military history magazin about Hitlers headquarters).
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@vfm66798 : Ich, Brittas Freund, wohne auf dem Land. Solange ich zurückdenken kann, hält mein Vater, wie schon seine Vorfahren, Hühner. Ich kann mich noch erinnern, daß meine Mutter früher in Zeiten , in denen die Hühner viele Eier legten, dieselben in eine geleeartige Flüssigkeit einlegte, für die Zeit, in denen die Hühner wenig legen.
1
-
1
-
@FF-ru8re : What i wanted to tell was, even someone is good in a foreign language, native speakers mostly notice it. For example many , especially older, dutch people speak good german, but it sounds a bit funny. Mr. Feltons german is understandable, but you notice, that he is no native speaker. When you want to learn german, try it. For someone who can speak english, german can " t be to difficult, you can see, that i as a german person can speak/ write in english about simple things, so the other way must be similar. Word order and vocabulary is often similar, but our four grammar cases and der, die or das instead of the is perhaps the most difficult thing for an english speaker.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@Axonteer : Britta is my girlfriend, she is from Hesse/Hessen, we use same computer. I am not swiss, but from your swabian tribal brothers. In case of ,Guten Morgen' i use ,Godda Morga' or only ,Morga', and , Auf Wiedersehen' is simply ,Adee'( Adieu). I use Standard German only, when there is realy, this means realy, a need to use this.
1
-
In case of Hamas/ palestinians nobody speaks about Mohammed Amir al Hosseini 1895 (?) to 1972. This palestinian man was once Great Mufti of Jerusalem. From 1936 to 1939 he organised an arabian revolt against British Mandate Gouvernement in nowadays Israel and Jordania. When the revolt failed, he fled to Nazi Germany. Photos show him talking with Hitler and showing Nazi salute in arabian (imam?) dress. Hitler was impressed and supported al Hosseini, his followers and egypt muslim brotherhood. For two reasons: A) He wrongly assumed, al Hosseini is in islamic world one of highest figures. B) SS commander Himmler noted: Islam is a religion, which creates brave warriors and has partly similarities to Nazi ideology ( compare Islam and Nazis: a) Cult of warriors and manlyness b) hate against jews c) lmportance and role of men and women d) Worthy people: Herrenmenschen/ muslim believers, worthless people: Untermenschen/ non believers). Al Hosseini became member of , Allgemeine SS'/ general SS, and highest field Imam of SS Division Handschar, formed of bosnian muslims ( see YouTube video , Muslim SS praying', note the skinhead in Hugo Boss suit) . In time of support by Hitler, al Hosseini flooded the region from Egypt to Syria with terrible antijewish Propaganda, disguised as muslim based, but mixed with Nazi ideology. The Propaganda seed of al Hosseini is now harvested by Hamas.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@ChromeMan04 : In ,high point' of ancient greece the , Heavy Infantry' called Hoplites used plate armour made of bronce, some very decorated like muscles of human chest, but in later time also armour similar to medieval/ rennaisance brigandines. Also the ,Linothorax' armour containing no metal was used. Today it is a bit unknown what this realy was, i is assumed, that this had been layers of a type of cloth called in german ,Leinen', which had been reinforced/ glued with plant / trees fluid ( don' t know english word), so basicly an ancient version of modern Kevlar vests.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
For logistic reason , german forces, prefered pistols in 9mm Parabellum/ Luger or 7,65 Browning/ .32 ACP, even such ones in 6,35 Browning / .25 ACP had been used for armed personal, being not realy soldiers. This common cartridges had been produced by german companies. In much smaller numbers, german / austrian companies also produced 7,63 Mauser, 9mm Steyr and 9 mm kurz /. 380 ACP. But ,exotic' cartridges, produced or used only in one country, had been not so liked by german authorities.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
In Germany a person with a ,von' in the name is a member of former nobility. In November 1918 monarchy in Germany ended, and in 1919 with new consistution the nobility was officialy abandonned, but up to now, it is allowed to use former titles in nonofficial documents. Some of this former noblemen use , von und zu', this means , they still own the castle. from which their Name once came.
There is an old Joke: Two elderly ladies meet each other after many years. One of the Ladies says: I married a noblemen with a ,von and zu'. The other Lady answered : I know this, my husband also went , auf und davon'. Auf und davon, this is a German saying for ,running away at once'.
My father told me a funny story: In an inn of my homevillage a Mr. Graf ( count) and a Mr. König ( King) had a loud Dispute. A Mr. Kaiser ( emperor) became angry about this loud Dispute: Mr. Graf and Mr. König be quiet! I am a Kaiser , so with my Rank i order this!
1
-
1
-
1
-
I am german, Brittas boyfriend, only using her Computer too. I am nostalgic, rural , conservative. So i still hope for a comeback of german monarchies. For decades i liked british monarchy, keeping old traditions, with Elisabeth ll as a Queen of correctness and Pflichtbewusstsein ( english is not my native language, means about: The duty, to do your duty). As a german , living next to mount Teck, i respected Queen Elizabeth ll also, because her grandmother was Mary von Teck. But what i hear and read the last few days- an unbelieveable shock for me!
1
-
@matt: You know absolutely nothing about german family names . Fensterscheib ( window glass) was / is a nickname. In family history of Fensterscheib there was an incident, where something happened with a window glass, or an ancestor was a Glaser ( a glass craftsman). Before 13th century no common german ( including current Austria/ Switzerland, Luxemburg , Liechtenstein, flemish pr dutch) person had a family name. This started in 13th century in southern part of german language area, and ended in late 15th century in northern part of german language area. What origin have german family names? Some end with sen, meaning son of ..., this system is still used in Iceland and irish Mac or Irish o' IS the same. Others , ending with -er mean ,the man comming from ...', for example Dettinger coming from Dettingen. Other names describe the tribe. For example Frank(e) means , coming from franconian tribal area'. Others are describing a craft: Bauer ( farmer), Fischer ( fisher) or Bäcker/ Becker/ Beck/ Bäck ( baker). The example Baker shows the dialect differences. Other family names show a first name of an ancestor, but no more common names cause today problems. For example Frommholz (religious / believing wood) is in reallity no more common first name Fromold. Other family names Lang ( long), Kurz ( short), Feist ( very fat), Schönhaar ( beautyfull hair) describe the Look/ body of an ancestor. Some names are pure nicknames, for example Sparbier ( saving beer): An ancestor was an innkeeper who.watered down the sold beer. Some names are today no more understandable, names, or words of old days are today unknown, because over many centuries german language changed very much, some words are unknown in other dialect regions, or mean something different in another dialect. Also: Before 1873 german language was not standardized, so you could until 1870s write, as you wanted, a problem for family name understanding. And in Renaissance periode educated persons translated their names into latin or old greek to sound educated and fancy. Mr. Pistorius' (current Minister of defence), had once ancestors with ordinary name Bäcker/ Baker, or reformationer Philipp Melanchthons real name was Schwarzerd ( black earth), oh Schwarzenegger means not Schwarzneger ( black negro), but ,Schwarze Äcker' - black fields. German Acker is perhaps related to english acre, which is in german a , Morgen '.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@Olav_Hansen : I am not Britta herself, but her boyfriend. The first real suits of armour i saw in 1971 during a Kindergarten trip to Lichtenstein castle and Bear Cave. Before this i knew only castle ruins, there are lots of in my german homeregion, and movies about Knights in TV. This was 51 years ago, and since then my knowledge about fortifications, historic weapons etc. became larger than average , not so interesseted people.
A lot of those still popular misconceptions about historic weapons and armours here in Germany ( in this context including Austria and Switzerland) date back to ,Romantic Periode' of german culture/history, starting in 1820s, when after centuries the medieval age came back into peoples mind, a lot of knowledge was lost, so errors of this time are still today in the brains of many persons.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@colbunkmust : I must explain more carefully. In 843 ( Treaty of Verdun) the Carolingian Empire was split Ingo three parts. A western part which became later France ( in german Frankreich) an eastern part, which later became Germany and a middle part , today Netherland, Belgium, Luxemburg, France along the Rhone river and northern Italy. In 911 in East frankish empire the last descendant of Karl dem Großen/ Charlemagne died. The ,german' nobles noticed, that in West frankish empire ,french' language dominated, they no more could speak with West frankish upper class. So they decided, not to reunite with Westfrankish empire and elected Konrad l as first ,german' king. But Konrad l was a frankish nobleman, so some germans think, he was somehow related to frankish/ carolingian dynasty and say Heinrich l, elected in 919 was the first german king. In 10th century the first third or Middle frankish empire split into four pieces ( Oberlothringen/ Niederlothringen/ Hochburgund/ Niederburgund) . When in 10/11 th century this parts of former Middle frankish empire became part of HRE, it really became an empire with german/dutch ( not totaly split in those days) , french, italian, czech and rhaetoromanic speakers. But in the very first years of 10th century East frankish empire became german.
The german/ french wars of the last 800 to 1000 years had been basicly about the question, who rules over former Middle frankish empire.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@zbigniewgurak8261 : When i was a little child, i only knew my dialect. One day i got a childrens book with many pictures of Farm annimals, i knew the annimals, because my parents and some neighbors had little farms. But when my grandmother took the noted book and told Stories about the annimals, I thougt, why does my grandmother speak so strange? She read the Texts to the pictures, this was the First time, I noticed, that there are two variants of german language: The unregulated dialects and regulated Standard German/ Hochdeutsch. Today most german people speak either a watered down dialect or Standard German mixed with dialect words. The number of real dialect speakers is declining rather fast, while the number of Standard German speakers is rising fast, especially in large Towns. Some months ago i was at a Gas Station, the Young Lady didn' t understand me speaking dialect, and the older lady working there had to explain.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Being a swabian tribesman, so a descendant of Suevi and Alemannen, i refuse to watch all kind of ,historical' movies. In my Homeregion in nearly every Village alemannic Warriors Graves are found. Most of graves contained only spearheads, shield Bosses ( Schildbuckel) and seaxes ( Saxe). Spathas and horse Equipment had been rare.
Rafaele , who knows a lot of medieval age, should do a Video about the Fights of Guelf ( House of Welf, still ruling in Great Brittain) and Ghibnelines ( die Waiblinger/ House of Hohenstaufen). For a swabian man, Britta is my girlfriend, it is a gift, to see Mount Hohenstaufen from my Homevillage.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@marshalljohnson7690 : The Duke of Lorraine/ Herzog von Lothringen would be currently the head of the Habsburg family. When in 1740 emperor Karl Vl died without a son, his son in law, the Duke of Lorraine became the next emperor, but the French king wanted to have his duchy Lorraine for recognizing him as the next emperor, with this unfine behaviour the french got Lorraine ( there had also been some innergerman trouble because of the election). So the current name of the Habsburg family is Habsburg- Lothringen, without a ,von' , because in 1919 all austrian noblemen lost the ,von' in their names. ( In Germany they still have the ,von' in their names, but not all germans with a ,von' are former noblemen).
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@corneliachrost3212 : Warum wurde wohl früher hauptsächlich gewildert? Die Leute waren arm, und wollten etwas zu essen, oder auch mal Fleisch. Im Amerika der ,großen Depression' haben viele Amerikaner aus Not gejagt, und auch bei uns wurde nach Ende der Weltkriege viel gewildert, und auch aus Gärten und von Feldern gestohlen. Der Mangel an Lebensmitteln , und der hohe Preis für Fleisch hat zu vielen Morden an Jägern/ Förstern , aber teilweise auch Schäfern geführt. 1919 wurde im Heimatort meiner ersten Freundin ( bin Brittas Freund, benutze nur ihren Anschluss mit) der ,Feldschütz' erschossen. Ich weis nicht, ob sie wissen was das war, beziehungsweise, wie diese Männer in ihrer Gegend genannt wurden ( in Frankreich: garde champetre). Wäre heute eine Hungersnot, so hätten die Bauern nichts, da ihnen alles von den Städtern weggeplündert würde.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@tictac2therevenge291 : In 1682 (83?) and 1796 the german village i live, about 30km east of Stuttgart was attacked by french troops. So please look into the mirror. The French etc. , allways forgett, that the german hate against France did not come ,out of the nothing'. Do some research about Richelieu, Louis XlV or Napoleon l, what funny things they did in Germany, in case of Louis XlV especially in Palatinate, Rhine Valley and parts of Black Forrest. Also compare France and ,Germany' of the noted era. It seems french and other nongermans forget, that France in this time was a united country with a centralised administration and the strongest european ground army and the second or third strong Fleet. ,Germany' had no Fleet, was divided into more than 300 Reichsstände with Seat in diet/ parlament and lots of territories without seat. Only Prussia, Austria could mobilize large armies, to lower level Bavaria, Saxony and Hannover. In military district Swabia/ Schwaben next to France on right bank of Rhine there had been 100 souvereign states in an area between Rhine , Lech, Lake of Constance and a line from Northern end of Black Forrest eastwards. The , Reichs' territories not included ( mostly Imperial Knights, but also independent villages, valleys ( Oberharmersbach) and even independent farms!). The 100 states had been 30-35 Imperial towns, 20- 25 Spiritual Lords ( includung the female abbot of an independent womens monastry) and 40-50 noble Lords. Their ,troops' had been policemen, ceremonial guards and lowtrained leviemen, but few welltrained soldiers. So basicly unuseable troops. This expains, why French troops had been so sucessfull between 1630 and 1812, and it clearly shows, that the german ,miniatur' rulers of this era had no need for being warlike. But this fact is rather unknown and unpopular. Si vous etais français, je etait pour quelques voyages dans votre pays, sans casque et fusil. ( Britta est mon amie) Il y a des regions belles, et je ne veut pas guerre. Mais, je n' aime pas, parler seulemet sur (?) des guerres, ou les allemands sont les , mauvaises', parce dans quelques guerres franco- allemand, les français etait les ,mauvaises'. Je pense, vous comprit mes mots.
1
-
@tictac2therevenge291 : Da mein Französisch nicht gut ist , und es unhöflich wäre, von Ihnen deutsch zu verlangen, i use english. Perhaps i repeat it, i am Brittas boyfriend. For some reasons, i was not often outside of Germany, but some times in your country. Normandie, Bretagne, Loire valley, some daytrips in Alsace, which is clearly a mix of german and french influence.
As a person with history knowledge, i know a lot of history, so i don' t like nationalists, who say, they are better than other people in every case. Such behavior is not fine and results endless hate and trouble. So i think, the franco- german way of our days is good.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
My fathers aunt, 1916 to 2012, once showed me, german, Brittas boyfriend, what she had from her husband, who was Feldwebel/ Sergeant and died at Monte Cassino battle. It was iron cross second class, Close Quarters Combat badge in silver, the Moskow medal ( known as Gefrierfleischorden/ frozen meat medal), and a badge, that he in his civilian job ( railwayman) helped building the Westwall. The document, that he died in action and ( with original packing paper!) the parcel with his notebook and two other things i have forgotten. This, a photo and a military dokument with his name ( a ,Passierschein'/ a paper, which documented, that he and three ordinary soldiers travelled in official mission) had been the only remaining things of her husband, which whom she was married only a rather short time ( no children).
There was also a collarpin showing a Swastika and the toppart of a wheat plant, this pin was given to my greatgrandfather, but only because he was for many years the breeding bull warden of the village, not for doing something in war.
1
-
1
-
I do not agree with the creator of this video. The reason? The creator of this video speaks of , germanic' not german. As far as i know, the anglo-saxons (coming from , Low Germany'), the Normans ( romaniced vikings) and Danes ( who ruled for aGe short time in England) are ALSO germanic people. Also Ireland was attacked by vikings and partly ruled. So the germanic ( not german!) part of ,blood' of the royal british family must be higher, and the british/ irish ( celtic) part of ,blood ' must be lower than shown in this video. Germanic and german is not the same , we Germans do not have this problem, because we call us ,deutsch'.
1
-
1
-
In german languages counties, dialects are still spoken.They are often closer to english than Standard German. For example in my swabian dialect i means ich (i). In Standard German ein means in english either a or one, in swabian dialect a and oi. Many words for Things, known before May be 800, are still similar. Tool names like Hammer/hammer,Axt/ axe, Pflug/ plough, annimal names like Bär/ bear, Bulle/ bull, Sier/steer, Schwein/ swine, Sau/ sow, Henne/ hen, Gockel ( Hahn)/ cock Ross ( Pferd)/horse, Gais (Ziege)/ goat, Hase/ hare, old weaponry Schwert/ sword, Speer/spear, Schild/ shield or Things of nature Wasser/water, Stein/ stone, Wind/ wind, Dunst/ dust, Flut/ flood.
A Sidenote to Knecht and knight. The first Knights ( Ritter, see Reiter/ Rider) had been chosen in Germany from unfree servants of high nobility, they had been at First an own class of persons, and are only since 1496 seen as a part of nobility.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@CountArtha : In german language countries, last use of pikes was at end of napoleonic wars. To eqip all volunteer units of prussian Landwehr, there had been at start enough muskets, so that some units had a mix of few muskets, much pikes and some axes. For war success reason, the pikes had been replaced with captured french muskets more and more. Also because nearly no troops had remainded in Württemberg, so the King ordered to build four ,rural regiments' basicly Landsturm for Police and guard duties. The regiments had only half size and the men elderly.Their main weapon was a pike, 2m shaft and 15cm blade. Also in 1848/49 Revolution attempt, many units of Citizens Militia/ Bürgerwehr had been armed with warskytes. As far as i know , in last Swiss war, Sonderbundkrieg' 1847, some few soldiers of poorer cantons had only warskytes.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@ribbitgoesthedoglastnamehe4681 : Wrong button! The dragoons had been in Germany used as second wave in charge, or sometimes as infantry, they once had been ( They had been armed with a slightly shortened musket/ Dragonergewehr, similar to marines muskets, bayonnet and staight blade sword/ Pallasch like cuirassiers and gendarmes). During 18th century the german dragons had been used fewer and fewer as infantry ( Frederick ll of prussia: The dragons fight mostly in horseback, infantry training should not be forgotten, but the quality of regular infantry is not necessary). As light cavallry the Hussars ( of hungarian orgin) had been used in Germany , armed with ( curved) saber and carbines. Carbines in small numbers had also been used by cuirassiers and gendarmes, and pistols also by hussars and dragons. Cavallry with lances was very (!) rare in 18th century germany, perhaps some few polish soldiers in prussian/austrian service, and austrian Grenzer/ Bosniaken/ border guards at the austrian- ottoma Militärgrenze/ military border. During napoleonic wars, lancers (Ulanen) had been introduced into some german armies, and german/austrian dragons have nearly lost the infantry fight ability. This was reintroduced in not so proper way in late 19th century, so german dragons entered wwl with Leatherhelmet with point like line infantry, but with carbines. Because german cavallry started in wwl with carbines and no bayonnet, they had to use their lances as substitute. So to come back to your comment, the solution is simply another military tradition. And bavarian light cavallry used the french name Chevaux legets'- light horse.
1
-
1
-
1
-
Inside of Germany the Electorate of Saxony was in HRE one of the richest regions, and the Electors of Germany had been rich and pompeous, especially ,August the Strong', who became also elected king oft Poland. For their wealth, they had large collections of Art, Weapons and Jewelry, you still can watch in museums in Dresden. For people interessted in muzzleloaders, edged weapons and suits of armor, the ,Zwinger' building is a ,must view'. For the reason of being a rich ruler ( Mines, including silver mines) the mounted bodyguard was equipped with such expensive weapony to show power and wealth. But in this time peride there had also pistols been made, where only the handle, which looked out of the saddle holster, was decorated with bone or ivory. Note: Before the mid 17th century, permanent armies had been very rare. So in peacetime in most german states, about 300 noble or spiritual lords and ,Imperial Towns'( semiindependant teritories and Imperial Knights not included!) had only bodyguards units, fortress guards, militias ( sometimes welltrained men, sometimes nearly untrained levies, sometimes a mix of police, ceremonial guards and ,Schützenverein'. So in wartime armies had to be formed of hired mercenaries, Some of those mercenaries came with full equipment ( horse, suit of armor, pistols and rapier) , others with no equipment or war exppierience. This men had to been trained with the most simple weapon, the pike, and in Germany the saying : He started with the pike/ Von der Pike auf gedient is still in use. So i assume , that the pistols (and carbines) used by ordinary hired mounted mercenaries had been not decorated. Those pistols shown in the video is the middle type of cavallry pistols. The early type had often a more angled handle, the later type ( 30 years war) longer barrels ( long barrel with thick walls, small bore , strong powder charge- good armor penetration). To the word ,Puffer'. In Austria this word is still sometimes used, i think it means the ,Bang' sound when shooting, some variants of explosions are still called ,Verpuffung'. In current german ,Puff' is a slang word for ,whore house', but in case of firearms , this makes no sense.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@hedgehog3180 : I am german, Brittas boyfriend. When Napoleonic Era was over, HRE with more than 300 states no more existed, new German Federation consisted of about fourty states. So after centuries, real policeforces could be established. In larger states, there was mostly a communal Police in Towns , which had been capitals of countries, districts, provinces or whole state. Also villages or ,rural towns' sometimes had a Communal Police, when rich. In villages and small ,rural towns' there had been state payed Gendarmerie/ Landjäger, basicly soldiers doing policework In case of unrest also the Citizens Militias had been up to 1848/49 mobilized as Support force for Army and Police. This militias had been a Mix of lowtrained and bad equipped militias, target shooters societies ( Schützenverein) and tradition keeping organisations. During 1848/49 Revolution attempt, additional militia units had been formed, often only armed with warscytes. In many Museums of my homeregion, former Kingdom Württemberg, you still see this warscytes. After 1849, at least in my state, those still existing militias are only tradition Keepers in historical uniforms. They appear at traditional Events, their band is playing, they do a short march and Drill Show and fire a salvo of blanks. But in addition to this militias, town Police and rural Gendarmerie also relicts of medieval Police still have existed. At first the Communal Nightwatchmen. In württembergian capital Stuttgart they had been replaced by , Nightpolicemen' in 1862, but in Weilheim/ Teck there was a Nightwatchman up to 1931! Well, there was a change of weapons. From 1923 to 1931, last nightwatchman was armed with a pistol in .32 Acp,but before, short polearms had been common, in Museums you see mostly worn down halberds or Spears with broad Tip. Then there was the Amtsdiener/ Büttel/ towncrier. This men wore a Kind of uniform, often an old worn down Uniform of any Kind, this and their short Saber or Baton gave them some authority as auxillary policeman. In 1945 in US occupation Zone this Amtsdiener lost their Status as auxillary policemen, but in rural Germany of those days an uniformed Person still had authority. In my Village the , towncrier ' was in 1955 replaced by a Kind of weekly official newspaper, but my girlfriend Britta told me , that in her small hessian homevillage still in early 1970s a towncrier was in service, a wwll Veteran, who had lost a Leg. Then there had been Field guards, in french ,gardes champetres ', whos Task it was, to protect the farmers fields from harvest thiefs. Bavarian field guards seem to have had some firearms for a short time after wwll, but according to my father, württembergian fieldguards had only canes and dogs. In my Village, last fieldguard ended his Work in 1979.
1
-
Lisa Gute : Haben sie dies heute? Rund zwei Milliarden Menschen haben praktisch keine Möglichkeit, ihrer diktatorischen Religion zu entkommen, da es den Oberen jener Religion recht erfolgreich gelungen ist, die Gläubigen zu verdummen, von ihrer eigenen Unfähigkeit abzulenken und den Ärger der Gläubigen auf andere Teile der Menschheit umzulenken.
Der Grund, weshalb ich, Brittas Freund, benutze gerade ihren Anschluss mit, meinen Kommentar geschrieben habe ist, daß es mich seit längerem verärgert, daß Untaten konservativ/ rechter Systeme ausgewalzt werden, während Untaten linker Systeme für meinen Geschmack immer mehr kleingeredet werden. Es wird meines Erachtens nicht genug gegen ALLE der Menschheit schädlichen Ideen vorgegangen, es wird zu viel geduldet!
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1