Comments by "David Himmelsbach" (@davidhimmelsbach557) on "The Front"
channel.
-
13
-
12
-
8
-
8
-
7
-
5
-
5
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
4
-
2
-
@cogitatione1 In the final event, Truman DIDN'T follow his own Potsdam declaration. At Potsdam, the US was still demanding unconditional surrender. Truman flip-flopped, now allowing the Emperor to sit on his throne only in the final daze of intra-American decision making. Yet, at the time, and for years afterwards, the USA always denied that Truman had walked away from unconditional surrender -- THE key FDR plank of the war.
But, the facts are plain. Truman dropped what he regarded as a totally insane, extreme position -- considering how many souls would be destroyed by sticking to it.
This flip-flop is what actually terminated the Pacific War. It eclipsed the logic of the atomic bombs. I know, hard to believe... but look at the video one more time. Tokyo really was willing to destroy millions of lives so that the Emperor could carry on, and on.
As regards the UK and USSR, the US was largely negotiating without negotiating.
Both London and Moscow were getting into the Big Chair WRT Europe -- but were side-show players in the Pacific. No matter what was said/promised at Potsdam, the UK and USSR WERE miffed that they had absolutely no say in Tokyo. This was another insistence of Truman walking away from imputations previously proffered by FDR. Naturally, for the official record, London and Moscow bit their tongues WRT how ticked off they were. Yes, Stalin wanted even MORE (northern) Japanese territory than he already had seized -- and Truman rejected Moscow's lust.
{BTW, Tokyo still wants Russia to cough up Stalin's land grabs. Japan is even willing to pay up LARGE to get those worthless islands back. Moscow covets them as their route into the deep Pacific blue.}
[ This 'Truman block' super infuriated Stalin when Molotov was told in simple English to get out of (Soviet occupied) Iran OR ELSE ! The newsreels of the time record Molotov's ire -- but do NOT lay out to the American public that Truman had just threatened to use the atomic bomb on Stalin over the issue. The Cold War had to pass for this little item to creep out from hiding. You can see why Stalin wanted the Bomb in the world's worst way -- and why once he obtained it -- he launched the Korean War. It ran on his tanks, trucks, oil, planes, pilots and generals. Kim couldn't take one-step without Moscow.]
Indeed, Australia had a much larger role than Britain; so too, New Zealand. That's why their dignitaries signed the actual instrument of surrender. When it counted, the ANZAC boys performed all of the heavy lifting for the British Empire... but they were independent nations when they did so.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@Yamato-tp2kf 1959 is the date.
Hawaii went into the Union -- the same way that Texas and California did... as territories/nations. Texas and California threw off Mexico. Hawaii had a revolution -- that had no small number of native Americans involved, to boot.
The US fought Spain primarily to eject it from Cuba. Guam, and all the rest, were collateral de-colonizations forced upon Spain. The original intent was to just get rid of Spain. This is why it didn't take forever for the US to make Cuba independent. The Philippines went down the same path -- a generation later. The independence of the Philippines directly triggered the independence of India, Pakistan and Bangledesh. With in weeks of 7-4-1946 the Indians hit the streets.
The Philippines -- and Cuba -- were NEVER expected to become part of the USA, by anybody. Hawaii, California and Texas WERE expected to join the Union, by THEMSELVES. Statehood for Hawaii and Alaska was held up for YEARS -- because -- politically -- they skewed super strongly Democrat and Republican. So, they were only -- finally -- accepted by Congress as a pair. Yup. That was the deal. They STILL vote Democrat and Republican. They are -- de facto -- one-party states... city states, in fact. Virtually all of their votes are in Honolulu or Anchorage, respectively. And both are massively subsidized by the US Federal budget -- and tourism.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
You danced close, but missed it. The mining campaign didn't cause starvation -- as the food at issue was coming from Korea. What it did do was totally screw up Japan's war industries. They all depended upon small coastal ships to bring materials to their docks -- even if the factories at issue were on the same island. That's how cheap shipping is, and how lousy Japanese roads were. (And railroads, too.)
When the Japanese built up their industries (1870-1940) they largely shunned railroads. (They did have plenty of short lines, though.)
The rights of way required were already long in use, and politics meant that even the Emperor was loathe to touch land use issues.
BTW, Japanese railroads are STILL an economic mess. They require epic government subsidies -- as far as the calendar projects.
You left out THE single most epic, over-looked battle: tel el issa. There the British 8th Army discovered that the Krauts had been using network analysis to hugely decipher British transmissions -- even without fully breaking British cyphers. This and other discoveries led directly to the Soviet super success of Uranus. The first step of Uranus was the capture -- in a white-out -- of the German Enigma stationed (against Adolf's explicit orders) up with the Hungarian Army. This machine, and its paperwork, and its crew, then spoofed 6th Army into one bad decision after another, leading it to become surrounded. Stavka used this Enigma to impersonate Adolf, himself. (!!!) Since the transmissions were mere cyphers, no-one could spot the deception -- until way too late.
Even years afterwards, Kraut war bios (largely) suppressed this fiasco. ( But see: Panzer Battles ) Even the Soviets suppressed their success. Likewise, the British never let on that the battle of tel el issa was THE turning point in North Africa. Rommel lost his B'dienst team there -- and never recovered his 'magic.' Well, no wonder! Signals analysis is what had made him the Desert Fox. Cute.
Even now the British do their best to get tel el issa expunged from the Internet. Instead, another, successive battle keeps popping up via search engines. It's the wrong one, of course.
1
-
1